Does the Cultural Context Really Shape Welfare? A Comparative Analysis - paper by John Hudson, Nam K. Jo and Antonia Keung presented to the UK Social Policy Association Annual Conference 2013, Sheffield, July 9th
Does the Cultural Context Really Shape Welfare? A Comparative Analysis
Presented to UK Social Policy Association Annual Conference 2013, Sheffield, July 9th
John Hudson*, Nam K. Jo* and Antonia Keung***
Abstract
Despite increasing attention recently paid to the role of culture within comparative welfare studies, empirical explorations of the impact of culture on social policy remain rare. One recent exception is Jo’s (2011) analysis of on an in-between level conception of culture based on the exploration of stable societal values using quantitative cross-national surveys of social values in high-income nations. In this paper we update and expand this framework by adding data from the most recent releases of the European Values Study and World Values Survey and by exploring a wider range of policy areas. In so doing, we address the underlining theoretical question of whether the cultural context really shapes welfare policies and conclude that there is strong evidence to support the ‘culture matters’ thesis.
Acknowledgements
This research is supported by ESRC award ES/J00460X/1
Author Contact Details
* Department of Social Policy and Social Work, University of York, UK. John Hudson: john.hudson@york.ac.uk.
** Department of Social Welfare, SungKongHoe University, South Korea. Nam K. Jo: namk.jo@skhu.ac.kr
*** Department of Social Policy and Social Work, University of York, UK. Antonia Keung: antonia.keung@york.ac.uk.
Similaire à Does the Cultural Context Really Shape Welfare? A Comparative Analysis - paper by John Hudson, Nam K. Jo and Antonia Keung presented to the UK Social Policy Association Annual Conference 2013, Sheffield, July 9th
Similaire à Does the Cultural Context Really Shape Welfare? A Comparative Analysis - paper by John Hudson, Nam K. Jo and Antonia Keung presented to the UK Social Policy Association Annual Conference 2013, Sheffield, July 9th (20)
Does the Cultural Context Really Shape Welfare? A Comparative Analysis - paper by John Hudson, Nam K. Jo and Antonia Keung presented to the UK Social Policy Association Annual Conference 2013, Sheffield, July 9th
1. Department of Social Policy and Social Work
Does the Cultural Context Really Shape Welfare?
A Comparative Analysis
John Hudson University of York, UK
Nam K. Jo SungKongHoe University, South Korea
Antonia Keung University of York, UK
Award ES/J00460X/1
spsw.york
@spsw
2. Department of Social Policy and Social Work
Background
‘Culture matters’ thesis
‘Macro’ perspective
‘Micro’ perspective
Broad conception, dominant beliefs, often post hoc explanations
Public opinion, specific issues, unstable
Advances in data, concepts and method
spsw.york
@spsw
3. Department of Social Policy and Social Work
In-Between Analysis
Jo (2011) culture as stable societal values
More concrete than macro
More enduring than micro
Cultural context of social policy making
Interplay of politics, economics, institutions and culture at meso-level
Not a decisive influence, but a significant one
spsw.york
@spsw
4. Department of Social Policy and Social Work
Analytic Strategy
Extract examples of societal values:
Data from successive waves EVS/WVS data 1981-2009
173 societal cases • 59 countries x max 4 time points • 243,975 responses
Factor analysis of pooled data • manual inspection and reanalysis
End goal: identify stable and distinct examples of societal values
Built on work of Hofstede, Jo, Schwartz, van de Vijver et al
spsw.york
@spsw
5. Department of Social Policy and Social Work
Analytic Strategy
Societal values used in OLS & MLM regression models
Models include OECD states only due to data limitations
Dependent Variables (Policy Decisions):
Following Jo: public opinion data and spending data on contentious issues
‘Old social risks’: perceptions of poverty • unemployment spending
Expand to ‘new social risks’: family policy spending • maternity leave policy
Exploit new data sources (OECD Family Policy Structures Database)
spsw.york
@spsw
6. Department of Social Policy and Social Work
Analytic Strategy
Additional Independent Variables (Policy Contexts):
Economic context (GDP per capita, growth, unemployment)
Political context (cabinet composition)
Institutional context (welfare regime)
Five year averages (except values)
Stage I of analysis: fs/QCA to follow
spsw.york
@spsw
7. Department of Social Policy and Social Work
Societal Values
Societal Value
Example Survey Item
Relgiosity
God is important in my life
Conservative Social Norms
Is divorce permissible?
Permissive Values on Adherence to Laws
Justifiable to cheat on taxes?
Optimistic Values
Satisfied with your life?
Traditional Family Values
Is marriage an out-dated institution?
Interpersonal tolerance
Would you not like heavy drinkers as your neigbours?
Political Activeness
Do you participate in lawful demonstrations?
Political Orientedness
Do you regularly discuss politics with friends?
spsw.york
@spsw
8. Department of Social Policy and Social Work
Public Opinion: individuals and poverty
Culture significantly improves models
Religiosity +
Political activeness -
Condition, but not status of economy
Political impact puzzling?
Regimes play clear role
spsw.york
@spsw
9. Department of Social Policy and Social Work
Unemployment Spending: Share SOCX
Culture significantly improves models
Inter-personal tolerance +
Political activeness -
Political orientedness +
Condition and status of economy matter
Regimes play muted role
Political context not significant
spsw.york
@spsw
10. Department of Social Policy and Social Work
Unemployment Spending: Share GDP
Remarkably consistent
Culture significantly improves models
But significant societal values alter
Inter-personal tolerance still +
Political activeness and political orientedness shift
Permissive values on adherence to laws
spsw.york
@spsw
11. Department of Social Policy and Social Work
Family Spending: Share GDP
Culture improves models but not significantly
Religiosity –
Regimes play muted role
Political context not significant
Status of economy matters
Less strong support for culture matters thesis…
spsw.york
@spsw
12. Department of Social Policy and Social Work
Family Spending: Share SOCX
Culture improves models but not significantly for MLM
Again religiosity -
Conservative social norms +
Political and institutional contexts not significant
Status and condition (unemp) of economy matters
Less strong support for culture matters thesis…
spsw.york
@spsw
13. Department of Social Policy and Social Work
Problems with Spending…
Societal values impact on politically charged normative debates
Unemployment spending captures this well
Family policy aggregates wide range of interventions e.g.:
Income supplements for lone parent and large families
Child care
In-work income top-ups for families with children
Universal child benefits
Maternity leave
Different normative debates for each
Move away from focus on expenditure
spsw.york
@spsw
14. Department of Social Policy and Social Work
Family Policy Structures
Considered maternity leave: replacement rate, length and FTE
Replacement rate:
Culture improves model but not significantly so
Modest support for culture matters thesis?
Length:
Culture improves model significantly
Largely the same for FTEs
Strong support for culture matters thesis…
spsw.york
@spsw
15. Department of Social Policy and Social Work
Conclusion
Shown value of in-between concept of culture
Facilitates empirical investigation of culture matters thesis
Tentative findings – refinements and fs/QCA to follow
Limits to approach here:
Data driven • Examples of societal values • Weaknesses in models
Added support to culture matters thesis
Interesting tentative findings worthy of further exploration
spsw.york
@spsw