SlideShare une entreprise Scribd logo
1  sur  21
Télécharger pour lire hors ligne
1Copyright © 2020 Accenture. All rights reserved.
WE STAND
TOGETHER FOR
EQUALITY
2Copyright © 2020 Accenture. All rights reserved.
OUR IMMERSIVE
VOLUME
RECRUITMENT
SOLUTION
WITH NO
ADVERSE
EFFECTS
ON GENDER
OR ETHNICITY
3Copyright © 2020 Accenture. All rights reserved.
DIVERSITY IS A KEY CHALLENGE IN RECRUITMENT
The impact of ‘soft’ solutions to improve diversity have had
negligible impact on the real world
The colour of someone’s skin or their name can still be a
barrier to social mobility: ethnic minorities are still facing the
same levels of discrimination in hiring they did 25 years ago1.
The gender pay gap still exists: women earn $73 for every
$100 a man makes2.
Men are 47 percent more likely to reach senior
manager/director positions than their female peers3.
Social mobility is harder than it’s ever been: America’s elite
colleges admit more young people from the wealthiest 1%
than from families in the bottom 60%4
If there is only one minority candidate in a final recruitment
pool they have almost no chance of being offered the role.
Two minority candidates are at least 79X more likely to be
offered the role5
4Copyright © 2020 Accenture. All rights reserved.
CANDIDATE EXPERIENCE IS CRITICAL
Today, candidates demand seamless experiences in recruitment and true purpose in employment. Purpose matters.
An organisation’s stance on inclusivity, candidate centricity and equality will be a key deciding factors for potential
talent. Candidate centric solutions should be:
• Ensure a consistent
experience for all
users throughout
the journey: know
what to expect and
how long it will take
• Ensure candidates
feel the same tone,
brand and values
throughout
Seamless
• Modern candidate
led technology
solutions
• AI / automation
leveraged to achieve
optimum human
versus machine
solutions
Digital
• Tailor the
experience to meet
the needs of both
the organisation and
the employee
• Deliver an
experience that has
a positive impact on
candidates –
whether successful
or unsuccessful
Human
• Solutions led by
inclusivity and
candidate centricity
• Mandate a fair
experience
• Demonstrate
flexibility
• Remove barriers and
biases
Inclusive
• Design with the
future in mind with a
solution that is
dynamic and flexible
• Ensure change and
adoption plans as
well as solution
designs put the user
front and center
Scalable
5Copyright © 2020 Accenture. All rights reserved.
EXISTING PLATFORMS AREN’T FIT FOR PURPOSE
Inadequate: not designed
for volume hiring
1 2 3 4
• Lack of insight causes
costly bottlenecks
• System of record, not
system of action
Biased: puts diverse
groups at a disadvantage
• Existing screening
process susceptible
to biases
Restricted: candidate
UX reduces pipeline
• Average 46% completion
rate with legacy ATS6
• Disproportionately
affects lower socio-
economic groups
Inefficient: extreme
time/efficiency losses
• Recruiter workflows are
poor with real operating
and productivity costs
6Copyright © 2020 Accenture. All rights reserved.
THE IMPACT
The uncomfortable truth is that the recruitment process is broken and inherently unfair.
This leads to:
Chronic Mis-hiring
Institutional Bias
Huge Costs
Lost Revenue
75%
Estimated that up to 75% of new
hires are mis-hires that won’t
ever reach the expectations set
by the company or themselves7.
$bn’s
The cost of a mishire is
conservatively estimated at
$40k9. The cost to a single large
enterprise can easily run into
the $100m’s.
50%+
The current recruitment practice
in most enterprise organisations
is inherently biased,
disadvantaging women and
ethnic minorities by over 50%8.
42%+
42% of ethnic minority shoppers
and 41% of LGBT shoppers
would switch to a retailer
committed to inclusion and
diversity10.
7Copyright © 2020 Accenture. All rights reserved.
WHY IS NOW THE TIME FOR CHANGE?
TREND 1 TREND 2 TREND 3
Societal spotlight on
discrimination
Movements and protests focusing
on diversity, discrimination and
equity in society and actions by
corporates to right wrongs
Unemployment creates
unsustainable volume
Higher unemployment rates as a
result of COVID-19 leads to
increased volume of applications,
unsustainable with current
resourcing levels
Using AI to automate and
reduce costs
Organizations are looking to
reduce cost base whilst increasing
flexibility and capability to meet
customer demands
7Copyright © 2020 Accenture. All rights reserved.
8Copyright © 2020 Accenture. All rights reserved.
WHAT’S GETTING IN THE WAY?
Hollow Commitment
Old systems are
entrenched
Business goals remain
the priority
Meaningful change to driving progress
in diversity requires commitment and
conviction at the highest levels of your
organisation
Real board level commitment to action
and change is required, as well as
influential internal champions who can
drive it
Existing systems/processes aren’t
flexible enough, not fit for purpose, not
adaptable.
New purpose-built systems need to
replace the old systems.
Balancing quality of hires with
candidate/recruiter experience without
high costs and inefficiencies
No compromise
Accuracy, quality of hiring and
business efficiencies have to remain at
the core of this change.
It must make business sense too.
9Copyright © 2020 Accenture. All rights reserved.
WHAT IS THE ANSWER?
A simplified process and solution that delivers...
Compelling call to action that supports
diverse talent pools
Great candidate engagement
Fairly assess all candidates ‘in context’ and their
suitability to the job. Measure potential, not privilege
Accurate screening & Assessment
Mobile optimised, fair and delivers high
completion rates
Great application experience
Manage high volume pipelines effectively
and with ease
Optimised Recruitment workflows
9Copyright © 2020 Accenture. All rights reserved.
10Copyright © 2020 Accenture. All rights reserved.
DEBIASED RECRUITMENT
By reimagining and simplifying the recruiting process with a focus on diversity, inclusion and
fairness, we can deliver a high-quality candidate and recruiter experience that in turn delivers
high-potential and high caliber applicants. Fairly and bias free.
• Understand candidate
motivations utilising internal
& external research to
(existing & prospective)
• Identify and segment
prospective new recruits
• Develop and deploy a data
driven attraction strategy,
comms plan and campaign
• Data driven communication
assets and planning for
effective campaigns
BRANDING &
ATTRACTION
DIGITAL CANDIDATE
EXPERIENCE
DIGITAL RECRUITER
EXPERIENCE
IMMERSIVE
ASSESSMENT
UNIQUE ASSESSMENT
CENTRE
OFFER &
ONBOARDING
• Increase application
completion through an
intuitive user experience
• Mobile optimised interface
• Unique applicant ‘profile’
gives candidates control over
data and process
• Automated Application
Matching, including initial
questions
• Screening conducted against
High Performer criteria
• Use of deprivation scale
enables social mobility by
putting relative performance
in context
• Measurement of potential, not
privilege
• 1st round selection testing,
typically cognitive
• Tests developed to assess key
skills and capabilities
