SlideShare une entreprise Scribd logo
1  sur  18
Télécharger pour lire hors ligne
FreeBalance®
               Aid Transparency Integration




The Integration of Donor and Recipient Government Financial
                          Systems

      Enabling Aid Transparency and Aid Effectiveness
Copyright Information



© FreeBalance Inc. 2011, Some Rights Reserved. Except where otherwise noted, this work is licensed under Creative Commons Attribution ShareAlike 3.0.
You are free:

o    to Share — to copy, distribute and transmit the work
o    to Remix — to adapt the work
Under the following conditions:

o    Attribution. You must attribute the work in the manner specified by the author or licensor (but not in
     any way that suggests that they endorse you or your use of the work).
o    Share Alike. If you alter, transform, or build upon this work, you may distribute the resulting work only
     under the same, similar or a compatible license.
o    For any reuse or distribution, you must make clear to others the license terms of this work. The best way
     to do this is with a link to this web page.
o    Any of the above conditions can be waived if you get permission from the copyright holder.
o    Nothing in this license impairs or restricts the author's moral rights.




                                                                                                                                                        2
FreeBalance®
The Integration of Donor and Recipient Government Financial Systems
Enabling Aid Transparency and Aid Effectiveness
The International Aid Transparency Initiative (IATI) “aims to make information about aid spending easier to
access, use and understand.” IATI seeks to improve aid effectiveness through transparency. Transparency
can improve aid harmonization and reduce aid transaction costs throughout the entire aid lifecycle from
donor funding through to result. International donors and partner countries have committed to improving aid
through harmonization and transparency through the Paris Declaration on Aid Effectiveness and the Accra
Agenda for Action. The goal: use strengthened country financial systems by donors rather than separate and
inefficient systems. Put donor funds on-budget – on the government books to ensure transparency.
The IATI Technical Advisory Group (TAG) has been studying methods for aid data integration among all
aid participants. The integration of data between donor systems and recipient government budget systems is
critical to IATI success. This integration can reduce administrative transaction costs. It can improve the
coordination of donors and governments to achieve results. And, it can lead to direct budgetary support that
ensures that aid better meets recipient government objectives. Transparency throughout the aid chain reduces
the opportunity for fraud and corruption. It’s all about improving aid effectiveness.
The TAG has encountered technical issues with donor and recipient government integration. Stakeholders
from donors, civil society, governments and NGOs have differing aid effectiveness improvement objectives.
Some stakeholders are concerned about the quality of historical statistical information, while others seek a
better understanding of transactions. Aid sector categories differ among stakeholders. There are differing
needs for the level information granularity. Current standards in use by International Financial Institutions
(IFIs) and governments operate at cross purposes, satisfying few stakeholders.
What’s the Technical Problem?
These difficulties are seen as technical metadata integration problems – data structures from operational
systems used among donors and recipient governments cannot be rationalized.
The technical problem of project, transactional and statistical information integration among donor and
recipient government budget systems is thought by some to be too complex and too expensive to
contemplate. Nothing should be further from the truth. At its core, the IATI technical integration challenge is
integrating donor budget with recipient government budget systems. Project data and statistical data are
hierarchical constructs of budget and financial transactions. Additional data elements, including documents,
project and statistical information can be linked directly to this transactional data.
Timely, effective, and automated integration among financial and project systems across the aid lifecycle
requires the adoption of good practices in financial management systems – the use of program
classifications. Herein lies the problem.




                                                                                                            3
FreeBalance®
Developing nation governments, particularly FreeBalance customers, use program classifications. (And, the
software enables progressively activating program classifications.) Many donors are not using this
established good practice and have financial software systems that are too rigid to quickly and inexpensively
adopt this good practice. 1

Towards Donor to Government Integration
Automating the Financial Aid Lifecycle: High Level
The integration of donor systems with recipient government budget systems for on-budget aid projects for
comprehensive Public Financial Management (PFM) includes the following elements:
1. Donor budget preparation systems 
   where donors determine upcoming 
   project budgets. These systems could 
   integrate directly with recipient 
   government budget preparation 
   systems that include anticipated on‐
   budget aid resulting in legally 
   mandated budget 
2. Alternatively, and perhaps preferably, 
   the donor budget preparation and 
   system could integrate with aid 
   management systems. Aid 
   management systems enable donors 
   and recipient governments to 
   collaborate in the definition, funding 
   and management of aid projects. Also 
   recipient government budget preparation systems could integrate with aid management systems to enable 
   multiple year budget planning and to harmonize the government and aid budgets 2 . 
3. The resulting budget prepared in the donor budget preparation system is formalized in the donor financial 
   management system for disbursements during the fiscal year. 
4. Disbursement information from the donor financial system could integrate with the recipient government 
   financial system. The recipient government receives the funds against the budget item and provides authority to 
   spend through appropriations or warrants. 
5. Alternatively, and perhaps preferably, the donor financial management provides disbursement information to 
   the aid management system that also integrates with the recipient government financial management system. 
   This provides disbursement information to all stakeholders to improve aid harmonization. 
6. Outcome and project reports are generated from the aid management system. 



1
  (Financial software designed for the private sector often provides rigid classifications because these change infrequently.
Government Chart of Accounts (COAs) change frequently to reflect modernization, reform, government restructuring, adoption of
performance management, support of standards – including new standards like IATI.) Some donors pull project information from
documents and have to manually reconcile with transactions.
2
  This enables governments to product more credible budgets and support Medium Term Expenditure Frameworks (MTEF)



                                                                                                                          4
FreeBalance®
7. Outcome and project reports from the donor financial management and recipient government financial systems 
   can also provide output, project and outcome information. 
8. Recipient government financial systems typically output statistical data using the IMF GFS standard. The IATI 
   standard could also be supported. 
9. Output, project, outcome and statistical data can be compared to support historical analysis. 

Automating the Financial Aid Lifecycle: Budget Preparation
All public sector organizations operate using commitment accounting techniques for financial management.
Budgets are developed that become the legal embodiment of government policy for recipient governments.
Bi-lateral donors are government entities that also manage based on legal budget. Multi-lateral and non-
profits donors also manage financials based on commitment accounting to satisfy funders.
The budget preparation cycle is similar among public sector organizations regardless of information systems
used.

Recipient Government Perspective
Aid intentions from donors,
regardless of the certainty of that
aid are critical to forming budgets.
Recipient governments require
harmonizing with donor budgets to
achieve government objectives.
The fact that a donor might
commit to funding is important
because the recipient government
can identify this likelihood and be
prepared should these funds be
made available 3 .
1. Numerous factors are analyzed 
   during the budget preparation process. This includes organizational objects, or the general policy of the 
   organization, macroeconomic analysis and historical information to determine budget assumptions for the 
   upcoming year, typically in the form of a budget circular. This budget circular is scheduled during the current 
   fiscal year for planning for a subsequent fiscal year. Many government organizations plan ahead on a medium 3 
   year term. Therefore, the historical information includes preliminary information about the upcoming fiscal year 
   and multiple year projects and commitments. 
2. The budget circular typically provides guidance on budget assumption in the form of budget ceilings to 
   organizational units. 
3. Government organizations follow an iterative process of numerous internal budget proposals or versions with 
   project and cost justifications. These versions are rolled‐up to budget organizations and analyzed. Scenarios are 
   examined. 
4. The budget organization completes a detailed budget document or budget book for approval. 


3
 Recipient governments can build contingencies in budget plans and ensure meeting government objectives through
complementary funding.



                                                                                                                    5
FreeBalance®
5. The budget is adapted by legislative processes through a vote.  
6. The result of the budget vote is a budget law in government. 
7. The budget law provides the allotment or appropriation information for budget execution in the government 
   financial system. 

Automating the Financial Aid
Lifecycle: Aid management
1. Donors prepare budgets based on 
   donor objectives 
2. Donor objectives are harmonized 
   with government objectives to 
   determine areas of mutual 
   interest with the view that reform 
   should be country driven 
3. Projects that meet objectives are 
   proposed 
4. That include a set of risk factors and performance measurements for expected outputs and outcomes 
5. Projects that are approved for funding are shown in donor and recipient budget preparation systems 
6. Budget information is shown in the budget execution module of donor and recipient government financial 
   management systems 
7. Funds are disbursed by donors to the recipient governments and progress shown in a monitoring and evaluation 
   module 
8. Funds received by donors are executed by the recipient governments, with progress shown in a monitoring and 
   evaluation module 
9. Results from the projects can be tracked against risk factors and performance measures in a monitoring and 
   evaluation module 

Automating the Financial Aid Lifecycle: Budget Execution
Budget execution includes the financial management of all revenues and expenditures controlled by the
budget. The budget can be adjusted throughout the fiscal year based on cash availability, macro-economic
changes and availability of new revenue sources.

Recipient Government Perspective
Budget execution is difficult for many developing countries to effectively manage. These governments tend
to experience cash shortfalls. Some governments are not able to spend the entire budget, hence reducing the
effectiveness of many initiatives. Many donors examine recipient government disbursements as an indicator
of progress. Yet, budget execution processes can expose in-progress spending through commitments and
obligations to give a better indication of the recipient government project budgets.
1. The budget law developed during formulation creates the annual budget. The budget typically includes annual 
   spending limits that are aggregated by organizational unit, fund source, project and type of expenditure such as 
   capital or recurrent. The budget law also includes detailed line‐item budget estimates that are used for estimates 




                                                                                                                  6
FreeBalance®
in most governments but not controls 4 . The appropriations including authority to spend typically include the 
    aggregate annual budget, some elements of the line item information and period budgetary controls 5 .  
2. Expenditures in government financial 
   management systems leverage 
   commitment accounting functions. Funds 
   are set aside during expenditure cycles to 
   ensure that budgets are overspent. Many 
   governments support two phases of 
   commitments where money is set aside 
   during the requisition stage as a soft 
   commitment or pre‐encumbrance. Good 
   practices in government financial 
   management ensure that contractual 
   obligations set aside funds when 
   purchase orders are created.  
3. Goods and services are received by the government are paid for through disbursements or payments.  
4. Government revenue may be higher or lower than expected based on macroeconomic changes. There may be 
   cash and liquidity issues. These situations often change expenditure budgets and appropriations. Cash and 
   liquidity issues can adjust budgets during the fiscal year. 
5. Governments often receive supplemental budgets. Recipient governments receive project funds when fiscal 
   years are not aligned with donors and there is no budget preparation integration. Special supplemental budgets 
   are often created because of macroeconomic shocks, such as stimulus packages or because of natural disasters.  
6. The spending status against the budget can be analyzed. Budget deficits and surpluses can be predicted. It is 
   considered a poor practice to under‐spend because this will reduce outputs and outcomes. Appropriations can 
   be loosened to encourage spending or tightened to reduce spending.  
7. Budget reports showing outputs and variances are produced.  

Automating the Financial Aid Lifecycle: Commitment Accounting Transactions
Commitment Accounting is sometimes considered as part of the Budget Execution cycle. PFM transactions
combine the traditional accounting transactions used in the private sector with budget controls.

Recipient Government Perspective
The status of commitments and obligations provides a better indicator of project progress than
disbursements. It should also be noted that there can be delays in payment cycles after expenses have been
approved. Therefore, the goods received and expense voucher stages in expenditures can also provide insight
to project progress because these indicate goods and services completed but not yet paid.
The commitment accounting transaction structure includes the following:
1. The budget law provides one or more appropriations that act as expenditure controls 



4
 Some government organizations use full line-item budget controls, but this is not considered a good practice in most situations.
5
 Many governments operate with monthly or quarterly controls that are more detailed than the annual appropriation to enable
more effective fiscal control.



                                                                                                                                7
FreeBalance®
2. Internal purchase requisitions are checked for budget availability in some countries. The estimated amount of 
   the expenditure is committed or set aside. 6 
3. Purchase orders are checked against budget availability. Differences with requisitions are adjusted. The purchase 
   order represents a contractual obligation or hard commitment. The obligation is set aside. 
4. Goods and services are 
   received and returned via 
   goods receipt and goods 
   returned notes are accrued if 
   the government is using 
   modified accrual or accrual 
   accounting 7 .  
5. Goods and services that are 
   accepted are approved for 
   expenditures through 
   expense vouchers that are 
   shown in the accounts 
   payable sub‐ledger. PFM 
   systems tend to post 
   accounts payable 
   transactions to the general 
   ledger immediately in order 
   to show the true cash and 
   budget situation 8 . 
6. Cash receipts, revenue from 
   taxation and other sources of government income are provided to Bank accounts and shown in the accounts 
   receivable sub‐ledger, posted in real time to the general ledger. 
7. Payments are posted to the accounts payable sub‐ledger and honoured by the bank 9 . 
8. The bank information is reconciled with the general ledger. 
9. The recipient government manages cash and liquidity based on bank information, expected payments from 
   accounts payable and the commitment cycle, revenue expected from accounts receivable, forecasts based on 
   appropriations, investments and debt. 

