General Principles of Intellectual Property: Concepts of Intellectual Proper...
2010 10-26 qbpc patents and standards
1. CAEFI Quality Brands Protection Committee
Patents & Standards in China
QBPC
Patent and Innovation Committee
October 26, 2010
Dr. Sven Wehser, vice chair
2. CAEFI Quality Brands Protection Committee
Agenda
1.Standards Landscape
2.Main Standardization Related Issues
3.Patents and Standards – Milestones
4.Outlook
3. CAEFI Quality Brands Protection Committee
The Standards Landscape
• Standardization in China is government driven
• Leading institutions are:
• SAC,
• CNIS,
• AQSIQ,
• CQC,…
• 22,000 national standards,
• More than 50,000 industry standards in China,
• More than 443 technical committees (TC’s) active in
organizations which deal with drafting standards
4. CAEFI Quality Brands Protection Committee
Main Standardization Related Issues
1.China Compulsory Certification (CCC)
process,
2.Transparency of standardization in China,
3.Equal and fair access to standardization,
4.Integration of Chinese standardization into
global standards systems,
5.Balance rules for patents in standards.
5. CAEFI Quality Brands Protection Committee
Patents and Standards – Milestones (I)
• In 2008, SPC decision (JI) on patents
• “Patent owner required to give a license at
a rate which is substantially lower than
market rate”
• Received lively feedback
6. CAEFI Quality Brands Protection Committee
Patents and Standards – Milestones (II)
• Nov 2, 2009
• SAC: Provisional Regulations
• Nat’l Standards
– Essentiality?
• Disclosure
– Requirements for non-participating parties
– Liability for non-disclosure
• Declaration
– Licensing
– Royalty-free
– ‘FRAND’ plus substantially lower than ‘normal licensing fee’
• Mandatory Standards
– Compulsory license
7. CAEFI Quality Brands Protection Committee
• Jan 28, 2010
• CNIS: Disposal rules
– Detailed process, ministerial level rules
– Detailed definitions, eg Essentiality, affiliates,
technical contribution
– Disclosure also of pending patents, even unpublished
– Licensing (royalty-free or FRAND) – no mentioning of
‘substantially-lower’
– No compulsory disclosure requirement for public or
penalty
– Stays behind provisional rules
Patents and Standards – Milestones (III)
8. CAEFI Quality Brands Protection Committee
Outlook
• Reason for pragmatic optimism,
• Further implementation roadmap not clear,
• Process delayed,
• QBPC will closely follow and update,
• Watch this space!