2. facebook past and future
Research Phase I: Phase II: Phase III: Research
Overview Survive Dominate Network Results
2010 Spring | Stern School of Business | Technological Innovation and New Product Development
3. facebook past and future
Research Phase I: Phase II: Phase III: Research
Overview Survive Dominate Network Results
Phase I: How Did Facebook Survive The Valley Of Death?
Research
Phase II: How Did They Come To Dominate The Social Networks?
Phase III: What Is Driving Growth?
Hypothesis:
Expanding User Base
Keys to Success
Talent Acquisition
Recommendations
Employee Management
User Centric Product Innovation
2010 Spring | Stern School of Business | Technological Innovation and New Product Development
4. facebook past and future
Research Phase I: Phase II: Phase III: Research
Overview Survive Dominate Network Results
The Worlds Most
Transitioning from
50 Most
Innovative Companies
a start-up to
Innovative Companies,
2010 (#1)
a profitable
BusinessWeek, 2009
company
Fast Company,
2010
2010 Spring | Stern School of Business | Technological Innovation and New Product Development
5. facebook past and future
Research Phase I: Phase II: Phase III: Research
Overview Survive Dominate Network Results
How could
Is facebook really
How did facebook
facebook survive
innovative?
become no. 1 this fast?
“the valley of death”?
Venture capital,
Design dominance…
Increasing returns…
Psychological
Hiring strategy,
positioning…
Corporate culture…
2010 Spring | Stern School of Business | Technological Innovation and New Product Development
6. facebook past and future
Research Phase I: Phase II: Phase III: Research
Overview Survive Dominate Network Results
PHASE I:
PHASE II:
PHASE III:
2004~2006
2006~
2007~
RECOMMENDATIONS
SURVIVE
DOMINATE
NETWORK
2010 Spring | Stern School of Business | Technological Innovation and New Product Development
7. facebook past and future
Research Phase I: Phase II: Phase III: Research
Overview Survive Dominate Network Results
How could it survive the Valley of Death?
General Life Cycle of a Venture‐Funded Company
2010 Spring | Stern School of Business | Technological Innovation and New Product Development
8. facebook past and future
Research Phase I: Phase II: Phase III: Research
Overview Survive Dominate Network Results
How could it survive the Valley of Death?
Venture capital Social capital Psychological positioning
“Zuckerberg said he thought - Why Facebook Went West - - Chatty Zuckerberg Tells
Facebook was worth about “So many of the [its] employees All About Facebook Finances -
$15 million, and was willing to have come from top Internet “For 2008, Zuckerberg projected
accept an investment ranging companies like Yahoo, eBay, revenue to be increased to
from $1 million to $3 million… and Google that the culture $300m-$350m [$150m in ’07]
he struck some partners at built at [it] is fundamentally …investment from MS pegged
the firm as a little too brash.” more Consumer Internet savvy.” the valuation of it at $15B.”
2010 Spring | Stern School of Business | Technological Innovation and New Product Development
9. facebook past and future
Research Phase I: Phase II: Phase III: Research
Overview Survive Dominate Network Results
Entry to the market
Fast Followers with key points
of differentiation
REPLICATE
Iterative design
Strong management focusing
INNOVATE
ITERATE
on monetization and growth
Access to capital
2010 Spring | Stern School of Business | Technological Innovation and New Product Development
10. facebook past and future
Research Phase I: Phase II: Phase III: Research
Overview Survive Dominate Network Results
Design... …ma=ers!
2010 Spring | Stern School of Business | Technological Innovation and New Product Development
11. facebook past and future
Research Phase I: Phase II: Phase III: Research
Overview Survive Dominate Network Results
MoneGze
1. Brand AdverEsing
2. MicrosoI AdverEsing
3. Virtual Goods
4. Performance Ads
Fiscal Year Annual Revenue ($MM)
2008 $280
2009 $635
2010* $1100
*projected
Source: insidefacebook.com
2010 Spring | Stern School of Business | Technological Innovation and New Product Development
12. facebook past and future
Research Phase !: Phase II: Phase III: Research
Overview Survive Dominate Network Results
How did facebook become no. 1 this fast?
Y!
