SlideShare une entreprise Scribd logo
1  sur  23
CASE-
 BASED
LEARNING:
Improving major
depression
management in
primary care
• About one in four adults
suffer from a diagnosable
mental disorder in a given year
• 70% of primary care visits
stem from psychosocial issues
• Most patients with mental
health issues access the health
system through primary care
• Most primary care physicians
lack the time or have not been
trained to address the range of
psychosocial issues presented
• Clinical depression is often
undiagnosed and undertreated
because symptoms go
unrecognized in the context of
multiple physical problems
• No biological tests confirm major depression
• Other disorders need to be ruled out before
diagnosing major depressive disorder, but the
differential diagnoses list is long
• It is estimated that 80%
of depression cases go
undiagnosed and
untreated
Closing the Gap through
Case-Based Learning
Case-Based Model




                   Kim et al, Medical Education, 40:867-876, 2006
I cannot teach anybody
anything, I can only make them
think .
     ― Socrates
Narrative Setting

                                                                                            • Research shows the
                                                                                            human brain has a
                                                                                            natural affinity for
                                                                                            narrative construction,
                                                                                            remembering facts more
                                                                                            accurately if encountered
                                                                                            in a story than in a list

                                                                                            • This program
                                                                                            challenges physicians to
                                                                                            gather information in
                                                                                            order to make
                                                                                            meaningful decisions in
                                                                                            real-life depression care


Carey, B (2007) This is your life (and How you Tell it). New York Times. Melanie Green http://www.unc.edu/”mcgreen/research.html
Compelling Story Line

                        • Effective cases tell
                        compelling stories and
                        focus on key issues

                        • Major depression
                        affects twice as many
                        women as men, is
                        most prevalent in
                        women before
                        menopause, and is
                        more common in
                        obese women

                        • Lissette: a 47 year old
                        perimenopausal
                        woman with a BMI of
                        34
Built on Dialogue


                    • Effective cases use
                    the characters’
                    dialogue to tell the
                    story

                    • Diagnosing
                    depression is an
                    evaluative notion,
                    usually created via the
                    process of dialogue
Interactive


              • Studies show
              interactivity –
              mutual action
              between the learner,
              the learning system,
              and the learning
              material – has a
              strong effect on
              learning (Stanford
              1990)
Unfolds Over Time


     Six Months           • Effective case
 After Major Depressive   studies unfold over
   Disorder Diagnosis
                          time

                          • The median duration
                          of major depression is
                          23 weeks and often
                          requires ongoing
                          medical care to
                          achieve remission and
                          prevent relapse
Active Discovery

                   • Effective case
                   studies place learners
                   in a simulated situation
                   and help them acquire
                   the decision-making
                   and critical-thinking
                   skills needed

                   • Depression
                   management requires
                   active discovery,
                   analysis, interpretation
                   and problem-solving
Branching                                            Diagnosis
                                                                                        Dysthymia



of Content                                                                           Bipolar Disorders



                       Hyperphagia                  Comorbidities
                                                                                 Posttraumatic Stress




• Effective cases                               Differential Diagnosis               Anxiety Disorders

provide an active
role in the learning
process                              Patient Compliance          Patient Education



• Diagnosing and
treating depression                                Exercise Therapy

can take a path of
exploration over
time and must be                                      Intervention                   Informed Consent
individualized to
each patient

                            Pharmacotherapy         Psychotherapy          Combination therapy
Guided Exploration

                     • Effective cases
                     clearly state and
                     illuminate the
                     dilemma without
                     resolving it

                     • Depression
                     management often
                     takes a collaborative
                     or integrated
                     approach
Goal Alignment

                                                             • Effective cases
                                                             closely align with
 OBJECTIVES:                                                 overall instructional
 At the end of this online enduring material,
 participants should be able to:                             objectives

 • Demonstrate how objective and subjective complexity       • As depression
 indicators can be used for major depressive disorder care
 in women                                                    remains largely
 • Show the importance of developing individualized          underrecognized
 treatment plans for MDD patients that is driven by data,
 evidence-based guidelines and patient input
                                                             and undertreated,
 • Manage MDD patients with a broad range of treatment       continuing
 strategies                                                  education can
 • Emphasize a collaborative multidisciplinary approach to
 patient management                                          improve effective
                                                             management
Mastery


          The experience of
          being competent,
          of achieving
          something
Mastery




          Continuing
          education
          credits awarded
          to maintain
          licensure
Behavior-Changing

                    • Effective cases
                    lead to behavior
                    change
                    • Changing behavior
                    in depression is
                    critical as half of
                    patients do not
                    receive
                    recommended levels
                    of care
                    • Assessing
                    commitment to
                    change vs. actual
                    change in practice
“Education is not the filling of a
pail, but the lighting of a fire.”
      - W.B. Yeats
Questions
                         or comments,
                             email:
                    threcme@outlook.com




to experience the case, please visit:
    www.mddinwomen.com

Contenu connexe

Tendances

Impact of stress management by development of emotional intelligence in cmts,...
Impact of stress management by development of emotional intelligence in cmts,...Impact of stress management by development of emotional intelligence in cmts,...
Impact of stress management by development of emotional intelligence in cmts,...
prjpublications
 
