SlideShare une entreprise Scribd logo
1  sur  33
The Effective Teaching of Legal
Ethics-Theory and Best
Practices
Varun Vaish (2008-74)
Structure







Link between Legal Education and Ethical
Lawyering.
Ethics, the Dog of law School-Why?
Theory for and against-Ethics need not,
cannot and should not be taught.
Best Practices.


Link between Legal Education and
Ethical Lawyering.

Anthony Kronman penned a treatise in 1993 on the
increasing decline of ethics and morality in the legal
profession, wherein he expressed his concerns about the
legal profession losing its foundational ideals as a whole.



He opined that for the most part legal education was to be
blamed for this problem since it did not create lawyers
‘cultured in ethics and grounded in morality’



While enunciating an intrinsic link between legal education
and the legal profession, Felix Fletcher also observed that
the law is essentially what lawyers are and lawyers are
in essence what law schools make them.



A firm conviction exists that the problem of declining
virtues in the legal profession finds its roots in the law
school
Link between Legal Education and
Ethical Lawyering. Working Group on Legal
 In 2005 report of the

Education (an initiative of the National
Knowledge Commission established by the
GoI) highlighted that the main aim of legal
education was to impart justice oriented
education to young minds who have
consciously chosen to be lawyers.



This aim, it stated, “requires that high
standards of professional ethics and
morality, coupled with a spirit of public
service, be inculcated in a law students from
the very beginning.”
Link between Legal Education and Ethical
Lawyering.


Legal ethics it is felt requires of critical reflection
vis-à-vis professional expectations, which it is felt
can be developed only during law school.



Furthermore the adoption of ethics while
practicing the law, where one is burdened with
expectations of doing well, with no real support
from other lawyers, who would in all likelihood be
dealing with similar dilemmas, becomes very
difficult.
Legal Ethics-Dog of law school


Unfortunately the study ethics and morality in the
legal profession constitutes a minuscule portion of
the overall curriculum.



Such is the indifference to the course in question
that one Harvard Law School Faculty was quoted as
stating that such a course "is not important, or that
it's all obvious or irrelevant, because the demands
of the world will dictate how they behave."



Most attribute this current state of affairs to the
Bar Council which has made it mandatory for this
course to be taught, thereby chaining faculty,
whereas many other attribute it to the neglect
shown to the course by the faculty itself to issues
of ethical importance.
Why LE is treated as 2nd class?


An explanation as regards to why courses on Legal ethics are
relegated to a second class status has been offered by Ronal
Pipkin in his study on legal education in the 1970’s which
squarely attributed the blame to a “curricular paradox” that
exists in law school syllabi.



In law school teaching, first and foremost analytical decision
making is sought to be inculcated within students using the
Socratic Method of teaching.



Sensitivity bought about by teaching through discussions,
ranks last in the hierarchy of educational goals at law
schools.



Traditional law school debate breaks down and student who
have otherwise been taught to master the art of rational
logic, are suddenly faced with having to deal with ethical
positions which involve
fair degree of personal and
emotional stakes.


Pipkin in another study conducted in 1976, concluded that as a
law student is on the verge of graduating, he views his time
spent in law school with increasing disdain and hence the
seeds of legal ethics mustn’t be sown at such an unreceptive
time, i.e. late in the law school curriculum.



Then there exist claims of the intrinsic hypocrisy in Law
Schools themselves, which portray to students the fact that they
do not always follow the laws they preach.



For example, pro bono work is considered an essential tenet
of legal professional responsibility, however law school
placement offices hardly ever direct students towards nonprofits, but rather largely towards corporate law firms
representing them to be the only viable mainstream career
option after law school.



This dichotomy further serves to undermine legal ethics in the
mind of the law student.
Ethics need not, can not and should
not be taught?


Members of the faculty often feel that ethics need
not be taught in law school, in part because they
feel that there should be a clear separation
between the academic study of law as a
discipline and the practice of law as a
profession.



However in counter to this argument it is said that
thought the study of ethics has a strong practical
element, one cannot say that it is not an
academic subject in its own right.
Ethics need not, can not and should
not be taught?


Need not be taught-They believe that a invisible
hand rewards ethical practitioners, which in turn
provides them with an impetus to remain ethical
and disciplinary committees exist merely to weed
out a small number of truly bad apples.



Though this may be true, it still does not take
away from a law schools duty to provide tools to
lawyer to help them make their decision or
understand the consequences thereof, on way or
the other.
Ethics need not, can not and should
not be taught?


Cannot be taught- They operate under the
belief that law students are young adults
whose values are “fully formed prior to law
school and are not likely to change”.



It has been adequately proven that ethical
absorption continues well into adulthood
and values can change at later stages of
life.
Ethics need not, can not and should
not be taught?


Should not be taught- Prof. langdell’s case study method.



This was a time when higher education was undergoing a
paradigm shift from moral to scientific.



Professor Langdell taught the law as a science wherein he
distinguished between facts, which could be taught, and values,
which could not.



Ethics were in the realm of values which could not be taught.



Langdell carried the analysis and dissection of appellate cases
with the same precision of as that of a scientist in a chemistry lab
and while most law professors don’t view themselves as
scientists, they continue to apply the langdell’s pedagogical
approach and strictly separate legal from ethical questions.
Ethics need not, can not and should
not be taught?


Students often ask questions pertaining to ethics of a
particular legal doctrine only to be reprimanded by
their professor who would state that the subject of the
class was law, not ethics.



However today the fact-value distinction is no longer
thought to be relevant and ethics have regained their
place as a respectful and serious academic subject
throughout higher education.



In fact even the scientific fraternity has accepted the
fact that science and ethics do in indeed mix and are
not mutually exclusive.
Best Practices-Teaching of Ethics
Pervasively


Kronman and Edwards both have argued that the
real problem of declining ethical standards and
morality starts at law school where ethical
education forms a minor percentage of the focus
levied on courses such as Constitution or
Contracts.



Students are left astray to garner ethics and
develop morality all on their own and while some
do, most choose to ignore developing it because
it does not have as much weightage as a course
in Penal laws or Corporate law.
Teaching of Ethics Pervasively-UCLA
Case Study.


The pervasive method “teaches students the
skills . . . to identify and analyze (ethical
questions) in settings where ethics is not
the primary focus of attention.



UCLA developed a mechanism to impart
such education via an infusion of ethics
‘throughout the law school curriculum’,
and not just during a single distinct
course.
Focus of this method

The ultimate goal sought to be achieved by this
new method was that students should know how
to recognize a legal ethics issue, even if they
could not immediately find “the right answer,
while at the same time developing some sense of,
self-regulation, individual responsibility, moral
and professional questioning, and concern for
the public interest and welfare.



The infusion method in essence required faculty to
develop materials and exercises that would
integrate legal ethics into their substantive
courses.
Infusion


This infusion no doubt required some measure
of re-education of the law school faculty,
wherein they were trained to utilize new
teaching technologies, such as experiential
exercises, film and videotape, role-playing,
historical material, and real case problems
pertaining to ethics dilemmas in traditional
law school courses.



