1. 1#BLACK PEAR ENGINEERING & MINGALAR ONLINE http://blackpearlengineering.com/power
Present Myanmar reform is same as 1990 China reform. Insufficient electridity is big issue. ံ
1. Government Policy
To install electrc power plant urgently
2. Job opportunites, Government & Congress action
3. Short Term (Private), Long Term (Government, FID, BOT)
4. Short Term (5 years Plan), selling 1unit k150 (15 cents)
- Law to write and approve
(Mutual Interest of Private Firm & Gov EPC)
- First 5 years, EPC, IPP small & median power plants
about 1200 station (~6000 mW)
- Present capacity 3142 mW / under-construction 1431 mW
5. Facts & Data
Appendix I eia.org Energy Information Administration (USA)
Appendix II American Generator (Dieseal Generators)
Appendix II Market Price List (Electricity Price, Power Plant cost ..etc)
Appendix IV Reference documents
Appendix V Myanmar Power Grid (Plants Network)
2
3 4
6-10
11
12-16
12
13
14
15
16
2. 2#BLACK PEAR ENGINEERING & MINGALAR ONLINE http://blackpearlengineering.com/power
Accenture's Energy – Industrial group, senior director Arthur Hanna read a paper
World Economic Forum in Yangon, 2013.
• Myanmar electricity production will be two time increased in two years by Myanmar government.
• Two times in two years is no match for Myanmar industry demand. As per his forcus, 12 times.
• Myanmar Energy Ministry, ADB Asia Development Bank and Accenture's Energy (3 parties) jointly
written a paper and Mr. Arthur Hanna was talked at forum. News: Popular Journal , June 6, 2013
USA government eia.gov information Appendex I
• Myanmar is lowest usage and production of Electricity in South East Asia.
• Government price and private selling price are 30 times differ. It is not a good sign. To reduce the
price gap, private (SME) electricity plants badly need. Government must do a “short term” plan.
LAW – Present Myanmar Electric Law
• Large scale investment on electric power generation is by Foreign Investment with a contract.
• Small scale <10mW plants , reginal government must do independently. (but no doing – reason)
• EPC law, Power Grip issue, Power distribution loss ..etc
• Foreign Investors trust is on Central Government (not local government)
• Power Plants to use 20% natural gas which are mostly sold to China & Thailand. (Present Biogass
plant and all future small scale SME power plant to get UNIDO Partnership)
B&M
3. 3#BLACK PEAR ENGINEERING & MINGALAR ONLINE http://blackpearlengineering.com/power
Electricity is expensive for Myanmar. Everybody need job with income to use
electricity. (eg – Malaysia)
SME Small & Median Enterprise owners
- Job
- Eat, Live and clothing (basic need)
- Electricity
- Water ..etc
- Health
- Education
Government Level
- Law and Transquality
- Foreign Investment FDI
- SME survival
- Internal Investment
- State Owned Enterprices
- Tax (law and action)
- Tax usage (budget)
Tax income – American is 40% of GDP, Thailand 17%, Singapore 30% and Myanmar 3%.
Myanmar is the least tax income (ref: CIA facts). Myanmar president said, looking for
income by selling resources with FDI, Joint Venture, BOT. Real job opportunity is from
Industry. Especially, Process Industry (Food Processing) can create many jobs. Therefore,
Industry can give more job opportunity and Profits also great. Process Industry need
energy, electricity…
No electricity, egg procution to blankets, computer to car production factory..etc.can not
compete foreign products.
B&M
4. 4#BLACK PEAR ENGINEERING & MINGALAR ONLINE http://blackpearlengineering.com/power
Present Myanmar Electricity production and usage
(Pyithu Hlut.Taw announce book)
2012 electricity use is Kw hour million 13378.3.
Production is mega watt 4006 (38% effencicy)
Transmission loss is huge (37% - orld averge is 3-5% only) by defect of line & thief.
Electric Power Plants
•Hydro Power, Combine Gas Turbine, Coal power boiler ..etc. Technical methods. Now solar energy
Us$250 million plant is copied from rich countries such as EU & American countries which are
following the Green Energy such as solar, win turbine, nuclear ..etc. Philipine, Indonesia use
Biomass, Ground heat and recycle materials..etc.
Private Electricity Production
• Firstly, draft a law.
Before law was approved, big companies’ project can start with MOU (eg. BOT agreement). Those
agreements are negotiate with Myanmar Government and Investors. Must be fare contract document.
Some leased agreement are one sided example, Hong Kong , Makao 99 years lease.
