SlideShare une entreprise Scribd logo
1  sur  12
Télécharger pour lire hors ligne
SHOULD SPANISH HOTELIERS IMPROVE THEIR COMMUNICATION AND
          DIRECT DISTRIBUTION STRATEGIES TO PREVENT LOSS OF REVENUE?


                           Josep M Altarriba, jmaltarriba@ub.edu, University of Barcelona
                            Tomeu Pons, tomeu.pons@tsi.url.edu, Ramon Llull University


ABSTRACT


As we know, many hoteliers have seen their level of dependence on OTAs increase in recent years. Through heavy
investment in online communication strategies, these virtual agencies are continuing to channel a large percentage of
reservations, which entails the payment of the corresponding fees on the part of the establishments.


             In this article, the first in a series of three that we are dedicating to the treatment of this issue, we will focus
on the study of this phenomenon mainly through an analysis of the roles played by various actors involved in the
process of online commercialization, and the tools that hoteliers have at their disposal to boost their direct
distribution, thus avoiding excessive third-party intermediation and retaining the portion of the revenue that is
currently allocated to payment of commissions to OTAs.


KEYWORDS

Direct Distribution · Hotel Booking Engines · Online Travel Agencies · Spain


1. Introduction

In the years following the invention and adoption of the Internet1, and its subsequent widespread use for marketing
purposes (Prasad et al.: 2001), e-commerce transactions have increased exponentially. In the specific case of the
tourism sector, this increase has been accompanied by the rapid emergence of a new player in the marketing process:
online travel agencies (OTAs), which, over time, have managed to entice the final client, and have created a high
demand for their websites through the intensive use of strategies in the online environment.


             As we know, these agencies act as brokers to whom the hotels pay a percentage of the reservations they
book through them. A considerable amount of the OTAs revenues is invested in Internet marketing campaigns, and
at first glance it seems virtually impossible that hoteliers could combat these strategies by changing their mode of
distribution. However, if we focus on the key performance indicators of these business models, we realize that with


1
    According to the Internet World Stats, in 2011 there were 2,095,000,000 Internet users in the planet, what makes a 30.2% of the population.

                                                                          1
cheaper access to technology, local small businesses in tourist destination can improve their performance and thus,
receive more direct benefits.


          In this paper we analyze the environment in which hotel distribution is currently developing, as well as the
opportunities available and the impact they can have on tourism enterprises, and consequently, on the economies of
the tourist destinations themselves; even though, as we will point in our conclusions, we are conducting further
research in order to empirically contrast some of our conjectures.


2. The Internet scenario: How consumers, online travel agencies (OTAs), hoteliers,
Administrations and social networks act?


a. Consumers


In today’s world, the consumer has lost almost all fear of making travel reservations online2. The modern consumer
understands and appreciates the advantages the online reservation process offers over the traditional off-line booking
methods. In fact, it is safe to say that in most cases, time spent planning and researching a vacation is often perceived
as a leisurely activity (Morosan, C. and Jeong, M.: 2006).


          Today, there exists a multitude of websites replete with content regarding travel destinations and activities
for tourists to enjoy during their stay. These websites have evolved substantially, and continue to grow and adapt to
the mediums used by consumers to access social networks.


          New accurately categorized, well-presented and easily accessible tourism contents are being created, and
among them, contents from other users, either or not they are known to the consumer, are of paramount value due to
the importance of their recommendations and opinions3.


          This relatively new activity, whose impact is of unarguable significance in the realm of travel and tourism,
necessarily requires the use of the Internet, and logically so, since it is inconceivable, in the age of the information, to
gather, sort, and disseminate such a large quantity of information without the use of the web.


          However, this process, while highly beneficial for the consumer, presents new challenges for the tourist
destinations themselves. Since travel information is so easily and quickly accessed, the consumer transforms the
information collection process to the process of evaluation, therefore dramatically decreasing the time between
acquisition of information and decision-making. And more precisely, consumers have reduced the time dedicated to

2
  In the case of Spain, a 68% of hotel reservations were made online in 2010 (Rheem, C. and Salgado, J.: 2011). In 2011, as per one of the key
findings of the congress sponsored by Microsoft “Destinola Nube”, a 60% of travelers that visited the country used the Internet to make their
reservations, and a 46% paid online.
3
  According to the “Activitat turística: el turista en hotel 1993-2010” report prepared by Barcelona Turisme, an 86% of tourists who visited
Barcelona in 2010 used the Internet to gather information about the destination.

                                                                      2
the purchase itself, what we consider as a key element that can have a high impact on the development of local
economies in tourist destinations.


b. Online Travel Agencies (OTAs)


OTAs models have evolved their to maximize the number of products offered and sales made, and to improve user
experience.


        Regarding the product, most OTAs have thousands of references in their catalogues, and nearly cover 100%
         of tourist destinations worldwide. Most hotels are listed within the portfolios of the major OTAs, even
         though there are some exceptions: very first-class and very low-class hotels, as well as those hotels with a
         limited number of rooms.


        Regarding sales, agencies have adopted sophisticated commercialization techniques and have improved
         their commercial policies, therefore making them more attractive to customers. For example, consumer
         friendly agencies do not require any down payment to secure the reservation, have eliminated cancellation
         fees, implemented loyalty programs, and developed flash sales with momentary discounts that eventually
         reach the 50% to customers that either purchase or travel within the designated time periods.


        Regarding usability, OTAs have exponentially improved the design of their websites through the use of
         sophisticated marketing research methods and techniques and maximized efficiency, thereby minimizing
         the time necessary to complete a transaction. Typically, websites are designed so that, in three or less steps,
         customers can carry out most booking processes, thus enhancing user experience.


c. Hoteliers


In response to the changing world of travel reservations, hoteliers, too, have adapted their strategies on the marketing
mix in the following ways:


              Product: Hotels have added new room categories with new room descriptions and pictures to better
               accommodate travelers’ needs and uses. Also, hotels have adapted services and products provided to
               guests.

              Price: Traditionally, as we all know, hotels have maintained static rates for their rooms. This trend has
               now become obsolete in the changing environment. From the spread of the use of the Internet, hotels
               have created new pricing indexes to account for new customer needs to such an extent that a 100-room
               hotel may offer up to 50 different rates. In fact, price generation has become such a complex task that
               even smaller hotels are hiring revenue managers, once employed only by larger chains.

                                                            3
   Promotion: Hoteliers have realized the necessity of having their own webpage. However, these
             websites cannot simply be a digital version of their old paper brochures; style and presentation are just
             as important as information and content. Hotels must take into account marketing and sales strategies
             when creating a webpage in order to successfully promote their hotel to a growing online audience.
             Therefore, hoteliers are paying more close attention to the text used (phrasing, style, presentation) and
             pictures presented (art direction, processing, and other varying aesthetic techniques). The hotels
             themselves must now assume these tasks, previously managed by communication agencies, and convey
             all these information to their corporate profiles on social networks.

            Place: The Internet has made it possible to reach anyone, anywhere, without intermediaries; hoteliers
             are aware of this fact. Not too long ago, customers could fill out online forms that would be answered
             within 24 hours, similar to the antiquated system of fax reservations. But in the last few years, most
             hotels have adopted CRS software, enabling customers to make immediate reservations. Basically,
             hotels have integrated the same services offered by OTAs into their own, unique websites.

d. Public Administrations


Since the beginning of the Internet, public Administrations of tourist destinations have assumed the role of
categorizing and providing tourist resources to potential travelers. Most public Administrations have followed this
path, but in doing so, acted incorrectly and in manners inconsistent with the consumers’ changing nature of
information acquisition. An encyclopedic resource that offers excessive information is an unnecessary and outdated
method to communicate tourism information, and is inconsistent with the online buyer decision process. In many
instances, the information displayed is not valuable for the user and does not include facts about the destination that
consumers would expect, such as maps, pet allowances or safety issues.


         Additionally, many of these web projects assumed by public administrations have taken too long to
complete, meanwhile the Internet has been rapidly evolving by generating new tools and applications to solve
customers’ needs without offering irrelevant or unnecessary information. These solutions to facilitate travel have
quickly spread between travelers through a virtual word of mouth (Lim, S. et al.: 2011).


         For these reasons, we have come to the conclusion that that role traditionally played by public
Administrations to promote tourism on the Internet is, in most of the cases, an obsolete resource for tourists, since
the net has allowed consumers to connect with each other, with OTAs and with hotels directly, thereby bypassing
public tourism websites. In other words, most of the actions that public Administrations can do to promote tourism
are already, and more efficiently, being done, and therefore, they should change their tactics. The primary function of
public Administrations, in this arena, is to promote tourism to their destination and the goal of online promotion is to
reach the greatest amount of people in the smallest time possible. Taking into account this premise, a more suitable
tactic would be to increase their presence and actions on social networking sites.