Participatory and experiential learning in
specific practical contexts forms the base of
such learning with the specific focus of
making students proficient in the making of
decisions where rules were less than clear or
unambiguous and where lawyers were called
upon to consult their own personal and
professional ethics.
Benefits


At UCLA the benefits of exposing law students
regularly to legal ethics in the context of substantive
law was that students began to view legal ethics not
as a distinct field but rather as an essential
component of everyday practice as a lawyer.



They also garnered the ability to identify ethical
issues in different contexts with greater clarity.



Exposure to ethics early in the law school so that
students will already have a foundational framework
as they begin to encounter ethics in their infusion
courses in other substantive subjects.
Ethics as the most important subject in
law school.


They believe that to teach ethics seriously it must
be restructured as the most important subject in
law school.



It has been suggested that innovations in the
teaching of legal ethics will not have any
significant impact and only the acknowledgement
of legal ethics as the most important subject in
law school curriculum will lead to significant
changes in the pedagogy surrounding legal
ethics.
Why as the center of the curriculum?Fordham University Law School.


This notion is born out of the belief that when
viewed from the lens of pragmatism, legal
ethics is the only subject that every student
who becomes a lawyer will encounter in
practice.



This rechristening of ethics as the most
important subject in law school will not
surprisingly
require
significant
overhauling of the law school curriculum.
Course Structure


Firstly Legal ethics would have to be a course
carrying a minimum three credit in the first year of
law school to convey the clear message to both
students and faculty that that ethics is a
foundational component of what it means to think
like--and to be--a lawyer.



This particular course cannot merely be
indoctrination in the rules of professional ethics,
but instead must teach those rules in context with
a focus on their purpose and history, and always
with fair concentration on the role of lawyers and
their dominant conception as aids in distributes
justice and maintenance of order.
Contd.


Secondly where most law schools require only one course in
legal ethics to date, the new curriculum would require a second
more advanced course on legal ethics towards the end of
one’s law school tenure, for two reasons.



First to demonstrate the fact that ethics remains central to
their development as lawyers and also to incorporate a
broad perception of ethics into their final assessment of their
practical experiences as students, including the formation of
their self-image as a practitioner in the particular field they will
pursue after graduation.



Fordham Law has led the way by providing such courses in the
final year that are specific to the chosen area of practice of the
concerned law student, such as Ethics in Corporate Practice,
Ethics in Criminal Advocacy, Ethics in Public Interest Law,
and Lawyering for Individuals etc.
University of Maryland-Best Practice


Another major positive development as witnessed in
University of Maryland law school has been the
infusion of ethics in moot courts and pro-bono
legal aid work and other clinical programs, as
these programs, have proven to be significantly
more effective than classroom teaching in terms
of providing a more visceral knowledge to
students regarding professional responsibility in
general and providing accessibility to the justice
system to the indigent in particular.
Harvard,West Virginia University College
of law, NYU-Reliance on Unorthodox
Materials.



As per Dean Wilkins of Harvard Law School, while casebooks
on legal ethics are still important, they are second in
importance class to clips being shown of Legal T.V. shows that
focus on ethical and moral dilemmas that lawyers face.



“The way to engage people into thinking about ethics is to give
them stories--not rules, not abstractions,” says Jim Elkins,
who teaches at West Virginia University College of Law.



New York University's Stephen Billers shares the same
sentiment when he states that: “The more we can stimulate or
incorporate a story in which the student plays a role, the
better the course.”


Reliance on Unorthodox Materials Contd.


Another methodology increasingly being applied by
law schools are the viewings of video taped
interviews of lawyers who are disbarred, who are
otherwise viewed as ‘aliens’ along with
interviews of their clients, to bring about a better
understanding of the reasons for their conduct
and establish the more humanistic side of the story .



This it is felt imprints more on the minds of
students, then reading facts about a particular
incident
Cont.-Connect with Practicing lawyers


In addition many law professors are of the opinion
that if legal ethics are to be taught it should ideally
be done through collaborations with practicing
lawyers and individuals already engaged in the
legal profession.



For example the American Inns of Court is a
voluntary organization that brings together
Judges, Senior Lawyers and Law professors, and
organises them in teams with 3rd year law
students and young lawyers for the purpose of
carrying out presentations in relation to
advocacy issues and ethical dilemmas, all in an
attempt to foster a mentor-mentee relationship
which develop skills in professionalism.
Lessons from UWO and U of T


It is felt that law schools can enhance their teaching of legal ethics
by having comparative information of what is being done in
different jurisdictions:

1) Committee on Professionalism
2) Mandatory First year Course on Professionalism and Legal
Ethics.


Chief Justice of Ontario's Advisory Committee on Professionalism.



This committee consisted of representatives of the judiciary, the
Law Society of Upper Canada, the legal academia, and various
provincial and county law organizations.



The goal of the committee was to spearhead various projects,
make recommendations and act as a clearing house for ideas
that would promote professionalism.

.
Committee on LE and Professionalism.


Since its inception the committee has performed three specific task for the
growth of professionalism.



firstly laying down a definition of professionalism to help lawyers better
understand the importance of professionalism and its impact on their work and
on the justice system.



Secondly the committee organizes two conferences each year, with the aim
of producing scholarly articles and commentary on the various aspects of legal
ethics and professionalism



Third and most importantly the committee has established a sub-committee
with the specific task of promoting and improving the teaching of
professionalism with a representative in every major university in Ontario.



This sub-committee organizes conferences in various law schools, which
centre around themes such as, challenges involved in teaching legal
professionalism, making professional education a life-long process, teaching
civility in the courtroom, and improving the instruction and evaluation of ethics
etc.
LE infusion in other courses database.


One of the primary concerns of non-specialist faculty was
the fact that resources needed to be developed to make
it easier for non-specialists to teach legal ethics as a
component of their courses.



Hence the sub-committee decided to create a database
or inventory of teaching resources for legal ethics and
professionalism.



It asked professor in each law school to gather information
from his or her institution to be sent to the committee in
order to gather a wide range of material.



Relevant books, articles, unpublished conference
materials, and cases would be included, as would
course outlines, assignments, exams, and problems for
discussion and organised not only as topic areas within
ethics, but also in terms of how they might be used in
other law school courses.
Ethics as a mandatory 1st year Course


Teaching ethics in the first year has the advantage of
exposing students to at least the basics of ethics, making
them more interested in taking optional courses on ethics
later on.



In addition ethics and professionalism courses are
sufficiently foundational that they should be introduced in
the first year of legal studies.



However it is felt that whatever is gained from first students
in terms of their enthusiasm and interest in the course is lost
in terms of their lack of knowledge as first year students may
find it difficult to understand the issues and the contexts
in which they arise.



Teacher at UWO were advised to endeavour to pitch the
material at the right level.
Structure of the 1st year Course at UWO


It ran for ten weeks in the spring term from February to April.



Each week the class met for between two and three hours.



The teaching was mainly by lecture although there were some debates
between the instructors and students, based on the understanding that that
if the teaching of legal ethics is to move beyond the mere teaching of rules
and provision of a professional code and cause students to introspect on
their own values and their relation to the profession. Small groups and
intensive discussions are critical.



