Soumettre la recherche
Mettre en ligne
Comparison and selection among alternatives
•
Télécharger en tant que PPT, PDF
•
0 j'aime
•
1,126 vues
Nafis Ahmad
Suivre
Comparison and selection among mutually exclusive alternatives
Lire moins
Lire la suite
Ingénierie
Affichage du diaporama
Signaler
Partager
Affichage du diaporama
Signaler
Partager
1 sur 25
Télécharger maintenant
Recommandé
Evaluating a Single Project
Evaluating a Single Project
Nafis Ahmad
Chapter 6 annual worth analysis
Chapter 6 annual worth analysis
Bich Lien Pham
Chapter 17 after-tax economic analysis
Chapter 17 after-tax economic analysis
Bich Lien Pham
Chapter 11 replacement & retention decisions
Chapter 11 replacement & retention decisions
Bich Lien Pham
Chapter 14 effects of inflation
Chapter 14 effects of inflation
Bich Lien Pham
Chapter 5 present worth analysis
Chapter 5 present worth analysis
Bich Lien Pham
Chapter 5 present worth analysis -with examples
Chapter 5 present worth analysis -with examples
Abdulaziz AlSuwaidi
Chapter 6&7 annual worth analysis & ror lo3b
Chapter 6&7 annual worth analysis & ror lo3b
Abdulaziz AlSuwaidi
Recommandé
Evaluating a Single Project
Evaluating a Single Project
Nafis Ahmad
Chapter 6 annual worth analysis
Chapter 6 annual worth analysis
Bich Lien Pham
Chapter 17 after-tax economic analysis
Chapter 17 after-tax economic analysis
Bich Lien Pham
Chapter 11 replacement & retention decisions
Chapter 11 replacement & retention decisions
Bich Lien Pham
Chapter 14 effects of inflation
Chapter 14 effects of inflation
Bich Lien Pham
Chapter 5 present worth analysis
Chapter 5 present worth analysis
Bich Lien Pham
Chapter 5 present worth analysis -with examples
Chapter 5 present worth analysis -with examples
Abdulaziz AlSuwaidi
Chapter 6&7 annual worth analysis & ror lo3b
Chapter 6&7 annual worth analysis & ror lo3b
Abdulaziz AlSuwaidi
8. Rate of return analysis
8. Rate of return analysis
Mohsin Siddique
Chapter 5 present worth analysis -with examples
Chapter 5 present worth analysis -with examples
Abdulaziz AlSuwaidi
Engineering Economy
Engineering Economy
Justine Asuncion
Chapter 3 combining factors
Chapter 3 combining factors
Bich Lien Pham
Chapter 2 factors, effect of time & interest on money
Chapter 2 factors, effect of time & interest on money
Bich Lien Pham
Chapter 8 ror analysis for multiple alternatives
Chapter 8 ror analysis for multiple alternatives
Bich Lien Pham
Chapter 4 nominal & effective interest rates
Chapter 4 nominal & effective interest rates
Bich Lien Pham
Chapter-4 Time value of money
Chapter-4 Time value of money
Bibek Paudyal
Time value of money
Time value of money
Nafis Ahmad
Chapter 5 present worth analysis
Chapter 5 present worth analysis
Bich Lien Pham
Future Worth method
Future Worth method
Suhail Ahmed
Chapter 16 depreciation methods
Chapter 16 depreciation methods
Bich Lien Pham
Chapter 12 independent projects & budget limitation
Chapter 12 independent projects & budget limitation
Bich Lien Pham
6. present worth analysis
6. present worth analysis
Mohsin Siddique
Comparing alternatives in Engineering Economics and Management
Comparing alternatives in Engineering Economics and Management
Nzar Braim
Module-4:Introduction to engineering economy,Interest and time value of money...
Module-4:Introduction to engineering economy,Interest and time value of money...
