SlideShare une entreprise Scribd logo
1  sur  12
INFORMATION LITERACY:
THE IMPORTANCE OF EVALUATING
NEWS
Willie Miller
Informatics & Journalism Librarian
Indiana University-Purdue
University Indianapolis
TODAY’S AGENDA
 Defining Information Literacy
 Evaluating News
 Bias
 News v. Opinion
 Real World Examples
 Other Concerns
INFORMATION LITERACY
The set of skills needed to
find, retrieve, analyze, and use
information effectively.
INFORMATION LITERACY
The set of skills needed to
find, retrieve, analyze, and use
information effectively.
EVALUATING NEWS
“The media tells us what is important and what is
trivial by what they take note of and what they
ignore, by what is amplified and what is muted or
omitted.”
Len Masterman, Teaching the Media (1985)
BIAS
Prejudice in favor of or against one
thing, person, or group compared with
another, usually in a way considered to be unfair
or one-sided.
DETECTING BIAS IN REPORTING
 Partiality
 One-sidedness
 Unbalanced selection or presentation
 Tendency or inclination that prevents a fair of balanced approach
 Temperamental or emotional leaning to one side
 Favoritism that distorts reality
 Personalized, unreasoned judgment
 Predisposition or preference (Sloan & Mckay, 2007 p. 6)
 Subjective languages
 Subtle insults
 Questionable quotes
NEWS | VERSUS | OPINION
News Opinion
 Informs
 Based on multiple
viewpoints
 Facts speak for
themselves
 Objective and impersonal
 Persuades
 Based on singular
viewpoints
 Presents informed
arguments
 Subjective and personal
Source: newstrust.net
EVEN TRUSTED SOURCES CAN
PRESENT BIAS VIEWPOINTS IN
THE NEWS. IT
IS, THEREFORE, IMPORTANT THAT
YOU ABLE TO DETECT IT.
GROUP ACTIVITY
Read news article
Determine if it has bias
Identify 4 in-text examples to support your
claim
Report to the class on your findings
OTHER CONCERNS
 Author
 Publisher
 Accuracy
 Publishing Date
 References
RESOURCES
News Resources
 Google News
 Newspaper Source (EBSCO)
 Newspapers (ProQuest) (click on News and Newspapers)
 Journalism Research Guide
 New York Times
 NPR
 Fox News
Also
 Factcheck.org
For APA Help
 Purdue OWL

Contenu connexe

Similaire à News Literacy Class Slides

Bias Presentation Extra (6 Jul 15)
Bias Presentation Extra (6 Jul 15)Bias Presentation Extra (6 Jul 15)
Bias Presentation Extra (6 Jul 15)
Lisa Mears
 
Differentiating BIas and Prejudice G-9 Presentation.pptx
Differentiating BIas and Prejudice  G-9 Presentation.pptxDifferentiating BIas and Prejudice  G-9 Presentation.pptx
Differentiating BIas and Prejudice G-9 Presentation.pptx
ElysaMicu
 
MARY REVIEW1.Chan, G. & Yanos, P. T. (2018). Media depictions .docx
MARY REVIEW1.Chan, G. & Yanos, P. T. (2018). Media depictions .docxMARY REVIEW1.Chan, G. & Yanos, P. T. (2018). Media depictions .docx
MARY REVIEW1.Chan, G. & Yanos, P. T. (2018). Media depictions .docx
alfredacavx97
 
MEDIA AUDIENCES AND CREDIBILITY
MEDIA AUDIENCES AND CREDIBILITYMEDIA AUDIENCES AND CREDIBILITY
MEDIA AUDIENCES AND CREDIBILITY
Nalini Prasad
 
Ic2s2 Tutorial on Modeling Human Values via Social Media Data
Ic2s2 Tutorial on Modeling Human Values via Social Media DataIc2s2 Tutorial on Modeling Human Values via Social Media Data
Ic2s2 Tutorial on Modeling Human Values via Social Media Data
ISI Foundation
 
SDRaiPracticingWithEmpathy
SDRaiPracticingWithEmpathySDRaiPracticingWithEmpathy
SDRaiPracticingWithEmpathy
Subadhra Rai
 
