SlideShare une entreprise Scribd logo
1  sur  10
Public Financial  Management Reform:  Trends and Lessons Bill Dorotinsky World Bank ICGFM December 2008 Washington, D.C.
Outline ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Popular Reforms Recommended reforms generally try to change incentives by changing rules, roles and information   External audit ? ? ? Accrual Accounting  Internal control/audit  Procurement    Reporting/ Transparency    Budget classification, chart of account   Treasury Single Account  Fiscal Responsibility Laws   IFMIS, automation   Performance, Program budgeting    Medium-Term Expenditure Frameworks Operational Efficiency Strategic Allocation Macrofiscal Discipline
And other popular themes…. ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
“ OECD” Model? ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
And other practices….. ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Budget Formulation Recent Reform Emphasis Different drivers of reforms confuse the picture. Which are donor-driven? Which country driven? Which address real need? Which are simply fashionable? If higher income enables more self-direction, interesting that performance budgeting of greater interest in upper-middle income countries. * 2006 gross national income (GNI) per capita. The groups are: low income (LIC) US$905 or less; lower middle income (LMIC) US$906–3,595; upper middle income (UMIC) US$3,596–11,115. 23% 21% 9% Capital-Investment Bdgts 38% 15% 23% Performance/Program Budgeting 46% 39% 37% MT Expenditure Framework 31% 45% 29% MT Fiscal Framework UMIC* (13) LMIC* (33) LIC* (35)
Budget Execution Recent Reform Emphasis na 12% 14% Procurement na 12% 11% Internal audit/control 15% 9% 17% Payroll/Personnel 23% 42% 40% Accounting/classification 8% 18% 11% Debt management 15% 18% 26% Commitment controls 31% 36% 51% Treasury/Cash management UMIC (13) LMIC (33) LIC (35)
Other Reforms Recent Reform Emphasis 23% 15% 26% Decentralization 15% 21% 3% PPPs 15% 30% 20% Transparency 23% 36% 26% Budget Law/Legal 8% 18% 3% MoF Reorganization 23% 36% 49% IFMIS UMIC (13) LMIC (33) LIC (35)
Observations ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]

Contenu connexe

Tendances

Streamlining Compliance for Community Banks
Streamlining Compliance for Community BanksStreamlining Compliance for Community Banks
Streamlining Compliance for Community BanksScott White
 
Mergers and acquisitions in the banking sector: the role of the institutional...
Mergers and acquisitions in the banking sector: the role of the institutional...Mergers and acquisitions in the banking sector: the role of the institutional...
Mergers and acquisitions in the banking sector: the role of the institutional...Alberto Asquer
 
Cómo converger hacia un informe integral en la empresa
Cómo converger hacia un informe integral en la empresaCómo converger hacia un informe integral en la empresa
Cómo converger hacia un informe integral en la empresaFundación Ramón Areces
 
The Role of Compliance in Government Enforcement
The Role of Compliance in Government EnforcementThe Role of Compliance in Government Enforcement
The Role of Compliance in Government EnforcementPYA, P.C.
 
Analysing the issue of mis selling of financial products in the uk
Analysing the issue of mis selling of financial products in the ukAnalysing the issue of mis selling of financial products in the uk
Analysing the issue of mis selling of financial products in the ukService_supportAssignment
 
Chapter 11 b :Financial Statement fraud
Chapter 11 b :Financial Statement fraud Chapter 11 b :Financial Statement fraud
Chapter 11 b :Financial Statement fraud VidaB
 
Non-investment Issues In Manager Evaluation - A Brief Overview
Non-investment Issues In Manager Evaluation - A Brief OverviewNon-investment Issues In Manager Evaluation - A Brief Overview
Non-investment Issues In Manager Evaluation - A Brief Overviewamadei77
 
Ch 10 IM
Ch 10 IMCh 10 IM
Ch 10 IME_Motz
 
Access to Finance
Access to Finance Access to Finance
Access to Finance ArmeniaFED
 
Taking the road to advanced approaches and heightened standards in risk manag...
Taking the road to advanced approaches and heightened standards in risk manag...Taking the road to advanced approaches and heightened standards in risk manag...
Taking the road to advanced approaches and heightened standards in risk manag...Grant Thornton LLP
 
2014.06.13 - NAEC EDRC Seminar_Macroprudential policy: Banks risk & Capital C...
2014.06.13 - NAEC EDRC Seminar_Macroprudential policy: Banks risk & Capital C...2014.06.13 - NAEC EDRC Seminar_Macroprudential policy: Banks risk & Capital C...
2014.06.13 - NAEC EDRC Seminar_Macroprudential policy: Banks risk & Capital C...OECD_NAEC
 
Buy-Side System Requirements
Buy-Side System RequirementsBuy-Side System Requirements
Buy-Side System RequirementsQuantifi
 

Tendances (14)

Streamlining Compliance for Community Banks
Streamlining Compliance for Community BanksStreamlining Compliance for Community Banks
Streamlining Compliance for Community Banks
 
Mergers and acquisitions in the banking sector: the role of the institutional...
Mergers and acquisitions in the banking sector: the role of the institutional...Mergers and acquisitions in the banking sector: the role of the institutional...
Mergers and acquisitions in the banking sector: the role of the institutional...
 