• Village & Subarb – small scale electricity production and selling must use this law which gurantee
the investment work even though, change the new local government. Need “law domination”
• EPC and government bodies , departments need to co-ordinate by 3rd Party institutes.
• SHORT TERM (Private small power station to generate by fuel oil import permit)
• LONG TERM (government hydro plant, natural gas plants ..etc)
B&M
5. 5#BLACK PEAR ENGINEERING & MINGALAR ONLINE http://blackpearlengineering.com/power
SHORT TERM
Private small & median plant to generate by fuel oil
• Lighting: Solar Energy power plants to import from China (quality to control)
• Biogas , Rice husk, wood or bambo electric power plants. (small & median plants)
• Coal & Natural gas power plants . 1 to 10mW
• Diesel oil power plant.
• Import electricity from Thailand , China with reasonable price.
Make use of Private Investment abality
• Minimise the corruption, Every township, respectable person to lead the electricity production
committee, Include the intellectual people, Prevent small company by manipulation (merger by large
company or prevent from lossing money.
• Central government to issue IPP which apply to reginal government.
LONG TERM
• Central government to draft electricity IPP law (copy from Singapore)
• 100% investment by foreign company (joint venture with local company to avoid because that will
caused high price of electricity in long term. (Example Philipine, Australia ..etc)
• To copy the practise from cheap electricity price (example vietnam, china) ္
• Conbined gas turbine (to use own gas), Dam at rivers
• Power Grid, Transmittion line update, EPC Management level officers
B&M
6. 6#BLACK PEAR ENGINEERING & MINGALAR ONLINE http://blackpearlengineering.com/power
SHORT TERM (Priority)
Private Small & Media Power Plant to generate power by imported fuel oil
Cities Power Distribution
• Industrial Zones: owner of industry and electricity generation companies must agree the best price
to negotiate and decide.
• Electric Power - Certified Accountants to audit (prevent corruption) and gurenttee for profits for
electricity companies.
• Diesel & Natural Gas to provide to electricity companies.
• Issue with government bodies (departmental authorities), Corruption to minimise
• Ease law to import 2nd hand, reconditioned power plants(1mW to 10mW)
• Loan opportunity from organization such as UNIDO. Must be justice and free loan partnership.
Electricity to Villeges and small towns
• House & Road Lighting
• Small industry
• Farmers’ agriculture base small & median industries
B&M
7. 7#BLACK PEAR ENGINEERING & MINGALAR ONLINE http://blackpearlengineering.com/power
ေရတို (ဦးစားေပးျခင္း)
ပုဂၢလိက အေသးစား၊အလတ္စားစက္ရံုမ်ား၊ ဆီတင္သြင္းျဖင့္ဓါတ္အားထုတ္ရန္
TECHNICAL PRESENTATION
• Data collection (Power Generation, Usage of Grid, Transmittion line
• Private Power usages
Small Power Plants
• US$1.00 million investment for 1mW power generation
• Distriution line to use own (no connection to EPC Grid) to discuss
• Priority is for agri and fishery industry
- Rice mill, Oil mill
- Ice mill, Fish Processing, Food Processing factory
Median Power Plants
• US$1.00 to US10.00 million investment
• Distribution line to use own (no connection to EPC Grid), to discuss
Technical
Presentation
(I)
I
II
III
IV
TechnicalPresentation
B&M
8. 8#BLACK PEAR ENGINEERING & MINGALAR ONLINE http://blackpearlengineering.com/power
Technical
Presentation
(II)
SHORT TERM (Priority)
TECHNICAL PRESENTATION
Preparation (Investment cost)
Power Plant Cost Report nrel-cost-report.pdf
http://mingalaronline.biz/mdg/4.electrical/nrel-cost-report.pdf
Material cost
Operation cost
Investment loan (interest and re-payment for 40yrs
Inflation