                                                           4
However, we believe that all these actions are only a portion of what is necessary for a tourist destination to
be reserved. In effect, after many years of focusing on the pre-sale portion of the booking process, we conclude there
has been a certain abandonment of the actual selling process. Thus, the Administration has promoted, in a massive
manner, tourist destinations that are then sold mostly through intermediaries, since frequently the tourism based
companies of the destination do not have the technological tools to take advantage of the flow of demand created
thanks to the advertisement investment, therefore losing the opportunity to obtain a fair return to these public
campaigns.


e. Social networks


Social networks are becoming new players that need to be taken into account. While their marketing role is still
relatively undefined (Withiam, G.: 2011b), there is no doubt that social networking sites’ involvement in all the
activities related to the online consumer will be crucial in the near future4. This is logical assumption to make: the
Internet has allowed large amounts of users to gather around common interests and share their concerns, and in
response, other users generate more contents. Since these virtual contents created and shared by users have no
foreseeable limit, the time of exposure to these platforms keep growing.


          Many networks, such as Facebook, currently allow the creation of corporate profiles. These profiles may
contain the same sections as traditional corporate web pages: general information, situation maps, contact data,
product description and pictures, opinions from customers, and official releases by which special offers and other
promotional sales can be announced. In short, corporate profiles on social networking sites are able to perform all the
primary functions as their corporate sites, with the added benefit of being more accessible to their target market.
Therefore, hoteliers will have to dedicate the same marketing efforts to their corporate profiles on social networks as
those they are dedicating to their corporate sites.


          On the other hand, new corporate profiles are incorporating new software developed by other companies,
either to manage profile contents or to manage the insights of communication actions through sophisticated strategic
marketing tools.


          Therefore, this medium (social networking sites) has the potential to become a substitute for hotel websites
as well, as they have the ability to contain the same information as an individual website with the added bonus of
being more easily accessed by the consumer. This is due to the enormous growth of social networks and time spent
by users on these sites, as we have previously stated.


3. Can this scenario create new opportunities?
4
 As the Nielsen State of the Media: Social Media Report (2011, Q3) shows, a 70% of active online adult social networkers shop online, 12%
percent more likely than the average adult Internet users.

                                                                   5
a. The customer and the online environment


Currently, and despite the 2008 financial crisis, international tourist markets have continued to grow, either because
the consumers of developed countries have included tourism activities in their basic necessities, or due to the
remarkable increase of travelers from BRICs and other emerging counties5.


           Regardless of the markets, all consumers have adopted the Internet as a basic tool to gain access to the
information they are looking for. In the case of tourism, the net provides information on destinations and allows
travelers to purchase services, specifically, transportation and lodging. In some cases, complementary products can
also be acquired, especially when they are scarce or there are difficulties to access them, such as visits to protected
areas or restricted monuments.


b. The customer and the OTA


OTAs have been leading a distribution process that they have been improving in all its stages (Morosan, C. and
Jeong, M: 2006): consumers and hotel prices gaining, product increases, website usability optimization, remarkable
investments in technological infrastructure and hardware, and constant enlargement of their customer services. Thus,
transactional models once offered by the first OTAs to final customers have nothing to do with the current models.


c. The OTA and the hotel


Overall, revenues of OTAs come mainly from hotel products and transportation. But, how does this revenue reach
the hotels? There are three possible ways:


     1.    The client makes a reservation with an OTA, to which they pay 100% of the price. This money stays in the
           hands of the OTA until the client has stayed the total number of nights at the hotel, and checked out. At
           which point, the OTA sends the money to the hotel, minus the commission charged by the OTA. The money
           stays, for a time, with the OTA so that they can respond to cancellations or complaints of the client.


     2.    The client makes reservations with an OTA and the OTA charges the client a fee to guarantee to hold the
           room at the hotel. In this case, the client doesn’t know that the percentage paid to secure the room is
           actually the commission that the OTA will keep. That is, the travel agent is paid at the time the reservation
           is made and the customer pays for the remainder of the stay directly to the hotel when checking out.



5
  According to the Spanish Institute of Tourism Studies (IET), in January 2012 Spain received 2,778,116 international tourists, 122,000 more than
in January 2011. Travelers from Russia grew by 61% (Nota de coyuntura de Frontur. Enero 2012). The tourists’ average daily expenditure
increased by 11.2%, reaching 99 euros per traveler per day (Nota de coyuntura de Egatur. Enero 2012).

                                                                       6
3.   In this form, the client reserves their hotel through an OTA, but pays at the hotel. In this case, the hotel pays
          a monthly commission to the OTA. The client secures their stay by giving their credit card number to the
          OTA, however, the OTA or hotel only use this card if the customer does not show up at the hotel and did
          not cancel the reservation (no show case).


          In the first model, many hoteliers perceive a certain amount of risk. Since the current economic crisis, many
OTAs and tour operators have shut down, and payments made to the OTA never arrive to the hotel, despite the
customer already being charged. Many hotels, including large international chains, have been unable collect payment
for rooms that have already been offered to (and paid for by) the customers.


          Currently, customers find it strange to make a 20% (commissions) or even a 100% (total stay) down
payment to secure their reservations, and one of the consequences is the loss of market share of some OTAs like
Expedia or Booking, taking into account that the first (Expedia) has not changed its OTA model.


          The third model is the most similar to the model implemented by hoteliers in their own web pages, which
allows for direct room reservations without any payment until customers have already stayed in the hotel, and at the
same time provides security for the hotel in the case of a “no show.” This model has become the most successful and
accepted among hoteliers, since hotels receive payments directly from the consumer and never has to offer their
services without security, in the form of a credit card number, in case the customer does not show up.


          Thus, compensations models of OTAs towards hotels have been simplified, especially because what matters
the most to the OTAs is having the largest possible number of hotels in their portfolios.


d. Disparity of prices or commercial rules


Some hoteliers sell rooms through Booking with a fees policy more advantageous to the consumer than through their
own website. The client, therefore, is more likely to reserve with Booking, as they are offering a better deal than the
hotel itself.


          However, when the hotel matches the conditions of sale exactly between their own website and those rooms
reserved on the OTA, the hotel experiences a rise in the number of rooms sold directly from hotel’s website, in a
phenomenon known by “billboard effect” (Anderson, C.: 2011).


          This indicates to us a key factor in the hotel reservation process: the client is willing to book directly with
the hotel when the hotel offers the same prices as the OTA, and when the conditions of purchasing, billing, and
cancellation are also equivalent. Therefore, any hotel or tourist establishment that applies not only a standard of price
parity, but also a standard of commercial parity, can raise their direct marketing on any customer, anywhere in the
world, thus lowering their level of dependence on OTAs. This consumer behavior, consequently, presents new

                                                             7
opportunities for income, based on the increase of direct sales without paying commissions to third parties. To do so,
hoteliers have to key tools6:


               A website managed by a CMS (content management system).
               A reservations manager CRS (central reservations system).


          Obviously, by now, everyone knows that with these two tools a hotel can exponentially increase their direct
bookings. However, our research has led us to determine that more than 76% of hotels do not effectively implement
these tools7. This is not only the case for hotels in leading destinations, but also, and more significantly, for hotels in
secondary destinations. If to this we add that commercial parity and/or price parity do not exist, we notice the missed
opportunities to optimize revenue.


4. What is happening now from a commercialization point of view?


The importance of knowing the effects that the Internet has on the tourism market is evident. These effects can be
divided into two areas: the effects on the client and the effects on the hotel establishment.


          As we know, the purchasing process is preceded by a search process, whose influence on the final decision
is key. This becomes particularly relevant in the Internet environment, as the search engine greatly influences the
final site through which the purchase will be made.


          In most cases, the consumer begins their search by using a search engine, which integrates SEM advertising
or prominently displays those websites sponsored by OTAs.


          In the early days of online advertising by the OTAs, these companies did not program their sponsored links
aggressively, but for some time now, their advertising departments have used this tool extensively. In fact, this
support may come to monopolize a large portion of their advertising budgets. Thus, some of them, such as Booking,
spend a considerable part of its turnover on ad-words campaigns in Google8, which in turn gives them a lot of traffic
from customers interested in hotel products. Along with Booking, other similar companies within its industrial group
(Agoda) or affiliated (Eurobookings) also sponsor links. Accordingly, we can say with certainty that the same
company occupies the majority of useful results, i.e. those located in preferred positions.




