The document discusses rubrics for assessment in education. It defines rubrics as assessment tools that provide clear criteria for evaluating student work or performance across different components. There are two main types of rubrics - holistic and analytical. A holistic rubric evaluates overall performance on a task with a single score, while an analytical rubric assesses each criterion separately. The document provides examples of criteria, performance levels, and scoring for developing rubrics. It outlines the stages of rubric development as reflecting on learning goals, listing criteria, grouping criteria, and applying levels of performance. Rubrics help provide consistent and detailed feedback to students and teachers.

1. https://www.mentimeter.com/app/presentation/alnusuyp3w23rog4t
itopy7ozg4cha22/bbbxxvvc6ijc/edit

2. NEP 2020 re-emphasizes the need to evaluate higher-order
skills, such as:
Analysis
Critical thinking
Conceptual clarity
Hence, shifting the focus of assessments from marks based to
competency based.

3.  It aims at implementing assessment frameworks encompassing
design of competencies, portfolio, rubrics, and standardized
assessments.

4. Rubrics
DR. MANJEET YADAV
ASSISTANT PROFESSOR
R. L. S. COLLEGE OF EDUCATION
SIDHRAWALI, GURUGRAM

5. Rubrics are the criterion-referenced rules for assessing
student performance holistically or analytically (on different
dimensions).
A scoring tool with specific expectations for an
assignment/task, providing a detailed description of what
constitutes acceptable or unacceptable levels of performance.
Used to examine how well students have met Cos, Pos & LOs
rather than how well they perform compared to their peers

6. A rubric is an assessment tool that clearly indicates
achievement criteria across all the components of any kind of
student work.
It can be used for marking assignments, class participation or
overall grades.
There are two types of rubrics:
 Holistic
 analytical

7. Holistic Rubric
 All criteria are assessed as a single score.
 Used for evaluating overall performance on a task.
 Detailed information on student performance for each criterion is
not provided as the levels of performance are taken as a whole.
• Reading fluency or response to an essay question . . .
• Overall quality or achievement or performance
• Judging the impact of a product

8. Score Description
5
Demonstrates complete understanding of the problem. All
requirements of task are included in response.
4
Demonstrates considerable understanding of the problem. All
requirements of task are included.
3
Demonstrates partial understanding of the problem. Most
requirements of task are included.
2
Demonstrates little understanding of the problem. Many
requirements of task are missing.
1 Demonstrates no understanding of the problem.
0 Noresponse/task not attempted.

9. When to use holistic rubric
 Overall quality, proficiency, or understanding of a specific
content or skills.
 Assessment is summative (e.g. at the end of a semester or
Major)
 Assessing significant number of samples/items.

10. Analytical Rubric
 Each criterion is assessed separately, using different
descriptive ratings.
 Each criterion has a separate score.
 Provides more detailed feedback.
 Judges complex performances, involving several significant
criteria.
 Provides more specific information or feedback to students.

11. Beginning 1 Developing 2 Accomplished 3 Exemplary 4
Score
Crit. #1
Description reflecting
beginning level of
performance
Description reflecting
movement toward
mastery level of
performance
Description reflecting
achievement of
mastery level of
performance
Description reflecting
highest level of
performance
Crit. #2
Description reflecting
beginning level of
performance
Description reflecting
movement toward
mastery level of
performance
Description reflecting
achievement of
mastery level of
performance
Description reflecting
highest level of
performance
Crit. #3 Description reflecting
beginning level of
performance
Description reflecting
movement toward
mastery level of
performance
Description reflecting
achievement of
mastery level of
performance
Description reflecting
highest level of
performance

12. When to use Analytic Rubrics
 Several teachers collectively assess student work.
Descriptions promote consistency in scoring.
 Outsiders examining the rubric scores.
 Substantial feedback to students or teachers is desired.
 Profiles of specific strengths/weaknesses are desired.

13.  What should the assignment include?
 What will be assessed?
 How will the assignment align with
standards?
 How will we measure student achievement?

14. Stages of Rubric Development
 Stage 1: Reflecting
What do we want from our students? Why did we create this
assignment? What happened the last time we did this?
 Stage 2: Listing
What are the learning outcomes we hope to see in the completed
assignment/product?
 Stage 3: Grouping and Labeling
Place similar outcomes together to comprise dimensions of the rubric.
 Stage 4: Application
Form the actual rubric by deploying dimensions and levels along each
side of the rubric.

15. EXAMPLES OF CRITERIA FOR A
STUDENT ASSIGNMENT
• Introduction
• Arguments presented/analysis
• Grammar and punctuation
• Spelling
• Conclusion
• References
• Presentation of the work

16. DESCRIPTION OF LEVELS OF
PERFORMANCE
• Excellent, Good, Fair, Poor
• Master, Apprentice, Beginner
• Exemplary, Accomplished, Developing, Beginning,
Undeveloped
• Complete, Incomplete
• Yes, No

17. SCORES
 1, 2, 3, 4, 5 or 2, 4, 6, 8

18. Descriptors
Explicit descriptions of the performance-
 What is expected of the students?
 What performance at a particular level looks like?
 How well students’ work is distinguished from the work of their
peers?
Detailed enough to differentiate between the different levels
and increase the objectivity of the rater.

19. examples

20. Student’s understanding of a concept

21. Role play

22. Group discussion

23. Summary of a Text

24. Writing
Task/
Assignment

25. Science project

26. Home work

27. angles

28. Statistics/measures of central tendency

29. Rubrics for map skill

30. Teacher’s
Self
Assessment
Rubric
NCERT,
2019

31. Let’s develop some Rubrics

32. Task Description
What the student is supposed to do?
 Write an essay, perform a drama/role play, make an oral
presentation…
 At the top of a sheet of paper, place the full description of
the assignment.
 Begin a grid that is headed by a descriptive title and
dimensions of the assignment.

33. Scale
How well or poorly has the student done on the task?
Sophisticated, competent, partly competent, not yet competent.
Exemplary, proficient, marginal, unacceptable.
Advanced, Intermediate, Novice.
Distinguished, proficient, intermediate, novice.
Accomplished, developing, beginning.
Consider whether a scale needs more than three levels. More levels
mean more time spent on assessment.

34. Dimensions
Break down a task into components and identify the importance
of these components.
Dimensions are descriptive, not evaluative
“organization” instead of “good organization”
Dimensions help students see that the work they are doing is
multidimensional and draws on multiple abilities.

35. Description of the Dimensions
At least a description of the highest level of performance.
Students need not fit into a single category.
 Descriptions for each level help students see that the work they are
doing, have varying levels of achievement. The difference between
poor and excellent work.

36. Develop a rubric for assessing a
PowerPoint Presentation

37. https://docs.google.com/forms/u/0/?ft
v=1

38. https://rubric-maker.com/projectmanager

39. Develop a rubric for assessing an
oral presentation by the students

40. Develop a rubric for assessing an
Art Project/Work

41. Develop a rubric for assessing the
Understanding of a
Concept/Assignment/Task from your subject

42. Thank You