"Subclassing and Composition – A Pythonic Tour of Trade-Offs", Hynek Schlawack
National Association of Healthcare Access Management Presentation
1. Diminishing the Impact of
Duplicate Records and Fraud for
Patient Safety & Quality of Care
Your Logo
2. Agenda
1 Patient Access Personnel: Key Team Member
2 Objectives of Patient Access Personnel
3 Goal: MPI Integrity Management
4 Causes of Poor MPI Integrity
5 How Big is the Problem
6 What is the Impact
✓ What are Solutions
7
8 Simplicity to Succeed
9 HIMSS Information, Articles & Resources
Nancy Farrington, CHAM
Based in part with NAHAM Special Projects, Policy
Development and Government Relations Committees
4. Objectives of Patient Access Personnel
Requirements & Solutions Requirements & Solutions
1 2
Accurately Identify every Practice techniques for
patient to their Medical Record reducing the creation of dups
for each visit or procedure as well as techniques to
across the system identify & resolve them
Continuing education of Review the adoption of
common causes, complexity industry Technology for the
and impact of duplicates & automation of patient identity
overlays on patient safety and and registration processes
cost containment
5. Goal: MPI Integrity Management
One Patient Identity
Authenticate Accurately authenticate
1
Patient’s Identity
patients identity for each
One Medical Record
visit or procedure and
2 Always Link Patient to
Correct Medical Record correctly link patient’s to
Technology their medical record
Explore technology to
3 help manage one
unique patient identity
across the Enterprise
for enterprise access
6. Causes of Poor MPI Integrity
Human Factors
Registration is challenging, staff turnover is high
1
Poorly defined, un-enforced standards
Emphasis on speed, throughput
Insufficient training on impacts
Historical Information System Limitations
2 Poor patient query tools, insufficient error reporting
Search results ambiguous, non-intuitive
Corrective measures difficult to perform
Other Factors
Past System/MPI Data conversions
3 Decentralized registration
Reference Labs, “temporary registrations”
7. How Big is the Problem?
Duplicates/Overlaps cost
Duplicates and Overlaps $100 or more Overlays: Catastrophic
1 2 3
Industry estimate 8% to Time & materials Risk of Clinical Error
12% of a hospital’s wasted by researching, Potential
records are duplicates identifying & correcting confidentiality
Rates may rise to 20% “on demand” (in breaches
or more for multiple downstream
systems) Cost of litigation
organizations that have
acquired or merged Duplicate testing
with other facilities Delays in billing & A/R
Your Organization? (72 hour rule)
8. What is the Impact
A Patient’s Perspective A Physician’s Perspective
Registration Delays 45% routinely found duplicate
Blood sample taken again for medical record numbers
repeat test 30% re-ordered tests due to
Medication changed after inability to find results in record
organism ID’d on 2nd test 25% felt duplicate records
Sick for additional 2 days— impacted the quality of care
missed work, lost wages they were able to deliver
Need to clarify billing with Lack of Confidence in your
insurance company organization
Dissatisfied Patient
9. Techniques to Resolve
Duplicate Records, Overlays and Fraud
Raise organizational awareness and propose solutions
Identify Process Create corrective action plans and execute procedures
Improvements for Identify common issues, document and educate
Targeted Areas Analyze all calls (to Help Desk, Call Center, etc.)
Utilize reports (Distribute auto and manual combine
reports to management and team on a regular basis)
Research with your IT Department for technology solutions
Consider Review Patient Identity Vendors using Biometrics* and/or
Utilizing Vendor Smart cards*
Products… Schedule webinar & follow up on-site demonstrations
Schedule site visits with vendor clients
10. Simplicity to Succeed
Using Procedures & Technoligy to Simplify Complicated Processes
Incorporate Implement,
Educate Procedures & Train and
Technology Measure
11. THANK YOU!
HIMSS Information, Articles and Resources in Following Slides.
This presentation is for educational purposes only.
Nancy Farrington, CHAM
Based in part with NAHAM Special Projects,
Policy Development and Government
Relations Committeesfarringtonn@mlhs.org
www.NAHAM.org
12. HIMSS
Patient Identity Integrity
PI Integrity is the accuracy and completeness of data
attached to or associated with an individual patient. Data must
be reliable, reproducible, and sufficiently extensive for matching
purposes.
