SlideShare une entreprise Scribd logo
1  sur  13
Télécharger pour lire hors ligne
A Seedlink Tech White Paper
in Collaboration with International Top Talent
February 2014
www.seedlinktech.com
www.RCXUE.com
Using Natural Language Processing to Improve Speed
and Quality of Employee Recruiting
QuestMatch:
Table of Contents
Introduction ..................................................................................................
Key China Data .............................................................................................
Key Research Findings....................................................................................
Discussion ....................................................................................................
Questions Are Key to Job Analysis .........................................................
Less Screening, More Interacting ...........................................................
................................................
Use Technology to do More with Less .....................................................
QuestMatch .................................................................................................
QuestMatch Data ..........................................................................................
...................
Conclusions ..................................................................................................
References ...................................................................................................
3
4
5
6
6
7
7
7
8
9
10
11
12
Introduction
but it is especially labor-intensive in emerging markets. With a
workforce of nearly 800 million, screening résumés in China is
extremely tedious and low-value. McKinsey reports that only 10%
(MNC). Seedlink case studies indicate
that sourcing just one suitable Chinese
candidate requires reviewing between
50 – 100 résumés or CVs. The
challenging recruitment environment
in China can offset the vast market
opportunities.
This paper covers three main topics. First, we will outline key
recruiting literature. Then, we suggest a four-step process for
Finally, we introduce the concept of Natural Language Processing
(NLP) and QuestMatch to improve speed, while managing the
entire pre-interview process.
With a combination of continued
process improvement and cutting-
edge technology, companies can
vastly improve the quality of recruits
while reducing overall cost. The
improvements can impact company
Second, better matches reduce overall turnover rate and in turn,
off-boarding and replacement costs. RCXUE with QuestMatch
provides an intuitive interface to bring NLP to the most demanding
companies’ recruitment practices.
McKinsey reports that only 10%
at a multinational corporation
Better matches reduce overall
turnover rate and thus off-
boarding and replacement costs
3
QuestMatch: Using Natural Language Processing to Improve Speed and Quality of Employee Recruiting
Key China Data
Figure 1:
790 million people in active labor force 1
7 million college graduates in 2013 2
Nearly 200 million total college graduates by 20203
4
20% of CVs and résumés 5
6
80% of turnover is due to bad hiring decisions 7
1
2
“College Graduation Data”, China Ministry of Education, 2013.
3
ibid
4
Diana Farrell and Andrew Grant, “Addressing China’s Looming Talent Shortage,” McKinsey Global Insights Research,
5
-
6
“Retention: Is It Getting Enough Attention,” Hays Research, 2012.
7
4
QuestMatch: Using Natural Language Processing to Improve Speed and Quality of Employee Recruiting
8
Fritzsche and Brannick, “The Importance of Representative Design in Judgment Tasks: The Case of Resume Screening,”
Journal of Occupational and Organizational Psychology 75, no.2 (June 2002): 163.
9
Cole et al., “Recruiters’ Perceptions and Use of Applicant Resume Information: Screening the Recent Graduate,” Applied
Psychology: An International Review 56, no.2 (April 2007): 319 – 343.
10
James M. Tyler and Jennifer Dane McCullough, “Violating Prescriptive Stereotypes on Job Resumes: A Self-
Presentational Perspective,” Management Communication Quarterly 23, no. 2 (November 2009): 272-287.
11
Journal of Social and
Personal Relationships 14, no.3 (June 1997): 417-431.
12
Journal of
Social Psychology 139, no. 6 (December 1999): 700-712.
13
Richard D. Arvey et al., “Interview Validity for Selecting Sales Clerks,” Personnel Psychology 40 (March 1987): 1-12.
14
Validity Study,” Journal of Applied Psychology 70, no.4 (November 1985): 774-776.
15
Marketing Management Journal 18, no. 2 (Fall 2008): 93-105.
