SlideShare une entreprise Scribd logo
1  sur  11
The Academic Review: How box blight of Buxus spp. is changing the
landscape in the 21st
Century.
Introduction
Buxussppis an importantplantinhistoryaswell asin today’sworld.The firstformal clippedbox
was usedbythe Egyptiansin4,000BC (TopiaryArts,2016). Throughouthistoryand still todaybox is
usedas the structural,formal elementingardensandlandscape design.Ithasbeen usedasa means
of executionof ‘control of nature’andas a status symbol of wealthandalso formedicinal purposes
(TopiaryArts,2016). Howeverthisiconicplantspeciesisunderthreatinthe wildaswell asinman-
made landscapesandgardens.The pestanddiseasesthat affectthe Buxusspp.are many.However
inthispaper the mainfocuswill be Box Blight’simpactonlandscapesandhorticulture.
Historic importance of the Buxus spp. in the UK.
In the UK particularlythe native Buxus sppwasgrowingwilduntil the Ice Age whereuponthe native
spp.was destroyed.Howeverthe Romaninvasionin100BC re-introducedthe species(TopiaryArts,
2016). In the Middle Agesandthroughto the Elizabethanperiodthe Buxuswasusedforknot
gardens,hedges,galleriesaswell asindividualspecimendisplays afteritwasfound thatcypressspp
were notas reliable (TopiaryArts,2016).The Hamptoncourt gardensof HenryVIIIhad box spheres,
conesand animals(TopiaryArts,2016). Topiarywas bornas a statussymbol and to indicate control
of nature. Throughthe 17th
into18th
centurythe naturalisticmovementledbyCapabilityBrownsaw
Buxus’usage decline asitwasno longerfashionable toimpose formalityontothe landscape (Wilson,
2014). In the 19th
centurythe returnof formalitycame ina re-birthof the ‘Italian Renaissance’The
Buxusbecame a staple; carpetbeddingschemes,low hedgesandextreme topiarydesignsof crowns,
birdsdominatedlandscape designandparks.Nurseriesinthe UKwere becomingspecialisedin
topiaryworksand selling‘alreadyformed’plantsincontainerstothe public(TopiaryArts,2016). The
returnof ‘knotstyle’gardensandparterresbecame the identityof the ‘BritishGarden’
In the 20th
centurythe Arts and Craftmovementmeantthatthe harshcontrol of nature was relaxed
thoughinformal borderdesignswithplantingschemesandlayoutdidnotbanishthe box but
incorporateditas a backdropand structural elementwithinadesign.Topiarywasless extremein
design.Inthe 60’s the publicwentthroughthe ‘FrontGardenMovement’ withclassicrose bedsand
the use of topiaryandhedgingwaspopular.We still see the Buxusasa stable plantinthe garden
and instructural landscape designsanduse itheavilyforcreationof shapesandbackdrops.Inthe
urban landscape itisusedinlowline fronthedgingasa protective andframingbarrieraround
plantingschemesandthe topiaryball andpyramidisusedoutside establishmentssuchashotels,
restaurants,shoppingcentresandpublichousestomarkformalisedentrances tobuildings.
The Main threats to Buxus spp.
The Box Caterpillar Moth– Cydalimaperspectalishasbecome anincreasing threatinrecentyears.
The Box CaterpillarenteredEurope in2007 andin 2011 the pesthad fullyreproducedinthis
country. In 2012 thiscaterpillarreplacedthe molluscsspp.(snail/slug) as the mosttroublesomepest
ina poll conductedbythe RHS (Appleby,M.2013). By 2014, it had become fullyestablishedin
Londonand the home-counties(Royal Horticultural Society,2016). These caterpillarscause
defoliationbyeatingthe foliage (Plate 1) andinclippedBuxuscause full dyingbackof the plantin
highdensityfeedingareas. The caterpillarprotectthemselveswithwhite webbingduringfeeding
and pupation.
Plate 1 - The Box Tree Caterpillar Image Source; Royal Horticultural Society https://www.rhs.org.uk/advice/profile?pid=760