Everyday lifeinformationseekingfinal
Everyday lifeinformationseekingfinalEveryday lifeinformationseekingfinal
Everyday lifeinformationseekingfinal
kcarter14
 
474 2014 persuasion and propaganda up
474 2014 persuasion and propaganda up474 2014 persuasion and propaganda up
474 2014 persuasion and propaganda up
mpeffl
 
Global Leadership Forum - Presidential Precint _Blog_Marie Lina Excellent
Global Leadership Forum - Presidential Precint _Blog_Marie Lina ExcellentGlobal Leadership Forum - Presidential Precint _Blog_Marie Lina Excellent
Global Leadership Forum - Presidential Precint _Blog_Marie Lina Excellent
Marie Lina Excellent
 
Chapter 10Helping OthersIt was their bravery that compelled .docx
Chapter 10Helping OthersIt was their bravery that compelled .docxChapter 10Helping OthersIt was their bravery that compelled .docx
Chapter 10Helping OthersIt was their bravery that compelled .docx
bartholomeocoombs
 
Chapter 10Helping OthersIt was their bravery that compelled .docx
Chapter 10Helping OthersIt was their bravery that compelled .docxChapter 10Helping OthersIt was their bravery that compelled .docx
Chapter 10Helping OthersIt was their bravery that compelled .docx
keturahhazelhurst
 

Similaire à News Literacy Class Slides (20)

Fear Response Bingo
Fear Response BingoFear Response Bingo
Fear Response Bingo
 
351 lecture 7 handout
351 lecture 7 handout351 lecture 7 handout
351 lecture 7 handout
 
Bias Presentation Extra (6 Jul 15)
Bias Presentation Extra (6 Jul 15)Bias Presentation Extra (6 Jul 15)
Bias Presentation Extra (6 Jul 15)
 
Differentiating BIas and Prejudice G-9 Presentation.pptx
Differentiating BIas and Prejudice  G-9 Presentation.pptxDifferentiating BIas and Prejudice  G-9 Presentation.pptx
Differentiating BIas and Prejudice G-9 Presentation.pptx
 
Unconscious Bias: From Awareness to Action (.ppt)
Unconscious Bias: From Awareness to Action (.ppt)Unconscious Bias: From Awareness to Action (.ppt)
Unconscious Bias: From Awareness to Action (.ppt)
 
MARY REVIEW1.Chan, G. & Yanos, P. T. (2018). Media depictions .docx
MARY REVIEW1.Chan, G. & Yanos, P. T. (2018). Media depictions .docxMARY REVIEW1.Chan, G. & Yanos, P. T. (2018). Media depictions .docx
MARY REVIEW1.Chan, G. & Yanos, P. T. (2018). Media depictions .docx
 
Bonnie Benard: Keynote at 2009 Urban Sites Network Conference
Bonnie Benard: Keynote at 2009 Urban Sites Network ConferenceBonnie Benard: Keynote at 2009 Urban Sites Network Conference
Bonnie Benard: Keynote at 2009 Urban Sites Network Conference
 
Culture, translation, and genre: The emergence of health literacy interventions
Culture, translation, and genre: The emergence of health literacy interventionsCulture, translation, and genre: The emergence of health literacy interventions
Culture, translation, and genre: The emergence of health literacy interventions
 
Mass media & politics week 3
Mass media & politics week 3Mass media & politics week 3
Mass media & politics week 3
 
MEDIA AUDIENCES AND CREDIBILITY
MEDIA AUDIENCES AND CREDIBILITYMEDIA AUDIENCES AND CREDIBILITY
MEDIA AUDIENCES AND CREDIBILITY
 
Ic2s2 Tutorial on Modeling Human Values via Social Media Data
Ic2s2 Tutorial on Modeling Human Values via Social Media DataIc2s2 Tutorial on Modeling Human Values via Social Media Data
Ic2s2 Tutorial on Modeling Human Values via Social Media Data
 
