Boiler efficiency by loss Method

Rajeev Saini
Rajeev SainiDeputy Manager -CCR Operation at DB Power Limited (2X600 MW Thermal Power Plant , à DB Power Limited (2X600MW)
Heat
Input
Radiation Loss
Steam Output
BOILER EFFICIENCY
Heat Input is Pulverised Coal
Heat Output is Superheated Steam By Rajeev Saini
Furnace
Second
Pass
ESP
Some important facts on Boiler Efficiency
1. Sec Air temp increased by 20*C =1% Fuel saving.
2. Flue gas temp reduced by 25*C = 1% Fuel saving.
3. Feed water temp increased by 5*C = 1% Fuel saving.
4. Oxygen % at APH I/L increased by 1%=0.32% Fuel Loss
Boiler
Use of low air pressure "film burners" helps save oil upto 15% in furnaces.
IBR Steam Boilers means any closed vessel exceeding 22.75 liters.
Boiler efficiency by loss Method
Efficiency Calculations Standards
Standard Applied :- ASME Standard PTC 4.1
IS 8753: Indian Standard for Boiler Efficiency Testing
British standards, BS845: 1987
The Indirect Method Testing/Loss Method
L1. Loss due to dry flue gas (sensible heat)
L2. Loss due to hydrogen in fuel (H2)
L3. Loss due to moisture in fuel (H2O)
L4. Loss due to moisture in air (H2O)
L5. Loss due to carbon monoxide (CO)
L6. Loss due to surface radiation, convection and other unaccounted
L7. Unburnt losses in fly ash (Carbon)
L8. Unburnt losses in bottom ash (Carbon)
Boiler Efficiency by indirect method =
100 - (L1 + L2 + L3 + L4 + L5 + L6 + L7 + L8)
This is also known as ‘input-output method’ due to the fact that it needs only the useful
output (steam) and the heat input (i.e. fuel) for evaluating the efficiency. This
efficiency can be evaluated using the formula
Q--Quantity of steam generated per hour in kg/hr.
q--Quantity of fuel used per hour in kg/hr.
GCV--gross calorific value of the fuel in kCal/kg of fuel
=[(11.6 x 38.16)+{34.8 x (2.03-(6.28/8))}+(4.35x0.53)]/100
= 4.882 Kg/Kg of Coal
=[(3.49)/(21-3.49)]X100
=19.9 %
=[1+(19.9/100)]X100 Kg/Kg of Coal
= 5.8535 Kg/Kg of Coal
L1:-
=[(0.467 X 44/12) +0.008+(5.885X 77/100) + (5.885-4.882)X23/100] Kg/Kg of Coal
= 6.274 Kg/Kg of Coal
L1=
=[(6.274) X0.23X(149-33)X100]/3300
= 5.07 %
L2:-
=[9X0.0203 X{584 +0.45 X(149-33)X100]/3300
= 3.52 %
L3:-
=[5.5X{584 +0.45 X(149-33)X100]/3300
= 1.06 %
L4:-
L5:-
=[5.885X0.0204 X0.45 X(149-33)X100]/3300
= 0.19 %
=[(0.55X0.3816)/(0.55+17)] X[5744*100/3300]
= 2.08 %
L6:-
= 0.184 %
L7:-
= 0.80 X0.467 X 452.5 X 100/ 3300
= 0.424 %
L8:-
= 0.80 X0.467 X 452.5 X 100/ 3300
= 1.152 %
= 100- (5.07+3.52+0.19+2.08+0.424+1.152)
= 86.320%
Merits and Demerits of Direct Method
Merits
. Plant people can evaluate quickly the efficiency of boilers
. Requires few parameters for computation
. Needs few instruments for monitoring
Demerits
. Does not give clues to the operator as to why efficiency of system is lower
. Does not calculate various losses accountable for various efficiency levels
. Evaporation ratio and efficiency may mislead, if the steam is highly wet due to water
carryover
How to Improve efficiency of boiler
Oxygen Trim Systems
Flue gas outlet temperature
MS temp
HRH temp
Feed Water Temp
Blowdown control
Blowdown heat recovery
Flash Steam Recovery
Steam Trap Leaks
Exhaust Draft Control
The effect of coal blending on combustion performance
Air to fuel ratio control
Factors Affecting Boiler Performance
The various factors affecting the boiler performance are listed below:
. Periodical cleaning of boilers
. Periodical soot blowing
. Proper water treatment programme and blow down control
. Draft control
. Excess air control
. Percentage loading of boiler
. Steam generation pressure and temperature
. Boiler insulation
. Quality of fuel
Boiler efficiency by loss Method
1 sur 17

