SlideShare une entreprise Scribd logo
1  sur  14
Evidence Against the
Simulation Hypothesis
© Peter Morgan Oct 2017 1
Peter Morgan
What Is the Simulation Hypothesis?
 The Simulation Hypothesis (SH) is the speculation that the observable
universe is a simulation created by a superior being, much in the same
way that we currently produce realistic 3D video games or environments
 It is not a new theory - it recently gained attention by Elon Musk saying
on National TV that he’s pretty sure we are living in a simulation [1]
 Essentially we can assign a probability of the SH being correct between 0
and 1. 0 means that the universe is absolutely certainly not a simulation,
and 1 means that the universe is a simulation with 100% certainty
 So 0 < P[SH is true] < 1
 Different people assign different values to the simulation hypothesis
being true [2]
© Peter Morgan Oct 2017 2
Arguments For & Against
 People who believe that the SH may be true argue that it is likely
because, just as we create video games, so we can extrapolate to a time
in the future whereby, with enough compute power, we could simulate
our entire universe
 To disprove the SH we (scientists) have to show why this cannot happen
 The laws of physics, including computation and energy conservation, are a
good place to start [3], [4]
 We will need to understand what computation and information processing
entail
© Peter Morgan Oct 2017 3
The Scientific Method – Appeal to Reason
 It’s easy to say something is possible, harder to do the physics (aka anybody
can say anything, but this certainly does not make it true)
 Note on the scientific method – a hypothesis is as powerful as the testable
predictions that it makes
 You can never prove a theory right, only disprove it
 What we can do, however, is to show that something is so unlikely that it is
effectively impossible, and that other theories are therefore, much more
likely to be correct
 For example, the big bang theory of creation is currently much more likely to
be the correct theory of creation than the simulation hypothesis
© Peter Morgan Oct 2017 4
What is Needed Computationally
 To disprove the SH, we need to show that it is physically impossible (or
exceedingly unlikely) to create a universe such as ours by
computational means
 What would it take to recreate our universe down to the scale
(granularity) currently measured by particle accelerators, or smaller?
d < 10TeV ~ 10^-19m
 And up to the large scale structure of our universe (approx. 46 billion
light-years, or 5 x 10^23km)
 Not to mention the creation of sentient beings (us) who can think
intelligently about such a hypothesis.
© Peter Morgan Oct 2017 5
Computation in the Biosphere
 There are approximately 10^80 atoms in the universe. Many of these are arranged
into very complex organic systems, or living organisms. These include humans,
animals, plants, fungi, bacteria and viruses
 We can estimate how many of these atoms are involved in living organisms. And
then calculate the processing power required to simulate all life in our biosphere
 In humans, there are approximately 10 trillion cells. Multiply this by the number of
humans on Earth (10 billion, order of magnitude)
 There are approximately 10 million species in all five classes of life [5]
 Estimate that on average there are 10 billion cells in each of these species (I have
taken 0.1% of the number of cells in a human)
 We then have 10^13 x 10^10 x 10^7 x 10^10 = 10^40 cells total for all the life on
Earth (in the biosphere)
 Another way at getting at this is by estimating the number of atoms in an average
adult human which is around 10^28 [6], but here we will follow the cellular
approach.
© Peter Morgan Oct 2017 6
Computation in the Biosphere
 How much compute power (TFlops, memory) is needed to simulate the 10^40
cells involved in life on Earth? We can get an idea by estimating the total DNA in
the Earth’s biosphere. From [7]:
 "Finding the amount of DNA in the biosphere enables an estimate of the
computational speed of the biosphere, in terms of the number of bases
transcribed per second, or Nucleotide Operations Per Second (NOPS), analogous
to the Floating-point Operations Per Second (FLOPS) metric used in electronic
computing
