This document provides 6 options for an analytical writing assignment on environmentalism. The options include assessing and comparing essays by Edward Abbey, David Orr, and Michael Berliner; interpreting a story by Ursula Le Guin; connecting two assigned texts; analyzing nature imagery in advertisements; evaluating Rowan University's sustainability website RUGreen; or creating your own option with instructor approval. Guidance is provided for purpose, audience, and inclusion of examples and summaries to support each analysis.
Comparing Environmental Perspectives in Abbey, Orr, and Berliner
1.
2. Option 1 Write an analytical argument in which you assess, compare, and contrast the essays by Edward Abbey, David Orr, and/or Michael Berliner (at least two of these three writers) and offer your point of view on environmentalism in the twenty-first century. Purpose- To convey an informed opinion about environmentalism and to assess methods of persuasion. Audience- Me and your classmates. Abbey, Orr, and/or Berliner. Notes- Include a brief summary of the texts you selected and specific examples to support your definition.
3. Option 2 Write an analytical argument in which you interpret Ursula Le Guin’sy and offer your interpretation of this story. Purpose- To convey an informed opinion about LeGuin’s text. Audience- your classmates and Me. LeGuin. Notes- Include a brief summary of LeGuin’s text and specific examples from her text to support your analysis. Aim for a strong or against the grain reading that uses textual evidence.
4. Option 3 Write an analytical essay in which you connect the text you selected with one of your classmate’s choices and/or LeGuin’s story. Purpose- To explore discursive ecology. Audience- Me, your classmates. Notes- offer brief summaries of the texts you select.
5. Option 4 Write an analytical argument about the use of nature imagery in one or more of the advertisements we reviewed in class and propose your own definition of nature. Purpose- To convey an informed argument about nature imagery in the media. Audience- Me, your classmates, the readers of the magazine/website where we found the advertisement. Notes- you might include images of the advertisements (This does not count towards the page minimum)
6. Option 5 Write an analytical argument about Rowan University’s RUGreen website. Analyze the purpose of this website, evaluate how successful it is, and note areas where it might be improved. Purpose- To convey an informed opinion about the RUGreen website. To improve the website. Audience- Me, your classmates, the RuGreen Webmaster. Notes- you might include screen shots of the website. This does not count towards the page minimum.
7. Option 6 Other: You create your own option. Determine your purpose Determine your audience. Determine your rhetorical tools and evaluation criteria. Make sure you discuss this with me first.