SlideShare une entreprise Scribd logo
1  sur  8
Télécharger pour lire hors ligne
Improving Classroom Dynamics: Click’N’Gage,
                 a Mobile Audience Response System

                  Ivo Neskovic
                            ∗
                                                      Dragan Bisercic                   Mitko Zafirovski
                  City College                           City College                      City College
             3, Leontos Sofou Street               3, Leontos Sofou Street           3, Leontos Sofou Street
              Thessaloniki, Greece                  Thessaloniki, Greece              Thessaloniki, Greece
          ivo.neskovic@gmail.com               dbisercic@city.academic.gr           mitkozaf@yahoo.com

ABSTRACT                                                         Keywords
The problem in communication between students and lec-           Audience response systems, classroom dynamics, connected
turers in large classrooms has increased substantially in last   limited device configuration, clickers, Java micro edition 2,
couple of years because many students do not participate         Java enterprise edition 6, mobile devices, student engage-
in classroom discussions. To engage students into dynamic        ment, sun Java wireless toolkit
classroom participation, universities often encourage stu-
dents to use audience response systems (ARS). By increasing
the interactivity between lecturer and students, the dynamic
student participation improves and the learning outcome is
                                                                 1. INTRODUCTION
expected to rise.                                                With the increasing number of students in the classrooms,
                                                                 the classroom teaching is becoming more and more a one
The progress in the mobile technologies has influenced new        way communication between lecturers and students. The
approaches in developing ARS. In this paper, we discuss the      problem with the large classrooms is that the lecturers are
need for mobile ARS and we propose a new architecture for        not able to engage in a discussion with every student. How-
developing those systems. Furthermore, we present details        ever, even when given chance, many students do not want to
from our reference implementation of the proposed architec-      get into discussion because they might be too shy, too tired,
ture, named Click’N’Gage, together with some of the crucial      or simply unconcerned with the topic discussed [11]. Such
design decisions we took while developing the system. The        one way communication approach to teaching can lead to
paper closes with a short evaluation of the system, together     many undesirable consequences. For example, the lecturer
with few ideas on how the system could be improved in the        in the classroom might not be able to always notice what
future.                                                          the students have understood in the lecture and what they
                                                                 have not understood. So, it might happen that the lecturer
                                                                 is moving too quickly over a difficult concept. The result is
Categories and Subject Descriptors                               students loosing interest in the subject matter. Therefore,
D.2.11 [Software Engineering]: Software Architectures—           the communication in the classroom should be a two way
domain-specific architectures; H.4 [Information Systems           communication between lecturers and students as often as
Applications]: Miscellaneous; J.1 [Computer Applica-             possible.
tions]: Administrative Data Processing—education; K.3.1
[Computers and Education]: Computer Uses in Edu-                 In order to enhance the classroom teaching and communi-
cation—computer-assisted instruction; K.3.2 [Computers           cation, many automated systems have been developed. The
and Education]: Computer and Information Science Edu-            goal of such automated systems is to get student responses
cation—self-assessment, curriculum                               as quickly and as cheaply as possible [5]. Also, the students
                                                                 are willing to participate more in classroom interaction when
                                                                 they can do it anonymously. Therefore, by letting all stu-
General Terms                                                    dents answer questions in class anonymously, the lecturers
Design, Performance, Human Factors                               can get more attention from students and improve the class-
                                                                 room learning.
∗City College is an International Faculty of the University
of Sheffield.                                                      In improving the classroom dynamics [7], we have found the
                                                                 main motivation for developing our system, Click’N’Gage.
                                                                 The inspiration of this paper is to present our solution to
                                                                 the problem explained above. The remainder of this paper
                                                                 is organized as follows: section 2 describes the audience re-
                                                                 sponse systems in general, section 3 discusses the advantages
                                                                 and disadvantages of some of the similar systems, section 4
                                                                 gives additional information on mobile clickers, section 5
                                                                 talks about the Click’N’Gage in detail, section 6 provides
                                                                 the evaluation of our system, and finally section 7 provides
                                                                 the conclusion and possible future extensions of the system.
2.   AUDIENCE RESPONSE SYSTEMS                                      ClassTalk used scientific calculators with data ports con-
An audience response system (ARS) is a system that can              nected to a basic network via wire [11]. It was a great sys-
help lecturers initiate the two way communication with their        tem for the time. However, nowadays such a system is not
students. The basic idea of such system can be explained in         considered appropriate due to high cost of the hardware and
three simple steps. Firstly, the lecturers introduce to stu-        many possible problems that can arise when trying to set up
dents a question with the list of possible answers. Secondly,       the system in the very large classrooms. Anyway, ClassTalk
the students choose the answer that they consider to be cor-        provides very simple functionality to its users. For exam-
rect. Finally, the answers are collected and the statistical        ple, the lecturer prompts the question on the projector and
results in the form of graphs are displayed to students.            the students answer the question via scientific calculators.
                                                                    When all the answers are collected by the system, the system
The most well known ARS systems used in education are               shows the graphs displaying the statistical results of student
clickers [15]. Clickers consist of three different parts. The        responses. These graphs tell the lecturer how much material
first part consists of the hand-held devices (clickers) that         has been understood by the students.
are used by the students to communicate information to
the system. Furthermore, the receiver is a device that gets         One of the first systems that used wireless communication
the information from the clickers. Finally, the third part is       between clickers and the system was EduCue’s PRS. This
a software application that stores, processes, and displays         system was developed at Hong Kong University of Science
student responses.                                                  and Technology by Nelson Cue and C. K. Lee [11]. EduCue
                                                                    used a keypad and infrared technology for sending signals. It
The clickers look similar to the TV remote control units            has become popular at many Universities. However, infrared
[15]. They can be hardwired to the receiver or they can             technology is today rarely used since it has been overcome
send data to the receiver wirelessly (infrared or radio fre-        by other modern wireless technologies.
quency). Such clickers have been used in Universities since
late 1990s. They enhance learning in class. Namely, by us-          Another interesting system that has been developed and
ing instant feedback, the lecturers are able to identify any        used is TXT-2-LRN. The system lets the students answer
concepts being misunderstood [13]. Also, they are fun to            the questions via their cellular phones using built in SMS
use since the lecturer can start a new, interesting, and dif-       technology. The only assumption that the developers made
ficult topic by starting the anonymous discussion between            was that most of the students actually own at least one cell
students. However, clickers are not free. Considering the           phone [12]. The system uses a sophisticated SMS filtering
fact that students need to pay tuition fees and textbooks,          tool on the server side. This approach leads to great avail-
the clickers can be too expensive for students if required for      ability of the system, which is easy to use since most of the
lectures. Also, it can be too expensive for the University to       students use SMS messaging facilities daily. The problem
provide clickers for all students. In addition to this, if click-   with this solutions, however, is the high cost of the SMS
ers are hardwired to the receiver, it might even be difficult         messages. It is a big burden for students when they need
to set up the system for very large classrooms.                     to pay from their own pockets for the use of the system.
                                                                    A survey has shown that almost 65% of the students using
The rapid development in mobile technologies has made pos-          TXT-2-LRN spend monthly around 35$ for SMS, approxi-
sible for developers to build cheaper ARS systems by using          mately sending 2 to 3 messages per day [12]. But, even with
cellular phones as the new development environment [12].            the high cost, 90% of the students had positive opinion of
The rationale for developing ARS systems on mobile phones           the system overall and they were happy to use it.
lies in the fact that most, if not all, students nowadays own
them [11, 8]. Modern mobile phones take all the advantages          Furthermore, one of the most advanced ARS systems today
of the new technologies. Therefore, these phones have be-           is VotApedia. This system is web based and gives its users
come more powerful than clickers. Not only that, mobile             few alternative options when voting. Namely, the users have
phones also do not require any installation process and they        the option to register with VotApedia web site and vote on-
do not distract students in classrooms while taking notes           line. Also, VotApedia has a specific algorithm that crates a
due to their small size [8]. The phones capable of running          specific phone number for each answer from the given ques-
Java applications using SMS, Bluetooth, or WiFi can signifi-         tion. The voters can call this phone number and answer the
cantly reduce the overall cost of the ARS system [3, 4]. Such       question or simply send SMS message with the answer to
mobile applications are fun and easy to use. However, the           the same phone number [2]. Given these options, VotApe-
possible drawback is that students might consume too much           dia can be very dynamic in terms of effectiveness, cost, and
time doing other things with the mobile phones instead of           complexity. Each of the voters can use anyone of the given
participating in class [12].                                        services. VotApedia seems to be a perfect system at the
                                                                    first glance, however, few flaws can be found when trying to
3.   SIMILAR SYSTEMS                                                apply the system in the classroom. The Web based voting
                                                                    option, where students need to log in and find the question
Many systems that use mobile phones or similar handheld
                                                                    created by the lecturer, can take a lot of time, which, unfor-
devices have been developed in recent years to improve the
                                                                    tunately, is a time that a class can not afford to lose. The
classroom interaction in educational institutions. In this
                                                                    other option, which is calling a number in order to vote, can
section, we discuss advantages and disadvantages of some of
                                                                    be easy for the students, but it disrupts the class when 200
these systems.
                                                                    students make a call at the same time. The SMS seems as
                                                                    a more discrete option than the previous two, however, the
One of the first ARS systems, developed in the early 1990s
                                                                    problems with SMS have already been explained above.
by Better Education Inc., is known today as ClassTalk [6].
While evaluating the above systems, a few drawbacks have          Connectivity: Due to the high cost of SMS messages, the
become apparent. The most notable disadvantage is the cost            proposed architecture utilizes the Internet. It is im-
of either setting up or using these systems. For example, in          portant to mention that the system will require only
most cases, the students are required to pay not only for the         an active Internet connection, not needing the details
tuition and books at the universities but also for the accom-         of how that connection is being established, whether
modation and food. Enforcing students to spend additional             it is through WAP, WiFi, GPRS or 3G. The rationale
resources for extra devices or services, which are needed only        behind this decision is that most of todays phones have
to improve the classroom participation, is considered as a            at least one way of connecting to the Internet and that
bad idea. In addition to this, not all universities can pro-          most universities offer free WiFi connection for its stu-
vide such devices or services for all of their students due to        dents inside its premises.
high cost. However, the cost is not the only drawback. The
                                                                  Duplicate Answers: It is imperative to restrict the stu-
lecturers need to put additional effort to design questions
                                                                      dent of providing more than one answer to a specific
before class. Therefore, some lecturers might consider the
                                                                      questions. Failure to achieve this feature might re-
benefits of using ARS negligible and continue lecturing in
                                                                      sult in inaccurate statistical charts presented to the
the traditional way.
                                                                      lecturer. The simplest method of achieving the de-
                                                                      sired effect is to assign user accounts to every stu-
4.     MOBILE CLICKERS AS AN AUDIENCE                                 dent and restrict the accounts of providing more than
       RESPONSE SYSTEM                                                one answer. However this conflicts with the feature
As we showcased in the previous section, mobile phones have           of anonymity, thus rendering it impossible to use ac-
been already an integral part of many of the most popular             counts. The mechanism of achieving this feature with-
audience response systems, albeit utilizing only the Short            out violation students’ anonymity is left for the con-
Message Service. Therefore, these systems generated high              crete implementation of our architecture, although we
costs for its end users, the students, which ranged to 35$            provide an example in our reference implementation
per month, a very high cost for the average student [12]. In          of the mobile clickers audience response system in the
spite of the high cost, most of the students were very happy          next section.
using their mobile device in the classroom [12, 15]. This         Question/Answer Correspondence: Students need to
paper proposes a new architecture for developing audience             know which question they are answering to and should
response systems utilizing mobile devices as their main com-          not be allowed to answer questions they are not sup-
ponent. The proposed architecture addresses the problems              posed to. This problem is solved by assigning a unique
raised in previous AR systems, introducing further improve-           code to every issued question which the students will
ments in the process.                                                 input before they provide their answer. The code will
                                                                      be generated by the system moments before the ques-
The abstract architecture of the mobile clickers ARS (Figure          tion is answered and will be presented by the lecturer
1) provides an overview of the proposed methodology:                  only to the class of students who should answer the
                                                                      question.
     1. Students use their Internet powered mobile devices to     Dynamic Number of Answers: Not all multiple choice
        answer questions [5]                                          questions will have the same number of possible an-
                                                                      swers. Usually, they are in the range of two, for true-
     2. Answers are sent over the Internet to the core applica-       false questions, to six answers. The system should al-
        tion system (server)                                          low the lecturer of specifying a concrete number of
                                                                      possible answers and this should be reflected at the
     3. Data is analyzed and statistical charts are generated         students mobile device screen. The way this could be
                                                                      achieved is by using a mechanism for dynamic genera-
     4. Results are observed by the lecturer                          tion of the answering form on the mobile device which
                                                                      will provide custom screens for every amount of possi-
                                                                      ble answers.
Using this architecture, answers are no longer sent via SMS
and it introduces the concept of an answers storage place,
which in turn provides the ability to extract statistical data    Using our proposed architecture does not only solve the
used by lecturers for self-improvement. Additionally, our         problems identified in the reviewed AR systems, but it also
architecture allows for implementing extra Quality of Service     provides extra features that are crucial for the adoption of
(QoS) [9] features into the system. We have identified five         the mobile clickers audience response system.
key features that every ARS should provide:
                                                                  5. REALIZATION OF CLICK’N’GAGE
                                                                  Click’N’Gage is the reference implementation of the mobile
Anonymity: The system does not use any student personal           clickers audience response system, developed in partial ful-
    data. Anonymity and trust are two very important is-          fillment of the Industrial Group Project module at City Col-
    sues that students have [1, 14, 6]. The reviewed AR           lege. As the proposed architectural design implies, the sys-
    systems use the students telephone number for identi-         tem is composed of two main components: the mobile client
    fication, which creates discomfort for them. The pro-          and the main system dashboard. Design-wise, both of the
    posed architecture does not use any data which can be         components were developed as separate systems in a vac-
    used to track back an answer to a specific student.            uum [10]. Consequently, each of them has been targeted to
Figure 1: Architectural overview of a mobile clickers audience response system.