The Classification of Aid Information
Classifying data is a typical information management problem. Information systems need to catalogue and
classify data to support process workflow, analysis, decision-making and reporting. Information systems
classify data based on needs. This data classification is known as “metadata.” Organizations often require
using “master data management” tools to harmonize data across multiple information systems. These


6
  Some countries use 2 commitment phases.
7
  Most governments are moving towards supporting accrual accounting.
8
  Many governments reconcile budgets information with ledger information as a second method of balancing.
9
  The use of Electronic Funds Transfer (EFT) is a good practice to reduce the opportunity for corruption because it is far easier to
track than cash money.



                                                                                                                                  8
FreeBalance®
systems reclassify and transform data to create common information. These systems also rationalize differing
levels of detail required in information systems. 10
The aid lifecycle includes project, budget and financial information. This metadata associated with aid
information tends to be multidimensional and hierarchical. For example, budget classifications or Charts of
Accounts (COA) often include multiple data segments. Each segment includes a hierarchy of details. These
classifications are used for every
financial transaction.
There are numerous COA practices
including:
    Budget classification structures tend 
     to change over time as donors and 
     recipient governments change 
     objectives, accounting methods (i.e. 
     accrual accounting) and items to 
     measure. 
    Organizations tend to modernize from 
     a simple structure including fund, 
     organization, object/economic item to 
     add program and output segments. 
    Mid‐developed countries are often 
     less likely to support international 
     standards and multiple segments. 
     Lower developed countries are most 
     likely to follow international 
     standards. High developed countries 
     have mature national standards that 
     are often at a par with international 
     standards. 
    International and some national 
     standards are supported via side 
     tables or side concepts. These items 
     roll‐up transactional data in 
     alternative methods through mapping 
     ranges of data to a different structure. 
     Budget and accounting users should 
     not be exposed to most statistical, project, and performance objects.  This method simplifies data entry yet 
     achieves reporting and integration requirements. 

Case Study: The Government of Sierra Leone and Side Concepts
The Government of Sierra Leone uses the program segment of 8 characters with 5 levels of hierarchy within
a COA of 5 segments and 27 digits.
10
  International data exchange standards like IATI provide a standard data target to facilitate integration. Organizations use MDM
tools to import and export data when systems are do not support standards natively.




                                                                                                                               9
FreeBalance®
Users enter budgets and
accounting transactions
where:
   Character 1 = Project 
    Type 
   Characters 2 & 3 = Project 
   Character 4 = Component 
   Characters 5 & 6 = Sub 
    Component 
   Characters 7 & 8 = Activity 
COA rules are able to take the 8 characters to infer 3 levels of government financial statistics support, 2
additional levels of project reporting, 4 additional levels of output or performance information and 1 level of
Millennium Development Goals.
The use of side concepts, supported by financial management systems used in almost all donors and most
developing countries is conceived to be the method to support IATI reporting and integration.

Aid Management Classifications
Aid management
systems track
information and
transactional
information related to
projects. This can vary
from government to
government, but the
data structure for any
project typically
includes:
   Project identification 
    including title, 
    description, 
    objective, purpose, 
    agreement number 
    and agreement date 
   Planning information 
    including project start and end dates, extension dates if any and project status 
   Project implementation information which includes whether it is implemented at national/sub national level and 
    the sector 
   Alignment of project to national priorities or MDGs 
   Project implementing and beneficiary partners 




                                                                                                               10
FreeBalance®
    Government and donor focal point contact information 

Integrating Structure across Systems
Integrating donor and recipient government systems is enabled because these systems hold more detailed
information than is needed by the IATI standard. This detailed information needs to be aggregated to meet
IATI needs. Yet, the structure of the budget data is different among stakeholders. However, there is
sufficient commonality to infer or roll-up to the aggregate project and statistical information required by the
IATI standard 11 . The process is conceptually no different than donors supporting CRS or recipient
governments supporting GFS.
1. The donor budget system includes chart of accounts that describes objective, project, sector, recipient and 
   object code. This information could be in as few as 2 segments structured hierarchically. The objective, project, 
   sector and recipient government information can integrate with an aid management system through a mapping 
   process. Mapping data structures is well understood in information technology using Extract, Transform, Load 
   (ETL), Enterprise Application Integration (EAI) or Business Process Management (BPM) tools.  Many Government 
   Resource Planning Systems (GRP) support side concepts meaning that additional software will not be required. 
2. The same information provided to the aid management system can integrate with the recipient government 
   chart of accounts. The conditions of the donor can be integrated through the fund and object segment and 
   controlled through valid code combinations to prevent improper spending. 
3. Documents and other material such as assessments, reviews and proposals can be linked directly to elements of 
   the budget and aid classifications. 
4. The highly detailed transactional information can be exported from donor budget systems through side table 
   COA structures or via mapping tools. 
5. The less detailed transactional information can be exported from aid management systems through reports or 
   via mapping tools. 
6. The highly detailed transactional information can be exported from recipient government budget systems 
   through side table COA structures or via mapping tools. 
7. Common elements from DAC/CRS produced by some donors and GFS could be used to enhance the IATI data set 
   or simplify the process of reporting. Of course, the IATI data structure can align with data elements found in 
   documents. Navigating and drilling through IATI data could include document discovery. 




11
  Samuel Moon and Zachary Mills analyzed numerous government classifications to reach a similar conclusion in a paper
published by the Oversees Development Institute



                                                                                                                        11
FreeBalance®
Supporting IATI within Financial
Systems
The IATI Secretariat recently published a simple
explanation of the IATI standard. This helps to
explain that much of IATI can be automated
through the proper use of financial management
systems by donors and recipient governments.
The premise is that financial information and
project metadata is stored within the budget
classifications or Chart of Accounts (COA). This
metadata enables tracking transactions within the
financial system with project documents and
enable consolidation to the IATI standard. Donors
use financial systems. Most recipient government
use financial systems. The following table
describes how financial systems can support the IATI standard.

Financial Systems and IATI Integration
Item                              Financial System Alignment 
Who is involved, where and how? 
1. What is the name of the reporting           High Level Consolidation that can be appended to any reports coming 
organisation?                                  from financial management software. 
2. Which organisations have given you 
funding? Which organisations are you           Provided in donor financial management software. 
funding? 
What are the project details? 
3. What is the IATI identification code for    Can be linked from COA, some systems support additional unique 
this project?                                  number (in this case IATI code) to COA element. 
                                               Projects are aligned typically through a program or project segment 
4. Project name                                where the project code in the COA has a description with the same name 
                                               as in documents. 
                                               Project name is sufficient to provide mapping between COA and 
5. Project summary or description              documents. Many COTS financial management software enable longer 
                                               descriptions and attachments. 
6. Are there documents related to this 
                                            Could be included in COA description information that can include links 
project that can be or are already 
                                            and attachments. 
published online? What is the link to them? 
7. What is the website connected with this 
                                            Could be included in COA description information that can include links 
activity 
8. Who are the points of contact for this  Could be included in COA description information that can include 
project?                                    project details like contact person. 




                                                                                                                  12
FreeBalance®
9. Are there other projects that are related 
                                              Often inferred within the structure of the COA. 
to this one? How are they related? 
                                              Geocoding is not typically in the COA. However, district is often 
                                              described in a separate COA segment or within the Organization 
10. What are the geographic details of this  segment. Donors are unlikely to have geographic details beyond country. 
project? (Optional)                           Recipient countries likely to have geographic details following the 
                                              political structure of the country, so has different levels of granularity. 
                                              Geographic details often can be linked to aid management systems. 
                                              Typically held within the budget preparation, aid 
11. What are the start and end dates for  management or project accounting systems. Medium Term Expenditure 
this project?                                 Frameworks (MTEF) with 3‐year perspectives helpful to support the IATI 
                                              standard because so many projects span multiple years. 
                                              Financial status (original budget, commitments, disbursements, and 
                                              remaining funds) is provided in the financial management software. 
12. What is the current status of this 
                                              This may not show the % completion. This is often stored in project 
project 
                                              accounting systems. Monitoring and evaluation systems that are part of 
                                              aid management systems include risk factors can be linked. 
                                              Performance information provided in aid management systems. The 
                                              performance structure is often found in the COA. Donors should be using 
13 What are the expected and actual           a structure to align project items to performance classifications. 
results of this project? (Optional)           Recipient governments often have linkages to MDGs and government 
                                              objectives as inferred dimension (or side tables) to the program 
                                              segment. 
14. Which sector or theme does this           Sector information typically stored in economic purpose or program 
project contribute to                         segments in COA. Also provided in aid management systems. 
15. Is procurement tied or restricted to 
                                              Procurement conditions often stored within procurement systems. Also 
certain countries? (Not necessarily 
                                              provided in aid management systems. 
applicable) 
                                              Can be achieved in government financial management software 
16. Are there any cross cutting themes to 
                                              through creating inferred dimensions within the COA and through 
highlight in this project? 
                                              attached narrative. Also provided in aid management systems. 
                                              Can be partly supported for conditionality in recipient systems. Many 
                                              recipient countries have a Fund segment in the COA. Conditions by fund 
17. Are there terms and conditions 
                                              source for expenditures can be automated. Specific project conditions 
attached to the project? 
                                              often attached to Revenue transactions. Also provided in aid 
                                              management systems. 
What are the financial details? 
18. What are the budgets in each financial  Budget preparation systems show multiple forward years. Financial 
year?                                         management software show previous year data and current year. 
                                              Budget preparation systems show planned disbursements across 
19. What are the planned disbursements in  multiple forward years. These planned disbursements are captured as 
each financial year?                          budgets in donor and recipient systems. This does not necessarily imply 
                                              ability to spend those funds. 
20. What are the dates, descriptions and  Provided in aid management systems. Budget preparation systems 
values of planned or committed financial  show planned disbursements across multiple forward years. Financial 



                                                                                                                      13
FreeBalance®
transactions?                                 systems show planned disbursements in the current fiscal year. This 
                                              includes when commitments are expected. Commitments and 
                                              obligations are key elements of any government This shows funds set 
                                              aside by donors in the financial system ahead of disbursements 
                                              including multiple year commitments. Recipient governments also 
                                              commit funds that have been disbursed from donors but not yet spent. 
                                              This is important because commitments can show progress (purchase 
                                              orders, goods received etc.) towards disbursements. 
21. What are the dates, descriptions and      Provided in aid management systems. Financial management 
values of already disbursed financial         software show full disbursement details including the type of 
transactions?                                 disbursement. 
                                              Provided in aid management systems. The donor COA should have aid 
22. What type of aid is this?                 types included. Recipient governments can classify the type of aid, 
                                              typically within the fund segment. 
                                              Provided in aid management systems. Financing mechanisms are 
                                              included in the object segment in the COA. Grant management 
23. What are the financing mechanisms         systems can capture the entire grants and loans lifecycle including 
used?                                         post‐award administration. Recipient governments can code the 
                                              mechanism in Fund or Object segments. Debt information is usually 
                                              included in debt management systems. 

Case Study: Government of Afghanistan Country System Effectiveness
Automating financial flows from donors to recipient governments reduces corruption by dramatically
reducing the fungibility of aid 12 . Integration across the budget
cycle, including with banking systems tracks funds and enable
audit.
Transparency International is the global coalition fighting against
corruption. On the Transparency International blog, author Maria
Gili of the International Defence and Security Programme
at Transparency International UK recently published an article
titled “Corruption in Afghanistan: The Status Quo is Not an
Option”.
The article describes how corruption is becoming endemic and
ranks as the highest concern for the people of Afghanistan. To
prevent corruption from becoming the status quo, the author
provides options that include a report on the total funds flowing
into the country.