6
  As it has been stated by Varini, K. and Murph, H.: 2006, even though revenue management systems (RMS) were critical to optimize revenue
from room sales, reliance on them became less certain by the irruption of other new technologies, such as intermediaries, that invaded the
hospitality sector causing disruption in the marketplace.
7
   For a comprehensive approach to the intensity of use of ICT’s for hospitalities customer relationship and communication in Spain, see Ruiz-
Molina, M.E. et al.: 2010).
8
  According to WordStream, Booking spent 40,400,000 dollars in Google Ads campaigns in 2011.

                                                                      8
Given these results, the consumer tries to find the link they want: some of them are led to any OTAs site in
which the name of the hotel appears, others to the website of the establishment itself, this being the turning point that
leads a consumer to choose one site over another from which to buy. However, as we know, the OTAs spend a vast
amount of their R&D resources on design and usability, so upon accessing their web pages, the consumer finds a
fully optimized and focused environment to close the sale. In addition, on the same screen the consumer can find
photos, status maps, opinions of consumers and up-to-date prices that are, by contract, the best offered by the hotel.


         Once the dates have been chosen on an OTA site, in just two steps the client is informed about the rooms
and the final price of the stay, and must only fill out a form with their personal and credit card information to secure
the reservation. It should be noted that, in OTAs like Booking, a monetary transaction dependent on a POS does not
even take place, so the process is simplified even more.


         This is the preferred process by most consumers who currently use the Internet to book hotels, offering ease,
speed and a low level of commitment. On the other hand, we must take into account that when the consumer uses the
hotel website to book, they must first browse through it in order to find information (Schegg, R. et al.: 2005) such as
the hotel’s location relative to nearby landmarks or points of interest. In addition, there are not customer comments
or opinions on hotel websites, and their booking engines need to be found by users.


         And it is precisely there where another ordeal begins, because there are times when reservation systems do
not occupy the foreground, do not work very well, or do not offer pictures and descriptions of the rooms or a
breakdown of prices, as well as other possible options or stipulations (early bird, non-refundable, late check-out).
Finally, we have to take into account accessibility to extra services offered by the hotel (massages, spa, parking,
etc.). In these cases as well, the OTAs booking engines use to be much more effective than those of the establishment
websites.


         In short, there are many hotels that do not have reservation systems on their own websites, and those that
do, in too many instances, are so complicated that the client prefers the simpler process of the OTAs, and all of this
implies that in the process of booking hotel rooms, hotels lose revenue to OTAs.


         It is necessary to keep in mind, as well, that the majority of these companies are a part of major
conglomerates that do not reinvest their profits in these various destinations. In fact, the profits made by OTAs will
most likely go to a completely different country, sometimes alien to the company activities and/or with advantageous
tax conditions.


Conclusions




                                                           9
After analyzing the environment, and returning to the principle question (and title) of our article ¨Should
Spanish hoteliers improve their communication and direct distribution strategies to prevent loss of revenue?¨ we
arrived to the conclusion that there exists an opportunity to increase direct revenue, increasing the profit margin of
any hotel product at the global level (Morosan, C. and Jeong, M.: 2006). The key to this opportunity are the new
reservation habits of the consumer; that is to say, the fact that the tourists can purchase directly from the producer
(hotel) with ease.


           We cannot ignore the fact that, in 2010, Spain was the fourth most popular tourist destination in the world 9
with tourism revenue of almost 40 billion euros10. And in the same year, the estimated turnover of the hotel
establishments in the country was 10.7 billion euros11, a fact that reflects the potential of the mentioned opportunity.
In this sense, although no specific studies have been carried out regarding the concrete origin of the indirect hotel
reservations (OTAs, hotels, or tour operators) for the whole of Spain, there are significant data regarding percentage
of sales made directly and indirectly by the establishments in some territories. For example, as shown by the results
of a study conducted in Tenerife (Flores Alberto, D. et al.: 2011), 74.56% of tourists booked accommodations
through an intermediary, a finding that we are expanding and breaking down for the entire country in the second
phase of our study.


           With what we have affirmed up until this point, we do not mean to say that hotels should completely cease
to sell through OTAs, but rather, as Withiam12 correctly indicates, that hoteliers must conceive their relationship with
these agencies as a strategic alliance that helps to sell their product as much in the good times as they do in the bad,
and especially, in those markets which the hotelier will find difficult to access.


           In addition, and as Ding13 says, the benefits of the direct channel are not only confined to the increase in
revenue, since marketing without intermediaries carries with it the possibility to interact with consumers, gain brand
loyalty, and build lasting competitive advantages14. To this list of benefits we would add the decrease in the level of
dependency on the OTAs and the generation of new skilled jobs in the destination, because the realization of this
opportunity requires specializing personnel and new professional profiles, among which might include web
managers, community managers, revenue managers or directors of electronic distribution.


           In conclusion, we believe that all the hotels in tourist destinations would have to provide direct sales tools
that function in the same way as those of the big online retailers. Having and utilizing these tools is of crucial
importance for hotels in the development of both mature and emerging markets. It is clear that part of the money


9
 UNWTO World Tourism Barometer (Interim Update April 2011).
10
   As per the statistics collected by the Bank of Spain, the country took in 39,596,000,000 euros from tourism in 2010.
11
   As estimated by DBK in “Estudios Sectores de Establecimientos Hoteleros”, 17th edition, April 2011.
12
   Withiam, G.: 2011a.
13
   Ding, W.: 2011.
14
   In the case of China, as the cited author makes clear, some hotel chains have recently reduced their dependence on indirect channels, exemplified
by the experience of Seven Days Inn, which has reached 70% of direct commercialization, while other chains based in the country only receive
8% of reservations through the OTA channel.

                                                                        10
currently paid by hotels in commissions to large foreign OTAs could be reinvested to generate economic activity in
tourist destinations. On the other hand, the sales volume of some hotels is strongly linked to OTAs, which entails a
high level of dependence. And finally, as we pointed before, the main focus of public Administrations is to make
plans to promote tourism (advertising, public relations), but we think that this work should be accompanied by
internal work in the destination itself, consisting of endowing it with direct sales tools, so the value chain could be
conveniently closed 15.


References


Anderson, C. (2011) Search, OTAs and Online Booking: An Expanded Analysis of the Billboard Effect, Cornell
Hospitality Report, 11(8).


Chan, A. and Law, R. (2006) Hotel Website Optimization: The Case of Hong Kong, Information and
Communication Technologies in Tourism, 2006:60-73.


Ding, Wei (2011) Challenges and Opportunities of Hotel Online Booking in China, Design, User Experience, and
Usability. Theory, Methods, Tools and Practice, Vol. 6670/2011:3-12.


Flores Alberto, D., Salazar Niebla, L., and Santana Turégano, M.A. (2011) ¿Desaparecerán los Tour Operadores? El
papel de los intermediarios en la distribución turística: Análisis del caso de Tenerife, Pasos: Revista de Turismo y
Patrimonio Cultural, 9(2): 341-351.


Lim, S., Zegarra Saldaña, A., and Zegarra Saldaña, P.E. (2011) Do market oriented firms adopt Web 2.0
technologies? An empirical study in hospitality firms, International Entrepreneurship and Management Journal,
7(4): 465-477.


Morosan, C. and Jeong, M. (2006) Understanding Travellers’ Adoption of Hotel Reservation Web Sites, Information
and Communication Technologies in Tourism, 2006:394-405.


Prasad, V.K., Ramamurthy, K., and Naidu, G.M. (2001) The influence of Internet-marketing integration on
marketing competencies and export performance, Journal of International Marketing, 9(4):82-110.


Rheem, C. and Salgado Criado, J. (2011) lookinside.travel: Estudio Sobre el Viajero Español. Edición 2010,
PhoCusWright.




15
   Some of them, as the Government of Andalucía, in Spain, are implementing tools to allow reservations in small hotels that do not use the
Internet channels (Economía Digital, February, 12, 2012).

                                                                    11
Ruiz-Molina, M.E., Gil-Saura, I., and Moliner-Velázquez, B. (2010) Does technology make a difference? Evidence
from Spanish hotels, Service Business, 5(1):1-12.


Schegg, R., Steiner, T., Gherissi-Labben, T., and Murphy, J. (2005) Using Log File Analysis and Website
Assessment to Improve Hospitality Websites, Information and Communication Technologies in Tourism, 2005:566-
576.


Schegg, R., Steiner, T., Gherissi-Labben, T., and Murphy, J. (2005) Using Log file Analysis and Website
Assessment to Improve Hospitality Websites, Information and Communication Technologies in Tourism, 2005:566-
576.


