SlideShare une entreprise Scribd logo
1  sur  32
[object Object],[object Object],More than 300 British soldiers who were shot during World War I for military offences are to receive formal pardons, Defence Secretary Des Browne has announced.   Mr Browne said he would be seeking a parliamentary group pardon for the men, executed for offences such as cowardice and desertion.  It is believed 306 British soldiers were shot during the war from 1914-1918.  Shot at dawn, pardoned 90 years on
 
Decided whether people, such as Private Harry Farr, deserve a posthumous pardon?
Posthumous?
      adj : occurring after a person's death; (in the case of a child)            born after the father's death; "a posthumous award"; "a            posthumous book"; "a posthumous child"
 
      Private Harry Farr Died 1916. Shot for cowardice
      Private Harry Farr Died 1916. Shot for cowardice R.I.P. ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
      So, what could his trial have looked like?
     
      McGEEHAN BURDEN HIGHGATE FARR Detail Soldier name
      Read your coloured sheet
      PAIR
      Group
      The announcement of the pardon came after years of campaigning from the family of Private Harry Farr.   Pte Farr volunteered to fight for his country in 1914 - the year the war with Germany began.  He had first served in the British Army between 1908 and 1912 but by the time World War I broke out, was working as a scaffolder and living in Kensington, west London, with his wife and one-year-old daughter, both called Gertrude.  Pte Farr fought at the Battle of the Somme and at Neuve Chapelle, but during 1915 and 1916 reported sick four times with nerves, his worst case seeing him spend five months in hospital, with symptoms his family said were consistent with a diagnosis of "shellshock".  He returned to action with the West Yorkshire Regiment but was court martialled after refusing to go to the trenches in September 1916, having asked to return to camp, saying he could not stand the noise of artillery and was not in a fit state.  At his court martial on 16 October 1916, Pte Farr was found guilty of "misbehaving before the enemy in such a manner as to show cowardice" and he was shot the following morning, aged 25.  He refused a blindfold at his execution, preferring to look the firing squad in the eye, and the army chaplain at the execution sent Pte Farr's widow a message saying "a finer soldier never lived".  His daughter Gertrude Harris, who was three years old at the time and is now 93, said: "I am so relieved that this ordeal is now over and I can be content knowing that my father's memory is intact.  "I have always argued that my father's refusal to rejoin the frontline, described in the court martial as resulting from cowardice, was in fact the result of shellshock, and I believe that many other soldiers suffered from this, not just my father."
      The announcement of the pardon came after years of campaigning from the family of Private Harry Farr.   ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
      Private Thomas Highgate, of the Royal West Kent Regiment, was the first British soldier to be executed for desertion during World War I - just 35 days into the war.  His offence, trial, sentencing and execution all took place on the same day - 8 September 1914 .  Aged 17, he had been unable to bear the carnage of the Battle of Mons, and had fled and hidden in a barn.  Pte Highgate was undefended at his court martial because all his regimental comrades had been killed, injured or captured.  In 2000, the parish council in his home village of Shoreham, Kent, voted not to include his name on its war memorial.  Phil Hobson, who was council chairman at the time, said: "We had the opportunity of putting the name on it because we were replacing the plaque with all the names on - after nearly 100 years it was very worn.  "We took what we thought to be the best compromise position in that a space was left for his name should people want it to be added at a later date."  Stuart Gendall, of the Royal British Legion, said Pte Highgate's name should be on the memorial: "I think it would be most appropriate and certainly very poignant in this year - the 90th anniversary of the Battle of the Somme."
      At the age of 16, Private Herbert Burden lied that he was two years older so he could join the Northumberland Fusiliers and fight in the war.   Ten months later he was court martialled for desertion after leaving his post to comfort a recently-bereaved friend stationed nearby, having seen many other friends killed at the Battle of Bellwarde Ridge.  The officers considering Pte Burden's case heard his unit had been issued orders to make for the front just before he went missing.  By the time he faced the firing squad on 21 July 1915, Pte Burden was 17 - still too young to even officially be in his regiment.  It was Pte Burden's case which led John Hipkin, a retired Newcastle teacher, to set up the Shot at Dawn campaign in the early 1990s.  The campaign fought for soldiers such as Pte Burden to be pardoned.  Mr Hipkin, now 80, fought in World War II, taken prisoner by the Germans at the age of 14, when he was cabin boy in the merchant navy.  He began campaigning after reading about Pte Burden's case and said: "I couldn't believe it was true, but when I looked into it there were others, and this really angered me."  On Wednesday he said of the news of the pardons: "It is great news, I could not believe it. It is well overdue."  A memorial to soldiers shot by their own side during WWI, a statue of a young soldier blindfolded and tied to a stake, unveiled in 2001 in Staffordshire, is modelled on Pte Burden.
      Private Bernard McGeehan, of the Liverpool King's Regiment, was executed on 2 November 1916, after being found guilty of desertion.   Aged 28 and from Derry, Northern Ireland, he had been transferred to the front line just after the Battle of the Somme earlier that year.  "He couldn't cope. He was shell-shocked completely, shaking, bewildered and lost.  "He went for a walk one day out of his lines and five days later walked back in again, looking for his regiment.  "He was arrested, court martialled and shot at dawn - for alleged desertion.  "I've always contended that anybody who walks back into his lines again is not planning to desert."
      McGEEHAN BURDEN HIGHGATE FARR Detail Soldier name
      Think back to last Monday’s lesson..... For each of the 4 people we looked at who were to receive a ‘posthumous’ pardon you need to rate their case. Give them a ranking [ 1= strongest case, 4= weakest case]. Then on the back of the sheet write an obituary for them.... McGHEE Aged 28 Court marshalled for desertion Actually walked back to the front line BURDEN Desertion after comforting a friend Inspired Shot at Dawn campaign Was 16 when lied to join the army HIGHGATE Died 1914 Offence, trial, sentence and execution all on the same day 17 years of age FARR Died 1916 Aged 25 Previously served in army Left a wife and young child
      Can I have your Homework please?
      We’re going to watch the whole episode of the trial today! Blackadder Season 4, Episode 2
     