Central topics for the lectures were an
introduction to ethical theory,
an introduction to legal ethics,
the role of the regulator,
the discipline process,
integrity and professionalism, c
Confidentiality and its exceptions,
conflict of interest,
civility in the adversarial system,
ethics of advocacy,
and defending the guilty.











Developments at the University of
Toronto


The first year at the University of Toronto features what are called “bridge
weeks”.



During each of these weeks, which may be scheduled at different times
throughout the course of the academic year, the normal course
schedule is suspended and students spend the week on the intensive
examination of a particular topic.



Previous topics have included critical legal studies, law and
development, law and economics, and legal pluralism. Students write a
paper for each of the three weeks. The two shorter papers are on a passfail basis and the longer one is graded.



In January 2003 the University of Toronto decided to devote one of the
bridge weeks to legal ethics, and this has continued each year since then.



This method has the evident benefit of exposing first year students to
legal ethics in an intensive manner without the rigor of a full term
course, and where students are graded by way of a short paper on a pass
and fail basis.
“I had learnt the true practice of law. I had learnt to find the better
side of human nature and to enter men’s hearts. I realized the true
function of a lawyer was to unite parties riven asunder. The lesson was
so indelibly burnt into me, that a large part of my time during the
twenty years of my practice as a lawyer was occupied in bringing about
private compromises of hundreds of cases. I lost nothing thereby –
not even money, certainly not my soul.”
-        Mahatma Gandhi, 1927

Thank you

Contenu connexe

Similaire à Je presentation

How to Teach Legal Ethics: Best Practices
How to Teach Legal Ethics: Best PracticesHow to Teach Legal Ethics: Best Practices
How to Teach Legal Ethics: Best PracticesVarun Vaish
 
A future for legal education: professional development and ethics - Nigel Duncan
A future for legal education: professional development and ethics - Nigel DuncanA future for legal education: professional development and ethics - Nigel Duncan
A future for legal education: professional development and ethics - Nigel DuncanThe Higher Education Academy
 
Quest in Education July 2018 ISSN: 0048-6434
Quest in Education July 2018   ISSN: 0048-6434Quest in Education July 2018   ISSN: 0048-6434
Quest in Education July 2018 ISSN: 0048-6434VIBHUTI PATEL
 
Stephen Wizner on the Theory and Practice of Law
Stephen Wizner on the Theory and Practice of LawStephen Wizner on the Theory and Practice of Law
Stephen Wizner on the Theory and Practice of LawShiva Kumar Srinivasan
 
Smart Without Purpose
Smart Without PurposeSmart Without Purpose
Smart Without PurposeLeslie820
 
Donald Nicholson - teaching ethics clinically without breaking the bank
Donald Nicholson - teaching ethics clinically without breaking the bankDonald Nicholson - teaching ethics clinically without breaking the bank
Donald Nicholson - teaching ethics clinically without breaking the bankHEA Law
 
- Government InvolvementBioethics Environmental Ethics.docx
- Government InvolvementBioethics Environmental Ethics.docx- Government InvolvementBioethics Environmental Ethics.docx
- Government InvolvementBioethics Environmental Ethics.docxhoney725342
 
Chapter 8a w.a. kritsonis, ph d - lecture notes - decision making
Chapter 8a   w.a. kritsonis, ph d - lecture notes - decision makingChapter 8a   w.a. kritsonis, ph d - lecture notes - decision making
Chapter 8a w.a. kritsonis, ph d - lecture notes - decision makingWilliam Kritsonis
 
THE QUEST FOR A CODE OF PROFESSIONAL ETHICS AN INTELLECTUAL AND M.docx
THE QUEST FOR A CODE OF PROFESSIONAL ETHICS AN INTELLECTUAL AND M.docxTHE QUEST FOR A CODE OF PROFESSIONAL ETHICS AN INTELLECTUAL AND M.docx
THE QUEST FOR A CODE OF PROFESSIONAL ETHICS AN INTELLECTUAL AND M.docxoreo10
 
THE QUEST FOR A CODE OF PROFESSIONAL ETHICS AN INTELLECTUAL AND M.docx
THE QUEST FOR A CODE OF PROFESSIONAL ETHICS AN INTELLECTUAL AND M.docxTHE QUEST FOR A CODE OF PROFESSIONAL ETHICS AN INTELLECTUAL AND M.docx
THE QUEST FOR A CODE OF PROFESSIONAL ETHICS AN INTELLECTUAL AND M.docxssusera34210
 
Academy of Management Execulive, 2004. Vol. 18, No. 2Manag.docx
Academy of Management Execulive, 2004. Vol. 18, No. 2Manag.docxAcademy of Management Execulive, 2004. Vol. 18, No. 2Manag.docx
Academy of Management Execulive, 2004. Vol. 18, No. 2Manag.docxnettletondevon
 
Modern Trends in Legal Education- By Anita Omonuwa
Modern Trends in Legal Education- By Anita OmonuwaModern Trends in Legal Education- By Anita Omonuwa
Modern Trends in Legal Education- By Anita OmonuwaAnita Omonuwa Ogbalu, MCIArb
 
Look it up before you leap: guiding students across the academic-vocational l...
Look it up before you leap: guiding students across the academic-vocational l...Look it up before you leap: guiding students across the academic-vocational l...
Look it up before you leap: guiding students across the academic-vocational l...UK Centre for Legal Education
 
The use of empirical legal research in the undergraduate curriculum
The use of empirical legal research in the undergraduate curriculumThe use of empirical legal research in the undergraduate curriculum
The use of empirical legal research in the undergraduate curriculumUK Centre for Legal Education
 
General ethics an introduction final 2003
General ethics  an introduction final 2003General ethics  an introduction final 2003
General ethics an introduction final 2003Shams Aref
 

Similaire à Je presentation (20)

How to Teach Legal Ethics: Best Practices
How to Teach Legal Ethics: Best PracticesHow to Teach Legal Ethics: Best Practices
How to Teach Legal Ethics: Best Practices
 
Legal ethics at the academic stage
Legal ethics at the academic stageLegal ethics at the academic stage
Legal ethics at the academic stage
 
A future for legal education: professional development and ethics - Nigel Duncan
A future for legal education: professional development and ethics - Nigel DuncanA future for legal education: professional development and ethics - Nigel Duncan
A future for legal education: professional development and ethics - Nigel Duncan
 
Quest in Education July 2018 ISSN: 0048-6434
Quest in Education July 2018   ISSN: 0048-6434Quest in Education July 2018   ISSN: 0048-6434
Quest in Education July 2018 ISSN: 0048-6434
 
Stephen Wizner on the Theory and Practice of Law
Stephen Wizner on the Theory and Practice of LawStephen Wizner on the Theory and Practice of Law
Stephen Wizner on the Theory and Practice of Law
 
The long revolution or the road not taken...? John Dewey and the Realists
The long revolution or the road not taken...?  John Dewey and the RealistsThe long revolution or the road not taken...?  John Dewey and the Realists
The long revolution or the road not taken...? John Dewey and the Realists
 