identified for High Performers
• Final round
Assessment Centre,
with possibility of
localisation
• Behavioural and
technical focus of
the assessment
• Builds on the experience of
the recruitment process
• Pre-defined onboarding
approach with clear visibility
for the new recruit
• Transparent expectations for
time to productivity and key
capabilities
• Continued communication
platform engages and
informs the candidate
reducing drop off
Real-time analytics enables the
adjustment of attraction channels
based on applicants’ profile mix
Performance on stage 1 assessment
enables review of criteria
weightings in application process
Performance on stage 1
assessment enables review
of criteria weightings in
application process
11Copyright © 2020 Accenture. All rights reserved.
PURPOSE DRIVEN BRANDING & ATTRACTION
Define internal
and external
perceptions
Articulate
Employer Value
Proposition
Data driven
innovative
recruitment
campaign
production
Rediscover your
organisations
Inner Purpose
Determine talent
segmentation
strategy
12Copyright © 2020 Accenture. All rights reserved.
SCREEN CANDIDATES FAIRLY AND CONTEXTUALLY
Responsive design accessible on
any candidate device
• Score every candidate against a single framework to
ensure equal, debiased screening
• Use of deprivation scale enables social mobility by
putting relative performance in context of their life
• Allow candidates to apply as their true selves on gender,
sexuality, ethnicity and more to increase application
completions
• Capture variety of data points on candidate background
13Copyright © 2020 Accenture. All rights reserved.
CONTEXTUAL SCREENING COMPONENTS
Industry Type Time
Sematic Skill Matching
Match
Score
Skills
Work
Experience
Socioeconomic
Index
Grades
Income
Education
Deprivation
index
University
School
Subjects
Degree types
Degree Grades
14Copyright © 2020 Accenture. All rights reserved.
PRIORITISE LARGE VOLUMES OF APPLICANTS
Modern recruiter
experience
Personalised
communications
Reduce recruiter
manual work
resulting in $$
savings
Search and
sort by
eligibility
and
suitability
Full pipeline
tracking
Bulk actions
and
automations
for saving
time
Applicants prioritised by
suitability and without bias
Hiring accuracy through
data science
Copyright © 2020 Accenture. All rights reserved. 14
15Copyright © 2020 Accenture. All rights reserved.
ANALYTICS FOR DIVERSITY
Powerful analytics to enable actionable insights
15
16Copyright © 2020 Accenture. All rights reserved.
CORE BENEFITS
More
flexibility
Market
differentiation
Eliminatingbias by
design
Driving quality in
volumerecruitment
Candidate
Experience
Copyright © 2020 Accenture. All rights reserved.
17Copyright © 2020 Accenture. All rights reserved.
ACCENTURE CASE STUDY: THE HIGHLIGHTS
110,000: applications via Headstart across 13 countries
92.25%: Avg. applicant match score for London Consulting,
post Assessment Centre
90%: Increase in female entry hiring into technology
2.5%: Increase in Afro Caribbean hires for core programmes
$2.1m: in cost-savings, with 55% lower cost-per-hire
“With Headstart, female entry level hiring into
technology grew by 90% in the UK,
increasing from 32% in FY17 to 61% in FY18”
Helen Lorigan, Accenture Candidate
Management Lead
“The results of these efforts
are impressive,”
RedThread/Mercer Report:
Identified increases in gender &
diversity hiring, alongside $2.1m
in savings due to automation
18Copyright © 2020 Accenture. All rights reserved.
HEADSTART TRUE STORIES
Copyright © 2020 Accenture. All rights reserved.
Born in Dagenham - the 12th poorest out of 326
local authorities in the UK
Attended school in an area with more murder
investigations than anywhere else in the UK
Went to Leicester University ranked outside the 150
globally
Now with the help of Headstart, a consultant at
Accenture since January 2019.
Nina Showobi*
*Name changed to protect privacy
Nina is not alone - Headstart have impacted the hires
of 100s of the brightest most marginalised candidates.
“The application process was
so different to anything else
I’ve applied for.”
19Copyright © 2020 Accenture. All rights reserved.
Driving business and societal progress through
innovative technologies
WE KNOW YOU/YOU KNOW US
We know your ambition is to create the best in class people,
culture and ways of working.
HUMAN-CENTRED METHODOLOGY
Pioneering digital recruitment through design-led methodology
putting the candidate at the heart of a seamless recruitment
process.
WE BRING UNPARALLELLED ASSETS
Our industry knowledge, research and digital savvy solutions
weave technology into the fabric of the best in class design.
WE BRING UNPARALLED
TECHNOLOGICAL EXPERTISE
Shape innovation and agility through new technologies, such as
Virtual Reality, data and workforce analytics and insights to drive
a more strategic and value-adding experience and solution.
WE DELIVER
Execution is in our DNA. We are strategic thinkers and thought
leaders who also deliver solutions. We are committed to achieve
what we promise and we have the capabilities to provide pace
and certainty along the journey.
SCREEN EVERY CANDIDATE FAIRLY
Match score machine learning framework screens every
candidate equally and fairly.
SOCIOECONOMIC DATA IN MACHINE LEARNING
The only applicant matching and management system to use
socioeconomic data to assess candidates in context.
BUILT FOR ENTERPRISE
Secure, stable, and reliable technology platform for use by
enterprise organizations.
Copyright © 2020 Accenture. All rights reserved.
REMOVE UNCONSCIOUS BIAS
Measurement of potential, not privilege
DATA DRIVEN DIVERSITY
Understand how to measure progress and engagement against
diversity targets
ENGAGING CANDIDATE EXPERIENCES
inclusive and bias-free.
ACTIONABLE INSIGHTS
Data, insights and reports that deliver actionable results – for
candidates and companies.
20Copyright © 2020 Accenture. All rights reserved.
CONTACTS:
Eimear Meredith
Jones
Kate Ellen John Fennessy
Accenture Accenture Headstart
21Copyright © 2020 Accenture. All rights reserved.
REFERENCES
1 – https://hbr.org/2017/10/hiring-discrimination-against-black-americans-hasnt-declined-in-25-years
2 - https://www.accenture.com/_acnmedia/PDF-73/Accenture-When-She-Rises-We-All-Rise.pdf#zoom=50
3- https://www.accenture.com/_acnmedia/PDF-73/Accenture-When-She-Rises-We-All-Rise.pdf#zoom=50 – 8% (M) 22%
(SM)
4- https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2017/01/18/upshot/some-colleges-have-more-students-from-the-top-1-percent-
than-the-bottom-60.html
5 – https://hbr.org/2016/04/if-theres-only-one-woman-in-your-candidate-pool-theres-statistically-no-chance-shell-be-
hired
6 - https://redthreadresearch.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/08/RedThread_DI_Report_Reduced_Final.pdf
7 – http://press.careerbuilder.com/2017-12-07-Nearly-Three-in-Four-Employers-Affected-by-a-Bad-Hire-According-to-a-
Recent-CareerBuilder-Survey
8 – https://www.bls.gov/ncs/ect/
9 – http://www.thedynamicsale.com/wp-content/uploads/2014/06/Avoid-Costly-Mis-Hires-by-Bradford-Smart.pdf
10 - https://www.thevaluable500.com/wp-content/themes/valuable500/downloads/files/The_Valuable_500_release.pdf

