SlideShare une entreprise Scribd logo
1  sur  18
Thoughts on the Internet's Founding Myths
Whenever I put forth on the Internet's numerous 
newsgroups, discussion fora and Websites a 
controversial view, an iconoclastic opinion, or a much-disputed 
thesis, the winning argument against my 
propositions starts with "everyone knows that ...". For a 
self-styled nonconformist medium, the Internet is the 
reification of herd mentality.
Actually, it is founded on the rather explicit belief in the 
implicit wisdom of the masses. This particularly 
pernicious strong version of egalitarianism postulates 
that veracity, accuracy, and truth are emergent 
phenomena, the inevitable and, therefore, guaranteed 
outcome of multiple interactions between users.
But the population of Internet users is not comprised of 
representative samples of experts in every discipline. 
Quite the contrary. The barriers to entry are so low that 
the Internet attracts those less gifted intellectually. It is a 
filter that lets in the stupid, the mentally ill, the 
charlatan and scammer, the very young, the bored, and 
the unqualified. It is far easier to publish a blog, for 
instance, than to write for the New York Times. Putting 
up a Website with all manner of spurious claims for 
knowledge or experience is easy compared to the peer 
review process that vets and culls scientific papers.
One can ever "contribute" to an online "encyclopedia", 
the Wikipedia, without the slightest acquaintance the 
topic one is "editing". Consequently, the other day, I 
discovered, to my utter shock, that Eichmann changed 
his name, posthumously, to Otto. It used to be Karl 
Adolf, at least until he was executed in 1962.
Granted, there are on the Internet isolated islands of 
academic merit, intellectually challenging and 
invigorating discourse, and true erudition or even 
scholarship. But they are mere islets in the tsunami of 
falsities, fatuity, and inanities that constitutes the bulk 
of User Generated Content (UGC).
Which leads me to the second myth: that access is 
progress.
Oceans of information are today at the fingertips of one 
and sundry. This is undisputed. The Internet is a vast 
storehouse of texts, images, audio recordings, and 
databases. But what matters is whether people make 
good use of this serendipitous cornucopia. A savage who 
finds himself amidst the collections of the Library of 
Congress is unlikely to benefit much.
Alas, most people today are cultural savages, Internet 
users the more so. They are lost among the dazzling 
riches that surround them. Rather than admit to their 
inferiority and accept their need to learn and improve, 
they claim "equal status". It is a form of rampant 
pathological narcissism, a defense mechanism that is 
aimed to fend off the injury of admitting to one's 
inadequacies and limitations.
Internet users have developed an ethos of anti-elitism. 
There are no experts, only opinions, There are no hard 
data, only poll results. Everyone is equally suited to 
contribute to any subject. Learning and scholarship are 
frowned on or even actively discouraged. The public's 
taste has completely substituted for good taste. 
Yardsticks, classics, science - have all been discarded.
Study after study have demonstrated clearly the decline 
of functional literacy (the ability to read and understand 
labels, simple instructions, and very basic texts) even as 
literacy (in other words, repeated exposure to the 
alphabet) has increased dramatically all over the world.
In other words: most people know how to read but 
precious few understand what they are reading. Yet, 
even the most illiterate, bolstered by the Internet's mob-rule, 
insist that their interpretation of the texts they do 
not comprehend is as potent and valid as anyone else's.
When I was growing up in a slum in Israel, I devoutly 
believed that knowledge and education will set me free 
and catapult me from my miserable circumstances into a 
glamorous world of happy learning. But now, as an 
adult, I find myself in an alien universe where "culture" 
means merely sports and music, where science is 
decried as evil and feared by increasingly hostile and 
aggressive masses, and where irrationality in all its 
forms (religiosity, the occult, conspiracy theories) 
flourishes.
The few real scholars and intellectuals left are on the 
retreat, back into the ivory towers of a century ago. 
Increasingly, their place is taken by self-taught 
"experts", narcissistic bloggers, wannabe "authors" and 
"auteurs", and partisan promoters of (often self-beneficial) 
"causes".
Dismal results ensue: fads like environmentalism and 
alternative "medicine" spread malignantly and seek to 
silence dissidents, sometimes by violent means; the fare 
served by the media now consists exclusively of soap 
operas and reality TV shows; Reading is on terminal 
decline; with few exceptions, the "new media" are a 
hodgepodge of sectarian view and fabricated "news"; 
the few credible sources of reliable information have 
long been drowned in a cacophony of fakes and phonies.
It is a sad mockery of the idea of progress. The more 
texts we make available online, the more research is 
published, the more books are written - the less 
educated people are, the more they rely on visuals and 
sounds rather than the written word, the more they 
seek to escape reality and be anesthetized rather than 
be challenged and provoked.
Even the ever-sliming minority who do wish to be 
enlightened are inundated by a suffocating and 
unmanageable avalanche of indiscriminate data, 
comprised of both real and pseudo-science. There is no 
way to tell the two apart, so a "democracy of 
knowledge" reins where everyone is equally qualified 
and everything goes and is equally merited. This 
relativism is dooming the twenty-first century to 
become the beginning of a new "Dark Age", hopefully a 
mere interregnum between two periods of genuine 
enlightenment.
http://easyinternetbusinesssystem.com/form.php?id=6 
32705