Cómo converger hacia un informe integral en la empresa
Cómo converger hacia un informe integral en la empresaCómo converger hacia un informe integral en la empresa
Cómo converger hacia un informe integral en la empresa
 
The Role of Compliance in Government Enforcement
The Role of Compliance in Government EnforcementThe Role of Compliance in Government Enforcement
The Role of Compliance in Government Enforcement
 
Analysing the issue of mis selling of financial products in the uk
Analysing the issue of mis selling of financial products in the ukAnalysing the issue of mis selling of financial products in the uk
Analysing the issue of mis selling of financial products in the uk
 
Chapter 11 b :Financial Statement fraud
Chapter 11 b :Financial Statement fraud Chapter 11 b :Financial Statement fraud
Chapter 11 b :Financial Statement fraud
 
Non-investment Issues In Manager Evaluation - A Brief Overview
Non-investment Issues In Manager Evaluation - A Brief OverviewNon-investment Issues In Manager Evaluation - A Brief Overview
Non-investment Issues In Manager Evaluation - A Brief Overview
 
Ch 10 IM
Ch 10 IMCh 10 IM
Ch 10 IM
 
Access to Finance
Access to Finance Access to Finance
Access to Finance
 
FM&INSTITUTES
FM&INSTITUTESFM&INSTITUTES
FM&INSTITUTES
 
Taking the road to advanced approaches and heightened standards in risk manag...
Taking the road to advanced approaches and heightened standards in risk manag...Taking the road to advanced approaches and heightened standards in risk manag...
Taking the road to advanced approaches and heightened standards in risk manag...
 
2014.06.13 - NAEC EDRC Seminar_Macroprudential policy: Banks risk & Capital C...
2014.06.13 - NAEC EDRC Seminar_Macroprudential policy: Banks risk & Capital C...2014.06.13 - NAEC EDRC Seminar_Macroprudential policy: Banks risk & Capital C...
2014.06.13 - NAEC EDRC Seminar_Macroprudential policy: Banks risk & Capital C...
 
Chap001
Chap001Chap001
Chap001
 
Buy-Side System Requirements
Buy-Side System RequirementsBuy-Side System Requirements
Buy-Side System Requirements
 

Similaire à Mon 300 Dorotinsky

Dorotinsky public financial management trends and lessons
Dorotinsky public financial management trends and lessonsDorotinsky public financial management trends and lessons
Dorotinsky public financial management trends and lessonsicgfmconference
 
Grant Thornton Banking Regulation: unravelling the regulatory spaghetti - mar...
Grant Thornton Banking Regulation: unravelling the regulatory spaghetti - mar...Grant Thornton Banking Regulation: unravelling the regulatory spaghetti - mar...
Grant Thornton Banking Regulation: unravelling the regulatory spaghetti - mar...theitchik
 
Ruffner Fallacy of Best Practice
Ruffner Fallacy of Best PracticeRuffner Fallacy of Best Practice
Ruffner Fallacy of Best Practiceicgfmconference
 
Day1 sp1 icgfm-conference_miamimay2014_richardallen_en
Day1 sp1 icgfm-conference_miamimay2014_richardallen_enDay1 sp1 icgfm-conference_miamimay2014_richardallen_en
Day1 sp1 icgfm-conference_miamimay2014_richardallen_enicgfmconference
 
Follow up actions by donors and countries, the case of pefa
Follow up actions by donors and countries, the case of pefaFollow up actions by donors and countries, the case of pefa
Follow up actions by donors and countries, the case of pefaicgfmconference
 
Are public financial management reforms yielding results in the Region? - Dun...
Are public financial management reforms yielding results in the Region? - Dun...Are public financial management reforms yielding results in the Region? - Dun...
Are public financial management reforms yielding results in the Region? - Dun...OECD Governance
 
Government accounting and financial reporting in Latin America: The state of ...
Government accounting and financial reporting in Latin America: The state of ...Government accounting and financial reporting in Latin America: The state of ...
Government accounting and financial reporting in Latin America: The state of ...OECD Governance
 
Pfm reform and_donor_funding_in_post-conflict-fisc
Pfm reform and_donor_funding_in_post-conflict-fiscPfm reform and_donor_funding_in_post-conflict-fisc
Pfm reform and_donor_funding_in_post-conflict-fiscFreeBalance
 
Automating Good Governance through Government Resource Planning software
Automating Good Governance through Government Resource Planning softwareAutomating Good Governance through Government Resource Planning software
Automating Good Governance through Government Resource Planning softwareFreeBalance
 
EY Global Insurance CFO Survey
EY Global Insurance CFO SurveyEY Global Insurance CFO Survey
EY Global Insurance CFO SurveyEY
 
How are Banks Turning Regulatory Compliance into An Opportunity.pdf
How are Banks Turning Regulatory Compliance into An Opportunity.pdfHow are Banks Turning Regulatory Compliance into An Opportunity.pdf
How are Banks Turning Regulatory Compliance into An Opportunity.pdfMaveric Systems
 
Public Budgeting and The Dynamics of Changing Budget Process
Public Budgeting and The Dynamics of Changing Budget ProcessPublic Budgeting and The Dynamics of Changing Budget Process
Public Budgeting and The Dynamics of Changing Budget ProcessThe University of Texas (UTRGV)
 
The four dimensions of public financial management
The four dimensions of public financial managementThe four dimensions of public financial management
The four dimensions of public financial managementicgfmconference
 
2 bill intl trend in pfm reforms
2 bill intl trend in pfm reforms2 bill intl trend in pfm reforms
2 bill intl trend in pfm reformssurardi12
 
2 bill intl trend in pfm reforms
2 bill intl trend in pfm reforms2 bill intl trend in pfm reforms
2 bill intl trend in pfm reformsZaidan Nirza Hassan
 