Contenu connexe

Tendances

The Changing Joule Dynamic | Accenture
The Changing Joule Dynamic | AccentureThe Changing Joule Dynamic | Accenture
The Changing Joule Dynamic | Accentureaccenture
 
The Industrialist: Trends & Innovations - July 2022
The Industrialist: Trends & Innovations - July 2022The Industrialist: Trends & Innovations - July 2022
The Industrialist: Trends & Innovations - July 2022accenture
 
Value Untangled Slideshare
Value Untangled SlideshareValue Untangled Slideshare
Value Untangled Slideshareaccenture
 
International Target Operating Model Design
International Target Operating Model DesignInternational Target Operating Model Design
International Target Operating Model DesignChris Oddy
 
Accenture Regulatory Services
Accenture Regulatory ServicesAccenture Regulatory Services
Accenture Regulatory Servicesaccenture
 
Digital Transformation
Digital TransformationDigital Transformation
Digital TransformationEvgeny Tsarkov
 
Signaling the Future for Supply Chain Success
Signaling the Future for Supply Chain SuccessSignaling the Future for Supply Chain Success
Signaling the Future for Supply Chain Successaccenture
 
Automating Procurement Plus
Automating Procurement PlusAutomating Procurement Plus
Automating Procurement Plusaccenture
 
How enterprise networks can boost Cloud Continuum experience
How enterprise networks can boost Cloud Continuum experienceHow enterprise networks can boost Cloud Continuum experience
How enterprise networks can boost Cloud Continuum experienceaccenture
 
A passwordless enterprise journey
A passwordless enterprise journeyA passwordless enterprise journey
A passwordless enterprise journeyaccenture
 
Shaping the Sustainable Organization | Accenture
Shaping the Sustainable Organization | AccentureShaping the Sustainable Organization | Accenture
Shaping the Sustainable Organization | Accentureaccenture
 
Free to be 100% me
Free to be 100% meFree to be 100% me
Free to be 100% meaccenture
 
The Reinvention Reset | Accenture
The Reinvention Reset | AccentureThe Reinvention Reset | Accenture
The Reinvention Reset | Accentureaccenture
 
Zero trust strategy: cloud security by design
Zero trust strategy: cloud security by designZero trust strategy: cloud security by design
Zero trust strategy: cloud security by designaccenture
 
Media-Morphosis Transforming Media and Entertainment
Media-Morphosis Transforming Media and EntertainmentMedia-Morphosis Transforming Media and Entertainment
Media-Morphosis Transforming Media and Entertainmentaccenture
 
High Performers in IT: Defined by Digital
High Performers in IT: Defined by DigitalHigh Performers in IT: Defined by Digital
High Performers in IT: Defined by Digitalaccenture
 
Diversity, Equity and Inclusion in Government Workforce
Diversity, Equity and Inclusion in Government WorkforceDiversity, Equity and Inclusion in Government Workforce
Diversity, Equity and Inclusion in Government Workforceaccenture
 
Pathways to Profitability for the Communications Industry
Pathways to Profitability for the Communications IndustryPathways to Profitability for the Communications Industry
Pathways to Profitability for the Communications Industryaccenture
 

Tendances (20)

The Changing Joule Dynamic | Accenture
The Changing Joule Dynamic | AccentureThe Changing Joule Dynamic | Accenture
The Changing Joule Dynamic | Accenture
 
The Industrialist: Trends & Innovations - July 2022
The Industrialist: Trends & Innovations - July 2022The Industrialist: Trends & Innovations - July 2022
The Industrialist: Trends & Innovations - July 2022
 
Lead Through Disruption Guide PDF
Lead Through Disruption Guide PDFLead Through Disruption Guide PDF
Lead Through Disruption Guide PDF
 
Value Untangled Slideshare
Value Untangled SlideshareValue Untangled Slideshare
Value Untangled Slideshare
 
International Target Operating Model Design
International Target Operating Model DesignInternational Target Operating Model Design
International Target Operating Model Design
 
Accenture Regulatory Services
Accenture Regulatory ServicesAccenture Regulatory Services
Accenture Regulatory Services
 
Digital Transformation
Digital TransformationDigital Transformation
Digital Transformation
 
Signaling the Future for Supply Chain Success
Signaling the Future for Supply Chain SuccessSignaling the Future for Supply Chain Success
Signaling the Future for Supply Chain Success
 
Automating Procurement Plus
Automating Procurement PlusAutomating Procurement Plus
Automating Procurement Plus
 
How enterprise networks can boost Cloud Continuum experience
How enterprise networks can boost Cloud Continuum experienceHow enterprise networks can boost Cloud Continuum experience
How enterprise networks can boost Cloud Continuum experience
 
A passwordless enterprise journey
A passwordless enterprise journeyA passwordless enterprise journey
A passwordless enterprise journey
 
Pivotal Moments All-in-One_FINAL.pdf
Pivotal Moments All-in-One_FINAL.pdfPivotal Moments All-in-One_FINAL.pdf
Pivotal Moments All-in-One_FINAL.pdf
 