Recommandé

Evaluation of a Boiler performance par
Evaluation of a Boiler performanceEvaluation of a Boiler performance
Evaluation of a Boiler performanceHashim Hasnain Hadi
7.1K vues53 diapositives
Boiler Efficiency Calculations par
Boiler Efficiency CalculationsBoiler Efficiency Calculations
Boiler Efficiency CalculationsManohar Tatwawadi
3.6K vues32 diapositives
Boiler Operation par
Boiler OperationBoiler Operation
Boiler OperationSusovan Sensharma
11.4K vues54 diapositives
Boiler Efficiency Calculation by Direct & Indirect Method par
Boiler Efficiency Calculation by Direct & Indirect MethodBoiler Efficiency Calculation by Direct & Indirect Method
Boiler Efficiency Calculation by Direct & Indirect MethodTahoor Alam Khan
436 vues44 diapositives
Steam generator part 2 par
Steam generator part 2Steam generator part 2
Steam generator part 2Mohammad Shoeb Siddiqui
23.1K vues124 diapositives
A Brief Introduction to Boilers par
A Brief Introduction to BoilersA Brief Introduction to Boilers
A Brief Introduction to BoilersSATYAKAM MOHAPATRA
14K vues73 diapositives

Contenu connexe

Tendances

Boiler Performance Monitoring par
Boiler Performance MonitoringBoiler Performance Monitoring
Boiler Performance MonitoringNational Productivity Council, Hyderabad, India
3.3K vues23 diapositives
Energy audit boiler and steam lines par
Energy audit  boiler and steam linesEnergy audit  boiler and steam lines
Energy audit boiler and steam linesRohil Kumar
1.2K vues32 diapositives
Boiler -Emergency Handling par
 Boiler -Emergency Handling Boiler -Emergency Handling
Boiler -Emergency HandlingAshish Kumar Jain
3.9K vues41 diapositives
A complete presentation on Boiler. par
A complete presentation on Boiler.A complete presentation on Boiler.
A complete presentation on Boiler.Anuj Maurya
1.1K vues29 diapositives
Super critical boiler par
Super critical boilerSuper critical boiler
Super critical boilerAshvani Shukla
5.8K vues32 diapositives
Boilers par
BoilersBoilers
BoilersAAR Mahaveer Engineering College
23.3K vues45 diapositives

Tendances(20)

Energy audit boiler and steam lines par Rohil Kumar
Energy audit  boiler and steam linesEnergy audit  boiler and steam lines
Energy audit boiler and steam lines
Rohil Kumar1.2K vues
A complete presentation on Boiler. par Anuj Maurya
A complete presentation on Boiler.A complete presentation on Boiler.
A complete presentation on Boiler.
Anuj Maurya1.1K vues
660 mw supercritical boiler par Ashvani Shukla
660 mw supercritical boiler660 mw supercritical boiler
660 mw supercritical boiler
Ashvani Shukla18.8K vues
Calculation of Turbine Efficiency par Jahanzeb Khan
Calculation of Turbine EfficiencyCalculation of Turbine Efficiency
Calculation of Turbine Efficiency
Jahanzeb Khan15.3K vues
Economiser & air preheater par dishti7
Economiser & air preheaterEconomiser & air preheater
Economiser & air preheater
dishti748.5K vues
Air Heater and PF Boiler Performance Indices par Manohar Tatwawadi
Air Heater and PF Boiler Performance IndicesAir Heater and PF Boiler Performance Indices
Air Heater and PF Boiler Performance Indices
Manohar Tatwawadi4.8K vues
Heater operation par JOMON M.C
Heater operationHeater operation
Heater operation
JOMON M.C17.2K vues

