SlideShare une entreprise Scribd logo
1  sur  2
Télécharger pour lire hors ligne
Worksheet by RJ Tarr at www.activehistory.co.uk / 1
Sourcework Questions: The Causes of the Vietnam War
Source A
'The loss of any single country in South East Asia could lead to the loss of all Asia,
then India and Japan, finally endangering the security of Europe.... You have a row of
dominoes set up, you knock over the first one and what will happen to the last one is
a certainty, that it will go over very quickly.'
President Eisenhower
Source B
'The path taken by the Chinese people is the path that should be taken by the people
of the various colonial and semi-colonial countries in their fight for national
independence and people's democracy ... that is the way of Mao Tse Tung.'
A Chinese Communist leader
Source C
'After 18 May 1955, the date on which all Vietminh forces were supposedly withdrawn
from the South, the Communists continued to exercise authority in many rural areas.
They had extensively infiltrated the civil service, the police and armed forces, and
they enjoyed considerable support of the rural population.'
An American reporter in South Vietnam, (1955)
Source D
'Let every nation know, whether it wishes us well or ill, that we shall pay any price,
bear any burden, meet any hardship, support any friend, oppose any foe, to assure
the survival and success of liberty. To those new states which we welcome to the
ranks of the free we pledge our word that one form of colonial control shall not have
passed away merely to be replaced by a far worse tyranny.'
President Kennedy, (1960)
Source E
'In the final analysis, it is their war. They are the ones who have to win it or lose it ...
the people of Vietnam against the Communists.'
President Kennedy, (1963)
Questions:
1. Study Source A.
To what extent does this source explain the reasons for American involvement in
Vietnam? (4)
2. Study Sources A & B.
Does Source B prove that Eisenhower’s judgement in Source A was correct? Explain
your answer. (6)
3. Here are three reasons why the US may have got involved in Vietnam:
i. Because they wanted to protect the world from communist dictatorship
ii. Because they were paranoid about the communist threat
iii. Because they were aggressively trying to dominate the civilised world
Which one of these interpretations do you find most convincing? (10)
Worksheet by RJ Tarr at www.activehistory.co.uk / 2
Markscheme:
1. Study Source A.
To what extent does this source explain the reasons for American involvement in Vietnam?
L1 1 Summarises / Describes the source at face value.
L2 2 Explains the meaning of the source by making inferences based on background knowledge /
cross referencing. Better answers will refer to specific details in the source and elaborate on
these points.
L3 3 As L2, but also addresses “How Much” aspect by questioning the reliability of the witness.
L4 4 As above, but gives other reasons for American involvement not mentioned by the source using
background knowledge / Cross referencing.
2. Study Sources A & B.
Does Source B prove that Eisenhower’s judgement in Source A was correct? Explain your answer.
L1 1 Answer argues “Yes” or “No”; but does not back up this argument with any details from the
sources
L2 2-3 Answer argues “Yes” or “No”; argument supported by details from the sources and/or from
background knowledge.
L3 4-5 Answer argues “Yes” and “No”; argument supported by details from the source and/or from
background knowledge.
L4 5-6 Answer argues “Yes” and “No”; recognises that in some ways the source helps to prove the case,
but in other ways it doesn’t (e.g. no single source tells us everything, or is totally reliable)
3. Here are three reasons why the US may have got involved in Vietnam:
i. Because they wanted to protect the world from communist dictatorship
ii. Because they were paranoid about the communist threat
iii. Because they were aggressively trying to dominate the civilised world
Which one of these interpretations do you find most convincing?
L1 1-2 Unsupported assertions
L2 3 One or two factors considered, uses background knowledge only.
L3 4 One or two factors considered, uses sources AND background knowledge.
L4 5 All factors considered, uses sources OR background.
L5 6 All factors considered, uses sources AND background.
L6 7-8 Reserved for answers which reaches a balanced conclusion through factors being compared /
categorised / linked effectively throughout.
Such answers do not look at one factor after another in no particular order.
They may recognise that in the final analysis some parts of the statement are true, but not
others; in the short term it was true, but not in the long term; for a certain country it was true, but
not for others (etc)