VIDYA VIKAS INSTITUTE OF ENGINEERING AND TECHNOLOGY
Chapter 1 foundations of engineering economy
Chapter 1 foundations of engineering economy
Bich Lien Pham
Predicting 28 Days Compressive Strength of Concrete from 7 Days Test Result
Predicting 28 Days Compressive Strength of Concrete from 7 Days Test Result
Monjurul Shuvo
economy Chapter6 2011_by louy Al hami
economy Chapter6 2011_by louy Al hami
Louy Alhamy
1 introduction to engineering economics
1 introduction to engineering economics
Mohsin Siddique
Replacement analysis
Replacement analysis
Nafis Ahmad
Evaluating a single project
Evaluating a single project
Nafis Ahmad
Contenu connexe
Tendances
8. Rate of return analysis
8. Rate of return analysis
Mohsin Siddique
Chapter 5 present worth analysis -with examples
Chapter 5 present worth analysis -with examples
Abdulaziz AlSuwaidi
Engineering Economy
Engineering Economy
Justine Asuncion
Chapter 3 combining factors
Chapter 3 combining factors
Bich Lien Pham
Chapter 2 factors, effect of time & interest on money
Chapter 2 factors, effect of time & interest on money
Bich Lien Pham
Chapter 8 ror analysis for multiple alternatives
Chapter 8 ror analysis for multiple alternatives
Bich Lien Pham
Chapter 4 nominal & effective interest rates
Chapter 4 nominal & effective interest rates
Bich Lien Pham
Chapter-4 Time value of money
Chapter-4 Time value of money
Bibek Paudyal
Time value of money
Time value of money
Nafis Ahmad
Chapter 5 present worth analysis
Chapter 5 present worth analysis
Bich Lien Pham
Future Worth method
Future Worth method
Suhail Ahmed
Chapter 16 depreciation methods
Chapter 16 depreciation methods
Bich Lien Pham
Chapter 12 independent projects & budget limitation
Chapter 12 independent projects & budget limitation
Bich Lien Pham
6. present worth analysis
6. present worth analysis
Mohsin Siddique
Comparing alternatives in Engineering Economics and Management
Comparing alternatives in Engineering Economics and Management
Nzar Braim
Module-4:Introduction to engineering economy,Interest and time value of money...
Module-4:Introduction to engineering economy,Interest and time value of money...
VIDYA VIKAS INSTITUTE OF ENGINEERING AND TECHNOLOGY
Chapter 1 foundations of engineering economy
Chapter 1 foundations of engineering economy
Bich Lien Pham
Predicting 28 Days Compressive Strength of Concrete from 7 Days Test Result
Predicting 28 Days Compressive Strength of Concrete from 7 Days Test Result
Monjurul Shuvo
economy Chapter6 2011_by louy Al hami
economy Chapter6 2011_by louy Al hami
Louy Alhamy
1 introduction to engineering economics
1 introduction to engineering economics
Mohsin Siddique
Tendances
(20)
8. Rate of return analysis
8. Rate of return analysis
Chapter 5 present worth analysis -with examples
Chapter 5 present worth analysis -with examples
Engineering Economy
Engineering Economy
Chapter 3 combining factors
Chapter 3 combining factors
Chapter 2 factors, effect of time & interest on money
Chapter 2 factors, effect of time & interest on money
Chapter 8 ror analysis for multiple alternatives
Chapter 8 ror analysis for multiple alternatives
Chapter 4 nominal & effective interest rates
Chapter 4 nominal & effective interest rates
Chapter-4 Time value of money
Chapter-4 Time value of money
Time value of money
Time value of money
Chapter 5 present worth analysis
Chapter 5 present worth analysis
Future Worth method
Future Worth method
Chapter 16 depreciation methods
Chapter 16 depreciation methods
Chapter 12 independent projects & budget limitation
Chapter 12 independent projects & budget limitation
6. present worth analysis
6. present worth analysis
Comparing alternatives in Engineering Economics and Management
Comparing alternatives in Engineering Economics and Management
Module-4:Introduction to engineering economy,Interest and time value of money...
Module-4:Introduction to engineering economy,Interest and time value of money...