 If all the DNA in the biosphere was being transcribed at these reported rates,
taking an estimated transcription rate of 30 bases per second, then the
potential computational power of the biosphere would be approximately 10^24
PetaNOPS
 This is about 10^22 times more processing power than the Tianhe-2
supercomputer [8], which has a processing power on the order of 100
PetaFLOPS."
© Peter Morgan Oct 2017 7
Computation in the Biosphere
© Peter Morgan Oct 2017 8
Figure 1 – DNA Computation Equivalence
Space and Power Requirements
 How much space would 10^22 Tianhe-2's take up? Let's say that a Tianhe-2
supercomputer takes up an area of 100m^2
 We would then need 10^24m^2 of space
 The surface area of the Earth is 5 x 10^14m^2, so we would need the
surface area of 10 billion Earths just to calculate the DNA computations on
Earth given the current state of HPC
 How much power would we need? Let's say that Tianhe-2 uses 25MWh. We
would then need 10^22 x 2.5 x 10^7 MWh = 2.5 x 10^17 TWh of power
 The current electricity generation capacity of Earth is around 2.5 x 10^16
TWh [9], so we would need 10X the entire Earths' electricity generation
capacity given current HPC energy performance
© Peter Morgan Oct 2017 9
Life on Other Planets
 The above calculations are just for life here on Earth. What if there is life
elsewhere in the universe, which recent Exoplanet observations indicate the
potential for?
 Let's say there are 1 billion planets with life in the Milky Way and that, on
average, they contain a similar amount of life in their biospheres as Earth
 We need to multiply 10^40 by 10^9 x 10^11 (there are 100 billion galaxies in
the observable universe) to give us a figure of 10^60 cells in the universe
 This is 10^20 times more computation than was needed in the calculations
for life on Earth alone
 It is hard for us to imagine another universe existing with the computational
resources (hardware, energy) required to make such an elaborate simulation
of this universe
© Peter Morgan Oct 2017 10
High Energy Cosmic Rays
 Paper by physicists at the University of Washington examining the limits to the
SH [10]
 Observable consequences of the hypothesis that the observed universe is a
numerical simulation performed on a cubic space-time lattice or grid are
explored
 Assumption: simulations of the future employ an underlying cubic lattice
structure
 Are there any signatures of a simulated universe that might be experimentally
detectable?
 One proposed signature is in the anisotropy of high energy cosmic rays (Note –
the GZK limit is the theoretical upper limit on the energy of cosmic rays)
© Peter Morgan Oct 2017 11
Conclusions
 The above calculations are just for DNA replications of all
organisms. There are other processes and interactions occurring
here on Earth and in the universe, that would require further
orders of magnitude more computational resource
 No evidence whatsoever from experimental probes so far
 In conclusion, the SH is extremely unlikely to be correct
 In principle there always remains the possibility for the
simulated to discover the simulators
© Peter Morgan Oct 2017 12
References
 [1] Elon Musk believes we are probably characters in some advanced
civilization's video game
http://www.vox.com/2016/6/2/11837608/elon-musk-simulation-argument
 [2] Are You Living In a Computer Simulation?
http://www.simulation-argument.com/
 [3] Lloyd, Seth, Ultimate Physical Limits to Computation, Nature, 406,1047,
1999 https://arxiv.org/abs/quant-ph/9908043
 [4] Wolfram, Stephen, A New Kind of Science, Wolfram Media, 2002
 [5] How many species are there on Earth?
https://www.sciencedaily.com/rel.../2011/08/110823180459.htm
© Peter Morgan Oct 2017 13
References
 [6] How many atoms are in the human body?
https://education.jlab.org/qa/mathatom_04.html
 [7] Landenmark et al, An estimate of the total DNA in the biosphere,
PLOS Biology, 2015
http://journals.plos.org/plosbiology/article?id=10.1371%2Fjournal.pbi
o.1002168
 [8] Tianhe-2 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tianhe-2
 [9] BP Energy Review 2016
https://www.bp.com/.../statistical.../electricity.html
 [10] Beane et al, Constraints on the Universe as a Numerical
Simulation, 2012 https://arxiv.org/abs/1210.1847v2
© Peter Morgan Oct 2017 14