a different user group, leading to design decision specific for
the targeted audience. The users of the mobile client are the
students themselves, whereas the users of the dashboard are
the university’s lecturers.

The mobile client has been developed for the Java platform,
using the Java Micro Edition 2.0 SDK. Considering the fact
that more than 2.1 million mobile devices are pre-installed
with a Java Virtual Machine (JVM), is a justification enough
for choosing the Java platform. Additionally, this allows
for easier distribution due to Java’s ”Write once, run any-
where!” nature. The application is packaged as a standard
Java Archive (JAR) file which is guaranteed to run on every
Java enabled mobile device.

5.1   Students’ Mobile Client                                    Figure 2: The main screens presented to the stu-
Simplicity and usability are two invariants present through-     dent.
out the mobile client system. It is imperative for the student
to easily answer a given question, with minimal involvement.
The only tasks required from the student are to enter the        all of the steps performed by the system and the input re-
question code and to provide the question answer. This is        quired from the user for a successful execution.
achieved by using only two forms which can be observed in
Figure 2.                                                        Finally, all of the five key characteristics of a mobile audience
                                                                 response system with the exception of Question/Answer Cor-
Internally, the mobile client is in a constant communica-        respondence are developed exclusively in the mobile client.
tion with the core Click’N’Gage application. This has been       The following few paragraphs discuss each of them in greater
achieved with the use of SOAP-enabled Web Services (WS).         detail.
Part of the core functionality has been exposed on the In-
ternet in a form of a WS, offering two operations:
                                                                 Anonymity vs. Duplicate Answers. Trust is one of the
                                                                 major issues that students have with audience response sys-
   • Validate the question code and return the number of         tems used in educational settings. Their main concern is
     possible answers for the corresponding question             that their performance, while answering the given questions
                                                                 in class, will affect their grade in an often negative way. For
   • Submit the student’s answer to the specific question         this reason, the Click’N’Gage system does not use the usual
                                                                 notion of accounts which is present in commercial audience
                                                                 response systems. This however, conflicts with the necessity
The mobile client has access to the service endpoint and con-    to control students to answer each question only once.
nects upon initialization. The operations of the Web Service
are then invoked as needed. The function flow diagram (Fig-       The solution implemented for this two conflicting issues is
ure 3) provides a more detailed explanation, clearly stating     the use a unique identifier of the mobile device. Every man-
Connectivity. One of the goals of Click’N’Gage is to allow
                                                                 students to use their preferred typed of connection (WAP,
                                                                 WiFi, GPRS or 3G) to connect their mobile clients to the
                                                                 core server of the application. Fortunately, Java ME offers
                                                                 an abstract way of establishing connections. Using Java’s
                                                                 Generic Connection Framework, the mobile client is devel-
                                                                 oped in such a way that it only needs an active Internet
                                                                 connection, without requiring the details of the type of the
                                                                 connection and how it is established. The framework auto-
                                                                 matically extracts this data from the native operating sys-
                                                                 tem of the mobile device. Because privacy is a crucial con-
                                                                 cept throughout the development of Click’N’Gage, this data
                                                                 is not accessed without the user’s consent.

                                                                 5.2 Lecturers’ Dashboard
                                                                 Similarly with the mobile client, the lecturers’ dashboard has
                                                                 been developed with two invariants present in the system:
                                                                 intuition and innovation. The dashboard is developed as
                                                                 a web application which offers novel and innovative way of
                                                                 interacting with the lecturer and presenting data. It acts as
                                                                 a management portal of the core Click’N’Gage application.

                                                                 Click’N’Gage has been developed as a Java Enterprise Edi-
                                                                 tion (EE) 6.0 application. It runs on a Glassfish V3.0 ap-
                                                                 plication server, and is connected to a database stored on
                                                                 a MySQL Community Edition Server 5.1.47. The presenta-
Figure 3:    Function flow diagram for the mobile                 tion layer of the overall application is handled by the recently
client.                                                          updated Java Server Faces 2.0 technology, which now allows
                                                                 for clear web site development using XHTML, while at the
                                                                 same time exposing custom tags with the ability to access
                                                                 data encapsulated in the Java application. The flow of the
                                                                 internal execution of Click’N’Gage is depicted in Figure 4,
ufactured mobile device, whether it is a GSM, WCDMA,             which emphasizes the core steps performed when an answer
iDEN or a satellite phone, has a unique International Mo-        is submitted to the system.
bile Equipment Identity (IMEI) number assigned to it. The
number is usually printed inside the batter compartment of       Prior to using the system, lecturers must register and create
the mobile device. Using Java’s ability to read the properties   their account with Click’N’Gage using the web registration
of the mobile device, the IMEI number is acquired which is       form. In order to prevent misuse of the system, upon the
processed by a hash function, together with the issue date of    completion of the registration, the lecturer needs to wait for
the question, and sent with every answer to the server. This     an official acceptance e-mail from the system’s administra-
in turn ensures that no question will be answered more than      tor, who is responsible for maintaining Click’N’Gage.
once from a device with the same IMEI number and because
there are no meaningful information enclosed in the hash it      Once registered, the lecturer is able to:
is impossible to track back the number to the specific user.
The hash is computed on both the IMEI number and the
issue date of the question answered to ensure that the same      Enroll on a course - Enrolling on a course signifies that
hash will not repeat itself on more than one question which          the lecturer is teaching the specific course. Lecturer’s
with some careful statistical analysis might lead to mapping         can only browse, create and issue questions for courses
the hash value to a student.                                         that they teach.

                                                                 Create a course - If a lecturer starts a new course at the
                                                                     university, he/she must first create it in the system by
Dynamic Form Generation. Click’N’Gage offers lecturers                specifying the course name and its unique code.
the ability to specify the number of possible answers to
a question, varying from the minimum of two answers, to          Create a question - Creating a question involves the lec-
the maximum of six. This feature however, leads to consis-           turer stating the question, providing some keywords
tency issues with the screens of the mobile device. The form         which describe it (keywords are used in refining the
present on the screen of the mobile device must offer the             search results), providing the possible answers and spec-
same number of choices as the question has. This has been            ifying the correct one, and finally selecting the type of
achieved by modifying the Web Service operation, which               chart in which the results will be displayed.
performs the validation of the question code, to return the
number of possible answers for said question. Afterwards,        Browse existing questions - Upon selecting a course, the
the form of choices is dynamically generated, according to           lecturer will be presented with a list of questions for
this number.                                                         the specific course. In the case of a long list, which
Figure 4: Detailed architectural diagram of the core Click’N’Gage system.