Chapter 1 foundations of engineering economy
Chapter 1 foundations of engineering economy
Predicting 28 Days Compressive Strength of Concrete from 7 Days Test Result
Predicting 28 Days Compressive Strength of Concrete from 7 Days Test Result
economy Chapter6 2011_by louy Al hami
economy Chapter6 2011_by louy Al hami
1 introduction to engineering economics
1 introduction to engineering economics
Similaire à Comparison and selection among alternatives
Replacement analysis
Replacement analysis
Nafis Ahmad
Evaluating a single project
Evaluating a single project
Nafis Ahmad
Benefit-Cost (B-C) ratio analysis
Benefit-Cost (B-C) ratio analysis
Nafis Ahmad
6232942.ppt
6232942.ppt
pisal3
Chapter 4 Application of Money-Time Relationship.ppt
Chapter 4 Application of Money-Time Relationship.ppt
KrishnaGupta191
Cost concepts and design economics
Cost concepts and design economics
Nafis Ahmad
Breakeven & sensitivity analysis
Breakeven & sensitivity analysis
Nafis Ahmad
Depreciation and income taxes
Depreciation and income taxes
Nafis Ahmad
Introduction to engineering economy
Introduction to engineering economy
Nafis Ahmad
Chapter 1 introduction to engineering economy
Chapter 1 introduction to engineering economy
Fhatiha Atika
Engineering_Economic_14th_by_William_Sul.ppt
Engineering_Economic_14th_by_William_Sul.ppt
PRAVAKARBOGATI1
1 Introduction to Engineering Economy.ppt
1 Introduction to Engineering Economy.ppt
bb3538493
chap007.ppt
chap007.ppt
narman1402
Aggregate spending _saving__and_consumpt
Aggregate spending _saving__and_consumpt
agjohnson
Accounting by Meigs & Meigs
Accounting by Meigs & Meigs
Shakeel Ahmed
Peirson business finance10e_power_point_05 (2)
Peirson business finance10e_power_point_05 (2)
Giriraj Srinivasan
Engineering Economy Chapter 3.pdf
Engineering Economy Chapter 3.pdf
bcimenoglu
Theories for value
Theories for value
Gerard Ilott
The Rise of the Yieldco
The Rise of the Yieldco
Tom Konrad
Kuliah bab6
Kuliah bab6
Dell Cekidelldell
Similaire à Comparison and selection among alternatives
(20)
Replacement analysis
Replacement analysis
Evaluating a single project
Evaluating a single project
Benefit-Cost (B-C) ratio analysis
Benefit-Cost (B-C) ratio analysis
6232942.ppt
6232942.ppt
Chapter 4 Application of Money-Time Relationship.ppt
Chapter 4 Application of Money-Time Relationship.ppt
Cost concepts and design economics
Cost concepts and design economics
Breakeven & sensitivity analysis
Breakeven & sensitivity analysis
Depreciation and income taxes
Depreciation and income taxes
Introduction to engineering economy
Introduction to engineering economy
Chapter 1 introduction to engineering economy
Chapter 1 introduction to engineering economy
Engineering_Economic_14th_by_William_Sul.ppt
Engineering_Economic_14th_by_William_Sul.ppt
1 Introduction to Engineering Economy.ppt
1 Introduction to Engineering Economy.ppt
chap007.ppt
chap007.ppt
Aggregate spending _saving__and_consumpt
Aggregate spending _saving__and_consumpt
Accounting by Meigs & Meigs
Accounting by Meigs & Meigs
Peirson business finance10e_power_point_05 (2)
Peirson business finance10e_power_point_05 (2)
Engineering Economy Chapter 3.pdf
Engineering Economy Chapter 3.pdf
Theories for value
Theories for value
The Rise of the Yieldco
The Rise of the Yieldco
Kuliah bab6
Kuliah bab6
Plus de Nafis Ahmad
Introduction CIM
Introduction CIM
Nafis Ahmad
Safety management
Safety management
Nafis Ahmad
IPE-431 Machine Tools (Part-C)
IPE-431 Machine Tools (Part-C)
Nafis Ahmad
Automatic Identification and Data Capture Techniques
Automatic Identification and Data Capture Techniques
Nafis Ahmad
Flexible Manufacturing System
Flexible Manufacturing System
Nafis Ahmad
CAD-CAM-CIM
CAD-CAM-CIM
Nafis Ahmad
Decision making considering multi-attributes
Decision making considering multi-attributes
Nafis Ahmad
CADCAM: Data exchange standards
CADCAM: Data exchange standards
Nafis Ahmad
Industrial Robots
Industrial Robots
Nafis Ahmad
Entity Manipulation
Entity Manipulation
Nafis Ahmad
Computer graphics
Computer graphics
Nafis Ahmad
Failure Mode & Effect Analysis
