This document provides an overview of Martha G. Russell's presentation on transformational value creation through network orchestration to Danish advertising executives. The presentation discusses forces affecting today's work environment and skills, levers for knowledge network productivity, and guidelines for network orchestration. It provides examples of public-private partnerships, research consortia, startups in various fields, and work related to technology transfer, marketing, and organizational change. The presentation emphasizes the importance of relationships in innovation ecosystems and outlines Stanford University's uniqueness in bridging academia and industry through its culture and resources.
2. • Transformative Value Creation in Your
Innovation Ecosystem Network
– Forces Affecting Today’s Work Environment
• And the skills to go with them
• Program, sector, region, country
– Levers for Knowledge Network Productivity
– Guidelines for Network Orchestration
3.
4. Martha G Russell
• Public-private partnerships – for science, technology & development
– Tecnopolis, MAMTech, IC2 Institute, Incubators linking SMEs to Value Chain,
CSATA, Agricultural Experiment Station, UNIDO
• Research consortia: University – Industry IDR Research initiatives for
education, research and outreach
– Microelectronic and Information Sciences Center
– Center for the Development of Technology Leadership
– Burnt Orange Productions
– IC2 Institute (Innovation, Creativity, Capital) Think and Do Tank
• Startups in
– Genetic engineering for cyclodextrins, Needleless injection, Aquaculture
– Online market research, desktop CSAT benchmarking, market segmentation
• Technology Transfer, Marketing and Organizational Change
– Internet2 Sociotechnical Summit, 1999
– Relationship-focused innovation ecosystems
• Catalyst – Innovator - Enabler
9. Stanford’s
Uniqueness
H-‐STAR
HUMAN
SCIENCES
AND
TECHNOLOGIES
ADVANCED
RESEARCH
INSTITUTE
Stanford
Facts
Seven
schools:
Earth
Sciences,
Educa)on,
Engineering,
Graduate
School
of
Business,
Humani)es
and
Sciences,
Law,
Medicine
1,771
regular
academic
faculty
6,705
undergraduate
students
from
68
countries
8,176
graduate
students
from
95
countries
9
independent
laboratories/centers
Several
na)onal
research
centers
(CASBS,
NBER,
SLAC)
4,500+
externally
sponsored
research
projects
Budget
for
sponsored
research
$975
million
87%
from
government
sources
~$122
million
/
yr
from
corpora)ons,
founda)ons
and
individuals
Media
X
sponsors
X-‐dept
X-‐discipline
research
on
IT
and
people
ques)ons
5
Professional
Schools,
all
ranked
in
Top
Ten
Few
other
Univ
have
all
5,
no
other
has
5
in
Top
Ten
10. The REAL Issue
Deep Knowledge with Wide Applicability
IN
THE
HEART
OF
SILICON
VALLEY
IN
A
CULTURE
OF
RAPID
ITERATION,
WHERE
DISRUPTION
IS
CELEBRATED
WHERE
TALENT,
INFORMATION
AND
CAPITAL
RESOURCES
FLOURISH
THE
ISSUE
IS
NOT
THE
RATE
TECHNOLOGY
TRANSFER
THE
ISSUE
IS
THE
EFFECTIVENESS
OF
INNOVATION
AND
KNOWLEDGE
TRANSFER
WE
CALL
THIS
“COLLABORATIVE
DISCOVERY”
OUR
APPROACH
WORK
ON
BOLD
IDEAS
WITH
BUSINESS,
TEST
SUCCESS/FAILURE
CONDITIONS,
ITERATE
RESULTS
QUICKLY,
TRANSFER
INSIGHTS
AT
EVERY
STAGE
11. H-‐STAR
HUMAN
SCIENCES
AND
TECHNOLOGIES
ADVANCED
RESEARCH
INSTITUTE
RELATIONSHIP
INTERFACES
FOR
DISCOVERY
COLLABORATIONS
Goal:
Do
something
together
neither
of
us
could
do
by
ourselves.
Research
on
people
and
technology
—
how
people
use
technology,
how
to
beeer
design
technology
to
make
it
more
usable,
how
technology
affects
people’s
lives,
and
the
innovaEve
use
of
technologies
in
research,
educa)on,
art,
business,
commerce,
entertainment,
communica)on,
security,
and
other
walks
of
life.
12. Stanford University Medical Media
& Information Technology
SUMMIT Distributed Vision Lab
DVL
Media X"
Discovery Collaborations !
Electrical Engineering Span Stanford Labs!