EY Take 5.pdf
EY Take 5.pdfEY Take 5.pdf
EY Take 5.pdfBC Chew
 
Accenture 2015 Global Structural Reform Study: Unlocking the Potential of Glo...
Accenture 2015 Global Structural Reform Study: Unlocking the Potential of Glo...Accenture 2015 Global Structural Reform Study: Unlocking the Potential of Glo...
Accenture 2015 Global Structural Reform Study: Unlocking the Potential of Glo...Accenture Insurance
 
Blome - Translating supply chain finance into SME productivity
Blome - Translating supply chain finance into SME productivityBlome - Translating supply chain finance into SME productivity
Blome - Translating supply chain finance into SME productivityOECD CFE
 

Similaire à Mon 300 Dorotinsky (20)

Dorotinsky public financial management trends and lessons
Dorotinsky public financial management trends and lessonsDorotinsky public financial management trends and lessons
Dorotinsky public financial management trends and lessons
 
Grant Thornton Banking Regulation: unravelling the regulatory spaghetti - mar...
Grant Thornton Banking Regulation: unravelling the regulatory spaghetti - mar...Grant Thornton Banking Regulation: unravelling the regulatory spaghetti - mar...
Grant Thornton Banking Regulation: unravelling the regulatory spaghetti - mar...
 
Ruffner Fallacy of Best Practice
Ruffner Fallacy of Best PracticeRuffner Fallacy of Best Practice
Ruffner Fallacy of Best Practice
 
Nikolai malyshev
Nikolai malyshevNikolai malyshev
Nikolai malyshev
 
Day1 sp1 icgfm-conference_miamimay2014_richardallen_en
Day1 sp1 icgfm-conference_miamimay2014_richardallen_enDay1 sp1 icgfm-conference_miamimay2014_richardallen_en
Day1 sp1 icgfm-conference_miamimay2014_richardallen_en
 
Follow up actions by donors and countries, the case of pefa
Follow up actions by donors and countries, the case of pefaFollow up actions by donors and countries, the case of pefa
Follow up actions by donors and countries, the case of pefa
 
Are public financial management reforms yielding results in the Region? - Dun...
Are public financial management reforms yielding results in the Region? - Dun...Are public financial management reforms yielding results in the Region? - Dun...
Are public financial management reforms yielding results in the Region? - Dun...
 
Government accounting and financial reporting in Latin America: The state of ...
Government accounting and financial reporting in Latin America: The state of ...Government accounting and financial reporting in Latin America: The state of ...
Government accounting and financial reporting in Latin America: The state of ...
 
Pfm reform and_donor_funding_in_post-conflict-fisc
Pfm reform and_donor_funding_in_post-conflict-fiscPfm reform and_donor_funding_in_post-conflict-fisc
Pfm reform and_donor_funding_in_post-conflict-fisc
 
Automating Good Governance through Government Resource Planning software
Automating Good Governance through Government Resource Planning softwareAutomating Good Governance through Government Resource Planning software
Automating Good Governance through Government Resource Planning software
 
EY Global Insurance CFO Survey
EY Global Insurance CFO SurveyEY Global Insurance CFO Survey
EY Global Insurance CFO Survey
 
How are Banks Turning Regulatory Compliance into An Opportunity.pdf
How are Banks Turning Regulatory Compliance into An Opportunity.pdfHow are Banks Turning Regulatory Compliance into An Opportunity.pdf
How are Banks Turning Regulatory Compliance into An Opportunity.pdf
 
Public Budgeting and The Dynamics of Changing Budget Process
Public Budgeting and The Dynamics of Changing Budget ProcessPublic Budgeting and The Dynamics of Changing Budget Process
Public Budgeting and The Dynamics of Changing Budget Process
 
The four dimensions of public financial management
The four dimensions of public financial managementThe four dimensions of public financial management
The four dimensions of public financial management
 
2 bill intl trend in pfm reforms
2 bill intl trend in pfm reforms2 bill intl trend in pfm reforms
2 bill intl trend in pfm reforms
 
2 bill intl trend in pfm reforms
2 bill intl trend in pfm reforms2 bill intl trend in pfm reforms
2 bill intl trend in pfm reforms
 
EY Take 5.pdf
EY Take 5.pdfEY Take 5.pdf
EY Take 5.pdf
 
Accenture 2015 Global Structural Reform Study: Unlocking the Potential of Glo...
Accenture 2015 Global Structural Reform Study: Unlocking the Potential of Glo...Accenture 2015 Global Structural Reform Study: Unlocking the Potential of Glo...
Accenture 2015 Global Structural Reform Study: Unlocking the Potential of Glo...
 
Mon 130 Angelovska
Mon 130 AngelovskaMon 130 Angelovska
Mon 130 Angelovska
 
Blome - Translating supply chain finance into SME productivity
Blome - Translating supply chain finance into SME productivityBlome - Translating supply chain finance into SME productivity
Blome - Translating supply chain finance into SME productivity
 

Plus de icgfmconference

2015 closing remarks_winter_conference_icgfm_maykoski_fr
2015 closing remarks_winter_conference_icgfm_maykoski_fr2015 closing remarks_winter_conference_icgfm_maykoski_fr
2015 closing remarks_winter_conference_icgfm_maykoski_fricgfmconference
 
2015 closing remarks_winter_conference_icgfm_maykoski_sp
2015 closing remarks_winter_conference_icgfm_maykoski_sp2015 closing remarks_winter_conference_icgfm_maykoski_sp
2015 closing remarks_winter_conference_icgfm_maykoski_spicgfmconference
 
2015 closing remarks winter_conference_icgfm_maykoski_en
2015 closing remarks winter_conference_icgfm_maykoski_en2015 closing remarks winter_conference_icgfm_maykoski_en
2015 closing remarks winter_conference_icgfm_maykoski_enicgfmconference
 