Failure Mode & Effect Analysis
Nafis Ahmad
Reliability Centered Maintenance
Reliability Centered Maintenance
Nafis Ahmad
Corrective maintenance
Corrective maintenance
Nafis Ahmad
Preventive maintenance
Preventive maintenance
Nafis Ahmad
Maintenance management and control
Maintenance management and control
Nafis Ahmad
Introduction to maintenance and safety management
Introduction to maintenance and safety management
Nafis Ahmad
Introduction to CAD/CAM
Introduction to CAD/CAM
Nafis Ahmad
Defining the model
Defining the model
Nafis Ahmad
Techniques for Geometric Modelling
Techniques for Geometric Modelling
Nafis Ahmad
Plus de Nafis Ahmad
(20)
Introduction CIM
Introduction CIM
Safety management
Safety management
IPE-431 Machine Tools (Part-C)
IPE-431 Machine Tools (Part-C)
Automatic Identification and Data Capture Techniques
Automatic Identification and Data Capture Techniques
Flexible Manufacturing System
Flexible Manufacturing System
CAD-CAM-CIM
CAD-CAM-CIM
Decision making considering multi-attributes
Decision making considering multi-attributes
CADCAM: Data exchange standards
CADCAM: Data exchange standards
Industrial Robots
Industrial Robots
Entity Manipulation
Entity Manipulation
Computer graphics
Computer graphics
Failure Mode & Effect Analysis
Failure Mode & Effect Analysis
Reliability Centered Maintenance
Reliability Centered Maintenance
Corrective maintenance
Corrective maintenance
Preventive maintenance
Preventive maintenance
Maintenance management and control
Maintenance management and control
Introduction to maintenance and safety management
Introduction to maintenance and safety management
Introduction to CAD/CAM
Introduction to CAD/CAM
Defining the model
Defining the model
Techniques for Geometric Modelling
Techniques for Geometric Modelling
Dernier
ENCODERS & DECODERS - Digital Electronics - diu swe
ENCODERS & DECODERS - Digital Electronics - diu swe
MohammadAliNayeem
Software Engineering - Modelling Concepts + Class Modelling + Building the An...
Software Engineering - Modelling Concepts + Class Modelling + Building the An...
Prakhyath Rai
KIT-601 Lecture Notes-UNIT-3.pdf Mining Data Stream
KIT-601 Lecture Notes-UNIT-3.pdf Mining Data Stream
Dr. Radhey Shyam
Online resume builder management system project report.pdf
Online resume builder management system project report.pdf
Kamal Acharya
School management system project report.pdf
School management system project report.pdf
Kamal Acharya
Online blood donation management system project.pdf
Online blood donation management system project.pdf
Kamal Acharya
2024 DevOps Pro Europe - Growing at the edge
2024 DevOps Pro Europe - Growing at the edge
Paco Orozco
Planetary Gears of automatic transmission of vehicle
Planetary Gears of automatic transmission of vehicle
ahmedmostafa941217
Peek implant persentation - Copy (1).pdf
Peek implant persentation - Copy (1).pdf
Ayahmorsy
internship exam ppt.pptx on embedded system and IOT
internship exam ppt.pptx on embedded system and IOT
NavyashreeS6
Roushan Kumar Java oracle certificate
Roushan Kumar Java oracle certificate
RaushanKumar452467
NO1 Pandit Black Magic Removal in Uk kala jadu Specialist kala jadu for Love ...
NO1 Pandit Black Magic Removal in Uk kala jadu Specialist kala jadu for Love ...
Amil baba
Online book store management system project.pdf
Online book store management system project.pdf
Kamal Acharya
Arduino based vehicle speed tracker project
Arduino based vehicle speed tracker project
Rased Khan
Research Methodolgy & Intellectual Property Rights Series 1
Research Methodolgy & Intellectual Property Rights Series 1
T.D. Shashikala
Natalia Rutkowska - BIM School Course in Kraków
Natalia Rutkowska - BIM School Course in Kraków
bim.edu.pl
Electrical shop management system project report.pdf
Electrical shop management system project report.pdf
Kamal Acharya
Lecture_8-Digital implementation of analog controller design.pdf
Lecture_8-Digital implementation of analog controller design.pdf
mohamedsamy9878
The battle for RAG, explore the pros and cons of using KnowledgeGraphs and Ve...
