SlideShare une entreprise Scribd logo
1  sur  28
PhD Evaluation The Progression Points Dr Sonja Tomaskovic Dr Raju Pathmeswaran     Developed by Dr Victoria Sheppard
What are Progression Points for? ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],Sisyphus  from   www.mythweb.com/encyc/zooms/sisyphus.gif
Today’s Session ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Criteria ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Research Skills ,[object Object],[object Object]
Understanding and Knowledge ,[object Object],[object Object]
Project Design and Management ,[object Object],[object Object]
Originality ,[object Object],[object Object]
Timeline for Salford full time PhD Year 1 Learning Agreement 3 month Year 2 Year 3 Interim Assessment 12 – 15 months Internal Evaluation  – 12 months after IA Annual Report Annual Report Annual Report Self Evaluation Report Self Evaluation Report Self Evaluation Report Write-up and assessment period
Part time model Learning Agreement 6 months Interim Assessment 20-26 months Internal Evaluation 20 months after IA Year 1 Year 2 Year 3 Year 4 Year 5 + 2 Write up and assessment Annual Report Annual Report Annual Report Annual Report Annual Report Self-Evaluation Self-Evaluation Self-Evaluation Self-Evaluation Self-Evaluation
Forms ,[object Object],www.pg.salford.ac.uk/page/general_forms Image © Luxomedia  http://www.flickr.com/photos/videolux/2389320345/
1. Learning Agreement ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
2. Annual Reports ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Why have annual reports? ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
PGR: ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
3. Interim Assessment ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Requirements ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Panel Evaluates: ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],Image © benprks  http://www.flickr.com/photos/rivet/2767279500/
IA Outcomes Continue with PhD Repeat Interim Assessment (3 months) OR  Terminate candidature Transfer to different programme – MPhil, MRes, MSc by Research Image © SLightlynorth  http://www.flickr.com/photos/slightlynorth/677514537/
4. Internal Evaluation ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
IE requirements ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Panel Evaluates: ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
IE Outcomes Continue with PhD Repeat Internal Evaluation (3 months) OR  Terminate candidature Transfer to different programme – MPhil, MRes, MSc by Research
Arrangements  ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Testimonials The presentation gave an overview of my report but concentrated on certain aspects of it   The assessors did not pick up on the things I thought they would […] Nobody picked up on ontological or etymological issues. We discussed in some detail a semantic definition of one of my central terms. We all realised that this will need some further work.   In the end, it was much more relaxed than I thought it would be. It was more a guidance than an examination.
Advice from researchers ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
And a few more… ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Please give us your FEEDBACK about this session: For any further queries ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]

Contenu connexe

Tendances

Showcase AP Research to Students
Showcase AP Research to StudentsShowcase AP Research to Students
Showcase AP Research to Students
Serena Magrogan
 
2010 Developing high quality online doctoral programs2
2010 Developing high quality online doctoral programs22010 Developing high quality online doctoral programs2
2010 Developing high quality online doctoral programs2
WCET
 
National university assessment process
National university assessment processNational university assessment process
National university assessment process
Ashley Kovacs
 
Graduation Project Overview
Graduation Project OverviewGraduation Project Overview
Graduation Project Overview
abhoskins
 

Tendances (19)

NCA Residency Session 7 March 8 2017
NCA Residency Session 7 March 8 2017NCA Residency Session 7 March 8 2017
NCA Residency Session 7 March 8 2017
 
Programme Evaluation in Open and Distance Learning
Programme Evaluation in Open and Distance LearningProgramme Evaluation in Open and Distance Learning
Programme Evaluation in Open and Distance Learning
 
Strengthening the internship performance review for slideshare
Strengthening the internship performance review for slideshareStrengthening the internship performance review for slideshare
Strengthening the internship performance review for slideshare
 
Documenting Research for P&T: What I wished I had known!
Documenting Research for P&T: What I wished I had known!Documenting Research for P&T: What I wished I had known!
Documenting Research for P&T: What I wished I had known!
 
Learning Outcomes
Learning Outcomes Learning Outcomes
Learning Outcomes
 
Engineering Sciences
Engineering SciencesEngineering Sciences
Engineering Sciences
 
Reimagining and Reinforcing Student Success Into Career Success Across the Cu...
Reimagining and Reinforcing Student Success Into Career Success Across the Cu...Reimagining and Reinforcing Student Success Into Career Success Across the Cu...
Reimagining and Reinforcing Student Success Into Career Success Across the Cu...
 
