SlideShare une entreprise Scribd logo
1  sur  20
Télécharger pour lire hors ligne
Kublai Camp 2009                  Kublai Camp 2011    administrative uncertainty starts




                        WHAT WENT WRONG?

      The rise and fall of an open government project – Alberto Cottica, May 2011
€ 115 bn
Impact = LOW
Transformative potential
!!!




Increased project serendipity
Project development in a network
Second Life for brainstorming
Values

Software

Outreach
2500 400
 users   projects
Kublai Camp 2009   Kublai Camp 2011   administrative uncertainty starts




                   But then...
So, what was the matter?
•uncertain planning horizon

•full transparency technically difficult

•rising costs (and overheads)

•sluggish, uncertain decisions

•impassable barriers between paid staff and community

•no budget for impact assessment
What would you do?
Legal stuff
This work is licensed under the Creative
Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-
NoDerivs 3.0 Unported License. To view a copy
of this license, visit http://creativecommons.org/
licenses/by-nc-nd/3.0/ or send a letter to
Creative Commons, 171 Second Street, Suite
300, San Francisco, California, 94105, USA.
All photos licensed CC on Flickr.com. Authors (top to bottom):
unknown author, CriticalCity, Alberto Cottica, Alberto Cottica,
Massimo Faccioli Pintozzi, Ballacoicinghiali

Contenu connexe

Similaire à What went wrong

Technology policy and me
Technology policy and meTechnology policy and me
Technology policy and meAlberto Cottica
 
Have we a Human Ecosystem?
Have we a Human Ecosystem?Have we a Human Ecosystem?
Have we a Human Ecosystem?AdaCore
 
Applications – Beyond Bits and Bytes
Applications – Beyond Bits and BytesApplications – Beyond Bits and Bytes
Applications – Beyond Bits and Bytesarjunrc
 
20210908 jim spohrer naples forum_2021 v1
20210908 jim spohrer naples forum_2021 v120210908 jim spohrer naples forum_2021 v1
20210908 jim spohrer naples forum_2021 v1ISSIP
 
Presentation DLM Symposium 2012 - Future of TV
Presentation DLM Symposium 2012 - Future of TV Presentation DLM Symposium 2012 - Future of TV
Presentation DLM Symposium 2012 - Future of TV Blockchain News
 
NA Developer Day - Addressing forces of change
NA Developer Day - Addressing forces of changeNA Developer Day - Addressing forces of change
NA Developer Day - Addressing forces of changeMicro Focus
 
Startup Junkie Underground - Top 10 Entrepreneurial Trends for 2011
Startup Junkie Underground - Top 10 Entrepreneurial Trends for 2011Startup Junkie Underground - Top 10 Entrepreneurial Trends for 2011
Startup Junkie Underground - Top 10 Entrepreneurial Trends for 2011DaVinci Institute
 
Global Ubiquitous Connectivity and the New Business World of Value Flows
Global Ubiquitous Connectivity and the New Business World of Value FlowsGlobal Ubiquitous Connectivity and the New Business World of Value Flows
Global Ubiquitous Connectivity and the New Business World of Value FlowsVictor Cho
 
Spotting Tomorrow's Key Technologies
Spotting Tomorrow's Key TechnologiesSpotting Tomorrow's Key Technologies
Spotting Tomorrow's Key Technologieslisbk
 
Social Media: Hype, Hell or Hope
Social Media: Hype, Hell or HopeSocial Media: Hype, Hell or Hope
Social Media: Hype, Hell or HopeRick Mans
 
Power to the People: Transforming Government with Open Source
Power to the People:  Transforming Government with Open SourcePower to the People:  Transforming Government with Open Source
Power to the People: Transforming Government with Open SourceAll Things Open
 
2009 Texas CIO Summit - Web 2.0
2009 Texas CIO Summit - Web 2.02009 Texas CIO Summit - Web 2.0
2009 Texas CIO Summit - Web 2.0NIC Inc | EGOV
 
Thomas Siebel - Digital transformation - Book Summary Pietro Stopponi
Thomas Siebel - Digital transformation - Book Summary Pietro StopponiThomas Siebel - Digital transformation - Book Summary Pietro Stopponi
Thomas Siebel - Digital transformation - Book Summary Pietro StopponiPietro Stopponi
 
No Microservice Is an Island
No Microservice Is an IslandNo Microservice Is an Island
No Microservice Is an IslandC4Media
 
IPSE QA Freelancer Awards - We are the Makers
IPSE QA Freelancer Awards - We are the MakersIPSE QA Freelancer Awards - We are the Makers
IPSE QA Freelancer Awards - We are the MakersDavid Walker
 
Presentation Global Collect Perspectives 2012
Presentation Global Collect Perspectives 2012Presentation Global Collect Perspectives 2012
Presentation Global Collect Perspectives 2012Blockchain News
 
Microsoft Dynamics Academic Alliance: How to win future of business
Microsoft Dynamics Academic Alliance: How to win future of businessMicrosoft Dynamics Academic Alliance: How to win future of business
Microsoft Dynamics Academic Alliance: How to win future of businessFrederik De Bruyne
 
Carvi Video & Metadata, Next Tsunami
Carvi Video & Metadata, Next TsunamiCarvi Video & Metadata, Next Tsunami
Carvi Video & Metadata, Next TsunamiMiguel Angel Morcuende
 

Similaire à What went wrong (20)

Technology policy and me
Technology policy and meTechnology policy and me
Technology policy and me
 
Have we a Human Ecosystem?
Have we a Human Ecosystem?Have we a Human Ecosystem?
Have we a Human Ecosystem?
 