The battle for RAG, explore the pros and cons of using KnowledgeGraphs and Ve...
Roi Lipman
BRAKING SYSTEM IN INDIAN RAILWAY AutoCAD DRAWING
BRAKING SYSTEM IN INDIAN RAILWAY AutoCAD DRAWING
KOUSTAV SARKAR
Dernier
(20)
ENCODERS & DECODERS - Digital Electronics - diu swe
ENCODERS & DECODERS - Digital Electronics - diu swe
Software Engineering - Modelling Concepts + Class Modelling + Building the An...
Software Engineering - Modelling Concepts + Class Modelling + Building the An...
KIT-601 Lecture Notes-UNIT-3.pdf Mining Data Stream
KIT-601 Lecture Notes-UNIT-3.pdf Mining Data Stream
Online resume builder management system project report.pdf
Online resume builder management system project report.pdf
School management system project report.pdf
School management system project report.pdf
Online blood donation management system project.pdf
Online blood donation management system project.pdf
2024 DevOps Pro Europe - Growing at the edge
2024 DevOps Pro Europe - Growing at the edge
Planetary Gears of automatic transmission of vehicle
Planetary Gears of automatic transmission of vehicle
Peek implant persentation - Copy (1).pdf
Peek implant persentation - Copy (1).pdf
internship exam ppt.pptx on embedded system and IOT
internship exam ppt.pptx on embedded system and IOT
Roushan Kumar Java oracle certificate
Roushan Kumar Java oracle certificate
NO1 Pandit Black Magic Removal in Uk kala jadu Specialist kala jadu for Love ...
NO1 Pandit Black Magic Removal in Uk kala jadu Specialist kala jadu for Love ...
Online book store management system project.pdf
Online book store management system project.pdf
Arduino based vehicle speed tracker project
Arduino based vehicle speed tracker project
Research Methodolgy & Intellectual Property Rights Series 1
Research Methodolgy & Intellectual Property Rights Series 1
Natalia Rutkowska - BIM School Course in Kraków
Natalia Rutkowska - BIM School Course in Kraków
Electrical shop management system project report.pdf
Electrical shop management system project report.pdf
Lecture_8-Digital implementation of analog controller design.pdf
Lecture_8-Digital implementation of analog controller design.pdf
The battle for RAG, explore the pros and cons of using KnowledgeGraphs and Ve...
The battle for RAG, explore the pros and cons of using KnowledgeGraphs and Ve...
BRAKING SYSTEM IN INDIAN RAILWAY AutoCAD DRAWING
BRAKING SYSTEM IN INDIAN RAILWAY AutoCAD DRAWING
Comparison and selection among alternatives
1.
Copyright ©2012 by
Pearson Education, Inc. Upper Saddle River, New Jersey 07458 All rights reserved. Engineering Economy, Fifteenth Edition By William G. Sullivan, Elin M. Wicks, and C. Patrick Koelling Engineering Economy Chapter 6: Comparison and Selection Among Alternatives
2.
Copyright ©2012 by
Pearson Education, Inc. Upper Saddle River, New Jersey 07458 All rights reserved. Engineering Economy, Fifteenth Edition By William G. Sullivan, Elin M. Wicks, and C. Patrick Koelling The objective of chapter 6 is to evaluate correctly capital investment alternatives when the time value of money is a key influence.
3.
Copyright ©2012 by
Pearson Education, Inc. Upper Saddle River, New Jersey 07458 All rights reserved. Engineering Economy, Fifteenth Edition By William G. Sullivan, Elin M. Wicks, and C. Patrick Koelling Making decisions means comparing alternatives. • In this chapter we examine feasible design alternatives. • The decisions considered are those selecting from among a set of mutually exclusive alternatives—when selecting one excludes the choice of any of the others.
4.
Copyright ©2012 by
Pearson Education, Inc. Upper Saddle River, New Jersey 07458 All rights reserved. Engineering Economy, Fifteenth Edition By William G. Sullivan, Elin M. Wicks, and C. Patrick Koelling Mutually exclusive alternatives (MEAs) • We examine these on the basis of economic considerations alone. • The alternatives may have different initial investments and their annual revenues and costs may vary. • The alternatives must provide comparable “usefulness”: performance, quality, etc. • The basic methods from chapter 5 provide the basis for economic comparison of the alternatives.
