SlideShare une entreprise Scribd logo
1  sur  12
Télécharger pour lire hors ligne
wHite PaPer


  CARING FOR THE UNINSURED
  AMID FINANCIAL PRESSURES
  USING TARGETED MARKETING METHODS TO INFLUENCE
  PATIENT BEHAVIOR




JEFFREY S. BARKOFF
DENNIS DUNN, PHD
KENT FRANCIS
LINDA MACCRACKEN, MBA
GARY PICKENS, PHD
LEAH H. RAY, MBA
MICHAEL SHIPLEY
MEREDITH A. WELLS, MS

APRIL 2010
TABLE OF CONTENTS
INTRODUCTION .......................................................................................................................................... 1

THE UNINSURED POPULATION: NOT HOMOGENOUS ..................................................................... 1

UNINSURED HEALTH SERVICES UTILIZATION .................................................................................. 2

OUTPATIENT SERVICE USE DIFFERS BY PAYER GROUP ................................................................. 3

INPATIENT SERVICE USE DIFFERS BY UNINSURED PATIENTS ..................................................... 3

USING MARKETING TO INFLUENCE BEHAVIOR OF THE UNINSURED ........................................ 4

STRIVING FOR BALANCE: TACTICS FOR CONSIDERATION ............................................................ 6

MARKETING TACTICS ............................................................................................................................... 6

FRONTLINE TACTICS .................................................................................................................................7

CONCLUSION...............................................................................................................................................7

APPENDIX ................................................................................................................................................... 8

REFERENCES .............................................................................................................................................. 9
INTRODUCTION
Across all political affiliations, industries, and
socioeconomic backgrounds, healthcare reform ranks
among today’s most discussed topics. But in the midst of
the debate, one fact remains clear: providing care to the
uninsured segment of the population is a monumental task
of paramount importance.
The total uninsured population now includes one out of every six Americans. Estimates of the total number
of uninsured individuals ranges from roughly 46.31 to 49.72 million. The uninsured population now exceeds
the total number of Medicare beneficiaries by roughly 22 percent. Furthermore, forecasts indicate that the
number of uninsured will reach 58 million Americans by 2014.3

The cost of continuing to provide care as we do today will translate into billions of dollars in unpaid medical
bills for patients with little or no coverage. But the more hospitals and healthcare providers know about
their patients – notably the uninsured – the better equipped they will be to meet their missions, maintain a
robust community benefit, and contain costs as components of financial viability. Regardless of the future of
healthcare reform, hospitals and healthcare providers are well served to assess utilization and care patterns,
examine their patient rosters, and develop strategies to lower expenses without sacrificing quality of care.

In supporting this need, Thomson Reuters experts explored the topic of caring for the uninsured by
examining national hospital data and consumer healthcare information to articulate the unique
characteristics and behaviors of this growing population. This paper identifies distinct segments with
different utilization trends/behaviors, as well as channels and receptiveness to marketing. In addition,
Thomson Reuters developed recommendations to hospital leadership on how to provide the right care at the
right site of service to help better manage the rising costs of serving the uninsured.

The research presented here draws upon multiple sources, including the Thomson Reuters Outpatient
Procedure Estimates and consumer research from the annual Thomson Reuters PULSE™ Healthcare Survey.

THE UNINSURED POPULATION: NOT HOMOGENOUS

Uninsured – Not Necessarily Low Income or Unemployed
For many Americans, the “uninsured” – when viewed as a single group – often means those without
employment or those who cannot afford individual healthcare coverage. The uninsured are not a
homogenous group and include both unemployed and employed individuals, at various income levels, as
well as their children and other dependents. Thomson Reuters experts have found significant differences
among the various subgroups of the uninsured, including site of service preferences and health conditions.

Thomson Reuters defined four mutually exclusive segments for the uninsured, based on employment
status and income level. Key differences in behaviors of the various segments are described as follows.

•	   Uninsured, employed with incomes under 300 percent of the Federal Poverty Level
•	   Uninsured, employed with incomes above 300 percent of the Federal Poverty Level
•	   Uninsured, unemployed with incomes under 300 percent of the Federal Poverty Level
•	   Uninsured, unemployed with incomes above 300 percent of the Federal Poverty Level


                                                                                                      Caring for the Uninsured Amid Financial Pressures 1
Uninsured – Low Income, not Medicaid
                                      Not all low-income individuals qualify for government coverage through Medicaid.4 Medicaid eligibility
                                      is based on considerations of income as well as other characteristics. Among the population groups that
                                      generally qualify for Medicaid are children, parents of dependent children, pregnant women, the disabled,
                                      and the elderly. The income levels at which these groups qualify differ from state to state, and group to
                                      group. Generally, coverage for children and pregnant women is available at higher income levels, followed
                                      by the disabled and elderly, and lastly, parents of dependent children. Childless adults who are not
                                      disabled or elderly do not qualify for Medicaid, even at the lowest income levels.5

                                      Uninsured Workers Across All Industries – Variations Within
                                      The uninsured are present and working across nearly all segments of American business, even at
                                      moderate income levels. There is a significant presence of uninsured/employed at greater than 300
                                      percent of the Federal Poverty Line (FPL), with high concentrations in the financial services, information
                                      technology, transportation, and utilities industries. These individuals are often the recipients of direct
                                      marketing targeted toward the purchasing individual for self-pay insurance plans.

                                      The construction industry, and the leisure and hospitality services industry, have the highest percentage
                                      of uninsured/unemployed individuals below 300 percent of the poverty level. While these industries
                                      have lower employee retention rates and may have higher incidences of on-the-job injuries, this group of
                                      individuals also moves between employed and unemployed status more frequently. This group is often
                                      unable to access quality health insurance given the number of workplace-related injuries that occur in
                                      these lines of work.

                                        Table 1: Uninsured Workers by Industry
                                                              EMPLOYED          EMPLOYED             UNEMPLOYED           UNEMPLOYED   GRAND TOTAL
                                                              UNINSURED         UNINSURED            UNINSURED            UNINSURED
                                       INDUSTRY               PERSONS:          PERSONS:             PERSONS:             PERSONS:
                                                              0-FPL300          FPL300+              0-FPL300             FPL300+

                                       Financial Activities   43%               35%                  17%                  6%           1,098,728
                                       Information            41%               30%                  20%                  9%           456,213
                                       Transportation and     44%               29%                  22%                  5%           1,340,292
                                       Utilities
                                       Educational and        46%               28%                  22%                  4%           3,576,886
                                       Health Services
                                       Professional and       40%               26%                  28%                  6%           3,149,590
                                       Business
                                       Wholesale and          46%               24%                  25%                  4%           4,499,978
                                       Retail Trade
                                       Manufacturing          49%               23%                  24%                  5%           2,264,383
                                       Construction           41%               22%                  33%                  5%           3,950,430
                                       Agriculture,           56%               18%                  24%                  3%           626,562
                                       Forestry
                                       Leisure and            50%               18%                  28%                  4%           4,756,268
                                       Hospitality
                                       Source: Bureau of Labor Statistics, Current Population Survey, March 2008 Supplement


                                      UNINSURED HEALTH SERVICES UTILIZATION

                                      Physician Office Visits Lower; Self-Reported Conditions Higher
                                      For the employed and unemployed uninsured, office visits occur infrequently. Regardless of employment
                                      status, the uninsured average 2.5 physician office visits per year – approximately half the rate of those
                                      with insurance.

                                      However, despite a lower number of visits to physicians’ offices, the uninsured population has below-
                                      average health status and experiences complicating factors that negatively impact health. Unemployed,
                                      uninsured individuals self-report heart problems, hypertension, and lung cancer at extremely high rates,
                                      and show a high prevalence of chronic conditions. Risk factors among unemployed, uninsured patients
                                      include: obesity, poor diet, extreme stress, depression, and anxiety.


2 Caring for the Uninsured Amid Financial Pressures
As a result, it’s not surprising that the uninsured often seek other locations and venues of care, including
inpatient and hospital emergency department settings.

OUTPATIENT SERVICE USE DIFFERS BY PAYER GROUP

Medicaid Usage Higher Than Uninsured
Medicaid outpatient utilization across all delivery settings, including high-cost surgical procedures,
invasive procedures, and deliveries, ranges from two to three times greater than that of the uninsured.