Day3 sp4 chemonics-icgfm_dec2015_fr
Day3 sp4 chemonics-icgfm_dec2015_frDay3 sp4 chemonics-icgfm_dec2015_fr
Day3 sp4 chemonics-icgfm_dec2015_fricgfmconference
 
Day3 sp4 chemonics-icgfm_dec2015_sp
Day3 sp4 chemonics-icgfm_dec2015_spDay3 sp4 chemonics-icgfm_dec2015_sp
Day3 sp4 chemonics-icgfm_dec2015_spicgfmconference
 
Day3 sp4 chemonics-icgfm_dec2015_en
Day3 sp4 chemonics-icgfm_dec2015_enDay3 sp4 chemonics-icgfm_dec2015_en
Day3 sp4 chemonics-icgfm_dec2015_enicgfmconference
 
Day3 sp3-3 georgetown-panelandreamurta_en
Day3 sp3-3 georgetown-panelandreamurta_enDay3 sp3-3 georgetown-panelandreamurta_en
Day3 sp3-3 georgetown-panelandreamurta_enicgfmconference
 
Day3 sp3-4 georgetown-panelyonatonmorse_en
Day3 sp3-4 georgetown-panelyonatonmorse_enDay3 sp3-4 georgetown-panelyonatonmorse_en
Day3 sp3-4 georgetown-panelyonatonmorse_enicgfmconference
 
Day3 sp3-2 georgetown-paneltomcardamone_en
Day3 sp3-2 georgetown-paneltomcardamone_enDay3 sp3-2 georgetown-paneltomcardamone_en
Day3 sp3-2 georgetown-paneltomcardamone_enicgfmconference
 
Day3 sp3-1 georgetown-paneljodivittori_en
Day3 sp3-1 georgetown-paneljodivittori_enDay3 sp3-1 georgetown-paneljodivittori_en
Day3 sp3-1 georgetown-paneljodivittori_enicgfmconference
 
Day3 sp2 nov 6 draft icgfm-wuertz_fr
Day3 sp2 nov 6 draft icgfm-wuertz_frDay3 sp2 nov 6 draft icgfm-wuertz_fr
Day3 sp2 nov 6 draft icgfm-wuertz_fricgfmconference
 
Day3 sp2 nov 6 draft icgfm-wuertz_sp
Day3 sp2 nov 6 draft icgfm-wuertz_spDay3 sp2 nov 6 draft icgfm-wuertz_sp
Day3 sp2 nov 6 draft icgfm-wuertz_spicgfmconference
 
Day3 sp2 nov 6 draft icgfm-wuertz_en
Day3 sp2 nov 6 draft icgfm-wuertz_enDay3 sp2 nov 6 draft icgfm-wuertz_en
Day3 sp2 nov 6 draft icgfm-wuertz_enicgfmconference
 
Day3 sp1 wright-membership_benefits_dec2015_fr
Day3 sp1 wright-membership_benefits_dec2015_frDay3 sp1 wright-membership_benefits_dec2015_fr
Day3 sp1 wright-membership_benefits_dec2015_fricgfmconference
 
Day3 sp1 wright-membership_benefits_dec2015_sp
Day3 sp1 wright-membership_benefits_dec2015_spDay3 sp1 wright-membership_benefits_dec2015_sp
Day3 sp1 wright-membership_benefits_dec2015_spicgfmconference
 
Day3 sp1 wright-membership_benefits_dec2015_en
Day3 sp1 wright-membership_benefits_dec2015_enDay3 sp1 wright-membership_benefits_dec2015_en
Day3 sp1 wright-membership_benefits_dec2015_enicgfmconference
 
Day2 sp5 23.10.2015-presentation-stateaid_taxationanddevelopmentinukraine_ief...
Day2 sp5 23.10.2015-presentation-stateaid_taxationanddevelopmentinukraine_ief...Day2 sp5 23.10.2015-presentation-stateaid_taxationanddevelopmentinukraine_ief...
Day2 sp5 23.10.2015-presentation-stateaid_taxationanddevelopmentinukraine_ief...icgfmconference
 
Day2 sp5 23.10.2015-presentation-stateaid_taxationanddevelopmentinukraine_ief...
Day2 sp5 23.10.2015-presentation-stateaid_taxationanddevelopmentinukraine_ief...Day2 sp5 23.10.2015-presentation-stateaid_taxationanddevelopmentinukraine_ief...
Day2 sp5 23.10.2015-presentation-stateaid_taxationanddevelopmentinukraine_ief...icgfmconference
 
Day2 sp5 23.10.2015-presentation-stateaid_taxationanddevelopmentinukraine_ief...
Day2 sp5 23.10.2015-presentation-stateaid_taxationanddevelopmentinukraine_ief...Day2 sp5 23.10.2015-presentation-stateaid_taxationanddevelopmentinukraine_ief...
Day2 sp5 23.10.2015-presentation-stateaid_taxationanddevelopmentinukraine_ief...icgfmconference
 
Day2 sp4 pres-washington_elettore_en
Day2 sp4 pres-washington_elettore_enDay2 sp4 pres-washington_elettore_en
Day2 sp4 pres-washington_elettore_enicgfmconference
 

Plus de icgfmconference (20)

2015 closing remarks_winter_conference_icgfm_maykoski_fr
2015 closing remarks_winter_conference_icgfm_maykoski_fr2015 closing remarks_winter_conference_icgfm_maykoski_fr
2015 closing remarks_winter_conference_icgfm_maykoski_fr
 