Contenu connexe

Tendances

Mapa conceitual Platão
Mapa conceitual PlatãoMapa conceitual Platão
Mapa conceitual Platão
eucenir
 
Moon landing hoax
Moon landing hoaxMoon landing hoax
Moon landing hoax
knepsam15
 

Tendances (20)

Sócrates: a dialética
Sócrates: a dialéticaSócrates: a dialética
Sócrates: a dialética
 
Mapa conceitual Platão
Mapa conceitual PlatãoMapa conceitual Platão
Mapa conceitual Platão
 
Café filosófico A felicidade
Café filosófico A felicidadeCafé filosófico A felicidade
Café filosófico A felicidade
 
Parábola do Últimos Lugares
Parábola do Últimos LugaresParábola do Últimos Lugares
Parábola do Últimos Lugares
 
Libro+dorado
Libro+doradoLibro+dorado
Libro+dorado
 
Mapa conceitual - conhecimento e lógica
Mapa conceitual - conhecimento e lógicaMapa conceitual - conhecimento e lógica
Mapa conceitual - conhecimento e lógica
 
Filosofia e Mito
Filosofia e MitoFilosofia e Mito
Filosofia e Mito
 
BLACK ROOTS SCIENCE
BLACK ROOTS SCIENCEBLACK ROOTS SCIENCE
BLACK ROOTS SCIENCE
 
Empirismo
EmpirismoEmpirismo
Empirismo
 
Matrix, Analise, Curiosidades e sua Filosofia
Matrix, Analise, Curiosidades e sua FilosofiaMatrix, Analise, Curiosidades e sua Filosofia
Matrix, Analise, Curiosidades e sua Filosofia
 
Pós modernidade e os meios de comunicação
Pós modernidade e os meios de comunicaçãoPós modernidade e os meios de comunicação
Pós modernidade e os meios de comunicação
 
Introdução à filosofia
Introdução à filosofiaIntrodução à filosofia
Introdução à filosofia
 
life on mars
life on marslife on mars
life on mars
 
Cap.02 A dúvida aula de filosofia 1º ano ensino medio
Cap.02 A dúvida aula de filosofia 1º ano ensino medioCap.02 A dúvida aula de filosofia 1º ano ensino medio
Cap.02 A dúvida aula de filosofia 1º ano ensino medio
 
BIG BANG THEORY & GOD'S PARTICLE
BIG BANG THEORY & GOD'S PARTICLEBIG BANG THEORY & GOD'S PARTICLE
BIG BANG THEORY & GOD'S PARTICLE
 
Moon landing hoax
Moon landing hoaxMoon landing hoax
Moon landing hoax
 
Aula de filosofia
Aula de filosofia Aula de filosofia
Aula de filosofia
 
Mapa conceitual - Filosofia medieval
Mapa conceitual - Filosofia medievalMapa conceitual - Filosofia medieval
Mapa conceitual - Filosofia medieval
 
Introdução à filosofia
Introdução à filosofiaIntrodução à filosofia
Introdução à filosofia
 
Huberto rohden lúcifer e lógos
Huberto rohden   lúcifer e lógosHuberto rohden   lúcifer e lógos
Huberto rohden lúcifer e lógos
 

Similaire à Simulation Hypothesis 2017

Will Robots Inherit Earth
Will Robots Inherit EarthWill Robots Inherit Earth
Will Robots Inherit Earth
elliando dias
 
Kain042710 mit sloan-school
Kain042710 mit sloan-schoolKain042710 mit sloan-school
Kain042710 mit sloan-school
Erik Chan
 
Singularity presentation Ray Kurzweil at Google
Singularity presentation Ray Kurzweil at GoogleSingularity presentation Ray Kurzweil at Google
Singularity presentation Ray Kurzweil at Google
Sergio Stein
 
Raymond Kurzweil presentation
Raymond Kurzweil presentationRaymond Kurzweil presentation
Raymond Kurzweil presentation
Antonio Eram
 
Constraints on the Universe as a Numerical Simulation
Constraints on the Universe as a Numerical SimulationConstraints on the Universe as a Numerical Simulation
Constraints on the Universe as a Numerical Simulation
solodoe
 
Ldb Convergenze Parallele_sozzolabbasso_01
Ldb Convergenze Parallele_sozzolabbasso_01Ldb Convergenze Parallele_sozzolabbasso_01
Ldb Convergenze Parallele_sozzolabbasso_01
laboratoridalbasso
 

