SlideShare une entreprise Scribd logo
1  sur  16
Télécharger pour lire hors ligne
The 2013 Resource Governance Index
A measure of transparency and accountability in
the oil, gas and mining sector
New York, UNDP, May 16, 2013
http://www.revenuewatch.org/rgi
What’s at stake?
• Oil, gas and mining sector governance as a development
challenge
– In resource rich countries, over 1 billion people live on
less than $5 a day, and 640 million live on $2 a day or
less.
– In 2011, Nigeria’s oil revenues alone were 60 percent
higher than international aid to all of sub-Saharan
Africa.
– In 1980-2006: Oil-rich states 3 times less likely to
democratize than non-oil producers.
• Governance is the challenge, but also the solution.
• The RGI aims to help advance this effort.
2
Why is a measure of resource governance needed?
• Raise awareness about a major development
challenge
• Concretize what may be seen as a vague challenge
• Enable empirical research and analysis
• Enable evidenced-based policymaking and advocacy
• Inform dialogue across all stakeholders
• A diagnostic tool to identify global and country
reform priorities
3
What is the Resource Governance Index?
• A measure of transparency
and accountability of the
oil, gas and mining sector in
58 countries.
• For each country,
researchers, gathered
primary information in 2012
to answer a standard
questionnaire with 173
questions, vetted by a peer
reviewer.
4
How is the Index built?
Resource Governance Index composite
5
80% of countries do not meet satisfactory
governance standards
98
92
88
85
80
77 76 75 74 74 73
70
68
66
63 62 61
58 57
56 56 56
54 53 53
51 50
48
47 47 47 46 46 46 46
43 43 43 43 42 42 41 41
39 38
37
34 34 33
31 31
29 28
26
19
13
5 4
0
20
40
60
80
100
1.Norway
2.UnitedStates(GulfofMexico)
3.UnitedKingdom
4.Australia(WesternAustralia)
5.Brazil
6.Mexico
7.Canada(Alberta)
8.Chile
9.Colombia
10.TrinidadandTobago
11.Peru
12.India
13.Timor-Leste
14.Indonesia
15.Ghana
16.Liberia
17.Zambia
18.Ecuador
19.Kazakhstan
20.Venezuela
21.SouthAfrica
22.Russia
23.Philippines
24.Bolivia
25.Morocco
26.Mongolia
27.Tanzania
28.Azerbaijan
29.Iraq
30.Botswana
31.Bahrain
32.Gabon
33.Guinea
34.Malaysia
35.SierraLeone
36.China
37.Yemen
38.Egypt
39.PapuaNewGuinea
40.Nigeria
41.Angola
42.Kuwait
43.Vietnam
44.Congo(DRC)
45.Algeria
46.Mozambique
47.Cameroon
48.SaudiArabia
49.Afghanistan
50.SouthSudan
51.Zimbabwe
52.Cambodia
53.Iran
54.Qatar
55.Libya
56.EquatorialGuinea
57.Turkmenistan
58.Myanmar
Satisfactory (71-100)
Partial (51-70)
Weak (41-50)
Failing (0-40)
6
RGI Results for the 58 countries
Transparency is missing where it is needed most
8
Satisfactory performance is possible in diverse contexts
9
Concrete Illustrations of the governance deficit
• In 20 countries (e.g. Venezuela) substantial resource
revenue bypass the treasury.
• 21 countries (e.g. Guinea) do not publish information
on primary sources of revenue (royalties, profit shares
or taxes)
• In 18 countries (e.g. Alberta, Canada) government
officials do not disclose their financial interest in any
extractive activity.
• Azerbaijan, Russia and Kazakhstan have poor records in
key areas including corruption, civil and political
liberties and democratic accountability.
10
Regional performance
11
State-owned companies in 45 countries
0
20
40
60
80
100
Statoil
Pemex
Petrobras
ONGC
Rosneft
Ecopetrol
PDVSA
KazMunaiGaz
Pertamina
CODELCO
CNPC
O.C.P.
Sonangol
Petromin
ZCCM-IH
SOCAR
Petrotrin
KPC
Petroecuador
Petronas
YPFB
Sonatrach
NNPC
MinistryofOil
YOGC
PMDC
ARAMCO
Petrovietnam
SNH
QatarPetroleum
STAMICO
Debswana
NilePetroleum
EGPC
Gecamines
ENH
ZMDC
ErdenesMGL
LibyanNationalOilCorporation
NIOC
BAPCO
GEPetrol
NorthernCoalEnterprise
MOGE
Turkmengas
12
Natural resource funds in 23 countries
0
20
40
60
80
100
13
Recommendations to improve resource
transparency and accountability
• Disclose contracts signed with extractive companies.
• Ensure that regulatory agencies publish timely,
comprehensive reports on oil, gas and mining operations.
• Extend transparency and accountability standards to SOCs
and natural resource funds.
• Concerted effort to control corruption, strengthen the rule
of law and guarantee civil and political rights.
• Adopt international reporting standards for governments
and companies.
14
RGI products on http://www.revenuewatch.org/rgi
• 58 printable country pages
15
Thank you!
http://www.revenuewatch.org/rgi
http://www.revenuewatch.org/rgi/findings
http://www.revenuewatch.org/rgi/countries

