This interesting articles suggest that successful salespeople need not always
exhibit extrovert tendencies, nor will salespeople be at a complete disadvantage
if they introverts. The author works on a concept proposed by bestselling author
Daniel Pink and proposes the ambivert (referring to an individual who falls
between an extrovert and an introvert) as the ones who are more likely to be
successful in the long run. Basing himself on a sample of salespeople, Adam
Grant, proves his point and offers some pointers for sales managers.
Rethinking the Sales Ideal: Ambiverts May Have Advantage
1. Vlerick Sales Centre Article Summary Series
Rethinking the Extraverted Sales Ideal: The Ambivert Advantage (by
Adam M. Grant, Psychological Science, 2013)
Summarized By Ellen Croux and Deva Rangarajan, Vlerick Sales Center
Article At a Glance:
This interesting articles suggest that successful salespeople need not always
exhibit extrovert tendencies, nor will salespeople be at a complete disadvantage
if they introverts. The author works on a concept proposed by bestselling author
Daniel Pink and proposes the ambivert (referring to an individual who falls
between an extrovert and an introvert) as the ones who are more likely to be
successful in the long run. Basing himself on a sample of salespeople, Adam
Grant, proves his point and offers some pointers for sales managers.
Introduction
Selling is a vital part of the economy, which is why psychologists have a long-
standing interest in the character traits of successful sales people. According to
conventional wisdom productive salespeople are more likely to be extraverted; they
tend to be assertive and enthusiastic and so they are more likely to be selected for
sales positions by managers. There are three major reasons for the advantage in
sales of extraverts. First, selling requires a lot of contact with potential customers
and extraverts tend to be more sociable and comfortable in initiating interactions
with others. Second, extraverts express the confidence, enthusiasm and energy
necessary to persuade customers. Third, extraverts are more likely convince
customers to change their attitude by not taking no for an answer with firm and
forceful behaviour. These reasons may seem obvious but research has shown weak
and conflicting relationships between extraversion and sales performance.
The theory of costs of extraversion in work settings
High levels of assertiveness and enthusiasm can also reduce the effectiveness of
extraverted salespeople in two ways. First, they may focus too heavily on their own
perspectives and dominate conversations. This way there is the possibility that they
neglect or suppress others’ perspectives. Extraverted salespeople may spend too
much time delivering assertive and enthusiastic pitches, while seeking stimulation
and social attention. As a result too little time is spend asking questions and
listening to customers’ answers.
2. Second, extraverted salespeople may elicit negative responses from customers
when their behaviour is perceived and recognized as persuasive intent. In this case
customers might interpret excitement and confidence as a signal that the
salesperson is trying to influence them and they react with actions to maintain
control and protect themselves by scrutinizing the salesperson’s message more
carefully, by marshalling counterarguments and by resisting or rejecting the
influence.
Hypothesis
This article offers a new perspective and proposes a curvilinear, inverted-U-shaped
relationship between extraversion and sales performance. It proposes that
ambiverts, who find themselves in the middle of the extraversion spectrum, should
achieve higher sales than introverts or extraverts do. Ambiverts are likely to
display the right requisite levels of enthusiasm and assertiveness to stimulate
customer interest and convert this interest into sales. At the same time they strike
a balance between talking and listening.
Research method and results
To test this hypothesis a study of 340 outbound-call-center representatives was
conducted, in which their extraversion and sales revenue was tracked over three
months. The study found a curvilinear relationship between sales revenue and
extraversion. The results suggest that ambiverts have a sales advantage over
extraverts regardless of their standing on the other four personality traits of the Big
Five: conscientiousness, openness, neuroticism and agreeableness.
Results from a hierarchical regression analysis showing a
predicted curvilinear relationship between extraversion and sales
revenue over 3 months
3. Findings and further research possibilities
Studies have demonstrated that job performance can suffer if employees are too
conscientious, too emotionally stable, too generous or too learning oriented, but
research about whether sales performance can suffer if employees are too
extraverted still has to be extended. The findings of this study call into question the
long-standing belief that most productive salespeople are extraverted. Previous
studies that found inconsistent results may be explained by too much focus on the
benefits of extraversion and underestimation of the costs. There exists a clear call
for greater attention to the dark sides of extraversion. Future research should
examine factors that might elevate the sales performance of extraverted people to
the same level as ambivert sales people, for example factors like clear reward
structures. There should be a study to examine whether the sales performance of
ambiverted people is consistently better than the performance of introverts or
extraverts. Also variation of the results by facets of extraversion should be
examined and whether there are other personality traits or behavioural patterns
that can reduce or eliminate the negative effects of high extraversion on sales
productivity.
Why these findings are good news
There exists a western cultural bias favouring extraversion, nowhere is this bias
more clear than in sales. Yet the findings of this study suggests that hiring
managers may be missing out on star performers and less extraverted people may
be missing out on productive careers. Organizations might stand to benefit from
training highly extraverted salespeople to model some of the quiet, reserved
tendencies of their more introverted colleagues. The finding that ambivert people
deliver the best sales results constitutes good news because in the world
population, levels of extraversion generally follow the shape of a bell curve. Which
means that most people find themselves somewhere in the middle, in the ambivert
spectrum. The logical conclusion is that most people are well suited to selling.