Caption: Identification information; The moth eggs are laid on the underside of the leaves in an overlapping/flat sheet
formation and have a greenish/yellow appearance. The young caterpillars have yellow/green bodies with a black head, as
they mature the body has black and white striping down the sides. The adult moth have white wings with a brown rim
border.
There ischemical treatmentavailable forthe caterpillaraswell asa pheromone treatmentfor
attractingthe adultstagedmothintotraps (Royal Horticultural Society,2016). The impactof this
invaderon the UK isa cause forconcern as ithas the potential toattack our wildbox treesandhave
a large impact onour hedges,topiaryspecimens.
Box Blight- There are twogeneticstrains of the fungal disease;Cylindrocladiumbuxicola(now
knownas Calonectriapseudonauiculata)affectingthe wholeBuxaceaefamily.The second;
Pseudonetriabuxi onlyaffecting the Buxusspp (Royal Horticultural Society,2015; Ivors,2016;
Horticulture Week,2015).The fungal infectionsco-existwithone anothermostoftenon aplant
Cylindrocladiumbuxicolabeingthe mostserious of the two(Royal HorticulturalSociety,2015; Ivors,
2016). Both strainsexhibitthe,browningandspottingonleaves,anddefoliation,dyingbackpatches
(Plate 2) whichleadstodeathof the plant (Henricot& Wedgwood,2013; Royal Horticultural Society
, 2015; Horticulture Week,2015).The Cylindrocladiumbuxicolaaffectsstemtissuesinadditionwith
blackstreaksand die back (Henricot&Wedgwood,2013) The sporesof the fungi are distinctly
differentandinwetweathercanbe seen.The Cylindrocladiumbuxicolahaswhite sporesandthe
Pseudonectriabuxi haspinkspores (Royal Horticultural Society,2015; Ivors,2016).
Plate 2 - Box Blight Image Source; Royal Horticultural Society https://www.rhs.org.uk/advice/profile?pid=96
Caption: A Fungal disease affecting foliage and is spread by moisture and overwintering reproductive soil borne spores.
Classic symptoms of browning and sudden dying back and death spots can take hold very quickly.
Climate Change
As we knowclimate change globallyisaffectingmany organismsandplantlife.Fromthe statistics
and analysisof the UK’s climate change forecast(UKCP09) reportitprojectsthat warmer andwetter
wintersanddrierbut more humidsummerswill become the UKclimate (UKClimate Projections -
Met Office,2009). Thiswill resultinarapidincrease of fungal infectionsandspeedof spread of box
blightandotherfungal infectionsinthe UK (Forestry Comission,2015).The wettersoil conditions
will alsoincrease the riskof rootrot diseasesforthe Buxusandof course other plants.
The Significance of Box Blight affecting Horticulture.
It isa worldwide spreadproblem. (Plate3) There are 70 speciesof Buxusworldwide whichare
mainlyinthe tropical andsubtropical regions, 30reside inCubaand 17 are native toMadagascar
(Wilson,2014). The restof the Buxusspp are spreadacross the Caribbean,Chinaandthe Americas
includingLatinAmerica(Henricot&Wedgwood,2013; Wilson,2014). The Native Europeanand
AsianBuxusare the onlyfrost hardy species.The true originof the disease isunknown.The earliest
record of the disease wasfoundinthe UK in1990’s (Henricot&Wedgwood,2013; Ivors,2016;
Wilson,2014; Weeda,S.M etal, 2012; Horticulture Week,2015) ina Hampshire nursery (Appleby,
M. 2013). From2002 onwardsit had spreadthroughEurope and to New Zealand (Weeda,S.M etal,
2012). In recentyearsit hasspreadto the Americasand East Asia (Henricot&Wedgwood,2013;
Ivors,2016; Wilson,2014, Weeds,S.Metal, 2012).