Figure 5: Example of a time-series statistical chart.
                                                                             Figure 6: Sample chart types.

     would be the result of using the system for few years,
     the lecturer can refine the search by filtering the search    Additionally, every issued question has a corresponding chart
     results using the keywords specified when creating the       illustrating the results from the students answers (Figure 6).
     question. Clicking on an entry in the presented list        The type of the chart is the one specified when the ques-
     will redirect the lecturer to the statistics page for the   tion is first created, possible choices being Bar, Bar 3D,
     selected question, and clicking on the Issue link next to   Pie, Pie 3D charts. An innovative feature implemented
     every question will generate the unique question code,      in Click’N’Gage is the dynamic generation of the images
     used by the students to answer the question.                representing the charts whenever they are requested from
                                                                 the browser or when embedded in a MicrosoftTM Power-
                                                                 Point presentation. When a user navigates its browser to
Using JFreeChart, an open source chart generation library        http://x.x.x.x/clickngage/charts/IQC.png, the system
implemented in the Java programming language, we offer a          automatically locates the question specified with the code,
variety of statistical charts to the lecturer. Every question    recalculates the submitted answers and returns an updated
has a time-series chart which represents the success rate of     chart every time. The same holds for the time-series charts,
the question over time (Figure 5). It calculates the amount      with the only difference in the request URL which is
of correct answers submitted to every question instance and      http://x.x.x.x/clickngage/timeseries/QID.png. This
it presents a graph where the domain axis is the set of dates    feature is specifically useful when embedding result charts
when the specific question has been issued to the students,       in various presentations and reports.
and the range axis is the set of percentages of correct an-
swers submitted for the question. This type of charts is         Last, but not least, it is important to mention that the web
particularly useful for the self-evaluation of lecturers.        application has been developed using the Web 2.0 standards,
which include asynchronous AJAX communication with the            ate feedback from students to be very helpful. They can use
server, full XHTML and CSS conformance and a design fol-          feedback to reevaluate and improve their teaching methods.
lowing the Web 2.0 guidelines.                                    The students, on the other hand, can easily participate in
                                                                  classroom discussions while using this system. The system
6.   EVALUATION                                                   provides anonymity and it is simple to use, therefore, it en-
Click’N’Gage has been demoed at the 9th Student Spring            courages students’ engagement in the classroom. Moreover,
Symposium, organized annually at City College, Thessa-            lecturers have insights on statistical data that is generated
loniki. The presentation included a detailed discussion of the    over significant period of time. This motivates lecturer to
system. After the presentation, the students in the audience      use the system.
got an opportunity to participate in the system evaluation.
Over 30 students took part in the evaluation. Firstly, they       The Click’N’Gage software application is built in a modular
were required to download the mobile application from our         approach. The modularity supports extensibility. There-
web site. Then, a question and a list of possible answers         fore, many possible future extensions are possible for our
were displayed on the projector. The students chose an an-        system. One possible future extension includes porting the
swer and submitted it via mobile application. After that,         Java mobile application to both iPhone and Android. The
the output was displayed in graphical notation. Finally, the      current version of the Click’N’Gage does not support these
students gave us feedback on the system. The feedback was         two popular mobile platforms. Furthermore, another possi-
positive and few interesting observations were discussed in       ble extension is the integration of Click’N’Gage with LMS.
greater detail.                                                   Such integration would keep the overhead of creating and
                                                                  enrolling courses by lecturer minimized. Last but not least,
Everyone at the symposium agreed that Click’N’Gage can            the system could, in the future, support student assessment
improve the traditional practices in education. Before eval-      in the form of quizzes and tests.
uation, many students considered that the system would be
unnecessary. However, later they enjoyed using it and saw         8. REFERENCES
the benefit for both students and lecturers. What students          [1] A. Abrahamson. Teaching with classroom
liked the most was that everyone was welcome to participate            communication system: What it involves and why it
in class. Also, they liked the simplicity and usability of the         works. In 7th International Workshop New Trends in
mobile application. The lecturers were particularly satisfied           Physics Teaching, Puebla, Mexico, number July 1992,
with the instant feedback received from the student.                   1999.
                                                                   [2] R. Alves. Enhancements to VotApedia Audience
Furthermore, before evaluation, some lecturers considered              Response System.
that activities related to designing questions and using mo-
                                                                   [3] R. Davidrajuh. Java Bluetooth Wireless Technology
bile clickers in class can be time consuming. They ques-
                                                                       for Evaluating Student Performance in Classroom.
tioned the benefit of the system by stressing the operational
                                                                       Citeseer, 5(4):33–38, 2005.
costs. However, after the demonstration, they accepted that
benefits of using the system are far more important than            [4] R. Davidrajuh. Evaluating performance of a
the overhead of creating questions before class. In addi-              Bluetooth-based classroom tool. International Journal
tion to this, lecturers made couple of interesting suggestions.        of Mobile Learning and Organisation, 3(2):148, 2009.
Namely, they would like to see the system integrated with          [5] M. Esponda. Electronic voting on-the-fly with mobile
the existing Learning Management Systems (LMS), such as                devices. ACM SIGCSE Bulletin, 40(3):93, August
Claroline - the one used at City College, in order to take             2008.
some of the advantages that those systems offer.                    [6] R. H. Kay and A. LeSage. Examining the benefits and
                                                                       challenges of using audience response systems: A
Nevertheless, both students and lecturers agreed at the end            review of the literature. Computers & Education,
that Click’N’Gage can keep students more focused and pro-              53(3):819–827, November 2009.
vide better communication. Therefore, the system provides          [7] S. O. King and C. L. Robinson. ’Pretty Lights’ and
the means for enhancing classroom learning. However, the               Maths! Increasing student engagement and enhancing
outcome of such teaching could not be evaluated. Only the              learning through the use of electronic voting systems.
use of the system for a longer period of time (couple of years)        Computers & Education, 53(1):189–199, August 2009.
can show the actual outcome of this approach to teaching.          [8] D. Lindquist, T. Denning, M. Kelly, R. Malani, W. G.
                                                                       Griswold, and B. Simon. Exploring the potential of
7. CONCLUSIONS AND FUTURE WORK                                         mobile phones for active learning in the classroom.
Classroom interaction at universities is considered to be very         Proceedinds of the 38th SIGCSE technical symposium
important. The recent advances in mobile technologies have             on Computer science education - SIGCSE ’07, page
enabled the use of mobile phones in the classrooms as a                384, 2007.
tool for the mutual benefit for both students and lecturers.        [9] I. Pah, C. Oprean, I. Moisil, and C. Kifor. Technology
Furthermore, the mobile phones provide notable extension               to Support Education Software Solutions for Quality
over the traditional clickers. By providing support for bet-           Assurance in e-learning. Communications, III:433–436,
ter communication between students and lecturers, mobile               2008.
phones are expected to improve the learning outcome as well.      [10] R. Pressman. Software Engineering: A Practitioner’s
                                                                       Approach. McGraw-Hill, Inc., New York, NY, USA,
Our software, Click’N’Gage, provides a support for better              7th edition, July 2010.
interactivity in classrooms. The lecturers find the immedi-        [11] G. Russell and I. Pitt. Visions of a wireless future in
education technology. Journal of issues in Informing
       Science and Information Technology, 1:747–752, 2004.
[12]   E. Scornavacca, S. Huff, and S. Marshall. Mobile
       phones in the classroom. Communications of the
       ACM, 52(4):142, April 2009.
[13]   B. F. E. Sharkawy and F. Meawad. Instant Feedback
       Using Mobile Messaging Technologies. 2009 Third
       International Conference on Next Generation Mobile
       Applications, Services and Technologies, pages
       539–544, September 2009.
[14]   J. Wasteney. The Impact of Voting Systems in the
       Classroom. Bill Tagg Bursary Research Project, 2005,
       2004.
[15]   W. Wood. Clickers: A Teaching Gimmick that Works.
       Developmental Cell, 7(6):796–798, 2004.

Contenu connexe

Tendances

Clickers-solicits-real-interactive-engagement-in-education4
Clickers-solicits-real-interactive-engagement-in-education4Clickers-solicits-real-interactive-engagement-in-education4
Clickers-solicits-real-interactive-engagement-in-education4Aakansha Sharma
 
Low cost audience polling using computer vision
Low cost audience polling using computer visionLow cost audience polling using computer vision
Low cost audience polling using computer visionMicrosoft India
 
Solving The Problem of Adaptive E-Learning By Using Social Networks
Solving The Problem of Adaptive E-Learning By Using Social NetworksSolving The Problem of Adaptive E-Learning By Using Social Networks
Solving The Problem of Adaptive E-Learning By Using Social NetworksEswar Publications
 
Question & Answer 2.0: A System to facilitate interaction during and after a ...
Question & Answer 2.0: A System to facilitate interaction during and after a ...Question & Answer 2.0: A System to facilitate interaction during and after a ...
Question & Answer 2.0: A System to facilitate interaction during and after a ...Kai Michael Höver
 
The utilization of virtual learning environment (vle) to improve mathematics ...
The utilization of virtual learning environment (vle) to improve mathematics ...The utilization of virtual learning environment (vle) to improve mathematics ...
The utilization of virtual learning environment (vle) to improve mathematics ...STEPHEN ONUH OLA
 
Tools and Evaluation Techniques to Support Social Awareness in CSCeL: The AVA...
Tools and Evaluation Techniques to Support Social Awareness in CSCeL: The AVA...Tools and Evaluation Techniques to Support Social Awareness in CSCeL: The AVA...
Tools and Evaluation Techniques to Support Social Awareness in CSCeL: The AVA...EuroCAT CSCL
 
E Learning In Modern Education System .
E Learning In Modern Education System .E Learning In Modern Education System .
E Learning In Modern Education System .Assignment Studio
 
Budget Simulation Assignment Renee Jackson
Budget Simulation Assignment Renee JacksonBudget Simulation Assignment Renee Jackson
Budget Simulation Assignment Renee Jacksonrjackstar
 
IRJET - Automatic Lip Reading: Classification of Words and Phrases using Conv...
IRJET - Automatic Lip Reading: Classification of Words and Phrases using Conv...IRJET - Automatic Lip Reading: Classification of Words and Phrases using Conv...
IRJET - Automatic Lip Reading: Classification of Words and Phrases using Conv...IRJET Journal
 
Using Virtual Computing Labs to Increase Active Learning Among K-12 Students
Using Virtual Computing Labs to Increase Active Learning Among K-12 StudentsUsing Virtual Computing Labs to Increase Active Learning Among K-12 Students
Using Virtual Computing Labs to Increase Active Learning Among K-12 StudentsBDPA Education and Technology Foundation
 
Lecturer perspectives on ict uptake in language teaching thu&giang-dec11
Lecturer perspectives on ict uptake in language teaching thu&giang-dec11Lecturer perspectives on ict uptake in language teaching thu&giang-dec11
Lecturer perspectives on ict uptake in language teaching thu&giang-dec11tdbt_123
 
iBaTs: Interactive Bash Shell Adaptive Tutoring System
iBaTs: Interactive Bash Shell Adaptive Tutoring SystemiBaTs: Interactive Bash Shell Adaptive Tutoring System
iBaTs: Interactive Bash Shell Adaptive Tutoring SystemCSCJournals
 
QOE MODEL FOR MULTIMEDIA CONTENT DELIVERY FROM MCLOUD TO MOBILE DEVICES
QOE MODEL FOR MULTIMEDIA CONTENT DELIVERY FROM MCLOUD TO MOBILE DEVICESQOE MODEL FOR MULTIMEDIA CONTENT DELIVERY FROM MCLOUD TO MOBILE DEVICES
QOE MODEL FOR MULTIMEDIA CONTENT DELIVERY FROM MCLOUD TO MOBILE DEVICESijfcstjournal
 

Tendances (18)

Clickers-solicits-real-interactive-engagement-in-education4
Clickers-solicits-real-interactive-engagement-in-education4Clickers-solicits-real-interactive-engagement-in-education4
Clickers-solicits-real-interactive-engagement-in-education4
 
Low cost audience polling using computer vision
Low cost audience polling using computer visionLow cost audience polling using computer vision
Low cost audience polling using computer vision
 
Solving The Problem of Adaptive E-Learning By Using Social Networks
Solving The Problem of Adaptive E-Learning By Using Social NetworksSolving The Problem of Adaptive E-Learning By Using Social Networks
Solving The Problem of Adaptive E-Learning By Using Social Networks
 
5009a270
5009a2705009a270
5009a270
 
Question & Answer 2.0: A System to facilitate interaction during and after a ...
Question & Answer 2.0: A System to facilitate interaction during and after a ...Question & Answer 2.0: A System to facilitate interaction during and after a ...
Question & Answer 2.0: A System to facilitate interaction during and after a ...
 
