SlideShare une entreprise Scribd logo
1  sur  13
Optimisation of the SPARTAN’S Scramjet Combustor
David Voller
“Astronomy compels the soul to look upward,
and leads us from this world to another.”
- Plato, The Republic, 342 BCE
[1]
Rocket Propulsion
•Current launch systems are dominated by rocket
propulsion
•Current rocket technology is operated close to
theoretical limits [4]
•~65% oxidiser and ~25% fuel mass fractions [3]
•The Saturn V weighed 2.72 million kg
•Liquid Oxygen: 1.81 million kg (~65%)
•Payload: 115000 kg (~4%) [3]
[2]
Scramjets For Access To Space
•Proposed use of airbreathing propulsion
•Takes advantage of increased specific impulse
•The idea of using scramjets for access to space systems
has been around since the mid 20th century [3]
•UQ’s Centre for Hypersonics has been developing the
SPARTAN which will take advantage of the rocket-
scramjet-rocket access to space system [6]
[5]
Scramjets: How do they work?
•Kinetic energy converts to internal energy
through oblique shocks
•Increases pressure, density, and temperature
of flow
•Compressed flow is mixed with injected fuel,
generally hydrogen
•Combustion, spontaneous or ignitors used
•Expansion to accelerate supersonic flow [3]
[7]
SPARTAN
•A feasibility study which investigated a rocket-
scramjet-rocket system was conducted in 2009 [8]
•Concluded that approximately 100kg could be
delivered to a 200km equatorial orbit with a mass
payload fraction of approximately 1.5% [8]
•Further design iterations suggest a payload mass
fraction of 1.26% for a launch taking 260kg to sun
synchronous orbit [9]
•SPARTAN 11.4% fuel mass, conventional rocket
systems ~90% fuel mass [9]
[6]
SPARTAN Scramjet Designs
•Re-usable second stage which is based on winged cone vehicle
(WCV) developed by the US National Aerospace Plane Program [9]
•Initial design uses RESTM12 Engine: start up Mach number of 6 [8]
•Further design iterations see the development of an inlet
optimised for the WCV (C-REST), the trajectory, and first and third
stages
•Further optimisation of the second stage scramjet engine will
mature the SPARTAN [8]
[10]
Lowering Start-up Mach Number
•Lowering the start-up Mach number allows the engine
to take advantage of higher air densities
•Constant dynamic pressure can be achieved lower in
the atmosphere. Results in higher thrust per unit
frontal area [5]
•Evaluate proposed engine design for operation at
Mach 5
•Optimisation through changing area distribution of
the combustor
[8]Current Combustor Schematic
Modelling
• Develop a script to model the scramjet combustor. Use for
validation against DMCycle
•Distribution of flow properties assists in understanding the
effects of area distributions throughout the duct
•Creating a script develops understanding of scramjet
modelling techniques. Allows for results to be understood and
realistic suggestions to be made
•DMCycle takes into account changing chemistry (e.g.
molecular weight, specific heat ratio)
•Utilize DMCycle script to calculate uninstalled thrust, and
scramjet performance
Attached Flow through Isolator and
Combustor (Smart, 2007) [5]
Scramjet Analysis
•Quasi-one dimensional analysis
•Numerically solve differential equation which describes the Mach
number distribution through the duct
•ODE developed using physical equations describing the
differential element provided to the right
•Integral relations are utilised to determine required flow
properties (Temperature and Pressure)
Assumptions:
•One dimensional, steady flow through the scramjet combustor
•Changes in stream properties are continuous
•Constant chemistry (Molecular weight, specific heat ratio)
Differential Element of Duct Flow[5]
Solution Method
•Shapiro’s differential equation simplified using previous assumptions [11]:
𝑑𝑀2
𝑀2
= −
2 1 +
𝛾 − 1
2
𝑀2
1 − 𝑀2
𝑑𝐴
𝐴
+
(1 + 𝛾𝑀2) 1 +
𝛾 − 1
2
𝑀2
1 − 𝑀2
𝑑𝑇𝑜
𝑇𝑜
+
4𝑓𝛾𝑀2 1 +
𝛾 − 1
2
𝑀2
1 − 𝑀2
𝑑𝑥
𝐷
•The Mach number and the specific heat ratio (𝑀, 𝛾) are known the differential equation can be
expressed in terms of constants B, C, and D to help visualise the problem:
𝑑𝑀2
𝑀2
= −𝐵
𝑑𝐴
𝐴
+ 𝐶
𝑑𝑇𝑜
𝑇𝑜
+ 𝐷
𝑓𝑑𝑥
𝐷
•Evidently, each term is dependent on a different effect. Area change, friction, and heat addition
Creating Script and Validation
•Validate Fanno Flow, Rayleigh Flow, and Isentropic area
change cases, using compressible flow tables [11]
•Implement each solution into one script which solves for flow
in a duct with competing friction, heat addition, and area
change
•Use script to produce a model of a scramjet which has
already been conducted using DMCycle for validation of the
complex script
Fanno Flow Validation Plots
Conclusions
•Implement burner solution with all effects
•Validation against DMCycle
•Modelling proposed combustor design at Mach 5
and evaluating performance
•Optimising the design using differing area
distributions
•Provide suggestions for optimal combustor designs
for operation at Mach 5
•Contribute to the future of access to space
systems!
NASA & Boeing’s X-51 Waverider [12]
Reference List
[1] https://wallpaperscraft.com/download/space_planet_ship_art_star_73877/1920x1080
[2] http://www.wallpapervortex.com/wallpaper-18574_rocket_launch_space_shuttle_launch.html#.V9ssgCh96M9
[3] William H Heiser and David T. Pratt. Hypersonic airbreathing propulsion. 1994.
[4] Thomas Jazra, Dawid Preller, and Michael Smart. Design of an airbreathing second
stage for a rocket-scramjet-rocket launch vehicle. 2013.
[5] Michael Smart. Scramjets. 2007.
[6] Launching Australia into Space”. 2015. https://www.uq.edu.au/news/article/2015/08/launching-australia-space
[7] https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/b/b8/ScramjetDiagram.gif
[8] Michael K. Smart and Matthew R. Tetlow. Orbital delivery of small payloads using
hypersonic airbreathing propulsion. 2009.
[9] Dawid Preller and Michael K. Smart. Scramjets for reusable launch of small satellites. 2015.
[10] https://hapb-www.larc.nasa.gov/Public/Engines/Rest/98L02289r.jpg
[11] Ascher H. Shapiro. The dynamics and thermodynamics of compressible fluid flow. V1,1953.
[12] “X-51 Waverider ‘SCRAMJET’ Test Flight Fails”, 2015, http://www.universetoday.com/96829/x-51-waverider-scramjet-test-flight-fails/