Shaping the Sustainable Organization | Accenture
Shaping the Sustainable Organization | AccentureShaping the Sustainable Organization | Accenture
Shaping the Sustainable Organization | Accenture
 
Free to be 100% me
Free to be 100% meFree to be 100% me
Free to be 100% me
 
The Reinvention Reset | Accenture
The Reinvention Reset | AccentureThe Reinvention Reset | Accenture
The Reinvention Reset | Accenture
 
Zero trust strategy: cloud security by design
Zero trust strategy: cloud security by designZero trust strategy: cloud security by design
Zero trust strategy: cloud security by design
 
Media-Morphosis Transforming Media and Entertainment
Media-Morphosis Transforming Media and EntertainmentMedia-Morphosis Transforming Media and Entertainment
Media-Morphosis Transforming Media and Entertainment
 
High Performers in IT: Defined by Digital
High Performers in IT: Defined by DigitalHigh Performers in IT: Defined by Digital
High Performers in IT: Defined by Digital
 
Diversity, Equity and Inclusion in Government Workforce
Diversity, Equity and Inclusion in Government WorkforceDiversity, Equity and Inclusion in Government Workforce
Diversity, Equity and Inclusion in Government Workforce
 
Pathways to Profitability for the Communications Industry
Pathways to Profitability for the Communications IndustryPathways to Profitability for the Communications Industry
Pathways to Profitability for the Communications Industry
 

Similaire à Accenture & Headstart - Diversity Hiring Proposition

Diversity Hiring: How to Leverage Recruitment Technology for Your Pipeline
Diversity Hiring: How to Leverage Recruitment Technology for Your PipelineDiversity Hiring: How to Leverage Recruitment Technology for Your Pipeline
Diversity Hiring: How to Leverage Recruitment Technology for Your PipelineAggregage
 
Webinar for May 2020 - Putting people skills and cultural change at the heart...
Webinar for May 2020 - Putting people skills and cultural change at the heart...Webinar for May 2020 - Putting people skills and cultural change at the heart...
Webinar for May 2020 - Putting people skills and cultural change at the heart...The Digital Insurer
 
Innovation With Purpose: Deploying Digital Technologies to Improve Outcomes i...
Innovation With Purpose: Deploying Digital Technologies to Improve Outcomes i...Innovation With Purpose: Deploying Digital Technologies to Improve Outcomes i...
Innovation With Purpose: Deploying Digital Technologies to Improve Outcomes i...accenture
 
Digital Insurance Enterprise: The Nest Case Study
Digital Insurance Enterprise: The Nest Case StudyDigital Insurance Enterprise: The Nest Case Study
Digital Insurance Enterprise: The Nest Case StudyTata Consultancy Services
 
KGWI: What Talent Wants - High Tech
KGWI: What Talent Wants - High TechKGWI: What Talent Wants - High Tech
KGWI: What Talent Wants - High TechKelly Services
 
How To Lead Digital Transformations
How To Lead Digital Transformations How To Lead Digital Transformations
How To Lead Digital Transformations Faisal Hoque
 
HOW AI IS CHANGING THE WAY YOU RECRUIT AND HIRE TOP TALENT
HOW AI IS CHANGING THE WAY YOU RECRUIT AND HIRE TOP TALENTHOW AI IS CHANGING THE WAY YOU RECRUIT AND HIRE TOP TALENT
HOW AI IS CHANGING THE WAY YOU RECRUIT AND HIRE TOP TALENTHuman Capital Media
 
Closing the Employee Skills Gap: A Framework for Future Success | Webinar 11....
Closing the Employee Skills Gap: A Framework for Future Success | Webinar 11....Closing the Employee Skills Gap: A Framework for Future Success | Webinar 11....
Closing the Employee Skills Gap: A Framework for Future Success | Webinar 11....BizLibrary
 
Responsible AI in Industry: Practical Challenges and Lessons Learned
Responsible AI in Industry: Practical Challenges and Lessons LearnedResponsible AI in Industry: Practical Challenges and Lessons Learned
Responsible AI in Industry: Practical Challenges and Lessons LearnedKrishnaram Kenthapadi
 
How CSR supports EPAM's Differentiation Strategy
How CSR supports EPAM's Differentiation StrategyHow CSR supports EPAM's Differentiation Strategy
How CSR supports EPAM's Differentiation StrategyAnastasia Shender
 
#FIRMday Birmimgham 19th June 2019 - Sova: Remaking Assessment for the Digita...
#FIRMday Birmimgham 19th June 2019 - Sova: Remaking Assessment for the Digita...#FIRMday Birmimgham 19th June 2019 - Sova: Remaking Assessment for the Digita...
#FIRMday Birmimgham 19th June 2019 - Sova: Remaking Assessment for the Digita...Emma Mirrington
 
Deloitte Cloud Accelerators Salesforce Tour Melbourne
Deloitte Cloud Accelerators Salesforce Tour Melbourne Deloitte Cloud Accelerators Salesforce Tour Melbourne
Deloitte Cloud Accelerators Salesforce Tour Melbourne Deloitte Australia
 
How Organizations Are Using Analytics in Succession Decisions
How Organizations Are Using Analytics in Succession DecisionsHow Organizations Are Using Analytics in Succession Decisions
How Organizations Are Using Analytics in Succession DecisionsDavid Underwood
 
The Power Of Assessment Thomas de Zeeuw, Managing Director, cut-e The Netherl...
The Power Of Assessment Thomas de Zeeuw, Managing Director, cut-e The Netherl...The Power Of Assessment Thomas de Zeeuw, Managing Director, cut-e The Netherl...
The Power Of Assessment Thomas de Zeeuw, Managing Director, cut-e The Netherl...TALiNT Partners
 
SFSF REC_Sales Guide and Tips for Identifying Recruiting Strategies and Opps....
SFSF REC_Sales Guide and Tips for Identifying Recruiting Strategies and Opps....SFSF REC_Sales Guide and Tips for Identifying Recruiting Strategies and Opps....
SFSF REC_Sales Guide and Tips for Identifying Recruiting Strategies and Opps....MarkPalma9
 
Shifting perspectives of Canadian organizations
Shifting perspectives of Canadian organizationsShifting perspectives of Canadian organizations
Shifting perspectives of Canadian organizationsJoel Martin
 