Dissertation
DissertationDissertation
Dissertation
 
The utilization of virtual learning environment (vle) to improve mathematics ...
The utilization of virtual learning environment (vle) to improve mathematics ...The utilization of virtual learning environment (vle) to improve mathematics ...
The utilization of virtual learning environment (vle) to improve mathematics ...
 
Tools and Evaluation Techniques to Support Social Awareness in CSCeL: The AVA...
Tools and Evaluation Techniques to Support Social Awareness in CSCeL: The AVA...Tools and Evaluation Techniques to Support Social Awareness in CSCeL: The AVA...
Tools and Evaluation Techniques to Support Social Awareness in CSCeL: The AVA...
 
E Learning In Modern Education System .
E Learning In Modern Education System .E Learning In Modern Education System .
E Learning In Modern Education System .
 
Budget Simulation Assignment Renee Jackson
Budget Simulation Assignment Renee JacksonBudget Simulation Assignment Renee Jackson
Budget Simulation Assignment Renee Jackson
 
IRJET - Automatic Lip Reading: Classification of Words and Phrases using Conv...
IRJET - Automatic Lip Reading: Classification of Words and Phrases using Conv...IRJET - Automatic Lip Reading: Classification of Words and Phrases using Conv...
IRJET - Automatic Lip Reading: Classification of Words and Phrases using Conv...
 
Using Virtual Computing Labs to Increase Active Learning Among K-12 Students
Using Virtual Computing Labs to Increase Active Learning Among K-12 StudentsUsing Virtual Computing Labs to Increase Active Learning Among K-12 Students
Using Virtual Computing Labs to Increase Active Learning Among K-12 Students
 
Lecturer perspectives on ict uptake in language teaching thu&giang-dec11
Lecturer perspectives on ict uptake in language teaching thu&giang-dec11Lecturer perspectives on ict uptake in language teaching thu&giang-dec11
Lecturer perspectives on ict uptake in language teaching thu&giang-dec11
 
iBaTs: Interactive Bash Shell Adaptive Tutoring System
iBaTs: Interactive Bash Shell Adaptive Tutoring SystemiBaTs: Interactive Bash Shell Adaptive Tutoring System
iBaTs: Interactive Bash Shell Adaptive Tutoring System
 
ICT in Assessment: A Backbone for Teaching and Learning Process
ICT in Assessment: A Backbone for Teaching and Learning ProcessICT in Assessment: A Backbone for Teaching and Learning Process
ICT in Assessment: A Backbone for Teaching and Learning Process
 
Technology and Learning
Technology and LearningTechnology and Learning
Technology and Learning
 
QOE MODEL FOR MULTIMEDIA CONTENT DELIVERY FROM MCLOUD TO MOBILE DEVICES
QOE MODEL FOR MULTIMEDIA CONTENT DELIVERY FROM MCLOUD TO MOBILE DEVICESQOE MODEL FOR MULTIMEDIA CONTENT DELIVERY FROM MCLOUD TO MOBILE DEVICES
QOE MODEL FOR MULTIMEDIA CONTENT DELIVERY FROM MCLOUD TO MOBILE DEVICES
 
ECHO project
ECHO projectECHO project
ECHO project
 

En vedette

Key skills of EFL teacher
Key skills of  EFL teacherKey skills of  EFL teacher
Key skills of EFL teachersherifakl
 
Body language and voice variety in teaching
Body language and voice variety in teachingBody language and voice variety in teaching
Body language and voice variety in teachingDavid Lind
 
Gamifiying learning in my classroom
Gamifiying learning in my classroomGamifiying learning in my classroom
Gamifiying learning in my classroomalice_leung
 
Training workshop for teachers on participatory teaching methods
Training workshop for teachers on participatory teaching methodsTraining workshop for teachers on participatory teaching methods
Training workshop for teachers on participatory teaching methodsAyoub Kafyulilo
 
the principles of teaching speaking
the principles of teaching speakingthe principles of teaching speaking
the principles of teaching speakingRead Wan
 
Interactive Teaching Strategies
Interactive Teaching StrategiesInteractive Teaching Strategies
Interactive Teaching StrategiesPinoy Guro
 
Activities in teaching speaking
Activities in teaching speakingActivities in teaching speaking
Activities in teaching speakingDraizelle Sexon
 

En vedette (9)

Key skills of EFL teacher
Key skills of  EFL teacherKey skills of  EFL teacher
Key skills of EFL teacher
 
Body language and voice variety in teaching
Body language and voice variety in teachingBody language and voice variety in teaching
Body language and voice variety in teaching
 
Gamifiying learning in my classroom
Gamifiying learning in my classroomGamifiying learning in my classroom
Gamifiying learning in my classroom
 
Classroom Dynamics
Classroom DynamicsClassroom Dynamics
Classroom Dynamics
 
The dynamic classroom
The dynamic classroomThe dynamic classroom
The dynamic classroom
 
Training workshop for teachers on participatory teaching methods
Training workshop for teachers on participatory teaching methodsTraining workshop for teachers on participatory teaching methods
Training workshop for teachers on participatory teaching methods
 
the principles of teaching speaking
the principles of teaching speakingthe principles of teaching speaking
the principles of teaching speaking
 
Interactive Teaching Strategies
Interactive Teaching StrategiesInteractive Teaching Strategies
Interactive Teaching Strategies
 
Activities in teaching speaking
Activities in teaching speakingActivities in teaching speaking
Activities in teaching speaking
 

Similaire à Improving Classroom Dynamics: Click’N’Gage, a Mobile Audience Response System

Using Ontology in Electronic Evaluation for Personalization of eLearning Systems
Using Ontology in Electronic Evaluation for Personalization of eLearning SystemsUsing Ontology in Electronic Evaluation for Personalization of eLearning Systems
Using Ontology in Electronic Evaluation for Personalization of eLearning Systemsinfopapers
 
Language Translation for E-learning Systems
Language Translation for E-learning SystemsLanguage Translation for E-learning Systems
Language Translation for E-learning SystemsIRJET Journal
 
A Survey on E-Learning System with Data Mining
A Survey on E-Learning System with Data MiningA Survey on E-Learning System with Data Mining
A Survey on E-Learning System with Data MiningIIRindia
 
Selection of Learning Materials Based on Students’ Behaviors in 3DMUVLE
Selection of Learning Materials Based on Students’ Behaviors in 3DMUVLESelection of Learning Materials Based on Students’ Behaviors in 3DMUVLE
Selection of Learning Materials Based on Students’ Behaviors in 3DMUVLETELKOMNIKA JOURNAL
 
IMMEDIATE FEEDBACK: A NEW MECHANISM FORREAL-TIMEFEEDBACK ON CLASSROOM TEACHIN...
IMMEDIATE FEEDBACK: A NEW MECHANISM FORREAL-TIMEFEEDBACK ON CLASSROOM TEACHIN...IMMEDIATE FEEDBACK: A NEW MECHANISM FORREAL-TIMEFEEDBACK ON CLASSROOM TEACHIN...
IMMEDIATE FEEDBACK: A NEW MECHANISM FORREAL-TIMEFEEDBACK ON CLASSROOM TEACHIN...IJITE
 
Immediate Feedback : A New Mechanism for Real Time Feedback on Classroom Teac...
Immediate Feedback : A New Mechanism for Real Time Feedback on Classroom Teac...Immediate Feedback : A New Mechanism for Real Time Feedback on Classroom Teac...
Immediate Feedback : A New Mechanism for Real Time Feedback on Classroom Teac...IJITE
 
IMMEDIATE FEEDBACK: A NEW MECHANISM FORREAL-TIMEFEEDBACK ON CLASSROOM TEACHIN...
IMMEDIATE FEEDBACK: A NEW MECHANISM FORREAL-TIMEFEEDBACK ON CLASSROOM TEACHIN...IMMEDIATE FEEDBACK: A NEW MECHANISM FORREAL-TIMEFEEDBACK ON CLASSROOM TEACHIN...
IMMEDIATE FEEDBACK: A NEW MECHANISM FORREAL-TIMEFEEDBACK ON CLASSROOM TEACHIN...IJITE
 
Immediate Feedback : A New Mechanism for Real Time Feedback on Classroom Teac...
Immediate Feedback : A New Mechanism for Real Time Feedback on Classroom Teac...Immediate Feedback : A New Mechanism for Real Time Feedback on Classroom Teac...
Immediate Feedback : A New Mechanism for Real Time Feedback on Classroom Teac...IJITE
 
Immediate Feedback : A New Mechanism for Real Time Feedback on Classroom Teac...
Immediate Feedback : A New Mechanism for Real Time Feedback on Classroom Teac...Immediate Feedback : A New Mechanism for Real Time Feedback on Classroom Teac...
Immediate Feedback : A New Mechanism for Real Time Feedback on Classroom Teac...IJITE
 
Mobile Learning Framework & Evaluation
Mobile Learning Framework & EvaluationMobile Learning Framework & Evaluation
Mobile Learning Framework & Evaluationador
 
A Flowchart-Based Intelligent Tutoring System For Improving Problem-Solving S...
A Flowchart-Based Intelligent Tutoring System For Improving Problem-Solving S...A Flowchart-Based Intelligent Tutoring System For Improving Problem-Solving S...
A Flowchart-Based Intelligent Tutoring System For Improving Problem-Solving S...Martha Brown
 
Recent Trends in E-Learning and Technologies
Recent Trends in E-Learning and Technologies Recent Trends in E-Learning and Technologies
Recent Trends in E-Learning and Technologies IIJSRJournal
 