Resiliency Program R. Davis U10A1
Resiliency Program R. Davis U10A1Resiliency Program R. Davis U10A1
Resiliency Program R. Davis U10A1
Rachel Davis
 
1 approaching crisis intervention
1 approaching crisis intervention1 approaching crisis intervention
1 approaching crisis intervention
Don Thompson
 
How the brain heals emotional wounds the functional neuroanatomy of forgivene...
How the brain heals emotional wounds the functional neuroanatomy of forgivene...How the brain heals emotional wounds the functional neuroanatomy of forgivene...
How the brain heals emotional wounds the functional neuroanatomy of forgivene...
Elsa von Licy
 

Tendances (12)

Impact of stress management by development of emotional intelligence in cmts,...
Impact of stress management by development of emotional intelligence in cmts,...Impact of stress management by development of emotional intelligence in cmts,...
Impact of stress management by development of emotional intelligence in cmts,...
 
Worry, Rumination and Repetitive Thinking: Special Interest Group
Worry, Rumination and Repetitive Thinking: Special Interest GroupWorry, Rumination and Repetitive Thinking: Special Interest Group
Worry, Rumination and Repetitive Thinking: Special Interest Group
 
Assessment Of Fear Avoidance In Chronic Pain - Dr Johan W S Vlaeyen
Assessment Of Fear Avoidance In Chronic Pain - Dr Johan W S VlaeyenAssessment Of Fear Avoidance In Chronic Pain - Dr Johan W S Vlaeyen
Assessment Of Fear Avoidance In Chronic Pain - Dr Johan W S Vlaeyen
 
Resiliency Program R. Davis U10A1
Resiliency Program R. Davis U10A1Resiliency Program R. Davis U10A1
Resiliency Program R. Davis U10A1
 
An Overview: Behavior Therpay
An Overview: Behavior TherpayAn Overview: Behavior Therpay
An Overview: Behavior Therpay
 
Gerhard Andersson
Gerhard AnderssonGerhard Andersson
Gerhard Andersson
 
Heartmath
HeartmathHeartmath
Heartmath
 
1 approaching crisis intervention
1 approaching crisis intervention1 approaching crisis intervention
1 approaching crisis intervention
 
CBT and Biofeedback
CBT and Biofeedback CBT and Biofeedback
CBT and Biofeedback
 
CRISIS FINAL
CRISIS FINALCRISIS FINAL
CRISIS FINAL
 
mHealth Behavior Change Lessons Learned
mHealth Behavior Change Lessons LearnedmHealth Behavior Change Lessons Learned
mHealth Behavior Change Lessons Learned
 
How the brain heals emotional wounds the functional neuroanatomy of forgivene...
How the brain heals emotional wounds the functional neuroanatomy of forgivene...How the brain heals emotional wounds the functional neuroanatomy of forgivene...
How the brain heals emotional wounds the functional neuroanatomy of forgivene...
 

Similaire à Using a case-based context to improve healthcare: Improving depression management in primary care

Connections
ConnectionsConnections
Connections
wef
 
2012 fall pp_ch_25.ppt_audio
2012 fall pp_ch_25.ppt_audio2012 fall pp_ch_25.ppt_audio
2012 fall pp_ch_25.ppt_audio
little1lz
 
Psychosocial rehabilitation
Psychosocial rehabilitationPsychosocial rehabilitation
Psychosocial rehabilitation
Fara Dyba
 
nursing research & ebp
nursing research & ebpnursing research & ebp
nursing research & ebp
twiggypiggy
 
53 a focus 5 research & ebp
53 a focus 5 research & ebp53 a focus 5 research & ebp
53 a focus 5 research & ebp
twiggypiggy
 
Chapter 8 outline
Chapter 8 outlineChapter 8 outline
Chapter 8 outline
jhoegh
 

Similaire à Using a case-based context to improve healthcare: Improving depression management in primary care (20)

Connections
ConnectionsConnections
Connections
 
2012 fall pp_ch_25.ppt_audio
2012 fall pp_ch_25.ppt_audio2012 fall pp_ch_25.ppt_audio
2012 fall pp_ch_25.ppt_audio
 
Pnwbha Poster 2012
Pnwbha Poster 2012Pnwbha Poster 2012
Pnwbha Poster 2012
 
Behavior sciences paper
Behavior sciences paperBehavior sciences paper
Behavior sciences paper
 
Process Theories
Process TheoriesProcess Theories
Process Theories
 
Psychosocial rehabilitation
Psychosocial rehabilitationPsychosocial rehabilitation
Psychosocial rehabilitation
 
Clinical reasoning apao
Clinical reasoning apaoClinical reasoning apao
Clinical reasoning apao
 
Critical thinking
Critical thinkingCritical thinking
Critical thinking
 
The theory and evidence behind self management
The theory and evidence behind self managementThe theory and evidence behind self management
The theory and evidence behind self management
 