Psychology
Computer
Science EE Psy Linguistics Communication Between Humans
Philosophy Ling and Interactive Media
CS CHIMe
Phil SHL Stanford Humanities Lab
Graduate School
VHIL GSB Of Business
Virtual Human Stanford Center
Interaction Lab SCIL for Innovations
in Learning
Center for the Study Of
CSLI Language & Information
Art Digital Art
Center
EngineeringEng
& Product
Design School of Education;
Ed Education and
PBLL Law Learning Sciences
Work
Technology & Center for
Organization SSP Legal
Des Stanford Joint
PBLL Program in Design
Project Based Informatics d.school
Learning Symbolic LIFE
Laboratory Systems Program Learning in Informal and
Formal Environments
13. Infrastructure
for
Network
Orchestra)on
-‐
-‐
-‐
Rela)onships
The Way We USED to Think About Organizations New
Organiza)onal
Chart
Based
on
Rela)onships
Relationship-Focused Co-Creation Infrastructure
(Companies
are
interlocked
through
key
people
–
informaPon
flow,
norms,
mental
models.(Davis,1996)
14. Alumni Entrepreneurial
Leadership Networks
The unique culture at Stanford:
Is strongly oriented toward world-class research
Expects socially-conscious, business-relevant intellectual leadership
- at every level of its research, education, and service
Facilitates frequent and fluid interaction with the business community
Respects contributions from non-academic colleagues
Fosters expectation that alumni will become innovators
15. Media
X’s
Unique
proposi)on
• Pose
a
ques)on
to
the
Stanford
thought
leaders
that
will
create
– Opportuni)es
for
discovery
collabora)ons
– On
novel
research
– That
leverages
the
latest
research
results
– To
iden)fy
the
new
ques)ons
that
will
lead
to
– Insights
that
address
edge
ques)ons
– 3
to
5
years
out
• Par)cipate
in
the
discovery
process
to
learn
• The
best
ques)ons
and
how
to
pursue
them
• Ra)onale
of
research
pathways
–
why?
why
not?
16. Members
Provide
the
Direc)on
• Huawei
• Accel
Partners
• Intel
• Apollo
Group
• Konica
Minolta
• Best
Buy
• Nissan
• BT
• Philips
• Capitol
One
• SAP
• Cisco
• Danish
Innova)on
• Singularity
• Fueon
• State
Farm
• FXPal
• Teleplace
• Hewlee
Packard
• TEKES
• HKUST
EMBAs
• Terapac
• Venable
Bell
&
Partners
17. Build
Capacity
for
Insights
-‐
Sooner
• Time
advantage
– 3
years
ahead
of
reading
the
latest
publica)ons
• Relevance
advantage
– Ques)ons
relevant
to
Samsung’s
future
• Lower
risk
of
explora)on
– Rapid
itera)on
– Know
sooner
what
works
– Externalizes
high
risk
• Capacity
building
– Iden)fy
new
exper)se
needed
– Enhance
exis)ng
exper)se
– Leverage
the
Stanford
network
18. ParEcipate
in
the
Media
X
HSTAR
Community
• Membership
• Visiting Researchers
http://mediax.stanford.edu/ • Research Initiatives
§ Martha.Russell@stanford.edu • Workshops
• Seminars
• Conferences
19. Changing
Energy
TransformaEon
Eco-‐System
Behavior
of
Consumers
TECHNOLOGY
PROGRAMS MODELING
PLATFORM SYSTEM
COLLECT
PRESENT
&
&
CAPTURE SENSOR FOUNDATIONAL ECONOMETRIC
DEVELOPMENT WORK ESTIMATION INFORM
PERVASIVE COMMUNICATION MEDIA WEB ENABLED INDIVIDUAL GROUP
SEGMENTATION
SENSORS NETWORK PROGRAMS
DEVICES
POLICY MULTI-AGENT
DATABASE PROGRAMS SIMULATION
COMMUNITY
ANALYTICS
PROGRAMS
ENERGY TRANSFORMATION BEHAVIOR
USE ENGINE CHANGE
20. Drivers of Change
Future Work Skills 2020 (2011) Institute for the Future and The University of Phoenix.
27. The Nature of Work is
Changing
• Past • Future
– Full-time – Decentralized
– Paid for time spent at – No particular time or
work place
– Common location – Beyond cognitive
– Stable hierarchies competencies
– What & how they do – Jobs reflect way of life
their jobs is prescribed Human
poten)al
will
be
the
major
agent
of
economic
growth,
and
how
to
unleash
then
– Evaluated by superiors leverage
that
poten)al
will
be
the
key
ques)on
organiza)ons
will
need
to
answer.
Talent
is
emerging
as
the
new
“IT”
David Bollier, (2011) The Future of Work: What it Means for Individuals, Businesses, Market and Governments,” The Aspen Institute.
