This document outlines an approach to occupational safety and health in agriculture according to the Basic Occupational Health Services (BOHS) model. It defines agriculture and its unique features including outdoor work exposing workers to weather conditions. It then describes the BOHS model which involves risk assessment, surveillance of hazards and workers' health, preventative actions, information/education, diagnosis of diseases, and evaluation. The goal is to provide basic occupational health services tailored to local agricultural conditions and needs.
1. Occupational Safety and Health in
Agriculture- The BOHS Approach
Prepared in Public Interest
By
Indian Association of
Occupational Health
April, 2013
2. IAOH - 2013 2
DEFINATION OF AGRICULTURE
Agricultural and forestry activities carried out in agricultural
undertakings including
Crop production, forestry activities, animal husbandry and insect
raising, the primary processing of agricultural and animal products
by or on behalf of the operator of the undertaking.
As well as the use and maintenance of machinery, equipment,
appliances, tools, and agricultural installations, including any
process, storage, operation or transportation in an agricultural
undertaking, which are directly related to agricultural production.
REF: ILO convention no. 184
3. IAOH - 2013 3
INTRODUCTION
An estimated 1.3 billion workers are engaged in agricultural
production worldwide. This represents half of the total world labour
force.
Almost 60% of them are in developing countries.
A great majority of agricultural workers are found in Asia, which is
the most densely populated region of the world, with more than
40% of the world's agricultural population concentrated in China
and more than 20% in India.
4. IAOH - 2013 4
SPECIFIC FEATURES OF AGRICULTURE
most tasks are carried out in the open air,
exposing workers to climatic conditions;
the seasonal nature of the work and the urgency
of certain tasks in specific periods;
a wide variety of tasks are performed by the same
person;
the type of working postures and the length of the
tasks performed;
5. IAOH - 2013 5
contact with animals and plants exposing workers
to bites, poisoning, infections, parasitic diseases,
allergies, toxicity and other health problems;
the use of chemicals and biological products ;
the considerable distances between living quarters
and workplaces.
SPECIFIC FEATURES OF AGRICULTURAL
WORK
6. IAOH - 2013 6
LABOUR FORCE IN AGRICULTURE
Lack of clear-cut distinctions between different categories
of workers.
Numerous types of labour relations and different forms of
labour force participation.
7. IAOH - 2013 7
PRINCIPLES OF BOHS
The following principles will be applied in the organization of
Basic Occupational Health Services:
Available to all working people
Addressing to local needs
Adapted to local conditions
Affordable to providers and clients
Organized by the employer for employees
Provided by the public sector for the self-employed and the
informal sector
Supported by intermediate level services
9. IAOH - 2013 9
ORIENTATION AND PLANNING
1. Analysis of the type of production indicating the risks and
problems typical of the branch or occupation in concern.
Agriculture involves a wide range of different types of machinery,
animals, plants and products, working in both indoor and outdoor
environments
In India labour-intensive farming is much more common.
2. Review of problems that have been identified previously in the
company
3. Review of the characteristics of the workforce of the company
child labour , migrant workers , seasonal, migratory and casual
labour.
10. IAOH - 2013 10
ORIENTATION AND PLANNING
4. Available data on occupational diseases and accidents
5. Data on working methods, chemical substances, etc.
6. The knowledge by employers and employees of occupational
health problems
7. Plans for changes in production systems, e.g. installation of
new facilities, machinery and equipment
11. IAOH - 2013 11
SURVEILLANCE OF THE WORK ENVIRONMENT
1. Identification and evaluation of ergonomic factors which may affect
the workers' health
Ergonomic factors affecting the health outcomes of agricultural workers
include:
the nature of the physical work environment (noise, heat, lighting,
thermal comfort), the agricultural tasks to be performed;
the technology applied to the prescribed tasks (including workplace
design, facility design, and agricultural material handling);
the manner in which tasks are organized (including use of shift
work); and
Worker characteristics (including demographics, physiology, human
error, and identification and treatment of injured workers).