Smart Without Purpose
Smart Without PurposeSmart Without Purpose
Smart Without Purpose
 
Donald Nicholson - teaching ethics clinically without breaking the bank
Donald Nicholson - teaching ethics clinically without breaking the bankDonald Nicholson - teaching ethics clinically without breaking the bank
Donald Nicholson - teaching ethics clinically without breaking the bank
 
- Government InvolvementBioethics Environmental Ethics.docx
- Government InvolvementBioethics Environmental Ethics.docx- Government InvolvementBioethics Environmental Ethics.docx
- Government InvolvementBioethics Environmental Ethics.docx
 
Chapter 8a w.a. kritsonis, ph d - lecture notes - decision making
Chapter 8a   w.a. kritsonis, ph d - lecture notes - decision makingChapter 8a   w.a. kritsonis, ph d - lecture notes - decision making
Chapter 8a w.a. kritsonis, ph d - lecture notes - decision making
 
Ethics
EthicsEthics
Ethics
 
THE QUEST FOR A CODE OF PROFESSIONAL ETHICS AN INTELLECTUAL AND M.docx
THE QUEST FOR A CODE OF PROFESSIONAL ETHICS AN INTELLECTUAL AND M.docxTHE QUEST FOR A CODE OF PROFESSIONAL ETHICS AN INTELLECTUAL AND M.docx
THE QUEST FOR A CODE OF PROFESSIONAL ETHICS AN INTELLECTUAL AND M.docx
 
THE QUEST FOR A CODE OF PROFESSIONAL ETHICS AN INTELLECTUAL AND M.docx
THE QUEST FOR A CODE OF PROFESSIONAL ETHICS AN INTELLECTUAL AND M.docxTHE QUEST FOR A CODE OF PROFESSIONAL ETHICS AN INTELLECTUAL AND M.docx
THE QUEST FOR A CODE OF PROFESSIONAL ETHICS AN INTELLECTUAL AND M.docx
 
Academy of Management Execulive, 2004. Vol. 18, No. 2Manag.docx
Academy of Management Execulive, 2004. Vol. 18, No. 2Manag.docxAcademy of Management Execulive, 2004. Vol. 18, No. 2Manag.docx
Academy of Management Execulive, 2004. Vol. 18, No. 2Manag.docx
 
Modern Trends in Legal Education- By Anita Omonuwa
Modern Trends in Legal Education- By Anita OmonuwaModern Trends in Legal Education- By Anita Omonuwa
Modern Trends in Legal Education- By Anita Omonuwa
 
Complicitous and contestatory - the hermeneutics of legal education
Complicitous and contestatory - the hermeneutics of legal educationComplicitous and contestatory - the hermeneutics of legal education
Complicitous and contestatory - the hermeneutics of legal education
 
Look it up before you leap: guiding students across the academic-vocational l...
Look it up before you leap: guiding students across the academic-vocational l...Look it up before you leap: guiding students across the academic-vocational l...
Look it up before you leap: guiding students across the academic-vocational l...
 
HKU Conference Slides
HKU Conference SlidesHKU Conference Slides
HKU Conference Slides
 
The use of empirical legal research in the undergraduate curriculum
The use of empirical legal research in the undergraduate curriculumThe use of empirical legal research in the undergraduate curriculum
The use of empirical legal research in the undergraduate curriculum
 
General ethics an introduction final 2003
General ethics  an introduction final 2003General ethics  an introduction final 2003
General ethics an introduction final 2003
 

Plus de Varun Vaish

Private external debt
Private external debtPrivate external debt
Private external debtVarun Vaish
 
Legal writing workshop
Legal writing workshopLegal writing workshop
Legal writing workshopVarun Vaish
 
Entertainement law presentation
Entertainement law presentationEntertainement law presentation
Entertainement law presentationVarun Vaish
 
Division of property on divorce In India
Division of property on divorce In IndiaDivision of property on divorce In India
Division of property on divorce In IndiaVarun Vaish
 
Transfer Pricing Regulations in India
Transfer Pricing Regulations in IndiaTransfer Pricing Regulations in India
Transfer Pricing Regulations in IndiaVarun Vaish
 
Corp law presentation
Corp law presentationCorp law presentation
Corp law presentationVarun Vaish
 
Land acquisition (rehabilitation and resettlement) bill
Land acquisition (rehabilitation and resettlement) billLand acquisition (rehabilitation and resettlement) bill
Land acquisition (rehabilitation and resettlement) billVarun Vaish
 
Delhi Gurgaon Expressway
Delhi Gurgaon ExpresswayDelhi Gurgaon Expressway
Delhi Gurgaon ExpresswayVarun Vaish
 
Inter country adoption
Inter country adoptionInter country adoption
Inter country adoptionVarun Vaish
 
Private external debt
Private external debtPrivate external debt
Private external debtVarun Vaish
 
Motor Vehicles Insurance
Motor Vehicles InsuranceMotor Vehicles Insurance
Motor Vehicles InsuranceVarun Vaish
 
Transfer Pricing Regulations
Transfer Pricing RegulationsTransfer Pricing Regulations
Transfer Pricing RegulationsVarun Vaish
 
REGULATIONS SURROUNDING THE LISTING OF
REGULATIONS SURROUNDING THE LISTING OF REGULATIONS SURROUNDING THE LISTING OF
REGULATIONS SURROUNDING THE LISTING OF Varun Vaish
 

Plus de Varun Vaish (13)

Private external debt
Private external debtPrivate external debt
Private external debt
 
Legal writing workshop
Legal writing workshopLegal writing workshop
Legal writing workshop
 
Entertainement law presentation
Entertainement law presentationEntertainement law presentation
Entertainement law presentation
 
Division of property on divorce In India
Division of property on divorce In IndiaDivision of property on divorce In India
Division of property on divorce In India
 
Transfer Pricing Regulations in India
Transfer Pricing Regulations in IndiaTransfer Pricing Regulations in India
Transfer Pricing Regulations in India
 
Corp law presentation
Corp law presentationCorp law presentation
Corp law presentation
 
Land acquisition (rehabilitation and resettlement) bill
Land acquisition (rehabilitation and resettlement) billLand acquisition (rehabilitation and resettlement) bill
Land acquisition (rehabilitation and resettlement) bill
 
Delhi Gurgaon Expressway
Delhi Gurgaon ExpresswayDelhi Gurgaon Expressway
Delhi Gurgaon Expressway
 
Inter country adoption
Inter country adoptionInter country adoption
Inter country adoption
 
Private external debt
Private external debtPrivate external debt
Private external debt
 
Motor Vehicles Insurance
Motor Vehicles InsuranceMotor Vehicles Insurance
Motor Vehicles Insurance
 
Transfer Pricing Regulations
Transfer Pricing RegulationsTransfer Pricing Regulations
Transfer Pricing Regulations
 
REGULATIONS SURROUNDING THE LISTING OF
REGULATIONS SURROUNDING THE LISTING OF REGULATIONS SURROUNDING THE LISTING OF
REGULATIONS SURROUNDING THE LISTING OF
 