Similaire à Simulation Hypothesis 2017 (20)

physics 2.pdf
physics 2.pdfphysics 2.pdf
physics 2.pdf
 
Will Robots Inherit Earth
Will Robots Inherit EarthWill Robots Inherit Earth
Will Robots Inherit Earth
 
Extra dimensions and the arrow of time.pdf
Extra dimensions and the arrow of time.pdfExtra dimensions and the arrow of time.pdf
Extra dimensions and the arrow of time.pdf
 
Quantum teleportation
Quantum teleportationQuantum teleportation
Quantum teleportation
 
constants nature John Barrow A Book Summary
constants nature John Barrow A Book Summaryconstants nature John Barrow A Book Summary
constants nature John Barrow A Book Summary
 
simulation.pdf
simulation.pdfsimulation.pdf
simulation.pdf
 
How much do we know - edited
How much do we know - editedHow much do we know - edited
How much do we know - edited
 
Teleportation
TeleportationTeleportation
Teleportation
 
WheregoodideascomefromStevenJohnson.docx
WheregoodideascomefromStevenJohnson.docxWheregoodideascomefromStevenJohnson.docx
WheregoodideascomefromStevenJohnson.docx
 
Kain042710 mit sloan-school
Kain042710 mit sloan-schoolKain042710 mit sloan-school
Kain042710 mit sloan-school
 
Singularity presentation Ray Kurzweil at Google
Singularity presentation Ray Kurzweil at GoogleSingularity presentation Ray Kurzweil at Google
Singularity presentation Ray Kurzweil at Google
 
Raymond Kurzweil presentation
Raymond Kurzweil presentationRaymond Kurzweil presentation
Raymond Kurzweil presentation
 
Constraints on the Universe as a Numerical Simulation
Constraints on the Universe as a Numerical SimulationConstraints on the Universe as a Numerical Simulation
Constraints on the Universe as a Numerical Simulation
 
Visit at CERN
Visit at CERNVisit at CERN
Visit at CERN
 
Why anthropic principle stopped to defend us: observation selection and fragi...
Why anthropic principle stopped to defend us: observation selection and fragi...Why anthropic principle stopped to defend us: observation selection and fragi...
Why anthropic principle stopped to defend us: observation selection and fragi...
 
Ldb Convergenze Parallele_sozzolabbasso_01
Ldb Convergenze Parallele_sozzolabbasso_01Ldb Convergenze Parallele_sozzolabbasso_01
Ldb Convergenze Parallele_sozzolabbasso_01
 
1.3 energy and equilibria notes
1.3 energy and equilibria notes1.3 energy and equilibria notes
1.3 energy and equilibria notes
 
Luz e Vida
Luz e VidaLuz e Vida
Luz e Vida
 
ICP.000524.pdf
ICP.000524.pdfICP.000524.pdf
ICP.000524.pdf
 
Black holes as tools for quantum computing by advanced extraterrestrial civil...
Black holes as tools for quantum computing by advanced extraterrestrial civil...Black holes as tools for quantum computing by advanced extraterrestrial civil...
Black holes as tools for quantum computing by advanced extraterrestrial civil...
 

Plus de Peter Morgan

Plus de Peter Morgan (12)

Towards AGI Berlin - Building AGI, May 2019
Towards AGI Berlin - Building AGI, May 2019Towards AGI Berlin - Building AGI, May 2019
Towards AGI Berlin - Building AGI, May 2019
 
AI in Physics - University of Washington, Jan 2024
AI in Physics - University of Washington, Jan 2024AI in Physics - University of Washington, Jan 2024
AI in Physics - University of Washington, Jan 2024
 
Towards a General Theory of Intelligence - April 2018
Towards a General Theory of Intelligence - April 2018Towards a General Theory of Intelligence - April 2018
Towards a General Theory of Intelligence - April 2018
 
AI Developments Aug 2017
AI Developments Aug 2017AI Developments Aug 2017
AI Developments Aug 2017
 
London Exponential Technologies Meetup, July 2017
London Exponential Technologies Meetup, July 2017London Exponential Technologies Meetup, July 2017
London Exponential Technologies Meetup, July 2017
 