M
e G
2010 Spring | Stern School of Business | Technological Innovation and New Product Development
13. facebook past and future
Research Phase !: Phase II: Phase III: Research
Overview Survive Dominate Network Results
Rapid Growth Over Time
Started as exclusive to students of Harvard University
Spread across 30 college networks in next four months
By Fall 2007, adding million users a week
Rapidly spread across the world by introducing new languages
Currently is the world’s largest social network – over 400 million users
2010 Spring | Stern School of Business | Technological Innovation and New Product Development
14. facebook past and future
Research Phase !: Phase II: Phase III: Research
Overview Survive Dominate Network Results
Strategies for Rapid Growth
2010 Spring | Stern School of Business | Technological Innovation and New Product Development
15. facebook past and future
Research Phase !: Phase II: Phase III: Research
Overview Survive Dominate Network Results
Ma=hew Effect
MoEvate developers – open code framework
MoEvate exisEng users to linger – applicaEons
Increase users’ touch points for interacEng with facebook ‐ Mobile
Encourage users and apps to invite addiEonal parEcipants
Proliferate the Internet with the new ‘Like’ and ‘Recommend’ buons
2010 Spring | Stern School of Business | Technological Innovation and New Product Development
16. facebook past and future
Research Phase !: Phase II: Phase III: Research
Overview Survive Dominate Network Results
Detailed Code DocumentaGon for Developers
2010 Spring | Stern School of Business | Technological Innovation and New Product Development
17. facebook past and future
Research Phase !: Phase II: Phase III: Research
Overview Survive Dominate Network Results
Increasing consumer touch points – Mobiles and Smart phones
2010 Spring | Stern School of Business | Technological Innovation and New Product Development
18. facebook past and future
Research Phase !: Phase II: Phase III: Research
Overview Survive Dominate Network Results
Encouraging Users To Stay
2010 Spring | Stern School of Business | Technological Innovation and New Product Development
19. facebook past and future
Research Phase !: Phase II: Phase III: Research
Overview Survive Dominate Network Results
IntegraGng with other networks to increase Network Effects
2010 Spring | Stern School of Business | Technological Innovation and New Product Development
20. facebook past and future
Research Phase !: Phase II: Phase III: Research
Overview Survive Dominate Network Results
CollaboraGve Strategy
2010 Spring | Stern School of Business | Technological Innovation and New Product Development
21. facebook past and future
Research Phase !: Phase II: Phase III: Research
Overview Survive Dominate Network Results
Overlapping With The Real World
The Facebook Window SGcker
encourages businesses to put up the
sEcker and remind them that
“businesses that promote their Page
on Facebook tend to see a 20%
greater increase in connects.
Possibly could encroach upon
FourSquare’s “check‐in” strategy for
businesses in the next phase.
2010 Spring | Stern School of Business | Technological Innovation and New Product Development
22. facebook past and future
Research Phase !: Phase II: Phase III: Research
Overview Survive Dominate Network Results
The growing company needed talents, a lot of them (from big companies)
Top 10 past companies of Facebook’s current employees
* San Francisco Bay Area only, total 877
Source: linkedin.com
2010 Spring | Stern School of Business | Technological Innovation and New Product Development
23. facebook past and future
Research Phase !: Phase II: Phase III: Research
Overview Survive Dominate Network Results
The growing company needed talents, a lot of them (from big companies)
Top 10 past companies of Google’s current employees
* San Francisco Bay Area only, total 8,115
MicrosoI
Yahoo!
IBM
Oracle America, Inc.
Oracle
Cisco Systems
Hewle‐Packard
Intel
eBay
Stanford University
Others
Source: linkedin.com
2010 Spring | Stern School of Business | Technological Innovation and New Product Development
24. facebook past and future
Research Phase !: Phase II: Phase III: Research
Overview Survive Dominate Network Results
The growing company needed talents, a lot of them (from big companies)
Top 10 past companies of eBay’s current employees
* San Francisco Bay Area only, total 3,147
Cisco Systems
Yahoo!
Oracle America, Inc
Accenture
Hewle‐Packard
Oracle
MicrosoI
PayPal
IBM
Intel
Others
Source: linkedin.com
2010 Spring | Stern School of Business | Technological Innovation and New Product Development
25. facebook past and future
Research Phase !: Phase II: Phase III: Research
Overview Survive Dominate Network Results
The growing company needed talents, a lot of them (from big companies)
Top 10 past companies of MySpace’s current employees
* San Francisco Bay Area only, total 91
AOL
Yahoo!