Key Research Findings
The Bad News
The Good News
résumé screening criteria among
professional recruiters 8
Experienced recruiters’ inference of hard skills and personality
résumés is not statistically valid 9
Recruiters are subject to identity-image biases and recommend
than company criteria 10, 11
Candidates subjected to more thorough and longer screening
hold more favorable attitudes toward job openings 12
Interviews based on job analysis are statistically valid predictors
of performance 13, 14
Non-traditional interview techniques offer similar results to
traditional (face-to-face) interviews 15
QuestMatch: Using Natural Language Processing to Improve Speed and Quality of Employee Recruiting
5
Discussion
Research suggests that CV and résumé screening for prospective
employees is inaccurate and subject to bias. Applicants commonly
augment the truth; while up to 20% of résumés have gross
discrepancies.16
Stretched truths can become outright lies. In
due to CV inaccuracies. The problem is pervasive; particularly in
background checks.
Furthermore, people conducting
screenings are subject to biases based
on personal opinions. Studies have
shown that mood biases, gender biases,
and self-identity biases all contribute
17, 18
In fact,
experienced recruiters even disagree
about what criteria are essential to job
performance.19
how does a large company know that it is getting the best workers
or just more of the same unreliable workers?
This white paper examines a four-part model for how candidate
screening can be vastly improved.
1. Questions are key to job analysis
Focusing job analysis on key issues employees face,
rather than a checklist of requirements, provides
through creating simple open-ended questions to
describe job functions. Instead of creating survey-
based assessments and wordy job descriptions, hiring
managers and recruiters focus on understanding
that can be analyzed and assessed.
How does a large company
know that it is getting the best
workers or just more of the same
unreliable workers?
16
Kroll Asia Study, 2008.
17
Tyler and McCullough, 2009.
18
Byrne, 1997.
19
Fritzsche and Brannick, 2002.
QuestMatch: Using Natural Language Processing to Improve Speed and Quality of Employee Recruiting
6
2. Spend less time screening and more time
interacting with candidates
Searching and screening candidates is slow and
passive. Instead, assess candidates from the outset
with questions created from job analysis. Sort
candidates into groups and actively engage groups
into a dialogue. With QuestMatch, recruiters can pose
questions to candidates digitally—before committing
time and effort to phone or face-to-face interviews.
CVs and résumés are static. People with ideas, skills
and thoughts are reduced to a paper representation.
out amongst large numbers of applicants.20
Dynamic
of recruits, while uncovering high-potential workers
whose credentials underrepresent their abilities.
RCXUE with QuestMatch automates this entire
process.
4. Use technology to do more with less
Interviews conducted via non-traditional methods
deliver results similar to face-to-face interviews. Web
applications, phone, email, and text chat are all viable
alternatives to assess potential employees. The next
era of recruitment technology will increase pre-
assessment interaction with candidates and automate
ranking.
20
International Top Talent (ITT) Research, Fall 2012.
7
QuestMatch: Using Natural Language Processing to Improve Speed and Quality of Employee Recruiting
QuestMatch
QuestMatch is a dynamic assessment software that allows
recruiters to interview groups of candidates digitally. Assessment
is based on open-ended questions rather than survey-based
assessment. This format allows greater variance of answers and
deeper granularity of results. Using cutting-edge Natural Language
Processing (NLP), the answers are aggregated for comparative
analysis, and candidates are automatically ranked.
Figure 2:
8
QuestMatch: Using Natural Language Processing to Improve Speed and Quality of Employee Recruiting
Figure 3:
QuestMatch Data
Variance in ranking by QuestMatch is statistically similar to the
variance recorded between individual recruiters.
Case studies reported greater than 70% correlation between
recruiters’ rankings and QuestMatch rankings.
Results were even more accurate for best and worst answers
(up to 90% accuracy).
compared to traditional HR practices.
9
QuestMatch: Using Natural Language Processing to Improve Speed and Quality of Employee Recruiting