Contenu connexe

Tendances

How media and social scientists present migration
How media and social scientists present migrationHow media and social scientists present migration
How media and social scientists present migrationMyna German Schleifer
 
Olivia Porter: Digital Research Presentation
Olivia Porter: Digital Research PresentationOlivia Porter: Digital Research Presentation
Olivia Porter: Digital Research Presentationoliviaprter
 
Sex, Violence, and "Hail Mary": Censorship in the Public Library
Sex, Violence, and "Hail Mary": Censorship in the Public LibrarySex, Violence, and "Hail Mary": Censorship in the Public Library
Sex, Violence, and "Hail Mary": Censorship in the Public LibraryAhniwa Ferrari
 
Next Library Conference, Aarhus 16 06 2009
Next  Library  Conference,  Aarhus 16 06 2009Next  Library  Conference,  Aarhus 16 06 2009
Next Library Conference, Aarhus 16 06 2009Chris Batt
 
The connecting machine. Librarians' mission after the Fourth revolution
The connecting machine. Librarians' mission after the Fourth revolutionThe connecting machine. Librarians' mission after the Fourth revolution
The connecting machine. Librarians' mission after the Fourth revolutionMatilde Fontanin
 
Propaganda with a mission (for ASREC Conference)
Propaganda with a mission (for ASREC Conference)Propaganda with a mission (for ASREC Conference)
Propaganda with a mission (for ASREC Conference)Bex Lewis
 
Social media history
Social media historySocial media history
Social media historyAdrian Holzer
 
Public Sociology in the Digital Era
Public Sociology in the Digital EraPublic Sociology in the Digital Era
Public Sociology in the Digital EraJessie Daniels
 
Doing the Digital: How Scholars Learned to Stop Worrying and Love the Computer
Doing the Digital: How Scholars Learned to Stop Worrying and Love the ComputerDoing the Digital: How Scholars Learned to Stop Worrying and Love the Computer
Doing the Digital: How Scholars Learned to Stop Worrying and Love the ComputerAndrew Prescott
 
Beyond the Academy—engagement, education, and exchange
Beyond the Academy—engagement, education, and exchangeBeyond the Academy—engagement, education, and exchange
Beyond the Academy—engagement, education, and exchangePip Willcox
 
Scientix 6th SPNE Brussels 8 May 2015: Youth projects Brussels Science Commun...
Scientix 6th SPNE Brussels 8 May 2015: Youth projects Brussels Science Commun...Scientix 6th SPNE Brussels 8 May 2015: Youth projects Brussels Science Commun...
Scientix 6th SPNE Brussels 8 May 2015: Youth projects Brussels Science Commun...Brussels, Belgium
 
Gbv Zpix Wosc08 Moral Aesthetic & Praxeological Symviability
Gbv Zpix Wosc08 Moral Aesthetic & Praxeological SymviabilityGbv Zpix Wosc08 Moral Aesthetic & Praxeological Symviability
Gbv Zpix Wosc08 Moral Aesthetic & Praxeological SymviabilityGary Boyd
 