12. IAOH - 2013 12
SURVEILLANCE OF THE WORK ENVIRONMENT
2. Assessment of conditions of occupational hygiene and factors,
such as physical, chemical, and biological exposures which may
generate risks to the health of workers
2. Assessment, where appropriate, of exposure of workers to adverse
psychological factors and aspects of work organization
3. Assessment of risk of occupational accidents and major hazards
4. Assessment of collective and personal protective equipment
5. Assessment of control systems designed to eliminate, prevent or
reduce exposure
6. Assessment of general hygiene and sanitary facilities
13. IAOH - 2013 13
Occupational Health Problems in Agriculture
Seasons, Unstable
loading
Physical work stress,
Accumulation of fatigue
Risk of traumatism
The overtension
diseases
Open Air work
Weather Conditions,
Dust
Over heating, Over
cooling
Dust diseases
Use of new technology
and machinery
Noise, Vibration
Hearing loss, Vibration
diseases
Pesticides, fertilisers
etc.
Chemical pollution of
environment
Sensitization, Allergic
diseases
Contact with animals
and biopreparations
Biological hazards Zoo-Anthroponoses
14. IAOH - 2013 14
Occupational Health Problems in Agriculture
Seasons,
Unstable
loading
Physical work
stress,
Accumulation of
fatigue
Risk of
traumatism
The overtension
diseases
Open Air work
Weather
Conditions,
Dust
Over heating,
Over cooling
Dust diseases
Use of new
technology and
machinery
Noise, Vibration
Hearing loss,
Vibration
diseases
Pesticides,
fertilisers etc.
Chemical
pollution of
environment
Sensitization,
Allergic
diseases
Contact with
animals and
biopreparations
Biological
hazards
Zoo-
Anthroponoses
15. IAOH - 2013 16
SURVEILLANCE OF WORKERS' HEALTH
The following types of health examinations are carried out either on
the basis of regulations or as a part of good occupational health
practice:
1. Pre-assignment (pre-employment) health examinations
2. Periodic health examinations
3. Return to work health examinations
4. General health examinations
5. Health examinations at termination or after ending of service
A new type of health examination has recently been introduced for
assessment of work ability of ageing workers.
16. IAOH - 2013 17
SURVEILLANCE OF WORKERS' HEALTH
In the case of exposure of workers to specific hazards, medical and
health surveillance should include, where appropriate, any
examination and investigations which may be necessary to detect
exposure levels and early effects and responses which also bear in
mind the biological difference between women and men.
Example, in pesticide handlers.
Pre-employment screening should ensure that those with inherently
low-level cholinesterase do not undertake work with
organophosphate or carbamate pesticides
baseline samples, periodic samples,
17. IAOH - 2013 18
ASSESSMENT OF HEALTH AND SAFETY RISKS
A “hazard” is anything with the potential to do harm, whereas a “risk” is
the likelihood of potential harm from that hazard being realised.
The identification of hazards in the workplace should take into
account:
(a) the situation or events or combination of circumstances that have
the potential to give rise to injury or illness;
(b) the nature of potential injury or illness relevant to the activity,
product or service;
(c) those likely to be harmed (e.g. young workers, older workers,
temporary workers, pregnant workers); and
(d) past injuries, incidents and illness.
18. IAOH - 2013 19
ASSESSMENT OF HEALTH AND SAFETY RISKS
The steps in an occupational health risk assessment include:
1. Identification of occupational health hazards (as a result of
surveillances)
Hazards Description
Mechanical
hazard
Poorly designed and/or guarded agricultural machinery is a
major cause of fatalities and accidents. Injuries from cutting
tools are another major risk.
Psycho social
hazards
low pay, sexual and other harassment, job insecurity, poor
promotion mechanisms, delay in payment of salaries.
Work
organisation
hazards
badly organised shift work and working hours, excessive
overtime, lone working, lack of control over work.