Contenu connexe

En vedette

Lightning talk nurturing social innovation in uzbekistan, aziza umarova (und...
Lightning talk  nurturing social innovation in uzbekistan, aziza umarova (und...Lightning talk  nurturing social innovation in uzbekistan, aziza umarova (und...
Lightning talk nurturing social innovation in uzbekistan, aziza umarova (und...United Nations Development Programme
 
Lightning talk micro naratives and sensors for real time monitoring, borko v...
Lightning talk  micro naratives and sensors for real time monitoring, borko v...Lightning talk  micro naratives and sensors for real time monitoring, borko v...
Lightning talk micro naratives and sensors for real time monitoring, borko v...United Nations Development Programme
 
2015 Year in Review - UNDP
2015 Year in Review - UNDP2015 Year in Review - UNDP
2015 Year in Review - UNDPFGV
 
UNDP Innovation Facility Brochure
UNDP Innovation Facility BrochureUNDP Innovation Facility Brochure
UNDP Innovation Facility BrochureRomolo Tassone
 
Nesta:undp:social innovation ws08072013
Nesta:undp:social innovation ws08072013Nesta:undp:social innovation ws08072013
Nesta:undp:social innovation ws08072013Scope Group
 
Lightning talk mobile technologies from the users by the users-jasmina belco...
Lightning talk  mobile technologies from the users by the users-jasmina belco...Lightning talk  mobile technologies from the users by the users-jasmina belco...
Lightning talk mobile technologies from the users by the users-jasmina belco...United Nations Development Programme
 
Social innovation and collaborative design
Social innovation and collaborative designSocial innovation and collaborative design
Social innovation and collaborative designMaksym Klyuchar
 
UNDP Proposal of the UAE Government for an Innovation Pavilion
UNDP Proposal of the UAE Government for an Innovation PavilionUNDP Proposal of the UAE Government for an Innovation Pavilion
UNDP Proposal of the UAE Government for an Innovation PavilionRomolo Tassone
 
Innovation journey - UNDP Armenia-George Hodge
Innovation journey - UNDP Armenia-George HodgeInnovation journey - UNDP Armenia-George Hodge
Innovation journey - UNDP Armenia-George HodgeIfade Raza
 
The Why and What of Innovation: Caffin UNDP Montenegro Nov 2013
The Why and What of Innovation: Caffin UNDP Montenegro Nov 2013The Why and What of Innovation: Caffin UNDP Montenegro Nov 2013
The Why and What of Innovation: Caffin UNDP Montenegro Nov 2013Brenton Caffin
 
Social Innovation Camp Toolkit
Social Innovation Camp ToolkitSocial Innovation Camp Toolkit
Social Innovation Camp ToolkitGeorge Hodge
 
Innovative Approaches to Address Gender-Based Violence
Innovative Approaches to Address Gender-Based ViolenceInnovative Approaches to Address Gender-Based Violence
Innovative Approaches to Address Gender-Based ViolenceBenjamin Kumpf
 
Innovation at the UN Development Programme - Pecha Kucha talk at Executive Bo...
Innovation at the UN Development Programme - Pecha Kucha talk at Executive Bo...Innovation at the UN Development Programme - Pecha Kucha talk at Executive Bo...
Innovation at the UN Development Programme - Pecha Kucha talk at Executive Bo...Benjamin Kumpf
 

En vedette (17)

Lightning talk nurturing social innovation in uzbekistan, aziza umarova (und...
Lightning talk  nurturing social innovation in uzbekistan, aziza umarova (und...Lightning talk  nurturing social innovation in uzbekistan, aziza umarova (und...
Lightning talk nurturing social innovation in uzbekistan, aziza umarova (und...
 
