The document presents an approach to model Ho Chi Minh City's tsunami crisis management plan as a workflow process. It involves representing the textual plan using BPMN, simulating the response plan using the YAWL workflow system, and mining the process using ProM. The goals are to analyze and improve crisis coordination and management by making plans more structured and amenable to simulation.
Automating Google Workspace (GWS) & more with Apps Script
Representing and Engineering Ho Chi Minh City Tsunami Plan by Means of Process Models - ISCRAM HN 2013
1. Context
Coordination models
HCM City Tsunami Plan
Workflow process
Engineering plans
Conclusion
Representing, Simulating and Analysing
Ho Chi Minh City Tsunami Plan
by Means of Process Models
Nguyen Tuan Thanh LE, Chihab HANACHI,
Serge STINCKWICH, Tuong Vinh HO
Presented by : LE Nguyen Tuan Thanh
SMAC Team - IRIT Laboratory, Toulouse
Hanoi, October 22, 2013
SMAC Team, IRIT
ISCRAM Vietnam 2013 Conference
1/27
2. Context
Coordination models
HCM City Tsunami Plan
Workflow process
Engineering plans
Conclusion
Outline
1
Context
2
Coordination models
3
HCM City Tsunami Plan
4
Workflow process
5
Engineering plans
6
Conclusion
SMAC Team, IRIT
ISCRAM Vietnam 2013 Conference
2/27
3. Context
Coordination models
HCM City Tsunami Plan
Workflow process
Engineering plans
Conclusion
Outline
1
Context
Context of our work
Our Approach
Our Contributions
2
Coordination models
3
HCM City Tsunami Plan
4
Workflow process
5
Engineering plans
SMAC Team, IRIT
ISCRAM Vietnam 2013 Conference
3/27
4. Context
Coordination models
HCM City Tsunami Plan
Workflow process
Engineering plans
Conclusion
Context of our work
Crisis problem
How to face up to this kind of situations?
SMAC Team, IRIT
ISCRAM Vietnam 2013 Conference
4/27
5. Context
Coordination models
HCM City Tsunami Plan
Workflow process
Engineering plans
Conclusion
Context of our work
Context of our work
Crisis
Haiti Earthquake , Hurricane Katrina, 11 September terrorist
attacks, Earthquakes/Tsunamis and nuclear incident in Japan
(2011) ...)
Different actors (such as police, firefighters, humanitarian aid
organizations ...)
Main issue
Coordination of these actors and their interventions are crucial
→ efficient control, crisis resolution
Difficulties
Dynamic, unstable and unpredictable environment
Heterogeneity (organizations, knowledge, responsibilities,
objectives)
SMAC Team, IRIT
ISCRAM Vietnam 2013 Conference
5/27
6. Context
Coordination models
HCM City Tsunami Plan
Workflow process
Engineering plans
Conclusion
Context of our work
Context of our work
Plans are often in printed
textual format
Difficulties to handle plans in
textual format:
Ambiguous interpretations
Do not provide direct means
to analyse, simulate, improve
Difficult to manage in real
time and in distributed setting
→ How to represent, analyze,
simulate and improve these textual
guidelines?
HCM City Tsunami Plan
SMAC Team, IRIT
ISCRAM Vietnam 2013 Conference
6/27
7. Context
Coordination models
HCM City Tsunami Plan
Workflow process
Engineering plans
Conclusion
Our Approach
Our Approach
A process oriented approach: representing textual plans in an
organizational context by means of workflow
Advantages: provide visibility on the whole crisis evolution
(past, present, future activities and their relationships)
→ Support the whole life cycle of a plan: description, simulation,
analysis, execution, monitoring and mining
SMAC Team, IRIT
ISCRAM Vietnam 2013 Conference
7/27
8. Context
Coordination models
HCM City Tsunami Plan
Workflow process
Engineering plans
Conclusion
Our Contributions
Our Contributions
Modelling Ho Chi Minh City crisis textual plan according to a
process approach
Showing how it could be used to improve tsunami
management
→ Towards a process aware information system for crisis
management
SMAC Team, IRIT
ISCRAM Vietnam 2013 Conference
8/27
9. Context
Coordination models
HCM City Tsunami Plan
Workflow process
Engineering plans
Conclusion
Outline
1
Context
2
Coordination models
Coordination
Coordination models for disaster management
3
HCM City Tsunami Plan
4
Workflow process
5
Engineering plans
6
Conclusion
SMAC Team, IRIT
ISCRAM Vietnam 2013 Conference
9/27
10. Context
Coordination models
HCM City Tsunami Plan
Workflow process
Engineering plans
Conclusion
Coordination
Coordination
Coordination is a main issue in crisis management [Chen2008,
Hanachi2012]
A coordination model is a triplet (E, M, R):
E : Set of coordinated entities (such as Police, Military, Red
Cross ...)
M : Media or infrastructure supporting the coordination (Map,
Blackboard, P2P channel ...)