12
     As described in FreeBalance Blog Entry



                                                                                                                 14
FreeBalance®
As the majority of funds spent in Afghanistan come from international donors, most of it is off-budget – not
on the government books. Some of these funds are provided directly to government entities outside of the
budget process. Most of it is expended directly by donors or through 3rd parties, such as NGOs.
This reduces the ability for donors and the government to coordinate action. This also reduces aid
effectiveness, which can be as big a problem as corruption in some countries.
But the real problem is that off-budget money is very hard to trace, especially cash payments. On-budget is
much easier to trace, control and audit.
The Afghanistan Ministry of Finance has made great strides at reducing corruption substantially in public
financial management (PFM). Since 2002, the Ministry of Finance has been using the Afghanistan Financial
Management Information System (AFMIS). The AFMIS is an automated PFM system based on the
FreeBalance Accountability Suite that can generate fully auditable reports on all transactions. Using the
AFMIS, more than 99% of the government’s budget execution is captured on a real-time basis.
Highlights of the AFMIS include:
   2010 saw the AFMIS Rollout team in Nuristan print its first cheque. With this achievement, the rollout of the 
    AFMIS across the provinces of Afghanistan was completed as Nuristan was the last province to be connected to 
    the AFMIS network. 
   All 34 Afghanistan provinces and all line Ministries at the centre now have system‐based budget controls, and can 
    execute system‐based payments with a very high degree of fiduciary control. 
   In the April 2011 World Bank Economic Premise note titled “Strengthening Public Financial Management in 
    Postconflict Countries,” the Government of Afghanistan was given a rating of “substantial” — the highest rating 
    — for PFM rebuilding and reform progress. 
And, as the documentary piece pointed out, Afghanistan has made significant capacity building gains as
regular training on the AFMIS has resulted in 262 government employees being added to the AFMIS skilled
workforce.
These are significant achievements that fail to get too much attention because of the overarching narrative
that all government institutions are corrupt.
Evidence suggests that public finances have improved in Afghanistan to be better than peer countries. Using
the AFMIS, the Government of Afghanistan has improved governance, accountability, and transparency.




                                                                                                                 15
FreeBalance®
Conclusions
   Integration between donor and government systems will reduce transaction costs and corruption 
    through automation while improving efficiency and effectiveness through harmonization 
   Aid information including transactions (and transaction stages),  project information (including 
    documents) can be integrated because charts of accounts provide the linking metadata 
   Differences among charts of accounts can be facilitated through the use of side tables or side concepts 
   Members of the aid ecosystem need to adopt program budgeting to enable integration – this cost will 
    enable timely aid reporting including monthly and quarterly 
   Manual methods of integration compromises data quality and timeliness resulting is less coordination 
    and less effective aid 
   Integration can be accomplished with aid management, budget preparation and budget execution 
    systems 
   Tracking disbursements from donors and payment by recipient governments does not show progress so 
    aid transparency and effectiveness can be improved by following the commitment cycle 




                                                                                                         16
FreeBalance®
About FreeBalance
FreeBalance is a For Profit Social Enterprise (FOPSE)
software company that helps governments around the
world to leverage robust Government Resource
Planning (GRP) technology to accelerate country
growth. Proven FreeBalance GRP products and
focused methodology supports financial reform and
modernization to improve governance, transparency
                                                          Contact FreeBalance
and accountability. Good governance is required to        T: +1 613 236-5150 (outside North America)
improve development results. FreeBalance ensures          info@freebalance.com
high success rates for governments under stress to        www.freebalance.com
those in the G8 and enables governments to improve        Canada
performance and comply with government goals.             FreeBalance (Headquarters)
Unlike other Commercial Off-the-Shelf (COTS)              1101 Prince of Wales Drive
vendors, FreeBalance is socially responsible as core,     Suite 210, Ottawa, Ontario
customer-centric and focused 100% on government.          Canada K2C 3W7
                                                          T: (613) 236-5150
The FreeBalance Accountability Suite is a                 Toll Free: 1-877-887-3733 (North America only)
comprehensive fully web-based Government Resource         F: (613) 236-7785
Planning software suite that supports the entire budget   Guatemala
cycle and strengthens governance by improving budget      FreeBalance
transparency, fiscal control and predictability. The      EuroPlaza World Business Center
                                                          Tower 1 – Suite 903 ‘A’
proven Suite integrates transactions with content and
                                                          5 Avenue 5-55 Zone 14
collaboration through innovative Government 2.0           Guatemala City, Guatemala
technology and links budget controls with objectives to
enable governments to improve performance,                Kosovo
                                                          FreeBalance
transparency and comply with government goals.            Bedri Pejani, 7A
Unlike other Commercial Off-the-Shelf (COTS)              10000 Pristina, Kosovo
software, the FreeBalance Accountability Suite is
proven in government implementations around the           Portugal
                                                          FreeBalance
word, programmed for government and progressively         Edificio Cyprum, Avenida 25 de Abril
activated to adapt to current and changing government     No. 15-B, 2D
context.                                                  Linda-a-Velha, Portugal

FreeBalance i3+qM is an integrated product                Uganda
development, implementation and sustainability            FreeBalance Inc.
                                                          Plot No. 23, Soliz House
services methodology designed for Government              Lumumba Avenue, Kampala, Uganda
Resource Planning to ensure long term implementation
success.                                                  United States
                                                          FreeBalance
                                                          1001 Connecticut Avenue, Suite 720
                                                          Washington, DC. 20036
                                                          T: 1-877-887-3733 (North America Toll Free)




                                                                                                           17
FreeBalance®
www.freebalance.com



                                     18
FreeBalance®

Contenu connexe

Tendances

Health Reform Bulletin – Completing the Transitional Reinsurance Fee Form
Health Reform Bulletin – Completing the Transitional Reinsurance Fee Form Health Reform Bulletin – Completing the Transitional Reinsurance Fee Form
Health Reform Bulletin – Completing the Transitional Reinsurance Fee Form CBIZ, Inc.
 
Enrollment md hcrcc_8.31.10
Enrollment md hcrcc_8.31.10Enrollment md hcrcc_8.31.10
Enrollment md hcrcc_8.31.10soder145
 
201502 accenture automatic exchange of information regime an emerging compl...
201502 accenture automatic exchange of information regime   an emerging compl...201502 accenture automatic exchange of information regime   an emerging compl...
201502 accenture automatic exchange of information regime an emerging compl...Francisco Calzado
 
Data and Methods for Constructing Synthetic Firms in CBO’s Health Insurance S...
Data and Methods for Constructing Synthetic Firms in CBO’s Health Insurance S...Data and Methods for Constructing Synthetic Firms in CBO’s Health Insurance S...
Data and Methods for Constructing Synthetic Firms in CBO’s Health Insurance S...Congressional Budget Office
 
“Federal Legislative and Regulatory Update,” Webinar at DFWHC
 “Federal Legislative and Regulatory Update,” Webinar at DFWHC “Federal Legislative and Regulatory Update,” Webinar at DFWHC
“Federal Legislative and Regulatory Update,” Webinar at DFWHCPYA, P.C.
 
HIT in the “New World” States, HITECH and Health Reform
HIT in the “New World” States, HITECH and Health ReformHIT in the “New World” States, HITECH and Health Reform
HIT in the “New World” States, HITECH and Health ReformNASHP HealthPolicy
 
Webinar: “Provider Relief Fund Payments – What We Know, What We Don’t Know, W...
Webinar: “Provider Relief Fund Payments – What We Know, What We Don’t Know, W...Webinar: “Provider Relief Fund Payments – What We Know, What We Don’t Know, W...
Webinar: “Provider Relief Fund Payments – What We Know, What We Don’t Know, W...PYA, P.C.
 
Webinar: CMS Pricing Transparency — Final Rule Requirements, Compliance Chall...
Webinar: CMS Pricing Transparency — Final Rule Requirements, Compliance Chall...Webinar: CMS Pricing Transparency — Final Rule Requirements, Compliance Chall...
Webinar: CMS Pricing Transparency — Final Rule Requirements, Compliance Chall...PYA, P.C.
 
Open Government Directive - Spending Transparency 04062010
Open Government Directive - Spending Transparency 04062010Open Government Directive - Spending Transparency 04062010
Open Government Directive - Spending Transparency 04062010dslunceford
 
HIX: Health Insurance Exchanges
HIX:  Health Insurance ExchangesHIX:  Health Insurance Exchanges
HIX: Health Insurance ExchangesChris Hoffmann
 
Office of Broadband Development Overview and Broadband Funding Streams
Office of Broadband Development Overview and Broadband Funding StreamsOffice of Broadband Development Overview and Broadband Funding Streams
Office of Broadband Development Overview and Broadband Funding StreamsAnn Treacy
 
Re-Evaluating Your Managed Care Revenue Improvement Opportunities
Re-Evaluating Your Managed Care Revenue Improvement OpportunitiesRe-Evaluating Your Managed Care Revenue Improvement Opportunities
Re-Evaluating Your Managed Care Revenue Improvement Opportunitieschriskalkhof
 
Engaging Your Board In the COVID-19 Era
Engaging Your Board In the COVID-19 EraEngaging Your Board In the COVID-19 Era
Engaging Your Board In the COVID-19 EraPYA, P.C.
 
Federal Regulatory Update
Federal Regulatory UpdateFederal Regulatory Update
Federal Regulatory UpdatePYA, P.C.
 
Public Education Audit
Public Education AuditPublic Education Audit
Public Education AuditCharlie Fuller
 
Modeling financial eligibility, ltss
Modeling financial eligibility, ltssModeling financial eligibility, ltss
Modeling financial eligibility, ltsssoder145
 

Tendances (20)

Health Reform Bulletin – Completing the Transitional Reinsurance Fee Form
Health Reform Bulletin – Completing the Transitional Reinsurance Fee Form Health Reform Bulletin – Completing the Transitional Reinsurance Fee Form
Health Reform Bulletin – Completing the Transitional Reinsurance Fee Form
 
Enrollment md hcrcc_8.31.10
Enrollment md hcrcc_8.31.10Enrollment md hcrcc_8.31.10
Enrollment md hcrcc_8.31.10
 
201502 accenture automatic exchange of information regime an emerging compl...
201502 accenture automatic exchange of information regime   an emerging compl...201502 accenture automatic exchange of information regime   an emerging compl...
201502 accenture automatic exchange of information regime an emerging compl...
 
Data and Methods for Constructing Synthetic Firms in CBO’s Health Insurance S...
Data and Methods for Constructing Synthetic Firms in CBO’s Health Insurance S...Data and Methods for Constructing Synthetic Firms in CBO’s Health Insurance S...
Data and Methods for Constructing Synthetic Firms in CBO’s Health Insurance S...
 
“Federal Legislative and Regulatory Update,” Webinar at DFWHC
 “Federal Legislative and Regulatory Update,” Webinar at DFWHC “Federal Legislative and Regulatory Update,” Webinar at DFWHC
“Federal Legislative and Regulatory Update,” Webinar at DFWHC
 
HIT in the “New World” States, HITECH and Health Reform
HIT in the “New World” States, HITECH and Health ReformHIT in the “New World” States, HITECH and Health Reform
HIT in the “New World” States, HITECH and Health Reform
 
Webinar: “Provider Relief Fund Payments – What We Know, What We Don’t Know, W...
Webinar: “Provider Relief Fund Payments – What We Know, What We Don’t Know, W...Webinar: “Provider Relief Fund Payments – What We Know, What We Don’t Know, W...
Webinar: “Provider Relief Fund Payments – What We Know, What We Don’t Know, W...
 
Webinar: CMS Pricing Transparency — Final Rule Requirements, Compliance Chall...
Webinar: CMS Pricing Transparency — Final Rule Requirements, Compliance Chall...Webinar: CMS Pricing Transparency — Final Rule Requirements, Compliance Chall...
Webinar: CMS Pricing Transparency — Final Rule Requirements, Compliance Chall...
 