Contenu connexe

Tendances

America Enters World War Ii
America Enters World War IiAmerica Enters World War Ii
America Enters World War Ii
jhyer
 
Unit 7 PowerPoint The Road to World War II
Unit 7 PowerPoint The Road to World War IIUnit 7 PowerPoint The Road to World War II
Unit 7 PowerPoint The Road to World War II
Crosswinds High School
 
Unit 8 Powerpoint (The Cold War Begins)
Unit 8 Powerpoint  (The Cold War Begins)Unit 8 Powerpoint  (The Cold War Begins)
Unit 8 Powerpoint (The Cold War Begins)
Crosswinds High School
 
League Of Nations Summary 1930\ S
League Of Nations Summary 1930\ SLeague Of Nations Summary 1930\ S
League Of Nations Summary 1930\ S
Del Nicholls
 
The Origins Of WW II Slideshare
The Origins Of WW II   SlideshareThe Origins Of WW II   Slideshare
The Origins Of WW II Slideshare
mtaft
 

Tendances (20)

Trench Warfare PPT
Trench Warfare PPTTrench Warfare PPT
Trench Warfare PPT
 
America Enters World War Ii
America Enters World War IiAmerica Enters World War Ii
America Enters World War Ii
 
The Rise of Hitler - Circumstances in Germany
The Rise of Hitler - Circumstances in GermanyThe Rise of Hitler - Circumstances in Germany
The Rise of Hitler - Circumstances in Germany
 
The Cold War
The Cold WarThe Cold War
The Cold War
 
CAMBRIDGE IGCSE HISTORY: WAS THE TREATY JUSTIFIED?
CAMBRIDGE IGCSE HISTORY: WAS THE TREATY JUSTIFIED?CAMBRIDGE IGCSE HISTORY: WAS THE TREATY JUSTIFIED?
CAMBRIDGE IGCSE HISTORY: WAS THE TREATY JUSTIFIED?
 
HISTORY IGCSE REVISION - MODEL PAPER 4 - WEIMAR REPUBLIC
HISTORY IGCSE REVISION - MODEL PAPER 4 - WEIMAR REPUBLICHISTORY IGCSE REVISION - MODEL PAPER 4 - WEIMAR REPUBLIC
HISTORY IGCSE REVISION - MODEL PAPER 4 - WEIMAR REPUBLIC
 
North Africa Campaign
North  Africa  CampaignNorth  Africa  Campaign
North Africa Campaign
 
CAMBRIDGE IGCSE HISTORY REVISION 9 - WHO WAS TO BLAME FOR THE COLD WAR - DIFF...
CAMBRIDGE IGCSE HISTORY REVISION 9 - WHO WAS TO BLAME FOR THE COLD WAR - DIFF...CAMBRIDGE IGCSE HISTORY REVISION 9 - WHO WAS TO BLAME FOR THE COLD WAR - DIFF...
CAMBRIDGE IGCSE HISTORY REVISION 9 - WHO WAS TO BLAME FOR THE COLD WAR - DIFF...
 
Unit 7 PowerPoint The Road to World War II
Unit 7 PowerPoint The Road to World War IIUnit 7 PowerPoint The Road to World War II
Unit 7 PowerPoint The Road to World War II
 
The united states enters world war 1
The united states enters world war 1The united states enters world war 1
The united states enters world war 1
 
Unit 8 Powerpoint (The Cold War Begins)
Unit 8 Powerpoint  (The Cold War Begins)Unit 8 Powerpoint  (The Cold War Begins)
Unit 8 Powerpoint (The Cold War Begins)
 
League Of Nations Summary 1930\ S
League Of Nations Summary 1930\ SLeague Of Nations Summary 1930\ S
League Of Nations Summary 1930\ S
 
The Origins Of WW II Slideshare
The Origins Of WW II   SlideshareThe Origins Of WW II   Slideshare
The Origins Of WW II Slideshare
 
CAMBRIDGE IGCSE HISTORY REVISION 4 - COLD WAR
CAMBRIDGE IGCSE HISTORY REVISION 4 - COLD WARCAMBRIDGE IGCSE HISTORY REVISION 4 - COLD WAR
CAMBRIDGE IGCSE HISTORY REVISION 4 - COLD WAR
 