Uninsured Patients Seek Lower Cost Medical Therapies, Minor Procedures, and Visits
The uninsured population frequently accesses lower cost medical therapies, minor invasive procedures,
and visits (often paid directly by the patient) at hospital outpatient or non-hospital clinic settings. In this
case, the uninsured take advantage of the various charity care and community benefits provided by area
hospitals that treat patients of all payer coverage categories or those without coverage at all. It’s also
common for the uninsured to use the Emergency Department for non-emergent visits at a much higher
rate than those with private insurance. But the use of Urgent Care centers, a lower cost-of-service site,
shows below average usage rates for the uninsured population.

To have an impact on this cycle of high-cost behavior across payer groups, hospital providers and their
marketing teams could benefit from developing and delivering targeted messaging regarding the various
sites of services, and clarifying the key situations for use.

Further insights on how frequently the uninsured population accesses healthcare services are revealed in
the chart below. For all outpatient services, the uninsured access care through a physician office at a rate
67 percent lower than the Medicaid population and 53 percent below the privately insured population.

  Table 2: Outpatient Visit Use Rates
 DIFFERENCE IN USE RATE FOR OUTPATIENT VISITS
 Visit Type                                  % Difference - Uninsured vs. Medicaid   % Difference - Uninsured vs. Private
 Emergency department visit, emergent          -25                                     -22
 Emergency department visit, urgent             -4                                      26
 Office medical visit, established patient     -52                                     -32
 Office medical visit, new patient             -55                                     -44
 Source: Thomson Reuters Outpatient Procedure Estimates, 2009

INPATIENT SERVICE USE DIFFERS BY UNINSURED PATIENTS

Postponement of Care a Factor
The uninsured that are unemployed with incomes above 300 percent of the Federal Poverty Level use
hospital inpatient services at a rate of nearly three-to-one, compared to other uninsured segments.
The difference between the inpatient usage rates of these groups likely stems from the fact that the
unemployed are more likely experiencing either chronic or disabling illnesses that prevent them from
working or pursuing employment.

In addition, this segment of the uninsured is the most likely to delay or postpone care for at least 12
months, creating a vicious cycle that further exacerbates chronic conditions and leads to increased
inpatient visit rates.

The situation is complicated by the fact that the uninsured, and in particular this segment of the
uninsured, are more likely to avoid receiving the recommended screening services to maintain health.
In short, the segment that needs the most care is the one most likely to use the costliest form of care
delivery (inpatient services) rather than accessing other, less-costly sites of services capable of managing
conditions.




                                                                                                                  Caring for the Uninsured Amid Financial Pressures 3
Chart 1: Physician Office vs. Inpatient Encounters
                                                  60
                                                                                                                                  n Employed Uninsured
                                                                                                                                    Persons: 0-FPL300
                                                  50
                                                                                                                                  n Employed Uninsured
                                                                                                                                    Persons: FPL300+
                                                  40



                                     Encounters
                                                                                                                                  n Unemployed Uninsured
                                                  30                                                                                Persons: 0-FPL300

                                                                                                                                  n Unemployed Uninsured
                                                  20
                                                                                                                                    Persons: FPL300+

                                                  10


                                                  0
                                                              Physician Visits   Inpatient Discharges     Inpatient Nights
                                                       Source: Bureau of Labor Statistics, Current Population Survey, March 2008 Supplement

                                      USING MARKETING TO INFLUENCE BEHAVIOR OF THE UNINSURED

                                      A hospital’s marketing programs and targeted messages can be an effective means of directing the
                                      various uninsured segments to appropriate and cost-effective settings of care. In fact, well-executed
                                      marketing and communications campaigns can positively impact the overall profitability of the entire
                                      healthcare organization.

                                      However, there are significant differences in preferred communication channels and messages to reach
                                      the targeted uninsured audience. In comparing the uninsured with the insured population, the uninsured
                                      segment, on average, has less information at hand when selecting a hospital. This information disparity
                                      suggests that concerted efforts to direct and channel care for the uninsured to specific services or sites
                                      must be precisely designed for the intended audience.

                                      A look at distinct marketing messaging opportunities, patient segmentation and clustering techniques,
                                      and marketing vehicles will help illustrate how these unique groups can be best reached.

                                      For example, the uninsured audience with incomes under 300 percent of the Federal Poverty Level,
                                      without differentiation to employment status6, is more likely to respond to traditional methods of
                                      communication about pursuit of services (e.g., radio, direct mail) than to Internet campaigns or
                                      information from employers.

                                              Chart 2: Preferred Communication Channel Compared to the Average


       Preferred Info Channel: Word of Mouth                                                                                                         n Less Than $50k
              Preferred Info Channel: Employer
                                                                                                                                                     n Greater Than $50k
      Preferred Info Channel: Physician Office
               Preferred Info Channel: Internet
                 Preferred Info Channel: Phone
            Preferred Info Channel: Direct Mail
           Preferred Info Channel: Newspaper
                  Preferred Info Channel: Radio
                     Preferred Info Channel: TV
            Heard/Saw Healthcare Advertising
           Use Internet For Health Info Lookup
                           Have Internet Access
                                                       -18%              -12%        -6%              0            6%             12%          18%
                                                                                      Percent Difference from Average

                                                         Source: Thomson Reuters PULSE™ Healthcare Survey, 2009


4 Caring for the Uninsured Amid Financial Pressures
While hospitals have shifted their budget allocations to create a host of scalable, efficient, online health
          resources (e.g., hospital Web sites, health content) that serve as patient education materials, they may
          miss the targeted audiences that need these resources most. A traditional target audience analysis, based
          on the HouseholdView® segmentation system, provides a window into the need to craft specific messages
          for the uninsured market.

          The chart below demonstrates that within the uninsured population, there are additional differences
          driven by demographic details, such as age, that may be leveraged for marketing success and cost
          containment.

                                  Chart 3: Likelihood to Postpone Care

                                   20.0%                                                                                                                                              n Postponed Care:
                                   15.0%                                                                                                                                                1 year
Percent Difference from Average




                                   10.0%                                                                                                                                              n Have PCP
                                    5.0%
                                    0.0%
                                   -5.0%
                                   -10.0%
                                   -15.0%
                                  -20.0%
                                  -25.0%
                                  -30.0%
                                                                                 Over-55 Segments                                                  Under-55 Segments
                                                   t
                                                 en




                                                                                                                              s
                                                                s
                                                 em




                                                                                                                           er
                                                              ck




                                                                                          o




                                                                                                                                                       ng
                                                                                                                         pp
                                                                                                           s
                                                              he




                                                                                          ng
                                              tir




                                                                                                          er
                                                                            rl




                                                                                                                                                      ivi
                                                                                                                         ho
                                            Re




                                                            C




                                                                                                                                                                         lo
                                                                                      Bi




                                                                                                        av
                                                                          Gi




                                                                                                                                         ls



                                                                                                                                                     eL




                                                                                                                                                                     So
                                                         ly




                                                                                                                      tS
                                                                                                       S
                                                                                      g
                                             l




                                                                          n




                                                                                                                                        il
                                                         th
                                         tfu




                                                                                    yin




                                                                                                    ny




                                                                                                                                     Fr



                                                                                                                                                   pl
                                                                       de




                                                                                                                    le




                                                                                                                                                                     g
                                                       on




                                                                                                                                                                     n
                                       es




                                                                                                                    ut




                                                                                                                                               im
                                                                                                   en
                                                                                  la
                                                                     ol




                                                                                                                                    o




                                                                                                                                                                 lyi
                                                    .M




                                                                                                                                    .N
                                     .R




                                                                                                               .O
                                                                                 .P
                                                                     .G




                                                                                                                                              .S
                                                                                                 .P




                                                                                                                                                                .F
                                                                                                                                  29
                                                  54
                                   55




                                                                                 46




                                                                                                               38
                                                                   47




                                                                                                                                              33
                                                                                               37




                                                                                                                                                              17
                                            Source: Thomson Reuters PULSE™ Healthcare Survey, 2009


          Messaging to Uninsured Greatest/Silent Generation – Get the Doctors on Board                                                                                        HEALTHCARE
          The Greatest/Silent Generation segment of the uninsured population, is more likely than their younger                                                               ATTITUDES
          counterparts to have a primary care physician (PCP). And despite being concerned about the cost of                                                                  OF FOUR
          medical services, they are more likely to seek care.                                                                                                                GENERATIONS7