En vedette

Improving steam boiler operating efficiency par
Improving steam boiler operating efficiencyImproving steam boiler operating efficiency
Improving steam boiler operating efficiencyNaqqash Sajid
9.7K vues229 diapositives
Thermal power plant par
Thermal power plantThermal power plant
Thermal power plantAshvani Shukla
4.3K vues36 diapositives
Control valves for thermal power plants par
Control valves for thermal power plantsControl valves for thermal power plants
Control valves for thermal power plantsSHIVAJI CHOUDHURY
24K vues38 diapositives
Thermal Power Plants par
Thermal Power PlantsThermal Power Plants
Thermal Power PlantsHarshad Desai
30.3K vues26 diapositives
Kota super thermal power plant,kstps ppt,RTU par
Kota super thermal power plant,kstps ppt,RTUKota super thermal power plant,kstps ppt,RTU
Kota super thermal power plant,kstps ppt,RTUManohar Nagar
2.9K vues23 diapositives
Energy performance assessment of boilers par
Energy performance assessment of boilersEnergy performance assessment of boilers
Energy performance assessment of boilersUtsav Jain
12.2K vues50 diapositives

En vedette(15)

Improving steam boiler operating efficiency par Naqqash Sajid
Improving steam boiler operating efficiencyImproving steam boiler operating efficiency
Improving steam boiler operating efficiency
Naqqash Sajid9.7K vues
Kota super thermal power plant,kstps ppt,RTU par Manohar Nagar
Kota super thermal power plant,kstps ppt,RTUKota super thermal power plant,kstps ppt,RTU
Kota super thermal power plant,kstps ppt,RTU
Manohar Nagar2.9K vues
Energy performance assessment of boilers par Utsav Jain
Energy performance assessment of boilersEnergy performance assessment of boilers
Energy performance assessment of boilers
Utsav Jain12.2K vues
Thermal power plant par sagar20jain
 Thermal power plant  Thermal power plant
Thermal power plant
sagar20jain14.8K vues
Boiler Process Instrumentation and controls par ADITYA AGARWAL
Boiler Process Instrumentation and controlsBoiler Process Instrumentation and controls
Boiler Process Instrumentation and controls
ADITYA AGARWAL23.9K vues
Panipat thermal power station training ppt par Mohit Verma
Panipat thermal power station training pptPanipat thermal power station training ppt
Panipat thermal power station training ppt
Mohit Verma11K vues
Boiler instrumentation-and-controls par DARSHAN B S
Boiler instrumentation-and-controlsBoiler instrumentation-and-controls
Boiler instrumentation-and-controls
DARSHAN B S41.2K vues
Instrumentation & Control For Thermal Power Plant par SHIVAJI CHOUDHURY
Instrumentation & Control For Thermal Power PlantInstrumentation & Control For Thermal Power Plant
Instrumentation & Control For Thermal Power Plant
SHIVAJI CHOUDHURY49.1K vues
Thermal power plant ppt par VIMLESH VERMA
Thermal power plant pptThermal power plant ppt
Thermal power plant ppt
VIMLESH VERMA176.2K vues
Best ppt on thermal power station working par Ronak Thakare
Best ppt on thermal power station workingBest ppt on thermal power station working
Best ppt on thermal power station working
Ronak Thakare123.1K vues

Similaire à Boiler efficiency by loss Method

Boiler Efficiency Improvement through Analysis of Losses par
Boiler Efficiency Improvement through Analysis of LossesBoiler Efficiency Improvement through Analysis of Losses
Boiler Efficiency Improvement through Analysis of Lossesijsrd.com
3K vues5 diapositives
Condition Monitoring of electrical machine par
Condition Monitoring of electrical machine Condition Monitoring of electrical machine
Condition Monitoring of electrical machine Molla Morshad
178 vues83 diapositives
Combustion Calculations par
Combustion CalculationsCombustion Calculations
Combustion CalculationsAhsanN2
140 vues25 diapositives
heat ppt.pptx par
heat ppt.pptxheat ppt.pptx
heat ppt.pptxGaurankamoran1
52 vues23 diapositives
Basics of Thermal Energy management.ppt par
Basics of Thermal Energy management.pptBasics of Thermal Energy management.ppt
Basics of Thermal Energy management.pptssuser2023f0
43 vues66 diapositives
FUELS.ppt par
FUELS.pptFUELS.ppt
FUELS.pptBhaveshKhuje
6 vues54 diapositives