Pacific Theater (WWII)
Pacific Theater (WWII)Pacific Theater (WWII)
Pacific Theater (WWII)
 
REVISION IGCSE CAMBRIDGE HISTORY: MUNICH AGREEMENT
REVISION IGCSE CAMBRIDGE HISTORY: MUNICH AGREEMENTREVISION IGCSE CAMBRIDGE HISTORY: MUNICH AGREEMENT
REVISION IGCSE CAMBRIDGE HISTORY: MUNICH AGREEMENT
 
20th Century History: Depth Study: The USA 1919-41
20th Century History: Depth Study: The USA 1919-4120th Century History: Depth Study: The USA 1919-41
20th Century History: Depth Study: The USA 1919-41
 
HISTORY YEAR 11 CAMBRIDGE IGCSE - RUSSIAN REVOLUTION
HISTORY YEAR 11 CAMBRIDGE IGCSE - RUSSIAN REVOLUTIONHISTORY YEAR 11 CAMBRIDGE IGCSE - RUSSIAN REVOLUTION
HISTORY YEAR 11 CAMBRIDGE IGCSE - RUSSIAN REVOLUTION
 
Vietnam war for Cambridge IGCSE History
Vietnam war for Cambridge IGCSE HistoryVietnam war for Cambridge IGCSE History
Vietnam war for Cambridge IGCSE History
 
World War 1
World War 1World War 1
World War 1
 

Similaire à Vietnam war causes source analysis

Ashford 5 - Week 4 - Instructor GuidanceWeek 4 - Instructor G.docx
Ashford 5 - Week 4 - Instructor GuidanceWeek 4 - Instructor G.docxAshford 5 - Week 4 - Instructor GuidanceWeek 4 - Instructor G.docx
Ashford 5 - Week 4 - Instructor GuidanceWeek 4 - Instructor G.docx
davezstarr61655
 
Matt Ayre Vietnam Dissertation
Matt Ayre Vietnam DissertationMatt Ayre Vietnam Dissertation
Matt Ayre Vietnam Dissertation
Matthew Ayre
 
Vietnam War SAC by Eric Marszalek
Vietnam War SAC by Eric MarszalekVietnam War SAC by Eric Marszalek
Vietnam War SAC by Eric Marszalek
jelenjos
 
Cold war learning stations
Cold war learning stationsCold war learning stations
Cold war learning stations
AlohaMaddy
 

Similaire à Vietnam war causes source analysis (12)

CIA in Vietnam Paper
CIA in Vietnam PaperCIA in Vietnam Paper
CIA in Vietnam Paper
 
Ike, Sputnik and the Civil Rights; the 1950's
Ike, Sputnik and the Civil Rights; the 1950'sIke, Sputnik and the Civil Rights; the 1950's
Ike, Sputnik and the Civil Rights; the 1950's
 
Ashford 5 - Week 4 - Instructor GuidanceWeek 4 - Instructor G.docx
Ashford 5 - Week 4 - Instructor GuidanceWeek 4 - Instructor G.docxAshford 5 - Week 4 - Instructor GuidanceWeek 4 - Instructor G.docx
Ashford 5 - Week 4 - Instructor GuidanceWeek 4 - Instructor G.docx
 
Matt Ayre Vietnam Dissertation
Matt Ayre Vietnam DissertationMatt Ayre Vietnam Dissertation
Matt Ayre Vietnam Dissertation
 
We Don’t Have to Fight Anymore
We Don’t Have to Fight AnymoreWe Don’t Have to Fight Anymore
We Don’t Have to Fight Anymore
 
Vietnam War SAC by Eric Marszalek
Vietnam War SAC by Eric MarszalekVietnam War SAC by Eric Marszalek
Vietnam War SAC by Eric Marszalek
 
Unit plan presentation
Unit plan presentationUnit plan presentation
Unit plan presentation
 
Vietnam power point
Vietnam power pointVietnam power point
Vietnam power point
 
Vietnam Power Point
Vietnam Power PointVietnam Power Point
Vietnam Power Point
 
Korean War Unit Plan Presentation
Korean War Unit Plan PresentationKorean War Unit Plan Presentation
Korean War Unit Plan Presentation
 