Plate 3 - Worldwide Map of Box Blight infections. Source; Authors own creation with map image from http//:mapsofthe
world.com.
The Native BuxussempervienslocatedinSurreywasreportedin2000 to have Box Blightpresent
(Appleby,M.2013) and the Turkishnative collection confirmedinfectionin2011 (Lehtrijarvi,2014)
whichisof greatconcern.
Production and Commercially
Commerciallythe salesof the Buxushave droppedinrecentyearsdue tothe fearand stigma
attachedto the plant. In additionsome nurseriesare unknowingly sellinginfectedplantstothe
gardencentre sectorby not fullyunderstandingthe diseasesidentifiable markers.Howeverinsome
casesthere has beenpoorpractice by nurseriesandproducersbysuppressinginfectedplantswith
fungicidesreadyforsale andthe gardencentressuddenlyexperiencingexplosionsof box blightfrom
the re-emergence(Henricot,B. 2013; The EuropeanBoxwoodandTopiarySociety,2014). Nurseries
such as BuckinghamNurseriesdiversifieddue toseeingBuxussalesdropby50% andthe sales of the
alternativesincreasing(Appleby,M.2013). Howeversome of the alternativesare currentlyinshort
supplyasmany establishmentshave notfully/speedilydiversified.Some of these‘replacementof
box plants’are vulnerable inthemselvesassuchas Loniceraspp. because theytendtobe mass/over
producedandthisin turn could furthercause weaknessestootherdiseases (Appleby,M.2013).
Historic/Visitor Attraction Gardens and Landscapes
In the amenitysectorof horticulture Box Blightgreatlyaffects the finances of visitorattractionsas
well asthe aestheticappearance andhistoric,iconiccharacterof a landscape (Reid,2015; Watkins&
Wright,2007; Wilson,2014; The EuropeanBoxwoodandTopiarySociety,2014). The economic
damage that the infectioncaninflictuponanestablishmentcanrunintothe thousands. The fact
that Buxusisslowgrowing; andit takes 18 yearsto grow and shape a large topiaryball means that
specimenwouldbe worth£1,000 if notmore (Wilson,2014). Whenan infectionbreaksout the need
for pathologyreports,closure of the site duringinfections,the fungicides, andmanpowerinitself
and the operationof removal of infectedmaterial andreplacementplantingare all factorsarising
fromBox Blightinfection (Reid,2015).In many historiclandscapesthe Buxusisthe mostimportant
structural plantand the loss/damage the diseasecausesmore than financial andpractical problems.
In some establishmentsthe spreadof itcan be so horrificand fast(48hrs) (Reid,2015; Horticulture
Week,2015) the devastationandlossof keyandspecial specimenscanhithard. IckworthParkthe
Italianate Renaissance Gardenswere repeatedlystruckoveratenyearperiodanda massive
infectionin2015 wipedout80% of the hedgingincludingaspecimenthatwasover200years old
(Reid,2015). Up and downthe UK managersof landscapes,gardensandvisitorattractionsare
havingto make difficult decisionsinregardstohow bestto manage the disease andthe future of the
designandplantselectionforthese establishments.The combinationof cultural practicesand
hygiene managementwithfungicidesisonlyworkinguptoapoint.
Management of the Disease and New Developments – Is there a way forward?
Buxus spp Genetics
The study of susceptibilitytothe box blightdisease hasbeenextensivelyresearchedand ithas been
foundthat there are some speciesandcultivarsthatappearto be more resistanttothe infection
(Shishkoff,2015) butthisis debatable asthe studiesshow thatthe resistance isnota ‘complete’
resistance.Eventuallytheydoall succumb to the box blightinfection andthatresistance is marginal
(Yonghong,2015). Eventhoughthe geneticvariation of the genusiswide ithas provendifficultto
