1. Linked Data in Practice:
Building Standards, Building Communities
rsanderson@lanl.gov
Robert Sanderson
// azaroth42@gmail.com
// @azaroth42
Linked Data in Practice: Building Standards and Communities
Yale Digital Collections Center, Nov 19 2013, New Haven CT, USA
1

2. Overview
• Standards
• Linked Data: Advantages and Challenges
• Graph Structure
• Open World
• Ontologies and Identities
• Serialization Formats
• Communities
WARNING: Packaged in a Factory Containing Controversy
Linked Data in Practice: Building Standards and Communities
Yale Digital Collections Center, Nov 19 2013, New Haven CT, USA
2

3. Standards
Standards are essential: Infrastructure like Electricity
Like Electricity, there can be more than one but having
the adapters is always a pain
Or Standards like USB...
Linked Data in Practice: Building Standards and Communities
Yale Digital Collections Center, Nov 19 2013, New Haven CT, USA
3

4. Building Standards
Standards are about agreement.
Technical side is easy compared to getting community
engagement and support.
(Much like herding cats)
Linked Data in Practice: Building Standards and Communities
Yale Digital Collections Center, Nov 19 2013, New Haven CT, USA
4

5. Building Web Standards
The web has revolutionized communication,
especially scholarly communication.
Any modern communication standard
needs to be a web standard
Web Standards are about linking things together.
Web Standards are about data.
Linked Data is done using a Graph,
expressed in a technical framework called RDF
Linked Data in Practice: Building Standards and Communities
Yale Digital Collections Center, Nov 19 2013, New Haven CT, USA
5

6. Graphs
ü Graphs are very powerful for modeling reality
ü Tree (like XML) is just a simple Graph
ü Don’t end up in semantic/syntactic hell (like XML)
Linked Data in Practice: Building Standards and Communities
Yale Digital Collections Center, Nov 19 2013, New Haven CT, USA
6

7. Graphs: Structure and Data
Ø Working with graphs must take structure into
account
Graph: Structure and Data important,
but data currently treated as second class citizen
Other: Only Data important, so easier to work with
• Can’t think about “documents” as all nodes/edges
are stored together
Linked Data in Practice: Building Standards and Communities
Yale Digital Collections Center, Nov 19 2013, New Haven CT, USA
7

8. Graphs: Structure and Data
Ø Visualization is difficult to get right
Ø … and hard to know when it is right
Ø Documents “easy” to visualize
Ø Graph visualization almost universally terrible
… because has to take structure into account
Linked Data in Practice: Building Standards and Communities
Yale Digital Collections Center, Nov 19 2013, New Haven CT, USA
8

9. Visualization Done Right
http://www.facebook.com/note.php?note_id=469716398919
Linked Data in Practice: Building Standards and Communities
Yale Digital Collections Center, Nov 19 2013, New Haven CT, USA
9

10. Not So Right
Linked Data in Practice: Building Standards and Communities
Yale Digital Collections Center, Nov 19 2013, New Haven CT, USA
10

11. Graphs
Other structures don’t get as complicated
because they lack the expressiveness of a graph
Linked Data in Practice: Building Standards and Communities
Yale Digital Collections Center, Nov 19 2013, New Haven CT, USA
11

12. The Open World
ü A Single Global Graph that everyone contributes to
ü
ü
ü
ü
ü
Great for data re-use
Global identities
Richness of data from multiple sources
Distributed: Can incrementally add to others descriptions
Fits with the WWW: The Data Web
Technically: If a statement is not asserted, then its truth-value is
unknown, rather than false.
Data:
Painting has X’s signature
Question:
Does the painting have Y’s signature?
Closed World: No
Open World:
I Don’t Know
Linked Data in Practice: Building Standards and Communities
Yale Digital Collections Center, Nov 19 2013, New Haven CT, USA
12

13. The Open World: Global Identities
Jon publishes an Annotation about part of a web page.
Linked Data in Practice: Building Standards and Communities
Yale Digital Collections Center, Nov 19 2013, New Haven CT, USA
13

14. The Open World: Global Identities
Brewster archives the page … and says where it is.
ü Without modifying
the annotation at all!
Linked Data in Practice: Building Standards and Communities
Yale Digital Collections Center, Nov 19 2013, New Haven CT, USA
14

15. The Open World: Local Complexity
Ø Every assertion is considered true in all contexts
Q: How do we say that Canvas 2 comes after Canvas
1, and Canvas 3 comes after Canvas 2?
Linked Data in Practice: Building Standards and Communities
Yale Digital Collections Center, Nov 19 2013, New Haven CT, USA
15

16. The Open World: Ordering
Did you think this?
Remember anyone can say anything, and it’s global…
Linked Data in Practice: Building Standards and Communities
Yale Digital Collections Center, Nov 19 2013, New Haven CT, USA
16