Information Communication Technology: Practices for Academia
Information Communication Technology: Practices for AcademiaInformation Communication Technology: Practices for Academia
Information Communication Technology: Practices for AcademiaIJMER
 
Technology To Support Learning
Technology To Support LearningTechnology To Support Learning
Technology To Support LearningMaha_Saeed
 
AN ADAPTIVE AND INTELLIGENT TUTOR BY EXPERT SYSTEMS FOR MOBILE DEVICES
AN ADAPTIVE AND INTELLIGENT TUTOR BY EXPERT SYSTEMS FOR MOBILE DEVICESAN ADAPTIVE AND INTELLIGENT TUTOR BY EXPERT SYSTEMS FOR MOBILE DEVICES
AN ADAPTIVE AND INTELLIGENT TUTOR BY EXPERT SYSTEMS FOR MOBILE DEVICESijmpict
 
Review of monitoring tools for e learning platforms
Review of monitoring tools for e learning platformsReview of monitoring tools for e learning platforms
Review of monitoring tools for e learning platformsijcsit
 
An analysis of Mobile Learning Implementation in Shinas College of Technology...
An analysis of Mobile Learning Implementation in Shinas College of Technology...An analysis of Mobile Learning Implementation in Shinas College of Technology...
An analysis of Mobile Learning Implementation in Shinas College of Technology...ijcnes
 

Similaire à Improving Classroom Dynamics: Click’N’Gage, a Mobile Audience Response System (20)

Using Ontology in Electronic Evaluation for Personalization of eLearning Systems
Using Ontology in Electronic Evaluation for Personalization of eLearning SystemsUsing Ontology in Electronic Evaluation for Personalization of eLearning Systems
Using Ontology in Electronic Evaluation for Personalization of eLearning Systems
 
Language Translation for E-learning Systems
Language Translation for E-learning SystemsLanguage Translation for E-learning Systems
Language Translation for E-learning Systems
 
A Survey on E-Learning System with Data Mining
A Survey on E-Learning System with Data MiningA Survey on E-Learning System with Data Mining
A Survey on E-Learning System with Data Mining
 
Selection of Learning Materials Based on Students’ Behaviors in 3DMUVLE
Selection of Learning Materials Based on Students’ Behaviors in 3DMUVLESelection of Learning Materials Based on Students’ Behaviors in 3DMUVLE
Selection of Learning Materials Based on Students’ Behaviors in 3DMUVLE
 
IMMEDIATE FEEDBACK: A NEW MECHANISM FORREAL-TIMEFEEDBACK ON CLASSROOM TEACHIN...
IMMEDIATE FEEDBACK: A NEW MECHANISM FORREAL-TIMEFEEDBACK ON CLASSROOM TEACHIN...IMMEDIATE FEEDBACK: A NEW MECHANISM FORREAL-TIMEFEEDBACK ON CLASSROOM TEACHIN...
IMMEDIATE FEEDBACK: A NEW MECHANISM FORREAL-TIMEFEEDBACK ON CLASSROOM TEACHIN...
 
Immediate Feedback : A New Mechanism for Real Time Feedback on Classroom Teac...
Immediate Feedback : A New Mechanism for Real Time Feedback on Classroom Teac...Immediate Feedback : A New Mechanism for Real Time Feedback on Classroom Teac...
Immediate Feedback : A New Mechanism for Real Time Feedback on Classroom Teac...
 
IMMEDIATE FEEDBACK: A NEW MECHANISM FORREAL-TIMEFEEDBACK ON CLASSROOM TEACHIN...
IMMEDIATE FEEDBACK: A NEW MECHANISM FORREAL-TIMEFEEDBACK ON CLASSROOM TEACHIN...IMMEDIATE FEEDBACK: A NEW MECHANISM FORREAL-TIMEFEEDBACK ON CLASSROOM TEACHIN...
IMMEDIATE FEEDBACK: A NEW MECHANISM FORREAL-TIMEFEEDBACK ON CLASSROOM TEACHIN...
 
Immediate Feedback : A New Mechanism for Real Time Feedback on Classroom Teac...
Immediate Feedback : A New Mechanism for Real Time Feedback on Classroom Teac...Immediate Feedback : A New Mechanism for Real Time Feedback on Classroom Teac...
Immediate Feedback : A New Mechanism for Real Time Feedback on Classroom Teac...
 
Immediate Feedback : A New Mechanism for Real Time Feedback on Classroom Teac...
Immediate Feedback : A New Mechanism for Real Time Feedback on Classroom Teac...Immediate Feedback : A New Mechanism for Real Time Feedback on Classroom Teac...
Immediate Feedback : A New Mechanism for Real Time Feedback on Classroom Teac...
 
Mobile Learning Framework & Evaluation
Mobile Learning Framework & EvaluationMobile Learning Framework & Evaluation
Mobile Learning Framework & Evaluation
 
V01 i010402
V01 i010402V01 i010402
V01 i010402
 
A Flowchart-Based Intelligent Tutoring System For Improving Problem-Solving S...
A Flowchart-Based Intelligent Tutoring System For Improving Problem-Solving S...A Flowchart-Based Intelligent Tutoring System For Improving Problem-Solving S...
A Flowchart-Based Intelligent Tutoring System For Improving Problem-Solving S...
 
Recent Trends in E-Learning and Technologies
Recent Trends in E-Learning and Technologies Recent Trends in E-Learning and Technologies
Recent Trends in E-Learning and Technologies
 
Information Communication Technology: Practices for Academia
Information Communication Technology: Practices for AcademiaInformation Communication Technology: Practices for Academia
Information Communication Technology: Practices for Academia
 
Ha3612571261
Ha3612571261Ha3612571261
Ha3612571261
 
Technology To Support Learning
Technology To Support LearningTechnology To Support Learning
Technology To Support Learning
 
AN ADAPTIVE AND INTELLIGENT TUTOR BY EXPERT SYSTEMS FOR MOBILE DEVICES
AN ADAPTIVE AND INTELLIGENT TUTOR BY EXPERT SYSTEMS FOR MOBILE DEVICESAN ADAPTIVE AND INTELLIGENT TUTOR BY EXPERT SYSTEMS FOR MOBILE DEVICES
AN ADAPTIVE AND INTELLIGENT TUTOR BY EXPERT SYSTEMS FOR MOBILE DEVICES
 
193
193193
193
 
Review of monitoring tools for e learning platforms
Review of monitoring tools for e learning platformsReview of monitoring tools for e learning platforms
Review of monitoring tools for e learning platforms
 
An analysis of Mobile Learning Implementation in Shinas College of Technology...
An analysis of Mobile Learning Implementation in Shinas College of Technology...An analysis of Mobile Learning Implementation in Shinas College of Technology...
An analysis of Mobile Learning Implementation in Shinas College of Technology...
 

Dernier

Independent Call Girls Andheri Nightlaila 9967584737
Independent Call Girls Andheri Nightlaila 9967584737Independent Call Girls Andheri Nightlaila 9967584737
Independent Call Girls Andheri Nightlaila 9967584737Riya Pathan
 
Youth Involvement in an Innovative Coconut Value Chain by Mwalimu Menza
Youth Involvement in an Innovative Coconut Value Chain by Mwalimu MenzaYouth Involvement in an Innovative Coconut Value Chain by Mwalimu Menza
Youth Involvement in an Innovative Coconut Value Chain by Mwalimu Menzaictsugar
 
The CMO Survey - Highlights and Insights Report - Spring 2024
The CMO Survey - Highlights and Insights Report - Spring 2024The CMO Survey - Highlights and Insights Report - Spring 2024
The CMO Survey - Highlights and Insights Report - Spring 2024christinemoorman
 
Kenya Coconut Production Presentation by Dr. Lalith Perera
Kenya Coconut Production Presentation by Dr. Lalith PereraKenya Coconut Production Presentation by Dr. Lalith Perera
Kenya Coconut Production Presentation by Dr. Lalith Pereraictsugar
 
Kenya’s Coconut Value Chain by Gatsby Africa
Kenya’s Coconut Value Chain by Gatsby AfricaKenya’s Coconut Value Chain by Gatsby Africa
Kenya’s Coconut Value Chain by Gatsby Africaictsugar
 
Future Of Sample Report 2024 | Redacted Version
Future Of Sample Report 2024 | Redacted VersionFuture Of Sample Report 2024 | Redacted Version
Future Of Sample Report 2024 | Redacted VersionMintel Group
 
Global Scenario On Sustainable and Resilient Coconut Industry by Dr. Jelfina...
Global Scenario On Sustainable  and Resilient Coconut Industry by Dr. Jelfina...Global Scenario On Sustainable  and Resilient Coconut Industry by Dr. Jelfina...
Global Scenario On Sustainable and Resilient Coconut Industry by Dr. Jelfina...ictsugar
 
Call Girls In Sikandarpur Gurgaon ❤️8860477959_Russian 100% Genuine Escorts I...
Call Girls In Sikandarpur Gurgaon ❤️8860477959_Russian 100% Genuine Escorts I...Call Girls In Sikandarpur Gurgaon ❤️8860477959_Russian 100% Genuine Escorts I...
Call Girls In Sikandarpur Gurgaon ❤️8860477959_Russian 100% Genuine Escorts I...lizamodels9
 
International Business Environments and Operations 16th Global Edition test b...
International Business Environments and Operations 16th Global Edition test b...International Business Environments and Operations 16th Global Edition test b...
International Business Environments and Operations 16th Global Edition test b...ssuserf63bd7
 
FULL ENJOY Call girls in Paharganj Delhi | 8377087607
FULL ENJOY Call girls in Paharganj Delhi | 8377087607FULL ENJOY Call girls in Paharganj Delhi | 8377087607
FULL ENJOY Call girls in Paharganj Delhi | 8377087607dollysharma2066
 
Contemporary Economic Issues Facing the Filipino Entrepreneur (1).pptx
Contemporary Economic Issues Facing the Filipino Entrepreneur (1).pptxContemporary Economic Issues Facing the Filipino Entrepreneur (1).pptx
Contemporary Economic Issues Facing the Filipino Entrepreneur (1).pptxMarkAnthonyAurellano
 
Ten Organizational Design Models to align structure and operations to busines...
Ten Organizational Design Models to align structure and operations to busines...Ten Organizational Design Models to align structure and operations to busines...
Ten Organizational Design Models to align structure and operations to busines...Seta Wicaksana
 
2024 Numerator Consumer Study of Cannabis Usage
2024 Numerator Consumer Study of Cannabis Usage2024 Numerator Consumer Study of Cannabis Usage
2024 Numerator Consumer Study of Cannabis UsageNeil Kimberley
 