Natural Language Processing (NLP) to Increase Speed
meaning from human language input. Progress over the last
decade allows modern algorithms to assess the sentiment
and feelings of people. Going forward there is opportunity
to utilize NLP to automate even more
sponsored by Harvard and MIT, is using
computer programs to grade student
papers. The variance of computer-
generated results is nearly identical to
variance in human readers.21
QuestMatch allows recruiters to reduce time spent on
creating and reviewing assessments through automation
and answer abstraction. The result is more engagement
strategy, interaction and coordination rather than searching,
sorting and screening.
As non-traditional interview results
are similar to face-to-face interviews,22
in-depth questions can be posed to
prospective candidates as a screening
procedure. QuestMatch then automates
the entire assessment process, saving
organizations time and money.
The variance of computer-
generated results is nearly
identical to variance in human
readers
Non-traditional interview results
are similar to face-to-face
interviews
21
The New York Times, April 4, 2013.
22
10
QuestMatch: Using Natural Language Processing to Improve Speed and Quality of Employee Recruiting
23
Cole et al., April 2007.
24
Fritzsche and Brannick, June 2002.
Conclusion
Résumé screening is an outdated recruitment paradigm. Prospective
candidates are reduced to words on paper, while recruiters’
inferences of skills from résumés are not statistically valid.23
Experienced recruiters even disagree on which criteria to judge
resumes.24
Furthermore, screening is tedious. The process is both
slow and inaccurate.
and results of candidate screening through process improvement
QuestMatch as the new paradigm in candidate screening.
Recruiters can now digitally interview groups of candidates and
automatically assess responses with NLP (Natural Language
Processing) and machine learning. The result is savings in time,
money, and effort.
11
QuestMatch: Using Natural Language Processing to Improve Speed and Quality of Employee Recruiting
References
Anat, Rafaeli, “Pre-Employment Screening and Applicants’ Attitudes Toward an Employment
Journal of Social Psychology 139, no. 6 (December 1999): 700-712.
Richard D. Arvey et al., “Interview Validity for Selecting Sales Clerks,” Personnel Psychology 40
(March 1987): 1-12.
Paradigm,” Journal of Social and Personal Relationships 14, no.3 (June 1997): 417-431.
Cole et al., “Recruiters’ Perceptions and Use of Applicant Resume Information: Screening the
Recent Graduate,” Applied Psychology: An International Review 56, no.2 (April 2007): 319 –
343.
“College Graduation Data”, China Ministry of Education, 2013.
Diana Farrell and Andrew Grant, “Addressing China’s Looming Talent Shortage,” McKinsey Global
Fritzsche and Brannick, “The Importance of Representative Design in Judgment Tasks: The Case
of Resume Screening,” Journal of Occupational and Organizational Psychology 75, no.2 (June
2002): 163.
International Top Talent (ITT) Research, Fall 2012.
The New York Times, April 4,
2013.
Interview Technique,” Marketing Management Journal 18, no. 2 (Fall 2008): 93-105.
A Comparative Validity Study,” Journal of Applied Psychology 70, no.4 (November 1985):
774-776.
“Retention: Is It Getting Enough Attention,” Hays Research, 2012.
James M. Tyler and Jennifer Dane McCullough, “Violating Prescriptive Stereotypes on Job
Resumes: A Self-Presentational Perspective,” Management Communication Quarterly 23,
no. 2 (November 2009): 272-287.
12
QuestMatch: Using Natural Language Processing to Improve Speed and Quality of Employee Recruiting
rights reserved. This document is provided for information purposes only and
the contents hereof are subject to change without notice. This document is not
warranted to be error-free, nor subject to any other warranties or conditions,
whether expressed orally or implied in law, including implied warranties and
disclaim any liability with respect to this document and no contractual obligations
are formed either directly or indirectly by this document. This document may
not be reproduced or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic or
mechanical, for any purpose, without our prior written permission.
Seedlink, QuestMatch, and RCXUE are trademarks of Seedlink Technology
respective owners.
QuestMatch: Using Natural
Language Processing to Improve
Speed and Quality of Employee
Recruiting
Februrary 2014
Seedlink Technology Holdings, Ltd.
700 Changping Road
Shanghai, China
200060
www.seedlinktech.com
www.RCXUE.com