Addressing Sales Practice and Conduct Risk in the Canadian Market
Addressing Sales Practice and Conduct Risk in the Canadian MarketAddressing Sales Practice and Conduct Risk in the Canadian Market
Addressing Sales Practice and Conduct Risk in the Canadian Marketaccenture
 
Webinar: People Transformation in a digital age
Webinar: People Transformation in a digital ageWebinar: People Transformation in a digital age
Webinar: People Transformation in a digital ageThe Digital Insurer
 

Similaire à Accenture & Headstart - Diversity Hiring Proposition (20)

Diversity Hiring: How to Leverage Recruitment Technology for Your Pipeline
Diversity Hiring: How to Leverage Recruitment Technology for Your PipelineDiversity Hiring: How to Leverage Recruitment Technology for Your Pipeline
Diversity Hiring: How to Leverage Recruitment Technology for Your Pipeline
 
04_CX Day 2023_Hanna Vuorikoski_Tietoevry.pdf
04_CX Day 2023_Hanna Vuorikoski_Tietoevry.pdf04_CX Day 2023_Hanna Vuorikoski_Tietoevry.pdf
04_CX Day 2023_Hanna Vuorikoski_Tietoevry.pdf
 
Webinar for May 2020 - Putting people skills and cultural change at the heart...
Webinar for May 2020 - Putting people skills and cultural change at the heart...Webinar for May 2020 - Putting people skills and cultural change at the heart...
Webinar for May 2020 - Putting people skills and cultural change at the heart...
 
Innovation With Purpose: Deploying Digital Technologies to Improve Outcomes i...
Innovation With Purpose: Deploying Digital Technologies to Improve Outcomes i...Innovation With Purpose: Deploying Digital Technologies to Improve Outcomes i...
Innovation With Purpose: Deploying Digital Technologies to Improve Outcomes i...
 
Digital Insurance Enterprise: The Nest Case Study
Digital Insurance Enterprise: The Nest Case StudyDigital Insurance Enterprise: The Nest Case Study
Digital Insurance Enterprise: The Nest Case Study
 
KGWI: What Talent Wants - High Tech
KGWI: What Talent Wants - High TechKGWI: What Talent Wants - High Tech
KGWI: What Talent Wants - High Tech
 
The Future Ready CPA Firm
The Future Ready CPA FirmThe Future Ready CPA Firm
The Future Ready CPA Firm
 
How To Lead Digital Transformations
How To Lead Digital Transformations How To Lead Digital Transformations
How To Lead Digital Transformations
 
HOW AI IS CHANGING THE WAY YOU RECRUIT AND HIRE TOP TALENT
HOW AI IS CHANGING THE WAY YOU RECRUIT AND HIRE TOP TALENTHOW AI IS CHANGING THE WAY YOU RECRUIT AND HIRE TOP TALENT
HOW AI IS CHANGING THE WAY YOU RECRUIT AND HIRE TOP TALENT
 
Closing the Employee Skills Gap: A Framework for Future Success | Webinar 11....
Closing the Employee Skills Gap: A Framework for Future Success | Webinar 11....Closing the Employee Skills Gap: A Framework for Future Success | Webinar 11....
Closing the Employee Skills Gap: A Framework for Future Success | Webinar 11....
 
Responsible AI in Industry: Practical Challenges and Lessons Learned
Responsible AI in Industry: Practical Challenges and Lessons LearnedResponsible AI in Industry: Practical Challenges and Lessons Learned
Responsible AI in Industry: Practical Challenges and Lessons Learned
 
How CSR supports EPAM's Differentiation Strategy
How CSR supports EPAM's Differentiation StrategyHow CSR supports EPAM's Differentiation Strategy
How CSR supports EPAM's Differentiation Strategy
 
#FIRMday Birmimgham 19th June 2019 - Sova: Remaking Assessment for the Digita...
#FIRMday Birmimgham 19th June 2019 - Sova: Remaking Assessment for the Digita...#FIRMday Birmimgham 19th June 2019 - Sova: Remaking Assessment for the Digita...
#FIRMday Birmimgham 19th June 2019 - Sova: Remaking Assessment for the Digita...
 
Deloitte Cloud Accelerators Salesforce Tour Melbourne
Deloitte Cloud Accelerators Salesforce Tour Melbourne Deloitte Cloud Accelerators Salesforce Tour Melbourne
Deloitte Cloud Accelerators Salesforce Tour Melbourne
 
How Organizations Are Using Analytics in Succession Decisions
How Organizations Are Using Analytics in Succession DecisionsHow Organizations Are Using Analytics in Succession Decisions
How Organizations Are Using Analytics in Succession Decisions
 
The Power Of Assessment Thomas de Zeeuw, Managing Director, cut-e The Netherl...
The Power Of Assessment Thomas de Zeeuw, Managing Director, cut-e The Netherl...The Power Of Assessment Thomas de Zeeuw, Managing Director, cut-e The Netherl...
The Power Of Assessment Thomas de Zeeuw, Managing Director, cut-e The Netherl...
 
SFSF REC_Sales Guide and Tips for Identifying Recruiting Strategies and Opps....
SFSF REC_Sales Guide and Tips for Identifying Recruiting Strategies and Opps....SFSF REC_Sales Guide and Tips for Identifying Recruiting Strategies and Opps....
SFSF REC_Sales Guide and Tips for Identifying Recruiting Strategies and Opps....
 
Shifting perspectives of Canadian organizations
Shifting perspectives of Canadian organizationsShifting perspectives of Canadian organizations
Shifting perspectives of Canadian organizations
 
Addressing Sales Practice and Conduct Risk in the Canadian Market
Addressing Sales Practice and Conduct Risk in the Canadian MarketAddressing Sales Practice and Conduct Risk in the Canadian Market
Addressing Sales Practice and Conduct Risk in the Canadian Market
 
Webinar: People Transformation in a digital age
Webinar: People Transformation in a digital ageWebinar: People Transformation in a digital age
Webinar: People Transformation in a digital age
 

Dernier

HRM PPT on placement , induction and socialization
HRM PPT on placement , induction and socializationHRM PPT on placement , induction and socialization
HRM PPT on placement , induction and socializationRishik53
 
How Leading Companies Deliver Value with People Analytics
How Leading Companies Deliver Value with People AnalyticsHow Leading Companies Deliver Value with People Analytics
How Leading Companies Deliver Value with People AnalyticsDavid Green
 
Webinar - How to set pay ranges in the context of pay transparency legislation
Webinar - How to set pay ranges in the context of pay transparency legislationWebinar - How to set pay ranges in the context of pay transparency legislation
Webinar - How to set pay ranges in the context of pay transparency legislationPayScale, Inc.
 