Contenu connexe

Tendances

Project_CFD
Project_CFDProject_CFD
Project_CFD
Hao Li
 
IJERD (www.ijerd.com) International Journal of Engineering Research and Devel...
IJERD (www.ijerd.com) International Journal of Engineering Research and Devel...IJERD (www.ijerd.com) International Journal of Engineering Research and Devel...
IJERD (www.ijerd.com) International Journal of Engineering Research and Devel...
IJERD Editor
 
Laminar Flow And Turbulence Modeling For Domestic Scale Wind Turbine Siting
Laminar Flow And Turbulence Modeling  For Domestic Scale Wind Turbine SitingLaminar Flow And Turbulence Modeling  For Domestic Scale Wind Turbine Siting
Laminar Flow And Turbulence Modeling For Domestic Scale Wind Turbine Siting
chittaranjang
 
Investigation of time diversity gain for earth to satellite link using rain r...
Investigation of time diversity gain for earth to satellite link using rain r...Investigation of time diversity gain for earth to satellite link using rain r...
Investigation of time diversity gain for earth to satellite link using rain r...
journalBEEI
 
Balancing of an air-bearing-based Acs Test Bed
Balancing of an air-bearing-based Acs Test BedBalancing of an air-bearing-based Acs Test Bed
Balancing of an air-bearing-based Acs Test Bed
Cesare Pepponi
 
2 ShengleiZhang_IGARSS2011_MO3.T04.2.ppt
2 ShengleiZhang_IGARSS2011_MO3.T04.2.ppt2 ShengleiZhang_IGARSS2011_MO3.T04.2.ppt
2 ShengleiZhang_IGARSS2011_MO3.T04.2.ppt
grssieee
 

Tendances (19)