Robotics Overview 2016
Robotics Overview 2016Robotics Overview 2016
Robotics Overview 2016
 
AI and Blockchain 2017
AI and Blockchain 2017AI and Blockchain 2017
AI and Blockchain 2017
 
AI in Healthcare 2017
AI in Healthcare 2017AI in Healthcare 2017
AI in Healthcare 2017
 
AI Predictions 2017
AI Predictions 2017AI Predictions 2017
AI Predictions 2017
 
AI State of Play Dec 2016 NYC
AI State of Play Dec 2016 NYCAI State of Play Dec 2016 NYC
AI State of Play Dec 2016 NYC
 
Big data – An Introduction, July 2013
Big data – An Introduction, July 2013Big data – An Introduction, July 2013
Big data – An Introduction, July 2013
 
Machine Learning - Where to Next?, May 2015
Machine Learning  - Where to Next?, May 2015Machine Learning  - Where to Next?, May 2015
Machine Learning - Where to Next?, May 2015
 

Dernier

biology HL practice questions IB BIOLOGY
biology HL practice questions IB BIOLOGYbiology HL practice questions IB BIOLOGY
biology HL practice questions IB BIOLOGY
1301aanya
 
The Mariana Trench remarkable geological features on Earth.pptx
The Mariana Trench remarkable geological features on Earth.pptxThe Mariana Trench remarkable geological features on Earth.pptx
The Mariana Trench remarkable geological features on Earth.pptx
seri bangash
 
Biogenic Sulfur Gases as Biosignatures on Temperate Sub-Neptune Waterworlds
Biogenic Sulfur Gases as Biosignatures on Temperate Sub-Neptune WaterworldsBiogenic Sulfur Gases as Biosignatures on Temperate Sub-Neptune Waterworlds
Biogenic Sulfur Gases as Biosignatures on Temperate Sub-Neptune Waterworlds
Sérgio Sacani
 
Cyathodium bryophyte: morphology, anatomy, reproduction etc.
Cyathodium bryophyte: morphology, anatomy, reproduction etc.Cyathodium bryophyte: morphology, anatomy, reproduction etc.
Cyathodium bryophyte: morphology, anatomy, reproduction etc.
Cherry
 
Porella : features, morphology, anatomy, reproduction etc.
Porella : features, morphology, anatomy, reproduction etc.Porella : features, morphology, anatomy, reproduction etc.
Porella : features, morphology, anatomy, reproduction etc.
Cherry
 
Digital Dentistry.Digital Dentistryvv.pptx
Digital Dentistry.Digital Dentistryvv.pptxDigital Dentistry.Digital Dentistryvv.pptx
Digital Dentistry.Digital Dentistryvv.pptx
MohamedFarag457087
 

Dernier (20)

Thyroid Physiology_Dr.E. Muralinath_ Associate Professor
Thyroid Physiology_Dr.E. Muralinath_ Associate ProfessorThyroid Physiology_Dr.E. Muralinath_ Associate Professor
Thyroid Physiology_Dr.E. Muralinath_ Associate Professor
 
Call Girls Ahmedabad +917728919243 call me Independent Escort Service
Call Girls Ahmedabad +917728919243 call me Independent Escort ServiceCall Girls Ahmedabad +917728919243 call me Independent Escort Service
Call Girls Ahmedabad +917728919243 call me Independent Escort Service
 
Plasmid: types, structure and functions.
Plasmid: types, structure and functions.Plasmid: types, structure and functions.
Plasmid: types, structure and functions.
 
Bhiwandi Bhiwandi ❤CALL GIRL 7870993772 ❤CALL GIRLS ESCORT SERVICE In Bhiwan...
Bhiwandi Bhiwandi ❤CALL GIRL 7870993772 ❤CALL GIRLS  ESCORT SERVICE In Bhiwan...Bhiwandi Bhiwandi ❤CALL GIRL 7870993772 ❤CALL GIRLS  ESCORT SERVICE In Bhiwan...
Bhiwandi Bhiwandi ❤CALL GIRL 7870993772 ❤CALL GIRLS ESCORT SERVICE In Bhiwan...
 