breedBuxus (Laere &Hermans,2015). Howeverthere iscurrentlysome optimismintermsof
breeding.The scientificcommunity isincreasingfurtherunderstandingof the characteristicsof the
Buxaceae family. The leaf structure of aparticularspp.such as thickerleaf cuticle/epidermal tissue
layersanda smallerleaf surface areaindicate aphysiological designthatprovestoprovide ‘alevel’
of plantdefence fromthe fungus (Shishkoff,2015).This isparticularlyapparentinthe macrophylla
subspeciesof Buxushavinga highertolerance andlowersusceptibilitycomparedtosempervirens
but the varietyof cultivarshada significantgeneticimpactof the resistance levelwithinthese sub
speciesgroups (Henricot&Wedgwood,2013; Shishkoff,2015; Yonghong,2015). Howeverthe
techniquesof testingsusceptibilityneedmore refining asfieldtrialsandlaboratoryscenariosare
verydifferentandusinginoculatedcuttingsisverydifferenttousingplantspecimens (Henricot,
2013; Yonghong,2015).
A newdevelopmentof aSSR-cDNalibraryhas been createdtolook forparticulargeneticmarkers.
845 of these have beenisolatedfrommRNA material andfromthose 23 polymorphicprimerpairs
have beenidentified (Thammina,2014) as keygeneticcharatisiticthatcan be usedforBox Blight
resistance ingeneticdiversity,hybridisationandcultivarbreedingof Buxus (Thammina,2014).
Hybridization of BuxustoF1 fromcross combinationsresultingin 4750 ‘interspecific’F1 seedlings
has recentlybeenachieved in2015 witha seedgerminationrate between0-47%. (Laere & Hermans,
2015). Howeverthese are earlydaysandthe interspecificrange of those seedlingsmay/maynotbe
variable orsuccessful butthe hybridscouldofferthe scientificcommunitythe opportunitytoexploit
the F1 fordesirable traits (Laere &Hermans,2015).
Biological Understanding of the Funguses Life Cycles
In a taxonomicre assessmentof Cylindrocladiumbuxicola(reclassifiedasCalonectriapseudonavicala
now) the fungushastwo geneticcladesunearthinganew phylogeneticspecies‘Calonectria
henricotiae’ (Gehesquière,2016) as an additional variantof the Box Blightdiseasewhichhasa
greatertolerance tohighertemperaturesandincreasedtolerance tofungicides (Gehesquière,2016).
Thisnewinformationisworryingbutthe communityknow thatthere ismore variance inthe fungal
familynowand more researchcan be undertaken (Gehesquière,2016). The twostrainsof Box Blight
have very differentoverwinteringmechanisms.Itwasfoundthatthe Cylindrocladiumbuxicolahasa
unique overwinteringstructure form; ‘Microsclerotia’whichallowsthe fungustoreproduce during
wintermonthswithinsoil.Thisexplainshow repeatedre infectionoccurfromleaf littermaterial and
dirtytools/machineryasthiscell structure cansurvive for5yearswithinleaf material andupto15
yearsin soil and inminusfigure temperatures (Weeda, S.Metal 2012; Ganci,2013). This
evolutionaryadaptationinthe Cylindrocladiumbuxicolaisnotpresentinthe Pseudonectriabuxi
strainof the fungus (Weeda, S.Met al 2012) whichconfirmshow andwhyone strainis more
rampant andmore difficulttotreatincomparisonto the otherstrain. Thiscouldunlockwhattypes
of fungicide touse andtailormake compoundingredientstotargetthisaspectof the funguseslife
cycle inthe future.
Fungicides
The EU have recentlybanned some fungicidesthatare used inthe treatmentof the disease (Royal
Horticultural Society,2015). The EU regularlyreviewschemical substancesand thismeansthat
horticulturistsacrossthe industryhave tokeepuptodate withthe use of fungicidesandother
chemical treatments (Royal Horticultural Society,2015; Wilson,2014). There have beena few