skill
B&M
I
II
III
IV
TechnicalPresentation
9. 9#BLACK PEAR ENGINEERING & MINGALAR ONLINE http://blackpearlengineering.com/power
Technical
Presentation
(III)
SHORT TERM (Priority)
TECHNICAL PRESENTATION
Installation & Production expenses
Labor & skill level (Not a skill industry for SME Power generation)
Planing
3 months sourcing (or) tool selection
2 months installaion
1 month – commissioning & testing
B&M
I
II
III
IV
TechnicalPresentation
10. 10#BLACK PEAR ENGINEERING & MINGALAR ONLINE http://blackpearlengineering.com/power
Technical
Presentation
(IV)
SHORT TERM (Priority)
TECHNICAL PRESENTATION
Plan tof 5 years to generate and sell electricity
(Balance Sheet to include , 5 years plan)
After 5 years, government & big power company can sell cheaper price
Our SME electricity generation price is estimated ~US$15cents
(see regional electricity price at Appendex I)
B&M
I
II
III
IV
TechnicalPresentation
11. 11#BLACK PEAR ENGINEERING & MINGALAR ONLINE http://blackpearlengineering.com/power
Technical
Presentation (V)
B&M
I
II
III
IV
TechnicalPresentation
Coal Power, Boiler power plant Combine Gas Turbine power plant
Gas Turbine power plant
Hydro Power Plant
12. 12#BLACK PEAR ENGINEERING & MINGALAR ONLINE http://blackpearlengineering.com/power
Conclusion
Fianl Suggestion
Proposal
1. TECHNICAL PRESENTATION
Power distribution and billing plan
(remote control , metering to prevent power thief & quality assurance)
1 meter cost $20 , control station server cost $5000 estimated)
Safety
Environment
B&M
Trend of IPP quantity and generation power (3mW per unit. After 2017 (5 years), small
power plant will be phase out. ,Estimated SOE (EPC) .. Restructured as China or Vietnam
13. 13#BLACK PEAR ENGINEERING & MINGALAR ONLINE http://blackpearlengineering.com/power
Notes
• South East Asia countries? Thailand, China to
keep as role model for electricity production
and distribution
• In 1990 period, China, Indonesia, Philipine
were short of electricity (same as present
Myanmar). These countries use IPP
Independent Power Producer by western
investment. Need to study and learn.
• Learn from Philippine which is now 1 unit 30
cents and very expensive. Indonesia
government to subsidise the fuel oil & gas to
prevent the price high.
• China, Vietnam – how they control the
electricity price?
• China, Vietnam privatizing to state own power
industries is a role model.
• (System - IPP Law) It is very good system but leakage will be exist. Therefore, government personels are critical.
• World poorest and most corrupted country Myanmar, need electricity ministry official family, should not involve in
business. Provide them their basic needs. Draft a bill of electricity committee like an engineering bill, to include
government staffs, public, social people, intellectuals, econommic acadmic and businessmen ..etc.
Appendix I
B&M
15. 15#BLACK PEAR ENGINEERING & MINGALAR ONLINE http://blackpearlengineering.com/power
2012 estimated
Myanmar energy use
1. Natural Gas 3.29 billion Cu M
2. Petroleum Products
109850 bbl per day
3. Electricity 13378 million Kwh per year
4. Others eg. Ricehusk Biogas (no data)
Electricity Price 2013
(US$ cent per Kwh)
Myanmar 3-80
China 7-11
India 8-12
Thailand 4-10
Vietnam 6-10
Malaysia 6-11
Singapore 21
Philippine 40
USA 8-17
Japan 20-24
Australia 30
Patro Price 2013
(Us$ per 1litter)
Myanmar $1.10
China $1.10
India $1.33
Thailand $1.00
Vietnam $1.03
Singapore $1.60
Malaysia $0.62
USA $0.96
Price 2013 (eia.gov)
Crude Oil 1bbl = US$95
Gas 1 mmBtu = US$3.58
Gas Price 2013
(US$ per mmBtu)
USA $3.58
UK ~$8.0
ဲJapan ~$14.0
Myanmar ??
Price 2013 (eia.gov)
Crude Oil 1bbl = US$95
Gas 1 mmBtu = US$3.58
Gas Price 2013
(US$ per mmBtu)
USA $3.58
UK ~$8.0
Japan ~$14.0
Myanmar ??