Contenu connexe

En vedette

Breast cancer diagnosis and recurrence prediction using machine learning tech...
Breast cancer diagnosis and recurrence prediction using machine learning tech...Breast cancer diagnosis and recurrence prediction using machine learning tech...
Breast cancer diagnosis and recurrence prediction using machine learning tech...eSAT Journals
 
bT-Locally Closed Sets and bT-Locally Continuous Functions In Supra Topologic...
bT-Locally Closed Sets and bT-Locally Continuous Functions In Supra Topologic...bT-Locally Closed Sets and bT-Locally Continuous Functions In Supra Topologic...
bT-Locally Closed Sets and bT-Locally Continuous Functions In Supra Topologic...IOSR Journals
 
Charge of the light brigade
Charge of the light brigadeCharge of the light brigade
Charge of the light brigadeAnis Zulaikha
 
Anisotropic Bianchi Type-III Dark Energy Model with Time-Dependent Decelerati...
Anisotropic Bianchi Type-III Dark Energy Model with Time-Dependent Decelerati...Anisotropic Bianchi Type-III Dark Energy Model with Time-Dependent Decelerati...
Anisotropic Bianchi Type-III Dark Energy Model with Time-Dependent Decelerati...IOSR Journals
 
Synthesis Of 2-(1, 3- Dihydro- 3 - Oxo- 2h - Pyridylpyrr- 2- Ylidene)-1, 2-Di...
Synthesis Of 2-(1, 3- Dihydro- 3 - Oxo- 2h - Pyridylpyrr- 2- Ylidene)-1, 2-Di...Synthesis Of 2-(1, 3- Dihydro- 3 - Oxo- 2h - Pyridylpyrr- 2- Ylidene)-1, 2-Di...
Synthesis Of 2-(1, 3- Dihydro- 3 - Oxo- 2h - Pyridylpyrr- 2- Ylidene)-1, 2-Di...IOSR Journals
 
On Series of Fuzzy Numbers
On Series of Fuzzy NumbersOn Series of Fuzzy Numbers
On Series of Fuzzy NumbersIOSR Journals
 

En vedette (12)

Loeff
LoeffLoeff
Loeff
 
Bruce Middle School Winter Camp
Bruce Middle School Winter CampBruce Middle School Winter Camp
Bruce Middle School Winter Camp
 
Propriété intellectuelle et Web 2.0
Propriété intellectuelle et Web 2.0Propriété intellectuelle et Web 2.0
Propriété intellectuelle et Web 2.0
 
Breast cancer diagnosis and recurrence prediction using machine learning tech...
Breast cancer diagnosis and recurrence prediction using machine learning tech...Breast cancer diagnosis and recurrence prediction using machine learning tech...
Breast cancer diagnosis and recurrence prediction using machine learning tech...
 
C0730711
C0730711C0730711
C0730711
 
bT-Locally Closed Sets and bT-Locally Continuous Functions In Supra Topologic...
bT-Locally Closed Sets and bT-Locally Continuous Functions In Supra Topologic...bT-Locally Closed Sets and bT-Locally Continuous Functions In Supra Topologic...
bT-Locally Closed Sets and bT-Locally Continuous Functions In Supra Topologic...
 
Charge of the light brigade
Charge of the light brigadeCharge of the light brigade
Charge of the light brigade
 
G0733945
G0733945G0733945
G0733945
 
Anisotropic Bianchi Type-III Dark Energy Model with Time-Dependent Decelerati...
Anisotropic Bianchi Type-III Dark Energy Model with Time-Dependent Decelerati...Anisotropic Bianchi Type-III Dark Energy Model with Time-Dependent Decelerati...
Anisotropic Bianchi Type-III Dark Energy Model with Time-Dependent Decelerati...
 
Synthesis Of 2-(1, 3- Dihydro- 3 - Oxo- 2h - Pyridylpyrr- 2- Ylidene)-1, 2-Di...
Synthesis Of 2-(1, 3- Dihydro- 3 - Oxo- 2h - Pyridylpyrr- 2- Ylidene)-1, 2-Di...Synthesis Of 2-(1, 3- Dihydro- 3 - Oxo- 2h - Pyridylpyrr- 2- Ylidene)-1, 2-Di...
Synthesis Of 2-(1, 3- Dihydro- 3 - Oxo- 2h - Pyridylpyrr- 2- Ylidene)-1, 2-Di...
 
E0731929
E0731929E0731929
E0731929
 
On Series of Fuzzy Numbers
On Series of Fuzzy NumbersOn Series of Fuzzy Numbers
On Series of Fuzzy Numbers
 

Similaire à QuestMatch - Using Natural Language Processing to Improve Speed and Quality of Employee Recruiting

Recruitment and Selection process: An evaluation of E-recruitment at Marks an...
Recruitment and Selection process: An evaluation of E-recruitment at Marks an...Recruitment and Selection process: An evaluation of E-recruitment at Marks an...
Recruitment and Selection process: An evaluation of E-recruitment at Marks an...Peachy Essay
 
Predictive Hiring: Find Candidates Who Will Succeed in Your Organization
Predictive Hiring: Find Candidates Who Will Succeed in Your OrganizationPredictive Hiring: Find Candidates Who Will Succeed in Your Organization
Predictive Hiring: Find Candidates Who Will Succeed in Your OrganizationHuman Capital Media
 
Linkedin ddr-ebook-final
Linkedin ddr-ebook-finalLinkedin ddr-ebook-final
Linkedin ddr-ebook-finalshibrah76
 
Data Driven Recruiting with LinkedIn
Data Driven Recruiting with LinkedInData Driven Recruiting with LinkedIn
Data Driven Recruiting with LinkedInDaorong Lin
 
linkedin-datadrivenrecruiting-ebook-final
linkedin-datadrivenrecruiting-ebook-finallinkedin-datadrivenrecruiting-ebook-final
linkedin-datadrivenrecruiting-ebook-finalSarah Dunbar
 