Varini, K. and Murph, H. (2006) An Investigation of Expert Predictions of Profit Optimisation Opportunities from
Information Communication Technologies (ICTs) in the Hotel Sector, Information and Communication
Technologies in Tourism, 2006:463-474.


Withiam, G. (2011a) Brave New World: Online Hotel Distribution, Cornell Hospitality Research Summit
Proceedings, 3(3).


Withiam, G. (2011b) Social Media and the Hospitality Industry: Holding the Tiger by the Tail, Cornell Hospitality
Research Summit Proceedings, 3(3).




                                                       12

Contenu connexe

Similaire à Spanish hoteliers ota online sales comissions

Common value management based on effective and efficent
Common value management   based on effective and efficentCommon value management   based on effective and efficent
Common value management based on effective and efficent
STIinnsbruck
 
Social local mobile
Social local mobileSocial local mobile
Social local mobile
freitasr21
 
11Proposal Part One - Part 1 Influence of Internet on Tourism
11Proposal Part One - Part 1 Influence of Internet on Tourism11Proposal Part One - Part 1 Influence of Internet on Tourism
11Proposal Part One - Part 1 Influence of Internet on Tourism
SantosConleyha
 
11Proposal Part One - Part 1 Influence of Internet on Tourism
11Proposal Part One - Part 1 Influence of Internet on Tourism11Proposal Part One - Part 1 Influence of Internet on Tourism
11Proposal Part One - Part 1 Influence of Internet on Tourism
BenitoSumpter862
 
MKT 5017 Article Critique - Mertcan Karabuk
MKT 5017 Article Critique - Mertcan KarabukMKT 5017 Article Critique - Mertcan Karabuk
MKT 5017 Article Critique - Mertcan Karabuk
Mertcan Karabük
 
How to-domesticate-the-multichannel-monster 27.11.2012
How to-domesticate-the-multichannel-monster 27.11.2012How to-domesticate-the-multichannel-monster 27.11.2012
How to-domesticate-the-multichannel-monster 27.11.2012
STIinnsbruck
 

Similaire à Spanish hoteliers ota online sales comissions (20)

Tdhd
TdhdTdhd
Tdhd
 
Common value management based on effective and efficent
Common value management   based on effective and efficentCommon value management   based on effective and efficent
Common value management based on effective and efficent
 
Social local mobile
Social local mobileSocial local mobile
Social local mobile
 
Social local mobile
Social local mobileSocial local mobile
Social local mobile
 
11Proposal Part One - Part 1 Influence of Internet on Tourism
11Proposal Part One - Part 1 Influence of Internet on Tourism11Proposal Part One - Part 1 Influence of Internet on Tourism
11Proposal Part One - Part 1 Influence of Internet on Tourism
 
11Proposal Part One - Part 1 Influence of Internet on Tourism
11Proposal Part One - Part 1 Influence of Internet on Tourism11Proposal Part One - Part 1 Influence of Internet on Tourism
11Proposal Part One - Part 1 Influence of Internet on Tourism
 
Engagement whitepaper 3.0 0
Engagement whitepaper 3.0 0Engagement whitepaper 3.0 0
Engagement whitepaper 3.0 0
 
MKT 5017 Article Critique - Mertcan Karabuk
MKT 5017 Article Critique - Mertcan KarabukMKT 5017 Article Critique - Mertcan Karabuk
MKT 5017 Article Critique - Mertcan Karabuk
 
2016 Hospitality Trends Report
2016 Hospitality Trends Report2016 Hospitality Trends Report
2016 Hospitality Trends Report
 
Case Crusade Case study
Case Crusade Case studyCase Crusade Case study
Case Crusade Case study
 
Hotel Digital Marketing Trends
Hotel Digital Marketing TrendsHotel Digital Marketing Trends
Hotel Digital Marketing Trends
 
Hotel Digital Marketing Trends Presentation - Best Stay Croatia 2015
Hotel Digital Marketing Trends Presentation - Best Stay Croatia 2015 Hotel Digital Marketing Trends Presentation - Best Stay Croatia 2015
Hotel Digital Marketing Trends Presentation - Best Stay Croatia 2015
 
OTAs are fundamentally breaking guest communication and hotels accept it
OTAs are fundamentally breaking guest communication and hotels accept itOTAs are fundamentally breaking guest communication and hotels accept it
OTAs are fundamentally breaking guest communication and hotels accept it
 
E-Tourism Assignment
E-Tourism AssignmentE-Tourism Assignment
E-Tourism Assignment
 
Pomegranate inside-series-travel-and-tourism
Pomegranate inside-series-travel-and-tourismPomegranate inside-series-travel-and-tourism
Pomegranate inside-series-travel-and-tourism
 
UNWTO Report: Online guest reviews and hotel classification sytems
UNWTO Report: Online guest reviews and hotel classification sytemsUNWTO Report: Online guest reviews and hotel classification sytems
UNWTO Report: Online guest reviews and hotel classification sytems
 
Presentation tourism
Presentation tourismPresentation tourism
Presentation tourism
 
Presentation Team Working
Presentation Team WorkingPresentation Team Working
Presentation Team Working
 
How to-domesticate-the-multichannel-monster 27.11.2012
How to-domesticate-the-multichannel-monster 27.11.2012How to-domesticate-the-multichannel-monster 27.11.2012
How to-domesticate-the-multichannel-monster 27.11.2012
 
A hybrid approach to tourism (1)
A hybrid approach to tourism (1)A hybrid approach to tourism (1)
A hybrid approach to tourism (1)
 

Plus de TOMEU PONS

Encuestas de satisfaccion 2012 Seminarios Alto Rendimiento en Revenue Manag...
Encuestas de satisfaccion 2012   Seminarios Alto Rendimiento en Revenue Manag...Encuestas de satisfaccion 2012   Seminarios Alto Rendimiento en Revenue Manag...
Encuestas de satisfaccion 2012 Seminarios Alto Rendimiento en Revenue Manag...
TOMEU PONS
 
Seminari barcelona activa cibernarium apartaments tecnologia comercializaci...
Seminari barcelona activa cibernarium   apartaments tecnologia comercializaci...Seminari barcelona activa cibernarium   apartaments tecnologia comercializaci...
Seminari barcelona activa cibernarium apartaments tecnologia comercializaci...
TOMEU PONS
 
Presentacion flamingo hotelier nov 2011 -2
Presentacion flamingo hotelier nov 2011 -2Presentacion flamingo hotelier nov 2011 -2
Presentacion flamingo hotelier nov 2011 -2
TOMEU PONS
 
Seminari barcelona activa cibernarium motors de reserves gener 2012
Seminari barcelona activa cibernarium motors de reserves   gener 2012Seminari barcelona activa cibernarium motors de reserves   gener 2012
Seminari barcelona activa cibernarium motors de reserves gener 2012
TOMEU PONS
 
Seminari barcelona activa cibernarium revenue management yield gener 2012
Seminari barcelona activa cibernarium revenue management yield   gener 2012Seminari barcelona activa cibernarium revenue management yield   gener 2012
Seminari barcelona activa cibernarium revenue management yield gener 2012
TOMEU PONS
 
INTRODUCCION REVENUE MANAGEMENT PARA HOTELES y YIELD MANAGEMENT
INTRODUCCION REVENUE MANAGEMENT PARA HOTELES y YIELD MANAGEMENTINTRODUCCION REVENUE MANAGEMENT PARA HOTELES y YIELD MANAGEMENT
INTRODUCCION REVENUE MANAGEMENT PARA HOTELES y YIELD MANAGEMENT
TOMEU PONS
 

Plus de TOMEU PONS (15)

Private talks and seminars: About revenue managment
Private talks and seminars: About revenue managmentPrivate talks and seminars: About revenue managment
Private talks and seminars: About revenue managment
 
Advanced revenue management for hotels 1 - lisbon 2016 - english
Advanced revenue management for hotels 1  - lisbon 2016 - englishAdvanced revenue management for hotels 1  - lisbon 2016 - english
Advanced revenue management for hotels 1 - lisbon 2016 - english
 
Motores de Reservas (Booking Engines) para Hoteles y Apartamentos
Motores de Reservas (Booking Engines) para Hoteles y Apartamentos Motores de Reservas (Booking Engines) para Hoteles y Apartamentos
Motores de Reservas (Booking Engines) para Hoteles y Apartamentos
 
Revenue Management para Apartamentos y Hoteles - Curso Gratuito en Cibernarium
Revenue Management para Apartamentos y Hoteles - Curso Gratuito en CibernariumRevenue Management para Apartamentos y Hoteles - Curso Gratuito en Cibernarium
Revenue Management para Apartamentos y Hoteles - Curso Gratuito en Cibernarium
 
Oviedo 2013
Oviedo 2013Oviedo 2013
Oviedo 2013
 
Tutorial introduction to revenue management for hotels hospitality seminar w...
Tutorial introduction to revenue management for hotels hospitality seminar  w...Tutorial introduction to revenue management for hotels hospitality seminar  w...
Tutorial introduction to revenue management for hotels hospitality seminar w...
 