Lightning talk micro naratives and sensors for real time monitoring, borko v...
Lightning talk  micro naratives and sensors for real time monitoring, borko v...Lightning talk  micro naratives and sensors for real time monitoring, borko v...
Lightning talk micro naratives and sensors for real time monitoring, borko v...
 
2015 Year in Review - UNDP
2015 Year in Review - UNDP2015 Year in Review - UNDP
2015 Year in Review - UNDP
 
UNDP Innovation Facility Brochure
UNDP Innovation Facility BrochureUNDP Innovation Facility Brochure
UNDP Innovation Facility Brochure
 
Nesta:undp:social innovation ws08072013
Nesta:undp:social innovation ws08072013Nesta:undp:social innovation ws08072013
Nesta:undp:social innovation ws08072013
 
Lightning talk mobile technologies from the users by the users-jasmina belco...
Lightning talk  mobile technologies from the users by the users-jasmina belco...Lightning talk  mobile technologies from the users by the users-jasmina belco...
Lightning talk mobile technologies from the users by the users-jasmina belco...
 
Social innovation and collaborative design
Social innovation and collaborative designSocial innovation and collaborative design
Social innovation and collaborative design
 
UNDP Proposal of the UAE Government for an Innovation Pavilion
UNDP Proposal of the UAE Government for an Innovation PavilionUNDP Proposal of the UAE Government for an Innovation Pavilion
UNDP Proposal of the UAE Government for an Innovation Pavilion
 
Innovation journey - UNDP Armenia-George Hodge
Innovation journey - UNDP Armenia-George HodgeInnovation journey - UNDP Armenia-George Hodge
Innovation journey - UNDP Armenia-George Hodge
 
The Why and What of Innovation: Caffin UNDP Montenegro Nov 2013
The Why and What of Innovation: Caffin UNDP Montenegro Nov 2013The Why and What of Innovation: Caffin UNDP Montenegro Nov 2013
The Why and What of Innovation: Caffin UNDP Montenegro Nov 2013
 
Polarity Thinking_CoCreative Consulting_20 March 2014
Polarity Thinking_CoCreative Consulting_20 March 2014Polarity Thinking_CoCreative Consulting_20 March 2014
Polarity Thinking_CoCreative Consulting_20 March 2014
 
Social Innovation Camp Toolkit
Social Innovation Camp ToolkitSocial Innovation Camp Toolkit
Social Innovation Camp Toolkit
 
Nec 2013 proposed commitment
Nec 2013 proposed commitmentNec 2013 proposed commitment
Nec 2013 proposed commitment
 
SHIFT Event Brochure v2.8
SHIFT Event Brochure v2.8SHIFT Event Brochure v2.8
SHIFT Event Brochure v2.8
 
2014 Innovation Facility Annual Review - social media analytics
2014 Innovation Facility Annual Review - social media analytics2014 Innovation Facility Annual Review - social media analytics
2014 Innovation Facility Annual Review - social media analytics
 
Innovative Approaches to Address Gender-Based Violence
Innovative Approaches to Address Gender-Based ViolenceInnovative Approaches to Address Gender-Based Violence
Innovative Approaches to Address Gender-Based Violence
 
Innovation at the UN Development Programme - Pecha Kucha talk at Executive Bo...
Innovation at the UN Development Programme - Pecha Kucha talk at Executive Bo...Innovation at the UN Development Programme - Pecha Kucha talk at Executive Bo...
Innovation at the UN Development Programme - Pecha Kucha talk at Executive Bo...
 

