Being Transparent with the Consumer: The Language of Trust - Kim Essex, Senior Vice President, Director, North American Food Practice, Ketchum, from the 2014 Global Roundtable for Sustainable Beef (GRSB), November 2 -5, 2014, São Paulo, Brazil.
More presentations at http://trufflemedia.com/agmedia/conference/2014-global-roundtable-sustainable-beef
6. 66
The Fundamental Concern
Consumers are most
concerned about
long-term health
• Cancer
• Obesity
• Diabetes
• Heart Health
Anything not
deemed “natural” is
a threat
• Antibiotics
• Hormones
• Factory farms
• Feedyards
• Pesticides
• Fertilizers
• Herbicides
• Biotech
• Chemicals
• Packaged Food
Ingredients
• Preservatives
Science/logic doesn’t
help: “if we put it in our
bodies, we don’t want
anything that messes with
nature”
• Amount is miniscule
• Research shows it is safe
• Lets us feed the world
• Gives people choices
• Keeps prices low
• Better for the environment
8. 88
“In short, meat — especially beef —
has become the stuff of fierce debate....
Meat is murder. Meat—especially beef—
is cigarettes and a Hummer rolled into
one. For the sake of the animals, our own
health, and the health of the planet, we
must eat less of it.
Meat is delicious. Meat is nutritious. Global demand is
soaring for good reason, and we must find a way to
produce more of it.
Here’s the inconvenient truth: Feedlots, with
their troubling use of pharmaceuticals, save land
and lower greenhouse gas emissions.”
18. • Buying more fresh, less
packaged and prepared foods
• Worry about processing
19. They Are The ‘Friends And Family’
Consumers Are Paying Attention To
20. 2020
42%
43%
45%
52%
53%
58%
60%
65%
80%
38%
33%
38%
44%
61%
54%
66%
59%
80%
30%
27%
28%
39%
57%
50%
67%
49%
76%
Information about how beef is processed
The impact of beef farming on the environment
Information about how cattle are raised
Animal welfare or humane treatment of animals
Information about the different cuts
The nutritional content in beef e.g. vitamins, minerals etc.
Information about how to cook the different cuts
More "sophisticated" recipes about beef
Easy recipes about beef
Boomers Gen X Millennials
SOURCE: Millennial Generation and Beef, December 2011
They are Driving Interest in How Beef is Raised
22. Focus on What
THEY Want To
Hear
THEIR
truth
YOUR
truth
communication
that works
23. 23
Defending Actions
of the Past and
Defending Standard
Practices Demonstrating
Commitment to
Improving the
Future
Building Trust vs. Proving You’re Right
24. 2424
1. Share continuous improvement
• You will not convince your audience their opinions are wrong
• But discussing the future creates a space of shared interest
• And how the beef community is continuously improving what we do
and how we do it is a universal positive
Which would you
most like to see in
how farmers and
ranchers grow and
raise food for
tomorrow?
October 2011
25. 2525
2. Be transparent
Perceived lack of transparency breeds distrust
Not just talking about, but being more transparent is the most
powerful potential improvement
“If it’s so non-harmful, then JUST TELL US.”
“I don’t know what I’m eating. That’s a problem.”
“Organic, at least you kind of know what you’re
getting. Non-organic, you don’t know WHAT it is.”
October 2011
27. 2727
3. Demonstrate more precise use
of what makes them uncomfortable
Food eVangelists are uncomfortable with some conventional
methods—this we know
Not surprisingly, improvements that enable farmers and
ranchers to use less of the very substances that make them
uncomfortable resonate
‘Using less’ or ‘more precisely using” directly answers Food
eVangelists’ concerns and demonstrates farmers and ranchers
ARE listening
“To hear that they’re using
less shows that they’re on
the right track… they hear
how we feel. ”
October 2011
28. 28
Hormones - Farmers and ranchers have been safely using growth hormones in cattle
since the 1950s. Studies during this time frame have repeatedly shown they pose no risk
to consumers.
218
4Antibiotics v1- Antibiotics in cattle are used carefully by farmers and ranchers in
cooperation with veterinarians and used as selectively as possible to treat, control or
prevent disease.
Antibiotics v2- Over the next three years, FDA will be phasing out the use of medically
important antibiotics to promote growth in livestock, while phasing in even more
veterinary oversight for use of these medically important antibiotics for disease
treatment, control or prevention in livestock.