FAIRSpectra - Enabling the FAIRification of Spectroscopy and Spectrometry
FAIRSpectra - Enabling the FAIRification of Spectroscopy and SpectrometryFAIRSpectra - Enabling the FAIRification of Spectroscopy and Spectrometry
FAIRSpectra - Enabling the FAIRification of Spectroscopy and Spectrometry
 
GBSN - Microbiology (Unit 3)Defense Mechanism of the body
GBSN - Microbiology (Unit 3)Defense Mechanism of the body GBSN - Microbiology (Unit 3)Defense Mechanism of the body
GBSN - Microbiology (Unit 3)Defense Mechanism of the body
 
Kanchipuram Escorts 🥰 8617370543 Call Girls Offer VIP Hot Girls
Kanchipuram Escorts 🥰 8617370543 Call Girls Offer VIP Hot GirlsKanchipuram Escorts 🥰 8617370543 Call Girls Offer VIP Hot Girls
Kanchipuram Escorts 🥰 8617370543 Call Girls Offer VIP Hot Girls
 
Terpineol and it's characterization pptx
Terpineol and it's characterization pptxTerpineol and it's characterization pptx
Terpineol and it's characterization pptx
 
biology HL practice questions IB BIOLOGY
biology HL practice questions IB BIOLOGYbiology HL practice questions IB BIOLOGY
biology HL practice questions IB BIOLOGY
 
The Mariana Trench remarkable geological features on Earth.pptx
The Mariana Trench remarkable geological features on Earth.pptxThe Mariana Trench remarkable geological features on Earth.pptx
The Mariana Trench remarkable geological features on Earth.pptx
 
Genetics and epigenetics of ADHD and comorbid conditions
Genetics and epigenetics of ADHD and comorbid conditionsGenetics and epigenetics of ADHD and comorbid conditions
Genetics and epigenetics of ADHD and comorbid conditions
 
PATNA CALL GIRLS 8617370543 LOW PRICE ESCORT SERVICE
PATNA CALL GIRLS 8617370543 LOW PRICE ESCORT SERVICEPATNA CALL GIRLS 8617370543 LOW PRICE ESCORT SERVICE
PATNA CALL GIRLS 8617370543 LOW PRICE ESCORT SERVICE
 
Biogenic Sulfur Gases as Biosignatures on Temperate Sub-Neptune Waterworlds
Biogenic Sulfur Gases as Biosignatures on Temperate Sub-Neptune WaterworldsBiogenic Sulfur Gases as Biosignatures on Temperate Sub-Neptune Waterworlds
Biogenic Sulfur Gases as Biosignatures on Temperate Sub-Neptune Waterworlds
 
Cyathodium bryophyte: morphology, anatomy, reproduction etc.
Cyathodium bryophyte: morphology, anatomy, reproduction etc.Cyathodium bryophyte: morphology, anatomy, reproduction etc.
Cyathodium bryophyte: morphology, anatomy, reproduction etc.
 
Porella : features, morphology, anatomy, reproduction etc.
Porella : features, morphology, anatomy, reproduction etc.Porella : features, morphology, anatomy, reproduction etc.
Porella : features, morphology, anatomy, reproduction etc.
 
Digital Dentistry.Digital Dentistryvv.pptx
Digital Dentistry.Digital Dentistryvv.pptxDigital Dentistry.Digital Dentistryvv.pptx
Digital Dentistry.Digital Dentistryvv.pptx
 
Climate Change Impacts on Terrestrial and Aquatic Ecosystems.pptx
Climate Change Impacts on Terrestrial and Aquatic Ecosystems.pptxClimate Change Impacts on Terrestrial and Aquatic Ecosystems.pptx
Climate Change Impacts on Terrestrial and Aquatic Ecosystems.pptx
 
Dr. E. Muralinath_ Blood indices_clinical aspects
Dr. E. Muralinath_ Blood indices_clinical  aspectsDr. E. Muralinath_ Blood indices_clinical  aspects
Dr. E. Muralinath_ Blood indices_clinical aspects
 