          In the Thomson Reuters PULSE™ Healthcare Survey, the age 55+ generations reveal strong physician                                                                    Greatest/Silent
                                                                                                                                                                              Generation
          alignment and consider “Physician Referral” and “Physician Affiliation” as the most important drivers
                                                                                                                                                                              (born before 1942)
          in selecting a hospital for care. Correspondingly, strengthening physician relationships, rather than
          increasing direct-to-consumer outreach, may ultimately be more advantageous in influencing individuals’                                                             Baby Boomers
          hospital selection process. Stronger physician relationships can foster paths of communication, with                                                                (born 1943–1960)
          the intent of shifting use of healthcare services to the appropriate settings and thereby improving care
                                                                                                                                                                              Generation X
          management. The behavior of the over-55 uninsured population is consistent across the segment and can
                                                                                                                                                                              (born 1961–1981)
          be messaged accordingly.
                                                                                                                                                                              Millennials (adults
          Messaging to Uninsured Baby Boomers and Gen Xers – Use Direct Mail or Phone Campaigns                                                                               born since 1982)
          Crafting effective messaging for the under-55 populations is a more difficult task, even for those with
          significant health issues, including younger uninsured segments that are at risk for hypertension,
          depression, and diabetes. As the chart Likelihood to Postpone Care indicates, these individuals are less
          apt to have a PCP and therefore are unable to be directed by their physician to appropriate sites of care.
          Even within the under-55 uninsured population, the Baby Boomer and Gen Xer groups prove to be two
          distinct populations:

          •	 Those who would act on healthcare advertising, but do not often see it (These segments make up the
             majority of the uninsured population.)
          •	 Those who are aware of healthcare advertising, but would not act on it


                                                                                                                                                          Caring for the Uninsured Amid Financial Pressures 5
Focusing on the former, those who would act on healthcare advertising, helps marketers to connect with
                                      a willing and receptive population. The dilemma comes in deciding which media and messages are most
                                      important and effective. The goal in developing a strategy that best suits this audience is to identify the
                                      most appropriate media to reach them, avenues that will draw upon their penchant to respond positively
                                      to any form of healthcare advertising.

                                      The two strongest media formats for this population are standard direct mail and telemarketing. Of these
                                      two mediums, direct mail is usually the most cost-effective communication channel to connect with the
                                      uninsured, under-55 population. In order to impact site of service selection, the goal of these mailings
                                      should be to direct individuals to a primary care physician and encourage them to pursue necessary care.
                                      Another tactic that has been effective with this audience is to develop a health lecture on a topic relevant
                                      to their lives. Since many uninsured individuals in this segment struggle with chronic stress and anxiety,
                                      health lectures on these topics are likely to resonate.

                                      Directing this population could utilize a strategy such as:
                                        Table 3: Potential Outreach Strategy
                                       CALL TO ACTION                           MEDIA                                    HOSPITAL GOAL
                                       Attend a health lecture                  Direct mail                              Help establish relationship with PCP
                                       Potential Topics: Anxiety, Depression,   Phone number provided for follow-up      Provide reason to see a PCP
                                       Stress Management                        questions
                                                                                Follow-up call after attending to make   Identify critical health conditions that
                                                                                an appointment with a primary care       require treatment and management
                                                                                physician (PCP)
                                       Source: Thomson Reuters crmView™ Marketing Solutions, 2010

                                      Successful efforts require consistent messaging through preferred media channels to help achieve the
                                      goals of identifying the most appropriate site of service and disease management program.

                                      STRIVING FOR BALANCE: TACTICS FOR CONSIDERATION

                                      While everyone from Washington to your hometown critiques and debates the tactics for healthcare
                                      improvement, hospitals continue to face the critical onus of delivering uncompensated care.8 There is an
                                      immediate need to identify and achieve real solutions. Regardless of the system-wide healthcare changes
                                      that may be on the horizon, most individual hospitals and healthcare systems face faltering business
                                      models that are forcing reductions in services and staff.

                                      This research raises plausible considerations for achieving a balance between meeting the mission of
                                      serving the uninsured, benefitting the community, and also addressing healthcare budgetary constraints
                                      while delivering a significant return to the board and other key stakeholders. Simple solutions may not
                                      exist. However, by guiding and transferring care to more appropriate care settings, healthcare providers
                                      have an opportunity to address the cost of care, while concurrently increasing quality of care, patient
                                      throughput, efficiency, and ultimately reimbursable care.

                                      To chart the roadmap toward these achievements, consider the following tactics:

                                      MARKETING TACTICS

                                      Focus on Patients Who Drive the Costs
                                      A small number of patients usually drive the majority of costs. Target these patients at the right time with
                                      the right message. Then, measure the impact of your efforts through response rate analysis and reporting,
                                      and support continuous improvement based on your successes.

                                      Mine the Customer Information to Gain Key Insights
                                      Mining, modeling, and measurement are vital steps in understanding your current and anticipated patient
                                      populations. Organizations without the internal talent or tools to achieve a comprehensive analysis can
                                      consider partnering with healthcare-focused strategic intelligence and consulting firms and/or purchasing
                                      market intelligence tools.




6 Caring for the Uninsured Amid Financial Pressures
Periodically Reevaluate Tactical Plans
                                                                                                                      Oakwood Annapolis
The tactics provided above are recommended as ongoing efforts, in lieu of one-time, evaluation processes.             Hospital, part of the
Though characteristics and utilization behaviors of patients continually change, patterns emerge and                  Oakwood Healthcare
measurement will provide key insights in determining the effectiveness of the aforementioned tactics.                 System in Wayne,
                                                                                                                      Michigan, receives
These marketing tactics can help your organization gain a greater understanding of your audience, the                 over 70 percent of
                                                                                                                      its admitted patients
best way to reach them, and how their behavior changes over time. The frontline tactics below offer                   from the emergency
additional suggestions for providers to consider.                                                                     department (ED).
                                                                                                                      The facility identified
FRONTLINE TACTICS                                                                                                     patterns of its ED
                                                                                                                      “frequent fliers”
                                                                                                                      through the use of
Partner With Physicians for Continued Patient Education and Direction                                                 Thomson Reuters
Ensure information is shared with patients on appropriate care settings. For example, emergency                       crmView™ Marketing
department (ED) physicians may be able to share literature on other facility resources, including primary             Solutions and
physicians, urgent care locations, and clinics.                                                                       employed direct
                                                                                                                      mail to generate
                                                                                                                      awareness within their
Review Increased Collection Efforts (at the Time of Service)                                                          target audiences.
Increased collection efforts may discourage the uninsured from seeking care at expensive sites of service
when less expensive sites provide equally appropriate care. Yet it is important to study both the short-term          They stressed the
and longer-term effects of such an effort. While the target audience may seek care at your ED much less               importance of seeing a
frequently, a patient’s disease or condition may worsen, and require acute inpatient services.9                       primary care physician
                                                                                                                      for non-life threatening
                                                                                                                      conditions and shared
Examine Success Stories                                                                                               information regarding
Identifying organizations that have successfully addressed the right care at the right site helps generate            federally qualified care
ideas on what to do and who to leverage for support.                                                                  centers. Among their
                                                                                                                      achievements, cost of
                                                                                                                      care decreased by $35
CONCLUSION                                                                                                            per ED visit; improper
                                                                                                                      utilization declined by
The challenges the medical community faces in meeting the needs of the uninsured while also remaining                 72 percent; physician
fiscally responsible to their own organizations are great. Although the landscape of healthcare politics              referrals for patients
remains in flux and is likely to continue so for the foreseeable future, healthcare organizations can take a          to more appropriate
                                                                                                                      health centers
number of practical steps to alleviate some of their most vexing financial challenges while improving their           increased by 12 percent;
ability to care for the uninsured.                                                                                    and the ordering and
                                                                                                                      prescribing of narcotics
                                                                                                                      in the ED declined
 Table 4: HouseholdView® Segments
                                                                                                                      by 10 percent. 10
SEGMENT NAME             AGE             MARITAL STATUS                          GENERATION
55. Restful Retirement   75+             Married/Married with Kids               Greatest/Silent
54. Monthly Checks       75+             Married/Married with Kids               Greatest/Silent
47. Golden Girl          65+             Single Female/Single Female with Kids   Greatest/Silent
46. Playing Bingo        65+             Single Female/Single Female with Kids   Greatest/Silent
38. Outlet Shoppers      55-64           Single Female/Single Female with Kids   Boomers
37. Penny Savers         55-64           Single Female/Single Female with Kids   Boomers
29. No Frills            45-54           Married with Kids                       Boomers
33. Simple Living        45-54           Married                                 Boomers
17. Flying Solo          35-54           Single Female                           Gen X/Boomer
Source: Thomson Reuters HouseholdView®