Completeness refers not only to having adequate data
elements present but also the correct pairing or linking of all
existing records for that individual within and across
information systems. PI Integrity is of central importance to
achieving quality of care, patient safety, and cost control
2009 Healthcare Information and Management Systems Society (HIMSS)
13. HIMSS
Patient Identity Integrity
Because of its potential for impacting quality of care
and patient safety, patient identity management is a long
standing challenge in the health care organization,
provider office, or anywhere patient databases are
collected. The increasing penetration of technology into
the healthcare environment only exacerbates the problem.
http://www.himss.org/asp/topics_Piitoolkit.asp
14. Articles and Resources
http://www.justassociates.com/Practice-Briefs.html
(AHIMA practice briefs -focus on MPI)
http://www.azumc.com/body.cfm?id=872
(from University of AZ Medical Center – presented as method to
encourage wide reporting of duplicates)
http://health-information.advanceweb.com/editorial/content/editorial.aspx?CC=151146
http://www.himss.org/asp/topics_Piitoolkit.asp
http://www.smartcardalliance.org/pages/smart-cards-applications-healthcare
Information on Smart card industry within healthcare
www.lifemedid.com
Patient Identity, automated registration and Smart card vendor (White Papers, Support Materials)
Nancy Farrington, CHAM
Based in part with NAHAM Special Projects,
Policy Development and Government
Relations Committeesfarringtonn@mlhs.org
www.NAHAM.org
Notes de l'éditeur
It is time to review current policies and procedures and take appropriate steps to ensure patient safety
MPI = Master Patient Index
Patient Access is the frontline to help ensure patient safety and identity is accurate and to link all patients to their correct medical record upon admissions or check-in. We must provide bullet proof procedures and technology to safeguard and support frontline…Patient Access personnel success.
We need to avoid moving our paper record problems into the electronic world as we implement EMR. These processes are an ongoing management of knowledge and human resources. Automating processes helps to manage keystroke and interaction errors.
An accurate MPI, whether in paper, electronic or somewhere in between, may be considered the most important resource in a health care facility, according to AHIMA Practice Brief Maintenance of Master Patient Index (MPI). According to a poll in the Dec. 3, 2007 issue of ADVANCE when asked "Does your office or facility have a process in place to help prevent duplicate medical record numbers?" Half of the respondents either said no (17 percent) or they weren't sure (33 percent).
Process involves many touch points where errors may occurWorkload impact and down-stream effectsTime constraintsLimited patient identification information (wrong information starting from physicians)Negative economic conditions may result in patients accessing healthcare services by assuming another person’s identity (identity theft; uninsured) Errors may multiply because the wrong information is accessed repeatedly and new errors may be createdThe larger an institution’s database, potentially the higher the percentage of duplicates A growing database implies more human interaction and decision making, which may lead to more data errors and variationsFixing the problem requires changes to existing processes that may cross a multitude of departmentsUnwillingness and resistance to process change or inability to change processesDelayed discovery of problem – sometimes involving accounts with multiple transactions in the interim, all of which must be investigated and resolved
Studies done by Just Associates and Quadramed (2 companies specializing in Master Person Index Integrity)Overall (2001-2008)Average MPI size - 708,499Highest Dupe Rate Single Facility- 57.7% Highest Dupe Rate Overlap - 73.4%Lowest Dupe Rate - 0.1%
Information from: survey conducted in preparation for Electronic Medical Record (EMR) by an individual Hospital
The longer an error exists, the worse it can get. Dups – bouncing ball… lab uses one record, radiology uses another – repeatedly – then patient admitted…Overlays – if not caught and corrected on a timely basis more and more clinical information will be commingledThis process is more commonly used when there is an overlay than a duplicate or a overlap; the risk with those is so grate that they need rapid resolution!*Patient Identity Smart cards and Biometric solutions are proven to help accurately identify each patient for each visit, automate the registration process and diminishes duplicate records, record overlays and patient fraud.Smart Cards Benefits:Proven sustainable model, small investment and a prompt ROI Limited IT requirements (about 20-30 hours per HL7)One Identity Card correctly connects patient to all their Medical Record Number’s Identity Card automatically evokes the correct medical record using current registration software (no key strokes)Streamline Registration and Insurance Verification Process (Patient Satisfaction)Diminish multiple identities, duplicate records and identity fraudAccurate billing and claims processing reducing days outstanding of Accounts ReceivableOptional: Real-time payment of co-pay, deductible with debit, HAS or VisaLinks multiple and disparate providers MRN’s to one verifiable IdentityBranded Identity for Patient Loyalty and Community EngagementBiometrics BenefitsFinger or Palm Vein correctly identities Patient within the providers locations and those aligned with the same database and Biometric solutionPatient record access with applying palm to a readerHarmless near-infrared lightPatients will always have them, no risk of leaving at home
Educate staff, incorporate procedures & technology to simplify and help ensure standards are in place to reduce the risk of errors and implement a plan to provide continuing education, review new technology and measure ongoing results throughout all departments
Disclaimer:These are offeredresources only and may be used as a starting point of research, reference and industry materials. It is strongly suggested to research all possibilities available prior to determining a solution.
Reference
Reference
Disclaimer:These are offeredresources only and may be used as a starting point of research, reference and industry materials. It is strongly suggested to research all possibilities available prior to determining a solution.