      Peter Caddick-Adams – Historian ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
      John McGeehan of campaign group  Shot at Dawn ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
      More than 300 British soldiers who were shot during World War I for military offences are to receive formal pardons, Defence Secretary Des Browne has announced .... It would be interesting if.... Minuses Positives
      Think back to last Monday’s lesson..... For each of the 4 people we looked at who were to receive a ‘posthumous’ pardon you need to rate their case. Give them a ranking [ 1= strongest case, 4= weakest case]. Then on the back of the sheet write an obituary for them.... McGHEE Aged 28 Court marshalled for desertion Actually walked back to the front line BURDEN Desertion after comforting a friend Inspired Shot at Dawn campaign Was 16 when lied to join the army HIGHGATE Died 1914 Offence, trial, sentence and execution all on the same day 17 years of age FARR Died 1916 Aged 25 Previously served in army Left a wife and young child
     
      Timed essay
      “ Surely the way to confront this World War I tragedy is to remember it, not pretend it had never happened” Peter Caddick-Adams In relation to the pardoning of soldiers from World War I how far do you agree with the statement?
      “ Surely the way to confront this World War I tragedy is to remember it, not pretend it had never happened” Peter Caddick-Adams In relation to the pardoning of soldiers from World War I how far do you agree with the statement?  Max 1,250 words Level 5 Agrees and shows increasing factual knowledge. Structured work making appropriate use of dates and terms. Level 6 Disagrees but also begins to assess the significance of the statement. Begins to analyse why there are different historical interpretations. Level 7  Balanced answer with supported conclusion whereby the pupil offers his/her own opinion. Assesses the significance of the quotation and relates it to their own life/ life in 2007. Reaches a substantiated conclusion. Level 8 Balanced answer with supported conclusion whereby the pupils offers his/her own opinion. Well-structured narrative, description and explanation making appropriate use of dates/terms. NB Max L5 if essay does not discuss cases of at least 4 soldiers who received a pardon Max L5 if essay does not include discussion on historical debate around ‘Shot at Dawn’ Max L5 if essay does not include factually correct information

Contenu connexe

Tendances

Ray merriam the malmédy massacre and trial - journal of historical review v...
Ray merriam   the malmédy massacre and trial - journal of historical review v...Ray merriam   the malmédy massacre and trial - journal of historical review v...
Ray merriam the malmédy massacre and trial - journal of historical review v...
RareBooksnRecords
 
11-8-13-WarsFathersVetsDay
11-8-13-WarsFathersVetsDay11-8-13-WarsFathersVetsDay
11-8-13-WarsFathersVetsDay
Telly Halkias
 