Open Government Directive - Spending Transparency 04062010
Open Government Directive - Spending Transparency 04062010Open Government Directive - Spending Transparency 04062010
Open Government Directive - Spending Transparency 04062010
 
Washington Update
Washington UpdateWashington Update
Washington Update
 
HIX: Health Insurance Exchanges
HIX:  Health Insurance ExchangesHIX:  Health Insurance Exchanges
HIX: Health Insurance Exchanges
 
Office of Broadband Development Overview and Broadband Funding Streams
Office of Broadband Development Overview and Broadband Funding StreamsOffice of Broadband Development Overview and Broadband Funding Streams
Office of Broadband Development Overview and Broadband Funding Streams
 
NCSL's Presentation to IL Senate on Medicaid
NCSL's Presentation to IL Senate on MedicaidNCSL's Presentation to IL Senate on Medicaid
NCSL's Presentation to IL Senate on Medicaid
 
Re-Evaluating Your Managed Care Revenue Improvement Opportunities
Re-Evaluating Your Managed Care Revenue Improvement OpportunitiesRe-Evaluating Your Managed Care Revenue Improvement Opportunities
Re-Evaluating Your Managed Care Revenue Improvement Opportunities
 
Office Hour: Medicare Advantage Value-Based Insurance Design Model - 2022 Pay...
Office Hour: Medicare Advantage Value-Based Insurance Design Model - 2022 Pay...Office Hour: Medicare Advantage Value-Based Insurance Design Model - 2022 Pay...
Office Hour: Medicare Advantage Value-Based Insurance Design Model - 2022 Pay...
 
Health Insurance Exchanges
Health Insurance ExchangesHealth Insurance Exchanges
Health Insurance Exchanges
 
Engaging Your Board In the COVID-19 Era
Engaging Your Board In the COVID-19 EraEngaging Your Board In the COVID-19 Era
Engaging Your Board In the COVID-19 Era
 
Federal Regulatory Update
Federal Regulatory UpdateFederal Regulatory Update
Federal Regulatory Update
 
Public Education Audit
Public Education AuditPublic Education Audit
Public Education Audit
 
Modeling financial eligibility, ltss
Modeling financial eligibility, ltssModeling financial eligibility, ltss
Modeling financial eligibility, ltss
 

En vedette

Public financial-management-control-and-security-in-the-age-of-transparency
Public financial-management-control-and-security-in-the-age-of-transparencyPublic financial-management-control-and-security-in-the-age-of-transparency
Public financial-management-control-and-security-in-the-age-of-transparencyFreeBalance
 
2008 05 18 Icgfm To Icgfm
2008 05 18 Icgfm To Icgfm2008 05 18 Icgfm To Icgfm
2008 05 18 Icgfm To IcgfmFreeBalance
 
Public Financial Management Good Practice Multiple Year Chart of Accounts
Public Financial Management Good Practice Multiple Year Chart of AccountsPublic Financial Management Good Practice Multiple Year Chart of Accounts
Public Financial Management Good Practice Multiple Year Chart of AccountsFreeBalance
 
FreeBalance Public Financial Management Sustainability the Government Resourc...
FreeBalance Public Financial Management Sustainability the Government Resourc...FreeBalance Public Financial Management Sustainability the Government Resourc...
FreeBalance Public Financial Management Sustainability the Government Resourc...FreeBalance
 
Lessons Learned on the Public Financial Management Front LInes
Lessons Learned on the Public Financial Management Front LInesLessons Learned on the Public Financial Management Front LInes
Lessons Learned on the Public Financial Management Front LInesFreeBalance
 
2012 07 decentralization, governance and grp final
2012 07 decentralization, governance and grp final2012 07 decentralization, governance and grp final
2012 07 decentralization, governance and grp finalFreeBalance
 
Embracing government-2-0-leading-trans-formative-change-in-the-public-sector
Embracing government-2-0-leading-trans-formative-change-in-the-public-sectorEmbracing government-2-0-leading-trans-formative-change-in-the-public-sector
Embracing government-2-0-leading-trans-formative-change-in-the-public-sectorFreeBalance
 
Why is failure a success in the digital age? by Mariano Bosaz
Why is failure a success in the digital age? by Mariano BosazWhy is failure a success in the digital age? by Mariano Bosaz
Why is failure a success in the digital age? by Mariano BosazMariano A. Bosaz
 

En vedette (8)

Public financial-management-control-and-security-in-the-age-of-transparency
Public financial-management-control-and-security-in-the-age-of-transparencyPublic financial-management-control-and-security-in-the-age-of-transparency
Public financial-management-control-and-security-in-the-age-of-transparency
 
2008 05 18 Icgfm To Icgfm
2008 05 18 Icgfm To Icgfm2008 05 18 Icgfm To Icgfm
2008 05 18 Icgfm To Icgfm
 
Public Financial Management Good Practice Multiple Year Chart of Accounts
Public Financial Management Good Practice Multiple Year Chart of AccountsPublic Financial Management Good Practice Multiple Year Chart of Accounts
Public Financial Management Good Practice Multiple Year Chart of Accounts
 
FreeBalance Public Financial Management Sustainability the Government Resourc...
FreeBalance Public Financial Management Sustainability the Government Resourc...FreeBalance Public Financial Management Sustainability the Government Resourc...
FreeBalance Public Financial Management Sustainability the Government Resourc...
 
Lessons Learned on the Public Financial Management Front LInes
Lessons Learned on the Public Financial Management Front LInesLessons Learned on the Public Financial Management Front LInes
Lessons Learned on the Public Financial Management Front LInes
 
2012 07 decentralization, governance and grp final
2012 07 decentralization, governance and grp final2012 07 decentralization, governance and grp final
2012 07 decentralization, governance and grp final
 
Embracing government-2-0-leading-trans-formative-change-in-the-public-sector
Embracing government-2-0-leading-trans-formative-change-in-the-public-sectorEmbracing government-2-0-leading-trans-formative-change-in-the-public-sector
Embracing government-2-0-leading-trans-formative-change-in-the-public-sector
 
Why is failure a success in the digital age? by Mariano Bosaz
Why is failure a success in the digital age? by Mariano BosazWhy is failure a success in the digital age? by Mariano Bosaz
Why is failure a success in the digital age? by Mariano Bosaz
 

Similaire à Free balance integrating-country-systems-a-white-paper

Supply Chain And Bergerac
Supply Chain And BergeracSupply Chain And Bergerac
Supply Chain And BergeracNicole Savoie
 
1. Analyze the overall manner in which the aforementioned budgets su.pdf
1. Analyze the overall manner in which the aforementioned budgets su.pdf1. Analyze the overall manner in which the aforementioned budgets su.pdf
1. Analyze the overall manner in which the aforementioned budgets su.pdfFOREVERPRODUCTCHD
 
Icgfm remarks miami_may_18_2011
Icgfm remarks miami_may_18_2011Icgfm remarks miami_may_18_2011
Icgfm remarks miami_may_18_2011icgfmconference
 
Integrated reporting cpa ohio society sec conference presented by liv watson ...
Integrated reporting cpa ohio society sec conference presented by liv watson ...Integrated reporting cpa ohio society sec conference presented by liv watson ...
Integrated reporting cpa ohio society sec conference presented by liv watson ...Workiva
 
75 words as reply to this post if you cite also reference  Dunca.docx
75 words as reply to this post if you cite also reference  Dunca.docx75 words as reply to this post if you cite also reference  Dunca.docx
75 words as reply to this post if you cite also reference  Dunca.docxpriestmanmable
 
RUNNING HEAD FINANCE FOR PUBLIC ADMINISTRATORS1FINANCE FOR P.docx
RUNNING HEAD FINANCE FOR PUBLIC ADMINISTRATORS1FINANCE FOR P.docxRUNNING HEAD FINANCE FOR PUBLIC ADMINISTRATORS1FINANCE FOR P.docx
RUNNING HEAD FINANCE FOR PUBLIC ADMINISTRATORS1FINANCE FOR P.docxcowinhelen
 
Budget Critique Portland
Budget Critique PortlandBudget Critique Portland
Budget Critique PortlandEric Schlimgen
 
Rethinking Revenue Cycle Management_April 2015
Rethinking Revenue Cycle Management_April 2015Rethinking Revenue Cycle Management_April 2015
Rethinking Revenue Cycle Management_April 2015Spencer Brownell
 
Concept Note on Electronic Financial Transactions and Data Standards
Concept Note on Electronic Financial Transactions and Data StandardsConcept Note on Electronic Financial Transactions and Data Standards
Concept Note on Electronic Financial Transactions and Data StandardsLife of A Public Auditor
 
Concept Note on Electronic Financial Transactions and Data Standards
Concept Note on Electronic Financial Transactions and Data StandardsConcept Note on Electronic Financial Transactions and Data Standards
Concept Note on Electronic Financial Transactions and Data StandardsLife of A Public Auditor
 
CHAPTER 9Public Health FinanceCopyright © 2020 by Jo
CHAPTER 9Public Health FinanceCopyright © 2020 by JoCHAPTER 9Public Health FinanceCopyright © 2020 by Jo
CHAPTER 9Public Health FinanceCopyright © 2020 by JoJinElias52
 
February Bucket Li$t 2014
February Bucket Li$t 2014February Bucket Li$t 2014
February Bucket Li$t 2014Anita Harris
 
Presentation_of_Budget_Information_in_Fi.ppt
Presentation_of_Budget_Information_in_Fi.pptPresentation_of_Budget_Information_in_Fi.ppt
Presentation_of_Budget_Information_in_Fi.pptwasanthaarachchi
 
Fiscal Transparency - Delphine MORETTI, OECD (English)
Fiscal Transparency - Delphine MORETTI, OECD (English)Fiscal Transparency - Delphine MORETTI, OECD (English)
Fiscal Transparency - Delphine MORETTI, OECD (English)OECD Governance
 
Developments in accrual accounting: United States - Christina Ho, United States
Developments in accrual accounting: United States - Christina Ho, United StatesDevelopments in accrual accounting: United States - Christina Ho, United States
Developments in accrual accounting: United States - Christina Ho, United StatesOECD Governance
 
Plan Sponsors looking for lower-cost investment vehicles
Plan Sponsors looking for lower-cost investment vehiclesPlan Sponsors looking for lower-cost investment vehicles
Plan Sponsors looking for lower-cost investment vehiclesDan Brennan
 
Performance Budgeting in the USA by Scott Pattison
Performance Budgeting in the USA by Scott Pattison Performance Budgeting in the USA by Scott Pattison
Performance Budgeting in the USA by Scott Pattison OECD Governance
 

Similaire à Free balance integrating-country-systems-a-white-paper (20)

Supply Chain And Bergerac
Supply Chain And BergeracSupply Chain And Bergerac
Supply Chain And Bergerac
 
NGA PPP-SIB Lessons Learned
NGA PPP-SIB Lessons LearnedNGA PPP-SIB Lessons Learned
NGA PPP-SIB Lessons Learned
 
1. Analyze the overall manner in which the aforementioned budgets su.pdf
1. Analyze the overall manner in which the aforementioned budgets su.pdf1. Analyze the overall manner in which the aforementioned budgets su.pdf
1. Analyze the overall manner in which the aforementioned budgets su.pdf
 
Icgfm remarks miami_may_18_2011
Icgfm remarks miami_may_18_2011Icgfm remarks miami_may_18_2011
Icgfm remarks miami_may_18_2011
 
Zero-based Budgeting System: Is Budgeting System the Determinant of Budget Im...
Zero-based Budgeting System: Is Budgeting System the Determinant of Budget Im...Zero-based Budgeting System: Is Budgeting System the Determinant of Budget Im...
Zero-based Budgeting System: Is Budgeting System the Determinant of Budget Im...
 
Integrated reporting cpa ohio society sec conference presented by liv watson ...
Integrated reporting cpa ohio society sec conference presented by liv watson ...Integrated reporting cpa ohio society sec conference presented by liv watson ...
Integrated reporting cpa ohio society sec conference presented by liv watson ...
 