IVC Poster
IVC PosterIVC Poster
IVC Poster
 
The PuffR R Package for Conducting Air Quality Dispersion Analyses
The PuffR R Package for Conducting Air Quality Dispersion AnalysesThe PuffR R Package for Conducting Air Quality Dispersion Analyses
The PuffR R Package for Conducting Air Quality Dispersion Analyses
 
Project_CFD
Project_CFDProject_CFD
Project_CFD
 
CE573_Poster2
CE573_Poster2CE573_Poster2
CE573_Poster2
 
Current research on simulations of flaoting offshore wind turbines
Current research on simulations of flaoting offshore wind turbinesCurrent research on simulations of flaoting offshore wind turbines
Current research on simulations of flaoting offshore wind turbines
 
IJERD (www.ijerd.com) International Journal of Engineering Research and Devel...
IJERD (www.ijerd.com) International Journal of Engineering Research and Devel...IJERD (www.ijerd.com) International Journal of Engineering Research and Devel...
IJERD (www.ijerd.com) International Journal of Engineering Research and Devel...
 
Laminar Flow And Turbulence Modeling For Domestic Scale Wind Turbine Siting
Laminar Flow And Turbulence Modeling  For Domestic Scale Wind Turbine SitingLaminar Flow And Turbulence Modeling  For Domestic Scale Wind Turbine Siting
Laminar Flow And Turbulence Modeling For Domestic Scale Wind Turbine Siting
 
River engineering flood design
River engineering flood designRiver engineering flood design
River engineering flood design
 
AERMOD
AERMODAERMOD
AERMOD
 
Simulation requirements and relevant load conditions in the design of floatin...
Simulation requirements and relevant load conditions in the design of floatin...Simulation requirements and relevant load conditions in the design of floatin...
Simulation requirements and relevant load conditions in the design of floatin...
 
Public defense PhD
Public defense PhDPublic defense PhD
Public defense PhD
 
Flood
FloodFlood
Flood
 
Investigation of time diversity gain for earth to satellite link using rain r...
Investigation of time diversity gain for earth to satellite link using rain r...Investigation of time diversity gain for earth to satellite link using rain r...
Investigation of time diversity gain for earth to satellite link using rain r...
 
Italian weather type
Italian weather typeItalian weather type
Italian weather type
 
Methodology for Estimating Wave Power Potential in places with scarce instrum...
Methodology for Estimating Wave Power Potential in places with scarce instrum...Methodology for Estimating Wave Power Potential in places with scarce instrum...
Methodology for Estimating Wave Power Potential in places with scarce instrum...
 
Downscaling climate information (BC3 Summer School _July 2015)
Downscaling climate information (BC3 Summer School _July 2015)Downscaling climate information (BC3 Summer School _July 2015)
Downscaling climate information (BC3 Summer School _July 2015)
 
CUPC2015Poster
CUPC2015PosterCUPC2015Poster
CUPC2015Poster
 
Balancing of an air-bearing-based Acs Test Bed
Balancing of an air-bearing-based Acs Test BedBalancing of an air-bearing-based Acs Test Bed
Balancing of an air-bearing-based Acs Test Bed
 
2 ShengleiZhang_IGARSS2011_MO3.T04.2.ppt
2 ShengleiZhang_IGARSS2011_MO3.T04.2.ppt2 ShengleiZhang_IGARSS2011_MO3.T04.2.ppt
2 ShengleiZhang_IGARSS2011_MO3.T04.2.ppt
 

En vedette

En vedette (20)

227821766 combustor-modelling
227821766 combustor-modelling227821766 combustor-modelling
227821766 combustor-modelling
 
Aniket
AniketAniket
Aniket
 
Aircraft propulsion combustor diffusor
Aircraft propulsion   combustor diffusorAircraft propulsion   combustor diffusor
Aircraft propulsion combustor diffusor
 
External Air Assisted Shaping of Fuel Spray for Gas Turbine Combustor
External Air Assisted Shaping of Fuel Spray for Gas Turbine CombustorExternal Air Assisted Shaping of Fuel Spray for Gas Turbine Combustor
External Air Assisted Shaping of Fuel Spray for Gas Turbine Combustor
 
RP Poster March 11
RP Poster March 11RP Poster March 11
RP Poster March 11
 
Black Gold Rush Industries Vent Gas Destruction Presentation
Black Gold Rush Industries Vent Gas Destruction PresentationBlack Gold Rush Industries Vent Gas Destruction Presentation
Black Gold Rush Industries Vent Gas Destruction Presentation
 