David irving churchill and u.s. entry into world war ii - volume 9 no. 3
David irving   churchill and u.s. entry into world war ii - volume 9 no. 3David irving   churchill and u.s. entry into world war ii - volume 9 no. 3
David irving churchill and u.s. entry into world war ii - volume 9 no. 3
RareBooksnRecords
 
Recounts written by room 9
Recounts written by room 9 Recounts written by room 9
Recounts written by room 9
mrsgribbs
 
Joseph halow innocent in dachau-the trial and punishment of franz kofler e...
Joseph halow    innocent in dachau-the trial and punishment of franz kofler e...Joseph halow    innocent in dachau-the trial and punishment of franz kofler e...
Joseph halow innocent in dachau-the trial and punishment of franz kofler e...
RareBooksnRecords
 

Tendances (19)

Czuma return
Czuma returnCzuma return
Czuma return
 
Emma willard and world war i
Emma willard and world war iEmma willard and world war i
Emma willard and world war i
 
World War 1 CFH
World War 1 CFHWorld War 1 CFH
World War 1 CFH
 
Ray merriam the malmédy massacre and trial - journal of historical review v...
Ray merriam   the malmédy massacre and trial - journal of historical review v...Ray merriam   the malmédy massacre and trial - journal of historical review v...
Ray merriam the malmédy massacre and trial - journal of historical review v...
 
Affixation in context
Affixation in contextAffixation in context
Affixation in context
 
11-8-13-WarsFathersVetsDay
11-8-13-WarsFathersVetsDay11-8-13-WarsFathersVetsDay
11-8-13-WarsFathersVetsDay
 
David irving churchill and u.s. entry into world war ii - volume 9 no. 3
David irving   churchill and u.s. entry into world war ii - volume 9 no. 3David irving   churchill and u.s. entry into world war ii - volume 9 no. 3
David irving churchill and u.s. entry into world war ii - volume 9 no. 3
 
Brisbane War Stories – Edited by Sophie Tarrant
Brisbane War Stories – Edited by Sophie TarrantBrisbane War Stories – Edited by Sophie Tarrant
Brisbane War Stories – Edited by Sophie Tarrant
 
S00584 tran
S00584 tranS00584 tran
S00584 tran
 
Law Is War
Law Is WarLaw Is War
Law Is War
 
Crime and Punishment prelims
Crime and Punishment prelimsCrime and Punishment prelims
Crime and Punishment prelims
 
Rosie's Diary
Rosie's DiaryRosie's Diary
Rosie's Diary
 
Recounts written by room 9
Recounts written by room 9 Recounts written by room 9
Recounts written by room 9
 
Audrey hepburn
Audrey hepburnAudrey hepburn
Audrey hepburn
 
Major Richard Dick Winters (Band of Brothers)
Major Richard Dick Winters (Band of Brothers)Major Richard Dick Winters (Band of Brothers)
Major Richard Dick Winters (Band of Brothers)
 
Steelworkers Fight Back pdf
Steelworkers Fight Back   pdf Steelworkers Fight Back   pdf
Steelworkers Fight Back pdf
 
Barbro Alving
Barbro AlvingBarbro Alving
Barbro Alving
 
Frederick's journey the life of frederick douglass
Frederick's journey  the life of frederick douglassFrederick's journey  the life of frederick douglass
Frederick's journey the life of frederick douglass
 
Joseph halow innocent in dachau-the trial and punishment of franz kofler e...
Joseph halow    innocent in dachau-the trial and punishment of franz kofler e...Joseph halow    innocent in dachau-the trial and punishment of franz kofler e...
Joseph halow innocent in dachau-the trial and punishment of franz kofler e...
 