studiesintothe effectivenessof themagainstBox Blightbutmostly sothe Cylindrocladiumbuxicola
strain.Theyhave beeninconclusive orofferasuppressive/moderate level of control.Howevera
recentstudy evaluatedandtestedvariousproducts andfoundthatone all-roundproduct
‘Opponent’ completelyeradiatedbox blightandtimingandchoice of fungicides suchas‘Bravo’,
‘Octave’and‘Signum’ greatly affected how wellthose productsworked(Henricot&Wedgwood,
2013). Howeverthese are all commercial productsthatthe publiccannotaccess.The study did
howeverfindthat‘FungusClear’ whichisonthe publicmarket, didofferamoderate control butstill
thisdoesnot reallyofferatotal solution tothe general public.
Plant Selections
The Buxusspp as discussedhaslimitedresistance tothe disease butthe followingtable show more
tolerantspecieswhich couldstill be usedwithinalandscape orsoldcommerciallytocustomers
whomstill desire box plants. (Table 1) There are a wide range of alternative thatcanbe usedinstead
of Buxus if the decisionistobe takento avoidall Buxusspp (Table 1) butthisnot the solutionand
otheralternative have theirownpitfalls.
Table 1 - Collective list of Buxus spp to avoid and use and alternative plant selections. Authors own consolidation from a
range of sources.
Buxus spp to avoid using More tolerant Buxus spp Alternatives to Buxus
B. sempervirens B. microphylla ‘Compacta’ Euonymus fortunei (various)
B. sempervirens ‘Elegantissima’ B. sinica var. insularis ‘Winter Beauty’ Rosmarinus officinalis
B. sempervirens ‘Suffruticosa’ B. sinica var. insularis ‘Pincushion’ Lavandula angustifolia
B. sempervirens ‘American’ B. microphylla ‘Faulker’ Ligustrum Ovalifolium
B. sinica var insularis ‘Justin
Brouwers’
B. macrophylla ‘Trompenburg’ Ilex crenata
B. sempervirens ‘Marginata’ B. harlandii Lonicera nitida and Lonicera
nitida ’Baggins Gold’
B. sempervirens ‘Jensen’ B. microphylla ‘Golden Dream’ Podocarpus lawrencei, salignus
and andina
B. sempervirens ‘Pendula’ B. microphylla ‘Winter Gem’ Taxus baccata
B. sempervirens ‘Scupi’ Myrtus communis
Berberis various
Hebe ‘buxifolia’ and ‘odora’
(short term solution for urban
building enterances)
Good Practice and Strategic Methodology
Non-chemical/goodpracticesare importanttopreventawiderspreadof box blightfromoutbreaks
howevertheyare limitedwithdealingwithinfectionsalone.The combinationof fungicidetreatment
and goodpractice offera moderate control of the disease (Royal Horticultural Society,2015). It has
beenknowthatsome Buxusdo survive afteraninfectionbuthave ahighriskof infectingother
surroundingspecimensandare likelytobecome re-infectedagain.
Belowisa range of advisoryinformationthatconsiderschemicalandnon-chemical options.
 The current advice fordealingwithbox blightinfectionswithoutfungicidesemphasises good
hygiene practice withmachinery,pruningequipmentandPPE/clothingbyusingdisinfectant
and washingclothingarticlesregularly(Horticulture Week,2015; Ganci, 2013; Ivors,2016;
The EuropeanBoxwoodandTopiarySociety,2014; Royal Horticultural Society,2015).
 Whenan infectionisidentifieditisimportanttoascertainwhichorif co-existence of strains
are present(Reid,2015; Henricot& Wedgwood,2013; Ivors,2016). That waythe decision
whethertouse fungicidesandpractice operationssuchaspruningoutmaterial can be
examined (RoyalHorticulturalSociety ,2015). The removal of all dead,dyingandinfected
material shouldbe incineratedandsoil disposedof inaccordance to legislation (Reid,2015;
The EuropeanBoxwoodandTopiarySociety,2014; Horticulture Week,2015; Watkins&
Wright,2007).
 Overheadirrigationincreasesthe spreadingpotential of the fungussothisshouldbe