Understanding Fake News: history, origins, solutions
Understanding Fake News: history, origins, solutionsUnderstanding Fake News: history, origins, solutions
Understanding Fake News: history, origins, solutionsDamian Radcliffe
 

Tendances (17)

How media and social scientists present migration
How media and social scientists present migrationHow media and social scientists present migration
How media and social scientists present migration
 
Olivia Porter: Digital Research Presentation
Olivia Porter: Digital Research PresentationOlivia Porter: Digital Research Presentation
Olivia Porter: Digital Research Presentation
 
Sex, Violence, and "Hail Mary": Censorship in the Public Library
Sex, Violence, and "Hail Mary": Censorship in the Public LibrarySex, Violence, and "Hail Mary": Censorship in the Public Library
Sex, Violence, and "Hail Mary": Censorship in the Public Library
 
Chris Batt
Chris BattChris Batt
Chris Batt
 
Next Library Conference, Aarhus 16 06 2009
Next  Library  Conference,  Aarhus 16 06 2009Next  Library  Conference,  Aarhus 16 06 2009
Next Library Conference, Aarhus 16 06 2009
 
6 thinking hats
6 thinking hats6 thinking hats
6 thinking hats
 
The connecting machine. Librarians' mission after the Fourth revolution
The connecting machine. Librarians' mission after the Fourth revolutionThe connecting machine. Librarians' mission after the Fourth revolution
The connecting machine. Librarians' mission after the Fourth revolution
 
Propaganda with a mission (for ASREC Conference)
Propaganda with a mission (for ASREC Conference)Propaganda with a mission (for ASREC Conference)
Propaganda with a mission (for ASREC Conference)
 
Social media history
Social media historySocial media history
Social media history
 
Social Media "101"
Social Media "101"Social Media "101"
Social Media "101"
 
The next memes of the press
The next memes of the pressThe next memes of the press
The next memes of the press
 
Public Sociology in the Digital Era
Public Sociology in the Digital EraPublic Sociology in the Digital Era
Public Sociology in the Digital Era
 
Doing the Digital: How Scholars Learned to Stop Worrying and Love the Computer
Doing the Digital: How Scholars Learned to Stop Worrying and Love the ComputerDoing the Digital: How Scholars Learned to Stop Worrying and Love the Computer
Doing the Digital: How Scholars Learned to Stop Worrying and Love the Computer
 
Beyond the Academy—engagement, education, and exchange
Beyond the Academy—engagement, education, and exchangeBeyond the Academy—engagement, education, and exchange
Beyond the Academy—engagement, education, and exchange
 
Scientix 6th SPNE Brussels 8 May 2015: Youth projects Brussels Science Commun...
Scientix 6th SPNE Brussels 8 May 2015: Youth projects Brussels Science Commun...Scientix 6th SPNE Brussels 8 May 2015: Youth projects Brussels Science Commun...
Scientix 6th SPNE Brussels 8 May 2015: Youth projects Brussels Science Commun...
 
Gbv Zpix Wosc08 Moral Aesthetic & Praxeological Symviability
Gbv Zpix Wosc08 Moral Aesthetic & Praxeological SymviabilityGbv Zpix Wosc08 Moral Aesthetic & Praxeological Symviability
Gbv Zpix Wosc08 Moral Aesthetic & Praxeological Symviability
 
Understanding Fake News: history, origins, solutions
Understanding Fake News: history, origins, solutionsUnderstanding Fake News: history, origins, solutions
Understanding Fake News: history, origins, solutions
 

En vedette

Video production supply, lighting rental, generators, grip equipment and film...
Video production supply, lighting rental, generators, grip equipment and film...Video production supply, lighting rental, generators, grip equipment and film...
Video production supply, lighting rental, generators, grip equipment and film...vidyasagar555
 
What color is it
What color is itWhat color is it
What color is itJose Agurto
 
Inovasi pendidikan kurikulum 2013
Inovasi pendidikan kurikulum 2013Inovasi pendidikan kurikulum 2013
Inovasi pendidikan kurikulum 2013ahmad almandili
 