En vedette (6)

Google Tips
Google TipsGoogle Tips
Google Tips
 
1933 Hitler rises to power
1933 Hitler rises to power1933 Hitler rises to power
1933 Hitler rises to power
 
J417 Ck Grids Paper I
J417 Ck Grids Paper IJ417 Ck Grids Paper I
J417 Ck Grids Paper I
 
GER gain from NAZI
GER gain from NAZIGER gain from NAZI
GER gain from NAZI
 
Aspen Conference, Nov 07
Aspen Conference, Nov 07Aspen Conference, Nov 07
Aspen Conference, Nov 07
 
1066(1)
1066(1)1066(1)
1066(1)
 

Similaire à Pt FARR

Canada Times Dec 2014 Final
Canada Times Dec 2014 FinalCanada Times Dec 2014 Final
Canada Times Dec 2014 Final
Leo Delaney
 
Remembrance day slide[1]
Remembrance day slide[1]Remembrance day slide[1]
Remembrance day slide[1]
Mr. Morrison
 
Battle of the Bulge
Battle of the BulgeBattle of the Bulge
Battle of the Bulge
guest36f5f9
 

Similaire à Pt FARR (11)

Dallas Morning News Memorial Day slide show 2015
Dallas Morning News Memorial Day slide show 2015Dallas Morning News Memorial Day slide show 2015
Dallas Morning News Memorial Day slide show 2015
 
Canada Times Dec 2014 Final
Canada Times Dec 2014 FinalCanada Times Dec 2014 Final
Canada Times Dec 2014 Final
 
Remembrance day slide[1]
Remembrance day slide[1]Remembrance day slide[1]
Remembrance day slide[1]
 
World War One - The Stafferton Men who went to War
World War One - The Stafferton Men who went to WarWorld War One - The Stafferton Men who went to War
World War One - The Stafferton Men who went to War
 
WWI Causes to Armistice
WWI Causes to ArmisticeWWI Causes to Armistice
WWI Causes to Armistice
 
Battle of the bulge
Battle of the bulgeBattle of the bulge
Battle of the bulge
 
World War I
World War IWorld War I
World War I
 
Battle of the Bulge
Battle of the BulgeBattle of the Bulge
Battle of the Bulge
 
All Day Articles[1].Pdf Dad In France
All Day Articles[1].Pdf Dad In  FranceAll Day Articles[1].Pdf Dad In  France
All Day Articles[1].Pdf Dad In France
 
Web quest
Web questWeb quest
Web quest
 
Journey's End Education Pack (Watermill Playhouse)
Journey's End Education Pack (Watermill Playhouse)Journey's End Education Pack (Watermill Playhouse)
Journey's End Education Pack (Watermill Playhouse)
 

Plus de Pete Lee

Ocr Nations Lessons 2 3 4
Ocr Nations Lessons 2 3 4Ocr Nations Lessons 2 3 4
Ocr Nations Lessons 2 3 4
Pete Lee
 
Ocr Nationals Lessons 5 6 7 8
Ocr Nationals Lessons 5 6 7 8Ocr Nationals Lessons 5 6 7 8
Ocr Nationals Lessons 5 6 7 8
Pete Lee
 

Plus de Pete Lee (20)

J417 ck grids_paper_i_with_blanks
J417 ck grids_paper_i_with_blanksJ417 ck grids_paper_i_with_blanks
J417 ck grids_paper_i_with_blanks
 
Paper_I_Half_Term_Session
Paper_I_Half_Term_SessionPaper_I_Half_Term_Session
Paper_I_Half_Term_Session
 
J417_Paper_I_sources
J417_Paper_I_sourcesJ417_Paper_I_sources
J417_Paper_I_sources
 
Play_as_Boris
Play_as_BorisPlay_as_Boris
Play_as_Boris
 
Mind_maps
Mind_mapsMind_maps
Mind_maps
 
J417 Ck Grids Paper II
J417 Ck Grids Paper IIJ417 Ck Grids Paper II
J417 Ck Grids Paper II
 
Reflect On Marking
Reflect On MarkingReflect On Marking
Reflect On Marking
 
Progress Afl
Progress AflProgress Afl
Progress Afl
 
J417 Ck Grids
J417 Ck GridsJ417 Ck Grids
J417 Ck Grids
 
Enterprise_Moseley_Moviemaker
Enterprise_Moseley_MoviemakerEnterprise_Moseley_Moviemaker
Enterprise_Moseley_Moviemaker
 
Media Library Whole Staff
Media Library Whole StaffMedia Library Whole Staff
Media Library Whole Staff
 
Media Library Computer Room
Media Library Computer RoomMedia Library Computer Room
Media Library Computer Room
 
Moseley_e_learning
Moseley_e_learningMoseley_e_learning
Moseley_e_learning
 
Possible Home Front/Women sources
Possible Home Front/Women sourcesPossible Home Front/Women sources
Possible Home Front/Women sources
 