Mastering Vendor Selection and Partnership Management
Mastering Vendor Selection and Partnership ManagementMastering Vendor Selection and Partnership Management
Mastering Vendor Selection and Partnership ManagementBoundless HQ
 
Mercer Global Talent Trends 2024 - Human Resources
Mercer Global Talent Trends 2024 - Human ResourcesMercer Global Talent Trends 2024 - Human Resources
Mercer Global Talent Trends 2024 - Human Resourcesmnavarrete3
 
100%Safe delivery(+971558539980)Abortion pills for sale..dubai sharjah, abu d...
100%Safe delivery(+971558539980)Abortion pills for sale..dubai sharjah, abu d...100%Safe delivery(+971558539980)Abortion pills for sale..dubai sharjah, abu d...
100%Safe delivery(+971558539980)Abortion pills for sale..dubai sharjah, abu d...hyt3577
 
Cleared Job Fair Handbook | May 2, 2024
Cleared Job Fair Handbook  |  May 2, 2024Cleared Job Fair Handbook  |  May 2, 2024
Cleared Job Fair Handbook | May 2, 2024ClearedJobs.Net
 
2k Shots ≽ 9205541914 ≼ Call Girls In Vinod Nagar East (Delhi)
2k Shots ≽ 9205541914 ≼ Call Girls In Vinod Nagar East (Delhi)2k Shots ≽ 9205541914 ≼ Call Girls In Vinod Nagar East (Delhi)
2k Shots ≽ 9205541914 ≼ Call Girls In Vinod Nagar East (Delhi)Delhi Call girls
 
VIP Russian Call Girls in Indore Komal 💚😋 9256729539 🚀 Indore Escorts
VIP Russian Call Girls in Indore Komal 💚😋  9256729539 🚀 Indore EscortsVIP Russian Call Girls in Indore Komal 💚😋  9256729539 🚀 Indore Escorts
VIP Russian Call Girls in Indore Komal 💚😋 9256729539 🚀 Indore Escortsaditipandeya
 
Arjan Call Girl Service #$# O56521286O $#$ Call Girls In Arjan
Arjan Call Girl Service #$# O56521286O $#$ Call Girls In ArjanArjan Call Girl Service #$# O56521286O $#$ Call Girls In Arjan
Arjan Call Girl Service #$# O56521286O $#$ Call Girls In Arjanparisharma5056
 
RecruZone - Your Recruiting Bounty marketplace
RecruZone - Your Recruiting Bounty marketplaceRecruZone - Your Recruiting Bounty marketplace
RecruZone - Your Recruiting Bounty marketplaceDavide Donghi
 

Dernier (11)

HRM PPT on placement , induction and socialization
HRM PPT on placement , induction and socializationHRM PPT on placement , induction and socialization
HRM PPT on placement , induction and socialization
 
How Leading Companies Deliver Value with People Analytics
How Leading Companies Deliver Value with People AnalyticsHow Leading Companies Deliver Value with People Analytics
How Leading Companies Deliver Value with People Analytics
 
Webinar - How to set pay ranges in the context of pay transparency legislation
Webinar - How to set pay ranges in the context of pay transparency legislationWebinar - How to set pay ranges in the context of pay transparency legislation
Webinar - How to set pay ranges in the context of pay transparency legislation
 
Mastering Vendor Selection and Partnership Management
Mastering Vendor Selection and Partnership ManagementMastering Vendor Selection and Partnership Management
Mastering Vendor Selection and Partnership Management
 
Mercer Global Talent Trends 2024 - Human Resources
Mercer Global Talent Trends 2024 - Human ResourcesMercer Global Talent Trends 2024 - Human Resources
Mercer Global Talent Trends 2024 - Human Resources
 
100%Safe delivery(+971558539980)Abortion pills for sale..dubai sharjah, abu d...
100%Safe delivery(+971558539980)Abortion pills for sale..dubai sharjah, abu d...100%Safe delivery(+971558539980)Abortion pills for sale..dubai sharjah, abu d...
100%Safe delivery(+971558539980)Abortion pills for sale..dubai sharjah, abu d...
 
Cleared Job Fair Handbook | May 2, 2024
Cleared Job Fair Handbook  |  May 2, 2024Cleared Job Fair Handbook  |  May 2, 2024
Cleared Job Fair Handbook | May 2, 2024
 
2k Shots ≽ 9205541914 ≼ Call Girls In Vinod Nagar East (Delhi)
2k Shots ≽ 9205541914 ≼ Call Girls In Vinod Nagar East (Delhi)2k Shots ≽ 9205541914 ≼ Call Girls In Vinod Nagar East (Delhi)
2k Shots ≽ 9205541914 ≼ Call Girls In Vinod Nagar East (Delhi)
 
VIP Russian Call Girls in Indore Komal 💚😋 9256729539 🚀 Indore Escorts
VIP Russian Call Girls in Indore Komal 💚😋  9256729539 🚀 Indore EscortsVIP Russian Call Girls in Indore Komal 💚😋  9256729539 🚀 Indore Escorts
VIP Russian Call Girls in Indore Komal 💚😋 9256729539 🚀 Indore Escorts
 
Arjan Call Girl Service #$# O56521286O $#$ Call Girls In Arjan
Arjan Call Girl Service #$# O56521286O $#$ Call Girls In ArjanArjan Call Girl Service #$# O56521286O $#$ Call Girls In Arjan
Arjan Call Girl Service #$# O56521286O $#$ Call Girls In Arjan
 
RecruZone - Your Recruiting Bounty marketplace
RecruZone - Your Recruiting Bounty marketplaceRecruZone - Your Recruiting Bounty marketplace
RecruZone - Your Recruiting Bounty marketplace
 