75 words as reply to this post if you cite also reference  Dunca.docx
75 words as reply to this post if you cite also reference  Dunca.docx75 words as reply to this post if you cite also reference  Dunca.docx
75 words as reply to this post if you cite also reference  Dunca.docx
 
RUNNING HEAD FINANCE FOR PUBLIC ADMINISTRATORS1FINANCE FOR P.docx
RUNNING HEAD FINANCE FOR PUBLIC ADMINISTRATORS1FINANCE FOR P.docxRUNNING HEAD FINANCE FOR PUBLIC ADMINISTRATORS1FINANCE FOR P.docx
RUNNING HEAD FINANCE FOR PUBLIC ADMINISTRATORS1FINANCE FOR P.docx
 
Budget Critique Portland
Budget Critique PortlandBudget Critique Portland
Budget Critique Portland
 
Rethinking Revenue Cycle Management_April 2015
Rethinking Revenue Cycle Management_April 2015Rethinking Revenue Cycle Management_April 2015
Rethinking Revenue Cycle Management_April 2015
 
Concept Note on Electronic Financial Transactions and Data Standards
Concept Note on Electronic Financial Transactions and Data StandardsConcept Note on Electronic Financial Transactions and Data Standards
Concept Note on Electronic Financial Transactions and Data Standards
 
Concept Note on Electronic Financial Transactions and Data Standards
Concept Note on Electronic Financial Transactions and Data StandardsConcept Note on Electronic Financial Transactions and Data Standards
Concept Note on Electronic Financial Transactions and Data Standards
 
CHAPTER 9Public Health FinanceCopyright © 2020 by Jo
CHAPTER 9Public Health FinanceCopyright © 2020 by JoCHAPTER 9Public Health FinanceCopyright © 2020 by Jo
CHAPTER 9Public Health FinanceCopyright © 2020 by Jo
 
February Bucket Li$t 2014
February Bucket Li$t 2014February Bucket Li$t 2014
February Bucket Li$t 2014
 
Presentation_of_Budget_Information_in_Fi.ppt
Presentation_of_Budget_Information_in_Fi.pptPresentation_of_Budget_Information_in_Fi.ppt
Presentation_of_Budget_Information_in_Fi.ppt
 
Fiscal Transparency - Delphine MORETTI, OECD (English)
Fiscal Transparency - Delphine MORETTI, OECD (English)Fiscal Transparency - Delphine MORETTI, OECD (English)
Fiscal Transparency - Delphine MORETTI, OECD (English)
 
Developments in accrual accounting: United States - Christina Ho, United States
Developments in accrual accounting: United States - Christina Ho, United StatesDevelopments in accrual accounting: United States - Christina Ho, United States
Developments in accrual accounting: United States - Christina Ho, United States
 
Plan Sponsors looking for lower-cost investment vehicles
Plan Sponsors looking for lower-cost investment vehiclesPlan Sponsors looking for lower-cost investment vehicles
Plan Sponsors looking for lower-cost investment vehicles
 
ACO faq 111611
ACO faq 111611ACO faq 111611
ACO faq 111611
 
Performance Budgeting in the USA by Scott Pattison
Performance Budgeting in the USA by Scott Pattison Performance Budgeting in the USA by Scott Pattison
Performance Budgeting in the USA by Scott Pattison
 

Plus de FreeBalance

Role of Public Financial Management for Risk Management in Developing Country...
Role of Public Financial Management for Risk Management in Developing Country...Role of Public Financial Management for Risk Management in Developing Country...
Role of Public Financial Management for Risk Management in Developing Country...FreeBalance
 
Government Integrated Financial Management Information Systems: Past Present ...
Government Integrated Financial Management Information Systems: Past Present ...Government Integrated Financial Management Information Systems: Past Present ...
Government Integrated Financial Management Information Systems: Past Present ...FreeBalance
 
Benefits of Joining ICGFM
Benefits of Joining ICGFMBenefits of Joining ICGFM
Benefits of Joining ICGFMFreeBalance
 
FreeBalance Government Customers on the Road to Improved Governance
FreeBalance Government Customers on the Road to Improved GovernanceFreeBalance Government Customers on the Road to Improved Governance
FreeBalance Government Customers on the Road to Improved GovernanceFreeBalance
 
GRP & IT Vendor Governance in Government
GRP & IT Vendor Governance in GovernmentGRP & IT Vendor Governance in Government
GRP & IT Vendor Governance in GovernmentFreeBalance
 
Technology Leapfrog Opportunity for Africa Government & Central Bank Governance
Technology Leapfrog Opportunity for Africa Government & Central Bank GovernanceTechnology Leapfrog Opportunity for Africa Government & Central Bank Governance
Technology Leapfrog Opportunity for Africa Government & Central Bank GovernanceFreeBalance
 
State of public financial management reform in developing countries
State of public financial management reform in developing countriesState of public financial management reform in developing countries
State of public financial management reform in developing countriesFreeBalance
 
Automating Good Governance through Government Resource Planning software
Automating Good Governance through Government Resource Planning softwareAutomating Good Governance through Government Resource Planning software
Automating Good Governance through Government Resource Planning softwareFreeBalance
 
2013 05-07 Lessons Learned on the Public Financial Management Front LInes
2013 05-07 Lessons Learned on the Public Financial Management Front LInes2013 05-07 Lessons Learned on the Public Financial Management Front LInes
2013 05-07 Lessons Learned on the Public Financial Management Front LInesFreeBalance
 
Good Practices in Government Resource Planning Vendor Specialization
Good Practices in Government Resource Planning Vendor SpecializationGood Practices in Government Resource Planning Vendor Specialization
Good Practices in Government Resource Planning Vendor SpecializationFreeBalance
 
Good Practices Government Resource Planning, Developing and Developed Countries
Good Practices Government Resource Planning, Developing and Developed CountriesGood Practices Government Resource Planning, Developing and Developed Countries
Good Practices Government Resource Planning, Developing and Developed CountriesFreeBalance
 
Public Financial Management Good Practice Government Resource Planning Resour...
Public Financial Management Good Practice Government Resource Planning Resour...Public Financial Management Good Practice Government Resource Planning Resour...
Public Financial Management Good Practice Government Resource Planning Resour...FreeBalance
 
Public Financial Management Good Practice Government Resource Planning Budget...
Public Financial Management Good Practice Government Resource Planning Budget...Public Financial Management Good Practice Government Resource Planning Budget...
Public Financial Management Good Practice Government Resource Planning Budget...FreeBalance
 
Public Financial Management Good Practice Government Resource Planning Total ...
Public Financial Management Good Practice Government Resource Planning Total ...Public Financial Management Good Practice Government Resource Planning Total ...
Public Financial Management Good Practice Government Resource Planning Total ...FreeBalance
 
Why so many sports related stores in 1 area
Why so many sports related stores in 1 areaWhy so many sports related stores in 1 area
Why so many sports related stores in 1 areaFreeBalance
 
2012 09-10 fmis-training_at_crown_agents
2012 09-10 fmis-training_at_crown_agents2012 09-10 fmis-training_at_crown_agents
2012 09-10 fmis-training_at_crown_agentsFreeBalance
 
How to-become-a-for-profit-social-enterprise-fopse
How to-become-a-for-profit-social-enterprise-fopseHow to-become-a-for-profit-social-enterprise-fopse
How to-become-a-for-profit-social-enterprise-fopseFreeBalance
 
Free balance-wp-towards-budget-2-0
Free balance-wp-towards-budget-2-0 Free balance-wp-towards-budget-2-0
Free balance-wp-towards-budget-2-0 FreeBalance
 
Gestion publica-controles-y-seguridad-en-la-era-de-la-transparencia
Gestion publica-controles-y-seguridad-en-la-era-de-la-transparenciaGestion publica-controles-y-seguridad-en-la-era-de-la-transparencia
Gestion publica-controles-y-seguridad-en-la-era-de-la-transparenciaFreeBalance
 
2011 04-25-afghanistan-pfm-case-study
2011 04-25-afghanistan-pfm-case-study2011 04-25-afghanistan-pfm-case-study
2011 04-25-afghanistan-pfm-case-studyFreeBalance
 

Plus de FreeBalance (20)

Role of Public Financial Management for Risk Management in Developing Country...
Role of Public Financial Management for Risk Management in Developing Country...Role of Public Financial Management for Risk Management in Developing Country...
Role of Public Financial Management for Risk Management in Developing Country...
 
Government Integrated Financial Management Information Systems: Past Present ...
Government Integrated Financial Management Information Systems: Past Present ...Government Integrated Financial Management Information Systems: Past Present ...
Government Integrated Financial Management Information Systems: Past Present ...
 
Benefits of Joining ICGFM
Benefits of Joining ICGFMBenefits of Joining ICGFM
Benefits of Joining ICGFM
 
FreeBalance Government Customers on the Road to Improved Governance
FreeBalance Government Customers on the Road to Improved GovernanceFreeBalance Government Customers on the Road to Improved Governance
FreeBalance Government Customers on the Road to Improved Governance
 
GRP & IT Vendor Governance in Government
GRP & IT Vendor Governance in GovernmentGRP & IT Vendor Governance in Government
GRP & IT Vendor Governance in Government
 
Technology Leapfrog Opportunity for Africa Government & Central Bank Governance
Technology Leapfrog Opportunity for Africa Government & Central Bank GovernanceTechnology Leapfrog Opportunity for Africa Government & Central Bank Governance
Technology Leapfrog Opportunity for Africa Government & Central Bank Governance
 
State of public financial management reform in developing countries
State of public financial management reform in developing countriesState of public financial management reform in developing countries
State of public financial management reform in developing countries
 
Automating Good Governance through Government Resource Planning software
Automating Good Governance through Government Resource Planning softwareAutomating Good Governance through Government Resource Planning software
Automating Good Governance through Government Resource Planning software
 
2013 05-07 Lessons Learned on the Public Financial Management Front LInes
2013 05-07 Lessons Learned on the Public Financial Management Front LInes2013 05-07 Lessons Learned on the Public Financial Management Front LInes
2013 05-07 Lessons Learned on the Public Financial Management Front LInes
 
Good Practices in Government Resource Planning Vendor Specialization
Good Practices in Government Resource Planning Vendor SpecializationGood Practices in Government Resource Planning Vendor Specialization
Good Practices in Government Resource Planning Vendor Specialization
 
Good Practices Government Resource Planning, Developing and Developed Countries
Good Practices Government Resource Planning, Developing and Developed CountriesGood Practices Government Resource Planning, Developing and Developed Countries
Good Practices Government Resource Planning, Developing and Developed Countries
 
Public Financial Management Good Practice Government Resource Planning Resour...
Public Financial Management Good Practice Government Resource Planning Resour...Public Financial Management Good Practice Government Resource Planning Resour...
Public Financial Management Good Practice Government Resource Planning Resour...
 
Public Financial Management Good Practice Government Resource Planning Budget...
Public Financial Management Good Practice Government Resource Planning Budget...Public Financial Management Good Practice Government Resource Planning Budget...
Public Financial Management Good Practice Government Resource Planning Budget...
 
Public Financial Management Good Practice Government Resource Planning Total ...
Public Financial Management Good Practice Government Resource Planning Total ...Public Financial Management Good Practice Government Resource Planning Total ...
Public Financial Management Good Practice Government Resource Planning Total ...
 