Professional Portfolio
Professional PortfolioProfessional Portfolio
Professional Portfolio
 
Showcase AP Research to Students
Showcase AP Research to StudentsShowcase AP Research to Students
Showcase AP Research to Students
 
Viewpoints Pitch
Viewpoints PitchViewpoints Pitch
Viewpoints Pitch
 
Raising achievement and ensuring success for students of History
Raising achievement and ensuring success for students of HistoryRaising achievement and ensuring success for students of History
Raising achievement and ensuring success for students of History
 
Nicol Ripon NOCN presentation
Nicol Ripon NOCN presentationNicol Ripon NOCN presentation
Nicol Ripon NOCN presentation
 
Case study shar e-fest
Case study shar e-festCase study shar e-fest
Case study shar e-fest
 
2010 Developing high quality online doctoral programs2
2010 Developing high quality online doctoral programs22010 Developing high quality online doctoral programs2
2010 Developing high quality online doctoral programs2
 
National university assessment process
National university assessment processNational university assessment process
National university assessment process
 
Graduation Project Overview
Graduation Project OverviewGraduation Project Overview
Graduation Project Overview
 
Programme Evaluation Article review by Cosme Zinsou Odjo
Programme Evaluation Article review by Cosme Zinsou OdjoProgramme Evaluation Article review by Cosme Zinsou Odjo
Programme Evaluation Article review by Cosme Zinsou Odjo
 
Completing the Assessment Cycle
Completing the Assessment CycleCompleting the Assessment Cycle
Completing the Assessment Cycle
 
Capstone Assessment Project
Capstone Assessment ProjectCapstone Assessment Project
Capstone Assessment Project
 

En vedette

Six months progress review (PhD work)
Six months progress review (PhD work)Six months progress review (PhD work)
Six months progress review (PhD work)
University of Melbourne, Australia
 
World Economic Forum - Annual Report 2007/2008
World Economic Forum - Annual Report 2007/2008World Economic Forum - Annual Report 2007/2008
World Economic Forum - Annual Report 2007/2008
WorldEconomicForumDavos
 
Dissertation oral defense presentation
Dissertation   oral defense presentationDissertation   oral defense presentation
Dissertation oral defense presentation
Dr. Naomi Mangatu
 

En vedette (8)

PhD Annual Report first page & detailed table of contents
PhD Annual Report first page & detailed table of contentsPhD Annual Report first page & detailed table of contents
PhD Annual Report first page & detailed table of contents
 
1 Year PhD Presentation
1 Year PhD Presentation1 Year PhD Presentation
1 Year PhD Presentation
 
Six months progress review (PhD work)
Six months progress review (PhD work)Six months progress review (PhD work)
Six months progress review (PhD work)
 
AIP-Maize Annual Progress Revieew
AIP-Maize Annual Progress RevieewAIP-Maize Annual Progress Revieew
AIP-Maize Annual Progress Revieew
 
Presentation in the working seminar
Presentation in the working seminarPresentation in the working seminar
Presentation in the working seminar
 
My thesis progress presentation
My thesis progress presentationMy thesis progress presentation
My thesis progress presentation
 
World Economic Forum - Annual Report 2007/2008
World Economic Forum - Annual Report 2007/2008World Economic Forum - Annual Report 2007/2008
World Economic Forum - Annual Report 2007/2008
 
Dissertation oral defense presentation
Dissertation   oral defense presentationDissertation   oral defense presentation
Dissertation oral defense presentation
 

Similaire à Progression Points

Assessment Brief ENG7142 INPER 25%.pdf
Assessment Brief ENG7142 INPER 25%.pdfAssessment Brief ENG7142 INPER 25%.pdf
Assessment Brief ENG7142 INPER 25%.pdf
frankdavis51
 
Aims internship project - presentation & preparation - guidelines
Aims   internship project - presentation & preparation - guidelinesAims   internship project - presentation & preparation - guidelines
Aims internship project - presentation & preparation - guidelines
surekha pawar
 
School of Social Sciences1Course title Research Methods (C3.docx
School of Social Sciences1Course title Research Methods (C3.docxSchool of Social Sciences1Course title Research Methods (C3.docx
School of Social Sciences1Course title Research Methods (C3.docx
jeffsrosalyn
 