Travaux dirigés de biochimie, biologie moléculaire et bioinformatique
Travaux dirigés de biochimie, biologie moléculaire et bioinformatiqueTravaux dirigés de biochimie, biologie moléculaire et bioinformatique
Travaux dirigés de biochimie, biologie moléculaire et bioinformatiqueabdesselam2015
 
Inovasi pendidikan. inovasi kurikulum kbk, ktsp, kbm
Inovasi pendidikan. inovasi kurikulum kbk, ktsp, kbmInovasi pendidikan. inovasi kurikulum kbk, ktsp, kbm
Inovasi pendidikan. inovasi kurikulum kbk, ktsp, kbmahmad almandili
 
Chris dixon cv met nl overzicht
Chris dixon cv met nl overzichtChris dixon cv met nl overzicht
Chris dixon cv met nl overzichtChris Dixon
 
Eddy de avevedo hsgajdh
Eddy de avevedo hsgajdhEddy de avevedo hsgajdh
Eddy de avevedo hsgajdhjessellie
 
Trash Hauling Tyler TX
Trash Hauling Tyler TXTrash Hauling Tyler TX
Trash Hauling Tyler TXvidyasagar555
 
Execution plans for mere mortals
Execution plans for mere mortalsExecution plans for mere mortals
Execution plans for mere mortalsMike Lawell
 

En vedette (14)

Question 4
Question 4Question 4
Question 4
 
Video production supply, lighting rental, generators, grip equipment and film...
Video production supply, lighting rental, generators, grip equipment and film...Video production supply, lighting rental, generators, grip equipment and film...
Video production supply, lighting rental, generators, grip equipment and film...
 
What color is it
What color is itWhat color is it
What color is it
 
Død over indbakken
Død over indbakkenDød over indbakken
Død over indbakken
 
Doc1
Doc1Doc1
Doc1
 
Infectologie
InfectologieInfectologie
Infectologie
 
Inovasi pendidikan kurikulum 2013
Inovasi pendidikan kurikulum 2013Inovasi pendidikan kurikulum 2013
Inovasi pendidikan kurikulum 2013
 
Travaux dirigés de biochimie, biologie moléculaire et bioinformatique
Travaux dirigés de biochimie, biologie moléculaire et bioinformatiqueTravaux dirigés de biochimie, biologie moléculaire et bioinformatique
Travaux dirigés de biochimie, biologie moléculaire et bioinformatique
 
Images used
Images usedImages used
Images used
 
Inovasi pendidikan. inovasi kurikulum kbk, ktsp, kbm
Inovasi pendidikan. inovasi kurikulum kbk, ktsp, kbmInovasi pendidikan. inovasi kurikulum kbk, ktsp, kbm
Inovasi pendidikan. inovasi kurikulum kbk, ktsp, kbm
 
Chris dixon cv met nl overzicht
Chris dixon cv met nl overzichtChris dixon cv met nl overzicht
Chris dixon cv met nl overzicht
 
Eddy de avevedo hsgajdh
Eddy de avevedo hsgajdhEddy de avevedo hsgajdh
Eddy de avevedo hsgajdh
 
Trash Hauling Tyler TX
Trash Hauling Tyler TXTrash Hauling Tyler TX
Trash Hauling Tyler TX
 
Execution plans for mere mortals
Execution plans for mere mortalsExecution plans for mere mortals
Execution plans for mere mortals
 

Similaire à Thoughts on the Internet's Founding Myths

Stranger Than Fiction 9-11 and Zionism
Stranger Than Fiction 9-11 and ZionismStranger Than Fiction 9-11 and Zionism
Stranger Than Fiction 9-11 and ZionismHear O World
 
IntroductionOne of my family’s legends (unverified) was th.docx
IntroductionOne of my family’s legends (unverified) was th.docxIntroductionOne of my family’s legends (unverified) was th.docx
IntroductionOne of my family’s legends (unverified) was th.docxnormanibarber20063
 
IntroductionOne of my family’s legends (unverified) was th.docx
IntroductionOne of my family’s legends (unverified) was th.docxIntroductionOne of my family’s legends (unverified) was th.docx
IntroductionOne of my family’s legends (unverified) was th.docxmariuse18nolet
 