5.
Copyright ©2012 by
Pearson Education, Inc. Upper Saddle River, New Jersey 07458 All rights reserved. Engineering Economy, Fifteenth Edition By William G. Sullivan, Elin M. Wicks, and C. Patrick Koelling Apply this rule, based on Principle 2 from Chapter 1. The alternative that requires the minimum investment of capital and produces satisfactory functional results will be chosen unless the incremental capital associated with an alternative having a larger investment can be justified with respect to its incremental benefits. This alternative is the base alternative.
6.
Copyright ©2012 by
Pearson Education, Inc. Upper Saddle River, New Jersey 07458 All rights reserved. Engineering Economy, Fifteenth Edition By William G. Sullivan, Elin M. Wicks, and C. Patrick Koelling For alternatives that have a larger investment than the base… If the extra benefits obtained by investing additional capital are better than those that could be obtained from investment of the same capital elsewhere in the company at the MARR, the investment should be made. (Please note that there are some cautions when considering more than two alternatives, which will be examined later.)
7.
Copyright ©2012 by
Pearson Education, Inc. Upper Saddle River, New Jersey 07458 All rights reserved. Engineering Economy, Fifteenth Edition By William G. Sullivan, Elin M. Wicks, and C. Patrick Koelling There are two basic types of alternatives. Investment Alternatives Those with initial (or front-end) capital investment that produces positive cash flows from increased revenue, savings through reduced costs, or both. Cost Alternatives Those with all negative cash flows, except for a possible positive cash flow from disposal of assets at the end of the project’s useful life.
8.
Copyright ©2012 by
Pearson Education, Inc. Upper Saddle River, New Jersey 07458 All rights reserved. Engineering Economy, Fifteenth Edition By William G. Sullivan, Elin M. Wicks, and C. Patrick Koelling Select the alternative that gives you the most money! • For investment alternatives the PW of all cash flows must be positive, at the MARR, to be attractive. Select the alternative with the largest PW. • For cost alternatives the PW of all cash flows will be negative. Select the alternative with the largest (smallest in absolute value) PW.
9.
Copyright ©2012 by
Pearson Education, Inc. Upper Saddle River, New Jersey 07458 All rights reserved. Engineering Economy, Fifteenth Edition By William G. Sullivan, Elin M. Wicks, and C. Patrick Koelling Investment alternative example Use a MARR of 10% and useful life of 5 years to select between the investment alternatives below. Alternative A B Capital investment -$100,000 -$125,000 Annual revenues less expenses $34,000 $41,000 Both alternatives are attractive, but Alternative B provides a greater present worth, so is better economically. Using AW & FW: AWA= AWB= FWA= FWB=
10.
Copyright ©2012 by
Pearson Education, Inc. Upper Saddle River, New Jersey 07458 All rights reserved. Engineering Economy, Fifteenth Edition By William G. Sullivan, Elin M. Wicks, and C. Patrick Koelling Cost alternative example Use a MARR of 12% and useful life of 4 years to select between the cost alternatives below. Alternative C D Capital investment -$80,000 -$60,000 Annual expenses -$25,000 -$30,000 Alternative D costs less than Alternative C, it has a greater PW, so D is better economically.
11.
Copyright ©2012 by
Pearson Education, Inc. Upper Saddle River, New Jersey 07458 All rights reserved. Engineering Economy, Fifteenth Edition By William G. Sullivan, Elin M. Wicks, and C. Patrick Koelling Your local foundry is adding a new furnace. There are several different styles and types of furnaces, so the foundry must select from among a set of mutually exclusive alternatives. Initial capital investment and annual expenses for each alternative are given in the table below. None have any market value at the end of its useful life. Using a MARR of 15%, which furnace should be chosen? Furnace F1 F2 F3 Investment $110,000 $125,000 $138,000 Useful life 10 years 10 years 10 years Total annual expenses $53,800 $51,625 $45,033 Pause and solve
12.