Unit Conversion
1 gallon = 3.78 litter
Diesel 1 ton (MT) = 312 gal
(7.3 bbl)
Gas 1 mmBtu = 28.26 cu M
1 cu M = 35 cu ft
Market Price, Production cost..etc
Appendix III
B&M
16. 16#BLACK PEAR ENGINEERING & MINGALAR ONLINE http://blackpearlengineering.com/power
Myanmar Energy (Slides) by AUNG KYAW HTOO
http://www.slideshare.net/yph1969/myanmar-petroleum-energy
Power Plant Cost Report nrel-cost-report.pdf
http://mingalaronline.biz/mdg/4.electrical/nrel-cost-report.pdf
USA government energy info
eia.gov (Q&A)
Combined Circle Power
Plant
http://www.ccj-online.com
References
Power-Generation-Oil-Gas
-Industies.pdf
Zaw Aung & Aye Nyein
Myanmar Safety (Singapore)
http://myanmarsafety.wordpress.com/
IPP (South East Asia - research papers)
To download
1. Independent Power Producer (IPP)
debacle in Indonesia & Philippine
(Author - Professors from NUS National
University of Singapore)
PDF File: 87KB
Singapore IPP Law
2. Vietnam reform and IPP (by Lovells)
PDF file 1.2MB
Appendix IV
B&M
17. 17#BLACK PEAR ENGINEERING & MINGALAR ONLINE http://blackpearlengineering.com/power
B&M
Appendix V
Power Map
902mW
ရန္ကုန္
50mW
ေက်ာက္ျဖဴ
315mW
တာပိန္၊ေရႊက်င္
400mW
ေပါင္းေလာင္း၊
ေသာက္ေရခပ္၊ကြ်န္းေခ်ာင္း
52mW
ဘီလူးေခ်ာင္း
Present 3142 mW
Planning 1431 mW
Total 4573 mW
Present Plan
Hydro 2244 529
Coal power 285
Gas 550 902
Diesel 63
Total 4573 1431
18. End of English Language Slides
Continue Burmese/Myanmar Language Slides
19. BLACK PEAR ENGINEERING & MINGALAR ONLINE http://blackpearlengineering.com/power
ျမန္မာႏိုင္ငံ ပါ၀င္သည္ 1990 တရုပ္ျပည္ျပဳျပင္ေျပာင္းလဲမႈအေျခအေနအတိုင္း လွ်ပ္စစ္မလံုေလာက္မႈ
ၾကီးစြာၾကံဳေတြ႔ေနရသည္။
၁။ အစိုးရေပၚလစီ
ဓါတ္အားေပးစက္ရံုမ်ားအျမန္ဆံုးေဆာက္ျခင္း
၂။ အလုပ္ကိုင္အေျခအေနႏွင့္လႊတ္ေတာ္လုပ္ငန္းစဥ္မ်ား
၃။ ေရတို (ပုဂၢလိက) ေရရွည္ (အစိုးရ၊ FDI, BOT)
၄။ က်ႏိုပ္တို႔၏ ေရတို (၅ႏွစ္စီမံကိန္း) တယူနစ္၁၅၀က်ပ္ေရာင္းခ်ေရး
- ဥပေဒကို အီးပီစီ EPC ႏွင့္အတူ၊ ၂ဦးအက်ိဳးတူေရးဆြဲရန္
- ၅ႏွစ္တြင္ IPP small & media power plants 1200 (6000 mW) ရမည္။
လက္ရွိ 3142 mW/construction 1431mW
၅။ အခ်က္အလက္မ်ား
Appendex I eia.org Energy Information Administration
Appendex II American Generator (Dieseal Generators)
Appendex II Market Price List (Electricity Price, Power Plant cost ..etc)
Appendex IV Reference documents
Appendex V Myanmar Power Grid (Plants Network)
2
3 4
6-10
11
12-16
12
13
14
15
16
25. BLACK PEAR ENGINEERING & MINGALAR ONLINE http://blackpearlengineering.com/power
ေရတို (ဦးစားေပးျခင္း)
ပုဂၢလိက အေသးစား၊အလတ္စားစက္ရံုမ်ား၊ ဆီတင္သြင္းျဖင့္ဓါတ္အားထုတ္ရန္
TECHNICAL PRESENTATION
• Data collection (Power Generation, Usage of Grid, Transmittion line
• Private Power usages
Small Power Plants
• US$1.00 million investment for 1mW power generation
• Distriution line to use own (no connection to EPC Grid) to discuss
• Priority is for agri and fishery industry
- Rice mill, Oil mill
- Ice mill, Fish Processing, Food Processing factory
Median Power Plants
• US$1.00 to US10.00 million investment
• Distribution line to use own (no connection to EPC Grid), to discuss
Technical
Presentation
(I)
I
II
III
IV
TechnicalPresentation
B&M
26. BLACK PEAR ENGINEERING & MINGALAR ONLINE http://blackpearlengineering.com/power
Technical
Presentation
(II)
ေရတို (ဦးစားေပးျခင္း)
TECHNICAL PRESENTATION
Preparation (Investment cost)
Power Plant Cost Report nrel-cost-report.pdf
http://mingalaronline.biz/mdg/4.electrical/nrel-cost-report.pdf
Material cost
Operation cost