Digital Transformation in the PLM domain - distrib.pdf
Digital Transformation in the PLM domain - distrib.pdfDigital Transformation in the PLM domain - distrib.pdf
Digital Transformation in the PLM domain - distrib.pdfJos Voskuil
 
Investment in The Coconut Industry by Nancy Cheruiyot
Investment in The Coconut Industry by Nancy CheruiyotInvestment in The Coconut Industry by Nancy Cheruiyot
Investment in The Coconut Industry by Nancy Cheruiyotictsugar
 
Islamabad Escorts | Call 03070433345 | Escort Service in Islamabad
Islamabad Escorts | Call 03070433345 | Escort Service in IslamabadIslamabad Escorts | Call 03070433345 | Escort Service in Islamabad
Islamabad Escorts | Call 03070433345 | Escort Service in IslamabadAyesha Khan
 
Annual General Meeting Presentation Slides
Annual General Meeting Presentation SlidesAnnual General Meeting Presentation Slides
Annual General Meeting Presentation SlidesKeppelCorporation
 
Market Sizes Sample Report - 2024 Edition
Market Sizes Sample Report - 2024 EditionMarket Sizes Sample Report - 2024 Edition
Market Sizes Sample Report - 2024 EditionMintel Group
 

Dernier (20)

Independent Call Girls Andheri Nightlaila 9967584737
Independent Call Girls Andheri Nightlaila 9967584737Independent Call Girls Andheri Nightlaila 9967584737
Independent Call Girls Andheri Nightlaila 9967584737
 
Youth Involvement in an Innovative Coconut Value Chain by Mwalimu Menza
Youth Involvement in an Innovative Coconut Value Chain by Mwalimu MenzaYouth Involvement in an Innovative Coconut Value Chain by Mwalimu Menza
Youth Involvement in an Innovative Coconut Value Chain by Mwalimu Menza
 
The CMO Survey - Highlights and Insights Report - Spring 2024
The CMO Survey - Highlights and Insights Report - Spring 2024The CMO Survey - Highlights and Insights Report - Spring 2024
The CMO Survey - Highlights and Insights Report - Spring 2024
 
Kenya Coconut Production Presentation by Dr. Lalith Perera
Kenya Coconut Production Presentation by Dr. Lalith PereraKenya Coconut Production Presentation by Dr. Lalith Perera
Kenya Coconut Production Presentation by Dr. Lalith Perera
 
Kenya’s Coconut Value Chain by Gatsby Africa
Kenya’s Coconut Value Chain by Gatsby AfricaKenya’s Coconut Value Chain by Gatsby Africa
Kenya’s Coconut Value Chain by Gatsby Africa
 
Future Of Sample Report 2024 | Redacted Version
Future Of Sample Report 2024 | Redacted VersionFuture Of Sample Report 2024 | Redacted Version
Future Of Sample Report 2024 | Redacted Version
 
Global Scenario On Sustainable and Resilient Coconut Industry by Dr. Jelfina...
Global Scenario On Sustainable  and Resilient Coconut Industry by Dr. Jelfina...Global Scenario On Sustainable  and Resilient Coconut Industry by Dr. Jelfina...
Global Scenario On Sustainable and Resilient Coconut Industry by Dr. Jelfina...
 
Call Girls In Sikandarpur Gurgaon ❤️8860477959_Russian 100% Genuine Escorts I...
Call Girls In Sikandarpur Gurgaon ❤️8860477959_Russian 100% Genuine Escorts I...Call Girls In Sikandarpur Gurgaon ❤️8860477959_Russian 100% Genuine Escorts I...
Call Girls In Sikandarpur Gurgaon ❤️8860477959_Russian 100% Genuine Escorts I...
 
International Business Environments and Operations 16th Global Edition test b...
International Business Environments and Operations 16th Global Edition test b...International Business Environments and Operations 16th Global Edition test b...
International Business Environments and Operations 16th Global Edition test b...
 
FULL ENJOY Call girls in Paharganj Delhi | 8377087607
FULL ENJOY Call girls in Paharganj Delhi | 8377087607FULL ENJOY Call girls in Paharganj Delhi | 8377087607
FULL ENJOY Call girls in Paharganj Delhi | 8377087607
 
Contemporary Economic Issues Facing the Filipino Entrepreneur (1).pptx
Contemporary Economic Issues Facing the Filipino Entrepreneur (1).pptxContemporary Economic Issues Facing the Filipino Entrepreneur (1).pptx
Contemporary Economic Issues Facing the Filipino Entrepreneur (1).pptx
 
Ten Organizational Design Models to align structure and operations to busines...
Ten Organizational Design Models to align structure and operations to busines...Ten Organizational Design Models to align structure and operations to busines...
Ten Organizational Design Models to align structure and operations to busines...
 
2024 Numerator Consumer Study of Cannabis Usage
2024 Numerator Consumer Study of Cannabis Usage2024 Numerator Consumer Study of Cannabis Usage
2024 Numerator Consumer Study of Cannabis Usage
 
Digital Transformation in the PLM domain - distrib.pdf
Digital Transformation in the PLM domain - distrib.pdfDigital Transformation in the PLM domain - distrib.pdf
Digital Transformation in the PLM domain - distrib.pdf
 
Investment in The Coconut Industry by Nancy Cheruiyot
Investment in The Coconut Industry by Nancy CheruiyotInvestment in The Coconut Industry by Nancy Cheruiyot
Investment in The Coconut Industry by Nancy Cheruiyot
 
Islamabad Escorts | Call 03070433345 | Escort Service in Islamabad
Islamabad Escorts | Call 03070433345 | Escort Service in IslamabadIslamabad Escorts | Call 03070433345 | Escort Service in Islamabad
Islamabad Escorts | Call 03070433345 | Escort Service in Islamabad
 
Japan IT Week 2024 Brochure by 47Billion (English)
Japan IT Week 2024 Brochure by 47Billion (English)Japan IT Week 2024 Brochure by 47Billion (English)
Japan IT Week 2024 Brochure by 47Billion (English)
 
Corporate Profile 47Billion Information Technology
Corporate Profile 47Billion Information TechnologyCorporate Profile 47Billion Information Technology
Corporate Profile 47Billion Information Technology
 
Annual General Meeting Presentation Slides
Annual General Meeting Presentation SlidesAnnual General Meeting Presentation Slides
Annual General Meeting Presentation Slides
 
Market Sizes Sample Report - 2024 Edition
Market Sizes Sample Report - 2024 EditionMarket Sizes Sample Report - 2024 Edition
Market Sizes Sample Report - 2024 Edition
 

