Presentation to Confab 2011 by Melissa Rach, Dialog Studios (formerly Brain Traffic) Let’s go beyond content deliverables and tactics and focus on the overall strategic process. In this session, we’ll discuss what strategy is, and what makes content strategy different from other strategic disciplines.
11. What I used to think
1. Bigwigs + strategists
2. Research + analysis
3. Objectives about mo
4. Grand master plan
5. Send plan to minions
6. Minions rejoice!
7. Success + $$$$$$$$
12. What I used to think
1. Bigwigs + strategists
2. Research + analysis
3. Objectives about
4. Grand master plan
5. Send plan to minions
6. Minions rejoice!
7. Success + $$$$$$$$
13. What I used to think
1. Bigwigs + strategists
2. Research + analysis
3. Objectives about money
4. Grand master plan
5. Send plan to minions
6. Minions rejoice!
7. Success + $$$$$$$$
14. What I used to think
1. Bigwigs + strategists
2. Research + analysis
3. Objectives about money
4. Grand master plan
5. Send plan to minions
6. Minions rejoice!
7. Success + $$$$$$$$
15. What I used to think
1. Bigwigs + strategists
2. Research + analysis
3. Objectives about money
4. Grand master plan
5. Send plan to minions
6. Minions rejoice!
7. Success + $$$$$$$$
16. What I used to think
1. Bigwigs + strategists
2. Research + analysis
3. Objectives about
money
4. Grand master plan
5. Send plan to minions
6. Minions rejoice!
7. Success + $$$$$$$$
17. What I used to think
1. Bigwigs + strategists
2. Research + analysis
3. Objectives about
money
4. Grand master plan
5. Send plan to minions
6. Minions rejoice!
7. Success + $$$$$$$$
24. Scientific management means a
constant search for the facts, the
true actualities, and their intelligent,
unprejudiced analysis. Thus, and in
no other way, policies and their
administration are determined…
Only by increased knowledge can
we progress, perhaps I had better
say survive.‖ (Sloan 1941)
25. “Practical men, who believe themselves to
be quite exempt from any intellectual
influences, are usually the slaves of some
defunct economist.”
-John Maynard Keynes (1936)
30. 60 years later
―Strategy‖ is necessary to survive
Profit is the #1 outcome of strategy
Classically-educated finance guys make the best
―generals‖
Constant research and measurement is required
– and must map to money (report progress
quarterly)
Work is done in functional silos
32. "Well, in our country," said Alice, still panting a little, "you'd generally
get to somewhere else — if you run very fast for a long time, as
we've been doing.―
"A slow sort of country!" said the Queen. "Now, here, you see, it
takes all the running you can do, to keep in the same place. If you
want to get somewhere else, you must run at least twice as fast as
that!―
- Lewis Carroll, Through the Looking-Glass
33. Adaptability is the key
Today’s sustainable strategies need to
have:
Flexible frameworks
Ongoing learning/education
Quick responses and reactions
Strategic routines vs. long-term
strategies
34. Knowledge is the advantage
Knowledge:
Gives you the ability to change quickly
Is valuable precisely because it’s not easily
captured
Is dispersed throughout the organization
Relies on innovation, which is not obviously
profitable
Requires constant learning and education
48. Think of strategy as a VERB
Everything you do, needs to do one of these
things:
Create clarity
Align stakeholders
Make smart decisions
Operationalize change
(Chris LaVictoire Mahai, Aveus)
49. Deliverables are tools, not outcomes
Education moments
Conversation starters
Records of past conversations
Memory aids
52. Make smart decisions
Give people the tools, knowledge, and
expert advice they need to:
To move confidently
Act independently
To move quickly
Make content decisions in their area of
expertise
55. We can be strategists AND engineers
Strategy sets the stage/direction
Engineering creates a solution based on
expertise
As content professionals we often do
both
And, both are extremely important
I’m going to guess every person in this room has a different definition of this wordDefining conceptual words like strategy, marketing, business isn’t like defining object words like book, projector, chairThese definitions are really theories – made up of our collective knowledge on the topicWhether that knowledge is from books, experience, or a mentor, whateverAnd theories are great because they create shortcuts in our brains, we don’t have to think something through every time But, the danger about them is that theory becomes indisputable fact in our heads
And, this worked so well for meIt’s neat and tidy – such a step-by-step process – with such a happy ending And quite honestly at the beginning of my career this worked super well – it was the beginning of the web Nobody knew what the web was supposed to do, they were kind of afraid of it, so they did what we, the 23-yr-old consultants said to do We didn’t always make the $, but it was new media, it didn’t have toSo to me, this definition was irrefutable fact, it’s the way it was always done, since the Greeks invented strategy in 2000BC
And, this worked so well for meIt’s neat and tidy – such a step-by-step process – with such a happy ending And quite honestly at the beginning of my career this worked super well – it was the beginning of the web Nobody knew what the web was supposed to do, they were kind of afraid of it, so they did what we, the 23-yr-old consultants said to do We didn’t always make the $, but it was new media, it didn’t have toSo to me, this definition was irrefutable fact, it’s the way it was always done, since the Greeks invented strategy in 2000BC
Make lovely plan reports with exciting graphics and fancy covers
And, this worked so well for meIt’s neat and tidy – such a step-by-step process – with such a happy ending And quite honestly at the beginning of my career this worked super well – it was the beginning of the web Nobody knew what the web was supposed to do, they were kind of afraid of it, so they did what we, the 23-yr-old consultants said to do We didn’t always make the $, but it was new media, it didn’t have toSo to me, this definition was irrefutable fact, it’s the way it was always done, since the Greeks invented strategy in 2000BC
Minions worship (or at least respect) plan