Why so many sports related stores in 1 area
Why so many sports related stores in 1 areaWhy so many sports related stores in 1 area
Why so many sports related stores in 1 area
 
2012 09-10 fmis-training_at_crown_agents
2012 09-10 fmis-training_at_crown_agents2012 09-10 fmis-training_at_crown_agents
2012 09-10 fmis-training_at_crown_agents
 
How to-become-a-for-profit-social-enterprise-fopse
How to-become-a-for-profit-social-enterprise-fopseHow to-become-a-for-profit-social-enterprise-fopse
How to-become-a-for-profit-social-enterprise-fopse
 
Free balance-wp-towards-budget-2-0
Free balance-wp-towards-budget-2-0 Free balance-wp-towards-budget-2-0
Free balance-wp-towards-budget-2-0
 
Gestion publica-controles-y-seguridad-en-la-era-de-la-transparencia
Gestion publica-controles-y-seguridad-en-la-era-de-la-transparenciaGestion publica-controles-y-seguridad-en-la-era-de-la-transparencia
Gestion publica-controles-y-seguridad-en-la-era-de-la-transparencia
 
2011 04-25-afghanistan-pfm-case-study
2011 04-25-afghanistan-pfm-case-study2011 04-25-afghanistan-pfm-case-study
2011 04-25-afghanistan-pfm-case-study
 

Dernier

India Consumer 2024 Redacted Sample Report
India Consumer 2024 Redacted Sample ReportIndia Consumer 2024 Redacted Sample Report
India Consumer 2024 Redacted Sample ReportMintel Group
 
8447779800, Low rate Call girls in New Ashok Nagar Delhi NCR
8447779800, Low rate Call girls in New Ashok Nagar Delhi NCR8447779800, Low rate Call girls in New Ashok Nagar Delhi NCR
8447779800, Low rate Call girls in New Ashok Nagar Delhi NCRashishs7044
 
2024 Numerator Consumer Study of Cannabis Usage
2024 Numerator Consumer Study of Cannabis Usage2024 Numerator Consumer Study of Cannabis Usage
2024 Numerator Consumer Study of Cannabis UsageNeil Kimberley
 
Innovation Conference 5th March 2024.pdf
Innovation Conference 5th March 2024.pdfInnovation Conference 5th March 2024.pdf
Innovation Conference 5th March 2024.pdfrichard876048
 
Cybersecurity Awareness Training Presentation v2024.03
Cybersecurity Awareness Training Presentation v2024.03Cybersecurity Awareness Training Presentation v2024.03
Cybersecurity Awareness Training Presentation v2024.03DallasHaselhorst
 
8447779800, Low rate Call girls in Kotla Mubarakpur Delhi NCR
8447779800, Low rate Call girls in Kotla Mubarakpur Delhi NCR8447779800, Low rate Call girls in Kotla Mubarakpur Delhi NCR
8447779800, Low rate Call girls in Kotla Mubarakpur Delhi NCRashishs7044
 
Investment in The Coconut Industry by Nancy Cheruiyot
Investment in The Coconut Industry by Nancy CheruiyotInvestment in The Coconut Industry by Nancy Cheruiyot
Investment in The Coconut Industry by Nancy Cheruiyotictsugar
 
Ten Organizational Design Models to align structure and operations to busines...
Ten Organizational Design Models to align structure and operations to busines...Ten Organizational Design Models to align structure and operations to busines...
Ten Organizational Design Models to align structure and operations to busines...Seta Wicaksana
 
APRIL2024_UKRAINE_xml_0000000000000 .pdf
APRIL2024_UKRAINE_xml_0000000000000 .pdfAPRIL2024_UKRAINE_xml_0000000000000 .pdf
APRIL2024_UKRAINE_xml_0000000000000 .pdfRbc Rbcua
 
International Business Environments and Operations 16th Global Edition test b...
International Business Environments and Operations 16th Global Edition test b...International Business Environments and Operations 16th Global Edition test b...
International Business Environments and Operations 16th Global Edition test b...ssuserf63bd7
 
Buy gmail accounts.pdf Buy Old Gmail Accounts
Buy gmail accounts.pdf Buy Old Gmail AccountsBuy gmail accounts.pdf Buy Old Gmail Accounts
Buy gmail accounts.pdf Buy Old Gmail AccountsBuy Verified Accounts
 
Market Sizes Sample Report - 2024 Edition
Market Sizes Sample Report - 2024 EditionMarket Sizes Sample Report - 2024 Edition
Market Sizes Sample Report - 2024 EditionMintel Group
 
Kenya Coconut Production Presentation by Dr. Lalith Perera
Kenya Coconut Production Presentation by Dr. Lalith PereraKenya Coconut Production Presentation by Dr. Lalith Perera
Kenya Coconut Production Presentation by Dr. Lalith Pereraictsugar
 
Kenya’s Coconut Value Chain by Gatsby Africa
Kenya’s Coconut Value Chain by Gatsby AfricaKenya’s Coconut Value Chain by Gatsby Africa
Kenya’s Coconut Value Chain by Gatsby Africaictsugar
 
Youth Involvement in an Innovative Coconut Value Chain by Mwalimu Menza
Youth Involvement in an Innovative Coconut Value Chain by Mwalimu MenzaYouth Involvement in an Innovative Coconut Value Chain by Mwalimu Menza
Youth Involvement in an Innovative Coconut Value Chain by Mwalimu Menzaictsugar
 
Future Of Sample Report 2024 | Redacted Version
Future Of Sample Report 2024 | Redacted VersionFuture Of Sample Report 2024 | Redacted Version
Future Of Sample Report 2024 | Redacted VersionMintel Group
 
Flow Your Strategy at Flight Levels Day 2024
Flow Your Strategy at Flight Levels Day 2024Flow Your Strategy at Flight Levels Day 2024
Flow Your Strategy at Flight Levels Day 2024Kirill Klimov
 
IoT Insurance Observatory: summary 2024
IoT Insurance Observatory:  summary 2024IoT Insurance Observatory:  summary 2024
IoT Insurance Observatory: summary 2024Matteo Carbone
 

Dernier (20)

India Consumer 2024 Redacted Sample Report
India Consumer 2024 Redacted Sample ReportIndia Consumer 2024 Redacted Sample Report
India Consumer 2024 Redacted Sample Report
 
8447779800, Low rate Call girls in New Ashok Nagar Delhi NCR
8447779800, Low rate Call girls in New Ashok Nagar Delhi NCR8447779800, Low rate Call girls in New Ashok Nagar Delhi NCR
8447779800, Low rate Call girls in New Ashok Nagar Delhi NCR
 
2024 Numerator Consumer Study of Cannabis Usage
2024 Numerator Consumer Study of Cannabis Usage2024 Numerator Consumer Study of Cannabis Usage
2024 Numerator Consumer Study of Cannabis Usage
 
Innovation Conference 5th March 2024.pdf
Innovation Conference 5th March 2024.pdfInnovation Conference 5th March 2024.pdf
Innovation Conference 5th March 2024.pdf
 
Cybersecurity Awareness Training Presentation v2024.03
Cybersecurity Awareness Training Presentation v2024.03Cybersecurity Awareness Training Presentation v2024.03
Cybersecurity Awareness Training Presentation v2024.03
 
8447779800, Low rate Call girls in Kotla Mubarakpur Delhi NCR
8447779800, Low rate Call girls in Kotla Mubarakpur Delhi NCR8447779800, Low rate Call girls in Kotla Mubarakpur Delhi NCR
8447779800, Low rate Call girls in Kotla Mubarakpur Delhi NCR
 
Investment in The Coconut Industry by Nancy Cheruiyot
Investment in The Coconut Industry by Nancy CheruiyotInvestment in The Coconut Industry by Nancy Cheruiyot
Investment in The Coconut Industry by Nancy Cheruiyot
 
Ten Organizational Design Models to align structure and operations to busines...
Ten Organizational Design Models to align structure and operations to busines...Ten Organizational Design Models to align structure and operations to busines...
Ten Organizational Design Models to align structure and operations to busines...
 
APRIL2024_UKRAINE_xml_0000000000000 .pdf
APRIL2024_UKRAINE_xml_0000000000000 .pdfAPRIL2024_UKRAINE_xml_0000000000000 .pdf
APRIL2024_UKRAINE_xml_0000000000000 .pdf
 
Enjoy ➥8448380779▻ Call Girls In Sector 18 Noida Escorts Delhi NCR
Enjoy ➥8448380779▻ Call Girls In Sector 18 Noida Escorts Delhi NCREnjoy ➥8448380779▻ Call Girls In Sector 18 Noida Escorts Delhi NCR
Enjoy ➥8448380779▻ Call Girls In Sector 18 Noida Escorts Delhi NCR
 
International Business Environments and Operations 16th Global Edition test b...
International Business Environments and Operations 16th Global Edition test b...International Business Environments and Operations 16th Global Edition test b...
International Business Environments and Operations 16th Global Edition test b...
 
Buy gmail accounts.pdf Buy Old Gmail Accounts
Buy gmail accounts.pdf Buy Old Gmail AccountsBuy gmail accounts.pdf Buy Old Gmail Accounts
Buy gmail accounts.pdf Buy Old Gmail Accounts
 
Market Sizes Sample Report - 2024 Edition
Market Sizes Sample Report - 2024 EditionMarket Sizes Sample Report - 2024 Edition
Market Sizes Sample Report - 2024 Edition
 
No-1 Call Girls In Goa 93193 VIP 73153 Escort service In North Goa Panaji, Ca...
No-1 Call Girls In Goa 93193 VIP 73153 Escort service In North Goa Panaji, Ca...No-1 Call Girls In Goa 93193 VIP 73153 Escort service In North Goa Panaji, Ca...
No-1 Call Girls In Goa 93193 VIP 73153 Escort service In North Goa Panaji, Ca...
 
Kenya Coconut Production Presentation by Dr. Lalith Perera
Kenya Coconut Production Presentation by Dr. Lalith PereraKenya Coconut Production Presentation by Dr. Lalith Perera
Kenya Coconut Production Presentation by Dr. Lalith Perera
 
Kenya’s Coconut Value Chain by Gatsby Africa
Kenya’s Coconut Value Chain by Gatsby AfricaKenya’s Coconut Value Chain by Gatsby Africa
Kenya’s Coconut Value Chain by Gatsby Africa
 
Youth Involvement in an Innovative Coconut Value Chain by Mwalimu Menza
Youth Involvement in an Innovative Coconut Value Chain by Mwalimu MenzaYouth Involvement in an Innovative Coconut Value Chain by Mwalimu Menza
Youth Involvement in an Innovative Coconut Value Chain by Mwalimu Menza
 
Future Of Sample Report 2024 | Redacted Version
Future Of Sample Report 2024 | Redacted VersionFuture Of Sample Report 2024 | Redacted Version
Future Of Sample Report 2024 | Redacted Version
 
Flow Your Strategy at Flight Levels Day 2024
Flow Your Strategy at Flight Levels Day 2024Flow Your Strategy at Flight Levels Day 2024
Flow Your Strategy at Flight Levels Day 2024
 
IoT Insurance Observatory: summary 2024
IoT Insurance Observatory:  summary 2024IoT Insurance Observatory:  summary 2024
IoT Insurance Observatory: summary 2024
 