Anti-Evolutionist History
Anti-Evolutionist HistoryAnti-Evolutionist History
Anti-Evolutionist HistoryJohn Lynch
 
Mitchell StephensThinking Through Moving Mediasocial r.docx
Mitchell StephensThinking Through Moving Mediasocial r.docxMitchell StephensThinking Through Moving Mediasocial r.docx
Mitchell StephensThinking Through Moving Mediasocial r.docxraju957290
 
Jon Spayde Learning in the key of lifeWhat does it mean—and mor.docx
Jon Spayde Learning in the key of lifeWhat does it mean—and mor.docxJon Spayde Learning in the key of lifeWhat does it mean—and mor.docx
Jon Spayde Learning in the key of lifeWhat does it mean—and mor.docxpriestmanmable
 
EDUSs Acquisition of MCUThe Situation The CEO of EducUS .docx
EDUSs Acquisition of MCUThe Situation The CEO of EducUS .docxEDUSs Acquisition of MCUThe Situation The CEO of EducUS .docx
EDUSs Acquisition of MCUThe Situation The CEO of EducUS .docxtoltonkendal
 
Spayde, Jon. Learning in the Key of Life.” The Presence of Ot.docx
Spayde, Jon. Learning in the Key of Life.” The Presence of Ot.docxSpayde, Jon. Learning in the Key of Life.” The Presence of Ot.docx
Spayde, Jon. Learning in the Key of Life.” The Presence of Ot.docxwhitneyleman54422
 
General Education courses A gymnasium of the mindKnowledge.docx
General Education courses A gymnasium of the mindKnowledge.docxGeneral Education courses A gymnasium of the mindKnowledge.docx
General Education courses A gymnasium of the mindKnowledge.docxbudbarber38650
 
Positive side-effects of misinformation
Positive side-effects of misinformationPositive side-effects of misinformation
Positive side-effects of misinformationJim Lippard
 
cancel culture in racial & queer communities of black
  cancel culture in racial & queer  communities of black  cancel culture in racial & queer  communities of black
cancel culture in racial & queer communities of blackTamsaPandya
 
21 lessons for the 21st century yuval noah harari
21 lessons for the 21st century   yuval noah harari21 lessons for the 21st century   yuval noah harari
21 lessons for the 21st century yuval noah harariMintesnotTesfaye4
 
Deaf Culture Essay.pdf
Deaf Culture Essay.pdfDeaf Culture Essay.pdf
Deaf Culture Essay.pdfMichelle Green
 

Similaire à Thoughts on the Internet's Founding Myths (15)

Stranger Than Fiction 9-11 and Zionism
Stranger Than Fiction 9-11 and ZionismStranger Than Fiction 9-11 and Zionism
Stranger Than Fiction 9-11 and Zionism
 
IntroductionOne of my family’s legends (unverified) was th.docx
IntroductionOne of my family’s legends (unverified) was th.docxIntroductionOne of my family’s legends (unverified) was th.docx
IntroductionOne of my family’s legends (unverified) was th.docx
 
IntroductionOne of my family’s legends (unverified) was th.docx
IntroductionOne of my family’s legends (unverified) was th.docxIntroductionOne of my family’s legends (unverified) was th.docx
IntroductionOne of my family’s legends (unverified) was th.docx
 
Anti-Evolutionist History
Anti-Evolutionist HistoryAnti-Evolutionist History
Anti-Evolutionist History
 
Mitchell StephensThinking Through Moving Mediasocial r.docx
Mitchell StephensThinking Through Moving Mediasocial r.docxMitchell StephensThinking Through Moving Mediasocial r.docx
Mitchell StephensThinking Through Moving Mediasocial r.docx
 
Jon Spayde Learning in the key of lifeWhat does it mean—and mor.docx
Jon Spayde Learning in the key of lifeWhat does it mean—and mor.docxJon Spayde Learning in the key of lifeWhat does it mean—and mor.docx
Jon Spayde Learning in the key of lifeWhat does it mean—and mor.docx
 