Applications – Beyond Bits and Bytes
Applications – Beyond Bits and BytesApplications – Beyond Bits and Bytes
Applications – Beyond Bits and Bytes
 
20210908 jim spohrer naples forum_2021 v1
20210908 jim spohrer naples forum_2021 v120210908 jim spohrer naples forum_2021 v1
20210908 jim spohrer naples forum_2021 v1
 
Presentation DLM Symposium 2012 - Future of TV
Presentation DLM Symposium 2012 - Future of TV Presentation DLM Symposium 2012 - Future of TV
Presentation DLM Symposium 2012 - Future of TV
 
NA Developer Day - Addressing forces of change
NA Developer Day - Addressing forces of changeNA Developer Day - Addressing forces of change
NA Developer Day - Addressing forces of change
 
Startup Junkie Underground - Top 10 Entrepreneurial Trends for 2011
Startup Junkie Underground - Top 10 Entrepreneurial Trends for 2011Startup Junkie Underground - Top 10 Entrepreneurial Trends for 2011
Startup Junkie Underground - Top 10 Entrepreneurial Trends for 2011
 
Global Ubiquitous Connectivity and the New Business World of Value Flows
Global Ubiquitous Connectivity and the New Business World of Value FlowsGlobal Ubiquitous Connectivity and the New Business World of Value Flows
Global Ubiquitous Connectivity and the New Business World of Value Flows
 
Uksg 2013-kelly
Uksg 2013-kellyUksg 2013-kelly
Uksg 2013-kelly
 
Spotting Tomorrow's Key Technologies
Spotting Tomorrow's Key TechnologiesSpotting Tomorrow's Key Technologies
Spotting Tomorrow's Key Technologies
 
Uksg 2013-kelly
Uksg 2013-kellyUksg 2013-kelly
Uksg 2013-kelly
 
Social Media: Hype, Hell or Hope
Social Media: Hype, Hell or HopeSocial Media: Hype, Hell or Hope
Social Media: Hype, Hell or Hope
 
Power to the People: Transforming Government with Open Source
Power to the People:  Transforming Government with Open SourcePower to the People:  Transforming Government with Open Source
Power to the People: Transforming Government with Open Source
 
2009 Texas CIO Summit - Web 2.0
2009 Texas CIO Summit - Web 2.02009 Texas CIO Summit - Web 2.0
2009 Texas CIO Summit - Web 2.0
 
Thomas Siebel - Digital transformation - Book Summary Pietro Stopponi
Thomas Siebel - Digital transformation - Book Summary Pietro StopponiThomas Siebel - Digital transformation - Book Summary Pietro Stopponi
Thomas Siebel - Digital transformation - Book Summary Pietro Stopponi
 
No Microservice Is an Island
No Microservice Is an IslandNo Microservice Is an Island
No Microservice Is an Island
 
IPSE QA Freelancer Awards - We are the Makers
IPSE QA Freelancer Awards - We are the MakersIPSE QA Freelancer Awards - We are the Makers
IPSE QA Freelancer Awards - We are the Makers
 
Presentation Global Collect Perspectives 2012
Presentation Global Collect Perspectives 2012Presentation Global Collect Perspectives 2012
Presentation Global Collect Perspectives 2012
 
Microsoft Dynamics Academic Alliance: How to win future of business
Microsoft Dynamics Academic Alliance: How to win future of businessMicrosoft Dynamics Academic Alliance: How to win future of business
Microsoft Dynamics Academic Alliance: How to win future of business
 
Carvi Video & Metadata, Next Tsunami
Carvi Video & Metadata, Next TsunamiCarvi Video & Metadata, Next Tsunami
Carvi Video & Metadata, Next Tsunami
 

What went wrong

  • 1. Kublai Camp 2009 Kublai Camp 2011 administrative uncertainty starts WHAT WENT WRONG? The rise and fall of an open government project – Alberto Cottica, May 2011
  • 5.
  • 6.
  • 9. Second Life for brainstorming
  • 11. 2500 400 users projects
  • 12.
  • 13.
  • 14.
  • 15.
  • 16.
  • 17. Kublai Camp 2009 Kublai Camp 2011 administrative uncertainty starts But then...
  • 18. So, what was the matter? •uncertain planning horizon •full transparency technically difficult •rising costs (and overheads) •sluggish, uncertain decisions •impassable barriers between paid staff and community •no budget for impact assessment
  • 20. Legal stuff This work is licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial- NoDerivs 3.0 Unported License. To view a copy of this license, visit http://creativecommons.org/ licenses/by-nc-nd/3.0/ or send a letter to Creative Commons, 171 Second Street, Suite 300, San Francisco, California, 94105, USA. All photos licensed CC on Flickr.com. Authors (top to bottom): unknown author, CriticalCity, Alberto Cottica, Alberto Cottica, Massimo Faccioli Pintozzi, Ballacoicinghiali