2015 closing remarks_winter_conference_icgfm_maykoski_sp
2015 closing remarks_winter_conference_icgfm_maykoski_sp2015 closing remarks_winter_conference_icgfm_maykoski_sp
2015 closing remarks_winter_conference_icgfm_maykoski_sp
 
2015 closing remarks winter_conference_icgfm_maykoski_en
2015 closing remarks winter_conference_icgfm_maykoski_en2015 closing remarks winter_conference_icgfm_maykoski_en
2015 closing remarks winter_conference_icgfm_maykoski_en
 
Day3 sp4 chemonics-icgfm_dec2015_fr
Day3 sp4 chemonics-icgfm_dec2015_frDay3 sp4 chemonics-icgfm_dec2015_fr
Day3 sp4 chemonics-icgfm_dec2015_fr
 
Day3 sp4 chemonics-icgfm_dec2015_sp
Day3 sp4 chemonics-icgfm_dec2015_spDay3 sp4 chemonics-icgfm_dec2015_sp
Day3 sp4 chemonics-icgfm_dec2015_sp
 
Day3 sp4 chemonics-icgfm_dec2015_en
Day3 sp4 chemonics-icgfm_dec2015_enDay3 sp4 chemonics-icgfm_dec2015_en
Day3 sp4 chemonics-icgfm_dec2015_en
 
Day3 sp3-3 georgetown-panelandreamurta_en
Day3 sp3-3 georgetown-panelandreamurta_enDay3 sp3-3 georgetown-panelandreamurta_en
Day3 sp3-3 georgetown-panelandreamurta_en
 
Day3 sp3-4 georgetown-panelyonatonmorse_en
Day3 sp3-4 georgetown-panelyonatonmorse_enDay3 sp3-4 georgetown-panelyonatonmorse_en
Day3 sp3-4 georgetown-panelyonatonmorse_en
 
Day3 sp3-2 georgetown-paneltomcardamone_en
Day3 sp3-2 georgetown-paneltomcardamone_enDay3 sp3-2 georgetown-paneltomcardamone_en
Day3 sp3-2 georgetown-paneltomcardamone_en
 
Day3 sp3-1 georgetown-paneljodivittori_en
Day3 sp3-1 georgetown-paneljodivittori_enDay3 sp3-1 georgetown-paneljodivittori_en
Day3 sp3-1 georgetown-paneljodivittori_en
 
Day3 sp2 nov 6 draft icgfm-wuertz_fr
Day3 sp2 nov 6 draft icgfm-wuertz_frDay3 sp2 nov 6 draft icgfm-wuertz_fr
Day3 sp2 nov 6 draft icgfm-wuertz_fr
 
Day3 sp2 nov 6 draft icgfm-wuertz_sp
Day3 sp2 nov 6 draft icgfm-wuertz_spDay3 sp2 nov 6 draft icgfm-wuertz_sp
Day3 sp2 nov 6 draft icgfm-wuertz_sp
 
Day3 sp2 nov 6 draft icgfm-wuertz_en
Day3 sp2 nov 6 draft icgfm-wuertz_enDay3 sp2 nov 6 draft icgfm-wuertz_en
Day3 sp2 nov 6 draft icgfm-wuertz_en
 
Day3 sp1 wright-membership_benefits_dec2015_fr
Day3 sp1 wright-membership_benefits_dec2015_frDay3 sp1 wright-membership_benefits_dec2015_fr
Day3 sp1 wright-membership_benefits_dec2015_fr
 
Day3 sp1 wright-membership_benefits_dec2015_sp
Day3 sp1 wright-membership_benefits_dec2015_spDay3 sp1 wright-membership_benefits_dec2015_sp
Day3 sp1 wright-membership_benefits_dec2015_sp
 
Day3 sp1 wright-membership_benefits_dec2015_en
Day3 sp1 wright-membership_benefits_dec2015_enDay3 sp1 wright-membership_benefits_dec2015_en
Day3 sp1 wright-membership_benefits_dec2015_en
 
Day2 sp5 23.10.2015-presentation-stateaid_taxationanddevelopmentinukraine_ief...
Day2 sp5 23.10.2015-presentation-stateaid_taxationanddevelopmentinukraine_ief...Day2 sp5 23.10.2015-presentation-stateaid_taxationanddevelopmentinukraine_ief...
Day2 sp5 23.10.2015-presentation-stateaid_taxationanddevelopmentinukraine_ief...
 
Day2 sp5 23.10.2015-presentation-stateaid_taxationanddevelopmentinukraine_ief...
Day2 sp5 23.10.2015-presentation-stateaid_taxationanddevelopmentinukraine_ief...Day2 sp5 23.10.2015-presentation-stateaid_taxationanddevelopmentinukraine_ief...
Day2 sp5 23.10.2015-presentation-stateaid_taxationanddevelopmentinukraine_ief...
 
Day2 sp5 23.10.2015-presentation-stateaid_taxationanddevelopmentinukraine_ief...
Day2 sp5 23.10.2015-presentation-stateaid_taxationanddevelopmentinukraine_ief...Day2 sp5 23.10.2015-presentation-stateaid_taxationanddevelopmentinukraine_ief...
Day2 sp5 23.10.2015-presentation-stateaid_taxationanddevelopmentinukraine_ief...
 