Improving Classroom Dynamics: Click’N’Gage, a Mobile Audience Response System

  • 1. Improving Classroom Dynamics: Click’N’Gage, a Mobile Audience Response System Ivo Neskovic ∗ Dragan Bisercic Mitko Zafirovski City College City College City College 3, Leontos Sofou Street 3, Leontos Sofou Street 3, Leontos Sofou Street Thessaloniki, Greece Thessaloniki, Greece Thessaloniki, Greece ivo.neskovic@gmail.com dbisercic@city.academic.gr mitkozaf@yahoo.com ABSTRACT Keywords The problem in communication between students and lec- Audience response systems, classroom dynamics, connected turers in large classrooms has increased substantially in last limited device configuration, clickers, Java micro edition 2, couple of years because many students do not participate Java enterprise edition 6, mobile devices, student engage- in classroom discussions. To engage students into dynamic ment, sun Java wireless toolkit classroom participation, universities often encourage stu- dents to use audience response systems (ARS). By increasing the interactivity between lecturer and students, the dynamic student participation improves and the learning outcome is 1. INTRODUCTION expected to rise. With the increasing number of students in the classrooms, the classroom teaching is becoming more and more a one The progress in the mobile technologies has influenced new way communication between lecturers and students. The approaches in developing ARS. In this paper, we discuss the problem with the large classrooms is that the lecturers are need for mobile ARS and we propose a new architecture for not able to engage in a discussion with every student. How- developing those systems. Furthermore, we present details ever, even when given chance, many students do not want to from our reference implementation of the proposed architec- get into discussion because they might be too shy, too tired, ture, named Click’N’Gage, together with some of the crucial or simply unconcerned with the topic discussed [11]. Such design decisions we took while developing the system. The one way communication approach to teaching can lead to paper closes with a short evaluation of the system, together many undesirable consequences. For example, the lecturer with few ideas on how the system could be improved in the in the classroom might not be able to always notice what future. the students have understood in the lecture and what they have not understood. So, it might happen that the lecturer is moving too quickly over a difficult concept. The result is Categories and Subject Descriptors students loosing interest in the subject matter. Therefore, D.2.11 [Software Engineering]: Software Architectures— the communication in the classroom should be a two way domain-specific architectures; H.4 [Information Systems communication between lecturers and students as often as Applications]: Miscellaneous; J.1 [Computer Applica- possible. tions]: Administrative Data Processing—education; K.3.1 [Computers and Education]: Computer Uses in Edu- In order to enhance the classroom teaching and communi- cation—computer-assisted instruction; K.3.2 [Computers cation, many automated systems have been developed. The and Education]: Computer and Information Science Edu- goal of such automated systems is to get student responses cation—self-assessment, curriculum as quickly and as cheaply as possible [5]. Also, the students are willing to participate more in classroom interaction when they can do it anonymously. Therefore, by letting all stu- General Terms dents answer questions in class anonymously, the lecturers Design, Performance, Human Factors can get more attention from students and improve the class- room learning. ∗City College is an International Faculty of the University of Sheffield. In improving the classroom dynamics [7], we have found the main motivation for developing our system, Click’N’Gage. The inspiration of this paper is to present our solution to the problem explained above. The remainder of this paper is organized as follows: section 2 describes the audience re- sponse systems in general, section 3 discusses the advantages and disadvantages of some of the similar systems, section 4 gives additional information on mobile clickers, section 5 talks about the Click’N’Gage in detail, section 6 provides the evaluation of our system, and finally section 7 provides the conclusion and possible future extensions of the system.
  • 2. 2. AUDIENCE RESPONSE SYSTEMS ClassTalk used scientific calculators with data ports con- An audience response system (ARS) is a system that can nected to a basic network via wire [11]. It was a great sys- help lecturers initiate the two way communication with their tem for the time. However, nowadays such a system is not students. The basic idea of such system can be explained in considered appropriate due to high cost of the hardware and three simple steps. Firstly, the lecturers introduce to stu- many possible problems that can arise when trying to set up dents a question with the list of possible answers. Secondly, the system in the very large classrooms. Anyway, ClassTalk the students choose the answer that they consider to be cor- provides very simple functionality to its users. For exam- rect. Finally, the answers are collected and the statistical ple, the lecturer prompts the question on the projector and results in the form of graphs are displayed to students. the students answer the question via scientific calculators. When all the answers are collected by the system, the system The most well known ARS systems used in education are shows the graphs displaying the statistical results of student clickers [15]. Clickers consist of three different parts. The responses. These graphs tell the lecturer how much material first part consists of the hand-held devices (clickers) that has been understood by the students. are used by the students to communicate information to the system. Furthermore, the receiver is a device that gets One of the first systems that used wireless communication the information from the clickers. Finally, the third part is between clickers and the system was EduCue’s PRS. This a software application that stores, processes, and displays system was developed at Hong Kong University of Science student responses. and Technology by Nelson Cue and C. K. Lee [11]. EduCue used a keypad and infrared technology for sending signals. It The clickers look similar to the TV remote control units has become popular at many Universities. However, infrared [15]. They can be hardwired to the receiver or they can technology is today rarely used since it has been overcome send data to the receiver wirelessly (infrared or radio fre- by other modern wireless technologies. quency). Such clickers have been used in Universities since late 1990s. They enhance learning in class. Namely, by us- Another interesting system that has been developed and ing instant feedback, the lecturers are able to identify any used is TXT-2-LRN. The system lets the students answer concepts being misunderstood [13]. Also, they are fun to the questions via their cellular phones using built in SMS use since the lecturer can start a new, interesting, and dif- technology. The only assumption that the developers made ficult topic by starting the anonymous discussion between was that most of the students actually own at least one cell students. However, clickers are not free. Considering the phone [12]. The system uses a sophisticated SMS filtering fact that students need to pay tuition fees and textbooks, tool on the server side. This approach leads to great avail- the clickers can be too expensive for students if required for ability of the system, which is easy to use since most of the lectures. Also, it can be too expensive for the University to students use SMS messaging facilities daily. The problem provide clickers for all students. In addition to this, if click- with this solutions, however, is the high cost of the SMS ers are hardwired to the receiver, it might even be difficult messages. It is a big burden for students when they need to set up the system for very large classrooms. to pay from their own pockets for the use of the system. A survey has shown that almost 65% of the students using The rapid development in mobile technologies has made pos- TXT-2-LRN spend monthly around 35$ for SMS, approxi- sible for developers to build cheaper ARS systems by using mately sending 2 to 3 messages per day [12]. But, even with cellular phones as the new development environment [12]. the high cost, 90% of the students had positive opinion of The rationale for developing ARS systems on mobile phones the system overall and they were happy to use it. lies in the fact that most, if not all, students nowadays own them [11, 8]. Modern mobile phones take all the advantages Furthermore, one of the most advanced ARS systems today of the new technologies. Therefore, these phones have be- is VotApedia. This system is web based and gives its users come more powerful than clickers. Not only that, mobile few alternative options when voting. Namely, the users have phones also do not require any installation process and they the option to register with VotApedia web site and vote on- do not distract students in classrooms while taking notes line. Also, VotApedia has a specific algorithm that crates a due to their small size [8]. The phones capable of running specific phone number for each answer from the given ques- Java applications using SMS, Bluetooth, or WiFi can signifi- tion. The voters can call this phone number and answer the cantly reduce the overall cost of the ARS system [3, 4]. Such question or simply send SMS message with the answer to mobile applications are fun and easy to use. However, the the same phone number [2]. Given these options, VotApe- possible drawback is that students might consume too much dia can be very dynamic in terms of effectiveness, cost, and time doing other things with the mobile phones instead of complexity. Each of the voters can use anyone of the given participating in class [12]. services. VotApedia seems to be a perfect system at the first glance, however, few flaws can be found when trying to 3. SIMILAR SYSTEMS apply the system in the classroom. The Web based voting option, where students need to log in and find the question Many systems that use mobile phones or similar handheld created by the lecturer, can take a lot of time, which, unfor- devices have been developed in recent years to improve the tunately, is a time that a class can not afford to lose. The classroom interaction in educational institutions. In this other option, which is calling a number in order to vote, can section, we discuss advantages and disadvantages of some of be easy for the students, but it disrupts the class when 200 these systems. students make a call at the same time. The SMS seems as a more discrete option than the previous two, however, the One of the first ARS systems, developed in the early 1990s problems with SMS have already been explained above. by Better Education Inc., is known today as ClassTalk [6].
  • 3. While evaluating the above systems, a few drawbacks have Connectivity: Due to the high cost of SMS messages, the become apparent. The most notable disadvantage is the cost proposed architecture utilizes the Internet. It is im- of either setting up or using these systems. For example, in portant to mention that the system will require only most cases, the students are required to pay not only for the an active Internet connection, not needing the details tuition and books at the universities but also for the accom- of how that connection is being established, whether modation and food. Enforcing students to spend additional it is through WAP, WiFi, GPRS or 3G. The rationale resources for extra devices or services, which are needed only behind this decision is that most of todays phones have to improve the classroom participation, is considered as a at least one way of connecting to the Internet and that bad idea. In addition to this, not all universities can pro- most universities offer free WiFi connection for its stu- vide such devices or services for all of their students due to dents inside its premises. high cost. However, the cost is not the only drawback. The Duplicate Answers: It is imperative to restrict the stu- lecturers need to put additional effort to design questions dent of providing more than one answer to a specific before class. Therefore, some lecturers might consider the questions. Failure to achieve this feature might re- benefits of using ARS negligible and continue lecturing in sult in inaccurate statistical charts presented to the the traditional way. lecturer. The simplest method of achieving the de- sired effect is to assign user accounts to every stu- 4. MOBILE CLICKERS AS AN AUDIENCE dent and restrict the accounts of providing more than RESPONSE SYSTEM one answer. However this conflicts with the feature As we showcased in the previous section, mobile phones have of anonymity, thus rendering it impossible to use ac- been already an integral part of many of the most popular counts. The mechanism of achieving this feature with- audience response systems, albeit utilizing only the Short out violation students’ anonymity is left for the con- Message Service. Therefore, these systems generated high crete implementation of our architecture, although we costs for its end users, the students, which ranged to 35$ provide an example in our reference implementation per month, a very high cost for the average student [12]. In of the mobile clickers audience response system in the spite of the high cost, most of the students were very happy next section. using their mobile device in the classroom [12, 15]. This Question/Answer Correspondence: Students need to paper proposes a new architecture for developing audience know which question they are answering to and should response systems utilizing mobile devices as their main com- not be allowed to answer questions they are not sup- ponent. The proposed architecture addresses the problems posed to. This problem is solved by assigning a unique raised in previous AR systems, introducing further improve- code to every issued question which the students will ments in the process. input before they provide their answer. The code will be generated by the system moments before the ques- The abstract architecture of the mobile clickers ARS (Figure tion is answered and will be presented by the lecturer 1) provides an overview of the proposed methodology: only to the class of students who should answer the question. 1. Students use their Internet powered mobile devices to Dynamic Number of Answers: Not all multiple choice answer questions [5] questions will have the same number of possible an- swers. Usually, they are in the range of two, for true- 2. Answers are sent over the Internet to the core applica- false questions, to six answers. The system should al- tion system (server) low the lecturer of specifying a concrete number of possible answers and this should be reflected at the 3. Data is analyzed and statistical charts are generated students mobile device screen. The way this could be achieved is by using a mechanism for dynamic genera- 4. Results are observed by the lecturer tion of the answering form on the mobile device which will provide custom screens for every amount of possi- ble answers. Using this architecture, answers are no longer sent via SMS and it introduces the concept of an answers storage place, which in turn provides the ability to extract statistical data Using our proposed architecture does not only solve the used by lecturers for self-improvement. Additionally, our problems identified in the reviewed AR systems, but it also architecture allows for implementing extra Quality of Service provides extra features that are crucial for the adoption of (QoS) [9] features into the system. We have identified five the mobile clickers audience response system. key features that every ARS should provide: 5. REALIZATION OF CLICK’N’GAGE Click’N’Gage is the reference implementation of the mobile Anonymity: The system does not use any student personal clickers audience response system, developed in partial ful- data. Anonymity and trust are two very important is- fillment of the Industrial Group Project module at City Col- sues that students have [1, 14, 6]. The reviewed AR lege. As the proposed architectural design implies, the sys- systems use the students telephone number for identi- tem is composed of two main components: the mobile client fication, which creates discomfort for them. The pro- and the main system dashboard. Design-wise, both of the posed architecture does not use any data which can be components were developed as separate systems in a vac- used to track back an answer to a specific student. uum [10]. Consequently, each of them has been targeted to