Encuestas de satisfaccion 2012 Seminarios Alto Rendimiento en Revenue Manag...
Encuestas de satisfaccion 2012   Seminarios Alto Rendimiento en Revenue Manag...Encuestas de satisfaccion 2012   Seminarios Alto Rendimiento en Revenue Manag...
Encuestas de satisfaccion 2012 Seminarios Alto Rendimiento en Revenue Manag...
 
Introduccion a la distribucion online para hoteles, gestión de ventas para ho...
Introduccion a la distribucion online para hoteles, gestión de ventas para ho...Introduccion a la distribucion online para hoteles, gestión de ventas para ho...
Introduccion a la distribucion online para hoteles, gestión de ventas para ho...
 
Curso formacion revenue management para hoteles version 12
Curso formacion revenue management para hoteles version 12Curso formacion revenue management para hoteles version 12
Curso formacion revenue management para hoteles version 12
 
Seminari barcelona activa cibernarium apartaments tecnologia comercializaci...
Seminari barcelona activa cibernarium   apartaments tecnologia comercializaci...Seminari barcelona activa cibernarium   apartaments tecnologia comercializaci...
Seminari barcelona activa cibernarium apartaments tecnologia comercializaci...
 
Distribución hotelera motor de reservas hotel resultados pp aedem_2012 (3)
Distribución hotelera motor de reservas hotel resultados pp aedem_2012 (3)Distribución hotelera motor de reservas hotel resultados pp aedem_2012 (3)
Distribución hotelera motor de reservas hotel resultados pp aedem_2012 (3)
 
Presentacion flamingo hotelier nov 2011 -2
Presentacion flamingo hotelier nov 2011 -2Presentacion flamingo hotelier nov 2011 -2
Presentacion flamingo hotelier nov 2011 -2
 
Seminari barcelona activa cibernarium motors de reserves gener 2012
Seminari barcelona activa cibernarium motors de reserves   gener 2012Seminari barcelona activa cibernarium motors de reserves   gener 2012
Seminari barcelona activa cibernarium motors de reserves gener 2012
 
Seminari barcelona activa cibernarium revenue management yield gener 2012
Seminari barcelona activa cibernarium revenue management yield   gener 2012Seminari barcelona activa cibernarium revenue management yield   gener 2012
Seminari barcelona activa cibernarium revenue management yield gener 2012
 
INTRODUCCION REVENUE MANAGEMENT PARA HOTELES y YIELD MANAGEMENT
INTRODUCCION REVENUE MANAGEMENT PARA HOTELES y YIELD MANAGEMENTINTRODUCCION REVENUE MANAGEMENT PARA HOTELES y YIELD MANAGEMENT
INTRODUCCION REVENUE MANAGEMENT PARA HOTELES y YIELD MANAGEMENT
 

Dernier

Histor y of HAM Radio presentation slide
Histor y of HAM Radio presentation slideHistor y of HAM Radio presentation slide
Histor y of HAM Radio presentation slide
vu2urc
 
IAC 2024 - IA Fast Track to Search Focused AI Solutions
IAC 2024 - IA Fast Track to Search Focused AI SolutionsIAC 2024 - IA Fast Track to Search Focused AI Solutions
IAC 2024 - IA Fast Track to Search Focused AI Solutions
Enterprise Knowledge
 
Artificial Intelligence: Facts and Myths
Artificial Intelligence: Facts and MythsArtificial Intelligence: Facts and Myths
Artificial Intelligence: Facts and Myths
Joaquim Jorge
 

Dernier (20)

Histor y of HAM Radio presentation slide
Histor y of HAM Radio presentation slideHistor y of HAM Radio presentation slide
Histor y of HAM Radio presentation slide
 
Finology Group – Insurtech Innovation Award 2024
Finology Group – Insurtech Innovation Award 2024Finology Group – Insurtech Innovation Award 2024
Finology Group – Insurtech Innovation Award 2024
 
The Role of Taxonomy and Ontology in Semantic Layers - Heather Hedden.pdf
The Role of Taxonomy and Ontology in Semantic Layers - Heather Hedden.pdfThe Role of Taxonomy and Ontology in Semantic Layers - Heather Hedden.pdf
The Role of Taxonomy and Ontology in Semantic Layers - Heather Hedden.pdf
 
08448380779 Call Girls In Diplomatic Enclave Women Seeking Men
08448380779 Call Girls In Diplomatic Enclave Women Seeking Men08448380779 Call Girls In Diplomatic Enclave Women Seeking Men
08448380779 Call Girls In Diplomatic Enclave Women Seeking Men
 
Tata AIG General Insurance Company - Insurer Innovation Award 2024
Tata AIG General Insurance Company - Insurer Innovation Award 2024Tata AIG General Insurance Company - Insurer Innovation Award 2024
Tata AIG General Insurance Company - Insurer Innovation Award 2024
 
IAC 2024 - IA Fast Track to Search Focused AI Solutions
IAC 2024 - IA Fast Track to Search Focused AI SolutionsIAC 2024 - IA Fast Track to Search Focused AI Solutions
IAC 2024 - IA Fast Track to Search Focused AI Solutions
 
What Are The Drone Anti-jamming Systems Technology?
What Are The Drone Anti-jamming Systems Technology?What Are The Drone Anti-jamming Systems Technology?
What Are The Drone Anti-jamming Systems Technology?
 
[2024]Digital Global Overview Report 2024 Meltwater.pdf
[2024]Digital Global Overview Report 2024 Meltwater.pdf[2024]Digital Global Overview Report 2024 Meltwater.pdf
[2024]Digital Global Overview Report 2024 Meltwater.pdf
 
Workshop - Best of Both Worlds_ Combine KG and Vector search for enhanced R...
Workshop - Best of Both Worlds_ Combine  KG and Vector search for  enhanced R...Workshop - Best of Both Worlds_ Combine  KG and Vector search for  enhanced R...
Workshop - Best of Both Worlds_ Combine KG and Vector search for enhanced R...
 
08448380779 Call Girls In Greater Kailash - I Women Seeking Men
08448380779 Call Girls In Greater Kailash - I Women Seeking Men08448380779 Call Girls In Greater Kailash - I Women Seeking Men
08448380779 Call Girls In Greater Kailash - I Women Seeking Men
 
Real Time Object Detection Using Open CV
Real Time Object Detection Using Open CVReal Time Object Detection Using Open CV
Real Time Object Detection Using Open CV
 
Presentation on how to chat with PDF using ChatGPT code interpreter
Presentation on how to chat with PDF using ChatGPT code interpreterPresentation on how to chat with PDF using ChatGPT code interpreter
Presentation on how to chat with PDF using ChatGPT code interpreter
 
Boost PC performance: How more available memory can improve productivity
Boost PC performance: How more available memory can improve productivityBoost PC performance: How more available memory can improve productivity
Boost PC performance: How more available memory can improve productivity
 
Artificial Intelligence: Facts and Myths
Artificial Intelligence: Facts and MythsArtificial Intelligence: Facts and Myths
Artificial Intelligence: Facts and Myths
 
Handwritten Text Recognition for manuscripts and early printed texts
Handwritten Text Recognition for manuscripts and early printed textsHandwritten Text Recognition for manuscripts and early printed texts
Handwritten Text Recognition for manuscripts and early printed texts
 
Scaling API-first – The story of a global engineering organization
Scaling API-first – The story of a global engineering organizationScaling API-first – The story of a global engineering organization
Scaling API-first – The story of a global engineering organization
 
Bajaj Allianz Life Insurance Company - Insurer Innovation Award 2024
Bajaj Allianz Life Insurance Company - Insurer Innovation Award 2024Bajaj Allianz Life Insurance Company - Insurer Innovation Award 2024
Bajaj Allianz Life Insurance Company - Insurer Innovation Award 2024
 
Strategies for Unlocking Knowledge Management in Microsoft 365 in the Copilot...
Strategies for Unlocking Knowledge Management in Microsoft 365 in the Copilot...Strategies for Unlocking Knowledge Management in Microsoft 365 in the Copilot...
Strategies for Unlocking Knowledge Management in Microsoft 365 in the Copilot...
 