Role of AI in seed science Predictive modelling and Beyond.pptx
Role of AI in seed science  Predictive modelling and  Beyond.pptxRole of AI in seed science  Predictive modelling and  Beyond.pptx
Role of AI in seed science Predictive modelling and Beyond.pptx
 
Genome sequencing,shotgun sequencing.pptx
Genome sequencing,shotgun sequencing.pptxGenome sequencing,shotgun sequencing.pptx
Genome sequencing,shotgun sequencing.pptx
 

Simulation Hypothesis 2017

  • 1. Evidence Against the Simulation Hypothesis © Peter Morgan Oct 2017 1 Peter Morgan
  • 2. What Is the Simulation Hypothesis?  The Simulation Hypothesis (SH) is the speculation that the observable universe is a simulation created by a superior being, much in the same way that we currently produce realistic 3D video games or environments  It is not a new theory - it recently gained attention by Elon Musk saying on National TV that he’s pretty sure we are living in a simulation [1]  Essentially we can assign a probability of the SH being correct between 0 and 1. 0 means that the universe is absolutely certainly not a simulation, and 1 means that the universe is a simulation with 100% certainty  So 0 < P[SH is true] < 1  Different people assign different values to the simulation hypothesis being true [2] © Peter Morgan Oct 2017 2
  • 3. Arguments For & Against  People who believe that the SH may be true argue that it is likely because, just as we create video games, so we can extrapolate to a time in the future whereby, with enough compute power, we could simulate our entire universe  To disprove the SH we (scientists) have to show why this cannot happen  The laws of physics, including computation and energy conservation, are a good place to start [3], [4]  We will need to understand what computation and information processing entail © Peter Morgan Oct 2017 3
  • 4. The Scientific Method – Appeal to Reason  It’s easy to say something is possible, harder to do the physics (aka anybody can say anything, but this certainly does not make it true)  Note on the scientific method – a hypothesis is as powerful as the testable predictions that it makes  You can never prove a theory right, only disprove it  What we can do, however, is to show that something is so unlikely that it is effectively impossible, and that other theories are therefore, much more likely to be correct  For example, the big bang theory of creation is currently much more likely to be the correct theory of creation than the simulation hypothesis © Peter Morgan Oct 2017 4
  • 5. What is Needed Computationally  To disprove the SH, we need to show that it is physically impossible (or exceedingly unlikely) to create a universe such as ours by computational means  What would it take to recreate our universe down to the scale (granularity) currently measured by particle accelerators, or smaller? d < 10TeV ~ 10^-19m  And up to the large scale structure of our universe (approx. 46 billion light-years, or 5 x 10^23km)  Not to mention the creation of sentient beings (us) who can think intelligently about such a hypothesis. © Peter Morgan Oct 2017 5
  • 6. Computation in the Biosphere  There are approximately 10^80 atoms in the universe. Many of these are arranged into very complex organic systems, or living organisms. These include humans, animals, plants, fungi, bacteria and viruses  We can estimate how many of these atoms are involved in living organisms. And then calculate the processing power required to simulate all life in our biosphere  In humans, there are approximately 10 trillion cells. Multiply this by the number of humans on Earth (10 billion, order of magnitude)  There are approximately 10 million species in all five classes of life [5]  Estimate that on average there are 10 billion cells in each of these species (I have taken 0.1% of the number of cells in a human)  We then have 10^13 x 10^10 x 10^7 x 10^10 = 10^40 cells total for all the life on Earth (in the biosphere)  Another way at getting at this is by estimating the number of atoms in an average adult human which is around 10^28 [6], but here we will follow the cellular approach. © Peter Morgan Oct 2017 6