Linkedin ddr-ebook-final datadrivenrecruiting
Linkedin ddr-ebook-final datadrivenrecruitingLinkedin ddr-ebook-final datadrivenrecruiting
Linkedin ddr-ebook-final datadrivenrecruitingMichael Cirrito
 
Data Driven Recruiting - 2016
Data Driven Recruiting - 2016Data Driven Recruiting - 2016
Data Driven Recruiting - 2016Ryan Yockey
 
Linkedin-ddr-ebook-final
Linkedin-ddr-ebook-finalLinkedin-ddr-ebook-final
Linkedin-ddr-ebook-finalWill Clarke
 
linkedin-data driven recriting-ebook-final
linkedin-data driven recriting-ebook-finallinkedin-data driven recriting-ebook-final
linkedin-data driven recriting-ebook-finalEva Löwenberg
 
Data Driven Recruiting
Data Driven RecruitingData Driven Recruiting
Data Driven RecruitingNicci Bosco
 
Data Driven Recruiting
Data Driven RecruitingData Driven Recruiting
Data Driven RecruitingJason Silver
 
Data driven recruitment playbook
Data driven recruitment playbookData driven recruitment playbook
Data driven recruitment playbookAndreas Persson
 
linkedin-datadrivenrecruiting-ebook-final
linkedin-datadrivenrecruiting-ebook-finallinkedin-datadrivenrecruiting-ebook-final
linkedin-datadrivenrecruiting-ebook-finalCraig Ringland
 
data.pdf
data.pdfdata.pdf
data.pdfCiente
 
data.pdf
data.pdfdata.pdf
data.pdfCiente
 
My summer project 03 afreen 2
My summer project 03    afreen 2My summer project 03    afreen 2
My summer project 03 afreen 2Rohit Rathore
 
Predictive Analytics for HR: A Primer to Get Started on your HR Analytics Jou...
Predictive Analytics for HR: A Primer to Get Started on your HR Analytics Jou...Predictive Analytics for HR: A Primer to Get Started on your HR Analytics Jou...
Predictive Analytics for HR: A Primer to Get Started on your HR Analytics Jou...Dr Susan Entwisle
 
Qualitative Research Is Good At Simplifying And Managing...
Qualitative Research Is Good At Simplifying And Managing...Qualitative Research Is Good At Simplifying And Managing...
Qualitative Research Is Good At Simplifying And Managing...Patricia Viljoen
 
Human Capital Growth Webinar: Employee selection practices for low literacy c...
Human Capital Growth Webinar: Employee selection practices for low literacy c...Human Capital Growth Webinar: Employee selection practices for low literacy c...
Human Capital Growth Webinar: Employee selection practices for low literacy c...Human Capital Growth
 

Similaire à QuestMatch - Using Natural Language Processing to Improve Speed and Quality of Employee Recruiting (20)

Recruitment and Selection process: An evaluation of E-recruitment at Marks an...
Recruitment and Selection process: An evaluation of E-recruitment at Marks an...Recruitment and Selection process: An evaluation of E-recruitment at Marks an...
Recruitment and Selection process: An evaluation of E-recruitment at Marks an...
 
Predictive Hiring: Find Candidates Who Will Succeed in Your Organization
Predictive Hiring: Find Candidates Who Will Succeed in Your OrganizationPredictive Hiring: Find Candidates Who Will Succeed in Your Organization
Predictive Hiring: Find Candidates Who Will Succeed in Your Organization
 
Linkedin ddr-ebook-final
Linkedin ddr-ebook-finalLinkedin ddr-ebook-final
Linkedin ddr-ebook-final
 
Data Driven Recruiting with LinkedIn
Data Driven Recruiting with LinkedInData Driven Recruiting with LinkedIn
Data Driven Recruiting with LinkedIn
 
linkedin-datadrivenrecruiting-ebook-final
linkedin-datadrivenrecruiting-ebook-finallinkedin-datadrivenrecruiting-ebook-final
linkedin-datadrivenrecruiting-ebook-final
 
Linkedin ddr-ebook-final datadrivenrecruiting
Linkedin ddr-ebook-final datadrivenrecruitingLinkedin ddr-ebook-final datadrivenrecruiting
Linkedin ddr-ebook-final datadrivenrecruiting
 
Data Driven Recruiting - 2016
Data Driven Recruiting - 2016Data Driven Recruiting - 2016
Data Driven Recruiting - 2016
 
Linkedin-ddr-ebook-final
Linkedin-ddr-ebook-finalLinkedin-ddr-ebook-final
Linkedin-ddr-ebook-final
 
linkedin-data driven recriting-ebook-final
linkedin-data driven recriting-ebook-finallinkedin-data driven recriting-ebook-final
linkedin-data driven recriting-ebook-final
 