If the plan is smart enough, it succeeds wildly And, this worked so well for meIt’s neat and tidy – such a step-by-step process – with such a happy ending And quite honestly at the beginning of my career this worked super well – it was the beginning of the web Nobody knew what the web was supposed to do, they were kind of afraid of it, so they did what we, the 23-yr-old consultants said to do We didn’t always make the $, but it was new media, it didn’t have to
So to me, this definition was irrefutable fact, it’s the way it was always done, since the Greeks invented strategy in 1200BC
Then I became a marketing/communication strategist (not web, general) The bigwigs/smart people often knew less than the minionsResearch wasn’t always conclusiveThe plan wasn’t always very grand The report was irrelevant the minute it was published The minions responded with distaste/apathy The plans weren’t implemented It was hard to measure value of communicationsAnti-climactic Research: competition, users The plan: tactical, hard to measure, hard to equate to $But, I was doing great – the clients loved it! So I tried to research harder, make more detailed plans, make lovely communication strategies for the minionsStill didn’t feel right
Classical American Method (what about the Greeks?)It was: Developed in 1950sFor huge manufacturing giants (GM/Du Pont) By guys who had military school educations and rich parents There are dozens of other strategies, but this one dominates the text booksAnd, it played a huge part in the way business, particularly in the US, but around the world works – and how content strategy can play So, I want to take a few minutes to tell you about it
Right after WWII (the Allies “won”)There was a glut of resources Business was about making stuff Manufacturing was a good job Communication came from authorities Competition risesMarketing becomes commonRight after WWII (the Allies “won”)There was a glut of resources Business was about making stuff Manufacturing was a good job Communication came from authorities Competition risesMarketing becomes common
Alfred Sloan: Create a About long-term vision Based off the military Centered around classical economic theoryIncluding intense measurement requirements Introduced frequent earnings statements as proof of success Adam Smith 1776“Rational economic man” We can see consequences and plan accordingly We can forgo short-term gain for long-term successTheory of valueThings are transparentThings are exclusive Alfred (Du Pont) Chandler
Alfred Sloan: Create a About long-term vision Based off the military Centered around classical economic theoryIncluding intense measurement requirements Introduced frequent earnings statements as proof of success Alfred (Du Pont) Chandler
“Rational economic man” We can see consequences and plan accordingly We can forgo short-term gain for long-term successTheory of valueThings are transparentThings are exclusive We still have this stuff – even if we don’t know about it
Worked well for GM, because of the context and they were first At the same time: 1960s:Bandwagon gets full – the SWOT is born; middle class gets a more educated, challenges authority 1970s: Not just Americans, don’t know your competition anymore 1980s: Global economy gets even bigger, lots of mobility 1990s: More Communication channels are added Evolutionists
2000s: Hyper competition and hyGame theory Chaos theory Complexity theory Evolution theory Cognitive psychology Real options theory
This is, of course, a theory Even the military gets it Silos are set up to compete – separate strategies, objectivesIt’s not profitable and not very measurable The pyramid doesn’t work – people are moving They have long-term visions and roadmaps
This is, of course, a theory Even the military gets it Silos are set up to compete – separate strategies, objectivesIt’s not profitable and not very measurable The pyramid doesn’t work – people are moving They have long-term visions and roadmaps
1993This one is even better
Lisa WelchmanFinancial guyThreatened
3. Don’t have obvious, secret, superior knowledge We have to earn trust, every time We have to acknowledge knowledge We more often coach, not advise
4. Can’t define value conventionally Based on function not exact numbers Less about profit, more about competitive advantage
We can’t change the whole business world and economic systemWhether you’re a client or consultant
It’s not about deliverables It’s about helping them achieve their business goals
All this conversation about deliverables is for usI like to geek out and see how amazing the work this community If you are a client, stop asking for it
Sloan was right, you need to do research, within reason, too fast paced for crazy It is not your job to haul out all your fancy terms and talk over their heads, help the client feel confident about what their talking about Earn their trust by letting them help you learn about their business They know the business better than you do. Let them be part of the solution. There is a ton of theory and best practices behind good contentMake sure you’re the team knows the ones that are applicable to themHelp them use the vocabulary Help them develop realistic goals for content
Threatening? Marketing strategy, UX, website strategy -- we do a deep dive on an area they would have overlooked, not a complementsWhere is the dividing line? Case by case. Who cares.
This is not about creating THE SOLUTION We think of decisions as commitments to future action Decisions made in formal settings are usually not acted onThey are more about mobilizing support and creating momentum
This is not about creating THE SOLUTION We think of decisions as commitments to future action Decisions made in formal settings are usually not acted onThey are more about mobilizing support and creating momentum
It’s not enough to just show them the mountain, gear, and compass Content strategists can’t do a runner Start with small projectsTest it did it work? Earn trust, communicate often Prove to leadership Measure it somehow that makes sense… it might not be dollars Based on function not exact numbers Less about profit, more about competitive advantage They are smart, resourceful, successfulBut they don’t have:The right equipmentTime to plan Guides or spottersAnd, everybody’s watching
This is a statement about strategyBut, it’s also a statement about classical american method This isn’t going to change overnight, and maybe not during our careers…But, it’s got to start somewhere