SlideShare une entreprise Scribd logo
1  sur  13
Télécharger pour lire hors ligne
Dissertation Thoughts

           (Like, as of April 21, 2010.)
(Really quickly tossed out there. Roll with me.)
                 (Kyle Stedman)
              (U of South Florida)
persuade

                            evoke emotion

                            explain




Writers compose.

They purposefully try to
achieve specific effects.
persuade

                            evoke emotion

                            explain




Musicians compose too.

That’s what they call it.
Music “composition.”
quotations, paraphrases,
summaries



the language and
ideas they’ve been
influenced by


Writers use sources.

Both in purposeful and
unavoidable ways.
samples

variations
and covers

  the composers and
  motifs they’ve been
  influenced by

Musicians use sources, too.

Both in purposeful and
unavoidable ways.
Yes, this could also
                                         be said about
                                         composing visuals,
No, composing words and                  etc. But I’m talking
composing music aren’t the same.         music right now. I’ve
                                         gotta focus
                                         somewhere.
But they’re intriguingly similar, too.
In college, students take classes to
help them be effective composers.

“Rhetorical” aims are often
separated from “aesthetic” aims.
So, what if I talked to students in
both disciplines about their
composing practices?

What stories would they tell about
the effects they were going for, and
what kinds of sources they used?
And what would I learn if I observed
their composing and research
habits?
That knowledge could be used to
make better composition teachers.
1. What effects do students try to achieve in
    their alphabetic and musical
    compositions?

 2. In what ways do students search for and
    integrate sources into their work?
Did you catch that? I have two big
questions.

I bet students will surprise me with
the cool things they know and with
the surprising things they don’t
know.

And both can inform better
pedagogy.
1. What effects do students try to achieve in
    their alphabetic and musical
    compositions?

 2. In what ways do students search for and
    integrate sources into their work?
                                      • information literacy
                                      • multimodal composition
                                      • music composition
I’d rely on research from different   • multiliteracy studies
fields and places to frame my         • new media poetics
interview and observation data.       • computers and writing
                                      • intellectual property
                                        studies
Mostly from rhetoric and
                                      • interviews with
composition, but also lots from         professional and amateur
elsewhere.                              composers
The End. (For now.)

Comment! Please! Either to kstedman
       [AT] mail [DOT] edu
                or at
    http://tinyurl.com/disskyle
             (That’s a pun.)

Contenu connexe

Tendances

Tendances (17)

Art critique
Art critiqueArt critique
Art critique
 
Discussing Artwork
Discussing ArtworkDiscussing Artwork
Discussing Artwork
 
Art Criticism 2 Ppt
Art Criticism 2 PptArt Criticism 2 Ppt
Art Criticism 2 Ppt
 
Task 2a what is an auteur
Task 2a what is an auteurTask 2a what is an auteur
Task 2a what is an auteur
 
Lecture 1
Lecture 1Lecture 1
Lecture 1
 
Prompts for Critique and Understanding
Prompts for Critique and UnderstandingPrompts for Critique and Understanding
Prompts for Critique and Understanding
 
Art Criticism Instructions
Art Criticism InstructionsArt Criticism Instructions
Art Criticism Instructions
 
04 Multiple Intelligences (Final Presentation)
04  Multiple Intelligences (Final Presentation)04  Multiple Intelligences (Final Presentation)
04 Multiple Intelligences (Final Presentation)
 
Criticism cheatsheet
Criticism cheatsheetCriticism cheatsheet
Criticism cheatsheet
 
Literature
LiteratureLiterature
Literature
 
Four components of art (3)
Four components of art (3)Four components of art (3)
Four components of art (3)
 
Method acting - BS VII
Method acting - BS VIIMethod acting - BS VII
Method acting - BS VII
 
Introduction to Writing About Art - Critical
Introduction to Writing About Art - CriticalIntroduction to Writing About Art - Critical
Introduction to Writing About Art - Critical
 
Bases For Art
Bases For ArtBases For Art
Bases For Art
 
Art Criticism
Art CriticismArt Criticism
Art Criticism
 
Formal analysis tutorial 2 d
Formal analysis tutorial 2 dFormal analysis tutorial 2 d
Formal analysis tutorial 2 d
 
Area of study guide to narrative writing
Area of study guide to narrative writingArea of study guide to narrative writing
Area of study guide to narrative writing
 

En vedette

En vedette (6)

資訊安全入門
資訊安全入門資訊安全入門
資訊安全入門
 
Plato E-business presentatie
Plato E-business presentatiePlato E-business presentatie
Plato E-business presentatie
 
Colostomy1
Colostomy1Colostomy1
Colostomy1
 
Wat is Dynamic Pricing en hoe maakt u hier slim gebruik van?
Wat is Dynamic Pricing en hoe maakt u hier slim gebruik van?Wat is Dynamic Pricing en hoe maakt u hier slim gebruik van?
Wat is Dynamic Pricing en hoe maakt u hier slim gebruik van?
 