ON THE INTEGRATION OF ROTARY HEATER IN GAS FIRED POWER PLANTS WITH POST-COMBU...
ON THE INTEGRATION OF ROTARY HEATER IN GAS FIRED POWER PLANTS WITH POST-COMBU...ON THE INTEGRATION OF ROTARY HEATER IN GAS FIRED POWER PLANTS WITH POST-COMBU...
ON THE INTEGRATION OF ROTARY HEATER IN GAS FIRED POWER PLANTS WITH POST-COMBU...
 
propulsion 1
propulsion 1propulsion 1
propulsion 1
 
Jet Propulsion: Combustion Chamber
Jet Propulsion: Combustion Chamber Jet Propulsion: Combustion Chamber
Jet Propulsion: Combustion Chamber
 
Lake Forest Arts Presentation
Lake Forest Arts PresentationLake Forest Arts Presentation
Lake Forest Arts Presentation
 
Samit Malkani_TiE Institute_Social Media Content Strategy_280712
Samit Malkani_TiE Institute_Social Media Content Strategy_280712Samit Malkani_TiE Institute_Social Media Content Strategy_280712
Samit Malkani_TiE Institute_Social Media Content Strategy_280712
 
Hamare Rusoom wa Quyood: Syed Ali Naqi Naqvi Sahab t.s.
Hamare Rusoom wa Quyood: Syed Ali Naqi Naqvi Sahab t.s.Hamare Rusoom wa Quyood: Syed Ali Naqi Naqvi Sahab t.s.
Hamare Rusoom wa Quyood: Syed Ali Naqi Naqvi Sahab t.s.
 
Ch06 1
Ch06 1Ch06 1
Ch06 1
 
Bharti B'Day Slide
Bharti B'Day SlideBharti B'Day Slide
Bharti B'Day Slide
 
Office
OfficeOffice
Office
 
Learning from games : Dr Joanne O'Mara
Learning from games : Dr Joanne O'MaraLearning from games : Dr Joanne O'Mara
Learning from games : Dr Joanne O'Mara
 
English teachers who blog
English teachers who blogEnglish teachers who blog
English teachers who blog
 
olajide doc.PDF
olajide doc.PDFolajide doc.PDF
olajide doc.PDF
 
AATE handout
AATE handoutAATE handout
AATE handout
 
Raman2
Raman2Raman2
Raman2
 

Similaire à Voller_s4321724_presentation

CRP presentation final
CRP presentation finalCRP presentation final
CRP presentation final
Tieg Laskowske
 
The SpaceDrive Project - First Results on EMDrive and Mach-Effect Thrusters
The SpaceDrive Project - First Results on EMDrive and Mach-Effect ThrustersThe SpaceDrive Project - First Results on EMDrive and Mach-Effect Thrusters
The SpaceDrive Project - First Results on EMDrive and Mach-Effect Thrusters
Sérgio Sacani
 

Similaire à Voller_s4321724_presentation (20)

K1
K1K1
K1
 
Slides for NSBE Oral Presentation.pptx
Slides for NSBE Oral Presentation.pptxSlides for NSBE Oral Presentation.pptx
Slides for NSBE Oral Presentation.pptx
 
Katerine Dykes: 2013 Sandia National Laboratoies Wind Plant Reliability Workshop
Katerine Dykes: 2013 Sandia National Laboratoies Wind Plant Reliability WorkshopKaterine Dykes: 2013 Sandia National Laboratoies Wind Plant Reliability Workshop
Katerine Dykes: 2013 Sandia National Laboratoies Wind Plant Reliability Workshop
 
G05094145
G05094145G05094145
G05094145
 
Welcome to International Journal of Engineering Research and Development (IJERD)
Welcome to International Journal of Engineering Research and Development (IJERD)Welcome to International Journal of Engineering Research and Development (IJERD)
Welcome to International Journal of Engineering Research and Development (IJERD)
 
Reservoir Simulation
Reservoir SimulationReservoir Simulation
Reservoir Simulation
 
CRP presentation final
CRP presentation finalCRP presentation final
CRP presentation final
 
CFD_Wind_drBorseBATU.pptx
CFD_Wind_drBorseBATU.pptxCFD_Wind_drBorseBATU.pptx
CFD_Wind_drBorseBATU.pptx
 