avoided (The EuropeanBoxwoodandTopiarySociety,2014). Dripirrigationinthe
commercial settingoffersareductioninrisk(Wilson,2014).
 Reducingthe clippingregimeof hedgesandtopiaryshouldbe consideredwherepossibleas
tightlyclippedspecimenshave poorairventilationandthis increasesthe riskof infection
(Royal Horticultural Society,2015; The EuropeanBoxwoodandTopiarySociety,2014).
 Landscape and Commercial Managersshouldtake cuttingsfromnon-infectedmaterial and
builda ‘safetybank’of specimens (The EuropeanBoxwoodandTopiarySociety,2014) so if
infectionstrikesthe replantationcostsare reducedbythe creationof yourownstock.
 Applicationof mulchonsoil areascouldassistinreducingre-infectionfrom fungusspores
leftinthe soil (CU Cooperative ExtensionTeam, 2015).
Conclusion
Commercial growers,nurseriesandlandscape managersneedtoselect,evaluate andplanhow they
wishto use fungicide productsonthe basisof theirsituationorpreventativemethodsof protecting
theirbox plants. The scientificcommunityare discoveringmore andmore aboutthe disease andthe
Buxaceae familyinwhichgeneticscreening,cataloguingandbreedingprogrammesare beginningto
developmethodsof producingplantswithtraitsthatcouldprove significantindisease resistance
and increasingtolerance levels.The morphological understandingof the fungushasshedlightona
newsubstrainof the disease fromCylindrocladiumbuxicolaandleda nomaculture reclassification
of thatstrain to Calonectriapseudonviculata.The fungi lifecycle andreproductivemechanismshave
beenexploredandthisinturnmay offera soil treatmentinthe future.The assessmentandattitude
to the usage of Buxus species inthe landscape isthatevenwiththe disease beingpresentthere are
waysforwardin termsof alternativesanddifferentselectionsof box plants.Stillthere are fearsof
Native spp.areaswill be greatlyaffectedbythe disease,climate change andotherpestand disease
infections.The combinationof hygieneandfungicidetreatmentofferaslow downto the spreadof
the disease butdonot offera true eradication. Fungicide developmentincorrelation to
understandingthe disease will eventuallybecomeasignificantmethodtopossiblyeradicate it.
Currentlyfungicide offersuppressionandcontainmentbutthe developmentof new productsare
provingtobe increasinglyeffective andthe timingof applicationshave proventobe a breakthrough
inthe managementof the disease. Onlytime,scienceandeffective managementwill determine how
far thisdisease takesholdandthe outcome forthe Buxussppas a plant.
Word Count2,804
References
Appleby,M.(2013) ‘Box blightdisease continuestostrike box hedges’The TelegraphOnline Article
written11th
February2013 TelegraphMediaGroupLimited2016
http://www.telegraph.co.uk/gardening/plants/9862995/Box-blight-disease-continues-to-strike-box-
hedges.html[Accessed14thFebruary2016]
CU Cooperative ExtensionTeam,2015. Clemson University - Home and Garden Information.
http://www.clemson.edu/extension/hgic/pests/plant_pests/shrubs/hgic2052.html
[Accessed3May 2016].
ForestryComission,2015. Forestry Research. http://www.forestry.gov.uk/fr/urgc-7qjery
[Accessed15 February2016].
Ganci, M., 2013. 'Evaluatingthe role of Microsclerotiainthe Diease Cycle of BoxwoodBlight,caused
by the fungusCylindrocladiumbuxicola. Collegeof Agricultureand Life Sciences - CAL NewLetter,
Issue https://www.cals.ncsu.edu/agcomm/news-center/perspectives/stopping-aggressive-boxwood-
blight/. [Accessed24th
March 2016]
Gehesquière,B.etal,2016. Characterizationandtaxonomicreassessmentof the box blight
