Clare Hooper from Liverpool University Press delivered a session on getting published. It includes insight into how the submission process works and advice to researchers about what to do and what not to do.
6. Finding the right journal
• Check your article is within the scope of the
journal you are submitting to!
• Familiarise yourself with the journal – speak with
colleagues/mentors – read it online?
• Follow the author guidelines/submission
procedures
• Send a speculative email to the editor if you are
unsure
• Don’t submit to more than one journal at once!
7. Open Access?
• Is journal fully OA/Hybrid?
• Funder requirements?
• CC – BY licence
You are free to:
Share — copy and redistribute the material in any
medium or format
Adapt — remix, transform, and build upon the material
for any purpose, even commercially
8. Indications of quality
• Editorial Board – distinguished? International?
• Brand – aware of the journal?
• Altmetrics?
• Abstracting & Indexing
• Impact Factor?
9. What is an Impact Factor?
the average number of times articles from the
journal published in the last two years have
been cited in the JCR year
Thomson - “a measure of the frequency with which the "average
article" in a journal has been cited in a particular year or period. The
annual JCR impact factor is a ratio between citations and recent citable
items published. Thus, the impact factor of a journal is calculated by
dividing the number of current year citations to the source items
published in that journal during the previous two years”
10. • A = the number of times that all items published
in that journal in 2013 and 2014 were cited by ISI
journals during 2015.
• B = the total number of "citable items" published
by that journal in 2013 and 2014. ("Citable items"
- articles, reviews, proceedings, or notes).
• A/B = 2015 Impact Factor
• 2015 Impact Factor published in 2016
11. Submitting your paper
• Abstract – needs to be clear and concise, outline
your argument
• Prepare your paper – title, authors, keyword list,
abstract, acknowledgments, references, illustrations
• Ask a colleague to check your work
• Write a review or a response – this is a good way to
get published (esp. for people at the beginning of
their career)
• Cover letter – don’t repeat abstract
12. Copyright
As the author, you need to ensure that you get
permission to use content you have not created
(to avoid delays, this should be done before you
submit your work)
Supply written confirmation from the copyright
holder when submitting your manuscript
If permission cannot be cleared, cannot publish
that specific content
14. How long?
• Editor does initial read – determine subject
matter/research appropriate
• Contacting of reviewers
• Reviewers – around 6-8 weeks to complete
• Editor assesses reviews and makes decision
• Usually takes around 3 months – can vary!
15. What happens if the paper is rejected?
• Ask for feedback
• Take feedback into account, improve the
paper, resubmit somewhere else?
• Don’t give up
17. Your article has been accepted and
published!
Promoting your work
• Share your work
• Be visible online
• Conferences – present your work
• Social Media
18. • Increase visiblity & impact
• Create ‘profiles’ for published articles
• Claim article, enrich with content, share to
social channels
• Measure impact of activity
• www.growkudos.com
19. • collect article level metrics and the online
conversations around research papers by
tracking a selection of online indicators to give
a measurement of digital impact and reach
• ‘Altmetric Attention Score’ to reflect the idea
that the aim is to measure the attention
around a given article, not just citations
20. • You can also measure your impact through usage
statistics (your publisher can supply) and
citations (what are the most valuable in your
subject area/country?)
21.
22. Thank you
Clare Hooper, Head of Journals
Liverpool University Press
Clare.Hooper@liverpool.ac.uk
@ClareHooperLUP
Notes de l'éditeur
So – a little bit about LUP?
Founded in 1899
UK's third oldest university press and one of its fastest growing publishers in recent years
Publishes approximately 70 books a year and 28 journals
13 members of staff
We are primarily a Humanities and Social Sciences publisher
Our 70 books and 28 journals specialise in literature, modern languages, history and visual culture
If you will allow a little brag….in 2015 LUP was awarded
The Bookseller Independent, Academic, Educational and Professional Publisher of the Year 2015
AND
The IPG Academic and Professional Publisher of the Year 2015
First university press to win the award, recent recipients SAGE Publications and Bloomsbury Academic
These awards reflect the journey that the Press has been through from our relaunch in 2004 (had 3 journals and 7 books) to where we are now in 2016.
Huge achievement
Open-ness to new ideas and new thinking, which made us agile as Publishers
Here to talk a little bit about publication process – focus on journals, not books
Your first task – to find the right journal to submit your work to….
Seems obvious, but make sure your article is within the scope of the journal you are submitting to
Look at the journals in your discipline? What are the top ones? Be realistic – you might not get published in a top journal straight away
Is it a journal you read yourself? If it’s a top journal, it’s most likely available in your institution’s library – have a look! Is it suitable? Is it publishing similar work to yours?
Important tip - make sure you follow the author guidelines, which vary between journals – has it an online submission system?
Don’t submit to more than one journal at once.
Some questions to ask yourself about open access?
Do you have funder requirements? Some funders require any publications coming from the research they are funding to be OA. Check!
They might also specify the license that the article needs to be published under – CC-BY being the most common. You need to understand what this means for your work…
Is there an APC?
An article publishing charge - fee which is sometimes charged to authors to make a work available open access. This fee is usually paid by an author's institution or research funder rather than by the author themselves.