  • 7. Computation in the Biosphere  How much compute power (TFlops, memory) is needed to simulate the 10^40 cells involved in life on Earth? We can get an idea by estimating the total DNA in the Earth’s biosphere. From [7]:  "Finding the amount of DNA in the biosphere enables an estimate of the computational speed of the biosphere, in terms of the number of bases transcribed per second, or Nucleotide Operations Per Second (NOPS), analogous to the Floating-point Operations Per Second (FLOPS) metric used in electronic computing  If all the DNA in the biosphere was being transcribed at these reported rates, taking an estimated transcription rate of 30 bases per second, then the potential computational power of the biosphere would be approximately 10^24 PetaNOPS  This is about 10^22 times more processing power than the Tianhe-2 supercomputer [8], which has a processing power on the order of 100 PetaFLOPS." © Peter Morgan Oct 2017 7
  • 8. Computation in the Biosphere © Peter Morgan Oct 2017 8 Figure 1 – DNA Computation Equivalence
  • 9. Space and Power Requirements  How much space would 10^22 Tianhe-2's take up? Let's say that a Tianhe-2 supercomputer takes up an area of 100m^2  We would then need 10^24m^2 of space  The surface area of the Earth is 5 x 10^14m^2, so we would need the surface area of 10 billion Earths just to calculate the DNA computations on Earth given the current state of HPC  How much power would we need? Let's say that Tianhe-2 uses 25MWh. We would then need 10^22 x 2.5 x 10^7 MWh = 2.5 x 10^17 TWh of power  The current electricity generation capacity of Earth is around 2.5 x 10^16 TWh [9], so we would need 10X the entire Earths' electricity generation capacity given current HPC energy performance © Peter Morgan Oct 2017 9
  • 10. Life on Other Planets  The above calculations are just for life here on Earth. What if there is life elsewhere in the universe, which recent Exoplanet observations indicate the potential for?  Let's say there are 1 billion planets with life in the Milky Way and that, on average, they contain a similar amount of life in their biospheres as Earth  We need to multiply 10^40 by 10^9 x 10^11 (there are 100 billion galaxies in the observable universe) to give us a figure of 10^60 cells in the universe  This is 10^20 times more computation than was needed in the calculations for life on Earth alone  It is hard for us to imagine another universe existing with the computational resources (hardware, energy) required to make such an elaborate simulation of this universe © Peter Morgan Oct 2017 10
  • 11. High Energy Cosmic Rays  Paper by physicists at the University of Washington examining the limits to the SH [10]  Observable consequences of the hypothesis that the observed universe is a numerical simulation performed on a cubic space-time lattice or grid are explored  Assumption: simulations of the future employ an underlying cubic lattice structure  Are there any signatures of a simulated universe that might be experimentally detectable?  One proposed signature is in the anisotropy of high energy cosmic rays (Note – the GZK limit is the theoretical upper limit on the energy of cosmic rays) © Peter Morgan Oct 2017 11
  • 12. Conclusions  The above calculations are just for DNA replications of all organisms. There are other processes and interactions occurring here on Earth and in the universe, that would require further orders of magnitude more computational resource  No evidence whatsoever from experimental probes so far  In conclusion, the SH is extremely unlikely to be correct  In principle there always remains the possibility for the simulated to discover the simulators © Peter Morgan Oct 2017 12
  • 13. References  [1] Elon Musk believes we are probably characters in some advanced civilization's video game http://www.vox.com/2016/6/2/11837608/elon-musk-simulation-argument  [2] Are You Living In a Computer Simulation? http://www.simulation-argument.com/  [3] Lloyd, Seth, Ultimate Physical Limits to Computation, Nature, 406,1047, 1999 https://arxiv.org/abs/quant-ph/9908043  [4] Wolfram, Stephen, A New Kind of Science, Wolfram Media, 2002  [5] How many species are there on Earth? https://www.sciencedaily.com/rel.../2011/08/110823180459.htm © Peter Morgan Oct 2017 13
  • 14. References  [6] How many atoms are in the human body? https://education.jlab.org/qa/mathatom_04.html  [7] Landenmark et al, An estimate of the total DNA in the biosphere, PLOS Biology, 2015 http://journals.plos.org/plosbiology/article?id=10.1371%2Fjournal.pbi o.1002168  [8] Tianhe-2 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tianhe-2  [9] BP Energy Review 2016 https://www.bp.com/.../statistical.../electricity.html  [10] Beane et al, Constraints on the Universe as a Numerical Simulation, 2012 https://arxiv.org/abs/1210.1847v2 © Peter Morgan Oct 2017 14