Presentation-for-teachers.pptx
Presentation-for-teachers.pptxPresentation-for-teachers.pptx
Presentation-for-teachers.pptx
 
CFD Analysis Of Savonius Vertical Axis Wind Turbine: A Review
CFD Analysis Of Savonius Vertical Axis Wind Turbine: A ReviewCFD Analysis Of Savonius Vertical Axis Wind Turbine: A Review
CFD Analysis Of Savonius Vertical Axis Wind Turbine: A Review
 
Final course project report
Final course project reportFinal course project report
Final course project report
 
Towards Exascale Engine Simulations with NEK5000
Towards Exascale Engine Simulations with NEK5000Towards Exascale Engine Simulations with NEK5000
Towards Exascale Engine Simulations with NEK5000
 
the engins that power the future.
the engins that power the future.the engins that power the future.
the engins that power the future.
 
Lcoe offshore
Lcoe offshoreLcoe offshore
Lcoe offshore
 
Compressed hydrogen2011 11_chato
Compressed hydrogen2011 11_chatoCompressed hydrogen2011 11_chato
Compressed hydrogen2011 11_chato
 
Computational Fluid Dynamics (CFD)
Computational Fluid Dynamics (CFD)Computational Fluid Dynamics (CFD)
Computational Fluid Dynamics (CFD)
 
The SpaceDrive Project - First Results on EMDrive and Mach-Effect Thrusters
The SpaceDrive Project - First Results on EMDrive and Mach-Effect ThrustersThe SpaceDrive Project - First Results on EMDrive and Mach-Effect Thrusters
The SpaceDrive Project - First Results on EMDrive and Mach-Effect Thrusters
 
Reactor Design 4
Reactor Design 4Reactor Design 4
Reactor Design 4
 
dynopts helicrafter rotor using cfd and structural analysis
dynopts helicrafter rotor using cfd and structural analysisdynopts helicrafter rotor using cfd and structural analysis
dynopts helicrafter rotor using cfd and structural analysis
 
