2. Overview
What is Social Contract Theory?
Who was Thomas Hobbes?
What was Hobbes’ view of man and the state
of nature?
What is this thing Hobbes calls Leviathan?
3. The Social Contract
Political theory concerning political authority
and legitimacy
Speaks of the basis for and scope of
political power
Key Elements: the state of nature (and
thereby, the nature of man)
4. Thomas Hobbes
Born in 1588, Died in 1679
Oxford-educated Englishman and political
philosopher
One of the first social contract theorists
Famous work: Leviathan
5. The State of Nature
“Homo lupus hominis”
The state of nature is a state of war: the war
of every man against every man
Hence, life is “solitary (alone,lonly), poor, nasty,
brutish and short.”
6. Human Nature
Man possesses natural desires and
aversions.(strongdislike)
Man lives to satisfy his desires, which are
insatiable
In particular, men desire power
Desire for power is the principal cause of
difference among men
7. The Laws of Nature
Man is naturally averse to destroying
his life
Man will be willing to lay down his right
to all things if others do the same
Men perform the covenants they make
with their fellows
9. Leviathan
Embodiment of the greatest political
power
Arises when:
Individuals voluntarily renounce their right
to all things
Individuals bestow power upon an
individual/group of individuals to exercise
authority over them
10. Leviathan (cont’d)
Leviathan (the commonwealth)
possesses sovereign authority
The sovereign is the author of all law
and the basis of all justice
Subjects are bound to abide by the law
absolutely
11. Leviathan (cont’d+)
Subjects only possess liberty under the
law
That subjects possess liberties does not
diminish sovereign power
Under the law, everything is legal unless
otherwise proscribed
12. Lessons
Governments arise voluntarily among
men.
They represent vicarious(has done) consent
from the people.
Governments are necessary to enforce
order among men.
Hence they must possess power in order
to keep such order.
14. Beyond Freedom and Dignity
In Beyond Freedom and Dignity,
• behavioral psychologist B. F. Skinner summarized his
ideas about the nature of science, the techniques for
controlling human behavior, and the possibility of building a
happier and more stable society.
• Convinced that all human behavior is determined by
environment and biology, he denied the existence of free
will (or freedom) and moral autonomy (or dignity).
• Indeed, he held that illusions about their existence are
harmful, because they militate against the establishment of
an effective technology to eliminate harmful forms of
behavior.
15. Beyond Freedom and Dignity
• Skinner confidently proclaimed that, because of
modern science, engineering a better society is
entirely possible and that, once established, such
a society would produce people who voluntarily
pursue policies that promote survival.
• In particular, citizens would embrace limitations
on population growth and restrictions on practices
that damage the environment.
16. Beyond Freedom and
Dignity
• With confidence in the engineering skills of those who
would design and control the community, he was happy to
give these benevolent engineers the power to change “the
conditions under which men live and, hence, [to engage] in
the control of human behavior.”
• The key term for Skinner was “operant,” by which he
referred to any nonreflexive behavior that reacts to the
environment and produces reinforcing effects. Although
every operant exists naturally, it tends to.
17. End
People in Behaviorism and works
• Ivan Pavlov- classical conditioning.
• B.F. Skinner- Operant Conditioning
• John B. Watson- classical conditioning
• Realism and materialism
• Behaviorism as phil. Of educ.
• Methods and curriculum
• Role of teacher
• The leviathan
• Beyond freedom and dignity
Notes de l'éditeur
Learning Objectives:
1.) To understand Hobbes’s views on human nature as well as the nature of the social contract.
2.) To explain Hobbes’s notion of Leviathan.
Hobbes was known for his pessimistic view of human nature
“…the nature of man, consisteth not in actual fighting, but in the known disposition thereto, during all the time there is no assurance to the contrary.” p. 333
“Where there is no common power, there is no law; where no law, no justice.” p. 335
Since men are created equal, they also possess the same hope of satisfying their desires
- The problem arises when two or more men desire the same thing, which only one can possess
- Hence, each will do whatever it takes to possess that object
3 Causes of Quarrel
1.) Competition
The desire for gain
Entails the use of violence to subjugate others
2.) Diffidence
The desire for safety
Entails the use of violence to defend one’s person, family and belongings
3.) Glory
The desire for reputation
Entails the use of violence to attain “trifles”
“Leviathan”: metaphor for the monolithic character of the state
Greatest political power: that which is compounded and united by consent
Leviathan:
“One person, of whose acts a great multitude, by mutual covenants one with another, have made themselves every one the author, to the end he may use the strength and means of them all, as he shall think expedient, for their peace and common defense.”
What is just and unjust are determined by the sovereign will.
Hence, the sovereign can never be unjust
More, the sovereign is above the law
Subjects are bound to abide by the law with very few exceptions
This is because they are indirectly the authors of the law, given that they are principals of the social contract
Sovereigns are bound to make good laws: “…that, which is needful, for the good of the people, and withal perspicuous.” p. 348
Laws must be enforced in order to be effective; hence the need for Leviathan
Leviathan may not be deposed without its consent
- It is the legitimate government for so long