Similaire à Rgi presentation undp

SDGs in OIC Countries: Data, Finance and Implementation
SDGs in OIC Countries: Data, Finance and ImplementationSDGs in OIC Countries: Data, Finance and Implementation
SDGs in OIC Countries: Data, Finance and ImplementationSDGsPlus
 
Food safety performance tool validation consultation
Food safety performance tool validation consultationFood safety performance tool validation consultation
Food safety performance tool validation consultationILRI
 
Cfsir1306 failedstatesindex2013-06l(1)
Cfsir1306 failedstatesindex2013-06l(1)Cfsir1306 failedstatesindex2013-06l(1)
Cfsir1306 failedstatesindex2013-06l(1)Univ. of Tripoli
 
Encuesta Fraser: El informe anual de 2014
Encuesta Fraser: El informe anual de 2014Encuesta Fraser: El informe anual de 2014
Encuesta Fraser: El informe anual de 2014Eduardo Nelson German
 
Presentation by Michael Green
Presentation by Michael GreenPresentation by Michael Green
Presentation by Michael GreenDr. Amit Kapoor
 
Press Conference August 15, 2016 Rio Media Center
Press Conference August 15, 2016 Rio Media CenterPress Conference August 15, 2016 Rio Media Center
Press Conference August 15, 2016 Rio Media Centersocprog
 
Knowledge Management Workshop - SUN Movement
Knowledge Management Workshop - SUN MovementKnowledge Management Workshop - SUN Movement
Knowledge Management Workshop - SUN MovementSUN_Movement
 
2012 KPCS List of participants
2012 KPCS List of participants 2012 KPCS List of participants
2012 KPCS List of participants Africa Diamonds
 
Ranking de corrupción de la WEF
Ranking de corrupción de la WEFRanking de corrupción de la WEF
Ranking de corrupción de la WEFJuan Macias
 
Berhanu abegaz midrand taylor and francis indaba presentation
Berhanu abegaz midrand taylor and francis indaba presentationBerhanu abegaz midrand taylor and francis indaba presentation
Berhanu abegaz midrand taylor and francis indaba presentationTaylor & Francis (Africa)
 
2015 legatum-prosperity-index-pdf
2015 legatum-prosperity-index-pdf2015 legatum-prosperity-index-pdf
2015 legatum-prosperity-index-pdfDaniel Alouidor
 
Startup Communities: From Nascence to Maturity
Startup Communities: From Nascence to MaturityStartup Communities: From Nascence to Maturity
Startup Communities: From Nascence to MaturityDaniel Cukier
 

Similaire à Rgi presentation undp (20)

SDGs in OIC Countries: Data, Finance and Implementation
SDGs in OIC Countries: Data, Finance and ImplementationSDGs in OIC Countries: Data, Finance and Implementation
SDGs in OIC Countries: Data, Finance and Implementation
 
Food safety performance tool validation consultation
Food safety performance tool validation consultationFood safety performance tool validation consultation
Food safety performance tool validation consultation
 
Cfsir1306 failedstatesindex2013-06l(1)
Cfsir1306 failedstatesindex2013-06l(1)Cfsir1306 failedstatesindex2013-06l(1)
Cfsir1306 failedstatesindex2013-06l(1)
 
Progress Toward Meeting Nutrition Targets in Africa
Progress Toward Meeting Nutrition Targets in AfricaProgress Toward Meeting Nutrition Targets in Africa
Progress Toward Meeting Nutrition Targets in Africa
 
indice di benessere 2014
indice di benessere 2014indice di benessere 2014
indice di benessere 2014
 
World_Bank.pptx
World_Bank.pptxWorld_Bank.pptx
World_Bank.pptx
 
Encuesta Fraser: El informe anual de 2014
Encuesta Fraser: El informe anual de 2014Encuesta Fraser: El informe anual de 2014
Encuesta Fraser: El informe anual de 2014
 
Presentation by Michael Green
Presentation by Michael GreenPresentation by Michael Green
Presentation by Michael Green
 
Press Conference August 15, 2016 Rio Media Center
Press Conference August 15, 2016 Rio Media CenterPress Conference August 15, 2016 Rio Media Center
Press Conference August 15, 2016 Rio Media Center
 
2015 Quality of Death Index Infographic
2015 Quality of Death Index Infographic2015 Quality of Death Index Infographic
2015 Quality of Death Index Infographic
 
Development of the road map on access to medicines and vaccines - English
Development of the road map on access to medicines and vaccines - EnglishDevelopment of the road map on access to medicines and vaccines - English
Development of the road map on access to medicines and vaccines - English
 