Colostomy care
Colostomy careColostomy care
Colostomy care
 
Colostomy
ColostomyColostomy
Colostomy
 

Similaire à Dissertation thoughts

The Fine Art of Common Core
The Fine Art of Common CoreThe Fine Art of Common Core
The Fine Art of Common Coreandrewwales
 
The Fine Art of Common Core (with comments)
The Fine Art of Common Core (with comments)The Fine Art of Common Core (with comments)
The Fine Art of Common Core (with comments)andrewwales
 
Copia di towards an ecology 2
Copia di towards an ecology 2Copia di towards an ecology 2
Copia di towards an ecology 2susan george
 
Copia di towards an ecology 2
Copia di towards an ecology 2Copia di towards an ecology 2
Copia di towards an ecology 2susan george
 
A musical ethnography is a piece of writing that explores some asp.docx
A musical ethnography is a piece of writing that explores some asp.docxA musical ethnography is a piece of writing that explores some asp.docx
A musical ethnography is a piece of writing that explores some asp.docxmehek4
 
Admit Me: Why College Application Essays and Artistic Statements Matter
Admit Me: Why College Application Essays and Artistic Statements MatterAdmit Me: Why College Application Essays and Artistic Statements Matter
Admit Me: Why College Application Essays and Artistic Statements MatterRebecca Joseph
 
Voice & style in Writing by Darsie Bowden
Voice & style in Writing by Darsie BowdenVoice & style in Writing by Darsie Bowden
Voice & style in Writing by Darsie BowdenDoha Zallag
 
Comm skills & multiple intelligences approach to communicative teaching
Comm skills & multiple intelligences approach to communicative teachingComm skills & multiple intelligences approach to communicative teaching
Comm skills & multiple intelligences approach to communicative teachingShelia Ann Peace
 
Film music
Film musicFilm music
Film musiccraigh99
 
Purpose, Audience, Form and Tone
Purpose, Audience, Form and TonePurpose, Audience, Form and Tone
Purpose, Audience, Form and ToneSuzie Allen
 
How We Express Ourselves
How We Express OurselvesHow We Express Ourselves
How We Express Ourselvesnistyear2
 
Transforming Healthcare: the power of participatory co-design and creative ar...
Transforming Healthcare: the power of participatory co-design and creative ar...Transforming Healthcare: the power of participatory co-design and creative ar...
Transforming Healthcare: the power of participatory co-design and creative ar...QUT
 
Characteristics of Gifted Children
Characteristics of Gifted ChildrenCharacteristics of Gifted Children
Characteristics of Gifted ChildrenDiaa Srahin
 
Investigation Workbooks (IWBs)
Investigation Workbooks (IWBs)Investigation Workbooks (IWBs)
Investigation Workbooks (IWBs)lindzbekah
 

Similaire à Dissertation thoughts (20)

The Fine Art of Common Core
The Fine Art of Common CoreThe Fine Art of Common Core
The Fine Art of Common Core
 
The Fine Art of Common Core (with comments)
The Fine Art of Common Core (with comments)The Fine Art of Common Core (with comments)
The Fine Art of Common Core (with comments)
 
Copia di towards an ecology 2
Copia di towards an ecology 2Copia di towards an ecology 2
Copia di towards an ecology 2
 
Copia di towards an ecology 2
Copia di towards an ecology 2Copia di towards an ecology 2
Copia di towards an ecology 2
 
A musical ethnography is a piece of writing that explores some asp.docx
A musical ethnography is a piece of writing that explores some asp.docxA musical ethnography is a piece of writing that explores some asp.docx
A musical ethnography is a piece of writing that explores some asp.docx
 