Are you an early career researcher – does your publisher have any policies regarding that?
LUP Authors Fund - The aim of the fund is to support gold open access publication by early career researchers in the humanities and social sciences.
Established LUP authors may donate all or part of their royalties to the Fund, and all contributions are then match-funded by the press
How to find out the quality of a journal?
Take a look at the editorial board – are they international, are they distinguished/well known?
What’s the brand of the journal? Are you aware of it? Do you read it? Do you cite it?
Are there any altmetrics available for the journal – we can talk about altmetrics a little later…
Is the journal included in any of the well know indices – Thomson Web of Science? Elsevier’s Scopus?
Most people have heard of Thomson Reuters ISI? (institute for scientific information)
a journal ranking system devised to measure the quality of journals based on citations.
If you are publishing in the Social Sciences/Sciences – does the journal has an impact factor?
(Factors taken into account when evaluating journals for coverage in Web of Science:
The journal's basic publishing standards
its editorial content
the international diversity of its authorship,
the citation data associated with it are all considered)
Use the Impact Factor. What is an impact factor….?
Thomson release a JCR Journal Citation Report every year
The Impact Factor is the average number of times articles from the journal published in the last two years have been cited in that year
Dead easy right? :D
If A is the number of times all items published in the journal were cited by other ISI ranked journals
And B is the total number of citable items published in the journal…
Then Thomson divide A/B to create impact factor.
Always published in the following year
In 2015 The Guardian asked some journal editors for advice on submitting a paper… some responses included
Abstract – needs to be clear and concise, outline your argument – don’t bury it, make sure it runs through the paper and ties together the theory and empirical material
Prepare your paper – title, authors, keyword list, abstract, acknowledgments, references, illustrations
Ask a colleague to check your work
Write a review or a response – this is a good way to get published (esp. for people at the beginning of their career)
Cover letter – don’t repeat abstract – needs to be an indication of what you think is most interesting and significant about the paper
As the author, you need to ensure that you get permission to use content you have not created before submitting your manuscript
e.g. tables, figures, illustrations, photographs and more
Supply written confirmation from the copyright holder when submitting your manuscript
Failing to do so exposes you to potential legal risks
Usually people will only be too happy to grant permission and will appreciate being asked
If permission cannot be cleared, we cannot republish that specific content
Once you have chosen the journal, and submitted it….
A little bit of info on the process from the submission of paper to the editorial decision
Three decision results – accept, reject, revise and resubmit
Revise and Resubmit decision
Remember that revise and resubmit may be a good thing, although seems not at time – editor invested/interested in paper
Remember human beings involved in all stages, be patient! Be polite!
Remember to respond directly and calmly to reviewer comments when you resubmit.
Ask why paper has been rejected - most editors will respond in detail
Try to improve the paper, resubmit elsewhere, makes sure target your paper to that journal’s aims and scope
Don’t give up – it may be you have just not submitted to the right journal!
So - your article has been accepted!
Share your paper – send the online link to colleagues, students etc
Personal page on your institution website? Keep your author profiles up to date (ORCID, SCOPUS)
Conferences – present your work to your peers
Social Media - approximately 313 million monthly active users on Twitter - seems to be the favourable social networking site for scholarly communication
pressure on academics to demonstrate the impact of their work - quick and easy way to reach wider audiences and have an impact on a broader community
Not about showing off, or trying to tick certain boxes for an employer, it is about communicating with other scholars, keeping up-to-date with your field & ensuring that your work reaches as wide an audience as possible
Lots of ways your publisher can help to promote your work….
Liverpool University Press is partnered with Kudos - main aim is helping authors increase the visibility and impact of their work
a new way for authors to use social media to engage the digital community with their research – free to researchers!
By creating 'profiles' for their published articles and adding short titles, lay summaries, impact statements and supplementary content, authors can make their articles more engaging
The steps to using Kudos are simple, all you have to do is claim your published articles, enrich them with content, and share them out to various social channels. You will also be able to measure the impact of your activity through personalised metrics.
On average, authors who make use of Kudos' tools receive 19% higher downloads of their work.
There is a huge amount of published work coming out every year - it’s hard to stand out.
Having your work out there on social media increases the likelihood of it reaching different outlets - such as newspapers, blogs, and magazines - this is the kind of data that Altmetric look at.
Altmetric collect article level metrics and the online conversations around research papers. They track a selection of online indicators to give a measurement of digital impact and reach
‘Mentions’ that contain links to any version of the same paper are picked up, and collated.
The result is the ‘Altmetric Attention Score’ - reflect the idea that their aim is to measure the attention around a given article, not just citations.
Having an Altmetric Attention Score is another way to measure the broader impact of your work, and using social media is one way in which you can increase your score.
University of Liverpool is an institutional member of Altmetric, so easy for you to get access to your attention score
I recommend that you use a number of tools to get the most accurate measure of the impact of your research.
Consider which citation indices are considered the most valuable in your country and subject area, find out from your publisher how many times your article has been downloaded, use software such as Altmetric or Kudos which measures the visibility of your work on social media.
With that, I will finish.