17. The Open World: Ordering
Jane
Freya
Now there are two next links from Canvas 1, and our list is … a graph.
Use Case: Manuscript has different page order at different times
Linked Data in Practice: Building Standards and Communities
Yale Digital Collections Center, Nov 19 2013, New Haven CT, USA
17

18. The Open World: Ordering
ORE introduces proxy nodes, as not just order is local.
Eg may wish to cite a resource in the context of a set of resources.
Linked Data in Practice: Building Standards and Communities
Yale Digital Collections Center, Nov 19 2013, New Haven CT, USA
18

19. The Open World: Ordering
Shared Canvas uses multiple classes and the rdf:List construction.
Serializations hide the list’s anonymous nodes.
Linked Data in Practice: Building Standards and Communities
Yale Digital Collections Center, Nov 19 2013, New Haven CT, USA
19

20. The Open World
Local identity for local context is good practice!
Think Globally
Identify Locally
Linked Data in Practice: Building Standards and Communities
Yale Digital Collections Center, Nov 19 2013, New Haven CT, USA
20

21. Ontologies and Identities
ü Shared relationships increase interoperability
ü dc:title is ‘name’ or ‘label’, not property title or Dr.
ü Re-use of semantics makes it easier to build applications
ü Communities can develop own ontologies of relationships
independently
ü Shared Identity makes it possible for graph to merge
serendipitously
ü Everyone can mint own IDs using http URIs
ü By reusing ids, graphs will merge, creating new knowledge
Linked Data in Practice: Building Standards and Communities
Yale Digital Collections Center, Nov 19 2013, New Haven CT, USA
21

22. Ontologies and Identities
Ø “The nice thing about … Ontologies … is that there’s
so many to choose from”
Ø Too many to choose from, hard to find the right one
Ø If almost right, do you reuse and hope for the best, or
specialize and create yet another ontology?
http://xkcd.com/927/
Linked Data in Practice: Building Standards and Communities
Yale Digital Collections Center, Nov 19 2013, New Haven CT, USA
22

23. Ontologies and Identities
Ø “The nice thing about … Identities … is that there’s
so many to choose from”
Ø Far far too many to choose from, hard to find the right one
Ø As anyone can create identity for anything, they do
Ø Identity can have a contextual component – does LANL’s
identifier for Oppenheimer differ from DBPedia’s?
Linked Data in Practice: Building Standards and Communities
Yale Digital Collections Center, Nov 19 2013, New Haven CT, USA
23

24. Ontologies and Identities
Standards! Communities!
House of Representatives from Huffington Post
http://www.flickr.com/photos/clydeorama/6693882429/
Linked Data in Practice: Building Standards and Communities
Yale Digital Collections Center, Nov 19 2013, New Haven CT, USA
24

25. Serializations
ü The new JSON-LD format is pretty good
{!
"@context": "http://www.w3.org/ns/oa.json", !
"@id": "http://example.org/anno1", !
"@type": "oa:Annotation", !
"annotatedAt": "2012-11-10T09:08:07", !
"annotatedBy": {!
"@id": "http://public.lanl.gov/rsanderson#me", !
"@type": "foaf:Person", !
"name": "Rob Sanderson"!
}, !
“hasBody": {"chars": "This... is CNN.”}, !
“hasTarget": “http://www.cnn.com/”!
}!
Linked Data in Practice: Building Standards and Communities
Yale Digital Collections Center, Nov 19 2013, New Haven CT, USA
25

26. Serializations
Ø The recommended RDF/XML is absolutely terrible
Ø “RDF/XML was the Semantic Web’s 3 Mile Island incident”
-- Manu Sporny, http://manu.sporny.org/2012/nuclear-rdf/
Linked Data in Practice: Building Standards and Communities
Yale Digital Collections Center, Nov 19 2013, New Haven CT, USA
26

27. Communities
Building Community is hard!
• W3C Community Groups
• Funding
• Engagement not Argument
• Early Embedding
• Merge when possible
Path may be longer together, but it’s better
Linked Data in Practice: Building Standards and Communities
Yale Digital Collections Center, Nov 19 2013, New Haven CT, USA
27

28. Thank You!
Slides:
http://www.slideshare.net/azaroth42/
xxx-yyy
Open Annotation:
http://www.openannotation.org/
http://www.w3.org/community/openannotation/
Shared Canvas:
http://www.shared-canvas.org/
http://iiif.io/
Rob Sanderson:
rsanderson@lanl.gov // azaroth42@gmail.com
@azaroth42 // http://public.lanl.gov/rsanderson/
Linked Data in Practice: Building Standards and Communities
Yale Digital Collections Center, Nov 19 2013, New Haven CT, USA
28