pathogenCalonectriapseudonaviculata,introducing Calonectriahenricotiae sp.nov.Plant
Pathology, Volume65, Issue 1, pp.37-52.
Henricot,B.& Wedgwood,E.,2013. Evaluationof FoliarFungicide Spraysforthe Control of Boxwood
Blight,Causedbythe FungusCylindrocladiumbuxicola. PlantManagementNetwork - PlantHealth
Progress, http://www.plantmanagementnetwork.org/pub/php/research/2013/boxwood/ [Accessed
14th Feburary2016]
Horticulture Week,2015. Pest and DiseaseManagement - Box Blight.
[Accessed14thFeburary2016].
Ivors,K.,2016. The NorthCarolina StateUniversity - Box Blight Guide.
https://yancey.ces.ncsu.edu/wp-content/uploads/2013/02/Boxwood-Blight-Guide-
01.03.13.pdf?fwd=no
[Accessed14thFebruary2016].
Laere,K. V.& Hermans,D. e.a., 2015. Interspecific hybridisationwithBuxusspp. Scientia
Horticulturea, Volume 185, pp. 139-144.
Lehtrijarvi,A.,2014. Cylindrocladiumbuxicolaisthreateningthe native Buxussempervirens
populationsinTurkey. PlantProtection Science, Volume50,Issue 4, pp. 227-229.
Reid,S.,2015. Head Gardener,LandscapeManager [Interview] (14thOctober2015).
Royal Horticultural Society,2015. Box Blight. [Online]
Available at:https://www.rhs.org.uk/advice/profile?pid=96
[Accessed14thFebruary2016].
Royal Horticultural Society,2016. Box Tree Caterpillar.
https://www.rhs.org.uk/advice/profile?pid=760
[Accessed24thMarch 2016].
Shishkoff,N.etal,2015. EvaluatingboxwoodsusceptibilitytoCalonectriapseudonviculatausing
cuttingsfromthe National BoxwoodCollection. PlantHealth Progress, Volume16,Issue 1, pp.11-15.
Thammina,C.et al,2014. Developmentof polymorphicgenic-SSRmarkersbycDNA library
sequencinginboxwood,Buxusspp.. Applicationsin PlantSciences,Volume 9, Issue 12.
The EuropeanBoxwoodandTopiarySociety,2014. The European Boxwoodand Topiary Society.
http://www.ebts.org/2014/02/another-year-with-box-blight-box-tree-moth/(Extracted/Printed
Originallyfrom'Topiarius'Volume17 page 31. 2013)
[Accessed2ndMay 2016].
TopiaryArts,2016. Topiary Arts - English Grown Topiary Design & Landscaping,Gardens&
Restoration. http://www.topiaryarts.com/tips-techniques/history
[Accessed14thFebruary2016].
UK Climate Projections - MetOffice,2009. UKClimate Projections - UKCP09.
http://ukclimateprojections.metoffice.gov.uk/21708
[Accessed28thSeptember2015].
Watkins,J.& Wright, T.,2007. The managementand maintenanceof historic parks,gardensand
landscapes:TheEngligh Heritage Handbook. 1ed.London:FrancesLincolnLtd .
Weeda,S.M. etal, 2012. Histological Evidence thatMicrosclerotiaPlayaSignificantRole inDisease
Cycle of the BoxwoodBlightPathogeninSoutheasternUnitedStatesandImplicationsforDisease
Mitigation. PlantManagementNetwork - PlantHealth Progress, p.
http://www.plantmanagementnetwork.org/pub/php/brief/2012/boxwood/.
Wilson,M.,2014. FinnanalTimes Online- Houseand Home - Gardens.
http://www.ft.com/cms/s/2/1ec2db22-eb1e-11e3-bab6-00144feabdc0.html#axzz46q7BrgIW
[Accessed23 04 2016].
Yonghong,G. e.a., 2015. Effective BioassaysforEvaluatingBoxwoodBlightSusceptibilityUsing
DetachedStemInoculations. HortScience, Volume50,Issue 2, pp. 268-271.
List of Plates
Plate 1 - The Box Tree CaterpillarImage Source;Royal Horticultural Society
https://www.rhs.org.uk/advice/profile?pid=760
Plate 2 - Box BlightImage Source;Royal Horticultural Society
https://www.rhs.org.uk/advice/profile?pid=96
Plate 3 - Worldwide Mapof Box Blightinfections.Source;Authorsowncreationwithmapimage
fromhttp://mapsoftheworld.com
List of Tables
Table 1 - Collective listof Buxusspptoavoidand use and alternative plantselections.Authorsown
consolidationfromarange of sources.