Criteria-2-–-Teaching-Learning-and-Evaluation-NAAC-Perspectives-by-Prof.-Rajm...
Criteria-2-–-Teaching-Learning-and-Evaluation-NAAC-Perspectives-by-Prof.-Rajm...Criteria-2-–-Teaching-Learning-and-Evaluation-NAAC-Perspectives-by-Prof.-Rajm...
Criteria-2-–-Teaching-Learning-and-Evaluation-NAAC-Perspectives-by-Prof.-Rajm...
taruian
 

Similaire à Progression Points (20)

Major-Project Guideline collage industrial project
Major-Project Guideline collage industrial projectMajor-Project Guideline collage industrial project
Major-Project Guideline collage industrial project
 
Assessment Brief ENG7142 INPER 25%.pdf
Assessment Brief ENG7142 INPER 25%.pdfAssessment Brief ENG7142 INPER 25%.pdf
Assessment Brief ENG7142 INPER 25%.pdf
 
Aims internship project - presentation & preparation - guidelines
Aims   internship project - presentation & preparation - guidelinesAims   internship project - presentation & preparation - guidelines
Aims internship project - presentation & preparation - guidelines
 
School of Social Sciences1Course title Research Methods (C3.docx
School of Social Sciences1Course title Research Methods (C3.docxSchool of Social Sciences1Course title Research Methods (C3.docx
School of Social Sciences1Course title Research Methods (C3.docx
 
Supervision Skills on Postgraduate Students
Supervision Skills on Postgraduate StudentsSupervision Skills on Postgraduate Students
Supervision Skills on Postgraduate Students
 
Monitoring and Supervising Curriculum & Curriculum Revision and Evaluation
Monitoring and Supervising Curriculum & Curriculum Revision and EvaluationMonitoring and Supervising Curriculum & Curriculum Revision and Evaluation
Monitoring and Supervising Curriculum & Curriculum Revision and Evaluation
 
Assessment as learning
Assessment as learningAssessment as learning
Assessment as learning
 
Syllabus-Term Paper.pdf
Syllabus-Term Paper.pdfSyllabus-Term Paper.pdf
Syllabus-Term Paper.pdf
 
OBE pdf [Autosaved].ppt
OBE pdf [Autosaved].pptOBE pdf [Autosaved].ppt
OBE pdf [Autosaved].ppt
 
Guidelines for SAR Writing
Guidelines for SAR WritingGuidelines for SAR Writing
Guidelines for SAR Writing
 
Criteria-2-–-Teaching-Learning-and-Evaluation-NAAC-Perspectives-by-Prof.-Rajm...
Criteria-2-–-Teaching-Learning-and-Evaluation-NAAC-Perspectives-by-Prof.-Rajm...Criteria-2-–-Teaching-Learning-and-Evaluation-NAAC-Perspectives-by-Prof.-Rajm...
Criteria-2-–-Teaching-Learning-and-Evaluation-NAAC-Perspectives-by-Prof.-Rajm...
 
04 course design development phase
04 course design   development phase04 course design   development phase
04 course design development phase
 
Guidelines for SAR Writing
Guidelines for SAR WritingGuidelines for SAR Writing
Guidelines for SAR Writing
 
Probationary Assessment Workshop2 2010 Gail Lewis
Probationary Assessment Workshop2 2010   Gail LewisProbationary Assessment Workshop2 2010   Gail Lewis
Probationary Assessment Workshop2 2010 Gail Lewis
 
Assessment for Learning I
Assessment for Learning IAssessment for Learning I
Assessment for Learning I
 
Workshop: Setting the Foundations for an Iterative Course Evolution Model – A...
Workshop: Setting the Foundations for an Iterative Course Evolution Model – A...Workshop: Setting the Foundations for an Iterative Course Evolution Model – A...
Workshop: Setting the Foundations for an Iterative Course Evolution Model – A...
 
Learning Outcomes.pdf
Learning Outcomes.pdfLearning Outcomes.pdf
Learning Outcomes.pdf
 
101 - Setting up an in-house mentoring scheme, a case study
101 - Setting up an in-house mentoring scheme, a case study101 - Setting up an in-house mentoring scheme, a case study
101 - Setting up an in-house mentoring scheme, a case study
 
Portfolio presentation
Portfolio presentationPortfolio presentation
Portfolio presentation
 
Module outline march 2015
Module outline march 2015Module outline march 2015
Module outline march 2015
 

Plus de Research & Graduate College, University of Salford

Plus de Research & Graduate College, University of Salford (20)

Social Media Enterprise
Social Media Enterprise Social Media Enterprise
Social Media Enterprise
 
Abstract writing
Abstract writingAbstract writing
Abstract writing
 
PhD Progression Points
PhD Progression PointsPhD Progression Points
PhD Progression Points
 
How do I make myself "Employable"?
How do I make myself "Employable"? How do I make myself "Employable"?
How do I make myself "Employable"?
 