Similaire à Boiler efficiency by loss Method(20)

Boiler Efficiency Improvement through Analysis of Losses par ijsrd.com
Boiler Efficiency Improvement through Analysis of LossesBoiler Efficiency Improvement through Analysis of Losses
Boiler Efficiency Improvement through Analysis of Losses
ijsrd.com3K vues
Condition Monitoring of electrical machine par Molla Morshad
Condition Monitoring of electrical machine Condition Monitoring of electrical machine
Condition Monitoring of electrical machine
Molla Morshad178 vues
Combustion Calculations par AhsanN2
Combustion CalculationsCombustion Calculations
Combustion Calculations
AhsanN2140 vues
Basics of Thermal Energy management.ppt par ssuser2023f0
Basics of Thermal Energy management.pptBasics of Thermal Energy management.ppt
Basics of Thermal Energy management.ppt
ssuser2023f043 vues
Lecture 16b Chemical Reactions and Combustion par Sijal Ahmed
Lecture 16b Chemical Reactions and CombustionLecture 16b Chemical Reactions and Combustion
Lecture 16b Chemical Reactions and Combustion
Sijal Ahmed1.3K vues
Airah Natural Refrigerants Special Interest Group Sydney 30 October 2008 par rhysemo
Airah Natural Refrigerants Special Interest Group Sydney 30 October 2008Airah Natural Refrigerants Special Interest Group Sydney 30 October 2008
Airah Natural Refrigerants Special Interest Group Sydney 30 October 2008
rhysemo250 vues
Airah Natural Refrigerants Special Interest Group Sydney 30 October 2008 par rhysemo
Airah Natural Refrigerants Special Interest Group Sydney 30 October 2008Airah Natural Refrigerants Special Interest Group Sydney 30 October 2008
Airah Natural Refrigerants Special Interest Group Sydney 30 October 2008
rhysemo296 vues
3193-292321-BOILER_EFFICIENCY.pptx par YADIIRWANTO
3193-292321-BOILER_EFFICIENCY.pptx3193-292321-BOILER_EFFICIENCY.pptx
3193-292321-BOILER_EFFICIENCY.pptx
YADIIRWANTO4 vues
Design and balance : Styrene Oxide Production par ARITRA MUKHERJEE
Design and balance : Styrene Oxide ProductionDesign and balance : Styrene Oxide Production
Design and balance : Styrene Oxide Production
ARITRA MUKHERJEE2.6K vues
Shaft Kiln Modelling and Simulation.pptx par IrfanAslam51
Shaft Kiln Modelling and Simulation.pptxShaft Kiln Modelling and Simulation.pptx
Shaft Kiln Modelling and Simulation.pptx
IrfanAslam5132 vues
Adipic Acid Plant Energy Balance par IshaneeSharma
Adipic Acid Plant Energy BalanceAdipic Acid Plant Energy Balance
Adipic Acid Plant Energy Balance
IshaneeSharma996 vues
Energy Science -Short- (Alane sir).pdf par AdityaSem12
Energy Science -Short- (Alane sir).pdfEnergy Science -Short- (Alane sir).pdf
Energy Science -Short- (Alane sir).pdf
AdityaSem127 vues
Developments in Ammonia Production Technology par Jahanzeb Khan
Developments in Ammonia Production TechnologyDevelopments in Ammonia Production Technology
Developments in Ammonia Production Technology
Jahanzeb Khan1.8K vues