Free balance integrating-country-systems-a-white-paper

  • 1. FreeBalance® Aid Transparency Integration The Integration of Donor and Recipient Government Financial Systems Enabling Aid Transparency and Aid Effectiveness
  • 2. Copyright Information © FreeBalance Inc. 2011, Some Rights Reserved. Except where otherwise noted, this work is licensed under Creative Commons Attribution ShareAlike 3.0. You are free: o to Share — to copy, distribute and transmit the work o to Remix — to adapt the work Under the following conditions: o Attribution. You must attribute the work in the manner specified by the author or licensor (but not in any way that suggests that they endorse you or your use of the work). o Share Alike. If you alter, transform, or build upon this work, you may distribute the resulting work only under the same, similar or a compatible license. o For any reuse or distribution, you must make clear to others the license terms of this work. The best way to do this is with a link to this web page. o Any of the above conditions can be waived if you get permission from the copyright holder. o Nothing in this license impairs or restricts the author's moral rights. 2 FreeBalance®
  • 3. The Integration of Donor and Recipient Government Financial Systems Enabling Aid Transparency and Aid Effectiveness The International Aid Transparency Initiative (IATI) “aims to make information about aid spending easier to access, use and understand.” IATI seeks to improve aid effectiveness through transparency. Transparency can improve aid harmonization and reduce aid transaction costs throughout the entire aid lifecycle from donor funding through to result. International donors and partner countries have committed to improving aid through harmonization and transparency through the Paris Declaration on Aid Effectiveness and the Accra Agenda for Action. The goal: use strengthened country financial systems by donors rather than separate and inefficient systems. Put donor funds on-budget – on the government books to ensure transparency. The IATI Technical Advisory Group (TAG) has been studying methods for aid data integration among all aid participants. The integration of data between donor systems and recipient government budget systems is critical to IATI success. This integration can reduce administrative transaction costs. It can improve the coordination of donors and governments to achieve results. And, it can lead to direct budgetary support that ensures that aid better meets recipient government objectives. Transparency throughout the aid chain reduces the opportunity for fraud and corruption. It’s all about improving aid effectiveness. The TAG has encountered technical issues with donor and recipient government integration. Stakeholders from donors, civil society, governments and NGOs have differing aid effectiveness improvement objectives. Some stakeholders are concerned about the quality of historical statistical information, while others seek a better understanding of transactions. Aid sector categories differ among stakeholders. There are differing needs for the level information granularity. Current standards in use by International Financial Institutions (IFIs) and governments operate at cross purposes, satisfying few stakeholders. What’s the Technical Problem? These difficulties are seen as technical metadata integration problems – data structures from operational systems used among donors and recipient governments cannot be rationalized. The technical problem of project, transactional and statistical information integration among donor and recipient government budget systems is thought by some to be too complex and too expensive to contemplate. Nothing should be further from the truth. At its core, the IATI technical integration challenge is integrating donor budget with recipient government budget systems. Project data and statistical data are hierarchical constructs of budget and financial transactions. Additional data elements, including documents, project and statistical information can be linked directly to this transactional data. Timely, effective, and automated integration among financial and project systems across the aid lifecycle requires the adoption of good practices in financial management systems – the use of program classifications. Herein lies the problem. 3 FreeBalance®
  • 4. Developing nation governments, particularly FreeBalance customers, use program classifications. (And, the software enables progressively activating program classifications.) Many donors are not using this established good practice and have financial software systems that are too rigid to quickly and inexpensively adopt this good practice. 1 Towards Donor to Government Integration Automating the Financial Aid Lifecycle: High Level The integration of donor systems with recipient government budget systems for on-budget aid projects for comprehensive Public Financial Management (PFM) includes the following elements: 1. Donor budget preparation systems  where donors determine upcoming  project budgets. These systems could  integrate directly with recipient  government budget preparation  systems that include anticipated on‐ budget aid resulting in legally  mandated budget  2. Alternatively, and perhaps preferably,  the donor budget preparation and  system could integrate with aid  management systems. Aid  management systems enable donors  and recipient governments to  collaborate in the definition, funding  and management of aid projects. Also  recipient government budget preparation systems could integrate with aid management systems to enable  multiple year budget planning and to harmonize the government and aid budgets 2 .  3. The resulting budget prepared in the donor budget preparation system is formalized in the donor financial  management system for disbursements during the fiscal year.  4. Disbursement information from the donor financial system could integrate with the recipient government  financial system. The recipient government receives the funds against the budget item and provides authority to  spend through appropriations or warrants.  5. Alternatively, and perhaps preferably, the donor financial management provides disbursement information to  the aid management system that also integrates with the recipient government financial management system.  This provides disbursement information to all stakeholders to improve aid harmonization.  6. Outcome and project reports are generated from the aid management system.  1 (Financial software designed for the private sector often provides rigid classifications because these change infrequently. Government Chart of Accounts (COAs) change frequently to reflect modernization, reform, government restructuring, adoption of performance management, support of standards – including new standards like IATI.) Some donors pull project information from documents and have to manually reconcile with transactions. 2 This enables governments to product more credible budgets and support Medium Term Expenditure Frameworks (MTEF) 4 FreeBalance®
  • 5. 7. Outcome and project reports from the donor financial management and recipient government financial systems  can also provide output, project and outcome information.  8. Recipient government financial systems typically output statistical data using the IMF GFS standard. The IATI  standard could also be supported.  9. Output, project, outcome and statistical data can be compared to support historical analysis.  Automating the Financial Aid Lifecycle: Budget Preparation All public sector organizations operate using commitment accounting techniques for financial management. Budgets are developed that become the legal embodiment of government policy for recipient governments. Bi-lateral donors are government entities that also manage based on legal budget. Multi-lateral and non- profits donors also manage financials based on commitment accounting to satisfy funders. The budget preparation cycle is similar among public sector organizations regardless of information systems used. Recipient Government Perspective Aid intentions from donors, regardless of the certainty of that aid are critical to forming budgets. Recipient governments require harmonizing with donor budgets to achieve government objectives. The fact that a donor might commit to funding is important because the recipient government can identify this likelihood and be prepared should these funds be made available 3 . 1. Numerous factors are analyzed  during the budget preparation process. This includes organizational objects, or the general policy of the  organization, macroeconomic analysis and historical information to determine budget assumptions for the  upcoming year, typically in the form of a budget circular. This budget circular is scheduled during the current  fiscal year for planning for a subsequent fiscal year. Many government organizations plan ahead on a medium 3  year term. Therefore, the historical information includes preliminary information about the upcoming fiscal year  and multiple year projects and commitments.  2. The budget circular typically provides guidance on budget assumption in the form of budget ceilings to  organizational units.  3. Government organizations follow an iterative process of numerous internal budget proposals or versions with  project and cost justifications. These versions are rolled‐up to budget organizations and analyzed. Scenarios are  examined.  4. The budget organization completes a detailed budget document or budget book for approval.  3 Recipient governments can build contingencies in budget plans and ensure meeting government objectives through complementary funding. 5 FreeBalance®
  • 6. 5. The budget is adapted by legislative processes through a vote.   6. The result of the budget vote is a budget law in government.  7. The budget law provides the allotment or appropriation information for budget execution in the government  financial system.  Automating the Financial Aid Lifecycle: Aid management 1. Donors prepare budgets based on  donor objectives  2. Donor objectives are harmonized  with government objectives to  determine areas of mutual  interest with the view that reform  should be country driven  3. Projects that meet objectives are  proposed  4. That include a set of risk factors and performance measurements for expected outputs and outcomes  5. Projects that are approved for funding are shown in donor and recipient budget preparation systems  6. Budget information is shown in the budget execution module of donor and recipient government financial  management systems  7. Funds are disbursed by donors to the recipient governments and progress shown in a monitoring and evaluation  module  8. Funds received by donors are executed by the recipient governments, with progress shown in a monitoring and  evaluation module  9. Results from the projects can be tracked against risk factors and performance measures in a monitoring and  evaluation module  Automating the Financial Aid Lifecycle: Budget Execution Budget execution includes the financial management of all revenues and expenditures controlled by the budget. The budget can be adjusted throughout the fiscal year based on cash availability, macro-economic changes and availability of new revenue sources. Recipient Government Perspective Budget execution is difficult for many developing countries to effectively manage. These governments tend to experience cash shortfalls. Some governments are not able to spend the entire budget, hence reducing the effectiveness of many initiatives. Many donors examine recipient government disbursements as an indicator of progress. Yet, budget execution processes can expose in-progress spending through commitments and obligations to give a better indication of the recipient government project budgets. 1. The budget law developed during formulation creates the annual budget. The budget typically includes annual  spending limits that are aggregated by organizational unit, fund source, project and type of expenditure such as  capital or recurrent. The budget law also includes detailed line‐item budget estimates that are used for estimates  6 FreeBalance®
  • 7. in most governments but not controls 4 . The appropriations including authority to spend typically include the  aggregate annual budget, some elements of the line item information and period budgetary controls 5 .   2. Expenditures in government financial  management systems leverage  commitment accounting functions. Funds  are set aside during expenditure cycles to  ensure that budgets are overspent. Many  governments support two phases of  commitments where money is set aside  during the requisition stage as a soft  commitment or pre‐encumbrance. Good  practices in government financial  management ensure that contractual  obligations set aside funds when  purchase orders are created.   3. Goods and services are received by the government are paid for through disbursements or payments.   4. Government revenue may be higher or lower than expected based on macroeconomic changes. There may be  cash and liquidity issues. These situations often change expenditure budgets and appropriations. Cash and  liquidity issues can adjust budgets during the fiscal year.  5. Governments often receive supplemental budgets. Recipient governments receive project funds when fiscal  years are not aligned with donors and there is no budget preparation integration. Special supplemental budgets  are often created because of macroeconomic shocks, such as stimulus packages or because of natural disasters.   6. The spending status against the budget can be analyzed. Budget deficits and surpluses can be predicted. It is  considered a poor practice to under‐spend because this will reduce outputs and outcomes. Appropriations can  be loosened to encourage spending or tightened to reduce spending.   7. Budget reports showing outputs and variances are produced.   Automating the Financial Aid Lifecycle: Commitment Accounting Transactions Commitment Accounting is sometimes considered as part of the Budget Execution cycle. PFM transactions combine the traditional accounting transactions used in the private sector with budget controls. Recipient Government Perspective The status of commitments and obligations provides a better indicator of project progress than disbursements. It should also be noted that there can be delays in payment cycles after expenses have been approved. Therefore, the goods received and expense voucher stages in expenditures can also provide insight to project progress because these indicate goods and services completed but not yet paid. The commitment accounting transaction structure includes the following: 1. The budget law provides one or more appropriations that act as expenditure controls  4 Some government organizations use full line-item budget controls, but this is not considered a good practice in most situations. 5 Many governments operate with monthly or quarterly controls that are more detailed than the annual appropriation to enable more effective fiscal control. 7 FreeBalance®
  • 8. 2. Internal purchase requisitions are checked for budget availability in some countries. The estimated amount of  the expenditure is committed or set aside. 6  3. Purchase orders are checked against budget availability. Differences with requisitions are adjusted. The purchase  order represents a contractual obligation or hard commitment. The obligation is set aside.  4. Goods and services are  received and returned via  goods receipt and goods  returned notes are accrued if  the government is using  modified accrual or accrual  accounting 7 .   5. Goods and services that are  accepted are approved for  expenditures through  expense vouchers that are  shown in the accounts  payable sub‐ledger. PFM  systems tend to post  accounts payable  transactions to the general  ledger immediately in order  to show the true cash and  budget situation 8 .  6. Cash receipts, revenue from  taxation and other sources of government income are provided to Bank accounts and shown in the accounts  receivable sub‐ledger, posted in real time to the general ledger.  7. Payments are posted to the accounts payable sub‐ledger and honoured by the bank 9 .  8. The bank information is reconciled with the general ledger.  9. The recipient government manages cash and liquidity based on bank information, expected payments from  accounts payable and the commitment cycle, revenue expected from accounts receivable, forecasts based on  appropriations, investments and debt.  The Classification of Aid Information Classifying data is a typical information management problem. Information systems need to catalogue and classify data to support process workflow, analysis, decision-making and reporting. Information systems classify data based on needs. This data classification is known as “metadata.” Organizations often require using “master data management” tools to harmonize data across multiple information systems. These 6 Some countries use 2 commitment phases. 7 Most governments are moving towards supporting accrual accounting. 8 Many governments reconcile budgets information with ledger information as a second method of balancing. 9 The use of Electronic Funds Transfer (EFT) is a good practice to reduce the opportunity for corruption because it is far easier to track than cash money. 8 FreeBalance®
  • 9. systems reclassify and transform data to create common information. These systems also rationalize differing levels of detail required in information systems. 10 The aid lifecycle includes project, budget and financial information. This metadata associated with aid information tends to be multidimensional and hierarchical. For example, budget classifications or Charts of Accounts (COA) often include multiple data segments. Each segment includes a hierarchy of details. These classifications are used for every financial transaction. There are numerous COA practices including:  Budget classification structures tend  to change over time as donors and  recipient governments change  objectives, accounting methods (i.e.  accrual accounting) and items to  measure.   Organizations tend to modernize from  a simple structure including fund,  organization, object/economic item to  add program and output segments.   Mid‐developed countries are often  less likely to support international  standards and multiple segments.  Lower developed countries are most  likely to follow international  standards. High developed countries  have mature national standards that  are often at a par with international  standards.   International and some national  standards are supported via side  tables or side concepts. These items  roll‐up transactional data in  alternative methods through mapping  ranges of data to a different structure.  Budget and accounting users should  not be exposed to most statistical, project, and performance objects.  This method simplifies data entry yet  achieves reporting and integration requirements.  Case Study: The Government of Sierra Leone and Side Concepts The Government of Sierra Leone uses the program segment of 8 characters with 5 levels of hierarchy within a COA of 5 segments and 27 digits. 10 International data exchange standards like IATI provide a standard data target to facilitate integration. Organizations use MDM tools to import and export data when systems are do not support standards natively. 9 FreeBalance®