R : Set of coordination rules. Rules may be abstracted by
coordination techniques
SMAC Team, IRIT
ISCRAM Vietnam 2013 Conference
10/27
11. Context
Coordination models
HCM City Tsunami Plan
Workflow process
Engineering plans
Conclusion
Coordination models for disaster management
Coordination models for disaster management
Our approach : Dynamic, Explicit, Process + Organization
SMAC Team, IRIT
ISCRAM Vietnam 2013 Conference
11/27
12. Context
Coordination models
HCM City Tsunami Plan
Workflow process
Engineering plans
Conclusion
Outline
1
Context
2
Coordination models
3
HCM City Tsunami Plan
Ho Chi Minh City Tsunami Management Plan
4
Workflow process
5
Engineering plans
6
Conclusion
SMAC Team, IRIT
ISCRAM Vietnam 2013 Conference
12/27
13. Context
Coordination models
HCM City Tsunami Plan
Workflow process
Engineering plans
Conclusion
Ho Chi Minh City Tsunami Management Plan
Ho Chi Minh City Tsunami Management Plan
Textual document (44 pages) by People’s Committee of Ho
Chi Minh City in 2012
It covers the following phases:
Mitigation
Preparedness
Response
Recovery
We identify 33 actors and several tasks for each actor
SMAC Team, IRIT
ISCRAM Vietnam 2013 Conference
13/27
14. Context
Coordination models
HCM City Tsunami Plan
Workflow process
Engineering plans
Conclusion
Ho Chi Minh City Tsunami Management Plan
Ho Chi Minh City Tsunami Management Plan
SMAC Team, IRIT
ISCRAM Vietnam 2013 Conference
14/27
15. Context
Coordination models
HCM City Tsunami Plan
Workflow process
Engineering plans
Conclusion
Outline
1
Context
2
Coordination models
3
HCM City Tsunami Plan
4
Workflow process
Overview of our approach
Representing a textual plan by means of a workflow process
5
Engineering plans
6
Conclusion
SMAC Team, IRIT
ISCRAM Vietnam 2013 Conference
15/27
16. Context
Coordination models
HCM City Tsunami Plan
Workflow process
Engineering plans
Conclusion
Overview of our approach
An overview of our approach
BPMN : Business Process Model and Notation
YAWL : BPM/Workflow system
ProM : Process Mining
SMAC Team, IRIT
ISCRAM Vietnam 2013 Conference
16/27
17. Context
Coordination models
HCM City Tsunami Plan
Workflow process
Engineering plans
Conclusion
Representing a textual plan by means of a workflow process
BPMN Representation
SMAC Team, IRIT
ISCRAM Vietnam 2013 Conference
17/27
18. Context
Coordination models
HCM City Tsunami Plan
Workflow process
Engineering plans
Conclusion
Representing a textual plan by means of a workflow process
BPMN Representation
SMAC Team, IRIT
ISCRAM Vietnam 2013 Conference
18/27
19. Context
Coordination models
HCM City Tsunami Plan
Workflow process
Engineering plans
Conclusion
Outline
1
Context
2
Coordination models
3
HCM City Tsunami Plan
4
Workflow process
5
Engineering plans
Engineering tsunami response plans
Response Plan in YAWL
Mining with ProM
SMAC Team, IRIT
ISCRAM Vietnam 2013 Conference
19/27
20. Context
Coordination models
HCM City Tsunami Plan
Workflow process
Engineering plans
Conclusion
Engineering tsunami response plans
Engineering tsunami response plans
SMAC Team, IRIT
ISCRAM Vietnam 2013 Conference
20/27
21. Context
Coordination models
HCM City Tsunami Plan
Workflow process
Engineering plans
Conclusion
Response Plan in YAWL
Process Perspective
SMAC Team, IRIT
ISCRAM Vietnam 2013 Conference
21/27
22. Context
Coordination models
HCM City Tsunami Plan
Workflow process
Engineering plans
Conclusion
Response Plan in YAWL
Simulation with YAWL Engine
SMAC Team, IRIT
ISCRAM Vietnam 2013 Conference
22/27
23. Context
Coordination models
HCM City Tsunami Plan
Workflow process
Engineering plans
Conclusion
Mining with ProM
Mining with ProM
Simulation links with ProM
environment
ProM : An open-source framework
implementing process mining
From event logs, using the plugins of
ProM to discover/mine
SMAC Team, IRIT
ISCRAM Vietnam 2013 Conference
23/27
24. Context
Coordination models
HCM City Tsunami Plan
Workflow process
Engineering plans
Conclusion
Mining with ProM
Petri Net using Alpha-algorithm
SMAC Team, IRIT
ISCRAM Vietnam 2013 Conference
24/27
25. Context
Coordination models
HCM City Tsunami Plan
Workflow process
Engineering plans
Conclusion
Mining with ProM
Sociogram
SMAC Team, IRIT
ISCRAM Vietnam 2013 Conference
25/27
26. Context
Coordination models
HCM City Tsunami Plan
Workflow process
Engineering plans
Conclusion
Conclusion
Conclusion
Introduce an approach to model crisis resolution plan from
textual guideline (Ho Chi Minh City Tsunami Plan)
Follow a process based approach using workflow technology
Conduct without involving real crisis stakeholders → Try to
make more realistic simulations
Create event log by hand → Extract the event logs
automatically from YAWL Engine
SMAC Team, IRIT
ISCRAM Vietnam 2013 Conference
26/27
27. Context
Coordination models
HCM City Tsunami Plan
Workflow process
Engineering plans
Conclusion
Conclusion
Question
SMAC Team, IRIT
ISCRAM Vietnam 2013 Conference
27/27