Dernier

Deerfoot Church of Christ Bulletin 4 28 24
Deerfoot Church of Christ Bulletin 4 28 24Deerfoot Church of Christ Bulletin 4 28 24
Deerfoot Church of Christ Bulletin 4 28 24deerfootcoc
 
NoHo First Good News online newsletter May 2024
NoHo First Good News online newsletter May 2024NoHo First Good News online newsletter May 2024
NoHo First Good News online newsletter May 2024NoHo FUMC
 
VADODARA CALL GIRL AVAILABLE 7568201473 call me
VADODARA CALL GIRL AVAILABLE 7568201473 call meVADODARA CALL GIRL AVAILABLE 7568201473 call me
VADODARA CALL GIRL AVAILABLE 7568201473 call meshivanisharma5244
 
No 1 Amil baba in UK Best Astrologer in UK Famous Vashikaran Specialist in UK
No 1 Amil baba in UK Best Astrologer in UK Famous Vashikaran Specialist in UKNo 1 Amil baba in UK Best Astrologer in UK Famous Vashikaran Specialist in UK
No 1 Amil baba in UK Best Astrologer in UK Famous Vashikaran Specialist in UKAmil Baba Naveed Bangali
 
Genesis 1:8 || Meditate the Scripture daily verse by verse
Genesis 1:8  ||  Meditate the Scripture daily verse by verseGenesis 1:8  ||  Meditate the Scripture daily verse by verse
Genesis 1:8 || Meditate the Scripture daily verse by versemaricelcanoynuay
 
Vashikaran Specialist in London Black Magic Removal No 1 Astrologer in UK
Vashikaran Specialist in London Black Magic Removal No 1 Astrologer in UKVashikaran Specialist in London Black Magic Removal No 1 Astrologer in UK
Vashikaran Specialist in London Black Magic Removal No 1 Astrologer in UKAmil Baba Naveed Bangali
 
CALL ON ➥8923113531 🔝Call Girls Nishatganj Lucknow best Female service 🕶
CALL ON ➥8923113531 🔝Call Girls Nishatganj Lucknow best Female service  🕶CALL ON ➥8923113531 🔝Call Girls Nishatganj Lucknow best Female service  🕶
CALL ON ➥8923113531 🔝Call Girls Nishatganj Lucknow best Female service 🕶anilsa9823
 
VIP Call Girls Service mohali 7001035870 Enjoy Call Girls With Our Escorts
VIP Call Girls Service mohali 7001035870 Enjoy Call Girls With Our EscortsVIP Call Girls Service mohali 7001035870 Enjoy Call Girls With Our Escorts
VIP Call Girls Service mohali 7001035870 Enjoy Call Girls With Our Escortssonatiwari757
 
Top Astrologer in UK Best Vashikaran Specialist in England Amil baba Contact ...
Top Astrologer in UK Best Vashikaran Specialist in England Amil baba Contact ...Top Astrologer in UK Best Vashikaran Specialist in England Amil baba Contact ...
Top Astrologer in UK Best Vashikaran Specialist in England Amil baba Contact ...Amil Baba Naveed Bangali
 
The_Chronological_Life_of_Christ_Part_98_Jesus_Frees_Us
The_Chronological_Life_of_Christ_Part_98_Jesus_Frees_UsThe_Chronological_Life_of_Christ_Part_98_Jesus_Frees_Us
The_Chronological_Life_of_Christ_Part_98_Jesus_Frees_UsNetwork Bible Fellowship
 
MEIDUNIDADE COM JESUS PALESTRA ESPIRITA1.pptx
MEIDUNIDADE COM JESUS  PALESTRA ESPIRITA1.pptxMEIDUNIDADE COM JESUS  PALESTRA ESPIRITA1.pptx
MEIDUNIDADE COM JESUS PALESTRA ESPIRITA1.pptxMneasEntidades
 
Amil baba, Kala ilam expert in Multan and Black magic specialist in Sindh and...
Amil baba, Kala ilam expert in Multan and Black magic specialist in Sindh and...Amil baba, Kala ilam expert in Multan and Black magic specialist in Sindh and...
Amil baba, Kala ilam expert in Multan and Black magic specialist in Sindh and...baharayali
 
Lucknow 💋 Call Girls Lucknow - Book 8923113531 Call Girls Available 24 Hours ...
Lucknow 💋 Call Girls Lucknow - Book 8923113531 Call Girls Available 24 Hours ...Lucknow 💋 Call Girls Lucknow - Book 8923113531 Call Girls Available 24 Hours ...
Lucknow 💋 Call Girls Lucknow - Book 8923113531 Call Girls Available 24 Hours ...anilsa9823
 
Famous No1 Amil baba in UK/Australia, Canada, Germany Amil baba Kala jadu
Famous No1 Amil baba in UK/Australia, Canada, Germany Amil baba Kala jaduFamous No1 Amil baba in UK/Australia, Canada, Germany Amil baba Kala jadu
Famous No1 Amil baba in UK/Australia, Canada, Germany Amil baba Kala jaduAmil Baba Naveed Bangali
 
Deerfoot Church of Christ Bulletin 5 5 24
Deerfoot Church of Christ Bulletin 5 5 24Deerfoot Church of Christ Bulletin 5 5 24
Deerfoot Church of Christ Bulletin 5 5 24deerfootcoc
 
Lucknow 💋 best call girls in Lucknow ₹7.5k Pick Up & Drop With Cash Payment 8...
Lucknow 💋 best call girls in Lucknow ₹7.5k Pick Up & Drop With Cash Payment 8...Lucknow 💋 best call girls in Lucknow ₹7.5k Pick Up & Drop With Cash Payment 8...
Lucknow 💋 best call girls in Lucknow ₹7.5k Pick Up & Drop With Cash Payment 8...anilsa9823
 
Flores de Mayo-history and origin we need to understand
Flores de Mayo-history and origin we need to understandFlores de Mayo-history and origin we need to understand
Flores de Mayo-history and origin we need to understandvillamilcecil909
 
call girls in rohini sector 22 Delhi 8264348440 ✅ call girls ❤️
call girls in rohini sector 22 Delhi 8264348440 ✅ call girls ❤️call girls in rohini sector 22 Delhi 8264348440 ✅ call girls ❤️
call girls in rohini sector 22 Delhi 8264348440 ✅ call girls ❤️soniya singh
 

Dernier (20)

Deerfoot Church of Christ Bulletin 4 28 24
Deerfoot Church of Christ Bulletin 4 28 24Deerfoot Church of Christ Bulletin 4 28 24
Deerfoot Church of Christ Bulletin 4 28 24
 
NoHo First Good News online newsletter May 2024
NoHo First Good News online newsletter May 2024NoHo First Good News online newsletter May 2024
NoHo First Good News online newsletter May 2024
 
VADODARA CALL GIRL AVAILABLE 7568201473 call me
VADODARA CALL GIRL AVAILABLE 7568201473 call meVADODARA CALL GIRL AVAILABLE 7568201473 call me
VADODARA CALL GIRL AVAILABLE 7568201473 call me
 