Accenture & Headstart - Diversity Hiring Proposition

  • 1. 1Copyright © 2020 Accenture. All rights reserved. WE STAND TOGETHER FOR EQUALITY
  • 2. 2Copyright © 2020 Accenture. All rights reserved. OUR IMMERSIVE VOLUME RECRUITMENT SOLUTION WITH NO ADVERSE EFFECTS ON GENDER OR ETHNICITY
  • 3. 3Copyright © 2020 Accenture. All rights reserved. DIVERSITY IS A KEY CHALLENGE IN RECRUITMENT The impact of ‘soft’ solutions to improve diversity have had negligible impact on the real world The colour of someone’s skin or their name can still be a barrier to social mobility: ethnic minorities are still facing the same levels of discrimination in hiring they did 25 years ago1. The gender pay gap still exists: women earn $73 for every $100 a man makes2. Men are 47 percent more likely to reach senior manager/director positions than their female peers3. Social mobility is harder than it’s ever been: America’s elite colleges admit more young people from the wealthiest 1% than from families in the bottom 60%4 If there is only one minority candidate in a final recruitment pool they have almost no chance of being offered the role. Two minority candidates are at least 79X more likely to be offered the role5
  • 4. 4Copyright © 2020 Accenture. All rights reserved. CANDIDATE EXPERIENCE IS CRITICAL Today, candidates demand seamless experiences in recruitment and true purpose in employment. Purpose matters. An organisation’s stance on inclusivity, candidate centricity and equality will be a key deciding factors for potential talent. Candidate centric solutions should be: • Ensure a consistent experience for all users throughout the journey: know what to expect and how long it will take • Ensure candidates feel the same tone, brand and values throughout Seamless • Modern candidate led technology solutions • AI / automation leveraged to achieve optimum human versus machine solutions Digital • Tailor the experience to meet the needs of both the organisation and the employee • Deliver an experience that has a positive impact on candidates – whether successful or unsuccessful Human • Solutions led by inclusivity and candidate centricity • Mandate a fair experience • Demonstrate flexibility • Remove barriers and biases Inclusive • Design with the future in mind with a solution that is dynamic and flexible • Ensure change and adoption plans as well as solution designs put the user front and center Scalable
  • 5. 5Copyright © 2020 Accenture. All rights reserved. EXISTING PLATFORMS AREN’T FIT FOR PURPOSE Inadequate: not designed for volume hiring 1 2 3 4 • Lack of insight causes costly bottlenecks • System of record, not system of action Biased: puts diverse groups at a disadvantage • Existing screening process susceptible to biases Restricted: candidate UX reduces pipeline • Average 46% completion rate with legacy ATS6 • Disproportionately affects lower socio- economic groups Inefficient: extreme time/efficiency losses • Recruiter workflows are poor with real operating and productivity costs
  • 6. 6Copyright © 2020 Accenture. All rights reserved. THE IMPACT The uncomfortable truth is that the recruitment process is broken and inherently unfair. This leads to: Chronic Mis-hiring Institutional Bias Huge Costs Lost Revenue 75% Estimated that up to 75% of new hires are mis-hires that won’t ever reach the expectations set by the company or themselves7. $bn’s The cost of a mishire is conservatively estimated at $40k9. The cost to a single large enterprise can easily run into the $100m’s. 50%+ The current recruitment practice in most enterprise organisations is inherently biased, disadvantaging women and ethnic minorities by over 50%8. 42%+ 42% of ethnic minority shoppers and 41% of LGBT shoppers would switch to a retailer committed to inclusion and diversity10.
  • 7. 7Copyright © 2020 Accenture. All rights reserved. WHY IS NOW THE TIME FOR CHANGE? TREND 1 TREND 2 TREND 3 Societal spotlight on discrimination Movements and protests focusing on diversity, discrimination and equity in society and actions by corporates to right wrongs Unemployment creates unsustainable volume Higher unemployment rates as a result of COVID-19 leads to increased volume of applications, unsustainable with current resourcing levels Using AI to automate and reduce costs Organizations are looking to reduce cost base whilst increasing flexibility and capability to meet customer demands 7Copyright © 2020 Accenture. All rights reserved.
  • 8. 8Copyright © 2020 Accenture. All rights reserved. WHAT’S GETTING IN THE WAY? Hollow Commitment Old systems are entrenched Business goals remain the priority Meaningful change to driving progress in diversity requires commitment and conviction at the highest levels of your organisation Real board level commitment to action and change is required, as well as influential internal champions who can drive it Existing systems/processes aren’t flexible enough, not fit for purpose, not adaptable. New purpose-built systems need to replace the old systems. Balancing quality of hires with candidate/recruiter experience without high costs and inefficiencies No compromise Accuracy, quality of hiring and business efficiencies have to remain at the core of this change. It must make business sense too.
  • 9. 9Copyright © 2020 Accenture. All rights reserved. WHAT IS THE ANSWER? A simplified process and solution that delivers... Compelling call to action that supports diverse talent pools Great candidate engagement Fairly assess all candidates ‘in context’ and their suitability to the job. Measure potential, not privilege Accurate screening & Assessment Mobile optimised, fair and delivers high completion rates Great application experience Manage high volume pipelines effectively and with ease Optimised Recruitment workflows 9Copyright © 2020 Accenture. All rights reserved.
  • 10. 10Copyright © 2020 Accenture. All rights reserved. DEBIASED RECRUITMENT By reimagining and simplifying the recruiting process with a focus on diversity, inclusion and fairness, we can deliver a high-quality candidate and recruiter experience that in turn delivers high-potential and high caliber applicants. Fairly and bias free. • Understand candidate motivations utilising internal & external research to (existing & prospective) • Identify and segment prospective new recruits • Develop and deploy a data driven attraction strategy, comms plan and campaign • Data driven communication assets and planning for effective campaigns BRANDING & ATTRACTION DIGITAL CANDIDATE EXPERIENCE DIGITAL RECRUITER EXPERIENCE IMMERSIVE ASSESSMENT UNIQUE ASSESSMENT CENTRE OFFER & ONBOARDING • Increase application completion through an intuitive user experience • Mobile optimised interface • Unique applicant ‘profile’ gives candidates control over data and process • Automated Application Matching, including initial questions • Screening conducted against High Performer criteria • Use of deprivation scale enables social mobility by putting relative performance in context • Measurement of potential, not privilege • 1st round selection testing, typically cognitive • Tests developed to assess key skills and capabilities identified for High Performers • Final round Assessment Centre, with possibility of localisation • Behavioural and technical focus of the assessment • Builds on the experience of the recruitment process • Pre-defined onboarding approach with clear visibility for the new recruit • Transparent expectations for time to productivity and key capabilities • Continued communication platform engages and informs the candidate reducing drop off Real-time analytics enables the adjustment of attraction channels based on applicants’ profile mix Performance on stage 1 assessment enables review of criteria weightings in application process Performance on stage 1 assessment enables review of criteria weightings in application process