Cold war learning stations
Cold war learning stationsCold war learning stations
Cold war learning stations
 
Cold War Learning Stations
Cold War Learning StationsCold War Learning Stations
Cold War Learning Stations
 

Plus de lennyambrosini

Plus de lennyambrosini (20)

The Cold War Episode 1 Bernusi
The Cold War Episode 1 BernusiThe Cold War Episode 1 Bernusi
The Cold War Episode 1 Bernusi
 
The Cold War-Episode 1 - Vorbeck
The Cold War-Episode 1 - Vorbeck The Cold War-Episode 1 - Vorbeck
The Cold War-Episode 1 - Vorbeck
 
The Cold War - Episode 1 - Segura
The Cold War - Episode 1 - SeguraThe Cold War - Episode 1 - Segura
The Cold War - Episode 1 - Segura
 
Cold War Notetaking - Larralde
Cold War Notetaking - LarraldeCold War Notetaking - Larralde
Cold War Notetaking - Larralde
 
Esquema de contenidos_nodales DIC 2019 formación ética y ciudadana
Esquema de contenidos_nodales DIC 2019  formación ética y ciudadanaEsquema de contenidos_nodales DIC 2019  formación ética y ciudadana
Esquema de contenidos_nodales DIC 2019 formación ética y ciudadana
 
Plan de trabajo DIC 2019 formación ética y ciudadana - 4to Año
Plan de trabajo DIC 2019 formación ética y ciudadana - 4to AñoPlan de trabajo DIC 2019 formación ética y ciudadana - 4to Año
Plan de trabajo DIC 2019 formación ética y ciudadana - 4to Año
 
Plan de Trabajo S3 History Feb 2019
Plan de Trabajo S3 History Feb 2019Plan de Trabajo S3 History Feb 2019
Plan de Trabajo S3 History Feb 2019
 
Plan de Trabajo Feb 2019 Matemática 5TO
Plan de Trabajo Feb 2019 Matemática 5TOPlan de Trabajo Feb 2019 Matemática 5TO
Plan de Trabajo Feb 2019 Matemática 5TO
 
History Senior 1- Esquema de Contenidos Nodales - Dic 2018
History Senior 1- Esquema de Contenidos Nodales - Dic 2018History Senior 1- Esquema de Contenidos Nodales - Dic 2018
History Senior 1- Esquema de Contenidos Nodales - Dic 2018
 
History Senior 3 - Esquema de Contenidos Nodales - Dic 2018
History Senior 3 - Esquema de Contenidos Nodales - Dic 2018History Senior 3 - Esquema de Contenidos Nodales - Dic 2018
History Senior 3 - Esquema de Contenidos Nodales - Dic 2018
 
Física Plan de Trabajo - Dic 2018
Física Plan de Trabajo - Dic 2018 Física Plan de Trabajo - Dic 2018
Física Plan de Trabajo - Dic 2018
 
Plan deTrabajo S1 History Dic 2018
Plan deTrabajo S1 History Dic 2018Plan deTrabajo S1 History Dic 2018
Plan deTrabajo S1 History Dic 2018
 
History S5 Plan de trabajo - Dic 2018
History S5 Plan de trabajo - Dic 2018History S5 Plan de trabajo - Dic 2018
History S5 Plan de trabajo - Dic 2018
 
Plan de Trabajo S3 History Dic 2018
Plan de Trabajo S3 History Dic 2018Plan de Trabajo S3 History Dic 2018
Plan de Trabajo S3 History Dic 2018
 
History IGCSE Tips
History IGCSE TipsHistory IGCSE Tips
History IGCSE Tips
 
May June PAPER 4 History IGCSE 2018
May June PAPER 4 History IGCSE 2018May June PAPER 4 History IGCSE 2018
May June PAPER 4 History IGCSE 2018
 
Descriptors - PAPER 4 History IGCSE
Descriptors - PAPER 4 History IGCSEDescriptors - PAPER 4 History IGCSE
Descriptors - PAPER 4 History IGCSE
 
Checklist de Blog 2019
Checklist de Blog 2019Checklist de Blog 2019
Checklist de Blog 2019
 
The League in the 1920s.
The League in the 1920s.  The League in the 1920s.
The League in the 1920s.
 