No 1 Amil baba in UK Best Astrologer in UK Famous Vashikaran Specialist in UK
No 1 Amil baba in UK Best Astrologer in UK Famous Vashikaran Specialist in UKNo 1 Amil baba in UK Best Astrologer in UK Famous Vashikaran Specialist in UK
No 1 Amil baba in UK Best Astrologer in UK Famous Vashikaran Specialist in UK
 
Genesis 1:8 || Meditate the Scripture daily verse by verse
Genesis 1:8  ||  Meditate the Scripture daily verse by verseGenesis 1:8  ||  Meditate the Scripture daily verse by verse
Genesis 1:8 || Meditate the Scripture daily verse by verse
 
Vashikaran Specialist in London Black Magic Removal No 1 Astrologer in UK
Vashikaran Specialist in London Black Magic Removal No 1 Astrologer in UKVashikaran Specialist in London Black Magic Removal No 1 Astrologer in UK
Vashikaran Specialist in London Black Magic Removal No 1 Astrologer in UK
 
CALL ON ➥8923113531 🔝Call Girls Nishatganj Lucknow best Female service 🕶
CALL ON ➥8923113531 🔝Call Girls Nishatganj Lucknow best Female service  🕶CALL ON ➥8923113531 🔝Call Girls Nishatganj Lucknow best Female service  🕶
CALL ON ➥8923113531 🔝Call Girls Nishatganj Lucknow best Female service 🕶
 
Russian Call Girls Rohini Sector 39 💓 Delhi 9999965857 @Sabina Modi VVIP MODE...
Russian Call Girls Rohini Sector 39 💓 Delhi 9999965857 @Sabina Modi VVIP MODE...Russian Call Girls Rohini Sector 39 💓 Delhi 9999965857 @Sabina Modi VVIP MODE...
Russian Call Girls Rohini Sector 39 💓 Delhi 9999965857 @Sabina Modi VVIP MODE...
 
VIP Call Girls Service mohali 7001035870 Enjoy Call Girls With Our Escorts
VIP Call Girls Service mohali 7001035870 Enjoy Call Girls With Our EscortsVIP Call Girls Service mohali 7001035870 Enjoy Call Girls With Our Escorts
VIP Call Girls Service mohali 7001035870 Enjoy Call Girls With Our Escorts
 
Top Astrologer in UK Best Vashikaran Specialist in England Amil baba Contact ...
Top Astrologer in UK Best Vashikaran Specialist in England Amil baba Contact ...Top Astrologer in UK Best Vashikaran Specialist in England Amil baba Contact ...
Top Astrologer in UK Best Vashikaran Specialist in England Amil baba Contact ...
 
The_Chronological_Life_of_Christ_Part_98_Jesus_Frees_Us
The_Chronological_Life_of_Christ_Part_98_Jesus_Frees_UsThe_Chronological_Life_of_Christ_Part_98_Jesus_Frees_Us
The_Chronological_Life_of_Christ_Part_98_Jesus_Frees_Us
 
MEIDUNIDADE COM JESUS PALESTRA ESPIRITA1.pptx
MEIDUNIDADE COM JESUS  PALESTRA ESPIRITA1.pptxMEIDUNIDADE COM JESUS  PALESTRA ESPIRITA1.pptx
MEIDUNIDADE COM JESUS PALESTRA ESPIRITA1.pptx
 
Amil baba, Kala ilam expert in Multan and Black magic specialist in Sindh and...
Amil baba, Kala ilam expert in Multan and Black magic specialist in Sindh and...Amil baba, Kala ilam expert in Multan and Black magic specialist in Sindh and...
Amil baba, Kala ilam expert in Multan and Black magic specialist in Sindh and...
 
Lucknow 💋 Call Girls Lucknow - Book 8923113531 Call Girls Available 24 Hours ...
Lucknow 💋 Call Girls Lucknow - Book 8923113531 Call Girls Available 24 Hours ...Lucknow 💋 Call Girls Lucknow - Book 8923113531 Call Girls Available 24 Hours ...
Lucknow 💋 Call Girls Lucknow - Book 8923113531 Call Girls Available 24 Hours ...
 
Famous No1 Amil baba in UK/Australia, Canada, Germany Amil baba Kala jadu
Famous No1 Amil baba in UK/Australia, Canada, Germany Amil baba Kala jaduFamous No1 Amil baba in UK/Australia, Canada, Germany Amil baba Kala jadu
Famous No1 Amil baba in UK/Australia, Canada, Germany Amil baba Kala jadu
 
St. Louise de Marillac and Poor Children
St. Louise de Marillac and Poor ChildrenSt. Louise de Marillac and Poor Children
St. Louise de Marillac and Poor Children
 
Deerfoot Church of Christ Bulletin 5 5 24
Deerfoot Church of Christ Bulletin 5 5 24Deerfoot Church of Christ Bulletin 5 5 24
Deerfoot Church of Christ Bulletin 5 5 24
 
Lucknow 💋 best call girls in Lucknow ₹7.5k Pick Up & Drop With Cash Payment 8...
Lucknow 💋 best call girls in Lucknow ₹7.5k Pick Up & Drop With Cash Payment 8...Lucknow 💋 best call girls in Lucknow ₹7.5k Pick Up & Drop With Cash Payment 8...
Lucknow 💋 best call girls in Lucknow ₹7.5k Pick Up & Drop With Cash Payment 8...
 
Flores de Mayo-history and origin we need to understand
Flores de Mayo-history and origin we need to understandFlores de Mayo-history and origin we need to understand
Flores de Mayo-history and origin we need to understand
 
call girls in rohini sector 22 Delhi 8264348440 ✅ call girls ❤️
call girls in rohini sector 22 Delhi 8264348440 ✅ call girls ❤️call girls in rohini sector 22 Delhi 8264348440 ✅ call girls ❤️
call girls in rohini sector 22 Delhi 8264348440 ✅ call girls ❤️
 

