The document discusses tools for tabletop game design, specifically spreadsheets and two online tools - Playtest and Card Warden. It provides examples of how spreadsheets can be used to track game systems, components, and attributes for balancing purposes. Playtest allows importing a CSV file to generate card layouts while Card Warden facilitates playtesting digitally by shuffling, dealing and manipulating virtual decks. The document demonstrates these tools through examples from the author's games Memory Matters and Ship Deck.
1. Tools For Tabletop Game Design
by Martin Grider
@livingtech - http://chesstris.com/
(Some)
2. WHAT AM I TALKING ABOUT?
• Game Design - definitions & disclaimer
• Spreadsheets - why, what, how
• My game (examples): Memory Matters, Ship Deck
• Tool Demo: Playtest
• Tool Demo: Card Warden
3. • Game Design can be difficult to talk about
• Lack of standard: nomenclature, taxonomy,
terminology, definition, syntax, semantics*
• It’s an “art” rather than “science” — i.e. what
is “better” is a matter of opinion rather than
quantifiable or measurable.
* Yes, there are people working on this, including books written on the topic.
5. WHY SPREADSHEETS?
• Ultimate tool for keeping track of things
• Lists of things
• Not just for numbers, but especially good for
numbers
6. • Spreadsheets - Uses
• Systems (A list of a game’s systems and how
they interact can be used to better understand
the game.)
• System Components (A list of individual things
in a system, with their attributes, this can help
with game balance.)
• Project Management (A list of tasks, deliverable
dates, etc.)
7. WHAT DO I MEAN BY
SYSTEM?
• Is a system a mechanic? (Yes, sort of.)
• I like to think that mechanics are “categories” of systems, a
mechanic is usually a generalized, (non-specific) way to talk about a
system. There are almost as many kinds of “worker placement
systems”, for example, as there are games that use that mechanic.
• Complex vs. Simple systems
• Spreadsheets are probably more useful in examining complex systems.
• Complex systems have “components” (with variables)
8. LISTING SYSTEMS
• Maybe best to think of it as a brainstorm. List everything first,
prune later.
• Might be hard to pull them apart
(That’s good! Generally speaking, the more your systems work
together, the more interesting the game as a whole will be.)
• Maybe there is only one system?
(Initially I thought maybe games like Dominion or Canabalt
were single system games.)
9. SYSTEMS IN CANABALT
• Diagram of influence
• Illustrates how the
systems interact
• Might suggest ideas or
options for change
• Another “lens” through
which to view your game*
* For more about lenses, see the Art of Game Design, by Jesse Schell
10. SPREADSHEETS FOR
COMPONENTS
• Components are elements (things) in a system
• Examples:
• Cards in a card game
• Obstacles in Canabalt
• Characters/Enemies in Mario Brothers
• Trivia questions in a trivia game
11. SPREADSHEETS FOR
COMPONENTS — ATTRIBUTES
• Examples:
• Cards in a card game
Traditional attributes: Suite & Rank
Non-traditional (Dominion): Cost, Action, etc.
• Obstacles in Canabalt
Attributes: Type (floor, crate, other), size (height, width, etc), etc.
• Characters/Enemies in Mario Brothers
Attributes: Movement (walking, flying, swimming), speed, can be attacked from above,
behaviors (will chase you, etc.)
• Trivia questions in a trivia game
Attributes: Question text, answer text, wrong answer text(?)
12. USES OF SPREADSHEETS FOR
COMPONENTS IN CARD GAMES
• Game “Balancing”:
• Probabilities & Distribution — how often are
things likely to happen?
• Attributes — comparing values on a specific
component to attribute values of other
components
13. EXAMPLE #1:
MEMORIES MATTER
• Trivia game
• Trivia is presented in “pairs”
(Well, for the first several game
modes.)
• Spreadsheets are used purely to
track / generate / manage the
content
• (Though in a way this is also game
balance, as categorizing the
content also involves grouping by
difficulty.)
15. EXAMPLE #1:
MEMORIES MATTER
1. create the csv by taking the spreadsheet and adding the following header rows: primary-item-type,
secondary-item-type,primary-item,secondary-item,did-you-know,year,tags (year, tags, and
did-you-know are optional.)
2. open the Plist Converter.app, and drag your .csv into it.
3. add the new .plist file into the project.
4. create new folders for image and/or audio files, add those to your project.
5. Add the new set to the KST_GameMatchSet enum in KST_MatchFactory.h
6. Edit KST_MatchFactory.m edit the setNameAndPlistArray and setNameForMatchSet: methods, adding
your new triva set to them. (You'll need the .plist filename, as well as the set name.)
7. Switch the project target to db-importer, and run the project.
8. Fix any errors / issues you see in the log.
9. When the db-importer runs "clean" (without errors), copy the Realm path, and open the project
root in your terminal. Copy the realm file into your project, overwriting the existing
default.realm file.
10. Add a UI button for the new set, make sure the new set is contemplated in
updateGameMatchSetButtons: and matchSetButtonPressed: method in KST_GameSetupViewController.m
11. Test.
• Steps to import:
(round-trip)
16. EXAMPLE #2:
SHIP DECK
• Deck Building meets 4X
• Many Card attributes
• Only two types of card:
• “ship part” cards and
• “goal” cards
17. CARD ATTRIBUTES FOR
SHIP DECK
• Each card has quite a few
attributes
• For a long time this was
overwhelming (admittedly,
that has nothing to do with
the spreadsheet aspect)
Victory Point Value Cost
Name Version
Action
Capacity
(fuel, ammo, cargo)
Discard
Ship Part
(color & position)
19. EXAMPLE #2:
SHIP DECK
• Some things that are possible
• Ask questions about your content and answer them
examples:
• “What is the average cost of my cards?”
• “How many red cards are Cargo cards?” (Note: this is old content.)
20. WHEN DO YOU LEAVE THE
SPREADSHEET?
• Answer maybe depends on your team makeup, who is performing what tasks.
• (If you are the only person working on the project, you can decide, otherwise,
it might depend on when your team mates need your work, as well as how
comfortable you will be making changes in the “final” format.)
• ASAP
• Goal should always be to get to a “playable” version
• Versioning is probably a concern, especially for complex systems
• Shorter round-trip between game and spreadsheet is desirable
• You WILL end up making changes in one and forgetting
22. TOOL: PLAYTEST
• Meant to be an “easy” .csv to visual layout for cards
• Uses .svg for design / visual output
• Uses a templating system for replacing {{variables}}
• support for “layer” column that turns .svg layers on
and off
• Export to .pdf (print), or individual files for Game Crafter
24. PLAYTEST & SHIP DECK
• Round trip steps:
• munge column headers (must be labeled the same as the template
{{name}} variables)
• add “layers” column
• export as .csv (I use .csv.txt, for ease of copy/pasting)
• create new “version” in playtest (possibly because I’m anal)
• paste .csv content into playtest
25. Card Warden
Created by Michael Azzara
@mike_azzara
http://www.mikeazzara.com/
(Note that I am not affiliated at all
with this product, only a consumer.)
26. TOOL: CARDWARDEN
• Import images as cards into “decks”
• Shuffle, deal, add or remove cards on the table
• Have many as many decks in play at once as you
want, adding to or removing from them “at will”
• Asynchronous or real-time multiplayer
(I have not tested this.)