Investment loan (interest and re-payment for 40yrs
Inflation
skill
B&M
I
II
III
IV
TechnicalPresentation
27. BLACK PEAR ENGINEERING & MINGALAR ONLINE http://blackpearlengineering.com/power
Technical
Presentation
(III)
ေရတို (ဦးစားေပးျခင္း)
TECHNICAL PRESENTATION
Installation & Production expenses
Labor & skill level (Not a skill industry for SME Power generation)
B&M
I
II
III
IV
TechnicalPresentation
28. BLACK PEAR ENGINEERING & MINGALAR ONLINE http://blackpearlengineering.com/power
Technical
Presentation
(IV)
ေရတို (ဦးစားေပးျခင္း)
TECHNICAL PRESENTATION
Plan tof 5 years to generate and sell electricity
(Balance Sheet to include , 5 years plan)
After 5 years, government & big power company can sell cheaper price
Our SME electricity generation price is estimated ~US$15cents
(see regional electricity price at Appendex I)
B&M
I
II
III
IV
TechnicalPresentation
29. BLACK PEAR ENGINEERING & MINGALAR ONLINE http://blackpearlengineering.com/power
Conclusion
နိဂံုး (အဆိုျပဳခ်က္)
Proposal
1. TECHNICAL PRESENTATION
Power distribution and billing plan
(remote control , metering to prevent power thief & quality assurance)
1 meter cost $20 , control station server cost $5000 estimated)
Safety
Environment
B&M
Trend of IPP quantity and generation power (3mW per unit. After 2017 (5 years), small
power plant will be phase out. ,Estimated SOE (EPC) .. Restructured as China or Vietnam
31. BLACK PEAR ENGINEERING & MINGALAR ONLINE http://blackpearlengineering.com/power
Diseal Generators
Appendex II
B&M
32. BLACK PEAR ENGINEERING & MINGALAR ONLINE http://blackpearlengineering.com/power
2012 estimated
Myanmar energy use
1. Natural Gas 3.29 billion Cu M
2. Petroleum Products
109850 bbl per day
3. Electricity 13378 million Kwh per year
4. Others eg. Ricehusk Biogas (no data)
Electricity Price 2013
(US$ cent per Kwh)
Myanmar 3-80
China 7-11
India 8-12
Thailand 4-10
Vietnam 6-10
Malaysia 6-11
Singapore 21
Philippine 40
USA 8-17
Japan 20-24
Australia 30
Patro Price 2013
(Us$ per 1litter)
Myanmar $1.10
China $1.10
India $1.33
Thailand $1.00
Vietnam $1.03
Singapore $1.60
Malaysia $0.62
USA $0.96
Price 2013 (eia.gov)
Crude Oil 1bbl = US$95
Gas 1 mmBtu = US$3.58
Gas Price 2013
(US$ per mmBtu)
USA $3.58
UK ~$8.0
ဲJapan ~$14.0
Myanmar ??
Price 2013 (eia.gov)
Crude Oil 1bbl = US$95
Gas 1 mmBtu = US$3.58
Gas Price 2013
(US$ per mmBtu)
USA $3.58
UK ~$8.0
Japan ~$14.0
Myanmar ??
Unit Conversion
1 gallon = 3.78 litter
Diesel 1 ton (MT) = 312 gal
(7.3 bbl)
Gas 1 mmBtu = 28.26 cu M
1 cu M = 35 cu ft
Market Price, Production cost..etc
Appendex III
B&M
33. BLACK PEAR ENGINEERING & MINGALAR ONLINE http://blackpearlengineering.com/power
Myanmar Energy (Slides) by AUNG KYAW HTOO
http://www.slideshare.net/yph1969/myanmar-petroleum-energy
Power Plant Cost Report nrel-cost-report.pdf
http://mingalaronline.biz/mdg/4.electrical/nrel-cost-report.pdf
USA government energy info
eia.gov (Q&A)
Combined Circle Power
Plant
http://www.ccj-online.com
References
Power-Generation-Oil-Gas
-Industies.pdf
Zaw Aung & Aye Nyein
Myanmar Safety (Singapore)
http://myanmarsafety.wordpress.com/
IPP (South East Asia - research papers)
To download
1. Independent Power Producer (IPP)
debacle in Indonesia & Philippine
(Author - Professors from NUS National
University of Singapore)
PDF File: 87KB
Singapore IPP Law
2. Vietnam reform and IPP (by Lovells)
PDF file 1.2MB
Appendex IV
B&M