World bank
World bank World bank
World bank
 
Knowledge Management Workshop - SUN Movement
Knowledge Management Workshop - SUN MovementKnowledge Management Workshop - SUN Movement
Knowledge Management Workshop - SUN Movement
 
2012 KPCS List of participants
2012 KPCS List of participants 2012 KPCS List of participants
2012 KPCS List of participants
 
ECONOMIC FREEDOM 2021.pdf
ECONOMIC FREEDOM 2021.pdfECONOMIC FREEDOM 2021.pdf
ECONOMIC FREEDOM 2021.pdf
 
Ranking de corrupción de la WEF
Ranking de corrupción de la WEFRanking de corrupción de la WEF
Ranking de corrupción de la WEF
 
Berhanu abegaz midrand taylor and francis indaba presentation
Berhanu abegaz midrand taylor and francis indaba presentationBerhanu abegaz midrand taylor and francis indaba presentation
Berhanu abegaz midrand taylor and francis indaba presentation
 
2015 legatum-prosperity-index-pdf
2015 legatum-prosperity-index-pdf2015 legatum-prosperity-index-pdf
2015 legatum-prosperity-index-pdf
 
PI2015Brochure_WEB
PI2015Brochure_WEBPI2015Brochure_WEB
PI2015Brochure_WEB
 
Startup Communities: From Nascence to Maturity
Startup Communities: From Nascence to MaturityStartup Communities: From Nascence to Maturity
Startup Communities: From Nascence to Maturity
 

Plus de United Nations Development Programme

Plus de United Nations Development Programme (8)

UNDP Innovation Facility 2014 Annual Review
UNDP Innovation Facility 2014 Annual ReviewUNDP Innovation Facility 2014 Annual Review
UNDP Innovation Facility 2014 Annual Review
 
Public service innovation global centre for public service excellence (singap...
Public service innovation global centre for public service excellence (singap...Public service innovation global centre for public service excellence (singap...
Public service innovation global centre for public service excellence (singap...
 
Lightning talk be responsible-marija novkovic, montenegro (1)
Lightning talk  be responsible-marija novkovic, montenegro (1)Lightning talk  be responsible-marija novkovic, montenegro (1)
Lightning talk be responsible-marija novkovic, montenegro (1)
 
Lightning talks challenges and crowdsourcing as a way to gather new ideas-sa...
Lightning talks  challenges and crowdsourcing as a way to gather new ideas-sa...Lightning talks  challenges and crowdsourcing as a way to gather new ideas-sa...
Lightning talks challenges and crowdsourcing as a way to gather new ideas-sa...
 
Global Innovation Webinar Series: Design Thinking and Youth - 10 Oct 2013
Global Innovation Webinar Series: Design Thinking and Youth - 10 Oct 2013Global Innovation Webinar Series: Design Thinking and Youth - 10 Oct 2013
Global Innovation Webinar Series: Design Thinking and Youth - 10 Oct 2013
 
SIC & Bethnal Green Ventures
SIC & Bethnal Green VenturesSIC & Bethnal Green Ventures
SIC & Bethnal Green Ventures
 
Project leader and polarity thinking session ppt by russ gaskin (co-creative...
Project leader and polarity thinking session ppt  by russ gaskin (co-creative...Project leader and polarity thinking session ppt  by russ gaskin (co-creative...
Project leader and polarity thinking session ppt by russ gaskin (co-creative...
 
Social-ecological resilience
Social-ecological resilienceSocial-ecological resilience
Social-ecological resilience
 