                                                                                                   Caring for the Uninsured Amid Financial Pressures 7
APPENDIX
  HEALTHCARE ATTITUDES OF
  FOUR GENERATIONS7
                                                               THOMSON REUTERS PULSE HEALTHCARE SURVEY
                                                               Thomson Reuters delivers unique insights into consumer healthcare behavior
  GREATEST/SILENT GENERATION
  (BORN BEFORE 1942):                                          and attitudes with the proprietary PULSE™ Healthcare Survey – the largest
  Attitude toward gathering healthcare                         ongoing, privately funded telephone healthcare survey in the United States.
  information: Physician Directs Me                            Through the PULSE Healthcare Survey, Thomson Reuters has compiled
  •	 Rely on personal doctors, defer to                        more than 100,000 household interviews annually since 1988. The survey is
     physicians’ preferences                                   conducted by telephone throughout the entire year to account for seasonality.
  •	 Rigid definitions of good service:                        Each year, Thomson Reuters clients help to determine the PULSE Healthcare
     the customer is always right                              Survey topics, ensuring the questions asked reflect the most important
  •	 Consider only physicians and nurses                       industry topics. The questions are both behavioral and attitudinal in nature
     as health professionals                                   and are modeled to reflect the larger population. The PULSE Healthcare
                                                               Survey is unique in that it ties results to two proven lifestyle segmentation
  BABY BOOMERS (BORN 1943–1960):
  Attitude toward gathering healthcare information:            systems: PRIZM® by Nielsen and HouseholdView®, a Thomson Reuters
  Engage Me                                                    methodology. The use of lifestyle segmentation gives healthcare clients better
  •	 Prefer individual engagement in healthcare                insights into who is using which services and where similar households are
                                                               located within their markets.
  •	 Seek counsel from and bring information to the
     physician, and then research
     physician recommendations                                 HOUSEHOLDVIEW
  •	 Consider only physicians and nurses as                    HouseholdView® is a dynamic, proprietary segmentation system for the
     health professionals                                      next generation of healthcare consumer insights. The 56 segments paint a
  •	 Often involved in decision-making for their aging         comprehensive picture of how healthcare consumers use health services,
     parents, while also informing the health needs of         select providers, define quality, obtain healthcare information, and respond
     their own children                                        to healthcare advertising. With a high level of sophistication for today’s
                                                               complex healthcare market place, each of the customer segments within
  GENERATION X (BORN 1961–1981):
  Attitude toward gathering healthcare information:            HouseholdView is a unique combination of the variables determined to be the
  Educate Me                                                   most predictive of consumer healthcare behavior. HouseholdView segments
  •	 Desire to be educated and involved                        align with the strategic planning and marketing challenges that face the
                                                               healthcare industry today.
  •	 Relatively healthy compared to older generations
  •	 Curious and actively seek information
                                                               THOMSON REUTERS OUTPATIENT PROCEDURE ESTIMATES
  •	 Assume physicians and staff are knowledgeable             Thomson Reuters Outpatient Procedure Estimates predicts the total annual
  •	 Strong interest in amenities                              volume of ambulatory procedures performed by ZIP code, age group, sex, site
  •	 Likely to switch physicians and hospitals based on        of service, and payer for every market in the United States. Procedures are
     recent experience                                         defined and reported by 591 categories of CPT® and HCPCS codes, which are
  •	 More in common with the Millennial adults than with       further grouped into clinical service lines as well as broad technical groups.
     the Boomers                                               To construct population-based use rates for all payers and all ambulatory
  •	 Definition of health professionals is broad and           care settings, Thomson Reuters uses proprietary and public claims, as well as
     includes nurse practitioners, physician assistants,       Federal surveys. The rates are adjusted to reflect local utilization patterns and
     insurance companies, and pharmacies
                                                               are then applied to demographic and insurance coverage projections by ZIP
  MILLENNIALS (ADULTS BORN SINCE 1982):                        code to estimate outpatient utilization for 2009 and 2014.
  Attitude toward gathering healthcare information:
  Connect with Me
  •	 Access healthcare system through primary care
     providers (PCP), urgent care centers, and Ob/Gyns
     with a higher likelihood to use Ob/Gyns as PCPs
  •	 Relatively low utilization of inpatient and
     outpatient services
  •	 When using inpatient services, most come through
     maternity and emergency departments
  •	 Enjoy and use technology
  •	 Maintain positive, personal relationship with physician
  •	 Seek health information from multiple sources
  •	 More likely to switch providers if confidence in care
     lost based on recent experience




8 Caring for the Uninsured Amid Financial Pressures
REFERENCES

1
    DeNavas-Walt, Carmen, Bernadette D. Proctor, Jessica C. Smith. Income, Poverty, and Health Insurance
      Coverage in the United States: 2008.
2
    2009 Thomson Reuters, Insurance Coverage Estimates.
3
    Abelson, Reed. Bills Stalled, Hospitals Fear Rising Unpaid Care, February 8, 2010.
      (http://www.nytimes.com/2010/02/09/health/policy/09hospital.html)
4
    (http://www.ache.org/Pubs/Releases/2010/TopIssues_2010.pdf) Retrieved on March 2, 2010.
5
    (http://www.cms.hhs.gov/MedicaidEligibility/) Retrieved on March 2, 2010.
6
    For the purposes of the following analysis, Thomson Reuters is comparing and contrasting the
       behaviors of the below $50,000 and above $50,000 income households. The $50,000 line is close,
       but not exactly comparable to 300 percent of the Federal Poverty Line for a family of three in the
       contiguous 48 states. As such, we are using household income for approximating behavior of the
       uninsured population 300 percent FPL compared to the above $50,000 household population as an
       approximation for the insured segment.
7
    Matching the Market: Using Generational Segments to Attract and Retain Consumers.
      Thomson Reuters, 2009. pgs. 2-3.
8
    Guggenheim, Ricardo, MD. Uncompensated Care is a $31 Billion Problem Waiting to be Solved.
      HealthLeaders News. September 26, 2008.
9
    Ibid, Guggenheim.
10
     Patient Marketing Addresses E.D. Over-Utilization and Lowers Cost of Care. Thomson Reuters, 2009.




                                                                                                 Caring for the Uninsured Amid Financial Pressures 9
aBOUt tHOMSON reUterS

Thomson Reuters is the world’s
leading source of intelligent
information for businesses and
professionals. We combine industry
expertise with innovative technology
to deliver critical information to
leading decision makers in the
financial, legal, tax and accounting,
healthcare and science and media
markets, powered by the world’s
most trusted news organization.
With headquarters in New York
and major operations in London
and Eagan, Minnesota, Thomson
Reuters employs more than 50,000
people and operates in over 100
countries. Thomson Reuters shares
are listed on the Toronto Stock
Exchange (TSX: TRI) and New York
Stock Exchange (NYSE: TRI).

thomsonreuters.com

Thomson Reuters
777 E. Eisenhower Parkway
Ann Arbor, MI 48108 USA
Phone +1 800 366 7526

©2010 Thomson Reuters.
All rights reserved.
MDS-7808 05/10 MC

Contenu connexe

Similaire à Caring For The Uninsured Final 050510

The people behind the mask impact of covid19 on jordanian consumers
The people behind the mask   impact of covid19 on jordanian consumersThe people behind the mask   impact of covid19 on jordanian consumers
The people behind the mask impact of covid19 on jordanian consumersOsama Khalidi
 
Running head BUSINESS PLAN NURSING CARE FACILITY .docx
Running head BUSINESS PLAN NURSING CARE FACILITY      .docxRunning head BUSINESS PLAN NURSING CARE FACILITY      .docx
Running head BUSINESS PLAN NURSING CARE FACILITY .docxsusanschei
 
Life as-medical-billers-coders-in-todays-economy
Life as-medical-billers-coders-in-todays-economyLife as-medical-billers-coders-in-todays-economy
Life as-medical-billers-coders-in-todays-economyMedical Billers and Coders
 
A Report on Unemployment - A basic study
A Report on Unemployment  - A basic studyA Report on Unemployment  - A basic study
A Report on Unemployment - A basic studyDhanya Pravin
 
Co venture elderly_care
Co venture elderly_careCo venture elderly_care
Co venture elderly_careAli Hamed
 
The 10 companies booming in healthcare sector small
The 10 companies booming in healthcare sector  smallThe 10 companies booming in healthcare sector  small
The 10 companies booming in healthcare sector smallinsightscare
 