Data Driven Recruiting
Data Driven RecruitingData Driven Recruiting
Data Driven Recruiting
 
Data Driven Recruiting
Data Driven RecruitingData Driven Recruiting
Data Driven Recruiting
 
Data driven recruitment playbook
Data driven recruitment playbookData driven recruitment playbook
Data driven recruitment playbook
 
linkedin-datadrivenrecruiting-ebook-final
linkedin-datadrivenrecruiting-ebook-finallinkedin-datadrivenrecruiting-ebook-final
linkedin-datadrivenrecruiting-ebook-final
 
data.pdf
data.pdfdata.pdf
data.pdf
 
data.pdf
data.pdfdata.pdf
data.pdf
 
My summer project 03 afreen 2
My summer project 03    afreen 2My summer project 03    afreen 2
My summer project 03 afreen 2
 
Predictive Analytics for HR: A Primer to Get Started on your HR Analytics Jou...
Predictive Analytics for HR: A Primer to Get Started on your HR Analytics Jou...Predictive Analytics for HR: A Primer to Get Started on your HR Analytics Jou...
Predictive Analytics for HR: A Primer to Get Started on your HR Analytics Jou...
 
Qualitative Research Is Good At Simplifying And Managing...
Qualitative Research Is Good At Simplifying And Managing...Qualitative Research Is Good At Simplifying And Managing...
Qualitative Research Is Good At Simplifying And Managing...
 
Job Analysis Project
Job Analysis ProjectJob Analysis Project
Job Analysis Project
 
Human Capital Growth Webinar: Employee selection practices for low literacy c...
Human Capital Growth Webinar: Employee selection practices for low literacy c...Human Capital Growth Webinar: Employee selection practices for low literacy c...
Human Capital Growth Webinar: Employee selection practices for low literacy c...
 

QuestMatch - Using Natural Language Processing to Improve Speed and Quality of Employee Recruiting