Copyright ©2012 by
Pearson Education, Inc. Upper Saddle River, New Jersey 07458 All rights reserved. Engineering Economy, Fifteenth Edition By William G. Sullivan, Elin M. Wicks, and C. Patrick Koelling Determining the study period. • A study period (or planning horizon) is the time period over which MEAs are compared, and it must be appropriate for the decision situation. • MEAs can have equal lives (in which case the study period used is these equal lives), or they can have unequal lives, and at least one does not match the study period. • The equal life case is straightforward, and was used in the previous two examples.
13.
Copyright ©2012 by
Pearson Education, Inc. Upper Saddle River, New Jersey 07458 All rights reserved. Engineering Economy, Fifteenth Edition By William G. Sullivan, Elin M. Wicks, and C. Patrick Koelling Unequal lives are handled in one of two ways. • Repeatability assumption – The study period is either indefinitely long or equal to a common multiple of the lives of the MEAs. – The economic consequences expected during the MEAs’ life spans will also happen in succeeding life spans (replacements). • Co-terminated assumption: uses a finite and identical study period for all MEAs. Cash flow adjustments may be made to satisfy alternative performance needs over the study period.
14.
Copyright ©2012 by
Pearson Education, Inc. Upper Saddle River, New Jersey 07458 All rights reserved. Engineering Economy, Fifteenth Edition By William G. Sullivan, Elin M. Wicks, and C. Patrick Koelling Comparing MEAs with equal lives. When lives are equal adjustments to cash flows are not required. The MEAs can be compared by directly comparing their equivalent worth (PW, FW, or AW) calculated using the MARR. The decision will be the same regardless of the equivalent worth method you use. For a MARR of 12%, select from among the MEAs below. Alternatives A B C D Capital investment -$150,000 -$85,000 -$75,000 -$120,000 Annual revenues $28,000 $16,000 $15,000 $22,000 Annual expenses -$1,000 -$550 -$500 -$700 Market Value (EOL) $20,000 $10,000 $6,000 $11,000 Life (years) 10 10 10 10
15.
Copyright ©2012 by
Pearson Education, Inc. Upper Saddle River, New Jersey 07458 All rights reserved. Engineering Economy, Fifteenth Edition By William G. Sullivan, Elin M. Wicks, and C. Patrick Koelling Selecting the best alternative. Present worth analysis select Alternative A (but C is close). Annual worth analysis—the decision is the same.
16.
Copyright ©2012 by
Pearson Education, Inc. Upper Saddle River, New Jersey 07458 All rights reserved. Engineering Economy, Fifteenth Edition By William G. Sullivan, Elin M. Wicks, and C. Patrick Koelling Using rates of return is another way to compare alternatives. • The return on investment (rate of return) is a popular measure of investment performance. • Selecting the alternative with the largest rate of return can lead to incorrect decisions—do not compare the IRR of one alternative to the IRR of another alternative. The only legitimate comparison is the IRR to the MARR. • Remember, the base alternative must be attractive (rate of return greater than the MARR), and the additional investment in other alternatives must itself make a satisfactory rate of return on that increment.
17.
Copyright ©2012 by
Pearson Education, Inc. Upper Saddle River, New Jersey 07458 All rights reserved. Engineering Economy, Fifteenth Edition By William G. Sullivan, Elin M. Wicks, and C. Patrick Koelling Use the incremental investment analysis procedure. • Arrange (rank order) the feasible alternatives based on increasing capital investment. • Establish a base alternative. – Cost alternatives—the first alternative is the base. – Investment alternatives—the first acceptable alternative (IRR>MARR) is the base. • Iteratively evaluate differences (incremental cash flows) between alternatives until all have been considered.
18.
Copyright ©2012 by
Pearson Education, Inc. Upper Saddle River, New Jersey 07458 All rights reserved. Engineering Economy, Fifteenth Edition By William G. Sullivan, Elin M. Wicks, and C. Patrick Koelling Evaluating incremental cash flows • Work up the order of ranked alternatives smallest to largest. • Subtract cash flows of the lower ranked alternative from the higher ranked. • Determine if the incremental initial investment in the higher ranked alternative is attractive (e.g., IRR>MARR, PW, FW, AW all >0). If it is attractive, it is the “winner.” If not, the lower ranked alternative is the “winner.” The “loser” from this comparison is removed from consideration. Continue until all alternatives have been considered. • This works for both cost and investment alternatives.
