1. Knowledge Access: The Role
of Scientific Attribution
Martin Fenner
Department of Hematology,
Hemostaseology, Oncology
and Stem Cell Transplantation
2. Proper assigning of credit for scholarly
work requires the ability to uniquely
identify specific contributors to research.
3. Proper assigning of credit for scientific
work requires the ability to uniquely
identify specific scientific contributions.
304
ea
twice a
post-treatmeD
thereh
beshared
Confidentialityan
publishingorsharingd
thisarticleprovidespractica
minimisingriskstopatientprivac
Consentforpublicationofappropriately
datashouldideallybesoughtfromparticipa
research
Directidentifierssuchaspatients’namesshouldbe
removedfromdatasets;datasetsthatcontainthreeormore
indirectidentifiers,suchasageorsex,shouldbereviewed
byanindependentresearcherorethicscommitteebefore
beingsubmittedforpublication
Citethisas:BMJ2010;340:c181
doi: 10.1136/bmj.c181
4. In order to create the scholarly record,
scientific contributions have to be
unambiguously assigned to specific
contributors.
5. Text
Systems that measure and evaluate scientific
contributions can and should be separate
from the databases that hold the scholarly
record.
7. Credit systems for scientific contributions
should be reevaluated on a regular basis.
8. In Summary …
?
Other
?
Other
Other ID
Researcher
Other ID
Researcher
Careful balance of costs and benefits. Regular reevaluation
Researcher
ORCID
Evaluation
Open Bibliography
researchers scientific contributions
Publication
CrossRef DOI
Data
DataCite DOI
01001001101010101011
10110010101010101010
10101010100101010100
10101010101010101010
10100000101111110101
01000101010100010010
01001001001010010010
00100100100100100100
10010100100111100100
?
Other
Evaluation EvaluationDiscovery