Dernier

Global airborne satcom market report par
Global airborne satcom market reportGlobal airborne satcom market report
Global airborne satcom market reportdefencereport78
6 vues13 diapositives
_MAKRIADI-FOTEINI_diploma thesis.pptx par
_MAKRIADI-FOTEINI_diploma thesis.pptx_MAKRIADI-FOTEINI_diploma thesis.pptx
_MAKRIADI-FOTEINI_diploma thesis.pptxfotinimakriadi
10 vues32 diapositives
Renewal Projects in Seismic Construction par
Renewal Projects in Seismic ConstructionRenewal Projects in Seismic Construction
Renewal Projects in Seismic ConstructionEngineering & Seismic Construction
5 vues8 diapositives
Design of Structures and Foundations for Vibrating Machines, Arya-ONeill-Pinc... par
Design of Structures and Foundations for Vibrating Machines, Arya-ONeill-Pinc...Design of Structures and Foundations for Vibrating Machines, Arya-ONeill-Pinc...
Design of Structures and Foundations for Vibrating Machines, Arya-ONeill-Pinc...csegroupvn
6 vues210 diapositives
sam_software_eng_cv.pdf par
sam_software_eng_cv.pdfsam_software_eng_cv.pdf
sam_software_eng_cv.pdfsammyigbinovia
9 vues5 diapositives
Créativité dans le design mécanique à l’aide de l’optimisation topologique par
Créativité dans le design mécanique à l’aide de l’optimisation topologiqueCréativité dans le design mécanique à l’aide de l’optimisation topologique
Créativité dans le design mécanique à l’aide de l’optimisation topologiqueLIEGE CREATIVE
5 vues84 diapositives

Dernier(20)

_MAKRIADI-FOTEINI_diploma thesis.pptx par fotinimakriadi
_MAKRIADI-FOTEINI_diploma thesis.pptx_MAKRIADI-FOTEINI_diploma thesis.pptx
_MAKRIADI-FOTEINI_diploma thesis.pptx
fotinimakriadi10 vues
Design of Structures and Foundations for Vibrating Machines, Arya-ONeill-Pinc... par csegroupvn
Design of Structures and Foundations for Vibrating Machines, Arya-ONeill-Pinc...Design of Structures and Foundations for Vibrating Machines, Arya-ONeill-Pinc...
Design of Structures and Foundations for Vibrating Machines, Arya-ONeill-Pinc...
csegroupvn6 vues
Créativité dans le design mécanique à l’aide de l’optimisation topologique par LIEGE CREATIVE
Créativité dans le design mécanique à l’aide de l’optimisation topologiqueCréativité dans le design mécanique à l’aide de l’optimisation topologique
Créativité dans le design mécanique à l’aide de l’optimisation topologique
SUMIT SQL PROJECT SUPERSTORE 1.pptx par Sumit Jadhav
SUMIT SQL PROJECT SUPERSTORE 1.pptxSUMIT SQL PROJECT SUPERSTORE 1.pptx
SUMIT SQL PROJECT SUPERSTORE 1.pptx
Sumit Jadhav 22 vues
Ansari: Practical experiences with an LLM-based Islamic Assistant par M Waleed Kadous
Ansari: Practical experiences with an LLM-based Islamic AssistantAnsari: Practical experiences with an LLM-based Islamic Assistant
Ansari: Practical experiences with an LLM-based Islamic Assistant
GDSC Mikroskil Members Onboarding 2023.pdf par gdscmikroskil
GDSC Mikroskil Members Onboarding 2023.pdfGDSC Mikroskil Members Onboarding 2023.pdf
GDSC Mikroskil Members Onboarding 2023.pdf
gdscmikroskil59 vues
REACTJS.pdf par ArthyR3
REACTJS.pdfREACTJS.pdf
REACTJS.pdf
ArthyR335 vues
ASSIGNMENTS ON FUZZY LOGIC IN TRAFFIC FLOW.pdf par AlhamduKure
ASSIGNMENTS ON FUZZY LOGIC IN TRAFFIC FLOW.pdfASSIGNMENTS ON FUZZY LOGIC IN TRAFFIC FLOW.pdf
ASSIGNMENTS ON FUZZY LOGIC IN TRAFFIC FLOW.pdf
AlhamduKure6 vues
BCIC - Manufacturing Conclave - Technology-Driven Manufacturing for Growth par Innomantra
BCIC - Manufacturing Conclave -  Technology-Driven Manufacturing for GrowthBCIC - Manufacturing Conclave -  Technology-Driven Manufacturing for Growth
BCIC - Manufacturing Conclave - Technology-Driven Manufacturing for Growth
Innomantra 10 vues
MongoDB.pdf par ArthyR3
MongoDB.pdfMongoDB.pdf
MongoDB.pdf
ArthyR349 vues

