This document discusses structural perspectives on poverty from a sociological viewpoint. It outlines three major social factors that influence poverty: group memberships, neighborhood effects, and social networks. Group memberships like race, gender, and socioeconomic class affect life chances and access to opportunities. Neighborhood effects, such as quality of schools and safety, also impact outcomes. Social networks determine access to information, resources, and support. Together, these social structures shape an individual's susceptibility to poverty beyond individual factors alone.
2. Groups Matter
“Our social connections have significant economic consequences” (Royce,
2015, p. 173)
We are connected to groups via ascribed and achieved statuses
Ascribed: race, ethnicity, gender, etc.
Achieved: book clubs, recreational sports, church, professional associations, etc.
3. Three Major Social Factors
Group memberships
Neighborhood effects
Social networks
“While social location certainly matters, it determines who is susceptible to
poverty; it does not explain why there is poverty at all or why poverty exists
to the extent it does” (p. 193)
4. Group Memberships
Group affiliations “affect both who we are and how we live our lives” (p. 175)
Groups help to reflect our identities (who we are and our beliefs, values,
attitudes, etc.)
Groups help determine our life chances or our access to the means to better our
lives
The memberships theory explains that “peer group effects, adult role
models effects, and labor market connections” greatly affect individuals’
likelihood to live in poverty or experience inequality first-hand (p. 176)
5. Privileged Position
“Groups vary in the status and prestige,” with some groups afforded more
greater privilege than others (i.e., men compared to women, whites
compared to non-whites, rich compared to poor, education compared to
uneducated, etc.)
“As a result of normal psychological processes,” individuals are “inclined to
perceive people who look, talk, and live the way they do as more intelligent,
competent, and worthy than people who are different” (p. 177)
6. Neighborhood Effects
Neighborhood effects “refers to the influence of neighborhood conditions on life
outcomes” such as:
“Social and cognitive development, physical and mental health, school readiness and
performance, educational attainment, sexual behavior and fertility, family formation,
delinquency and crime, and for adults, employment and earnings” (p. 180).
Neighborhood differ mainly in terms of class and race
The highest-poverty neighborhoods are comprised of African-Americans and Latinos
Class differences produce drastic differences (e.g., South Bronx compared to affluent CT
suburbs)
“Because of neighborhood inequalities, poor families are often stuck with inferior
schools, inadequate public facilities, and an unhealthy and sometimes dangerous
residential environment” (p. 179)
7. Institutional Resources
Examples of these community resources: schools, libraries, recreational centers,
stores, hospitals, transportation services, etc.
The poor need these resources the most, yet have the least access to them
Functions of these key resources include:
Play a significant role during socialization
Provide safe place for childhood activities
Provide essential services
Lead to psychological, cultural, and human capital
Can create political awareness and solidarity
8. Labor Market Conditions
William Julius Wilson explained that in the 1970s and 1980s “structural
economic changes” hit poor urban communities especially hard. Examples:
Shift from good-producing to service-producing work
Increase gaps between low-wage and high-wage job sectors
Technological innovations
Relocation of manufacturing out of inner cities
9. Additional Factors Related to
Neighborhood Effects
Collective socialization
Community influences from adult neighbors, peer groups, role models, etc. who
provide negative norms and values – encouraging negative behaviors and
reinforcing poverty
Social disorganization
Related to “collective efficacy,” which is seen through neighbors’ experience of
frequent interaction, social ties, and shared norms (p. 182)
The poor experience weak informal social control and low levels of collective
efficacy
10. Social Networks & Social Capital
Social networks: patterns of “recurrent interpersonal relationships” (p. 183)
Social functions include:
Channel information and convey cultural messages
Create social connections
Define expectations for behavior and enforce social norms
Creates mutual trust and social support
Allows for use of power and influence
Networks create social capital: “benefits people derive from their personal
interactions and social relations” (p. 184)
People can have resource-rich connections or resource-poor networks
11. Key Social Network Characteristics
Research finds that people with weak social networks and limited social capital are
vulnerable to poverty and find it difficult to escape
The following characteristics make a difference:
Size of social networks (poor have few interpersonal connections)
Social isolation (limited access to high levels of social mobility)
Difficulty in mobilizing social networks (poor find it hard to make use of social connections)
Preponderance of strong ties (poor have great strong ties than productive weak ties)
Reliance on disposable ties (poor need to get by day-to-day)
Homogeneous social networks (the power of weak social ties are great if they are diverse,
which the poor have limited access to)
Lack of productive social capital (hard for the poor to turn their social capital into other
forms of capital)
Preponderance of social support ties (poor have access to social support, not social leverage)
Negative social capital (poor are more likely to be exposed to deviant norms and feel
pressure of social support and loyalty)