Ergonomic
hazards
These hazards can cause permanent injuries and
disablement. For example: badly designed machinery,
prolonged static working positions, repetitive work, unsuitable
tools used by workers, poor seating
Others - Physical hazards , Biological hazards, chemical hazards, environmental
19. IAOH - 2013 20
ASSESSMENT OF HEALTH AND SAFETY RISKS
2. Identification of workers or groups of workers exposed to specific
hazards for e.g. in tea plantation workers the hazards are
different for pruners, pluckers, sprayers
3. Analysis of how the hazard may affect the worker (ways of entry
and type of exposure, threshold limit values, dosage/ response
relationships, adverse health effects it may cause, etc.in case of
sprayers who are in constant contact with the pesticides)
4. Determination of intensity (level) and magnitude (volume) of risk
20. IAOH - 2013 21
ASSESSMENT OF HEALTH AND SAFETY RISKS
5. Identification of individuals and groups with special vulnerabilities,
e.g. young workers, old workers, pregnant workers, temporary workers
6. Evaluation of available hazard prevention and control measures
7. Making conclusions and recommendations for the management and
control of risks
21. IAOH - 2013 22
ASSESSMENT OF HEALTH AND SAFETY RISKS
Hierarchy of control measures for reducing risks in the work place.
A. Elimination
B. Substitution
C. Others
technical and engineering control- enclosure, isolation,
ventilation
Safe systems of work- changing work schedules, extending
rest periods, training and information
Issuing Personal Protective Equipment (PPE)
8. Documenting the findings of the assessment
9. Periodic review and, if necessary, reassessment of risks
22. IAOH - 2013 23
INFORMATION AND EDUCATION ON RISKS AND
ADVICE ON THE NEED FOR PREVENTIVE AND
CONTROL ACTIONS
The information and education include the following aspects:
1. Workers in agriculture should have the right to be informed and
consulted on OSH matters including risks from new technologies;
and
2. The workers have a right to know and get continuously
information on hazards related to their own work and the
workplace.
3. The employer is responsible for training the workers on safe and
healthy work practices.
23. IAOH - 2013 24
4. The workers have a duty to follow the safety instructions and
safe and healthy work practices.
5. Confidential health information of an individual worker is subject
to special legislation and practices and to informed consent.
6. The advice provided by OHS personnel must be given in a form
which is easily understood by employers and workers.
7. Information given to various partners should be documented.
INFORMATION AND EDUCATION ON RISKS AND
ADVICE ON THE NEED FOR PREVENTIVE AND
CONTROL ACTIONS
24. IAOH - 2013 25
PREVENTIVE ACTIONS FOR THE MANAGEMENT AND
CONTROL OF HEALTH AND SAFETY HAZARDS AND
RISKS
Control measures should be monitored and reviewed at regular
intervals and if necessary revised, especially when circumstances
change or if new information becomes available about the risks
posed or the suitability of existing control measures.
Control measures should also be reviewed and if necessary
revised following an accident.
25. IAOH - 2013 26
The risk management actions may comprise:
• Control of hazards at the source
• Ventilation or control technology
• Dust control
• Ergonomic measures
• Use of personal protective equipment
• Regulation of thermal conditions, etc.
PREVENTIVE ACTIONS FOR THE MANAGEMENT AND
CONTROL OF HEALTH AND SAFETY HAZARDS AND
RISKS
26. IAOH - 2013 27
PREVENTION OF ACCIDENTS
1. Safe planning of facilities, machinery, etc.
The employer should not permit the use of any unsafe or faulty
equipment.
The employer should ensure the provision of adequate
information, instruction and training for those using equipment,
and that their skill levels are periodically evaluated.
2. Good housekeeping, order and cleanliness
The employer should ensure that workers are clearly instructed
and supervised in good housekeeping measures that can
prevent slips, trips and falls.
27. IAOH - 2013 28
3. Making walkways and other structures safe (e.g. scaffolds,
fences)
The employer shall ensure that: walking surfaces and stairs
inside facilities are equipped with adequate lighting; stairs and
ladders are maintained in good condition with handrails in
place; .
4. Guarding dangerous machines- by providing enclosures, safety
symbols surrounding such places.
Unauthorized persons should not be allowed to operate
machinery. In particular, children should be kept away from all
agricultural equipment.
PREVENTION OF ACCIDENTS
28. IAOH - 2013 29
5. Technical aids for moving and lifting heavy loads
With regard to the use and maintenance of ladders, the
employer should ensure that appropriate, well-maintained
equipment is available and is appropriate to the task at hand.
the use of mechanical means to lift or lower heavy objects; and
other practices appropriate to the task at hand.
6. Safe tools and safety equipment for workers
Workers should use handholds when mounting and
dismounting equipment.