  • 10. Users enter budgets and accounting transactions where:  Character 1 = Project  Type   Characters 2 & 3 = Project   Character 4 = Component   Characters 5 & 6 = Sub  Component   Characters 7 & 8 = Activity  COA rules are able to take the 8 characters to infer 3 levels of government financial statistics support, 2 additional levels of project reporting, 4 additional levels of output or performance information and 1 level of Millennium Development Goals. The use of side concepts, supported by financial management systems used in almost all donors and most developing countries is conceived to be the method to support IATI reporting and integration. Aid Management Classifications Aid management systems track information and transactional information related to projects. This can vary from government to government, but the data structure for any project typically includes:  Project identification  including title,  description,  objective, purpose,  agreement number  and agreement date   Planning information  including project start and end dates, extension dates if any and project status   Project implementation information which includes whether it is implemented at national/sub national level and  the sector   Alignment of project to national priorities or MDGs   Project implementing and beneficiary partners  10 FreeBalance®
  • 11. Government and donor focal point contact information  Integrating Structure across Systems Integrating donor and recipient government systems is enabled because these systems hold more detailed information than is needed by the IATI standard. This detailed information needs to be aggregated to meet IATI needs. Yet, the structure of the budget data is different among stakeholders. However, there is sufficient commonality to infer or roll-up to the aggregate project and statistical information required by the IATI standard 11 . The process is conceptually no different than donors supporting CRS or recipient governments supporting GFS. 1. The donor budget system includes chart of accounts that describes objective, project, sector, recipient and  object code. This information could be in as few as 2 segments structured hierarchically. The objective, project,  sector and recipient government information can integrate with an aid management system through a mapping  process. Mapping data structures is well understood in information technology using Extract, Transform, Load  (ETL), Enterprise Application Integration (EAI) or Business Process Management (BPM) tools.  Many Government  Resource Planning Systems (GRP) support side concepts meaning that additional software will not be required.  2. The same information provided to the aid management system can integrate with the recipient government  chart of accounts. The conditions of the donor can be integrated through the fund and object segment and  controlled through valid code combinations to prevent improper spending.  3. Documents and other material such as assessments, reviews and proposals can be linked directly to elements of  the budget and aid classifications.  4. The highly detailed transactional information can be exported from donor budget systems through side table  COA structures or via mapping tools.  5. The less detailed transactional information can be exported from aid management systems through reports or  via mapping tools.  6. The highly detailed transactional information can be exported from recipient government budget systems  through side table COA structures or via mapping tools.  7. Common elements from DAC/CRS produced by some donors and GFS could be used to enhance the IATI data set  or simplify the process of reporting. Of course, the IATI data structure can align with data elements found in  documents. Navigating and drilling through IATI data could include document discovery.  11 Samuel Moon and Zachary Mills analyzed numerous government classifications to reach a similar conclusion in a paper published by the Oversees Development Institute 11 FreeBalance®
  • 12. Supporting IATI within Financial Systems The IATI Secretariat recently published a simple explanation of the IATI standard. This helps to explain that much of IATI can be automated through the proper use of financial management systems by donors and recipient governments. The premise is that financial information and project metadata is stored within the budget classifications or Chart of Accounts (COA). This metadata enables tracking transactions within the financial system with project documents and enable consolidation to the IATI standard. Donors use financial systems. Most recipient government use financial systems. The following table describes how financial systems can support the IATI standard. Financial Systems and IATI Integration Item  Financial System Alignment  Who is involved, where and how?  1. What is the name of the reporting  High Level Consolidation that can be appended to any reports coming  organisation?  from financial management software.  2. Which organisations have given you  funding? Which organisations are you  Provided in donor financial management software.  funding?  What are the project details?  3. What is the IATI identification code for  Can be linked from COA, some systems support additional unique  this project?  number (in this case IATI code) to COA element.  Projects are aligned typically through a program or project segment  4. Project name  where the project code in the COA has a description with the same name  as in documents.  Project name is sufficient to provide mapping between COA and  5. Project summary or description  documents. Many COTS financial management software enable longer  descriptions and attachments.  6. Are there documents related to this  Could be included in COA description information that can include links  project that can be or are already  and attachments.  published online? What is the link to them?  7. What is the website connected with this  Could be included in COA description information that can include links  activity  8. Who are the points of contact for this  Could be included in COA description information that can include  project?  project details like contact person.  12 FreeBalance®
  • 13. 9. Are there other projects that are related  Often inferred within the structure of the COA.  to this one? How are they related?  Geocoding is not typically in the COA. However, district is often  described in a separate COA segment or within the Organization  10. What are the geographic details of this  segment. Donors are unlikely to have geographic details beyond country.  project? (Optional)  Recipient countries likely to have geographic details following the  political structure of the country, so has different levels of granularity.  Geographic details often can be linked to aid management systems.  Typically held within the budget preparation, aid  11. What are the start and end dates for  management or project accounting systems. Medium Term Expenditure  this project?  Frameworks (MTEF) with 3‐year perspectives helpful to support the IATI  standard because so many projects span multiple years.  Financial status (original budget, commitments, disbursements, and  remaining funds) is provided in the financial management software.  12. What is the current status of this  This may not show the % completion. This is often stored in project  project  accounting systems. Monitoring and evaluation systems that are part of  aid management systems include risk factors can be linked.  Performance information provided in aid management systems. The  performance structure is often found in the COA. Donors should be using  13 What are the expected and actual  a structure to align project items to performance classifications.  results of this project? (Optional)  Recipient governments often have linkages to MDGs and government  objectives as inferred dimension (or side tables) to the program  segment.  14. Which sector or theme does this  Sector information typically stored in economic purpose or program  project contribute to  segments in COA. Also provided in aid management systems.  15. Is procurement tied or restricted to  Procurement conditions often stored within procurement systems. Also  certain countries? (Not necessarily  provided in aid management systems.  applicable)  Can be achieved in government financial management software  16. Are there any cross cutting themes to  through creating inferred dimensions within the COA and through  highlight in this project?  attached narrative. Also provided in aid management systems.  Can be partly supported for conditionality in recipient systems. Many  recipient countries have a Fund segment in the COA. Conditions by fund  17. Are there terms and conditions  source for expenditures can be automated. Specific project conditions  attached to the project?  often attached to Revenue transactions. Also provided in aid  management systems.  What are the financial details?  18. What are the budgets in each financial  Budget preparation systems show multiple forward years. Financial  year?  management software show previous year data and current year.  Budget preparation systems show planned disbursements across  19. What are the planned disbursements in  multiple forward years. These planned disbursements are captured as  each financial year?  budgets in donor and recipient systems. This does not necessarily imply  ability to spend those funds.  20. What are the dates, descriptions and  Provided in aid management systems. Budget preparation systems  values of planned or committed financial  show planned disbursements across multiple forward years. Financial  13 FreeBalance®
  • 14. transactions?  systems show planned disbursements in the current fiscal year. This  includes when commitments are expected. Commitments and  obligations are key elements of any government This shows funds set  aside by donors in the financial system ahead of disbursements  including multiple year commitments. Recipient governments also  commit funds that have been disbursed from donors but not yet spent.  This is important because commitments can show progress (purchase  orders, goods received etc.) towards disbursements.  21. What are the dates, descriptions and  Provided in aid management systems. Financial management  values of already disbursed financial  software show full disbursement details including the type of  transactions?  disbursement.  Provided in aid management systems. The donor COA should have aid  22. What type of aid is this?  types included. Recipient governments can classify the type of aid,  typically within the fund segment.  Provided in aid management systems. Financing mechanisms are  included in the object segment in the COA. Grant management  23. What are the financing mechanisms  systems can capture the entire grants and loans lifecycle including  used?  post‐award administration. Recipient governments can code the  mechanism in Fund or Object segments. Debt information is usually  included in debt management systems.  Case Study: Government of Afghanistan Country System Effectiveness Automating financial flows from donors to recipient governments reduces corruption by dramatically reducing the fungibility of aid 12 . Integration across the budget cycle, including with banking systems tracks funds and enable audit. Transparency International is the global coalition fighting against corruption. On the Transparency International blog, author Maria Gili of the International Defence and Security Programme at Transparency International UK recently published an article titled “Corruption in Afghanistan: The Status Quo is Not an Option”. The article describes how corruption is becoming endemic and ranks as the highest concern for the people of Afghanistan. To prevent corruption from becoming the status quo, the author provides options that include a report on the total funds flowing into the country. 12 As described in FreeBalance Blog Entry 14 FreeBalance®
  • 15. As the majority of funds spent in Afghanistan come from international donors, most of it is off-budget – not on the government books. Some of these funds are provided directly to government entities outside of the budget process. Most of it is expended directly by donors or through 3rd parties, such as NGOs. This reduces the ability for donors and the government to coordinate action. This also reduces aid effectiveness, which can be as big a problem as corruption in some countries. But the real problem is that off-budget money is very hard to trace, especially cash payments. On-budget is much easier to trace, control and audit. The Afghanistan Ministry of Finance has made great strides at reducing corruption substantially in public financial management (PFM). Since 2002, the Ministry of Finance has been using the Afghanistan Financial Management Information System (AFMIS). The AFMIS is an automated PFM system based on the FreeBalance Accountability Suite that can generate fully auditable reports on all transactions. Using the AFMIS, more than 99% of the government’s budget execution is captured on a real-time basis. Highlights of the AFMIS include:  2010 saw the AFMIS Rollout team in Nuristan print its first cheque. With this achievement, the rollout of the  AFMIS across the provinces of Afghanistan was completed as Nuristan was the last province to be connected to  the AFMIS network.   All 34 Afghanistan provinces and all line Ministries at the centre now have system‐based budget controls, and can  execute system‐based payments with a very high degree of fiduciary control.   In the April 2011 World Bank Economic Premise note titled “Strengthening Public Financial Management in  Postconflict Countries,” the Government of Afghanistan was given a rating of “substantial” — the highest rating  — for PFM rebuilding and reform progress.  And, as the documentary piece pointed out, Afghanistan has made significant capacity building gains as regular training on the AFMIS has resulted in 262 government employees being added to the AFMIS skilled workforce. These are significant achievements that fail to get too much attention because of the overarching narrative that all government institutions are corrupt. Evidence suggests that public finances have improved in Afghanistan to be better than peer countries. Using the AFMIS, the Government of Afghanistan has improved governance, accountability, and transparency. 15 FreeBalance®
  • 16. Conclusions  Integration between donor and government systems will reduce transaction costs and corruption  through automation while improving efficiency and effectiveness through harmonization   Aid information including transactions (and transaction stages),  project information (including  documents) can be integrated because charts of accounts provide the linking metadata   Differences among charts of accounts can be facilitated through the use of side tables or side concepts   Members of the aid ecosystem need to adopt program budgeting to enable integration – this cost will  enable timely aid reporting including monthly and quarterly   Manual methods of integration compromises data quality and timeliness resulting is less coordination  and less effective aid   Integration can be accomplished with aid management, budget preparation and budget execution  systems   Tracking disbursements from donors and payment by recipient governments does not show progress so  aid transparency and effectiveness can be improved by following the commitment cycle  16 FreeBalance®
  • 17. About FreeBalance FreeBalance is a For Profit Social Enterprise (FOPSE) software company that helps governments around the world to leverage robust Government Resource Planning (GRP) technology to accelerate country growth. Proven FreeBalance GRP products and focused methodology supports financial reform and modernization to improve governance, transparency Contact FreeBalance and accountability. Good governance is required to T: +1 613 236-5150 (outside North America) improve development results. FreeBalance ensures info@freebalance.com high success rates for governments under stress to www.freebalance.com those in the G8 and enables governments to improve Canada performance and comply with government goals. FreeBalance (Headquarters) Unlike other Commercial Off-the-Shelf (COTS) 1101 Prince of Wales Drive vendors, FreeBalance is socially responsible as core, Suite 210, Ottawa, Ontario customer-centric and focused 100% on government. Canada K2C 3W7 T: (613) 236-5150 The FreeBalance Accountability Suite is a Toll Free: 1-877-887-3733 (North America only) comprehensive fully web-based Government Resource F: (613) 236-7785 Planning software suite that supports the entire budget Guatemala cycle and strengthens governance by improving budget FreeBalance transparency, fiscal control and predictability. The EuroPlaza World Business Center Tower 1 – Suite 903 ‘A’ proven Suite integrates transactions with content and 5 Avenue 5-55 Zone 14 collaboration through innovative Government 2.0 Guatemala City, Guatemala technology and links budget controls with objectives to enable governments to improve performance, Kosovo FreeBalance transparency and comply with government goals. Bedri Pejani, 7A Unlike other Commercial Off-the-Shelf (COTS) 10000 Pristina, Kosovo software, the FreeBalance Accountability Suite is proven in government implementations around the Portugal FreeBalance word, programmed for government and progressively Edificio Cyprum, Avenida 25 de Abril activated to adapt to current and changing government No. 15-B, 2D context. Linda-a-Velha, Portugal FreeBalance i3+qM is an integrated product Uganda development, implementation and sustainability FreeBalance Inc. Plot No. 23, Soliz House services methodology designed for Government Lumumba Avenue, Kampala, Uganda Resource Planning to ensure long term implementation success. United States FreeBalance 1001 Connecticut Avenue, Suite 720 Washington, DC. 20036 T: 1-877-887-3733 (North America Toll Free) 17 FreeBalance®
  • 18. www.freebalance.com 18 FreeBalance®