Day2 sp4 pres-washington_elettore_en
Day2 sp4 pres-washington_elettore_enDay2 sp4 pres-washington_elettore_en
Day2 sp4 pres-washington_elettore_en
 

Dernier

In Sharjah ௵(+971)558539980 *_௵abortion pills now available.
In Sharjah ௵(+971)558539980 *_௵abortion pills now available.In Sharjah ௵(+971)558539980 *_௵abortion pills now available.
In Sharjah ௵(+971)558539980 *_௵abortion pills now available.hyt3577
 
Turbhe Fantastic Escorts📞📞9833754194 Kopar Khairane Marathi Call Girls-Kopar ...
Turbhe Fantastic Escorts📞📞9833754194 Kopar Khairane Marathi Call Girls-Kopar ...Turbhe Fantastic Escorts📞📞9833754194 Kopar Khairane Marathi Call Girls-Kopar ...
Turbhe Fantastic Escorts📞📞9833754194 Kopar Khairane Marathi Call Girls-Kopar ...priyasharma62062
 
Call Girls in Benson Town / 8250092165 Genuine Call girls with real Photos an...
Call Girls in Benson Town / 8250092165 Genuine Call girls with real Photos an...Call Girls in Benson Town / 8250092165 Genuine Call girls with real Photos an...
Call Girls in Benson Town / 8250092165 Genuine Call girls with real Photos an...kajal
 
Fixed exchange rate and flexible exchange rate.pptx
Fixed exchange rate and flexible exchange rate.pptxFixed exchange rate and flexible exchange rate.pptx
Fixed exchange rate and flexible exchange rate.pptxTintoTom3
 
Strategic Resources May 2024 Corporate Presentation
Strategic Resources May 2024 Corporate PresentationStrategic Resources May 2024 Corporate Presentation
Strategic Resources May 2024 Corporate PresentationAdnet Communications
 
✂️ 👅 Independent Bhubaneswar Escorts Odisha Call Girls With Room Bhubaneswar ...
✂️ 👅 Independent Bhubaneswar Escorts Odisha Call Girls With Room Bhubaneswar ...✂️ 👅 Independent Bhubaneswar Escorts Odisha Call Girls With Room Bhubaneswar ...
✂️ 👅 Independent Bhubaneswar Escorts Odisha Call Girls With Room Bhubaneswar ...Call Girls Mumbai
 
Significant AI Trends for the Financial Industry in 2024 and How to Utilize Them
Significant AI Trends for the Financial Industry in 2024 and How to Utilize ThemSignificant AI Trends for the Financial Industry in 2024 and How to Utilize Them
Significant AI Trends for the Financial Industry in 2024 and How to Utilize Them360factors
 
Bhubaneswar🌹Kalpana Mesuem ❤CALL GIRLS 9777949614 💟 CALL GIRLS IN bhubaneswa...
Bhubaneswar🌹Kalpana Mesuem  ❤CALL GIRLS 9777949614 💟 CALL GIRLS IN bhubaneswa...Bhubaneswar🌹Kalpana Mesuem  ❤CALL GIRLS 9777949614 💟 CALL GIRLS IN bhubaneswa...
Bhubaneswar🌹Kalpana Mesuem ❤CALL GIRLS 9777949614 💟 CALL GIRLS IN bhubaneswa...Call Girls Mumbai
 
Escorts Indore Call Girls-9155612368-Vijay Nagar Decent Fantastic Call Girls ...
Escorts Indore Call Girls-9155612368-Vijay Nagar Decent Fantastic Call Girls ...Escorts Indore Call Girls-9155612368-Vijay Nagar Decent Fantastic Call Girls ...
Escorts Indore Call Girls-9155612368-Vijay Nagar Decent Fantastic Call Girls ...sanakhan51485
 
Call Girls Howrah ( 8250092165 ) Cheap rates call girls | Get low budget
Call Girls Howrah ( 8250092165 ) Cheap rates call girls | Get low budgetCall Girls Howrah ( 8250092165 ) Cheap rates call girls | Get low budget
Call Girls Howrah ( 8250092165 ) Cheap rates call girls | Get low budgetSareena Khatun
 
Webinar on E-Invoicing for Fintech Belgium
Webinar on E-Invoicing for Fintech BelgiumWebinar on E-Invoicing for Fintech Belgium
Webinar on E-Invoicing for Fintech BelgiumFinTech Belgium
 
Explore Dual Citizenship in Africa | Citizenship Benefits & Requirements
Explore Dual Citizenship in Africa | Citizenship Benefits & RequirementsExplore Dual Citizenship in Africa | Citizenship Benefits & Requirements
Explore Dual Citizenship in Africa | Citizenship Benefits & Requirementsmarketingkingdomofku
 
Premium Call Girls Bangalore Call Girls Service Just Call 🍑👄6378878445 🍑👄 Top...
Premium Call Girls Bangalore Call Girls Service Just Call 🍑👄6378878445 🍑👄 Top...Premium Call Girls Bangalore Call Girls Service Just Call 🍑👄6378878445 🍑👄 Top...
Premium Call Girls Bangalore Call Girls Service Just Call 🍑👄6378878445 🍑👄 Top...vershagrag
 
CBD Belapur((Thane)) Charming Call Girls📞❤9833754194 Kamothe Beautiful Call G...
CBD Belapur((Thane)) Charming Call Girls📞❤9833754194 Kamothe Beautiful Call G...CBD Belapur((Thane)) Charming Call Girls📞❤9833754194 Kamothe Beautiful Call G...
CBD Belapur((Thane)) Charming Call Girls📞❤9833754194 Kamothe Beautiful Call G...priyasharma62062
 
Female Escorts Service in Hyderabad Starting with 5000/- for Savita Escorts S...
Female Escorts Service in Hyderabad Starting with 5000/- for Savita Escorts S...Female Escorts Service in Hyderabad Starting with 5000/- for Savita Escorts S...
Female Escorts Service in Hyderabad Starting with 5000/- for Savita Escorts S...kajalverma014
 