Poster- QCS
Poster- QCSPoster- QCS
Poster- QCS
 

Voller_s4321724_presentation

  • 1. Optimisation of the SPARTAN’S Scramjet Combustor David Voller “Astronomy compels the soul to look upward, and leads us from this world to another.” - Plato, The Republic, 342 BCE [1]
  • 2. Rocket Propulsion •Current launch systems are dominated by rocket propulsion •Current rocket technology is operated close to theoretical limits [4] •~65% oxidiser and ~25% fuel mass fractions [3] •The Saturn V weighed 2.72 million kg •Liquid Oxygen: 1.81 million kg (~65%) •Payload: 115000 kg (~4%) [3] [2]
  • 3. Scramjets For Access To Space •Proposed use of airbreathing propulsion •Takes advantage of increased specific impulse •The idea of using scramjets for access to space systems has been around since the mid 20th century [3] •UQ’s Centre for Hypersonics has been developing the SPARTAN which will take advantage of the rocket- scramjet-rocket access to space system [6] [5]
  • 4. Scramjets: How do they work? •Kinetic energy converts to internal energy through oblique shocks •Increases pressure, density, and temperature of flow •Compressed flow is mixed with injected fuel, generally hydrogen •Combustion, spontaneous or ignitors used •Expansion to accelerate supersonic flow [3] [7]
  • 5. SPARTAN •A feasibility study which investigated a rocket- scramjet-rocket system was conducted in 2009 [8] •Concluded that approximately 100kg could be delivered to a 200km equatorial orbit with a mass payload fraction of approximately 1.5% [8] •Further design iterations suggest a payload mass fraction of 1.26% for a launch taking 260kg to sun synchronous orbit [9] •SPARTAN 11.4% fuel mass, conventional rocket systems ~90% fuel mass [9] [6]
  • 6. SPARTAN Scramjet Designs •Re-usable second stage which is based on winged cone vehicle (WCV) developed by the US National Aerospace Plane Program [9] •Initial design uses RESTM12 Engine: start up Mach number of 6 [8] •Further design iterations see the development of an inlet optimised for the WCV (C-REST), the trajectory, and first and third stages •Further optimisation of the second stage scramjet engine will mature the SPARTAN [8] [10]
  • 7. Lowering Start-up Mach Number •Lowering the start-up Mach number allows the engine to take advantage of higher air densities •Constant dynamic pressure can be achieved lower in the atmosphere. Results in higher thrust per unit frontal area [5] •Evaluate proposed engine design for operation at Mach 5 •Optimisation through changing area distribution of the combustor [8]Current Combustor Schematic
  • 8. Modelling • Develop a script to model the scramjet combustor. Use for validation against DMCycle •Distribution of flow properties assists in understanding the effects of area distributions throughout the duct •Creating a script develops understanding of scramjet modelling techniques. Allows for results to be understood and realistic suggestions to be made •DMCycle takes into account changing chemistry (e.g. molecular weight, specific heat ratio) •Utilize DMCycle script to calculate uninstalled thrust, and scramjet performance Attached Flow through Isolator and Combustor (Smart, 2007) [5]
  • 9. Scramjet Analysis •Quasi-one dimensional analysis •Numerically solve differential equation which describes the Mach number distribution through the duct •ODE developed using physical equations describing the differential element provided to the right •Integral relations are utilised to determine required flow properties (Temperature and Pressure) Assumptions: •One dimensional, steady flow through the scramjet combustor •Changes in stream properties are continuous •Constant chemistry (Molecular weight, specific heat ratio) Differential Element of Duct Flow[5]
  • 10. Solution Method •Shapiro’s differential equation simplified using previous assumptions [11]: 𝑑𝑀2 𝑀2 = − 2 1 + 𝛾 − 1 2 𝑀2 1 − 𝑀2 𝑑𝐴 𝐴 + (1 + 𝛾𝑀2) 1 + 𝛾 − 1 2 𝑀2 1 − 𝑀2 𝑑𝑇𝑜 𝑇𝑜 + 4𝑓𝛾𝑀2 1 + 𝛾 − 1 2 𝑀2 1 − 𝑀2 𝑑𝑥 𝐷 •The Mach number and the specific heat ratio (𝑀, 𝛾) are known the differential equation can be expressed in terms of constants B, C, and D to help visualise the problem: 𝑑𝑀2 𝑀2 = −𝐵 𝑑𝐴 𝐴 + 𝐶 𝑑𝑇𝑜 𝑇𝑜 + 𝐷 𝑓𝑑𝑥 𝐷 •Evidently, each term is dependent on a different effect. Area change, friction, and heat addition
  • 11. Creating Script and Validation •Validate Fanno Flow, Rayleigh Flow, and Isentropic area change cases, using compressible flow tables [11] •Implement each solution into one script which solves for flow in a duct with competing friction, heat addition, and area change •Use script to produce a model of a scramjet which has already been conducted using DMCycle for validation of the complex script Fanno Flow Validation Plots
  • 12. Conclusions •Implement burner solution with all effects •Validation against DMCycle •Modelling proposed combustor design at Mach 5 and evaluating performance •Optimising the design using differing area distributions •Provide suggestions for optimal combustor designs for operation at Mach 5 •Contribute to the future of access to space systems! NASA & Boeing’s X-51 Waverider [12]
  • 13. Reference List [1] https://wallpaperscraft.com/download/space_planet_ship_art_star_73877/1920x1080 [2] http://www.wallpapervortex.com/wallpaper-18574_rocket_launch_space_shuttle_launch.html#.V9ssgCh96M9 [3] William H Heiser and David T. Pratt. Hypersonic airbreathing propulsion. 1994. [4] Thomas Jazra, Dawid Preller, and Michael Smart. Design of an airbreathing second stage for a rocket-scramjet-rocket launch vehicle. 2013. [5] Michael Smart. Scramjets. 2007. [6] Launching Australia into Space”. 2015. https://www.uq.edu.au/news/article/2015/08/launching-australia-space [7] https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/b/b8/ScramjetDiagram.gif [8] Michael K. Smart and Matthew R. Tetlow. Orbital delivery of small payloads using hypersonic airbreathing propulsion. 2009. [9] Dawid Preller and Michael K. Smart. Scramjets for reusable launch of small satellites. 2015. [10] https://hapb-www.larc.nasa.gov/Public/Engines/Rest/98L02289r.jpg [11] Ascher H. Shapiro. The dynamics and thermodynamics of compressible fluid flow. V1,1953. [12] “X-51 Waverider ‘SCRAMJET’ Test Flight Fails”, 2015, http://www.universetoday.com/96829/x-51-waverider-scramjet-test-flight-fails/