7. Analysis of major hazard risks and provision of "redundant
safety"
PREVENTION OF ACCIDENTS
29. IAOH - 2013 30
MAINTAINING PREPAREDNESS TO FIRST AID AND
PARTICIPATION IN EMERGENCY PREPAREDNESS
1. Providing first aid services at the workplace when appropriate
2. Introducing and training first aid practices to workers and
supervisors
3. Maintaining and periodically inspecting the first aid readiness and
facilities
4. Participating from the health point of view in emergency planning
and organizing the health elements in emergency response
30. IAOH - 2013 31
MAINTAINING PREPAREDNESS TO FIRST AID AND
PARTICIPATION IN EMERGENCY PREPAREDNESS
Emergency preparedness
Date______________
Checklist
Self-audit
Step
1
Step2 Step 3
Planning N/A Yes No Priority for
action
What action is
required
1. Does the workplace have an emergency response plan?
2. Does the workplace have established emergency escape routes and procedures?
3. Does the workplace have a trained first-aider(s)?
4. Does the workplace have basic rescue equipment and are workers trained to use
it?
31. IAOH - 2013 32
DIAGNOSIS OF OCCUPATIONAL AND WORK-
RELATED DISEASES
1. Identification of exposure which may cause the disease
2. Examination of clinical findings which are known to be associated
with the specific exposure (lists of occupational diseases)
3. Exclusion of non-occupational factors as a possible cause of
disease
4. Conclusion on existence or non-existence of occupational disease
(diagnosis)
5. Statement on occupational disease for workmen's compensation
6. Proposals for preventive actions to the workplace of the worker in
concern
7. Notification of occupational diseases to authorities
32. IAOH - 2013 33
GENERAL HEALTH CARE, CURATIVE AND
REHABILITATION SERVICES
1. Immunizations and other preventive measures
2. Participation in public health actions and programmes
3. GP-level general health services
4. Inspection and advice on canteens, sanitary facilities
5. Advice and education in general personal and community hygiene
6. Actions for rehabilitation and adjustment of work for workers after
injuries, diseases, reduced work ability and on return to work from long
sick leaves
7. General health promotion and introduction of healthy lifestyles
33. IAOH - 2013 34
RECORD KEEPING
1. General health record, if the workers are treated as patients or
health service clients
2. Data on surveyed, detected and measured occupational exposures
and risk assessments made
3. Statistics on occupational diseases and injuries
4. Data on health examinations
5. Documents on proposals for preventive and control measures
34. IAOH - 2013 35
EVALUATION
1. Evaluation is carried out as an inbuilt part of BOHS activity, at least
annually
2. Evaluation is made when the working methods, production
structures or other aspects at work are substantially changed
3. Evaluation is made if the methods or conditions of operation of
services are substantially changed
35. IAOH - 2013 36
EVALUATION
4. The following questions are answered through evaluation:
a) Do the services respond to the needs of the workplace?
b) Are the activities directed to priority problems?
c) Is good occupational health practice followed?
d) Are the resources, human and technical, sufficient?
e) Are the services effective in elimination of health problems?
f) What can be improved?
36. IAOH - 2013 37
ROVISION OF BOHS
Primary health services model
Big company model with in-company services
Group services organized jointly, e.g. by several SMEs
Social security institution as a service provider
Private physician who has special competence in occupational
health
Private health centre either providing occupational health services
only or occupational health as a part of its services
Local or regional outpatient clinic of hospitals
39. IAOH - 2013 40
REFERENCES
BOHS. a response to the Joint ILO/WHO Committee on Occupational
Health priority area for ILO/WHO/ICOH collaboration, with support of the
Finnish Institute of Occupational Health (FIOH). Author: Professor Jorma
Rantanen. 3rd, revised edition, Helsinki 28 September 2007
Safety and health in agriculture. Programme on safety, health and the
environment. Labour Protection Department. ILO.
Code of practice on safety and health in agriculture .2010.
INTERNATIONAL LABOUR OFFICE GENEVA.
Top on the agenda: Health and safety in agriculture. Labour Education
2000/ 1-2 Nos. 118/119. ILO
Health, Safety and Environment: A Series of Trade Union Education
Manuals for Agricultural Workers Written by: Peter Hurst & Peter Kirby.