19.
Copyright ©2012 by
Pearson Education, Inc. Upper Saddle River, New Jersey 07458 All rights reserved. Engineering Economy, Fifteenth Edition By William G. Sullivan, Elin M. Wicks, and C. Patrick Koelling Incremental analysis Alt. A Alt. B Alt. B-Alt. A Initial cost -$25,000 -$35,000 -$10,000 Net annual income $7,500 $10,200 $3,200 IRR on total cash flow 15% 14% 11% Which is preferred using a 5 year study period and MARR=10%? Both alternatives A and B are acceptable—each one has a rate of return that exceeds the MARR. Choosing Alternative A because of its larger IRR would be an incorrect decision. By examining the incremental cash flows we see that the extra amount invested in Alternative B earns a return (11%) that exceeds the MARR—so B is preferred to A. Also note…
20.
Copyright ©2012 by
Pearson Education, Inc. Upper Saddle River, New Jersey 07458 All rights reserved. Engineering Economy, Fifteenth Edition By William G. Sullivan, Elin M. Wicks, and C. Patrick Koelling Acme Molding is examining 5 alternatives for a piece of material handling equipment. Each has an expected life of 8 years with no salvage value, and Acme’s MARR is 12%. Using an incremental analysis, which material handling alternative should be chosen? The table below includes initial investment, net annual income, and IRR for each alternative. Alternative A B C D E Capital investment $12,000 $12,500 $14,400 $16,250 $20,000 Net annual income $2,500 $2,520 $3,050 $3,620 $4,400 IRR 12.99% 12.04% 13.48% 14.99% 14.61% Pause and solve
21.
Copyright ©2012 by
Pearson Education, Inc. Upper Saddle River, New Jersey 07458 All rights reserved. Engineering Economy, Fifteenth Edition By William G. Sullivan, Elin M. Wicks, and C. Patrick Koelling Comparing MEAs with unequal lives. • The repeatability assumption, when applicable, simplified comparison of alternatives. • If repeatability cannot be used, an appropriate study period must be selected (the co-terminated assumption). This is most often used in engineering practice because product life cycles are becoming shorter.
22.
Copyright ©2012 by
Pearson Education, Inc. Upper Saddle River, New Jersey 07458 All rights reserved. Engineering Economy, Fifteenth Edition By William G. Sullivan, Elin M. Wicks, and C. Patrick Koelling The useful life of an alternative is less than the study period. • Cost alternatives – Contracting or leasing for remaining years may be appropriate – Repeat part of the useful life and use an estimated market value to truncate • Investment alternatives – Cash flows reinvested at the MARR at the end of the study period – Replace with another asset, with possibly different cash flows, after the study period
23.
Copyright ©2012 by
Pearson Education, Inc. Upper Saddle River, New Jersey 07458 All rights reserved. Engineering Economy, Fifteenth Edition By William G. Sullivan, Elin M. Wicks, and C. Patrick Koelling The useful life of an alternative is greater than the study period. • Truncate the alternative at the end of the study period, using an estimated market value. • The underlying principle in all such analysis is to compare the MEAs in a decision situation over the same study (analysis) period.
24.
Copyright ©2012 by
Pearson Education, Inc. Upper Saddle River, New Jersey 07458 All rights reserved. Engineering Economy, Fifteenth Edition By William G. Sullivan, Elin M. Wicks, and C. Patrick Koelling Equivalent worth methods can be used for MEAs with unequal lives. • If repeatability can be assumed, the MEAs are most easily compared by finding the annual worth (AW) of each alternative over its own useful life, and recommending the one having the most economical value. • For cotermination, use any equivalent worth method using the cash flows available for the study period.
25.
Copyright ©2012 by
Pearson Education, Inc. Upper Saddle River, New Jersey 07458 All rights reserved. Engineering Economy, Fifteenth Edition By William G. Sullivan, Elin M. Wicks, and C. Patrick Koelling We can use incremental rate of return analysis on MEAs with unequal lives. Equate the MEAs annual worths (AW) over their respective lives. A B Capital Investment $3,500 $5,000 Annual Cash Flow $1,255 $1,480 Useful Live (years) 4 6 Solving, we find i*=26%, so Alt B is preferred.
Télécharger maintenant