Possible Paper I Sources Updated 2009
Possible Paper I Sources Updated 2009Possible Paper I Sources Updated 2009
Possible Paper I Sources Updated 2009
 
Paper I Tips 2009
Paper I Tips 2009Paper I Tips 2009
Paper I Tips 2009
 
Web 2.0
Web 2.0Web 2.0
Web 2.0
 
NQT_IWB_training_Dec_17_2008
NQT_IWB_training_Dec_17_2008NQT_IWB_training_Dec_17_2008
NQT_IWB_training_Dec_17_2008
 
Ocr Nations Lessons 2 3 4
Ocr Nations Lessons 2 3 4Ocr Nations Lessons 2 3 4
Ocr Nations Lessons 2 3 4
 
Ocr Nationals Lessons 5 6 7 8
Ocr Nationals Lessons 5 6 7 8Ocr Nationals Lessons 5 6 7 8
Ocr Nationals Lessons 5 6 7 8
 

Pt FARR

  • 1.
  • 2.  
  • 3. Decided whether people, such as Private Harry Farr, deserve a posthumous pardon?
  • 5.       adj : occurring after a person's death; (in the case of a child)            born after the father's death; "a posthumous award"; "a            posthumous book"; "a posthumous child"
  • 6.  
  • 7.       Private Harry Farr Died 1916. Shot for cowardice
  • 8.
  • 9.       So, what could his trial have looked like?
  • 11.       McGEEHAN BURDEN HIGHGATE FARR Detail Soldier name
  • 12.       Read your coloured sheet
  • 15.       The announcement of the pardon came after years of campaigning from the family of Private Harry Farr. Pte Farr volunteered to fight for his country in 1914 - the year the war with Germany began. He had first served in the British Army between 1908 and 1912 but by the time World War I broke out, was working as a scaffolder and living in Kensington, west London, with his wife and one-year-old daughter, both called Gertrude. Pte Farr fought at the Battle of the Somme and at Neuve Chapelle, but during 1915 and 1916 reported sick four times with nerves, his worst case seeing him spend five months in hospital, with symptoms his family said were consistent with a diagnosis of "shellshock". He returned to action with the West Yorkshire Regiment but was court martialled after refusing to go to the trenches in September 1916, having asked to return to camp, saying he could not stand the noise of artillery and was not in a fit state. At his court martial on 16 October 1916, Pte Farr was found guilty of "misbehaving before the enemy in such a manner as to show cowardice" and he was shot the following morning, aged 25. He refused a blindfold at his execution, preferring to look the firing squad in the eye, and the army chaplain at the execution sent Pte Farr's widow a message saying "a finer soldier never lived". His daughter Gertrude Harris, who was three years old at the time and is now 93, said: "I am so relieved that this ordeal is now over and I can be content knowing that my father's memory is intact. "I have always argued that my father's refusal to rejoin the frontline, described in the court martial as resulting from cowardice, was in fact the result of shellshock, and I believe that many other soldiers suffered from this, not just my father."
  • 16.
  • 17.       Private Thomas Highgate, of the Royal West Kent Regiment, was the first British soldier to be executed for desertion during World War I - just 35 days into the war. His offence, trial, sentencing and execution all took place on the same day - 8 September 1914 . Aged 17, he had been unable to bear the carnage of the Battle of Mons, and had fled and hidden in a barn. Pte Highgate was undefended at his court martial because all his regimental comrades had been killed, injured or captured. In 2000, the parish council in his home village of Shoreham, Kent, voted not to include his name on its war memorial. Phil Hobson, who was council chairman at the time, said: "We had the opportunity of putting the name on it because we were replacing the plaque with all the names on - after nearly 100 years it was very worn. "We took what we thought to be the best compromise position in that a space was left for his name should people want it to be added at a later date." Stuart Gendall, of the Royal British Legion, said Pte Highgate's name should be on the memorial: "I think it would be most appropriate and certainly very poignant in this year - the 90th anniversary of the Battle of the Somme."