28. A Revolution is Coming In the Productivity
of Knowledge Work
35. Measuring
&
Increasing
Knowledge
Worker
Produc)vity
Productivity of Knowledge Workers
Media
X
Themed
Research
selected from 25 proposals
7 projects
Harnessing Social Evaluations on Content:
Using Video Game Platforms to Understand Social Cues and Reliability in Information and
Thinking Styles of People Engaged in Knowledge Sharing
Collaboration
The Utility of Calming
EteRNA: Accelerating Knowledge Creation for Technologies in Improving Creativity and Culture: Understanding Team
RNA Bioengineering through Internet-Scale Productivity Creativity and What Fosters It
Gaming
A Journey from Islands of Knowledge to
Process Integration Platform: Enabling
Mutual Understanding In Global Business
Process Transparency Within Teams and
Meetings
scaling of Process Knowledge Across the
Entire Firm
35
36. The
new
maps
may
be
based
on
the
connec)ons
-‐
rather
than
on
distance.
§ Ecosystem
Perspec)ve
§ Rela)onship
based
§ Links
form
networks
§ Resource
flows
=
knowledge,
capital,
talent
§ Network
orchestra)on
38. Can Health Spread As Well
As Disease?
Transmitting Relationships Happiness Networks
Salathe´ M, Jones JH (2010) Dynamics and Control of Diseases in
Networks with Community Structure. PLoS Comput Biol 6(4):
e1000736. doi:10.1371/ journal.pcbi.1000736
Contact – Vulnerability - Conditions
Access - Trust - Relevance
James H Fowler and Nicholas A Christakis, “Dynamic Spread of
Happiness in a Large Social Network: longitudinal analysis over 20
years in the Framingham Heart Study network,” BMJ 2008;337
40. Case
Study
-‐
CapDigital
Conducted
stakeholder
interviews
to
understand
shared
vision,
tap
knowledge
in
prac)ce,
iden)fy
transforma)onal
metrics
• CapDigital
staff
• CapDigital
members:
– Small
startup
– Large
company
– Collabora)on
Vision
To
catalyze
the
new
digital
infrastructure
in
France
with
global
connec)ons
To
create
an
ecosystem
to
facilitate
the
rela)onship
between
France
and
global
market
Enable
Paris
to
become
global
region
of
the
market
for
digital
services
Innova)on
Ecosystems
Network
November
40
2010
44. Zone
1
Opportunity
VC
Community
In
Zone
1,
most
of
the
companies
are
highly
connected
with
VC
or
other
companies.
VCs
are
making
investments
ac)vely
-‐
many
high
poten)al
opportuni)es
to
funding.
Venture
&
financing
provides
local
rela)onships
Alto-‐invest
Funds
6
French
media
companies,
none
are
CapDigital
members
Some
funded
by
other
VCs
also
Some
VCs
and
companies
provide
global
rela)onships
– Unruly
Media
(headquartered
in
London)
– Unruly
Media
helps
agencies
and
marketers
distribute
branded
content
on
the
social
web.
– Using
a
cost-‐per-‐engagement
pricing
model
and
non-‐interrup)ve
adver)sing
formats,
Unruly
Media’s
global
network
of
influen)al
blogs,
cult
web
proper)es,
video
sites,
and
social
media
applica)ons
brings
scale,
targe)ng,
and
safety
to
a
fragmented
and
chao)c
long-‐tail
media
landscape.
– Founded
in
2006
by
Scoe
Bueon,
Mae
Cooke
and
Sarah
Wood,
Unruly
is
headquartered
in
London,
UK.
Innova)on
Ecosystems
Network
44
45. Zone
2
Opportunity
Poten)al
New
Members
for
Cap
Digital
In
zone
2,
most
of
the
companies
have
fewer
connec)ons
There
are
many
French
based
companies,
to
which
CapDigital
reach
out
Some
zone
2
companies
already
have
global
connec)ons
to
be
leveraged.
• Webwag
publishes
Mobile
and
Web
widget
convergent
solu)ons,
helps
users
create
a
personalized
home
page
with
data
feeds
and
web
2.0
services
that
are
always
accessible
from
any
computer
or
mobile.
Its
technologies
are
made
available
in
white
brand
to
its
customers
that
include
Network
Operators,
handset
and
connected
devices
manufacturers,
service
owners
and
media
publishers.
Innova)on
Ecosystems
Network
45
46. Zone
3
Opportunity
Expand
Global
Network
Many
foreign
companies
in
Zone
3
-‐
opportuni)es
for
CapDigital
to
seek
interna)onal
partnerships.
Wellington
Partners
• A
venture
capital
firm
that
invests
in
French
and
intl
firms
in
Digital
Media
and
Sotware
• Offices
in
Munich,
London,
Palo
Alto,
Zuirch.
• Co-‐invests
with
a
French
VC.