  • 11. 11Copyright © 2020 Accenture. All rights reserved. PURPOSE DRIVEN BRANDING & ATTRACTION Define internal and external perceptions Articulate Employer Value Proposition Data driven innovative recruitment campaign production Rediscover your organisations Inner Purpose Determine talent segmentation strategy
  • 12. 12Copyright © 2020 Accenture. All rights reserved. SCREEN CANDIDATES FAIRLY AND CONTEXTUALLY Responsive design accessible on any candidate device • Score every candidate against a single framework to ensure equal, debiased screening • Use of deprivation scale enables social mobility by putting relative performance in context of their life • Allow candidates to apply as their true selves on gender, sexuality, ethnicity and more to increase application completions • Capture variety of data points on candidate background
  • 13. 13Copyright © 2020 Accenture. All rights reserved. CONTEXTUAL SCREENING COMPONENTS Industry Type Time Sematic Skill Matching Match Score Skills Work Experience Socioeconomic Index Grades Income Education Deprivation index University School Subjects Degree types Degree Grades
  • 14. 14Copyright © 2020 Accenture. All rights reserved. PRIORITISE LARGE VOLUMES OF APPLICANTS Modern recruiter experience Personalised communications Reduce recruiter manual work resulting in $$ savings Search and sort by eligibility and suitability Full pipeline tracking Bulk actions and automations for saving time Applicants prioritised by suitability and without bias Hiring accuracy through data science Copyright © 2020 Accenture. All rights reserved. 14
  • 15. 15Copyright © 2020 Accenture. All rights reserved. ANALYTICS FOR DIVERSITY Powerful analytics to enable actionable insights 15
  • 16. 16Copyright © 2020 Accenture. All rights reserved. CORE BENEFITS More flexibility Market differentiation Eliminatingbias by design Driving quality in volumerecruitment Candidate Experience Copyright © 2020 Accenture. All rights reserved.
  • 17. 17Copyright © 2020 Accenture. All rights reserved. ACCENTURE CASE STUDY: THE HIGHLIGHTS 110,000: applications via Headstart across 13 countries 92.25%: Avg. applicant match score for London Consulting, post Assessment Centre 90%: Increase in female entry hiring into technology 2.5%: Increase in Afro Caribbean hires for core programmes $2.1m: in cost-savings, with 55% lower cost-per-hire “With Headstart, female entry level hiring into technology grew by 90% in the UK, increasing from 32% in FY17 to 61% in FY18” Helen Lorigan, Accenture Candidate Management Lead “The results of these efforts are impressive,” RedThread/Mercer Report: Identified increases in gender & diversity hiring, alongside $2.1m in savings due to automation
  • 18. 18Copyright © 2020 Accenture. All rights reserved. HEADSTART TRUE STORIES Copyright © 2020 Accenture. All rights reserved. Born in Dagenham - the 12th poorest out of 326 local authorities in the UK Attended school in an area with more murder investigations than anywhere else in the UK Went to Leicester University ranked outside the 150 globally Now with the help of Headstart, a consultant at Accenture since January 2019. Nina Showobi* *Name changed to protect privacy Nina is not alone - Headstart have impacted the hires of 100s of the brightest most marginalised candidates. “The application process was so different to anything else I’ve applied for.”
  • 19. 19Copyright © 2020 Accenture. All rights reserved. Driving business and societal progress through innovative technologies WE KNOW YOU/YOU KNOW US We know your ambition is to create the best in class people, culture and ways of working. HUMAN-CENTRED METHODOLOGY Pioneering digital recruitment through design-led methodology putting the candidate at the heart of a seamless recruitment process. WE BRING UNPARALLELLED ASSETS Our industry knowledge, research and digital savvy solutions weave technology into the fabric of the best in class design. WE BRING UNPARALLED TECHNOLOGICAL EXPERTISE Shape innovation and agility through new technologies, such as Virtual Reality, data and workforce analytics and insights to drive a more strategic and value-adding experience and solution. WE DELIVER Execution is in our DNA. We are strategic thinkers and thought leaders who also deliver solutions. We are committed to achieve what we promise and we have the capabilities to provide pace and certainty along the journey. SCREEN EVERY CANDIDATE FAIRLY Match score machine learning framework screens every candidate equally and fairly. SOCIOECONOMIC DATA IN MACHINE LEARNING The only applicant matching and management system to use socioeconomic data to assess candidates in context. BUILT FOR ENTERPRISE Secure, stable, and reliable technology platform for use by enterprise organizations. Copyright © 2020 Accenture. All rights reserved. REMOVE UNCONSCIOUS BIAS Measurement of potential, not privilege DATA DRIVEN DIVERSITY Understand how to measure progress and engagement against diversity targets ENGAGING CANDIDATE EXPERIENCES inclusive and bias-free. ACTIONABLE INSIGHTS Data, insights and reports that deliver actionable results – for candidates and companies.
  • 20. 20Copyright © 2020 Accenture. All rights reserved. CONTACTS: Eimear Meredith Jones Kate Ellen John Fennessy Accenture Accenture Headstart
  • 21. 21Copyright © 2020 Accenture. All rights reserved. REFERENCES 1 – https://hbr.org/2017/10/hiring-discrimination-against-black-americans-hasnt-declined-in-25-years 2 - https://www.accenture.com/_acnmedia/PDF-73/Accenture-When-She-Rises-We-All-Rise.pdf#zoom=50 3- https://www.accenture.com/_acnmedia/PDF-73/Accenture-When-She-Rises-We-All-Rise.pdf#zoom=50 – 8% (M) 22% (SM) 4- https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2017/01/18/upshot/some-colleges-have-more-students-from-the-top-1-percent- than-the-bottom-60.html 5 – https://hbr.org/2016/04/if-theres-only-one-woman-in-your-candidate-pool-theres-statistically-no-chance-shell-be- hired 6 - https://redthreadresearch.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/08/RedThread_DI_Report_Reduced_Final.pdf 7 – http://press.careerbuilder.com/2017-12-07-Nearly-Three-in-Four-Employers-Affected-by-a-Bad-Hire-According-to-a- Recent-CareerBuilder-Survey 8 – https://www.bls.gov/ncs/ect/ 9 – http://www.thedynamicsale.com/wp-content/uploads/2014/06/Avoid-Costly-Mis-Hires-by-Bradford-Smart.pdf 10 - https://www.thevaluable500.com/wp-content/themes/valuable500/downloads/files/The_Valuable_500_release.pdf