Admit Me: Why College Application Essays and Artistic Statements Matter
Admit Me: Why College Application Essays and Artistic Statements MatterAdmit Me: Why College Application Essays and Artistic Statements Matter
Admit Me: Why College Application Essays and Artistic Statements Matter
 
Voice & style in Writing by Darsie Bowden
Voice & style in Writing by Darsie BowdenVoice & style in Writing by Darsie Bowden
Voice & style in Writing by Darsie Bowden
 
Comm skills & multiple intelligences approach to communicative teaching
Comm skills & multiple intelligences approach to communicative teachingComm skills & multiple intelligences approach to communicative teaching
Comm skills & multiple intelligences approach to communicative teaching
 
Film music
Film musicFilm music
Film music
 
Poetrypacket
PoetrypacketPoetrypacket
Poetrypacket
 
Purpose, Audience, Form and Tone
Purpose, Audience, Form and TonePurpose, Audience, Form and Tone
Purpose, Audience, Form and Tone
 
The Language of Disney Songs: A Formalistic Analysis
The Language of Disney Songs: A Formalistic Analysis The Language of Disney Songs: A Formalistic Analysis
The Language of Disney Songs: A Formalistic Analysis
 
How We Express Ourselves
How We Express OurselvesHow We Express Ourselves
How We Express Ourselves
 
[RELO] Teaching Through Emotions
[RELO] Teaching Through Emotions[RELO] Teaching Through Emotions
[RELO] Teaching Through Emotions
 
Multiple inteligences
Multiple inteligencesMultiple inteligences
Multiple inteligences
 
Transforming Healthcare: the power of participatory co-design and creative ar...
Transforming Healthcare: the power of participatory co-design and creative ar...Transforming Healthcare: the power of participatory co-design and creative ar...
Transforming Healthcare: the power of participatory co-design and creative ar...
 
Individual factors4444
Individual factors4444Individual factors4444
Individual factors4444
 
Characteristics of Gifted Children
Characteristics of Gifted ChildrenCharacteristics of Gifted Children
Characteristics of Gifted Children
 
Investigation Workbooks (IWBs)
Investigation Workbooks (IWBs)Investigation Workbooks (IWBs)
Investigation Workbooks (IWBs)
 
Brain-Based Foreign Language Learning
Brain-Based Foreign Language LearningBrain-Based Foreign Language Learning
Brain-Based Foreign Language Learning
 

Dissertation thoughts

  • 1. Dissertation Thoughts (Like, as of April 21, 2010.) (Really quickly tossed out there. Roll with me.) (Kyle Stedman) (U of South Florida)
  • 2. persuade evoke emotion explain Writers compose. They purposefully try to achieve specific effects.
  • 3. persuade evoke emotion explain Musicians compose too. That’s what they call it. Music “composition.”
  • 4. quotations, paraphrases, summaries the language and ideas they’ve been influenced by Writers use sources. Both in purposeful and unavoidable ways.
  • 5. samples variations and covers the composers and motifs they’ve been influenced by Musicians use sources, too. Both in purposeful and unavoidable ways.
  • 6. Yes, this could also be said about composing visuals, No, composing words and etc. But I’m talking composing music aren’t the same. music right now. I’ve gotta focus somewhere. But they’re intriguingly similar, too.
  • 7. In college, students take classes to help them be effective composers. “Rhetorical” aims are often separated from “aesthetic” aims.
  • 8. So, what if I talked to students in both disciplines about their composing practices? What stories would they tell about the effects they were going for, and what kinds of sources they used?
  • 9. And what would I learn if I observed their composing and research habits?
  • 10. That knowledge could be used to make better composition teachers.
  • 11. 1. What effects do students try to achieve in their alphabetic and musical compositions? 2. In what ways do students search for and integrate sources into their work? Did you catch that? I have two big questions. I bet students will surprise me with the cool things they know and with the surprising things they don’t know. And both can inform better pedagogy.
  • 12. 1. What effects do students try to achieve in their alphabetic and musical compositions? 2. In what ways do students search for and integrate sources into their work? • information literacy • multimodal composition • music composition I’d rely on research from different • multiliteracy studies fields and places to frame my • new media poetics interview and observation data. • computers and writing • intellectual property studies Mostly from rhetoric and • interviews with composition, but also lots from professional and amateur elsewhere. composers
  • 13. The End. (For now.) Comment! Please! Either to kstedman [AT] mail [DOT] edu or at http://tinyurl.com/disskyle (That’s a pun.)