Je presentation

  • 1. The Effective Teaching of Legal Ethics-Theory and Best Practices Varun Vaish (2008-74)
  • 2. Structure     Link between Legal Education and Ethical Lawyering. Ethics, the Dog of law School-Why? Theory for and against-Ethics need not, cannot and should not be taught. Best Practices.
  • 3.  Link between Legal Education and Ethical Lawyering. Anthony Kronman penned a treatise in 1993 on the increasing decline of ethics and morality in the legal profession, wherein he expressed his concerns about the legal profession losing its foundational ideals as a whole.  He opined that for the most part legal education was to be blamed for this problem since it did not create lawyers ‘cultured in ethics and grounded in morality’  While enunciating an intrinsic link between legal education and the legal profession, Felix Fletcher also observed that the law is essentially what lawyers are and lawyers are in essence what law schools make them.  A firm conviction exists that the problem of declining virtues in the legal profession finds its roots in the law school
  • 4. Link between Legal Education and Ethical Lawyering. Working Group on Legal  In 2005 report of the Education (an initiative of the National Knowledge Commission established by the GoI) highlighted that the main aim of legal education was to impart justice oriented education to young minds who have consciously chosen to be lawyers.  This aim, it stated, “requires that high standards of professional ethics and morality, coupled with a spirit of public service, be inculcated in a law students from the very beginning.”
  • 5. Link between Legal Education and Ethical Lawyering.  Legal ethics it is felt requires of critical reflection vis-à-vis professional expectations, which it is felt can be developed only during law school.  Furthermore the adoption of ethics while practicing the law, where one is burdened with expectations of doing well, with no real support from other lawyers, who would in all likelihood be dealing with similar dilemmas, becomes very difficult.
  • 6. Legal Ethics-Dog of law school  Unfortunately the study ethics and morality in the legal profession constitutes a minuscule portion of the overall curriculum.  Such is the indifference to the course in question that one Harvard Law School Faculty was quoted as stating that such a course "is not important, or that it's all obvious or irrelevant, because the demands of the world will dictate how they behave."  Most attribute this current state of affairs to the Bar Council which has made it mandatory for this course to be taught, thereby chaining faculty, whereas many other attribute it to the neglect shown to the course by the faculty itself to issues of ethical importance.
  • 7. Why LE is treated as 2nd class?  An explanation as regards to why courses on Legal ethics are relegated to a second class status has been offered by Ronal Pipkin in his study on legal education in the 1970’s which squarely attributed the blame to a “curricular paradox” that exists in law school syllabi.  In law school teaching, first and foremost analytical decision making is sought to be inculcated within students using the Socratic Method of teaching.  Sensitivity bought about by teaching through discussions, ranks last in the hierarchy of educational goals at law schools.  Traditional law school debate breaks down and student who have otherwise been taught to master the art of rational logic, are suddenly faced with having to deal with ethical positions which involve fair degree of personal and emotional stakes.
  • 8.  Pipkin in another study conducted in 1976, concluded that as a law student is on the verge of graduating, he views his time spent in law school with increasing disdain and hence the seeds of legal ethics mustn’t be sown at such an unreceptive time, i.e. late in the law school curriculum.  Then there exist claims of the intrinsic hypocrisy in Law Schools themselves, which portray to students the fact that they do not always follow the laws they preach.  For example, pro bono work is considered an essential tenet of legal professional responsibility, however law school placement offices hardly ever direct students towards nonprofits, but rather largely towards corporate law firms representing them to be the only viable mainstream career option after law school.  This dichotomy further serves to undermine legal ethics in the mind of the law student.
  • 9. Ethics need not, can not and should not be taught?  Members of the faculty often feel that ethics need not be taught in law school, in part because they feel that there should be a clear separation between the academic study of law as a discipline and the practice of law as a profession.  However in counter to this argument it is said that thought the study of ethics has a strong practical element, one cannot say that it is not an academic subject in its own right.
  • 10. Ethics need not, can not and should not be taught?  Need not be taught-They believe that a invisible hand rewards ethical practitioners, which in turn provides them with an impetus to remain ethical and disciplinary committees exist merely to weed out a small number of truly bad apples.  Though this may be true, it still does not take away from a law schools duty to provide tools to lawyer to help them make their decision or understand the consequences thereof, on way or the other.
  • 11. Ethics need not, can not and should not be taught?  Cannot be taught- They operate under the belief that law students are young adults whose values are “fully formed prior to law school and are not likely to change”.  It has been adequately proven that ethical absorption continues well into adulthood and values can change at later stages of life.
  • 12. Ethics need not, can not and should not be taught?  Should not be taught- Prof. langdell’s case study method.  This was a time when higher education was undergoing a paradigm shift from moral to scientific.  Professor Langdell taught the law as a science wherein he distinguished between facts, which could be taught, and values, which could not.  Ethics were in the realm of values which could not be taught.  Langdell carried the analysis and dissection of appellate cases with the same precision of as that of a scientist in a chemistry lab and while most law professors don’t view themselves as scientists, they continue to apply the langdell’s pedagogical approach and strictly separate legal from ethical questions.
  • 13. Ethics need not, can not and should not be taught?  Students often ask questions pertaining to ethics of a particular legal doctrine only to be reprimanded by their professor who would state that the subject of the class was law, not ethics.  However today the fact-value distinction is no longer thought to be relevant and ethics have regained their place as a respectful and serious academic subject throughout higher education.  In fact even the scientific fraternity has accepted the fact that science and ethics do in indeed mix and are not mutually exclusive.
  • 14. Best Practices-Teaching of Ethics Pervasively  Kronman and Edwards both have argued that the real problem of declining ethical standards and morality starts at law school where ethical education forms a minor percentage of the focus levied on courses such as Constitution or Contracts.  Students are left astray to garner ethics and develop morality all on their own and while some do, most choose to ignore developing it because it does not have as much weightage as a course in Penal laws or Corporate law.
  • 15. Teaching of Ethics Pervasively-UCLA Case Study.  The pervasive method “teaches students the skills . . . to identify and analyze (ethical questions) in settings where ethics is not the primary focus of attention.  UCLA developed a mechanism to impart such education via an infusion of ethics ‘throughout the law school curriculum’, and not just during a single distinct course.
  • 16. Focus of this method The ultimate goal sought to be achieved by this new method was that students should know how to recognize a legal ethics issue, even if they could not immediately find “the right answer, while at the same time developing some sense of, self-regulation, individual responsibility, moral and professional questioning, and concern for the public interest and welfare.  The infusion method in essence required faculty to develop materials and exercises that would integrate legal ethics into their substantive courses.
  • 17. Infusion  This infusion no doubt required some measure of re-education of the law school faculty, wherein they were trained to utilize new teaching technologies, such as experiential exercises, film and videotape, role-playing, historical material, and real case problems pertaining to ethics dilemmas in traditional law school courses.  Participatory and experiential learning in specific practical contexts forms the base of such learning with the specific focus of making students proficient in the making of decisions where rules were less than clear or unambiguous and where lawyers were called upon to consult their own personal and professional ethics.
  • 18. Benefits  At UCLA the benefits of exposing law students regularly to legal ethics in the context of substantive law was that students began to view legal ethics not as a distinct field but rather as an essential component of everyday practice as a lawyer.  They also garnered the ability to identify ethical issues in different contexts with greater clarity.  Exposure to ethics early in the law school so that students will already have a foundational framework as they begin to encounter ethics in their infusion courses in other substantive subjects.
  • 19. Ethics as the most important subject in law school.  They believe that to teach ethics seriously it must be restructured as the most important subject in law school.  It has been suggested that innovations in the teaching of legal ethics will not have any significant impact and only the acknowledgement of legal ethics as the most important subject in law school curriculum will lead to significant changes in the pedagogy surrounding legal ethics.
