A brief presentation on the improper special education placement, its impact on delinquent behavior acquisition and the importance of culturally responsive teaching. This presentation is designed as a foundation for current research into the Concentric Zone Hypothesis. Seeking a dissertation mentor to further explore this research.
2. WHAT IS CULTURE?
A SET OF BELIEFS, RELIGION, SOCIAL NORMS OF A GROUP OF PEOPLE.
3. ARE PEOPLE WITHIN A CULTURE THE SAME?
WITHIN THE BLACK COMMUNITY, THE CULTURE IS AS DIVERSE AS OUR HAIR TEXTURE, OUR
COMPLEXIONS, AND FACIAL FEATURES. LESSONS SHOULD BE CATERED TO THE SPECIFIC SUBCULTURE,
NOT THE MAINSTREAM CONCEPT OF RACE.
4. STUDENT DEMOGRAPHICS
BALTIMORE CITY SCHOOLS
55% LOW INCOME
80% AFRICAN AMERICAN
14% SPECIAL EDUCATION
JUVENILE DETENTION
94% AFRICAN AMERICAN
YOUTH OF COLOR ARE OVER-
REPRESENTED
MOST ARE FROM LOW-INCOME AREAS
5. BIRDS OF A
FEATHER…
SEVERAL THEORIES EXIST, ADDRESSING
THE ACQUISITION OF DELINQUENT
BEHAVIORS IN CHILDREN. FOR THE
PURPOSES OF THIS PRESENTATION, THE
CONCENTRIC HYPOTHESIS AND THE
SOCIAL LEARNING THEORY.
6. THEORIES OF DELINQUENT BEHAVIOR
CONCENTRIC ZONE HYPOTHESIS
• AREAS WITH HIGHER CONCENTRATIONS OF
JUVENILE DELINQUENCY
• HIGHER POPULATION, PER CAPITA
• LIMITED RESOURCES
• AREAS WITH HIGH TRANSIENT POPULATION
SOCIAL LEARNING THEORY
• CHILDREN LEARN DELINQUENT BEHAVIORS FROM
ONE ANOTHER
• DELINQUENT BEHAVIORS ARE REWARDED
• BEHAVIORS COULD BE LEARNED IN SCHOOL
• BEHAVIORS COULD BE ACQUIRED FROM
ENVIRONMENT
9. STUDENT PROFILES
STUDENT A
• PARENTS ARE MARRIED
• MOTHER IS A “STAY AT HOME” MOM; FATHER WORKS THREE
JOBS
• LIVES IN SECTION 8 HOUSING, NEXT TO THE “PROJECTS”
• READS AT A THIRD GRADE LEVEL IN THE SEVENTH GRADE
• PLACED IN SPECIAL EDUCATION
STUDENT B
• FATHER IS INCARCERATED
• MOTHER IS SELF-EMPLOYED
• LIVES IN A WORKING CLASS NEIGHBORHOOD
• READS AT A FIFTH GRADE LEVEL IN THE SEVENTH GRADE
• PLACED IN SPECIAL EDUCATION
10. WHO IS THE MOST LIKELY TO DEVELOP DELINQUENT
BEHAVIORS IN THE CLASSROOM?
11. SPECIAL EDUCATION TO JUVENILE DELINQUENCY:
THE “NOT-SO” BIG LEAP
BASED ON WHAT WE KNOW OF BEHAVIOR, IT IS NOT HARD TO CONCLUDE THAT CHILDREN WILL
ACQUIRE MALADAPTIVE BEHAVIORS FROM EACH OTHER.
12. SUBCULTURAL THEORY OF DELINQUENCY
• ALBERT COHEN DISCUSSED THE SUBCULTURAL THEORY OF DELINQUENCY IN 1955. BASED ON HIS
RESEARCH, COHEN ASSERTS THAT WITHIN CULTURES, SUBCULTURES HAVE THEIR OWN SET OF
BELIEFS AND VALUE SYSTEMS.
13. THE INTERSECTION OF CRT AND DELINQUENCY
• CULTURAL RESPONSIVE TEACHING PLACES EMPHASIS ON CULTURAL REPRESENTATION IN THE
LITERATURE, AND PREPARING LESSONS THAT ARE CULTURALLY APPROPRIATE.
• HOWEVER, ATTENTION SHOULD BE GIVEN TO THE SUBCULTURE IN WHICH THE CHILD RESIDES.
• BASED ON COHEN’S THEORY, A CHILD’S SUBCULTURE HAS A HEAVIER INFLUENCE, THAN THE
CHILD’S PERCEIVED MAINSTREAM CULTURE.
• CHILDREN RESIDING IN A COMMUNITY WHERE EDUCATION IS NOT VALUED, WILL NOT APPRECIATE
THE IMPACT OF REPRESENTATION, IN THE SAME WAY AS A CHILD OF THE SAME ETHNICITY FROM A
COMMUNITY WHERE EDUCATION IS REVERED.