Boiler efficiency by loss Method

  • 1. Heat Input Radiation Loss Steam Output BOILER EFFICIENCY Heat Input is Pulverised Coal Heat Output is Superheated Steam By Rajeev Saini Furnace Second Pass ESP
  • 2. Some important facts on Boiler Efficiency 1. Sec Air temp increased by 20*C =1% Fuel saving. 2. Flue gas temp reduced by 25*C = 1% Fuel saving. 3. Feed water temp increased by 5*C = 1% Fuel saving. 4. Oxygen % at APH I/L increased by 1%=0.32% Fuel Loss
  • 3. Boiler Use of low air pressure "film burners" helps save oil upto 15% in furnaces. IBR Steam Boilers means any closed vessel exceeding 22.75 liters.
  • 5. Efficiency Calculations Standards Standard Applied :- ASME Standard PTC 4.1 IS 8753: Indian Standard for Boiler Efficiency Testing British standards, BS845: 1987
  • 6. The Indirect Method Testing/Loss Method L1. Loss due to dry flue gas (sensible heat) L2. Loss due to hydrogen in fuel (H2) L3. Loss due to moisture in fuel (H2O) L4. Loss due to moisture in air (H2O) L5. Loss due to carbon monoxide (CO) L6. Loss due to surface radiation, convection and other unaccounted L7. Unburnt losses in fly ash (Carbon) L8. Unburnt losses in bottom ash (Carbon) Boiler Efficiency by indirect method = 100 - (L1 + L2 + L3 + L4 + L5 + L6 + L7 + L8)
  • 7. This is also known as ‘input-output method’ due to the fact that it needs only the useful output (steam) and the heat input (i.e. fuel) for evaluating the efficiency. This efficiency can be evaluated using the formula Q--Quantity of steam generated per hour in kg/hr. q--Quantity of fuel used per hour in kg/hr. GCV--gross calorific value of the fuel in kCal/kg of fuel
  • 8. =[(11.6 x 38.16)+{34.8 x (2.03-(6.28/8))}+(4.35x0.53)]/100 = 4.882 Kg/Kg of Coal =[(3.49)/(21-3.49)]X100 =19.9 % =[1+(19.9/100)]X100 Kg/Kg of Coal = 5.8535 Kg/Kg of Coal
  • 9. L1:- =[(0.467 X 44/12) +0.008+(5.885X 77/100) + (5.885-4.882)X23/100] Kg/Kg of Coal = 6.274 Kg/Kg of Coal L1= =[(6.274) X0.23X(149-33)X100]/3300 = 5.07 %
  • 10. L2:- =[9X0.0203 X{584 +0.45 X(149-33)X100]/3300 = 3.52 % L3:- =[5.5X{584 +0.45 X(149-33)X100]/3300 = 1.06 %
  • 11. L4:- L5:- =[5.885X0.0204 X0.45 X(149-33)X100]/3300 = 0.19 % =[(0.55X0.3816)/(0.55+17)] X[5744*100/3300] = 2.08 %
  • 12. L6:- = 0.184 % L7:- = 0.80 X0.467 X 452.5 X 100/ 3300 = 0.424 %
  • 13. L8:- = 0.80 X0.467 X 452.5 X 100/ 3300 = 1.152 % = 100- (5.07+3.52+0.19+2.08+0.424+1.152) = 86.320%
  • 14. Merits and Demerits of Direct Method Merits . Plant people can evaluate quickly the efficiency of boilers . Requires few parameters for computation . Needs few instruments for monitoring Demerits . Does not give clues to the operator as to why efficiency of system is lower . Does not calculate various losses accountable for various efficiency levels . Evaporation ratio and efficiency may mislead, if the steam is highly wet due to water carryover
  • 15. How to Improve efficiency of boiler Oxygen Trim Systems Flue gas outlet temperature MS temp HRH temp Feed Water Temp Blowdown control Blowdown heat recovery Flash Steam Recovery Steam Trap Leaks Exhaust Draft Control The effect of coal blending on combustion performance Air to fuel ratio control
  • 16. Factors Affecting Boiler Performance The various factors affecting the boiler performance are listed below: . Periodical cleaning of boilers . Periodical soot blowing . Proper water treatment programme and blow down control . Draft control . Excess air control . Percentage loading of boiler . Steam generation pressure and temperature . Boiler insulation . Quality of fuel