Clinical failures in healthcare systems can occur when:
[1] Systems do not know who needs emergency care, who has dangerous pregnancy complications, or who has tuberculosis due to a lack of monitoring and health information management.
[2] Simple interventions like oxygen mask use and effective waiting areas are not universally implemented across contexts and times.
[3] Community health workers using mobile phones can help address these failures by monitoring patients, ensuring drug and vaccination program resupply, and improving health outcomes in a more cost effective manner.
25. Further Reading.
Introduction to the social scientific view of global health:
Pathologies of Power by Paul Farmer
Community Health Workers:
Rosenthal MM, Greiner JR. The Barefoot Doctors of China: from political creation to professionalization.
Hum Organ. Winter 1982;41(4):330-341
McPake B, Mensah K. Task shifting in health care in resource-poor countries. Lancet. Sep 13
2008;372(9642):870-871.
Singh, P. (2012). One Million Community Health Workers (p. 104).
These stories are related to my experience cofounding Medic Mobile, we’ve undertaken 35 mobile health projects in 20 countries. \n
\n
St Gabriel’s Hospital in Namitete, Malawi\n
A woman carries a child on her back in the traditional manner. \n
A typical home in Malawi. About 80% of Malawi’s population lives in rural areas. \n
This is a photo of the road to a clinic in rural Liberia, where Medic Mobile supports local partner Tiyatien Health. \n\n
Transportation is a health issue. \n
Is the health worker crisis a sign that we haven’t invested enough in clinical biomedicine? Or is at a failure inherent in the system?\n\nInternational notions of biomedical ‘best practices’ structure investment in the individual--a fungible asset that can be appropriated by wealthy countries.\nIn the 1990s there were more Malawian physicians working in Manchester than in Malawi.\n\n\n
Failure to seek medical care and engage in healthy practices is regarded as a major explanation of the failure of clinical biomedicine to improve health outcomes in some countries. This explanation emphasises the shortcomings of patients rather than emphasising the shortcomings of clinical care. \nDecisions to seek medical care are influenced by sense of medical efficacy, perceived and actual self efficacy. \n
\n
\n
\n
\n
How do health workers in Malawi diagnose Malaria?\nMalaria is a mosquito-borne infectious disease of humans and other animals caused by protists (a type of microorganism) of the genus Plasmodium. \n\nThis is a photo of a Plasmodium in the form that enters humans and other vertebrates from the saliva of female mosquitoes (a sporozoite) traverses the cytoplasm of a mosquito midgut epithelial cell.\nhttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Malaria.jpg\n\n\n
Is this technology trustworthy?\n
At what point would you chose to reject biomedicine?\nAlternatives to western medicine--herbal remedies at Lighthouse.\nIs this example a rejection of biomedicine?\n\n
This is Deus, a community health worker in Malawi. \nIn the 1940s Chairman Mao began to critique structures in the biomedical profession that fostered an urban elitism and left the rural poor behind. China sparked the CHW movement with their Barefoot Doctor program, training over 1.7 million farmers by the mid ‘70s.\nIn 2011 the WHO estimated that there were 1.3 million CHWs worldwide, but this is a gross under-estimate. “Task shifting” from physicians to less-trained professionals is widely regarded as a major strategy for improving outcomes in poor areas.\n\n
Many CHW programs emphasize “social” motivation rather than financial compensation. Regardless, managers of CHW programs concern themselves with appropriate training, monitoring, supervision and support.\n
Increasingly mobile phones are being used to coordinate health service delivery. \n
Who is a health worker? “Anyone in a group of people working together to solve a problem.” - Dr. Gwenigale, Minister of Health in Liberia\n
\n
\n
Bangladesh. \n\nSome appendix slides in case people feel like discussing technology and CHW programs.\n
\n
\n
\n
Nepal MCH study.\n
Working with disease surveillance officers, CDC, and WHO, we are building a platform for community-level disease surveillance focused on polio, measles, and pneumonia. The technology also has implications for cholera and tuberculosis tracking.\n