• THESE CHILDREN ARE TYPICALLY PLACED IN SPECIAL EDUCATION, DROP OUT, AND CONTINUE
WITH DELINQUENT BEHAVIORS.
14. (SUB)CULTURALLY RESPONSIVE TEACHING
• UNDERSTAND THE COMMUNITY SURROUNDING THE SCHOOL.
• CONNECT WITH PARENTS AND COMMUNITY LEADERS.
• UNDERSTAND THE CULTURE OF THE SCHOOL.
• CREATE LESSONS THAT ARE DIVERSE IN NATURE: DO ACTIVITIES THAT PROMOTE CRITICAL THINKING
SKILLS.
• DO NOT LOWER EXPECTATIONS.
• INTRODUCE RELATABLE EDUCATIONAL RESOURCES, THAT ARE AGE APPROPRIATE, AND THEN BUILD.
• CREATE MORE “OUT OF CLASSROOM” EXPERIENCES.
16. CONTACT INFORMATION AND SOCIAL NETWORKS
SHANNON MCFADDEN, MS
EDUCATIONAL ADVOCATE AND BLOGGER
IG: FUTUREACHIEVERSCENTER
BLOG: WWW.CLASSROOMACTIVISM.BLOGSPOT.COM
EMAIL: FUTUREACHIEVERSCENTERINC@GMAIL.COM
18. REFERENCES, CONT.
DEMARTINO, C. H., RICE, R. E., & SALTZ, R. (2015). AN APPLIED TEST OF THE SOCIAL LEARNING
THEORY OF DEVIANCE TO COLLEGE ALCOHOL USE. JOURNAL OF HEALTH COMMUNICATION, 20,
479-490.
HEDGER, J. (2017). A “MOM” AND “POP” CONFINEMENT: HOW FAMILIES CAN AND MUST GET
INVOLVED IN THE JUVENILE SYSTEM. CORRECTIONS TODAY, 2, 32-36.
GRAVES, S. L., & YE, F. F. (2017). ARE SPECIAL EDUCATION LABELS ACCURATE FOR BLACK
CHILDREN? RACIAL DIFFERENCES IN ACADEMIC TRAJECTORIES OF YOUTH DIAGNOSED WITH
SPECIFIC LEARNING AND INTELLECTUAL DISABILITIES. JOURNAL OF BLACK PSYCHOLOGY,
43(2), 192-213.
Notes de l'éditeur
Have participants describe their individual cultures. Have them start with the general, and then branch out, discussing their various subcultures.
Have them discuss and describe their different educational environments and have each compare and contrast. Understanding how differences within a culture impact CRT. It is more than just placing a black person in front of a child.
Discuss how over 70% of juvenile cases are in high school, juxtaposed with the 70% graduation rate of Baltimore City African American students. Lead a discussion as to what may be the underlying reason, as only 14% of children are in special education, but only 15% can read on, or above grade level.
After they describe each student, discuss how they perceive their subcultures to differ.
Have the participants tell why children from certain subcultures are more likely to be placed in special education, and then as they become older, the chances of delinquent behaviors and juvenile incarceration increase.
How would an educator connect the subculture to the CRT lessons they already use.
Discuss the two boys in the beginning. Have the participants create different narratives for each boy. And then have them discuss how the through different subcultures, the boys will do better, or worse in school. Have them point out how the disconnect between teachers and students, and nut understanding the subculture of students, creates racial disparities in juvenile delinquency and special education placement.
Get to know the parents, the neighborhood people. Invite them in. Do not treat them as outsiders. Understand that majority of the parents care, they just feel inferior, especially with white teachers.
Create neighborhood partnerships and activities, that are educational and non-educational in nature.
Look at the school demographical data. Look at how many children are left to care for others. Determine how many are free and reduced lunch, and then determine how that would impact your learning. Create resources for parents.
GET OUT OF THE CLASSROOM
A lot of children who are below grade level are there because of lack of exposure. Keep expectations high. Just create different avenues to engage. Allow children to explore the lesson in their own way, and engage. Especially the other ones. The purpose is for them to learn and understand. The method is not always important.
Instead of teaching Shakespeare by using the 1997 Romeo and Juliet, use Othello. When teaching poetry, don’t always use Langston Hughes and Nikki Giovanni. Understand that rap is prose. Movies are good for comprehension and asking questions. *Reel Talk*
As stated earlier, lack of exposure causes more educational problems. It is believed that testing is more important, and parents will expose their children to certain things. Parents may not be able to take their children places. The school must provide that exposure, to introduce new things into the subculture, and therefore make teaching easier.
Subculture is overlooked when addressing CRT. It is important to understand the culture of children… Failure to instill a separate set of values and beliefs will make CRT ineffective, as education is not valued, but delinquent behavior is. A 70% graduation rate and 70% incarceration rate don’t lie.