Collecting banker, Capacity of collecting Banker, conditions under section 13...
Collecting banker, Capacity of collecting Banker, conditions under section 13...Collecting banker, Capacity of collecting Banker, conditions under section 13...
Collecting banker, Capacity of collecting Banker, conditions under section 13...RaniT11
 
Test bank for advanced assessment interpreting findings and formulating diffe...
Test bank for advanced assessment interpreting findings and formulating diffe...Test bank for advanced assessment interpreting findings and formulating diffe...
Test bank for advanced assessment interpreting findings and formulating diffe...robinsonayot
 
Certified Kala Jadu, Black magic specialist in Rawalpindi and Bangali Amil ba...
Certified Kala Jadu, Black magic specialist in Rawalpindi and Bangali Amil ba...Certified Kala Jadu, Black magic specialist in Rawalpindi and Bangali Amil ba...
Certified Kala Jadu, Black magic specialist in Rawalpindi and Bangali Amil ba...batoole333
 
Solution Manual For Financial Statement Analysis, 13th Edition By Charles H. ...
Solution Manual For Financial Statement Analysis, 13th Edition By Charles H. ...Solution Manual For Financial Statement Analysis, 13th Edition By Charles H. ...
Solution Manual For Financial Statement Analysis, 13th Edition By Charles H. ...rightmanforbloodline
 
Famous No1 Amil Baba Love marriage Astrologer Specialist Expert In Pakistan a...
Famous No1 Amil Baba Love marriage Astrologer Specialist Expert In Pakistan a...Famous No1 Amil Baba Love marriage Astrologer Specialist Expert In Pakistan a...
Famous No1 Amil Baba Love marriage Astrologer Specialist Expert In Pakistan a...janibaber266
 

Dernier (20)

In Sharjah ௵(+971)558539980 *_௵abortion pills now available.
In Sharjah ௵(+971)558539980 *_௵abortion pills now available.In Sharjah ௵(+971)558539980 *_௵abortion pills now available.
In Sharjah ௵(+971)558539980 *_௵abortion pills now available.
 
Turbhe Fantastic Escorts📞📞9833754194 Kopar Khairane Marathi Call Girls-Kopar ...
Turbhe Fantastic Escorts📞📞9833754194 Kopar Khairane Marathi Call Girls-Kopar ...Turbhe Fantastic Escorts📞📞9833754194 Kopar Khairane Marathi Call Girls-Kopar ...
Turbhe Fantastic Escorts📞📞9833754194 Kopar Khairane Marathi Call Girls-Kopar ...
 
Call Girls in Benson Town / 8250092165 Genuine Call girls with real Photos an...
Call Girls in Benson Town / 8250092165 Genuine Call girls with real Photos an...Call Girls in Benson Town / 8250092165 Genuine Call girls with real Photos an...
Call Girls in Benson Town / 8250092165 Genuine Call girls with real Photos an...
 
Fixed exchange rate and flexible exchange rate.pptx
Fixed exchange rate and flexible exchange rate.pptxFixed exchange rate and flexible exchange rate.pptx
Fixed exchange rate and flexible exchange rate.pptx
 
Strategic Resources May 2024 Corporate Presentation
Strategic Resources May 2024 Corporate PresentationStrategic Resources May 2024 Corporate Presentation
Strategic Resources May 2024 Corporate Presentation
 
✂️ 👅 Independent Bhubaneswar Escorts Odisha Call Girls With Room Bhubaneswar ...
✂️ 👅 Independent Bhubaneswar Escorts Odisha Call Girls With Room Bhubaneswar ...✂️ 👅 Independent Bhubaneswar Escorts Odisha Call Girls With Room Bhubaneswar ...
✂️ 👅 Independent Bhubaneswar Escorts Odisha Call Girls With Room Bhubaneswar ...
 
Significant AI Trends for the Financial Industry in 2024 and How to Utilize Them
Significant AI Trends for the Financial Industry in 2024 and How to Utilize ThemSignificant AI Trends for the Financial Industry in 2024 and How to Utilize Them
Significant AI Trends for the Financial Industry in 2024 and How to Utilize Them
 
Bhubaneswar🌹Kalpana Mesuem ❤CALL GIRLS 9777949614 💟 CALL GIRLS IN bhubaneswa...
Bhubaneswar🌹Kalpana Mesuem  ❤CALL GIRLS 9777949614 💟 CALL GIRLS IN bhubaneswa...Bhubaneswar🌹Kalpana Mesuem  ❤CALL GIRLS 9777949614 💟 CALL GIRLS IN bhubaneswa...
Bhubaneswar🌹Kalpana Mesuem ❤CALL GIRLS 9777949614 💟 CALL GIRLS IN bhubaneswa...
 
Escorts Indore Call Girls-9155612368-Vijay Nagar Decent Fantastic Call Girls ...
Escorts Indore Call Girls-9155612368-Vijay Nagar Decent Fantastic Call Girls ...Escorts Indore Call Girls-9155612368-Vijay Nagar Decent Fantastic Call Girls ...
Escorts Indore Call Girls-9155612368-Vijay Nagar Decent Fantastic Call Girls ...
 