26
3
2
6
25
Inhumane Treatment - Feedyard cattle live in pens that allow ample room to move
around, with access to clean water, a balanced diet and veterinary care. The cattle often
stand close together in these pens because that is their natural herding instinct. 20
9
1
Cattle Diet - Cattle can get the nutrients they need from eating a wide range of plants,
including a variety of grains and grasses. While at a feedyard, for example, cattle are fed
a combination of grain and hay formulated by a professional nutritionist to ensure a well-
balanced and nutritious diet.
23
9
GMO - Crops from biotechnology seeds are studied extensively to make sure they are
safe for people, animals and the environment before they reach the farm or ranch.
7
22
2
Does Info Make You More Comfortable?
Stimulus Specific to Concerns
29. 29
Hormones - Farmers and ranchers have been
safely using growth hormones in cattle since the
1950s. Studies during this time frame have
repeatedly shown they pose no risk to consumers.
6
25
GMO - Crops from biotechnology seeds are
studied extensively to make sure they are
safe for people, animals and the environment
before they reach the farm or ranch.
Does This Make You
More Comfortable?
Stimuli Specific to Concerns
7
22
2
NO
NO
30. 3030
4. Show continuous education
Language about education tested extremely well
But Food eVangelists wanted to hear if what these farmers and
ranchers are learning actually aligns with what they want to see
They want to understand how education is being brought back to
the farm
“Are they teaching them more
about how to keep animals
comfortable and healthy?”
October 2011
31. 3131
5. Champion more research
The call for more research acknowledges agriculture is aware of
concerns and is working to address them, even when there aren’t
compelling examples of how they’re improving right now
That said, the idea isn’t enough
You must communicate concrete examples of WHAT’S being
researched
“This would be perfect if it’s
actually the attitude of these
big food and farm companies.”
October 2011
http://www.nationalgeographic.com/foodfeatures/meat/
Carnivore’s Dilemma Robert Kunzig
Because Shift Happened
The underlying premise of Food 2020: Consumer as CEO is that our world is in the midst of a total and permanent power shift in the marketplace. Our wired world has shifted power most definitely – and possibly permanently – to the people.
It’s not surprising. Information is power and power rests in the hands of those who curate and share information. In this new socially connected world, corporations and brands create only a fraction of the information being shared about food and agriculture today. Yet, corporations insist on trying to control information flow, access and message.
We are also seeing that there is a symbiotic relationship between Food Involved and Food e-Vangelists.
The Food Involved are followers of Food e-Vangelists, the ‘friends and family’ that the former turn to for endorsements, recommendations and opinions.
Conversely, Food e-Vangelists believe it’s their responsibility to know and share with others, drive awareness and change behavior.
Most interest in beef production among generations
Access to information drives purchase. Food e-Vangelists are willing to pay more and are more likely to purchase items that give them or point them towards information about how food was grown/raised. Conversely, lack of information makes them think the industry is hiding something.
While the Food e-Vangelist group does not represent a major percentage of the population from a marketer standpoint, the group can influence others who normally put price first to look beyond price toward brands that prioritize values of health, safety and quality.
In this year’s Food 2020 research, we went deeper to explore how marketers and communicators can bridge the gap and reach this important but elusive audience. The research indicated that corporations and companies are creating distance, diminishing credibility because their communication is all about THEM.
All successful communication starts with your audience. All communications must start with the audience’s emotions, context and perceptions to earn trust and gain permission to share facts about their organization and offerings. There is a time for selling and a time for telling; the two must remain separated!
Kim
AND AFTER LISTENING AND ACKNOWLEDGING
SHARE A STORY ABOUT WHAT YOU DO. NOT SOME BIG MACRO … THE INDUSTRY DOES THIS. OR DID YOU KNOW THERE ARE 50x MORE HORMONES IN BIRTH CONTROL PILLS THAN IN A SOYBEAN?
RATHER … WHAT YOU DO … AND WHAT YOU HAVE DONE OR WILL DO ON YOUR FARM OR RANCH TO IMPROVE HOW YOU GROW FOOD.
Jen
Jen
Jen
Jen
We learned the recipe for food companies to be heard requires less information, messaging and spin and more listening, sharing, conversation, access and engagement.
For companies, being heard will require becoming a listener first and a talker second. Relationships should be built through daily conversations and actions should demonstrate a desire to help others make a valuable change in their communities or broader world. It is beyond selling a product. It is engaging consumers in experiences that allow them to discover your business, your brand, your behaviors and your attributes.