EDUSs Acquisition of MCUThe Situation The CEO of EducUS .docx
EDUSs Acquisition of MCUThe Situation The CEO of EducUS .docxEDUSs Acquisition of MCUThe Situation The CEO of EducUS .docx
EDUSs Acquisition of MCUThe Situation The CEO of EducUS .docx
 
Spayde, Jon. Learning in the Key of Life.” The Presence of Ot.docx
Spayde, Jon. Learning in the Key of Life.” The Presence of Ot.docxSpayde, Jon. Learning in the Key of Life.” The Presence of Ot.docx
Spayde, Jon. Learning in the Key of Life.” The Presence of Ot.docx
 
Stanford march 23
Stanford march 23Stanford march 23
Stanford march 23
 
General Education courses A gymnasium of the mindKnowledge.docx
General Education courses A gymnasium of the mindKnowledge.docxGeneral Education courses A gymnasium of the mindKnowledge.docx
General Education courses A gymnasium of the mindKnowledge.docx
 
Positive side-effects of misinformation
Positive side-effects of misinformationPositive side-effects of misinformation
Positive side-effects of misinformation
 
cancel culture in racial & queer communities of black
  cancel culture in racial & queer  communities of black  cancel culture in racial & queer  communities of black
cancel culture in racial & queer communities of black
 
Catholic Inquisition &: "Modernity"
Catholic Inquisition &: "Modernity"Catholic Inquisition &: "Modernity"
Catholic Inquisition &: "Modernity"
 
21 lessons for the 21st century yuval noah harari
21 lessons for the 21st century   yuval noah harari21 lessons for the 21st century   yuval noah harari
21 lessons for the 21st century yuval noah harari
 
Deaf Culture Essay.pdf
Deaf Culture Essay.pdfDeaf Culture Essay.pdf
Deaf Culture Essay.pdf
 

Plus de touchdown777a

True Reciprocal Link
True Reciprocal LinkTrue Reciprocal Link
True Reciprocal Linktouchdown777a
 
Issues You Will Confront When Using Third Parties To Build Out Sites
Issues You Will Confront When Using Third Parties To Build Out SitesIssues You Will Confront When Using Third Parties To Build Out Sites
Issues You Will Confront When Using Third Parties To Build Out Sitestouchdown777a
 
How to blog your way to success?
How to blog your way to success?How to blog your way to success?
How to blog your way to success?touchdown777a
 
Good Communication Promotes Positive Feedback On Ebay
Good Communication Promotes Positive Feedback On EbayGood Communication Promotes Positive Feedback On Ebay
Good Communication Promotes Positive Feedback On Ebaytouchdown777a
 
Advertising Site Is Helping Us Have Our Dream Child
Advertising Site Is Helping Us Have Our Dream ChildAdvertising Site Is Helping Us Have Our Dream Child
Advertising Site Is Helping Us Have Our Dream Childtouchdown777a
 
Marketing via E-mail for Search Engines
Marketing via E-mail for Search EnginesMarketing via E-mail for Search Engines
Marketing via E-mail for Search Enginestouchdown777a
 
Internet Shopping Up Again!
Internet Shopping Up Again!Internet Shopping Up Again!
Internet Shopping Up Again!touchdown777a
 
Learning how to be successful at selling on eBay
Learning how to be successful at selling on eBayLearning how to be successful at selling on eBay
Learning how to be successful at selling on eBaytouchdown777a
 
Reasons To Be Careful When Buying Goods On Ebay
Reasons To Be Careful When Buying Goods On EbayReasons To Be Careful When Buying Goods On Ebay
Reasons To Be Careful When Buying Goods On Ebaytouchdown777a
 
8 Steps To Irresistible Email Copy Every Time
8 Steps To Irresistible Email Copy Every Time8 Steps To Irresistible Email Copy Every Time
8 Steps To Irresistible Email Copy Every Timetouchdown777a
 
The Power Of Internet Marketing
The Power Of Internet MarketingThe Power Of Internet Marketing
The Power Of Internet Marketingtouchdown777a
 