Call Girls Howrah ( 8250092165 ) Cheap rates call girls | Get low budget
Call Girls Howrah ( 8250092165 ) Cheap rates call girls | Get low budgetCall Girls Howrah ( 8250092165 ) Cheap rates call girls | Get low budget
Call Girls Howrah ( 8250092165 ) Cheap rates call girls | Get low budget
 
Webinar on E-Invoicing for Fintech Belgium
Webinar on E-Invoicing for Fintech BelgiumWebinar on E-Invoicing for Fintech Belgium
Webinar on E-Invoicing for Fintech Belgium
 
Explore Dual Citizenship in Africa | Citizenship Benefits & Requirements
Explore Dual Citizenship in Africa | Citizenship Benefits & RequirementsExplore Dual Citizenship in Africa | Citizenship Benefits & Requirements
Explore Dual Citizenship in Africa | Citizenship Benefits & Requirements
 
Premium Call Girls Bangalore Call Girls Service Just Call 🍑👄6378878445 🍑👄 Top...
Premium Call Girls Bangalore Call Girls Service Just Call 🍑👄6378878445 🍑👄 Top...Premium Call Girls Bangalore Call Girls Service Just Call 🍑👄6378878445 🍑👄 Top...
Premium Call Girls Bangalore Call Girls Service Just Call 🍑👄6378878445 🍑👄 Top...
 
CBD Belapur((Thane)) Charming Call Girls📞❤9833754194 Kamothe Beautiful Call G...
CBD Belapur((Thane)) Charming Call Girls📞❤9833754194 Kamothe Beautiful Call G...CBD Belapur((Thane)) Charming Call Girls📞❤9833754194 Kamothe Beautiful Call G...
CBD Belapur((Thane)) Charming Call Girls📞❤9833754194 Kamothe Beautiful Call G...
 
Female Escorts Service in Hyderabad Starting with 5000/- for Savita Escorts S...
Female Escorts Service in Hyderabad Starting with 5000/- for Savita Escorts S...Female Escorts Service in Hyderabad Starting with 5000/- for Savita Escorts S...
Female Escorts Service in Hyderabad Starting with 5000/- for Savita Escorts S...
 
Collecting banker, Capacity of collecting Banker, conditions under section 13...
Collecting banker, Capacity of collecting Banker, conditions under section 13...Collecting banker, Capacity of collecting Banker, conditions under section 13...
Collecting banker, Capacity of collecting Banker, conditions under section 13...
 
Test bank for advanced assessment interpreting findings and formulating diffe...
Test bank for advanced assessment interpreting findings and formulating diffe...Test bank for advanced assessment interpreting findings and formulating diffe...
Test bank for advanced assessment interpreting findings and formulating diffe...
 
Certified Kala Jadu, Black magic specialist in Rawalpindi and Bangali Amil ba...
Certified Kala Jadu, Black magic specialist in Rawalpindi and Bangali Amil ba...Certified Kala Jadu, Black magic specialist in Rawalpindi and Bangali Amil ba...
Certified Kala Jadu, Black magic specialist in Rawalpindi and Bangali Amil ba...
 
Solution Manual For Financial Statement Analysis, 13th Edition By Charles H. ...
Solution Manual For Financial Statement Analysis, 13th Edition By Charles H. ...Solution Manual For Financial Statement Analysis, 13th Edition By Charles H. ...
Solution Manual For Financial Statement Analysis, 13th Edition By Charles H. ...
 
Famous No1 Amil Baba Love marriage Astrologer Specialist Expert In Pakistan a...
Famous No1 Amil Baba Love marriage Astrologer Specialist Expert In Pakistan a...Famous No1 Amil Baba Love marriage Astrologer Specialist Expert In Pakistan a...
Famous No1 Amil Baba Love marriage Astrologer Specialist Expert In Pakistan a...
 

Mon 300 Dorotinsky

  • 1. Public Financial Management Reform: Trends and Lessons Bill Dorotinsky World Bank ICGFM December 2008 Washington, D.C.
  • 2.
  • 3. Popular Reforms Recommended reforms generally try to change incentives by changing rules, roles and information   External audit ? ? ? Accrual Accounting  Internal control/audit  Procurement    Reporting/ Transparency    Budget classification, chart of account   Treasury Single Account  Fiscal Responsibility Laws   IFMIS, automation   Performance, Program budgeting    Medium-Term Expenditure Frameworks Operational Efficiency Strategic Allocation Macrofiscal Discipline
  • 4.
  • 5.
  • 6.
  • 7. Budget Formulation Recent Reform Emphasis Different drivers of reforms confuse the picture. Which are donor-driven? Which country driven? Which address real need? Which are simply fashionable? If higher income enables more self-direction, interesting that performance budgeting of greater interest in upper-middle income countries. * 2006 gross national income (GNI) per capita. The groups are: low income (LIC) US$905 or less; lower middle income (LMIC) US$906–3,595; upper middle income (UMIC) US$3,596–11,115. 23% 21% 9% Capital-Investment Bdgts 38% 15% 23% Performance/Program Budgeting 46% 39% 37% MT Expenditure Framework 31% 45% 29% MT Fiscal Framework UMIC* (13) LMIC* (33) LIC* (35)
  • 8. Budget Execution Recent Reform Emphasis na 12% 14% Procurement na 12% 11% Internal audit/control 15% 9% 17% Payroll/Personnel 23% 42% 40% Accounting/classification 8% 18% 11% Debt management 15% 18% 26% Commitment controls 31% 36% 51% Treasury/Cash management UMIC (13) LMIC (33) LIC (35)
  • 9. Other Reforms Recent Reform Emphasis 23% 15% 26% Decentralization 15% 21% 3% PPPs 15% 30% 20% Transparency 23% 36% 26% Budget Law/Legal 8% 18% 3% MoF Reorganization 23% 36% 49% IFMIS UMIC (13) LMIC (33) LIC (35)
  • 10.