Driving Behavioral Change for Information Management through Data-Driven Gree...
Driving Behavioral Change for Information Management through Data-Driven Gree...Driving Behavioral Change for Information Management through Data-Driven Gree...
Driving Behavioral Change for Information Management through Data-Driven Gree...
 
Apidays Singapore 2024 - Building Digital Trust in a Digital Economy by Veron...
Apidays Singapore 2024 - Building Digital Trust in a Digital Economy by Veron...Apidays Singapore 2024 - Building Digital Trust in a Digital Economy by Veron...
Apidays Singapore 2024 - Building Digital Trust in a Digital Economy by Veron...
 

Spanish hoteliers ota online sales comissions

  • 1. SHOULD SPANISH HOTELIERS IMPROVE THEIR COMMUNICATION AND DIRECT DISTRIBUTION STRATEGIES TO PREVENT LOSS OF REVENUE? Josep M Altarriba, jmaltarriba@ub.edu, University of Barcelona Tomeu Pons, tomeu.pons@tsi.url.edu, Ramon Llull University ABSTRACT As we know, many hoteliers have seen their level of dependence on OTAs increase in recent years. Through heavy investment in online communication strategies, these virtual agencies are continuing to channel a large percentage of reservations, which entails the payment of the corresponding fees on the part of the establishments. In this article, the first in a series of three that we are dedicating to the treatment of this issue, we will focus on the study of this phenomenon mainly through an analysis of the roles played by various actors involved in the process of online commercialization, and the tools that hoteliers have at their disposal to boost their direct distribution, thus avoiding excessive third-party intermediation and retaining the portion of the revenue that is currently allocated to payment of commissions to OTAs. KEYWORDS Direct Distribution · Hotel Booking Engines · Online Travel Agencies · Spain 1. Introduction In the years following the invention and adoption of the Internet1, and its subsequent widespread use for marketing purposes (Prasad et al.: 2001), e-commerce transactions have increased exponentially. In the specific case of the tourism sector, this increase has been accompanied by the rapid emergence of a new player in the marketing process: online travel agencies (OTAs), which, over time, have managed to entice the final client, and have created a high demand for their websites through the intensive use of strategies in the online environment. As we know, these agencies act as brokers to whom the hotels pay a percentage of the reservations they book through them. A considerable amount of the OTAs revenues is invested in Internet marketing campaigns, and at first glance it seems virtually impossible that hoteliers could combat these strategies by changing their mode of distribution. However, if we focus on the key performance indicators of these business models, we realize that with 1 According to the Internet World Stats, in 2011 there were 2,095,000,000 Internet users in the planet, what makes a 30.2% of the population. 1
  • 2. cheaper access to technology, local small businesses in tourist destination can improve their performance and thus, receive more direct benefits. In this paper we analyze the environment in which hotel distribution is currently developing, as well as the opportunities available and the impact they can have on tourism enterprises, and consequently, on the economies of the tourist destinations themselves; even though, as we will point in our conclusions, we are conducting further research in order to empirically contrast some of our conjectures. 2. The Internet scenario: How consumers, online travel agencies (OTAs), hoteliers, Administrations and social networks act? a. Consumers In today’s world, the consumer has lost almost all fear of making travel reservations online2. The modern consumer understands and appreciates the advantages the online reservation process offers over the traditional off-line booking methods. In fact, it is safe to say that in most cases, time spent planning and researching a vacation is often perceived as a leisurely activity (Morosan, C. and Jeong, M.: 2006). Today, there exists a multitude of websites replete with content regarding travel destinations and activities for tourists to enjoy during their stay. These websites have evolved substantially, and continue to grow and adapt to the mediums used by consumers to access social networks. New accurately categorized, well-presented and easily accessible tourism contents are being created, and among them, contents from other users, either or not they are known to the consumer, are of paramount value due to the importance of their recommendations and opinions3. This relatively new activity, whose impact is of unarguable significance in the realm of travel and tourism, necessarily requires the use of the Internet, and logically so, since it is inconceivable, in the age of the information, to gather, sort, and disseminate such a large quantity of information without the use of the web. However, this process, while highly beneficial for the consumer, presents new challenges for the tourist destinations themselves. Since travel information is so easily and quickly accessed, the consumer transforms the information collection process to the process of evaluation, therefore dramatically decreasing the time between acquisition of information and decision-making. And more precisely, consumers have reduced the time dedicated to 2 In the case of Spain, a 68% of hotel reservations were made online in 2010 (Rheem, C. and Salgado, J.: 2011). In 2011, as per one of the key findings of the congress sponsored by Microsoft “Destinola Nube”, a 60% of travelers that visited the country used the Internet to make their reservations, and a 46% paid online. 3 According to the “Activitat turística: el turista en hotel 1993-2010” report prepared by Barcelona Turisme, an 86% of tourists who visited Barcelona in 2010 used the Internet to gather information about the destination. 2
  • 3. the purchase itself, what we consider as a key element that can have a high impact on the development of local economies in tourist destinations. b. Online Travel Agencies (OTAs) OTAs models have evolved their to maximize the number of products offered and sales made, and to improve user experience.  Regarding the product, most OTAs have thousands of references in their catalogues, and nearly cover 100% of tourist destinations worldwide. Most hotels are listed within the portfolios of the major OTAs, even though there are some exceptions: very first-class and very low-class hotels, as well as those hotels with a limited number of rooms.  Regarding sales, agencies have adopted sophisticated commercialization techniques and have improved their commercial policies, therefore making them more attractive to customers. For example, consumer friendly agencies do not require any down payment to secure the reservation, have eliminated cancellation fees, implemented loyalty programs, and developed flash sales with momentary discounts that eventually reach the 50% to customers that either purchase or travel within the designated time periods.  Regarding usability, OTAs have exponentially improved the design of their websites through the use of sophisticated marketing research methods and techniques and maximized efficiency, thereby minimizing the time necessary to complete a transaction. Typically, websites are designed so that, in three or less steps, customers can carry out most booking processes, thus enhancing user experience. c. Hoteliers In response to the changing world of travel reservations, hoteliers, too, have adapted their strategies on the marketing mix in the following ways:  Product: Hotels have added new room categories with new room descriptions and pictures to better accommodate travelers’ needs and uses. Also, hotels have adapted services and products provided to guests.  Price: Traditionally, as we all know, hotels have maintained static rates for their rooms. This trend has now become obsolete in the changing environment. From the spread of the use of the Internet, hotels have created new pricing indexes to account for new customer needs to such an extent that a 100-room hotel may offer up to 50 different rates. In fact, price generation has become such a complex task that even smaller hotels are hiring revenue managers, once employed only by larger chains. 3
  • 4. Promotion: Hoteliers have realized the necessity of having their own webpage. However, these websites cannot simply be a digital version of their old paper brochures; style and presentation are just as important as information and content. Hotels must take into account marketing and sales strategies when creating a webpage in order to successfully promote their hotel to a growing online audience. Therefore, hoteliers are paying more close attention to the text used (phrasing, style, presentation) and pictures presented (art direction, processing, and other varying aesthetic techniques). The hotels themselves must now assume these tasks, previously managed by communication agencies, and convey all these information to their corporate profiles on social networks.  Place: The Internet has made it possible to reach anyone, anywhere, without intermediaries; hoteliers are aware of this fact. Not too long ago, customers could fill out online forms that would be answered within 24 hours, similar to the antiquated system of fax reservations. But in the last few years, most hotels have adopted CRS software, enabling customers to make immediate reservations. Basically, hotels have integrated the same services offered by OTAs into their own, unique websites. d. Public Administrations Since the beginning of the Internet, public Administrations of tourist destinations have assumed the role of categorizing and providing tourist resources to potential travelers. Most public Administrations have followed this path, but in doing so, acted incorrectly and in manners inconsistent with the consumers’ changing nature of information acquisition. An encyclopedic resource that offers excessive information is an unnecessary and outdated method to communicate tourism information, and is inconsistent with the online buyer decision process. In many instances, the information displayed is not valuable for the user and does not include facts about the destination that consumers would expect, such as maps, pet allowances or safety issues. Additionally, many of these web projects assumed by public administrations have taken too long to complete, meanwhile the Internet has been rapidly evolving by generating new tools and applications to solve customers’ needs without offering irrelevant or unnecessary information. These solutions to facilitate travel have quickly spread between travelers through a virtual word of mouth (Lim, S. et al.: 2011). For these reasons, we have come to the conclusion that that role traditionally played by public Administrations to promote tourism on the Internet is, in most of the cases, an obsolete resource for tourists, since the net has allowed consumers to connect with each other, with OTAs and with hotels directly, thereby bypassing public tourism websites. In other words, most of the actions that public Administrations can do to promote tourism are already, and more efficiently, being done, and therefore, they should change their tactics. The primary function of public Administrations, in this arena, is to promote tourism to their destination and the goal of online promotion is to reach the greatest amount of people in the smallest time possible. Taking into account this premise, a more suitable tactic would be to increase their presence and actions on social networking sites. 4