  • 1. A Seedlink Tech White Paper in Collaboration with International Top Talent February 2014 www.seedlinktech.com www.RCXUE.com Using Natural Language Processing to Improve Speed and Quality of Employee Recruiting QuestMatch:
  • 2. Table of Contents Introduction .................................................................................................. Key China Data ............................................................................................. Key Research Findings.................................................................................... Discussion .................................................................................................... Questions Are Key to Job Analysis ......................................................... Less Screening, More Interacting ........................................................... ................................................ Use Technology to do More with Less ..................................................... QuestMatch ................................................................................................. QuestMatch Data .......................................................................................... ................... Conclusions .................................................................................................. References ................................................................................................... 3 4 5 6 6 7 7 7 8 9 10 11 12
  • 3. Introduction but it is especially labor-intensive in emerging markets. With a workforce of nearly 800 million, screening résumés in China is extremely tedious and low-value. McKinsey reports that only 10% (MNC). Seedlink case studies indicate that sourcing just one suitable Chinese candidate requires reviewing between 50 – 100 résumés or CVs. The challenging recruitment environment in China can offset the vast market opportunities. This paper covers three main topics. First, we will outline key recruiting literature. Then, we suggest a four-step process for Finally, we introduce the concept of Natural Language Processing (NLP) and QuestMatch to improve speed, while managing the entire pre-interview process. With a combination of continued process improvement and cutting- edge technology, companies can vastly improve the quality of recruits while reducing overall cost. The improvements can impact company Second, better matches reduce overall turnover rate and in turn, off-boarding and replacement costs. RCXUE with QuestMatch provides an intuitive interface to bring NLP to the most demanding companies’ recruitment practices. McKinsey reports that only 10% at a multinational corporation Better matches reduce overall turnover rate and thus off- boarding and replacement costs 3 QuestMatch: Using Natural Language Processing to Improve Speed and Quality of Employee Recruiting
  • 4. Key China Data Figure 1: 790 million people in active labor force 1 7 million college graduates in 2013 2 Nearly 200 million total college graduates by 20203 4 20% of CVs and résumés 5 6 80% of turnover is due to bad hiring decisions 7 1 2 “College Graduation Data”, China Ministry of Education, 2013. 3 ibid 4 Diana Farrell and Andrew Grant, “Addressing China’s Looming Talent Shortage,” McKinsey Global Insights Research, 5 - 6 “Retention: Is It Getting Enough Attention,” Hays Research, 2012. 7 4 QuestMatch: Using Natural Language Processing to Improve Speed and Quality of Employee Recruiting
  • 5. 8 Fritzsche and Brannick, “The Importance of Representative Design in Judgment Tasks: The Case of Resume Screening,” Journal of Occupational and Organizational Psychology 75, no.2 (June 2002): 163. 9 Cole et al., “Recruiters’ Perceptions and Use of Applicant Resume Information: Screening the Recent Graduate,” Applied Psychology: An International Review 56, no.2 (April 2007): 319 – 343. 10 James M. Tyler and Jennifer Dane McCullough, “Violating Prescriptive Stereotypes on Job Resumes: A Self- Presentational Perspective,” Management Communication Quarterly 23, no. 2 (November 2009): 272-287. 11 Journal of Social and Personal Relationships 14, no.3 (June 1997): 417-431. 12 Journal of Social Psychology 139, no. 6 (December 1999): 700-712. 13 Richard D. Arvey et al., “Interview Validity for Selecting Sales Clerks,” Personnel Psychology 40 (March 1987): 1-12. 14 Validity Study,” Journal of Applied Psychology 70, no.4 (November 1985): 774-776. 15 Marketing Management Journal 18, no. 2 (Fall 2008): 93-105. Key Research Findings The Bad News The Good News résumé screening criteria among professional recruiters 8 Experienced recruiters’ inference of hard skills and personality résumés is not statistically valid 9 Recruiters are subject to identity-image biases and recommend than company criteria 10, 11 Candidates subjected to more thorough and longer screening hold more favorable attitudes toward job openings 12 Interviews based on job analysis are statistically valid predictors of performance 13, 14 Non-traditional interview techniques offer similar results to traditional (face-to-face) interviews 15 QuestMatch: Using Natural Language Processing to Improve Speed and Quality of Employee Recruiting 5
  • 6. Discussion Research suggests that CV and résumé screening for prospective employees is inaccurate and subject to bias. Applicants commonly augment the truth; while up to 20% of résumés have gross discrepancies.16 Stretched truths can become outright lies. In due to CV inaccuracies. The problem is pervasive; particularly in background checks. Furthermore, people conducting screenings are subject to biases based on personal opinions. Studies have shown that mood biases, gender biases, and self-identity biases all contribute 17, 18 In fact, experienced recruiters even disagree about what criteria are essential to job performance.19 how does a large company know that it is getting the best workers or just more of the same unreliable workers? This white paper examines a four-part model for how candidate screening can be vastly improved. 1. Questions are key to job analysis Focusing job analysis on key issues employees face, rather than a checklist of requirements, provides through creating simple open-ended questions to describe job functions. Instead of creating survey- based assessments and wordy job descriptions, hiring managers and recruiters focus on understanding that can be analyzed and assessed. How does a large company know that it is getting the best workers or just more of the same unreliable workers? 16 Kroll Asia Study, 2008. 17 Tyler and McCullough, 2009. 18 Byrne, 1997. 19 Fritzsche and Brannick, 2002. QuestMatch: Using Natural Language Processing to Improve Speed and Quality of Employee Recruiting 6