Perfect Storm 15 For Nurse Symposium 1
Perfect Storm 15 For Nurse Symposium 1Perfect Storm 15 For Nurse Symposium 1
Perfect Storm 15 For Nurse Symposium 1kyguy1085
 
Mercer Capital's Value Focus: Medical Technology | Mid-Year 2021
Mercer Capital's Value Focus: Medical Technology | Mid-Year 2021Mercer Capital's Value Focus: Medical Technology | Mid-Year 2021
Mercer Capital's Value Focus: Medical Technology | Mid-Year 2021Mercer Capital
 
11th asia conference on health insurance & health care, singapore, sharad...
11th asia conference on health insurance & health care, singapore, sharad...11th asia conference on health insurance & health care, singapore, sharad...
11th asia conference on health insurance & health care, singapore, sharad...Nikash Deka
 
Digital healthcare leap pwc
Digital healthcare leap pwcDigital healthcare leap pwc
Digital healthcare leap pwcAshima Khurana
 
Digital healthcare leap pwc (emerging markets)
Digital healthcare leap pwc (emerging markets)Digital healthcare leap pwc (emerging markets)
Digital healthcare leap pwc (emerging markets)Ashima Khurana
 
Extending health insurance coverage to the informal sector: Lessons from a pr...
Extending health insurance coverage to the informal sector: Lessons from a pr...Extending health insurance coverage to the informal sector: Lessons from a pr...
Extending health insurance coverage to the informal sector: Lessons from a pr...HFG Project
 
The Digital Healthcare Leap | PWC
The Digital Healthcare Leap | PWCThe Digital Healthcare Leap | PWC
The Digital Healthcare Leap | PWCGalen Growth
 
MCB3020L General Microbiology LaboratoryLab #9Section U01G
MCB3020L General Microbiology LaboratoryLab #9Section U01GMCB3020L General Microbiology LaboratoryLab #9Section U01G
MCB3020L General Microbiology LaboratoryLab #9Section U01GAbramMartino96
 
MicroinsurancePoV_01.12
MicroinsurancePoV_01.12MicroinsurancePoV_01.12
MicroinsurancePoV_01.12Riaan Singh
 
The 10 Companies Booming in Healthcare Sector
The 10 Companies Booming in Healthcare SectorThe 10 Companies Booming in Healthcare Sector
The 10 Companies Booming in Healthcare Sectorinsightscare
 
Actuarial insurance trends guide
Actuarial insurance trends guideActuarial insurance trends guide
Actuarial insurance trends guidejacobsongroup
 
healthcare industry_report
healthcare industry_reporthealthcare industry_report
healthcare industry_reportDouglas Tauro
 

Similaire à Caring For The Uninsured Final 050510 (20)

The people behind the mask impact of covid19 on jordanian consumers
The people behind the mask   impact of covid19 on jordanian consumersThe people behind the mask   impact of covid19 on jordanian consumers
The people behind the mask impact of covid19 on jordanian consumers
 
Running head BUSINESS PLAN NURSING CARE FACILITY .docx
Running head BUSINESS PLAN NURSING CARE FACILITY      .docxRunning head BUSINESS PLAN NURSING CARE FACILITY      .docx
Running head BUSINESS PLAN NURSING CARE FACILITY .docx
 
Life as-medical-billers-coders-in-todays-economy
Life as-medical-billers-coders-in-todays-economyLife as-medical-billers-coders-in-todays-economy
Life as-medical-billers-coders-in-todays-economy
 
A Report on Unemployment - A basic study
A Report on Unemployment  - A basic studyA Report on Unemployment  - A basic study
A Report on Unemployment - A basic study
 
Co venture elderly_care
Co venture elderly_careCo venture elderly_care
Co venture elderly_care
 
The 10 companies booming in healthcare sector small
The 10 companies booming in healthcare sector  smallThe 10 companies booming in healthcare sector  small
The 10 companies booming in healthcare sector small
 
Perfect Storm 15 For Nurse Symposium 1
Perfect Storm 15 For Nurse Symposium 1Perfect Storm 15 For Nurse Symposium 1
Perfect Storm 15 For Nurse Symposium 1
 
Shifting Expectations Mexico
Shifting Expectations MexicoShifting Expectations Mexico
Shifting Expectations Mexico
 
Mercer Capital's Value Focus: Medical Technology | Mid-Year 2021
Mercer Capital's Value Focus: Medical Technology | Mid-Year 2021Mercer Capital's Value Focus: Medical Technology | Mid-Year 2021
Mercer Capital's Value Focus: Medical Technology | Mid-Year 2021
 
11th asia conference on health insurance & health care, singapore, sharad...
11th asia conference on health insurance & health care, singapore, sharad...11th asia conference on health insurance & health care, singapore, sharad...
11th asia conference on health insurance & health care, singapore, sharad...
 
Digital healthcare leap pwc
Digital healthcare leap pwcDigital healthcare leap pwc
Digital healthcare leap pwc
 
Digital healthcare leap pwc (emerging markets)
Digital healthcare leap pwc (emerging markets)Digital healthcare leap pwc (emerging markets)
Digital healthcare leap pwc (emerging markets)
 
Extending health insurance coverage to the informal sector: Lessons from a pr...
Extending health insurance coverage to the informal sector: Lessons from a pr...Extending health insurance coverage to the informal sector: Lessons from a pr...
Extending health insurance coverage to the informal sector: Lessons from a pr...
 
The Digital Healthcare Leap | PWC
The Digital Healthcare Leap | PWCThe Digital Healthcare Leap | PWC
The Digital Healthcare Leap | PWC
 
MCB3020L General Microbiology LaboratoryLab #9Section U01G
MCB3020L General Microbiology LaboratoryLab #9Section U01GMCB3020L General Microbiology LaboratoryLab #9Section U01G
MCB3020L General Microbiology LaboratoryLab #9Section U01G
 
MicroinsurancePoV_01.12
MicroinsurancePoV_01.12MicroinsurancePoV_01.12
MicroinsurancePoV_01.12
 
The 10 Companies Booming in Healthcare Sector
The 10 Companies Booming in Healthcare SectorThe 10 Companies Booming in Healthcare Sector
The 10 Companies Booming in Healthcare Sector
 
Actuarial insurance trends guide
Actuarial insurance trends guideActuarial insurance trends guide
Actuarial insurance trends guide
 
healthcare industry_report
healthcare industry_reporthealthcare industry_report
healthcare industry_report
 
Top Workforce Trends Impacting the Healthcare Industry in 2020
Top Workforce Trends Impacting the Healthcare Industry in 2020Top Workforce Trends Impacting the Healthcare Industry in 2020
Top Workforce Trends Impacting the Healthcare Industry in 2020
 