Rgi presentation undp

  • 1. The 2013 Resource Governance Index A measure of transparency and accountability in the oil, gas and mining sector New York, UNDP, May 16, 2013 http://www.revenuewatch.org/rgi
  • 2. What’s at stake? • Oil, gas and mining sector governance as a development challenge – In resource rich countries, over 1 billion people live on less than $5 a day, and 640 million live on $2 a day or less. – In 2011, Nigeria’s oil revenues alone were 60 percent higher than international aid to all of sub-Saharan Africa. – In 1980-2006: Oil-rich states 3 times less likely to democratize than non-oil producers. • Governance is the challenge, but also the solution. • The RGI aims to help advance this effort. 2
  • 3. Why is a measure of resource governance needed? • Raise awareness about a major development challenge • Concretize what may be seen as a vague challenge • Enable empirical research and analysis • Enable evidenced-based policymaking and advocacy • Inform dialogue across all stakeholders • A diagnostic tool to identify global and country reform priorities 3
  • 4. What is the Resource Governance Index? • A measure of transparency and accountability of the oil, gas and mining sector in 58 countries. • For each country, researchers, gathered primary information in 2012 to answer a standard questionnaire with 173 questions, vetted by a peer reviewer. 4
  • 5. How is the Index built? Resource Governance Index composite 5
  • 6. 80% of countries do not meet satisfactory governance standards 98 92 88 85 80 77 76 75 74 74 73 70 68 66 63 62 61 58 57 56 56 56 54 53 53 51 50 48 47 47 47 46 46 46 46 43 43 43 43 42 42 41 41 39 38 37 34 34 33 31 31 29 28 26 19 13 5 4 0 20 40 60 80 100 1.Norway 2.UnitedStates(GulfofMexico) 3.UnitedKingdom 4.Australia(WesternAustralia) 5.Brazil 6.Mexico 7.Canada(Alberta) 8.Chile 9.Colombia 10.TrinidadandTobago 11.Peru 12.India 13.Timor-Leste 14.Indonesia 15.Ghana 16.Liberia 17.Zambia 18.Ecuador 19.Kazakhstan 20.Venezuela 21.SouthAfrica 22.Russia 23.Philippines 24.Bolivia 25.Morocco 26.Mongolia 27.Tanzania 28.Azerbaijan 29.Iraq 30.Botswana 31.Bahrain 32.Gabon 33.Guinea 34.Malaysia 35.SierraLeone 36.China 37.Yemen 38.Egypt 39.PapuaNewGuinea 40.Nigeria 41.Angola 42.Kuwait 43.Vietnam 44.Congo(DRC) 45.Algeria 46.Mozambique 47.Cameroon 48.SaudiArabia 49.Afghanistan 50.SouthSudan 51.Zimbabwe 52.Cambodia 53.Iran 54.Qatar 55.Libya 56.EquatorialGuinea 57.Turkmenistan 58.Myanmar Satisfactory (71-100) Partial (51-70) Weak (41-50) Failing (0-40) 6
  • 7. RGI Results for the 58 countries
  • 8. Transparency is missing where it is needed most 8
  • 9. Satisfactory performance is possible in diverse contexts 9
  • 10. Concrete Illustrations of the governance deficit • In 20 countries (e.g. Venezuela) substantial resource revenue bypass the treasury. • 21 countries (e.g. Guinea) do not publish information on primary sources of revenue (royalties, profit shares or taxes) • In 18 countries (e.g. Alberta, Canada) government officials do not disclose their financial interest in any extractive activity. • Azerbaijan, Russia and Kazakhstan have poor records in key areas including corruption, civil and political liberties and democratic accountability. 10
  • 12. State-owned companies in 45 countries 0 20 40 60 80 100 Statoil Pemex Petrobras ONGC Rosneft Ecopetrol PDVSA KazMunaiGaz Pertamina CODELCO CNPC O.C.P. Sonangol Petromin ZCCM-IH SOCAR Petrotrin KPC Petroecuador Petronas YPFB Sonatrach NNPC MinistryofOil YOGC PMDC ARAMCO Petrovietnam SNH QatarPetroleum STAMICO Debswana NilePetroleum EGPC Gecamines ENH ZMDC ErdenesMGL LibyanNationalOilCorporation NIOC BAPCO GEPetrol NorthernCoalEnterprise MOGE Turkmengas 12
  • 13. Natural resource funds in 23 countries 0 20 40 60 80 100 13
  • 14. Recommendations to improve resource transparency and accountability • Disclose contracts signed with extractive companies. • Ensure that regulatory agencies publish timely, comprehensive reports on oil, gas and mining operations. • Extend transparency and accountability standards to SOCs and natural resource funds. • Concerted effort to control corruption, strengthen the rule of law and guarantee civil and political rights. • Adopt international reporting standards for governments and companies. 14
  • 15. RGI products on http://www.revenuewatch.org/rgi • 58 printable country pages 15