  • 18.       At the age of 16, Private Herbert Burden lied that he was two years older so he could join the Northumberland Fusiliers and fight in the war. Ten months later he was court martialled for desertion after leaving his post to comfort a recently-bereaved friend stationed nearby, having seen many other friends killed at the Battle of Bellwarde Ridge. The officers considering Pte Burden's case heard his unit had been issued orders to make for the front just before he went missing. By the time he faced the firing squad on 21 July 1915, Pte Burden was 17 - still too young to even officially be in his regiment. It was Pte Burden's case which led John Hipkin, a retired Newcastle teacher, to set up the Shot at Dawn campaign in the early 1990s. The campaign fought for soldiers such as Pte Burden to be pardoned. Mr Hipkin, now 80, fought in World War II, taken prisoner by the Germans at the age of 14, when he was cabin boy in the merchant navy. He began campaigning after reading about Pte Burden's case and said: "I couldn't believe it was true, but when I looked into it there were others, and this really angered me." On Wednesday he said of the news of the pardons: "It is great news, I could not believe it. It is well overdue." A memorial to soldiers shot by their own side during WWI, a statue of a young soldier blindfolded and tied to a stake, unveiled in 2001 in Staffordshire, is modelled on Pte Burden.
  • 19.       Private Bernard McGeehan, of the Liverpool King's Regiment, was executed on 2 November 1916, after being found guilty of desertion. Aged 28 and from Derry, Northern Ireland, he had been transferred to the front line just after the Battle of the Somme earlier that year. "He couldn't cope. He was shell-shocked completely, shaking, bewildered and lost. "He went for a walk one day out of his lines and five days later walked back in again, looking for his regiment. "He was arrested, court martialled and shot at dawn - for alleged desertion. "I've always contended that anybody who walks back into his lines again is not planning to desert."
  • 20.       McGEEHAN BURDEN HIGHGATE FARR Detail Soldier name
  • 21.       Think back to last Monday’s lesson..... For each of the 4 people we looked at who were to receive a ‘posthumous’ pardon you need to rate their case. Give them a ranking [ 1= strongest case, 4= weakest case]. Then on the back of the sheet write an obituary for them.... McGHEE Aged 28 Court marshalled for desertion Actually walked back to the front line BURDEN Desertion after comforting a friend Inspired Shot at Dawn campaign Was 16 when lied to join the army HIGHGATE Died 1914 Offence, trial, sentence and execution all on the same day 17 years of age FARR Died 1916 Aged 25 Previously served in army Left a wife and young child
  • 22.       Can I have your Homework please?
  • 23.       We’re going to watch the whole episode of the trial today! Blackadder Season 4, Episode 2
  • 25.
  • 26.
  • 27.       More than 300 British soldiers who were shot during World War I for military offences are to receive formal pardons, Defence Secretary Des Browne has announced .... It would be interesting if.... Minuses Positives
  • 28.       Think back to last Monday’s lesson..... For each of the 4 people we looked at who were to receive a ‘posthumous’ pardon you need to rate their case. Give them a ranking [ 1= strongest case, 4= weakest case]. Then on the back of the sheet write an obituary for them.... McGHEE Aged 28 Court marshalled for desertion Actually walked back to the front line BURDEN Desertion after comforting a friend Inspired Shot at Dawn campaign Was 16 when lied to join the army HIGHGATE Died 1914 Offence, trial, sentence and execution all on the same day 17 years of age FARR Died 1916 Aged 25 Previously served in army Left a wife and young child
  • 31.       “ Surely the way to confront this World War I tragedy is to remember it, not pretend it had never happened” Peter Caddick-Adams In relation to the pardoning of soldiers from World War I how far do you agree with the statement?
  • 32.       “ Surely the way to confront this World War I tragedy is to remember it, not pretend it had never happened” Peter Caddick-Adams In relation to the pardoning of soldiers from World War I how far do you agree with the statement? Max 1,250 words Level 5 Agrees and shows increasing factual knowledge. Structured work making appropriate use of dates and terms. Level 6 Disagrees but also begins to assess the significance of the statement. Begins to analyse why there are different historical interpretations. Level 7 Balanced answer with supported conclusion whereby the pupil offers his/her own opinion. Assesses the significance of the quotation and relates it to their own life/ life in 2007. Reaches a substantiated conclusion. Level 8 Balanced answer with supported conclusion whereby the pupils offers his/her own opinion. Well-structured narrative, description and explanation making appropriate use of dates/terms. NB Max L5 if essay does not discuss cases of at least 4 soldiers who received a pardon Max L5 if essay does not include discussion on historical debate around ‘Shot at Dawn’ Max L5 if essay does not include factually correct information