Sources of knowledge
Sources of knowledgeSources of knowledge
Sources of knowledge
 
nursing research & ebp
nursing research & ebpnursing research & ebp
nursing research & ebp
 
53 a focus 5 research & ebp
53 a focus 5 research & ebp53 a focus 5 research & ebp
53 a focus 5 research & ebp
 
Hf poster april 2009
Hf poster   april 2009Hf poster   april 2009
Hf poster april 2009
 
Chapter 8 outline
Chapter 8 outlineChapter 8 outline
Chapter 8 outline
 
Cbt ashwathi
Cbt ashwathiCbt ashwathi
Cbt ashwathi
 
Stories Worth Telling
Stories Worth TellingStories Worth Telling
Stories Worth Telling
 
Aaron Becks Cognitive Therapy
Aaron Becks Cognitive TherapyAaron Becks Cognitive Therapy
Aaron Becks Cognitive Therapy
 
Working Appreciatively in End-of-Life Care
Working Appreciatively in End-of-Life CareWorking Appreciatively in End-of-Life Care
Working Appreciatively in End-of-Life Care
 
Peplau's Theory
Peplau's TheoryPeplau's Theory
Peplau's Theory
 
Guidance and counseling
Guidance and counselingGuidance and counseling
Guidance and counseling
 

Using a case-based context to improve healthcare: Improving depression management in primary care

  • 2. • About one in four adults suffer from a diagnosable mental disorder in a given year • 70% of primary care visits stem from psychosocial issues
  • 3. • Most patients with mental health issues access the health system through primary care • Most primary care physicians lack the time or have not been trained to address the range of psychosocial issues presented
  • 4. • Clinical depression is often undiagnosed and undertreated because symptoms go unrecognized in the context of multiple physical problems
  • 5. • No biological tests confirm major depression • Other disorders need to be ruled out before diagnosing major depressive disorder, but the differential diagnoses list is long
  • 6. • It is estimated that 80% of depression cases go undiagnosed and untreated
  • 7. Closing the Gap through Case-Based Learning
  • 8. Case-Based Model Kim et al, Medical Education, 40:867-876, 2006
  • 9. I cannot teach anybody anything, I can only make them think . ― Socrates
  • 10. Narrative Setting • Research shows the human brain has a natural affinity for narrative construction, remembering facts more accurately if encountered in a story than in a list • This program challenges physicians to gather information in order to make meaningful decisions in real-life depression care Carey, B (2007) This is your life (and How you Tell it). New York Times. Melanie Green http://www.unc.edu/”mcgreen/research.html
  • 11. Compelling Story Line • Effective cases tell compelling stories and focus on key issues • Major depression affects twice as many women as men, is most prevalent in women before menopause, and is more common in obese women • Lissette: a 47 year old perimenopausal woman with a BMI of 34
  • 12. Built on Dialogue • Effective cases use the characters’ dialogue to tell the story • Diagnosing depression is an evaluative notion, usually created via the process of dialogue
  • 13. Interactive • Studies show interactivity – mutual action between the learner, the learning system, and the learning material – has a strong effect on learning (Stanford 1990)
  • 14. Unfolds Over Time Six Months • Effective case After Major Depressive studies unfold over Disorder Diagnosis time • The median duration of major depression is 23 weeks and often requires ongoing medical care to achieve remission and prevent relapse
  • 15. Active Discovery • Effective case studies place learners in a simulated situation and help them acquire the decision-making and critical-thinking skills needed • Depression management requires active discovery, analysis, interpretation and problem-solving
  • 16. Branching Diagnosis Dysthymia of Content Bipolar Disorders Hyperphagia Comorbidities Posttraumatic Stress • Effective cases Differential Diagnosis Anxiety Disorders provide an active role in the learning process Patient Compliance Patient Education • Diagnosing and treating depression Exercise Therapy can take a path of exploration over time and must be Intervention Informed Consent individualized to each patient Pharmacotherapy Psychotherapy Combination therapy
  • 17. Guided Exploration • Effective cases clearly state and illuminate the dilemma without resolving it • Depression management often takes a collaborative or integrated approach
  • 18. Goal Alignment • Effective cases closely align with OBJECTIVES: overall instructional At the end of this online enduring material, participants should be able to: objectives • Demonstrate how objective and subjective complexity • As depression indicators can be used for major depressive disorder care in women remains largely • Show the importance of developing individualized underrecognized treatment plans for MDD patients that is driven by data, evidence-based guidelines and patient input and undertreated, • Manage MDD patients with a broad range of treatment continuing strategies education can • Emphasize a collaborative multidisciplinary approach to patient management improve effective management
  • 19. Mastery The experience of being competent, of achieving something
  • 20. Mastery Continuing education credits awarded to maintain licensure
  • 21. Behavior-Changing • Effective cases lead to behavior change • Changing behavior in depression is critical as half of patients do not receive recommended levels of care • Assessing commitment to change vs. actual change in practice
  • 22. “Education is not the filling of a pail, but the lighting of a fire.” - W.B. Yeats
  • 23. Questions or comments, email: threcme@outlook.com to experience the case, please visit: www.mddinwomen.com