SDRaiPracticingWithEmpathy
SDRaiPracticingWithEmpathySDRaiPracticingWithEmpathy
SDRaiPracticingWithEmpathy
 
Everyday lifeinformationseekingfinal
Everyday lifeinformationseekingfinalEveryday lifeinformationseekingfinal
Everyday lifeinformationseekingfinal
 
474 2014 persuasion and propaganda up
474 2014 persuasion and propaganda up474 2014 persuasion and propaganda up
474 2014 persuasion and propaganda up
 
Global Leadership Forum - Presidential Precint _Blog_Marie Lina Excellent
Global Leadership Forum - Presidential Precint _Blog_Marie Lina ExcellentGlobal Leadership Forum - Presidential Precint _Blog_Marie Lina Excellent
Global Leadership Forum - Presidential Precint _Blog_Marie Lina Excellent
 
Chapter 10Helping OthersIt was their bravery that compelled .docx
Chapter 10Helping OthersIt was their bravery that compelled .docxChapter 10Helping OthersIt was their bravery that compelled .docx
Chapter 10Helping OthersIt was their bravery that compelled .docx
 
Chapter 10Helping OthersIt was their bravery that compelled .docx
Chapter 10Helping OthersIt was their bravery that compelled .docxChapter 10Helping OthersIt was their bravery that compelled .docx
Chapter 10Helping OthersIt was their bravery that compelled .docx
 
Modeling Human Values with Social Media
Modeling Human Values with Social MediaModeling Human Values with Social Media
Modeling Human Values with Social Media
 
Discarding confusion: Navigating Information Disorder in South Sudan
Discarding confusion: Navigating Information Disorder in South SudanDiscarding confusion: Navigating Information Disorder in South Sudan
Discarding confusion: Navigating Information Disorder in South Sudan
 
Spot news
Spot newsSpot news
Spot news
 

News Literacy Class Slides

  • 1. INFORMATION LITERACY: THE IMPORTANCE OF EVALUATING NEWS Willie Miller Informatics & Journalism Librarian Indiana University-Purdue University Indianapolis
  • 2. TODAY’S AGENDA  Defining Information Literacy  Evaluating News  Bias  News v. Opinion  Real World Examples  Other Concerns
  • 3. INFORMATION LITERACY The set of skills needed to find, retrieve, analyze, and use information effectively.
  • 4. INFORMATION LITERACY The set of skills needed to find, retrieve, analyze, and use information effectively.
  • 5. EVALUATING NEWS “The media tells us what is important and what is trivial by what they take note of and what they ignore, by what is amplified and what is muted or omitted.” Len Masterman, Teaching the Media (1985)
  • 6. BIAS Prejudice in favor of or against one thing, person, or group compared with another, usually in a way considered to be unfair or one-sided.
  • 7. DETECTING BIAS IN REPORTING  Partiality  One-sidedness  Unbalanced selection or presentation  Tendency or inclination that prevents a fair of balanced approach  Temperamental or emotional leaning to one side  Favoritism that distorts reality  Personalized, unreasoned judgment  Predisposition or preference (Sloan & Mckay, 2007 p. 6)  Subjective languages  Subtle insults  Questionable quotes
  • 8. NEWS | VERSUS | OPINION News Opinion  Informs  Based on multiple viewpoints  Facts speak for themselves  Objective and impersonal  Persuades  Based on singular viewpoints  Presents informed arguments  Subjective and personal Source: newstrust.net
  • 9. EVEN TRUSTED SOURCES CAN PRESENT BIAS VIEWPOINTS IN THE NEWS. IT IS, THEREFORE, IMPORTANT THAT YOU ABLE TO DETECT IT.
  • 10. GROUP ACTIVITY Read news article Determine if it has bias Identify 4 in-text examples to support your claim Report to the class on your findings
  • 11. OTHER CONCERNS  Author  Publisher  Accuracy  Publishing Date  References
  • 12. RESOURCES News Resources  Google News  Newspaper Source (EBSCO)  Newspapers (ProQuest) (click on News and Newspapers)  Journalism Research Guide  New York Times  NPR  Fox News Also  Factcheck.org For APA Help  Purdue OWL