Do Your Autoresponders Drive Your Customers Crazy?
Do Your Autoresponders Drive Your Customers Crazy?Do Your Autoresponders Drive Your Customers Crazy?
Do Your Autoresponders Drive Your Customers Crazy?touchdown777a
 
Essentials of Search Engine Optimisation Campaign
Essentials of Search Engine Optimisation CampaignEssentials of Search Engine Optimisation Campaign
Essentials of Search Engine Optimisation Campaigntouchdown777a
 
Create Bonus Reports
Create Bonus ReportsCreate Bonus Reports
Create Bonus Reportstouchdown777a
 

Plus de touchdown777a (17)

True Reciprocal Link
True Reciprocal LinkTrue Reciprocal Link
True Reciprocal Link
 
Issues You Will Confront When Using Third Parties To Build Out Sites
Issues You Will Confront When Using Third Parties To Build Out SitesIssues You Will Confront When Using Third Parties To Build Out Sites
Issues You Will Confront When Using Third Parties To Build Out Sites
 
What is WebSense?
What is WebSense?What is WebSense?
What is WebSense?
 
How to blog your way to success?
How to blog your way to success?How to blog your way to success?
How to blog your way to success?
 
Good Communication Promotes Positive Feedback On Ebay
Good Communication Promotes Positive Feedback On EbayGood Communication Promotes Positive Feedback On Ebay
Good Communication Promotes Positive Feedback On Ebay
 
Advertising Site Is Helping Us Have Our Dream Child
Advertising Site Is Helping Us Have Our Dream ChildAdvertising Site Is Helping Us Have Our Dream Child
Advertising Site Is Helping Us Have Our Dream Child
 
Marketing via E-mail for Search Engines
Marketing via E-mail for Search EnginesMarketing via E-mail for Search Engines
Marketing via E-mail for Search Engines
 
Internet Shopping Up Again!
Internet Shopping Up Again!Internet Shopping Up Again!
Internet Shopping Up Again!
 
Niche Jerk
Niche JerkNiche Jerk
Niche Jerk
 
Learning how to be successful at selling on eBay
Learning how to be successful at selling on eBayLearning how to be successful at selling on eBay
Learning how to be successful at selling on eBay
 
Reasons To Be Careful When Buying Goods On Ebay
Reasons To Be Careful When Buying Goods On EbayReasons To Be Careful When Buying Goods On Ebay
Reasons To Be Careful When Buying Goods On Ebay
 
8 Steps To Irresistible Email Copy Every Time
8 Steps To Irresistible Email Copy Every Time8 Steps To Irresistible Email Copy Every Time
8 Steps To Irresistible Email Copy Every Time
 
The Power Of Internet Marketing
The Power Of Internet MarketingThe Power Of Internet Marketing
The Power Of Internet Marketing
 
Do Your Autoresponders Drive Your Customers Crazy?
Do Your Autoresponders Drive Your Customers Crazy?Do Your Autoresponders Drive Your Customers Crazy?
Do Your Autoresponders Drive Your Customers Crazy?
 
Essentials of Search Engine Optimisation Campaign
Essentials of Search Engine Optimisation CampaignEssentials of Search Engine Optimisation Campaign
Essentials of Search Engine Optimisation Campaign
 
mhj
mhjmhj
mhj
 
Create Bonus Reports
Create Bonus ReportsCreate Bonus Reports
Create Bonus Reports
 