Caring For The Uninsured Final 050510

  • 1. wHite PaPer CARING FOR THE UNINSURED AMID FINANCIAL PRESSURES USING TARGETED MARKETING METHODS TO INFLUENCE PATIENT BEHAVIOR JEFFREY S. BARKOFF DENNIS DUNN, PHD KENT FRANCIS LINDA MACCRACKEN, MBA GARY PICKENS, PHD LEAH H. RAY, MBA MICHAEL SHIPLEY MEREDITH A. WELLS, MS APRIL 2010
  • 2. TABLE OF CONTENTS INTRODUCTION .......................................................................................................................................... 1 THE UNINSURED POPULATION: NOT HOMOGENOUS ..................................................................... 1 UNINSURED HEALTH SERVICES UTILIZATION .................................................................................. 2 OUTPATIENT SERVICE USE DIFFERS BY PAYER GROUP ................................................................. 3 INPATIENT SERVICE USE DIFFERS BY UNINSURED PATIENTS ..................................................... 3 USING MARKETING TO INFLUENCE BEHAVIOR OF THE UNINSURED ........................................ 4 STRIVING FOR BALANCE: TACTICS FOR CONSIDERATION ............................................................ 6 MARKETING TACTICS ............................................................................................................................... 6 FRONTLINE TACTICS .................................................................................................................................7 CONCLUSION...............................................................................................................................................7 APPENDIX ................................................................................................................................................... 8 REFERENCES .............................................................................................................................................. 9
  • 3. INTRODUCTION Across all political affiliations, industries, and socioeconomic backgrounds, healthcare reform ranks among today’s most discussed topics. But in the midst of the debate, one fact remains clear: providing care to the uninsured segment of the population is a monumental task of paramount importance. The total uninsured population now includes one out of every six Americans. Estimates of the total number of uninsured individuals ranges from roughly 46.31 to 49.72 million. The uninsured population now exceeds the total number of Medicare beneficiaries by roughly 22 percent. Furthermore, forecasts indicate that the number of uninsured will reach 58 million Americans by 2014.3 The cost of continuing to provide care as we do today will translate into billions of dollars in unpaid medical bills for patients with little or no coverage. But the more hospitals and healthcare providers know about their patients – notably the uninsured – the better equipped they will be to meet their missions, maintain a robust community benefit, and contain costs as components of financial viability. Regardless of the future of healthcare reform, hospitals and healthcare providers are well served to assess utilization and care patterns, examine their patient rosters, and develop strategies to lower expenses without sacrificing quality of care. In supporting this need, Thomson Reuters experts explored the topic of caring for the uninsured by examining national hospital data and consumer healthcare information to articulate the unique characteristics and behaviors of this growing population. This paper identifies distinct segments with different utilization trends/behaviors, as well as channels and receptiveness to marketing. In addition, Thomson Reuters developed recommendations to hospital leadership on how to provide the right care at the right site of service to help better manage the rising costs of serving the uninsured. The research presented here draws upon multiple sources, including the Thomson Reuters Outpatient Procedure Estimates and consumer research from the annual Thomson Reuters PULSE™ Healthcare Survey. THE UNINSURED POPULATION: NOT HOMOGENOUS Uninsured – Not Necessarily Low Income or Unemployed For many Americans, the “uninsured” – when viewed as a single group – often means those without employment or those who cannot afford individual healthcare coverage. The uninsured are not a homogenous group and include both unemployed and employed individuals, at various income levels, as well as their children and other dependents. Thomson Reuters experts have found significant differences among the various subgroups of the uninsured, including site of service preferences and health conditions. Thomson Reuters defined four mutually exclusive segments for the uninsured, based on employment status and income level. Key differences in behaviors of the various segments are described as follows. • Uninsured, employed with incomes under 300 percent of the Federal Poverty Level • Uninsured, employed with incomes above 300 percent of the Federal Poverty Level • Uninsured, unemployed with incomes under 300 percent of the Federal Poverty Level • Uninsured, unemployed with incomes above 300 percent of the Federal Poverty Level Caring for the Uninsured Amid Financial Pressures 1
  • 4. Uninsured – Low Income, not Medicaid Not all low-income individuals qualify for government coverage through Medicaid.4 Medicaid eligibility is based on considerations of income as well as other characteristics. Among the population groups that generally qualify for Medicaid are children, parents of dependent children, pregnant women, the disabled, and the elderly. The income levels at which these groups qualify differ from state to state, and group to group. Generally, coverage for children and pregnant women is available at higher income levels, followed by the disabled and elderly, and lastly, parents of dependent children. Childless adults who are not disabled or elderly do not qualify for Medicaid, even at the lowest income levels.5 Uninsured Workers Across All Industries – Variations Within The uninsured are present and working across nearly all segments of American business, even at moderate income levels. There is a significant presence of uninsured/employed at greater than 300 percent of the Federal Poverty Line (FPL), with high concentrations in the financial services, information technology, transportation, and utilities industries. These individuals are often the recipients of direct marketing targeted toward the purchasing individual for self-pay insurance plans. The construction industry, and the leisure and hospitality services industry, have the highest percentage of uninsured/unemployed individuals below 300 percent of the poverty level. While these industries have lower employee retention rates and may have higher incidences of on-the-job injuries, this group of individuals also moves between employed and unemployed status more frequently. This group is often unable to access quality health insurance given the number of workplace-related injuries that occur in these lines of work. Table 1: Uninsured Workers by Industry EMPLOYED EMPLOYED UNEMPLOYED UNEMPLOYED GRAND TOTAL UNINSURED UNINSURED UNINSURED UNINSURED INDUSTRY PERSONS: PERSONS: PERSONS: PERSONS: 0-FPL300 FPL300+ 0-FPL300 FPL300+ Financial Activities 43% 35% 17% 6% 1,098,728 Information 41% 30% 20% 9% 456,213 Transportation and 44% 29% 22% 5% 1,340,292 Utilities Educational and 46% 28% 22% 4% 3,576,886 Health Services Professional and 40% 26% 28% 6% 3,149,590 Business Wholesale and 46% 24% 25% 4% 4,499,978 Retail Trade Manufacturing 49% 23% 24% 5% 2,264,383 Construction 41% 22% 33% 5% 3,950,430 Agriculture, 56% 18% 24% 3% 626,562 Forestry Leisure and 50% 18% 28% 4% 4,756,268 Hospitality Source: Bureau of Labor Statistics, Current Population Survey, March 2008 Supplement UNINSURED HEALTH SERVICES UTILIZATION Physician Office Visits Lower; Self-Reported Conditions Higher For the employed and unemployed uninsured, office visits occur infrequently. Regardless of employment status, the uninsured average 2.5 physician office visits per year – approximately half the rate of those with insurance. However, despite a lower number of visits to physicians’ offices, the uninsured population has below- average health status and experiences complicating factors that negatively impact health. Unemployed, uninsured individuals self-report heart problems, hypertension, and lung cancer at extremely high rates, and show a high prevalence of chronic conditions. Risk factors among unemployed, uninsured patients include: obesity, poor diet, extreme stress, depression, and anxiety. 2 Caring for the Uninsured Amid Financial Pressures
  • 5. As a result, it’s not surprising that the uninsured often seek other locations and venues of care, including inpatient and hospital emergency department settings. OUTPATIENT SERVICE USE DIFFERS BY PAYER GROUP Medicaid Usage Higher Than Uninsured Medicaid outpatient utilization across all delivery settings, including high-cost surgical procedures, invasive procedures, and deliveries, ranges from two to three times greater than that of the uninsured. Uninsured Patients Seek Lower Cost Medical Therapies, Minor Procedures, and Visits The uninsured population frequently accesses lower cost medical therapies, minor invasive procedures, and visits (often paid directly by the patient) at hospital outpatient or non-hospital clinic settings. In this case, the uninsured take advantage of the various charity care and community benefits provided by area hospitals that treat patients of all payer coverage categories or those without coverage at all. It’s also common for the uninsured to use the Emergency Department for non-emergent visits at a much higher rate than those with private insurance. But the use of Urgent Care centers, a lower cost-of-service site, shows below average usage rates for the uninsured population. To have an impact on this cycle of high-cost behavior across payer groups, hospital providers and their marketing teams could benefit from developing and delivering targeted messaging regarding the various sites of services, and clarifying the key situations for use. Further insights on how frequently the uninsured population accesses healthcare services are revealed in the chart below. For all outpatient services, the uninsured access care through a physician office at a rate 67 percent lower than the Medicaid population and 53 percent below the privately insured population. Table 2: Outpatient Visit Use Rates DIFFERENCE IN USE RATE FOR OUTPATIENT VISITS Visit Type % Difference - Uninsured vs. Medicaid % Difference - Uninsured vs. Private Emergency department visit, emergent -25 -22 Emergency department visit, urgent -4 26 Office medical visit, established patient -52 -32 Office medical visit, new patient -55 -44 Source: Thomson Reuters Outpatient Procedure Estimates, 2009 INPATIENT SERVICE USE DIFFERS BY UNINSURED PATIENTS Postponement of Care a Factor The uninsured that are unemployed with incomes above 300 percent of the Federal Poverty Level use hospital inpatient services at a rate of nearly three-to-one, compared to other uninsured segments. The difference between the inpatient usage rates of these groups likely stems from the fact that the unemployed are more likely experiencing either chronic or disabling illnesses that prevent them from working or pursuing employment. In addition, this segment of the uninsured is the most likely to delay or postpone care for at least 12 months, creating a vicious cycle that further exacerbates chronic conditions and leads to increased inpatient visit rates. The situation is complicated by the fact that the uninsured, and in particular this segment of the uninsured, are more likely to avoid receiving the recommended screening services to maintain health. In short, the segment that needs the most care is the one most likely to use the costliest form of care delivery (inpatient services) rather than accessing other, less-costly sites of services capable of managing conditions. Caring for the Uninsured Amid Financial Pressures 3