  • 20. Why as the center of the curriculum?Fordham University Law School.  This notion is born out of the belief that when viewed from the lens of pragmatism, legal ethics is the only subject that every student who becomes a lawyer will encounter in practice.  This rechristening of ethics as the most important subject in law school will not surprisingly require significant overhauling of the law school curriculum.
  • 21. Course Structure  Firstly Legal ethics would have to be a course carrying a minimum three credit in the first year of law school to convey the clear message to both students and faculty that that ethics is a foundational component of what it means to think like--and to be--a lawyer.  This particular course cannot merely be indoctrination in the rules of professional ethics, but instead must teach those rules in context with a focus on their purpose and history, and always with fair concentration on the role of lawyers and their dominant conception as aids in distributes justice and maintenance of order.
  • 22. Contd.  Secondly where most law schools require only one course in legal ethics to date, the new curriculum would require a second more advanced course on legal ethics towards the end of one’s law school tenure, for two reasons.  First to demonstrate the fact that ethics remains central to their development as lawyers and also to incorporate a broad perception of ethics into their final assessment of their practical experiences as students, including the formation of their self-image as a practitioner in the particular field they will pursue after graduation.  Fordham Law has led the way by providing such courses in the final year that are specific to the chosen area of practice of the concerned law student, such as Ethics in Corporate Practice, Ethics in Criminal Advocacy, Ethics in Public Interest Law, and Lawyering for Individuals etc.
  • 23. University of Maryland-Best Practice  Another major positive development as witnessed in University of Maryland law school has been the infusion of ethics in moot courts and pro-bono legal aid work and other clinical programs, as these programs, have proven to be significantly more effective than classroom teaching in terms of providing a more visceral knowledge to students regarding professional responsibility in general and providing accessibility to the justice system to the indigent in particular.
  • 24. Harvard,West Virginia University College of law, NYU-Reliance on Unorthodox Materials.  As per Dean Wilkins of Harvard Law School, while casebooks on legal ethics are still important, they are second in importance class to clips being shown of Legal T.V. shows that focus on ethical and moral dilemmas that lawyers face.  “The way to engage people into thinking about ethics is to give them stories--not rules, not abstractions,” says Jim Elkins, who teaches at West Virginia University College of Law.  New York University's Stephen Billers shares the same sentiment when he states that: “The more we can stimulate or incorporate a story in which the student plays a role, the better the course.” 
  • 25. Reliance on Unorthodox Materials Contd.  Another methodology increasingly being applied by law schools are the viewings of video taped interviews of lawyers who are disbarred, who are otherwise viewed as ‘aliens’ along with interviews of their clients, to bring about a better understanding of the reasons for their conduct and establish the more humanistic side of the story .  This it is felt imprints more on the minds of students, then reading facts about a particular incident
  • 26. Cont.-Connect with Practicing lawyers  In addition many law professors are of the opinion that if legal ethics are to be taught it should ideally be done through collaborations with practicing lawyers and individuals already engaged in the legal profession.  For example the American Inns of Court is a voluntary organization that brings together Judges, Senior Lawyers and Law professors, and organises them in teams with 3rd year law students and young lawyers for the purpose of carrying out presentations in relation to advocacy issues and ethical dilemmas, all in an attempt to foster a mentor-mentee relationship which develop skills in professionalism.
  • 27. Lessons from UWO and U of T  It is felt that law schools can enhance their teaching of legal ethics by having comparative information of what is being done in different jurisdictions: 1) Committee on Professionalism 2) Mandatory First year Course on Professionalism and Legal Ethics.  Chief Justice of Ontario's Advisory Committee on Professionalism.  This committee consisted of representatives of the judiciary, the Law Society of Upper Canada, the legal academia, and various provincial and county law organizations.  The goal of the committee was to spearhead various projects, make recommendations and act as a clearing house for ideas that would promote professionalism. .
  • 28. Committee on LE and Professionalism.  Since its inception the committee has performed three specific task for the growth of professionalism.  firstly laying down a definition of professionalism to help lawyers better understand the importance of professionalism and its impact on their work and on the justice system.  Secondly the committee organizes two conferences each year, with the aim of producing scholarly articles and commentary on the various aspects of legal ethics and professionalism  Third and most importantly the committee has established a sub-committee with the specific task of promoting and improving the teaching of professionalism with a representative in every major university in Ontario.  This sub-committee organizes conferences in various law schools, which centre around themes such as, challenges involved in teaching legal professionalism, making professional education a life-long process, teaching civility in the courtroom, and improving the instruction and evaluation of ethics etc.
  • 29. LE infusion in other courses database.  One of the primary concerns of non-specialist faculty was the fact that resources needed to be developed to make it easier for non-specialists to teach legal ethics as a component of their courses.  Hence the sub-committee decided to create a database or inventory of teaching resources for legal ethics and professionalism.  It asked professor in each law school to gather information from his or her institution to be sent to the committee in order to gather a wide range of material.  Relevant books, articles, unpublished conference materials, and cases would be included, as would course outlines, assignments, exams, and problems for discussion and organised not only as topic areas within ethics, but also in terms of how they might be used in other law school courses.
  • 30. Ethics as a mandatory 1st year Course  Teaching ethics in the first year has the advantage of exposing students to at least the basics of ethics, making them more interested in taking optional courses on ethics later on.  In addition ethics and professionalism courses are sufficiently foundational that they should be introduced in the first year of legal studies.  However it is felt that whatever is gained from first students in terms of their enthusiasm and interest in the course is lost in terms of their lack of knowledge as first year students may find it difficult to understand the issues and the contexts in which they arise.  Teacher at UWO were advised to endeavour to pitch the material at the right level.
  • 31. Structure of the 1st year Course at UWO  It ran for ten weeks in the spring term from February to April.  Each week the class met for between two and three hours.  The teaching was mainly by lecture although there were some debates between the instructors and students, based on the understanding that that if the teaching of legal ethics is to move beyond the mere teaching of rules and provision of a professional code and cause students to introspect on their own values and their relation to the profession. Small groups and intensive discussions are critical.  Central topics for the lectures were an introduction to ethical theory, an introduction to legal ethics, the role of the regulator, the discipline process, integrity and professionalism, c Confidentiality and its exceptions, conflict of interest, civility in the adversarial system, ethics of advocacy, and defending the guilty.          
  • 32. Developments at the University of Toronto  The first year at the University of Toronto features what are called “bridge weeks”.  During each of these weeks, which may be scheduled at different times throughout the course of the academic year, the normal course schedule is suspended and students spend the week on the intensive examination of a particular topic.  Previous topics have included critical legal studies, law and development, law and economics, and legal pluralism. Students write a paper for each of the three weeks. The two shorter papers are on a passfail basis and the longer one is graded.  In January 2003 the University of Toronto decided to devote one of the bridge weeks to legal ethics, and this has continued each year since then.  This method has the evident benefit of exposing first year students to legal ethics in an intensive manner without the rigor of a full term course, and where students are graded by way of a short paper on a pass and fail basis.
  • 33. “I had learnt the true practice of law. I had learnt to find the better side of human nature and to enter men’s hearts. I realized the true function of a lawyer was to unite parties riven asunder. The lesson was so indelibly burnt into me, that a large part of my time during the twenty years of my practice as a lawyer was occupied in bringing about private compromises of hundreds of cases. I lost nothing thereby – not even money, certainly not my soul.” -        Mahatma Gandhi, 1927 Thank you