ILO.
40. IAOH - 2013 41
CONTRIBUTORS
Dr. Shwetha Marali, Senior Resident, Department of Community
Health, St. John’s Medical College
Dr. Bobby Joseph, Professor and Head, Division of Occupational
Health Services of the same Department..
Notes de l'éditeur
In the Convention, however, the term agriculture does not cover:
subsistence farming;
industrial processes that use agricultural products as raw material and the related services; and
the industrial exploitation of forests.
With more than a third of the world’s labour force employed in the sector, agriculture is the second greatest source of employment worldwide after services. It is also the most important sector for female employment in many countries, especially in Africa and Asia, and a major proportion of agricultural workers are women.
Agriculture is in fact one of the most hazardous of all sectors and many agricultural workers suffer occupational accidents and ill-health each year.
The BOHS cycle follows the conventional action model:
identification of needs ―> assessment of problems ―> management of actions ―> evaluation of effect ―> revision of the programme.
The various steps indicated in Figure have a dual target: The work environment-oriented activities (outside the action cycle) or the worker-oriented activities (inside the action cycle), and often both simultaneously. It is important to see BOHS as a functional process instead of a number of separate actions.
6. The wide-ranging profiles in agriculture both in terms of employment and of enterprise have a significant bearing on levels of risk awareness and on attitudes towards preventing accidents and diseases within the sector.
such as tractors, trucks and harvesters, and cutting and piercing tools;
This slide supplements the previous slide, if needed
Medical surveillance includes, where appropriate, pre-assignment and periodical medical examinations. It also includes, where appropriate, medical examinations following an incident, when workers report symptoms of poisoning, upon resumption of work after a prolonged absence for health reasons, and upon and after termination of work involving exposure to chemicals.
For example, the hazard associated with power-driven agricultural machinery might be getting trapped or entangled by moving parts. The risk may be high if guards are not fitted and workers are in close proximity to the machine. If however, the machine is properly guarded, regularly maintained and repaired by competent staff, then the risk will be lower.
Evaluation of risk takes into consideration both the likelihood of the hazard causing harm to persons and the severity of such harm if it were to occur.
(6) As part of the risk-assessment process, the employer, in consultation with workers and their representatives, should chart the flow of raw materials, intermediate and finished products, mobile equipment and workers in the course of operations, noting the hazards that pertain to each step.
Control measures
Ask whether the hazard can be eliminated. For example, remove the need to use a toxic pesticide by using organic farming methods
2. If the hazard cannot be prevented or eliminated, consider substitution with a less risky process or substance in the case of chemicals
Employers should provide training to all personnel at no cost to the worker and training should take place during working hours. The timing and other arrangements should be agreed upon between the employer and workers’ representatives, taking into account childcare and family responsibilities.
EXAMPLE OF PESTICIDE CAN BE GIVEN
2. These include having walking aisles or pathways clearly identified; keeping stairs and passageways clear of tools, buckets, slippery substances, etc.; and keeping buildings free of accumulations of trash and other objects not needed in the workspace.
walkways that are exposed to wet or slippery substances are roughened; damaged floor boards and concrete defects are repaired, as needed; and ladder openings, hay chutes and animal house clean-out openings are protected with railings and toe-boards
Workers should be properly instructed in the use of ladders and supervised when using them. Safe work practices include the presence of a second person at the base of the ladder; the avoidance of work on ladders in windy or stormy conditions;
Many occupational diseases can be diagnosed in the BOHS service but many of them need to be referred to specialized occupational medicine clinics
the workplace can be an important source of information for workers of both genders on wellness, and how to maintain a healthy lifestyle, through a proper diet, personal hygiene, rest and recreation. Employers should consider establishing an enterprise wellness programme as well as establishing clear policies with regard to alcohol- and drug-related problems, HIV/aids, workplace violence, harassment and bullying, and smoking.
The investigation of the origin and underlying causes of work-related injuries, ill health, diseases and incidents should identify any failures in the OSH management system and should be documented.
The corrective action resulting from such investigations should be implemented in order to avoid repetition of work-related injuries, ill health, diseases and incidents.