  • 6. Chart 1: Physician Office vs. Inpatient Encounters 60 n Employed Uninsured Persons: 0-FPL300 50 n Employed Uninsured Persons: FPL300+ 40 Encounters n Unemployed Uninsured 30 Persons: 0-FPL300 n Unemployed Uninsured 20 Persons: FPL300+ 10 0 Physician Visits Inpatient Discharges Inpatient Nights Source: Bureau of Labor Statistics, Current Population Survey, March 2008 Supplement USING MARKETING TO INFLUENCE BEHAVIOR OF THE UNINSURED A hospital’s marketing programs and targeted messages can be an effective means of directing the various uninsured segments to appropriate and cost-effective settings of care. In fact, well-executed marketing and communications campaigns can positively impact the overall profitability of the entire healthcare organization. However, there are significant differences in preferred communication channels and messages to reach the targeted uninsured audience. In comparing the uninsured with the insured population, the uninsured segment, on average, has less information at hand when selecting a hospital. This information disparity suggests that concerted efforts to direct and channel care for the uninsured to specific services or sites must be precisely designed for the intended audience. A look at distinct marketing messaging opportunities, patient segmentation and clustering techniques, and marketing vehicles will help illustrate how these unique groups can be best reached. For example, the uninsured audience with incomes under 300 percent of the Federal Poverty Level, without differentiation to employment status6, is more likely to respond to traditional methods of communication about pursuit of services (e.g., radio, direct mail) than to Internet campaigns or information from employers. Chart 2: Preferred Communication Channel Compared to the Average Preferred Info Channel: Word of Mouth n Less Than $50k Preferred Info Channel: Employer n Greater Than $50k Preferred Info Channel: Physician Office Preferred Info Channel: Internet Preferred Info Channel: Phone Preferred Info Channel: Direct Mail Preferred Info Channel: Newspaper Preferred Info Channel: Radio Preferred Info Channel: TV Heard/Saw Healthcare Advertising Use Internet For Health Info Lookup Have Internet Access -18% -12% -6% 0 6% 12% 18% Percent Difference from Average Source: Thomson Reuters PULSE™ Healthcare Survey, 2009 4 Caring for the Uninsured Amid Financial Pressures
  • 7. While hospitals have shifted their budget allocations to create a host of scalable, efficient, online health resources (e.g., hospital Web sites, health content) that serve as patient education materials, they may miss the targeted audiences that need these resources most. A traditional target audience analysis, based on the HouseholdView® segmentation system, provides a window into the need to craft specific messages for the uninsured market. The chart below demonstrates that within the uninsured population, there are additional differences driven by demographic details, such as age, that may be leveraged for marketing success and cost containment. Chart 3: Likelihood to Postpone Care 20.0% n Postponed Care: 15.0% 1 year Percent Difference from Average 10.0% n Have PCP 5.0% 0.0% -5.0% -10.0% -15.0% -20.0% -25.0% -30.0% Over-55 Segments Under-55 Segments t en s s em er ck o ng pp s he ng tir er rl ivi ho Re C lo Bi av Gi ls eL So ly tS S g l n il th tfu yin ny Fr pl de le g on n es ut im en la ol o lyi .M .N .R .O .P .G .S .P .F 29 54 55 46 38 47 33 37 17 Source: Thomson Reuters PULSE™ Healthcare Survey, 2009 Messaging to Uninsured Greatest/Silent Generation – Get the Doctors on Board HEALTHCARE The Greatest/Silent Generation segment of the uninsured population, is more likely than their younger ATTITUDES counterparts to have a primary care physician (PCP). And despite being concerned about the cost of OF FOUR medical services, they are more likely to seek care. GENERATIONS7 In the Thomson Reuters PULSE™ Healthcare Survey, the age 55+ generations reveal strong physician Greatest/Silent Generation alignment and consider “Physician Referral” and “Physician Affiliation” as the most important drivers (born before 1942) in selecting a hospital for care. Correspondingly, strengthening physician relationships, rather than increasing direct-to-consumer outreach, may ultimately be more advantageous in influencing individuals’ Baby Boomers hospital selection process. Stronger physician relationships can foster paths of communication, with (born 1943–1960) the intent of shifting use of healthcare services to the appropriate settings and thereby improving care Generation X management. The behavior of the over-55 uninsured population is consistent across the segment and can (born 1961–1981) be messaged accordingly. Millennials (adults Messaging to Uninsured Baby Boomers and Gen Xers – Use Direct Mail or Phone Campaigns born since 1982) Crafting effective messaging for the under-55 populations is a more difficult task, even for those with significant health issues, including younger uninsured segments that are at risk for hypertension, depression, and diabetes. As the chart Likelihood to Postpone Care indicates, these individuals are less apt to have a PCP and therefore are unable to be directed by their physician to appropriate sites of care. Even within the under-55 uninsured population, the Baby Boomer and Gen Xer groups prove to be two distinct populations: • Those who would act on healthcare advertising, but do not often see it (These segments make up the majority of the uninsured population.) • Those who are aware of healthcare advertising, but would not act on it Caring for the Uninsured Amid Financial Pressures 5
  • 8. Focusing on the former, those who would act on healthcare advertising, helps marketers to connect with a willing and receptive population. The dilemma comes in deciding which media and messages are most important and effective. The goal in developing a strategy that best suits this audience is to identify the most appropriate media to reach them, avenues that will draw upon their penchant to respond positively to any form of healthcare advertising. The two strongest media formats for this population are standard direct mail and telemarketing. Of these two mediums, direct mail is usually the most cost-effective communication channel to connect with the uninsured, under-55 population. In order to impact site of service selection, the goal of these mailings should be to direct individuals to a primary care physician and encourage them to pursue necessary care. Another tactic that has been effective with this audience is to develop a health lecture on a topic relevant to their lives. Since many uninsured individuals in this segment struggle with chronic stress and anxiety, health lectures on these topics are likely to resonate. Directing this population could utilize a strategy such as: Table 3: Potential Outreach Strategy CALL TO ACTION MEDIA HOSPITAL GOAL Attend a health lecture Direct mail Help establish relationship with PCP Potential Topics: Anxiety, Depression, Phone number provided for follow-up Provide reason to see a PCP Stress Management questions Follow-up call after attending to make Identify critical health conditions that an appointment with a primary care require treatment and management physician (PCP) Source: Thomson Reuters crmView™ Marketing Solutions, 2010 Successful efforts require consistent messaging through preferred media channels to help achieve the goals of identifying the most appropriate site of service and disease management program. STRIVING FOR BALANCE: TACTICS FOR CONSIDERATION While everyone from Washington to your hometown critiques and debates the tactics for healthcare improvement, hospitals continue to face the critical onus of delivering uncompensated care.8 There is an immediate need to identify and achieve real solutions. Regardless of the system-wide healthcare changes that may be on the horizon, most individual hospitals and healthcare systems face faltering business models that are forcing reductions in services and staff. This research raises plausible considerations for achieving a balance between meeting the mission of serving the uninsured, benefitting the community, and also addressing healthcare budgetary constraints while delivering a significant return to the board and other key stakeholders. Simple solutions may not exist. However, by guiding and transferring care to more appropriate care settings, healthcare providers have an opportunity to address the cost of care, while concurrently increasing quality of care, patient throughput, efficiency, and ultimately reimbursable care. To chart the roadmap toward these achievements, consider the following tactics: MARKETING TACTICS Focus on Patients Who Drive the Costs A small number of patients usually drive the majority of costs. Target these patients at the right time with the right message. Then, measure the impact of your efforts through response rate analysis and reporting, and support continuous improvement based on your successes. Mine the Customer Information to Gain Key Insights Mining, modeling, and measurement are vital steps in understanding your current and anticipated patient populations. Organizations without the internal talent or tools to achieve a comprehensive analysis can consider partnering with healthcare-focused strategic intelligence and consulting firms and/or purchasing market intelligence tools. 6 Caring for the Uninsured Amid Financial Pressures