  • 5. However, we believe that all these actions are only a portion of what is necessary for a tourist destination to be reserved. In effect, after many years of focusing on the pre-sale portion of the booking process, we conclude there has been a certain abandonment of the actual selling process. Thus, the Administration has promoted, in a massive manner, tourist destinations that are then sold mostly through intermediaries, since frequently the tourism based companies of the destination do not have the technological tools to take advantage of the flow of demand created thanks to the advertisement investment, therefore losing the opportunity to obtain a fair return to these public campaigns. e. Social networks Social networks are becoming new players that need to be taken into account. While their marketing role is still relatively undefined (Withiam, G.: 2011b), there is no doubt that social networking sites’ involvement in all the activities related to the online consumer will be crucial in the near future4. This is logical assumption to make: the Internet has allowed large amounts of users to gather around common interests and share their concerns, and in response, other users generate more contents. Since these virtual contents created and shared by users have no foreseeable limit, the time of exposure to these platforms keep growing. Many networks, such as Facebook, currently allow the creation of corporate profiles. These profiles may contain the same sections as traditional corporate web pages: general information, situation maps, contact data, product description and pictures, opinions from customers, and official releases by which special offers and other promotional sales can be announced. In short, corporate profiles on social networking sites are able to perform all the primary functions as their corporate sites, with the added benefit of being more accessible to their target market. Therefore, hoteliers will have to dedicate the same marketing efforts to their corporate profiles on social networks as those they are dedicating to their corporate sites. On the other hand, new corporate profiles are incorporating new software developed by other companies, either to manage profile contents or to manage the insights of communication actions through sophisticated strategic marketing tools. Therefore, this medium (social networking sites) has the potential to become a substitute for hotel websites as well, as they have the ability to contain the same information as an individual website with the added bonus of being more easily accessed by the consumer. This is due to the enormous growth of social networks and time spent by users on these sites, as we have previously stated. 3. Can this scenario create new opportunities? 4 As the Nielsen State of the Media: Social Media Report (2011, Q3) shows, a 70% of active online adult social networkers shop online, 12% percent more likely than the average adult Internet users. 5
  • 6. a. The customer and the online environment Currently, and despite the 2008 financial crisis, international tourist markets have continued to grow, either because the consumers of developed countries have included tourism activities in their basic necessities, or due to the remarkable increase of travelers from BRICs and other emerging counties5. Regardless of the markets, all consumers have adopted the Internet as a basic tool to gain access to the information they are looking for. In the case of tourism, the net provides information on destinations and allows travelers to purchase services, specifically, transportation and lodging. In some cases, complementary products can also be acquired, especially when they are scarce or there are difficulties to access them, such as visits to protected areas or restricted monuments. b. The customer and the OTA OTAs have been leading a distribution process that they have been improving in all its stages (Morosan, C. and Jeong, M: 2006): consumers and hotel prices gaining, product increases, website usability optimization, remarkable investments in technological infrastructure and hardware, and constant enlargement of their customer services. Thus, transactional models once offered by the first OTAs to final customers have nothing to do with the current models. c. The OTA and the hotel Overall, revenues of OTAs come mainly from hotel products and transportation. But, how does this revenue reach the hotels? There are three possible ways: 1. The client makes a reservation with an OTA, to which they pay 100% of the price. This money stays in the hands of the OTA until the client has stayed the total number of nights at the hotel, and checked out. At which point, the OTA sends the money to the hotel, minus the commission charged by the OTA. The money stays, for a time, with the OTA so that they can respond to cancellations or complaints of the client. 2. The client makes reservations with an OTA and the OTA charges the client a fee to guarantee to hold the room at the hotel. In this case, the client doesn’t know that the percentage paid to secure the room is actually the commission that the OTA will keep. That is, the travel agent is paid at the time the reservation is made and the customer pays for the remainder of the stay directly to the hotel when checking out. 5 According to the Spanish Institute of Tourism Studies (IET), in January 2012 Spain received 2,778,116 international tourists, 122,000 more than in January 2011. Travelers from Russia grew by 61% (Nota de coyuntura de Frontur. Enero 2012). The tourists’ average daily expenditure increased by 11.2%, reaching 99 euros per traveler per day (Nota de coyuntura de Egatur. Enero 2012). 6
  • 7. 3. In this form, the client reserves their hotel through an OTA, but pays at the hotel. In this case, the hotel pays a monthly commission to the OTA. The client secures their stay by giving their credit card number to the OTA, however, the OTA or hotel only use this card if the customer does not show up at the hotel and did not cancel the reservation (no show case). In the first model, many hoteliers perceive a certain amount of risk. Since the current economic crisis, many OTAs and tour operators have shut down, and payments made to the OTA never arrive to the hotel, despite the customer already being charged. Many hotels, including large international chains, have been unable collect payment for rooms that have already been offered to (and paid for by) the customers. Currently, customers find it strange to make a 20% (commissions) or even a 100% (total stay) down payment to secure their reservations, and one of the consequences is the loss of market share of some OTAs like Expedia or Booking, taking into account that the first (Expedia) has not changed its OTA model. The third model is the most similar to the model implemented by hoteliers in their own web pages, which allows for direct room reservations without any payment until customers have already stayed in the hotel, and at the same time provides security for the hotel in the case of a “no show.” This model has become the most successful and accepted among hoteliers, since hotels receive payments directly from the consumer and never has to offer their services without security, in the form of a credit card number, in case the customer does not show up. Thus, compensations models of OTAs towards hotels have been simplified, especially because what matters the most to the OTAs is having the largest possible number of hotels in their portfolios. d. Disparity of prices or commercial rules Some hoteliers sell rooms through Booking with a fees policy more advantageous to the consumer than through their own website. The client, therefore, is more likely to reserve with Booking, as they are offering a better deal than the hotel itself. However, when the hotel matches the conditions of sale exactly between their own website and those rooms reserved on the OTA, the hotel experiences a rise in the number of rooms sold directly from hotel’s website, in a phenomenon known by “billboard effect” (Anderson, C.: 2011). This indicates to us a key factor in the hotel reservation process: the client is willing to book directly with the hotel when the hotel offers the same prices as the OTA, and when the conditions of purchasing, billing, and cancellation are also equivalent. Therefore, any hotel or tourist establishment that applies not only a standard of price parity, but also a standard of commercial parity, can raise their direct marketing on any customer, anywhere in the world, thus lowering their level of dependence on OTAs. This consumer behavior, consequently, presents new 7
  • 8. opportunities for income, based on the increase of direct sales without paying commissions to third parties. To do so, hoteliers have to key tools6:  A website managed by a CMS (content management system).  A reservations manager CRS (central reservations system). Obviously, by now, everyone knows that with these two tools a hotel can exponentially increase their direct bookings. However, our research has led us to determine that more than 76% of hotels do not effectively implement these tools7. This is not only the case for hotels in leading destinations, but also, and more significantly, for hotels in secondary destinations. If to this we add that commercial parity and/or price parity do not exist, we notice the missed opportunities to optimize revenue. 4. What is happening now from a commercialization point of view? The importance of knowing the effects that the Internet has on the tourism market is evident. These effects can be divided into two areas: the effects on the client and the effects on the hotel establishment. As we know, the purchasing process is preceded by a search process, whose influence on the final decision is key. This becomes particularly relevant in the Internet environment, as the search engine greatly influences the final site through which the purchase will be made. In most cases, the consumer begins their search by using a search engine, which integrates SEM advertising or prominently displays those websites sponsored by OTAs. In the early days of online advertising by the OTAs, these companies did not program their sponsored links aggressively, but for some time now, their advertising departments have used this tool extensively. In fact, this support may come to monopolize a large portion of their advertising budgets. Thus, some of them, such as Booking, spend a considerable part of its turnover on ad-words campaigns in Google8, which in turn gives them a lot of traffic from customers interested in hotel products. Along with Booking, other similar companies within its industrial group (Agoda) or affiliated (Eurobookings) also sponsor links. Accordingly, we can say with certainty that the same company occupies the majority of useful results, i.e. those located in preferred positions. 6 As it has been stated by Varini, K. and Murph, H.: 2006, even though revenue management systems (RMS) were critical to optimize revenue from room sales, reliance on them became less certain by the irruption of other new technologies, such as intermediaries, that invaded the hospitality sector causing disruption in the marketplace. 7 For a comprehensive approach to the intensity of use of ICT’s for hospitalities customer relationship and communication in Spain, see Ruiz- Molina, M.E. et al.: 2010). 8 According to WordStream, Booking spent 40,400,000 dollars in Google Ads campaigns in 2011. 8