Micro(blogging)
Micro(blogging)Micro(blogging)
Micro(blogging)
 
Supervisors workshop
Supervisors workshopSupervisors workshop
Supervisors workshop
 
Broadeninghorizonstaster
BroadeninghorizonstasterBroadeninghorizonstaster
Broadeninghorizonstaster
 
#PGfuturesintroduction2011
#PGfuturesintroduction2011#PGfuturesintroduction2011
#PGfuturesintroduction2011
 
July2011 PRISM CVs
July2011 PRISM CVsJuly2011 PRISM CVs
July2011 PRISM CVs
 
PG Futures 2011 Creative Job Search ppt 21 06-11
PG Futures 2011 Creative Job Search ppt 21 06-11PG Futures 2011 Creative Job Search ppt 21 06-11
PG Futures 2011 Creative Job Search ppt 21 06-11
 
Pgfutures2011
Pgfutures2011Pgfutures2011
Pgfutures2011
 
#pgfutures2011
#pgfutures2011 #pgfutures2011
#pgfutures2011
 
REDS guide to networking
REDS guide to networkingREDS guide to networking
REDS guide to networking
 
Pgcap feedback-on-summative-assessment group powerpoint
Pgcap feedback-on-summative-assessment group powerpointPgcap feedback-on-summative-assessment group powerpoint
Pgcap feedback-on-summative-assessment group powerpoint
 
Online copyright
Online copyrightOnline copyright
Online copyright
 
Thinking about postgraduate study 2011
Thinking about postgraduate study 2011Thinking about postgraduate study 2011
Thinking about postgraduate study 2011
 
Career Planning: Key Steps
Career Planning: Key StepsCareer Planning: Key Steps
Career Planning: Key Steps
 
Ra how to
Ra how toRa how to
Ra how to
 
Vice chancellor's Networking Event 2010
Vice chancellor's Networking Event 2010Vice chancellor's Networking Event 2010
Vice chancellor's Networking Event 2010
 
Career stories of international graduates
Career stories of international graduatesCareer stories of international graduates
Career stories of international graduates
 

Progression Points

  • 1. PhD Evaluation The Progression Points Dr Sonja Tomaskovic Dr Raju Pathmeswaran Developed by Dr Victoria Sheppard
  • 2.
  • 3.
  • 4.
  • 5.
  • 6.
  • 7.
  • 8.
  • 9. Timeline for Salford full time PhD Year 1 Learning Agreement 3 month Year 2 Year 3 Interim Assessment 12 – 15 months Internal Evaluation – 12 months after IA Annual Report Annual Report Annual Report Self Evaluation Report Self Evaluation Report Self Evaluation Report Write-up and assessment period
  • 10. Part time model Learning Agreement 6 months Interim Assessment 20-26 months Internal Evaluation 20 months after IA Year 1 Year 2 Year 3 Year 4 Year 5 + 2 Write up and assessment Annual Report Annual Report Annual Report Annual Report Annual Report Self-Evaluation Self-Evaluation Self-Evaluation Self-Evaluation Self-Evaluation
  • 11.
  • 12.
  • 13.
  • 14.
  • 15.
  • 16.
  • 17.
  • 18.
  • 19. IA Outcomes Continue with PhD Repeat Interim Assessment (3 months) OR Terminate candidature Transfer to different programme – MPhil, MRes, MSc by Research Image © SLightlynorth http://www.flickr.com/photos/slightlynorth/677514537/
  • 20.
  • 21.
  • 22.
  • 23. IE Outcomes Continue with PhD Repeat Internal Evaluation (3 months) OR Terminate candidature Transfer to different programme – MPhil, MRes, MSc by Research
  • 24.
  • 25. Testimonials The presentation gave an overview of my report but concentrated on certain aspects of it The assessors did not pick up on the things I thought they would […] Nobody picked up on ontological or etymological issues. We discussed in some detail a semantic definition of one of my central terms. We all realised that this will need some further work. In the end, it was much more relaxed than I thought it would be. It was more a guidance than an examination.
  • 26.
  • 27.
  • 28.