Organic
LinkedIn
Fox InteracEve Media
Netscape
Cisco Systems
Google
Adobe Systems
eBay
Others
Source: linkedin.com
2010 Spring | Stern School of Business | Technological Innovation and New Product Development
26. facebook past and future
Research Phase I: Phase II: Phase III: Research
Overview Survive Dominate Network Results
However… Facebookers joined ambiGously, leaving more ambiGously
A couple of months ago, after three years as a Google product manager, I decided to leave for Facebook.
I am writing this note to spread Good News to all the friends I haven't already overwhelmed with my enthusiasm:
Facebook really is That company.
Which company? That one. That company that shows up once in a very long while -- the Google of yesterday,
the Microsoft of long ago. That company where large numbers of stunningly-brilliant people congregate and
feed off each other's genius…
- June 2007, A note of an ex-Googler and new Facebooker, Justin Rosenstein
But something else exciting happened in the year and a half since I joined Facebook. I started spending
a lot of time after work talking to Dustin [the co-founder of Facebook]…
We see this new venture as very complimentary to Facebook. Our software will use Facebook Connect
as the default option for identity and authentication. Our user interface will adopt many of Facebook’s conventions,
creating a seamless and familiar experience for current Facebook users. And if our new development tools turn out
to be useful, we hope the Facebook engineering team will come to adopt them.
- October 2008, A note of an ex-Facebooker and now co-founder of Asana, Justin Rosenstein
2010 Spring | Stern School of Business | Technological Innovation and New Product Development
27. facebook past and future
Research Phase I: Phase II: Phase III: Research
Overview Survive Dominate Network Results
Top ExecuGves “unfriending” facebook ‐ Facebook’s organizaEonal chart (Aug. 2009, unofficial)
Mark Zuckerberg
CEO
SVP Sales & Director of
General Technical Director of Director of Director of
Strategic CFO COO Business
Counsel OperaEons Engineering MarkeEng Product
MarkeEng Development
VP of Product
Co‐founder and VP of CommunicaEons VP Strategy &
Privacy VP of Sales Treasurer MarkeEng and
VP of Engineering and Public Policy Bus OPs
OperaEons
“The departed include:
Facebook Director of Business Development Netanel Net Jacobsson , Developer Charlie Cheever, Cofounder Dustin Moskovitz,
Platform director Ben Ling, Designer Katie Geminder, Designer Eston Bond, Data guru Jeff Hammerbacher,
Marketing VP Matt Cohler, Top Engineeer Justin Rosenstein, Sandberg's Executive Assistant, Camille Hart,
CTO Adam D'Angelo, Cofounder Chris Hughes, COO Owen Van Natta, President Sean Parker, CFO Mike Sheridan,
Controller Catherine Chang, VP of Product Doug Hirsch, Cofounder Andrew McCollum, Cofounder Eduardo Saverin,
first VP of Sales Tricia Black, VP of engineering TS Ramakrishnan, Director of Operations Nick Heyman …”
- March 2009, gawker.com tipster’s report
2010 Spring | Stern School of Business | Technological Innovation and New Product Development
28. facebook past and future
Research Phase I: Phase II: Phase III: Research
Overview Survive Dominate Network Results
RecommendaGon I: Respect home‐grown stars
Leaders role: more about NOT to DEmotivate people Stars who’ll remain for long
“…Now, in 2009, it's become a company of close to 1,000 “…why you’re usually better
employees where more and more, people are eyeing the exits, off growing stars than buying
wondering how they can escape the tyrannical whims of 24-year- them. If companies want to,
old CEO Mark Zuckerberg and his tormented lieutenants.” they can develop stars.”
2010 Spring | Stern School of Business | Technological Innovation and New Product Development
29. facebook past and future
Research Phase I: Phase II: Phase III: Research
Overview Survive Dominate Network Results
RecommendaGon: II: Respect User Privacy
Facebook started a Site
Governance Page to gather
comments about their policy
changes.
But is that enough?
Lawsuits against facebook have been
filed as users think their privacy was
violated.
2010 Spring | Stern School of Business | Technological Innovation and New Product Development
30. facebook past and future
Research Phase I: Phase II: Phase III: Research
Overview Survive Dominate Network Results
QuesGons?
?
Jeehyun Moon
Thomas Li=le
Chris Fischer
Soumitra Dasnurkar
Kwasi Frye
2010 Spring | Stern School of Business | Technological Innovation and New Product Development