  • 9. Given these results, the consumer tries to find the link they want: some of them are led to any OTAs site in which the name of the hotel appears, others to the website of the establishment itself, this being the turning point that leads a consumer to choose one site over another from which to buy. However, as we know, the OTAs spend a vast amount of their R&D resources on design and usability, so upon accessing their web pages, the consumer finds a fully optimized and focused environment to close the sale. In addition, on the same screen the consumer can find photos, status maps, opinions of consumers and up-to-date prices that are, by contract, the best offered by the hotel. Once the dates have been chosen on an OTA site, in just two steps the client is informed about the rooms and the final price of the stay, and must only fill out a form with their personal and credit card information to secure the reservation. It should be noted that, in OTAs like Booking, a monetary transaction dependent on a POS does not even take place, so the process is simplified even more. This is the preferred process by most consumers who currently use the Internet to book hotels, offering ease, speed and a low level of commitment. On the other hand, we must take into account that when the consumer uses the hotel website to book, they must first browse through it in order to find information (Schegg, R. et al.: 2005) such as the hotel’s location relative to nearby landmarks or points of interest. In addition, there are not customer comments or opinions on hotel websites, and their booking engines need to be found by users. And it is precisely there where another ordeal begins, because there are times when reservation systems do not occupy the foreground, do not work very well, or do not offer pictures and descriptions of the rooms or a breakdown of prices, as well as other possible options or stipulations (early bird, non-refundable, late check-out). Finally, we have to take into account accessibility to extra services offered by the hotel (massages, spa, parking, etc.). In these cases as well, the OTAs booking engines use to be much more effective than those of the establishment websites. In short, there are many hotels that do not have reservation systems on their own websites, and those that do, in too many instances, are so complicated that the client prefers the simpler process of the OTAs, and all of this implies that in the process of booking hotel rooms, hotels lose revenue to OTAs. It is necessary to keep in mind, as well, that the majority of these companies are a part of major conglomerates that do not reinvest their profits in these various destinations. In fact, the profits made by OTAs will most likely go to a completely different country, sometimes alien to the company activities and/or with advantageous tax conditions. Conclusions 9
  • 10. After analyzing the environment, and returning to the principle question (and title) of our article ¨Should Spanish hoteliers improve their communication and direct distribution strategies to prevent loss of revenue?¨ we arrived to the conclusion that there exists an opportunity to increase direct revenue, increasing the profit margin of any hotel product at the global level (Morosan, C. and Jeong, M.: 2006). The key to this opportunity are the new reservation habits of the consumer; that is to say, the fact that the tourists can purchase directly from the producer (hotel) with ease. We cannot ignore the fact that, in 2010, Spain was the fourth most popular tourist destination in the world 9 with tourism revenue of almost 40 billion euros10. And in the same year, the estimated turnover of the hotel establishments in the country was 10.7 billion euros11, a fact that reflects the potential of the mentioned opportunity. In this sense, although no specific studies have been carried out regarding the concrete origin of the indirect hotel reservations (OTAs, hotels, or tour operators) for the whole of Spain, there are significant data regarding percentage of sales made directly and indirectly by the establishments in some territories. For example, as shown by the results of a study conducted in Tenerife (Flores Alberto, D. et al.: 2011), 74.56% of tourists booked accommodations through an intermediary, a finding that we are expanding and breaking down for the entire country in the second phase of our study. With what we have affirmed up until this point, we do not mean to say that hotels should completely cease to sell through OTAs, but rather, as Withiam12 correctly indicates, that hoteliers must conceive their relationship with these agencies as a strategic alliance that helps to sell their product as much in the good times as they do in the bad, and especially, in those markets which the hotelier will find difficult to access. In addition, and as Ding13 says, the benefits of the direct channel are not only confined to the increase in revenue, since marketing without intermediaries carries with it the possibility to interact with consumers, gain brand loyalty, and build lasting competitive advantages14. To this list of benefits we would add the decrease in the level of dependency on the OTAs and the generation of new skilled jobs in the destination, because the realization of this opportunity requires specializing personnel and new professional profiles, among which might include web managers, community managers, revenue managers or directors of electronic distribution. In conclusion, we believe that all the hotels in tourist destinations would have to provide direct sales tools that function in the same way as those of the big online retailers. Having and utilizing these tools is of crucial importance for hotels in the development of both mature and emerging markets. It is clear that part of the money 9 UNWTO World Tourism Barometer (Interim Update April 2011). 10 As per the statistics collected by the Bank of Spain, the country took in 39,596,000,000 euros from tourism in 2010. 11 As estimated by DBK in “Estudios Sectores de Establecimientos Hoteleros”, 17th edition, April 2011. 12 Withiam, G.: 2011a. 13 Ding, W.: 2011. 14 In the case of China, as the cited author makes clear, some hotel chains have recently reduced their dependence on indirect channels, exemplified by the experience of Seven Days Inn, which has reached 70% of direct commercialization, while other chains based in the country only receive 8% of reservations through the OTA channel. 10
  • 11. currently paid by hotels in commissions to large foreign OTAs could be reinvested to generate economic activity in tourist destinations. On the other hand, the sales volume of some hotels is strongly linked to OTAs, which entails a high level of dependence. And finally, as we pointed before, the main focus of public Administrations is to make plans to promote tourism (advertising, public relations), but we think that this work should be accompanied by internal work in the destination itself, consisting of endowing it with direct sales tools, so the value chain could be conveniently closed 15. References Anderson, C. (2011) Search, OTAs and Online Booking: An Expanded Analysis of the Billboard Effect, Cornell Hospitality Report, 11(8). Chan, A. and Law, R. (2006) Hotel Website Optimization: The Case of Hong Kong, Information and Communication Technologies in Tourism, 2006:60-73. Ding, Wei (2011) Challenges and Opportunities of Hotel Online Booking in China, Design, User Experience, and Usability. Theory, Methods, Tools and Practice, Vol. 6670/2011:3-12. Flores Alberto, D., Salazar Niebla, L., and Santana Turégano, M.A. (2011) ¿Desaparecerán los Tour Operadores? El papel de los intermediarios en la distribución turística: Análisis del caso de Tenerife, Pasos: Revista de Turismo y Patrimonio Cultural, 9(2): 341-351. Lim, S., Zegarra Saldaña, A., and Zegarra Saldaña, P.E. (2011) Do market oriented firms adopt Web 2.0 technologies? An empirical study in hospitality firms, International Entrepreneurship and Management Journal, 7(4): 465-477. Morosan, C. and Jeong, M. (2006) Understanding Travellers’ Adoption of Hotel Reservation Web Sites, Information and Communication Technologies in Tourism, 2006:394-405. Prasad, V.K., Ramamurthy, K., and Naidu, G.M. (2001) The influence of Internet-marketing integration on marketing competencies and export performance, Journal of International Marketing, 9(4):82-110. Rheem, C. and Salgado Criado, J. (2011) lookinside.travel: Estudio Sobre el Viajero Español. Edición 2010, PhoCusWright. 15 Some of them, as the Government of Andalucía, in Spain, are implementing tools to allow reservations in small hotels that do not use the Internet channels (Economía Digital, February, 12, 2012). 11
  • 12. Ruiz-Molina, M.E., Gil-Saura, I., and Moliner-Velázquez, B. (2010) Does technology make a difference? Evidence from Spanish hotels, Service Business, 5(1):1-12. Schegg, R., Steiner, T., Gherissi-Labben, T., and Murphy, J. (2005) Using Log File Analysis and Website Assessment to Improve Hospitality Websites, Information and Communication Technologies in Tourism, 2005:566- 576. Schegg, R., Steiner, T., Gherissi-Labben, T., and Murphy, J. (2005) Using Log file Analysis and Website Assessment to Improve Hospitality Websites, Information and Communication Technologies in Tourism, 2005:566- 576. Varini, K. and Murph, H. (2006) An Investigation of Expert Predictions of Profit Optimisation Opportunities from Information Communication Technologies (ICTs) in the Hotel Sector, Information and Communication Technologies in Tourism, 2006:463-474. Withiam, G. (2011a) Brave New World: Online Hotel Distribution, Cornell Hospitality Research Summit Proceedings, 3(3). Withiam, G. (2011b) Social Media and the Hospitality Industry: Holding the Tiger by the Tail, Cornell Hospitality Research Summit Proceedings, 3(3). 12