  • 7. 2. Spend less time screening and more time interacting with candidates Searching and screening candidates is slow and passive. Instead, assess candidates from the outset with questions created from job analysis. Sort candidates into groups and actively engage groups into a dialogue. With QuestMatch, recruiters can pose questions to candidates digitally—before committing time and effort to phone or face-to-face interviews. CVs and résumés are static. People with ideas, skills and thoughts are reduced to a paper representation. out amongst large numbers of applicants.20 Dynamic of recruits, while uncovering high-potential workers whose credentials underrepresent their abilities. RCXUE with QuestMatch automates this entire process. 4. Use technology to do more with less Interviews conducted via non-traditional methods deliver results similar to face-to-face interviews. Web applications, phone, email, and text chat are all viable alternatives to assess potential employees. The next era of recruitment technology will increase pre- assessment interaction with candidates and automate ranking. 20 International Top Talent (ITT) Research, Fall 2012. 7 QuestMatch: Using Natural Language Processing to Improve Speed and Quality of Employee Recruiting
  • 8. QuestMatch QuestMatch is a dynamic assessment software that allows recruiters to interview groups of candidates digitally. Assessment is based on open-ended questions rather than survey-based assessment. This format allows greater variance of answers and deeper granularity of results. Using cutting-edge Natural Language Processing (NLP), the answers are aggregated for comparative analysis, and candidates are automatically ranked. Figure 2: 8 QuestMatch: Using Natural Language Processing to Improve Speed and Quality of Employee Recruiting
  • 9. Figure 3: QuestMatch Data Variance in ranking by QuestMatch is statistically similar to the variance recorded between individual recruiters. Case studies reported greater than 70% correlation between recruiters’ rankings and QuestMatch rankings. Results were even more accurate for best and worst answers (up to 90% accuracy). compared to traditional HR practices. 9 QuestMatch: Using Natural Language Processing to Improve Speed and Quality of Employee Recruiting
  • 10. Natural Language Processing (NLP) to Increase Speed meaning from human language input. Progress over the last decade allows modern algorithms to assess the sentiment and feelings of people. Going forward there is opportunity to utilize NLP to automate even more sponsored by Harvard and MIT, is using computer programs to grade student papers. The variance of computer- generated results is nearly identical to variance in human readers.21 QuestMatch allows recruiters to reduce time spent on creating and reviewing assessments through automation and answer abstraction. The result is more engagement strategy, interaction and coordination rather than searching, sorting and screening. As non-traditional interview results are similar to face-to-face interviews,22 in-depth questions can be posed to prospective candidates as a screening procedure. QuestMatch then automates the entire assessment process, saving organizations time and money. The variance of computer- generated results is nearly identical to variance in human readers Non-traditional interview results are similar to face-to-face interviews 21 The New York Times, April 4, 2013. 22 10 QuestMatch: Using Natural Language Processing to Improve Speed and Quality of Employee Recruiting
  • 11. 23 Cole et al., April 2007. 24 Fritzsche and Brannick, June 2002. Conclusion Résumé screening is an outdated recruitment paradigm. Prospective candidates are reduced to words on paper, while recruiters’ inferences of skills from résumés are not statistically valid.23 Experienced recruiters even disagree on which criteria to judge resumes.24 Furthermore, screening is tedious. The process is both slow and inaccurate. and results of candidate screening through process improvement QuestMatch as the new paradigm in candidate screening. Recruiters can now digitally interview groups of candidates and automatically assess responses with NLP (Natural Language Processing) and machine learning. The result is savings in time, money, and effort. 11 QuestMatch: Using Natural Language Processing to Improve Speed and Quality of Employee Recruiting
  • 12. References Anat, Rafaeli, “Pre-Employment Screening and Applicants’ Attitudes Toward an Employment Journal of Social Psychology 139, no. 6 (December 1999): 700-712. Richard D. Arvey et al., “Interview Validity for Selecting Sales Clerks,” Personnel Psychology 40 (March 1987): 1-12. Paradigm,” Journal of Social and Personal Relationships 14, no.3 (June 1997): 417-431. Cole et al., “Recruiters’ Perceptions and Use of Applicant Resume Information: Screening the Recent Graduate,” Applied Psychology: An International Review 56, no.2 (April 2007): 319 – 343. “College Graduation Data”, China Ministry of Education, 2013. Diana Farrell and Andrew Grant, “Addressing China’s Looming Talent Shortage,” McKinsey Global Fritzsche and Brannick, “The Importance of Representative Design in Judgment Tasks: The Case of Resume Screening,” Journal of Occupational and Organizational Psychology 75, no.2 (June 2002): 163. International Top Talent (ITT) Research, Fall 2012. The New York Times, April 4, 2013. Interview Technique,” Marketing Management Journal 18, no. 2 (Fall 2008): 93-105. A Comparative Validity Study,” Journal of Applied Psychology 70, no.4 (November 1985): 774-776. “Retention: Is It Getting Enough Attention,” Hays Research, 2012. James M. Tyler and Jennifer Dane McCullough, “Violating Prescriptive Stereotypes on Job Resumes: A Self-Presentational Perspective,” Management Communication Quarterly 23, no. 2 (November 2009): 272-287. 12 QuestMatch: Using Natural Language Processing to Improve Speed and Quality of Employee Recruiting
  • 13. rights reserved. This document is provided for information purposes only and the contents hereof are subject to change without notice. This document is not warranted to be error-free, nor subject to any other warranties or conditions, whether expressed orally or implied in law, including implied warranties and disclaim any liability with respect to this document and no contractual obligations are formed either directly or indirectly by this document. This document may not be reproduced or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic or mechanical, for any purpose, without our prior written permission. Seedlink, QuestMatch, and RCXUE are trademarks of Seedlink Technology respective owners. QuestMatch: Using Natural Language Processing to Improve Speed and Quality of Employee Recruiting Februrary 2014 Seedlink Technology Holdings, Ltd. 700 Changping Road Shanghai, China 200060 www.seedlinktech.com www.RCXUE.com