Innova)on
Ecosystems
Network
46
48. Companies, branches,
financial orgs
In the ~75,000 companies in ICT
1772 companies described with “educat”
THE GLOBAL NETWORK:
Independent
Only small proportion have outside investors
Network is not evident
Innovation Ecosystems Dataset, September 2011
52. Global ecosystem of learning
technology companies
Innovation Ecosystems Dataset, September 2011
53. Measuring Impact of
Transformative Coalitions
Impact Measure & Track
Co-Create
网
网
Value
Shared
Vision
网
Transforma)on
Event
Coalition
Interact &
Feedback
Martha G. Russell, Kaisa Still, Jukka Huhtamaki, and Neil Rubens, “Transforming innovation ecosystems through shared vision
and network orchestration,” Triple Helix IX Conference, Stanford University, July 13, 2011.
54.
55. HARVEST
Investments
from
Chinese
(making
investments)
Neil
Rubens,
Kaisa
S)ll,
Jukka
Huhtamaki,
Martha
G.
Russell,
A
Network
Analysis
of
Investment
Firms
as
Resource
Routers
in
Chinese
Innova)on
Ecosystem,
Journal
of
Networks,
Fall,
2010.
Innova)on
Ecosystem
Network
56. CULTIVATION
Investments
into
China
(receiving
investments)
Neil
Rubens,
Kaisa
S)ll,
Jukka
Huhtamaki,
Martha
G.
Russell
A
Network
Analysis
of
Investment
Firms
as
Resource
Routers
in
Chinese
Innova)on
Ecosystem,
Journal
of
Networks,
Fall,
2010.
Innova)on
Ecosystem
Network
57. Emerging
Chinese
business
clusters
linked
by
firms’
rela)onships
Neil
Rubens,
Kaisa
S)ll,
Jukka
Huhtamaki,
Martha
G.
Russell
A
Network
Analysis
of
Investment
Firms
as
Resource
Routers
in
Chinese
Innova)on
Ecosystem,
Journal
of
Networks,
Fall,
2010.
58. A City’s Reputation for Innovation
hep://www.flickr.com/photos/3670644995_d5bcb5b8f6_o.jpg/
59. Collected Tweets with “#innovat*” for 12 months
Analyzed by hashtag co-occurrence
Analyzed text by city – WORDL
Camilla Yu, Jan Poeschke,, Martha G. Russell, Kaisa Still, Neil Rubens, Jukka Huhtamaki, “Social media, reputation and branding
of innovation hubs: A periscope using network analysis of Twitter,” Triple Helix IX Conference, Stanford University, July 13, 2011.
60. Boston
Camilla
Yu,
Jan
Poeschke,
Martha
G.
Russell,
Kaisa
S)ll,
Neil
Rubens,
Jukka
Huhtamaki,
“Social
media,
reputa)on
and
branding
of
innova)on
hubs:
A
periscope
using
network
analysis
of
Twieer,”
Triple
Helix
IX
Conference,
Stanford
University,
July
13,
2011.
61. London
Camilla
Yu,
Jan
Poeschke,
Martha
G.
Russell,
Kaisa
S)ll,
Neil
Rubens,
Jukka
Huhtamaki,
“Social
media,
reputa)on
and
branding
of
innova)on
hubs:
A
periscope
using
network
analysis
of
Twieer,”
Triple
Helix
IX
Conference,
Stanford
University,
July
13,
2011.
62. New York City
Camilla
Yu,
,Jan
Poeschke,
Martha
G.
Russell,
Kaisa
S)ll,
Neil
Rubens,
Jukka
Huhtamaki,
“Social
media,
reputa)on
and
branding
of
innova)on
hubs:
A
periscope
using
network
analysis
of
Twieer,”
Triple
Helix
IX
Conference,
Stanford
University,
July
13,
2011.
63. Recipe for Buzz
Camilla
Yu,
,Jan
Poeschke,
Martha
G.
Russell,
Kaisa
S)ll,
Neil
Rubens,
Jukka
Huhtamaki,
“Social
media,
reputa)on
and
branding
of
innova)on
hubs:
A
periscope
using
network
analysis
of
Twieer,”
Triple
Helix
IX
Conference,
Stanford
University,
July
13,
2011.
64. Measuring Impact of
Transformative Coalitions
Impact Measure & Track
Co-Create
网
网
Value
Shared
Vision
网
Transforma)on
Event
Coalition
Interact &
Feedback
Martha G. Russell, Kaisa Still, Jukka Huhtamaki, and Neil Rubens, “Transforming innovation ecosystems through shared vision
and network orchestration,” Triple Helix IX Conference, Stanford University, July 13, 2011.
66. What Can We Do Together
That Neither of Us Could Do Alone?
Thank You
Martha.Russell@stanford.edu
www.innovation-ecosystems.com
http://mediax.stanford.edu