The Korean War Plan
The Korean War PlanThe Korean War Plan
The Korean War Plan
 

Vietnam war causes source analysis

  • 1. Worksheet by RJ Tarr at www.activehistory.co.uk / 1 Sourcework Questions: The Causes of the Vietnam War Source A 'The loss of any single country in South East Asia could lead to the loss of all Asia, then India and Japan, finally endangering the security of Europe.... You have a row of dominoes set up, you knock over the first one and what will happen to the last one is a certainty, that it will go over very quickly.' President Eisenhower Source B 'The path taken by the Chinese people is the path that should be taken by the people of the various colonial and semi-colonial countries in their fight for national independence and people's democracy ... that is the way of Mao Tse Tung.' A Chinese Communist leader Source C 'After 18 May 1955, the date on which all Vietminh forces were supposedly withdrawn from the South, the Communists continued to exercise authority in many rural areas. They had extensively infiltrated the civil service, the police and armed forces, and they enjoyed considerable support of the rural population.' An American reporter in South Vietnam, (1955) Source D 'Let every nation know, whether it wishes us well or ill, that we shall pay any price, bear any burden, meet any hardship, support any friend, oppose any foe, to assure the survival and success of liberty. To those new states which we welcome to the ranks of the free we pledge our word that one form of colonial control shall not have passed away merely to be replaced by a far worse tyranny.' President Kennedy, (1960) Source E 'In the final analysis, it is their war. They are the ones who have to win it or lose it ... the people of Vietnam against the Communists.' President Kennedy, (1963) Questions: 1. Study Source A. To what extent does this source explain the reasons for American involvement in Vietnam? (4) 2. Study Sources A & B. Does Source B prove that Eisenhower’s judgement in Source A was correct? Explain your answer. (6) 3. Here are three reasons why the US may have got involved in Vietnam: i. Because they wanted to protect the world from communist dictatorship ii. Because they were paranoid about the communist threat iii. Because they were aggressively trying to dominate the civilised world Which one of these interpretations do you find most convincing? (10)
  • 2. Worksheet by RJ Tarr at www.activehistory.co.uk / 2 Markscheme: 1. Study Source A. To what extent does this source explain the reasons for American involvement in Vietnam? L1 1 Summarises / Describes the source at face value. L2 2 Explains the meaning of the source by making inferences based on background knowledge / cross referencing. Better answers will refer to specific details in the source and elaborate on these points. L3 3 As L2, but also addresses “How Much” aspect by questioning the reliability of the witness. L4 4 As above, but gives other reasons for American involvement not mentioned by the source using background knowledge / Cross referencing. 2. Study Sources A & B. Does Source B prove that Eisenhower’s judgement in Source A was correct? Explain your answer. L1 1 Answer argues “Yes” or “No”; but does not back up this argument with any details from the sources L2 2-3 Answer argues “Yes” or “No”; argument supported by details from the sources and/or from background knowledge. L3 4-5 Answer argues “Yes” and “No”; argument supported by details from the source and/or from background knowledge. L4 5-6 Answer argues “Yes” and “No”; recognises that in some ways the source helps to prove the case, but in other ways it doesn’t (e.g. no single source tells us everything, or is totally reliable) 3. Here are three reasons why the US may have got involved in Vietnam: i. Because they wanted to protect the world from communist dictatorship ii. Because they were paranoid about the communist threat iii. Because they were aggressively trying to dominate the civilised world Which one of these interpretations do you find most convincing? L1 1-2 Unsupported assertions L2 3 One or two factors considered, uses background knowledge only. L3 4 One or two factors considered, uses sources AND background knowledge. L4 5 All factors considered, uses sources OR background. L5 6 All factors considered, uses sources AND background. L6 7-8 Reserved for answers which reaches a balanced conclusion through factors being compared / categorised / linked effectively throughout. Such answers do not look at one factor after another in no particular order. They may recognise that in the final analysis some parts of the statement are true, but not others; in the short term it was true, but not in the long term; for a certain country it was true, but not for others (etc)