  • 9. Periodically Reevaluate Tactical Plans Oakwood Annapolis The tactics provided above are recommended as ongoing efforts, in lieu of one-time, evaluation processes. Hospital, part of the Though characteristics and utilization behaviors of patients continually change, patterns emerge and Oakwood Healthcare measurement will provide key insights in determining the effectiveness of the aforementioned tactics. System in Wayne, Michigan, receives These marketing tactics can help your organization gain a greater understanding of your audience, the over 70 percent of its admitted patients best way to reach them, and how their behavior changes over time. The frontline tactics below offer from the emergency additional suggestions for providers to consider. department (ED). The facility identified FRONTLINE TACTICS patterns of its ED “frequent fliers” through the use of Partner With Physicians for Continued Patient Education and Direction Thomson Reuters Ensure information is shared with patients on appropriate care settings. For example, emergency crmView™ Marketing department (ED) physicians may be able to share literature on other facility resources, including primary Solutions and physicians, urgent care locations, and clinics. employed direct mail to generate awareness within their Review Increased Collection Efforts (at the Time of Service) target audiences. Increased collection efforts may discourage the uninsured from seeking care at expensive sites of service when less expensive sites provide equally appropriate care. Yet it is important to study both the short-term They stressed the and longer-term effects of such an effort. While the target audience may seek care at your ED much less importance of seeing a frequently, a patient’s disease or condition may worsen, and require acute inpatient services.9 primary care physician for non-life threatening conditions and shared Examine Success Stories information regarding Identifying organizations that have successfully addressed the right care at the right site helps generate federally qualified care ideas on what to do and who to leverage for support. centers. Among their achievements, cost of care decreased by $35 CONCLUSION per ED visit; improper utilization declined by The challenges the medical community faces in meeting the needs of the uninsured while also remaining 72 percent; physician fiscally responsible to their own organizations are great. Although the landscape of healthcare politics referrals for patients remains in flux and is likely to continue so for the foreseeable future, healthcare organizations can take a to more appropriate health centers number of practical steps to alleviate some of their most vexing financial challenges while improving their increased by 12 percent; ability to care for the uninsured. and the ordering and prescribing of narcotics in the ED declined Table 4: HouseholdView® Segments by 10 percent. 10 SEGMENT NAME AGE MARITAL STATUS GENERATION 55. Restful Retirement 75+ Married/Married with Kids Greatest/Silent 54. Monthly Checks 75+ Married/Married with Kids Greatest/Silent 47. Golden Girl 65+ Single Female/Single Female with Kids Greatest/Silent 46. Playing Bingo 65+ Single Female/Single Female with Kids Greatest/Silent 38. Outlet Shoppers 55-64 Single Female/Single Female with Kids Boomers 37. Penny Savers 55-64 Single Female/Single Female with Kids Boomers 29. No Frills 45-54 Married with Kids Boomers 33. Simple Living 45-54 Married Boomers 17. Flying Solo 35-54 Single Female Gen X/Boomer Source: Thomson Reuters HouseholdView® Caring for the Uninsured Amid Financial Pressures 7
  • 10. APPENDIX HEALTHCARE ATTITUDES OF FOUR GENERATIONS7 THOMSON REUTERS PULSE HEALTHCARE SURVEY Thomson Reuters delivers unique insights into consumer healthcare behavior GREATEST/SILENT GENERATION (BORN BEFORE 1942): and attitudes with the proprietary PULSE™ Healthcare Survey – the largest Attitude toward gathering healthcare ongoing, privately funded telephone healthcare survey in the United States. information: Physician Directs Me Through the PULSE Healthcare Survey, Thomson Reuters has compiled • Rely on personal doctors, defer to more than 100,000 household interviews annually since 1988. The survey is physicians’ preferences conducted by telephone throughout the entire year to account for seasonality. • Rigid definitions of good service: Each year, Thomson Reuters clients help to determine the PULSE Healthcare the customer is always right Survey topics, ensuring the questions asked reflect the most important • Consider only physicians and nurses industry topics. The questions are both behavioral and attitudinal in nature as health professionals and are modeled to reflect the larger population. The PULSE Healthcare Survey is unique in that it ties results to two proven lifestyle segmentation BABY BOOMERS (BORN 1943–1960): Attitude toward gathering healthcare information: systems: PRIZM® by Nielsen and HouseholdView®, a Thomson Reuters Engage Me methodology. The use of lifestyle segmentation gives healthcare clients better • Prefer individual engagement in healthcare insights into who is using which services and where similar households are located within their markets. • Seek counsel from and bring information to the physician, and then research physician recommendations HOUSEHOLDVIEW • Consider only physicians and nurses as HouseholdView® is a dynamic, proprietary segmentation system for the health professionals next generation of healthcare consumer insights. The 56 segments paint a • Often involved in decision-making for their aging comprehensive picture of how healthcare consumers use health services, parents, while also informing the health needs of select providers, define quality, obtain healthcare information, and respond their own children to healthcare advertising. With a high level of sophistication for today’s complex healthcare market place, each of the customer segments within GENERATION X (BORN 1961–1981): Attitude toward gathering healthcare information: HouseholdView is a unique combination of the variables determined to be the Educate Me most predictive of consumer healthcare behavior. HouseholdView segments • Desire to be educated and involved align with the strategic planning and marketing challenges that face the healthcare industry today. • Relatively healthy compared to older generations • Curious and actively seek information THOMSON REUTERS OUTPATIENT PROCEDURE ESTIMATES • Assume physicians and staff are knowledgeable Thomson Reuters Outpatient Procedure Estimates predicts the total annual • Strong interest in amenities volume of ambulatory procedures performed by ZIP code, age group, sex, site • Likely to switch physicians and hospitals based on of service, and payer for every market in the United States. Procedures are recent experience defined and reported by 591 categories of CPT® and HCPCS codes, which are • More in common with the Millennial adults than with further grouped into clinical service lines as well as broad technical groups. the Boomers To construct population-based use rates for all payers and all ambulatory • Definition of health professionals is broad and care settings, Thomson Reuters uses proprietary and public claims, as well as includes nurse practitioners, physician assistants, Federal surveys. The rates are adjusted to reflect local utilization patterns and insurance companies, and pharmacies are then applied to demographic and insurance coverage projections by ZIP MILLENNIALS (ADULTS BORN SINCE 1982): code to estimate outpatient utilization for 2009 and 2014. Attitude toward gathering healthcare information: Connect with Me • Access healthcare system through primary care providers (PCP), urgent care centers, and Ob/Gyns with a higher likelihood to use Ob/Gyns as PCPs • Relatively low utilization of inpatient and outpatient services • When using inpatient services, most come through maternity and emergency departments • Enjoy and use technology • Maintain positive, personal relationship with physician • Seek health information from multiple sources • More likely to switch providers if confidence in care lost based on recent experience 8 Caring for the Uninsured Amid Financial Pressures
  • 11. REFERENCES 1 DeNavas-Walt, Carmen, Bernadette D. Proctor, Jessica C. Smith. Income, Poverty, and Health Insurance Coverage in the United States: 2008. 2 2009 Thomson Reuters, Insurance Coverage Estimates. 3 Abelson, Reed. Bills Stalled, Hospitals Fear Rising Unpaid Care, February 8, 2010. (http://www.nytimes.com/2010/02/09/health/policy/09hospital.html) 4 (http://www.ache.org/Pubs/Releases/2010/TopIssues_2010.pdf) Retrieved on March 2, 2010. 5 (http://www.cms.hhs.gov/MedicaidEligibility/) Retrieved on March 2, 2010. 6 For the purposes of the following analysis, Thomson Reuters is comparing and contrasting the behaviors of the below $50,000 and above $50,000 income households. The $50,000 line is close, but not exactly comparable to 300 percent of the Federal Poverty Line for a family of three in the contiguous 48 states. As such, we are using household income for approximating behavior of the uninsured population 300 percent FPL compared to the above $50,000 household population as an approximation for the insured segment. 7 Matching the Market: Using Generational Segments to Attract and Retain Consumers. Thomson Reuters, 2009. pgs. 2-3. 8 Guggenheim, Ricardo, MD. Uncompensated Care is a $31 Billion Problem Waiting to be Solved. HealthLeaders News. September 26, 2008. 9 Ibid, Guggenheim. 10 Patient Marketing Addresses E.D. Over-Utilization and Lowers Cost of Care. Thomson Reuters, 2009. Caring for the Uninsured Amid Financial Pressures 9
  • 12. aBOUt tHOMSON reUterS Thomson Reuters is the world’s leading source of intelligent information for businesses and professionals. We combine industry expertise with innovative technology to deliver critical information to leading decision makers in the financial, legal, tax and accounting, healthcare and science and media markets, powered by the world’s most trusted news organization. With headquarters in New York and major operations in London and Eagan, Minnesota, Thomson Reuters employs more than 50,000 people and operates in over 100 countries. Thomson Reuters shares are listed on the Toronto Stock Exchange (TSX: TRI) and New York Stock Exchange (NYSE: TRI). thomsonreuters.com Thomson Reuters 777 E. Eisenhower Parkway Ann Arbor, MI 48108 USA Phone +1 800 366 7526 ©2010 Thomson Reuters. All rights reserved. MDS-7808 05/10 MC