Thoughts on the Internet's Founding Myths

  • 1. Thoughts on the Internet's Founding Myths
  • 2. Whenever I put forth on the Internet's numerous newsgroups, discussion fora and Websites a controversial view, an iconoclastic opinion, or a much-disputed thesis, the winning argument against my propositions starts with "everyone knows that ...". For a self-styled nonconformist medium, the Internet is the reification of herd mentality.
  • 3. Actually, it is founded on the rather explicit belief in the implicit wisdom of the masses. This particularly pernicious strong version of egalitarianism postulates that veracity, accuracy, and truth are emergent phenomena, the inevitable and, therefore, guaranteed outcome of multiple interactions between users.
  • 4. But the population of Internet users is not comprised of representative samples of experts in every discipline. Quite the contrary. The barriers to entry are so low that the Internet attracts those less gifted intellectually. It is a filter that lets in the stupid, the mentally ill, the charlatan and scammer, the very young, the bored, and the unqualified. It is far easier to publish a blog, for instance, than to write for the New York Times. Putting up a Website with all manner of spurious claims for knowledge or experience is easy compared to the peer review process that vets and culls scientific papers.
  • 5. One can ever "contribute" to an online "encyclopedia", the Wikipedia, without the slightest acquaintance the topic one is "editing". Consequently, the other day, I discovered, to my utter shock, that Eichmann changed his name, posthumously, to Otto. It used to be Karl Adolf, at least until he was executed in 1962.
  • 6. Granted, there are on the Internet isolated islands of academic merit, intellectually challenging and invigorating discourse, and true erudition or even scholarship. But they are mere islets in the tsunami of falsities, fatuity, and inanities that constitutes the bulk of User Generated Content (UGC).
  • 7. Which leads me to the second myth: that access is progress.
  • 8. Oceans of information are today at the fingertips of one and sundry. This is undisputed. The Internet is a vast storehouse of texts, images, audio recordings, and databases. But what matters is whether people make good use of this serendipitous cornucopia. A savage who finds himself amidst the collections of the Library of Congress is unlikely to benefit much.
  • 9. Alas, most people today are cultural savages, Internet users the more so. They are lost among the dazzling riches that surround them. Rather than admit to their inferiority and accept their need to learn and improve, they claim "equal status". It is a form of rampant pathological narcissism, a defense mechanism that is aimed to fend off the injury of admitting to one's inadequacies and limitations.
  • 10. Internet users have developed an ethos of anti-elitism. There are no experts, only opinions, There are no hard data, only poll results. Everyone is equally suited to contribute to any subject. Learning and scholarship are frowned on or even actively discouraged. The public's taste has completely substituted for good taste. Yardsticks, classics, science - have all been discarded.
  • 11. Study after study have demonstrated clearly the decline of functional literacy (the ability to read and understand labels, simple instructions, and very basic texts) even as literacy (in other words, repeated exposure to the alphabet) has increased dramatically all over the world.
  • 12. In other words: most people know how to read but precious few understand what they are reading. Yet, even the most illiterate, bolstered by the Internet's mob-rule, insist that their interpretation of the texts they do not comprehend is as potent and valid as anyone else's.
  • 13. When I was growing up in a slum in Israel, I devoutly believed that knowledge and education will set me free and catapult me from my miserable circumstances into a glamorous world of happy learning. But now, as an adult, I find myself in an alien universe where "culture" means merely sports and music, where science is decried as evil and feared by increasingly hostile and aggressive masses, and where irrationality in all its forms (religiosity, the occult, conspiracy theories) flourishes.
  • 14. The few real scholars and intellectuals left are on the retreat, back into the ivory towers of a century ago. Increasingly, their place is taken by self-taught "experts", narcissistic bloggers, wannabe "authors" and "auteurs", and partisan promoters of (often self-beneficial) "causes".
  • 15. Dismal results ensue: fads like environmentalism and alternative "medicine" spread malignantly and seek to silence dissidents, sometimes by violent means; the fare served by the media now consists exclusively of soap operas and reality TV shows; Reading is on terminal decline; with few exceptions, the "new media" are a hodgepodge of sectarian view and fabricated "news"; the few credible sources of reliable information have long been drowned in a cacophony of fakes and phonies.
  • 16. It is a sad mockery of the idea of progress. The more texts we make available online, the more research is published, the more books are written - the less educated people are, the more they rely on visuals and sounds rather than the written word, the more they seek to escape reality and be anesthetized rather than be challenged and provoked.
  • 17. Even the ever-sliming minority who do wish to be enlightened are inundated by a suffocating and unmanageable avalanche of indiscriminate data, comprised of both real and pseudo-science. There is no way to tell the two apart, so a "democracy of knowledge" reins where everyone is equally qualified and everything goes and is equally merited. This relativism is dooming the twenty-first century to become the beginning of a new "Dark Age", hopefully a mere interregnum between two periods of genuine enlightenment.