  • 4. Figure 1: Architectural overview of a mobile clickers audience response system. a different user group, leading to design decision specific for the targeted audience. The users of the mobile client are the students themselves, whereas the users of the dashboard are the university’s lecturers. The mobile client has been developed for the Java platform, using the Java Micro Edition 2.0 SDK. Considering the fact that more than 2.1 million mobile devices are pre-installed with a Java Virtual Machine (JVM), is a justification enough for choosing the Java platform. Additionally, this allows for easier distribution due to Java’s ”Write once, run any- where!” nature. The application is packaged as a standard Java Archive (JAR) file which is guaranteed to run on every Java enabled mobile device. 5.1 Students’ Mobile Client Figure 2: The main screens presented to the stu- Simplicity and usability are two invariants present through- dent. out the mobile client system. It is imperative for the student to easily answer a given question, with minimal involvement. The only tasks required from the student are to enter the all of the steps performed by the system and the input re- question code and to provide the question answer. This is quired from the user for a successful execution. achieved by using only two forms which can be observed in Figure 2. Finally, all of the five key characteristics of a mobile audience response system with the exception of Question/Answer Cor- Internally, the mobile client is in a constant communica- respondence are developed exclusively in the mobile client. tion with the core Click’N’Gage application. This has been The following few paragraphs discuss each of them in greater achieved with the use of SOAP-enabled Web Services (WS). detail. Part of the core functionality has been exposed on the In- ternet in a form of a WS, offering two operations: Anonymity vs. Duplicate Answers. Trust is one of the major issues that students have with audience response sys- • Validate the question code and return the number of tems used in educational settings. Their main concern is possible answers for the corresponding question that their performance, while answering the given questions in class, will affect their grade in an often negative way. For • Submit the student’s answer to the specific question this reason, the Click’N’Gage system does not use the usual notion of accounts which is present in commercial audience response systems. This however, conflicts with the necessity The mobile client has access to the service endpoint and con- to control students to answer each question only once. nects upon initialization. The operations of the Web Service are then invoked as needed. The function flow diagram (Fig- The solution implemented for this two conflicting issues is ure 3) provides a more detailed explanation, clearly stating the use a unique identifier of the mobile device. Every man-
  • 5. Connectivity. One of the goals of Click’N’Gage is to allow students to use their preferred typed of connection (WAP, WiFi, GPRS or 3G) to connect their mobile clients to the core server of the application. Fortunately, Java ME offers an abstract way of establishing connections. Using Java’s Generic Connection Framework, the mobile client is devel- oped in such a way that it only needs an active Internet connection, without requiring the details of the type of the connection and how it is established. The framework auto- matically extracts this data from the native operating sys- tem of the mobile device. Because privacy is a crucial con- cept throughout the development of Click’N’Gage, this data is not accessed without the user’s consent. 5.2 Lecturers’ Dashboard Similarly with the mobile client, the lecturers’ dashboard has been developed with two invariants present in the system: intuition and innovation. The dashboard is developed as a web application which offers novel and innovative way of interacting with the lecturer and presenting data. It acts as a management portal of the core Click’N’Gage application. Click’N’Gage has been developed as a Java Enterprise Edi- tion (EE) 6.0 application. It runs on a Glassfish V3.0 ap- plication server, and is connected to a database stored on a MySQL Community Edition Server 5.1.47. The presenta- Figure 3: Function flow diagram for the mobile tion layer of the overall application is handled by the recently client. updated Java Server Faces 2.0 technology, which now allows for clear web site development using XHTML, while at the same time exposing custom tags with the ability to access data encapsulated in the Java application. The flow of the internal execution of Click’N’Gage is depicted in Figure 4, ufactured mobile device, whether it is a GSM, WCDMA, which emphasizes the core steps performed when an answer iDEN or a satellite phone, has a unique International Mo- is submitted to the system. bile Equipment Identity (IMEI) number assigned to it. The number is usually printed inside the batter compartment of Prior to using the system, lecturers must register and create the mobile device. Using Java’s ability to read the properties their account with Click’N’Gage using the web registration of the mobile device, the IMEI number is acquired which is form. In order to prevent misuse of the system, upon the processed by a hash function, together with the issue date of completion of the registration, the lecturer needs to wait for the question, and sent with every answer to the server. This an official acceptance e-mail from the system’s administra- in turn ensures that no question will be answered more than tor, who is responsible for maintaining Click’N’Gage. once from a device with the same IMEI number and because there are no meaningful information enclosed in the hash it Once registered, the lecturer is able to: is impossible to track back the number to the specific user. The hash is computed on both the IMEI number and the issue date of the question answered to ensure that the same Enroll on a course - Enrolling on a course signifies that hash will not repeat itself on more than one question which the lecturer is teaching the specific course. Lecturer’s with some careful statistical analysis might lead to mapping can only browse, create and issue questions for courses the hash value to a student. that they teach. Create a course - If a lecturer starts a new course at the university, he/she must first create it in the system by Dynamic Form Generation. Click’N’Gage offers lecturers specifying the course name and its unique code. the ability to specify the number of possible answers to a question, varying from the minimum of two answers, to Create a question - Creating a question involves the lec- the maximum of six. This feature however, leads to consis- turer stating the question, providing some keywords tency issues with the screens of the mobile device. The form which describe it (keywords are used in refining the present on the screen of the mobile device must offer the search results), providing the possible answers and spec- same number of choices as the question has. This has been ifying the correct one, and finally selecting the type of achieved by modifying the Web Service operation, which chart in which the results will be displayed. performs the validation of the question code, to return the number of possible answers for said question. Afterwards, Browse existing questions - Upon selecting a course, the the form of choices is dynamically generated, according to lecturer will be presented with a list of questions for this number. the specific course. In the case of a long list, which
  • 6. Figure 4: Detailed architectural diagram of the core Click’N’Gage system. Figure 5: Example of a time-series statistical chart. Figure 6: Sample chart types. would be the result of using the system for few years, the lecturer can refine the search by filtering the search Additionally, every issued question has a corresponding chart results using the keywords specified when creating the illustrating the results from the students answers (Figure 6). question. Clicking on an entry in the presented list The type of the chart is the one specified when the ques- will redirect the lecturer to the statistics page for the tion is first created, possible choices being Bar, Bar 3D, selected question, and clicking on the Issue link next to Pie, Pie 3D charts. An innovative feature implemented every question will generate the unique question code, in Click’N’Gage is the dynamic generation of the images used by the students to answer the question. representing the charts whenever they are requested from the browser or when embedded in a MicrosoftTM Power- Point presentation. When a user navigates its browser to Using JFreeChart, an open source chart generation library http://x.x.x.x/clickngage/charts/IQC.png, the system implemented in the Java programming language, we offer a automatically locates the question specified with the code, variety of statistical charts to the lecturer. Every question recalculates the submitted answers and returns an updated has a time-series chart which represents the success rate of chart every time. The same holds for the time-series charts, the question over time (Figure 5). It calculates the amount with the only difference in the request URL which is of correct answers submitted to every question instance and http://x.x.x.x/clickngage/timeseries/QID.png. This it presents a graph where the domain axis is the set of dates feature is specifically useful when embedding result charts when the specific question has been issued to the students, in various presentations and reports. and the range axis is the set of percentages of correct an- swers submitted for the question. This type of charts is Last, but not least, it is important to mention that the web particularly useful for the self-evaluation of lecturers. application has been developed using the Web 2.0 standards,
  • 7. which include asynchronous AJAX communication with the ate feedback from students to be very helpful. They can use server, full XHTML and CSS conformance and a design fol- feedback to reevaluate and improve their teaching methods. lowing the Web 2.0 guidelines. The students, on the other hand, can easily participate in classroom discussions while using this system. The system 6. EVALUATION provides anonymity and it is simple to use, therefore, it en- Click’N’Gage has been demoed at the 9th Student Spring courages students’ engagement in the classroom. Moreover, Symposium, organized annually at City College, Thessa- lecturers have insights on statistical data that is generated loniki. The presentation included a detailed discussion of the over significant period of time. This motivates lecturer to system. After the presentation, the students in the audience use the system. got an opportunity to participate in the system evaluation. Over 30 students took part in the evaluation. Firstly, they The Click’N’Gage software application is built in a modular were required to download the mobile application from our approach. The modularity supports extensibility. There- web site. Then, a question and a list of possible answers fore, many possible future extensions are possible for our were displayed on the projector. The students chose an an- system. One possible future extension includes porting the swer and submitted it via mobile application. After that, Java mobile application to both iPhone and Android. The the output was displayed in graphical notation. Finally, the current version of the Click’N’Gage does not support these students gave us feedback on the system. The feedback was two popular mobile platforms. Furthermore, another possi- positive and few interesting observations were discussed in ble extension is the integration of Click’N’Gage with LMS. greater detail. Such integration would keep the overhead of creating and enrolling courses by lecturer minimized. Last but not least, Everyone at the symposium agreed that Click’N’Gage can the system could, in the future, support student assessment improve the traditional practices in education. Before eval- in the form of quizzes and tests. uation, many students considered that the system would be unnecessary. However, later they enjoyed using it and saw 8. REFERENCES the benefit for both students and lecturers. What students [1] A. Abrahamson. Teaching with classroom liked the most was that everyone was welcome to participate communication system: What it involves and why it in class. Also, they liked the simplicity and usability of the works. In 7th International Workshop New Trends in mobile application. The lecturers were particularly satisfied Physics Teaching, Puebla, Mexico, number July 1992, with the instant feedback received from the student. 1999. [2] R. Alves. Enhancements to VotApedia Audience Furthermore, before evaluation, some lecturers considered Response System. that activities related to designing questions and using mo- [3] R. Davidrajuh. Java Bluetooth Wireless Technology bile clickers in class can be time consuming. They ques- for Evaluating Student Performance in Classroom. tioned the benefit of the system by stressing the operational Citeseer, 5(4):33–38, 2005. costs. However, after the demonstration, they accepted that benefits of using the system are far more important than [4] R. Davidrajuh. Evaluating performance of a the overhead of creating questions before class. In addi- Bluetooth-based classroom tool. International Journal tion to this, lecturers made couple of interesting suggestions. of Mobile Learning and Organisation, 3(2):148, 2009. Namely, they would like to see the system integrated with [5] M. Esponda. Electronic voting on-the-fly with mobile the existing Learning Management Systems (LMS), such as devices. ACM SIGCSE Bulletin, 40(3):93, August Claroline - the one used at City College, in order to take 2008. some of the advantages that those systems offer. [6] R. H. Kay and A. LeSage. Examining the benefits and challenges of using audience response systems: A Nevertheless, both students and lecturers agreed at the end review of the literature. Computers & Education, that Click’N’Gage can keep students more focused and pro- 53(3):819–827, November 2009. vide better communication. Therefore, the system provides [7] S. O. King and C. L. Robinson. ’Pretty Lights’ and the means for enhancing classroom learning. However, the Maths! Increasing student engagement and enhancing outcome of such teaching could not be evaluated. Only the learning through the use of electronic voting systems. use of the system for a longer period of time (couple of years) Computers & Education, 53(1):189–199, August 2009. can show the actual outcome of this approach to teaching. [8] D. Lindquist, T. Denning, M. Kelly, R. Malani, W. G. Griswold, and B. Simon. Exploring the potential of 7. CONCLUSIONS AND FUTURE WORK mobile phones for active learning in the classroom. Classroom interaction at universities is considered to be very Proceedinds of the 38th SIGCSE technical symposium important. The recent advances in mobile technologies have on Computer science education - SIGCSE ’07, page enabled the use of mobile phones in the classrooms as a 384, 2007. tool for the mutual benefit for both students and lecturers. [9] I. Pah, C. Oprean, I. Moisil, and C. Kifor. Technology Furthermore, the mobile phones provide notable extension to Support Education Software Solutions for Quality over the traditional clickers. By providing support for bet- Assurance in e-learning. Communications, III:433–436, ter communication between students and lecturers, mobile 2008. phones are expected to improve the learning outcome as well. [10] R. Pressman. Software Engineering: A Practitioner’s Approach. McGraw-Hill, Inc., New York, NY, USA, Our software, Click’N’Gage, provides a support for better 7th edition, July 2010. interactivity in classrooms. The lecturers find the immedi- [11] G. Russell and I. Pitt. Visions of a wireless future in
  • 8. education technology. Journal of issues in Informing Science and Information Technology, 1:747–752, 2004. [12] E. Scornavacca, S. Huff, and S. Marshall. Mobile phones in the classroom. Communications of the ACM, 52(4):142, April 2009. [13] B. F. E. Sharkawy and F. Meawad. Instant Feedback Using Mobile Messaging Technologies. 2009 Third International Conference on Next Generation Mobile Applications, Services and Technologies, pages 539–544, September 2009. [14] J. Wasteney. The Impact of Voting Systems in the Classroom. Bill Tagg Bursary Research Project, 2005, 2004. [15] W. Wood. Clickers: A Teaching Gimmick that Works. Developmental Cell, 7(6):796–798, 2004.