Contenu connexe

Tendances

Introduction to pathology by muhammad asif
Introduction to pathology by muhammad asifIntroduction to pathology by muhammad asif
Introduction to pathology by muhammad asif
Muhmmad Asif
 
Understanding the Rearing of mosquito in laboratory and Mosquito Vector Surve...
Understanding the Rearing of mosquito in laboratory and Mosquito Vector Surve...Understanding the Rearing of mosquito in laboratory and Mosquito Vector Surve...
Understanding the Rearing of mosquito in laboratory and Mosquito Vector Surve...
Muhammad Kamran (Sial)
 
Sample Paper_epw_Science_Society_and_Risk_in_the_Anthropocene
Sample Paper_epw_Science_Society_and_Risk_in_the_AnthropoceneSample Paper_epw_Science_Society_and_Risk_in_the_Anthropocene
Sample Paper_epw_Science_Society_and_Risk_in_the_Anthropocene
nutan maurya
 
Umer nawaz
Umer nawazUmer nawaz
Umer nawaz
Azmi Ali
 

Tendances (20)

Introduction to pathology by muhammad asif
Introduction to pathology by muhammad asifIntroduction to pathology by muhammad asif
Introduction to pathology by muhammad asif
 
01 host parasite interactions
01 host parasite interactions01 host parasite interactions
01 host parasite interactions
 
Efficacy of Detection Canines for Avian Botulism Surveillance & Mitigationn
Efficacy of Detection Canines for Avian Botulism Surveillance & MitigationnEfficacy of Detection Canines for Avian Botulism Surveillance & Mitigationn
Efficacy of Detection Canines for Avian Botulism Surveillance & Mitigationn
 
Understanding the Rearing of mosquito in laboratory and Mosquito Vector Surve...
Understanding the Rearing of mosquito in laboratory and Mosquito Vector Surve...Understanding the Rearing of mosquito in laboratory and Mosquito Vector Surve...
Understanding the Rearing of mosquito in laboratory and Mosquito Vector Surve...
 
A new look at ectoparasites affecting indigenous village poultry in Ethiopia
A new look at ectoparasites affecting indigenous village poultry in EthiopiaA new look at ectoparasites affecting indigenous village poultry in Ethiopia
A new look at ectoparasites affecting indigenous village poultry in Ethiopia
 
Sample Paper_epw_Science_Society_and_Risk_in_the_Anthropocene
Sample Paper_epw_Science_Society_and_Risk_in_the_AnthropoceneSample Paper_epw_Science_Society_and_Risk_in_the_Anthropocene
Sample Paper_epw_Science_Society_and_Risk_in_the_Anthropocene
 
Climate change effects on pest problems on grain legumes
Climate change effects on pest problems on grain legumesClimate change effects on pest problems on grain legumes
Climate change effects on pest problems on grain legumes
 
History of plant pathology
History of plant pathologyHistory of plant pathology
History of plant pathology
 
Microbiology: Human - Microbe Interactions
Microbiology: Human - Microbe InteractionsMicrobiology: Human - Microbe Interactions
Microbiology: Human - Microbe Interactions
 
Isolation and characterization of fungi associated with spoiled tomatoes
Isolation and characterization of fungi associated with spoiled tomatoesIsolation and characterization of fungi associated with spoiled tomatoes
Isolation and characterization of fungi associated with spoiled tomatoes
 
An Insect-less Earth: Gauging The Possibilities
An Insect-less Earth: Gauging The PossibilitiesAn Insect-less Earth: Gauging The Possibilities
An Insect-less Earth: Gauging The Possibilities
 
jee.tov397.abstract
jee.tov397.abstractjee.tov397.abstract
jee.tov397.abstract
 
FINAL
FINALFINAL
FINAL
 
Relations between pathogens, hosts and environment
Relations between pathogens, hosts and environmentRelations between pathogens, hosts and environment
Relations between pathogens, hosts and environment
 
Medical entomology
Medical entomologyMedical entomology
Medical entomology
 
Cararacterization of Salmonella Isangi possessing a CTX-M15 ESBL associated w...
Cararacterization of Salmonella Isangi possessing a CTX-M15 ESBL associated w...Cararacterization of Salmonella Isangi possessing a CTX-M15 ESBL associated w...
Cararacterization of Salmonella Isangi possessing a CTX-M15 ESBL associated w...
 
Amensalism
Amensalism Amensalism
Amensalism
 
2. B Bakteria
2. B Bakteria2. B Bakteria
2. B Bakteria
 
Umer nawaz
Umer nawazUmer nawaz
Umer nawaz
 
Microbes Ecology, Microflora & Sanitary-indicative bacteria of soil, water & Air
Microbes Ecology, Microflora & Sanitary-indicative bacteria of soil, water & AirMicrobes Ecology, Microflora & Sanitary-indicative bacteria of soil, water & Air
Microbes Ecology, Microflora & Sanitary-indicative bacteria of soil, water & Air
 

En vedette (8)

Ppt defensa
Ppt defensaPpt defensa
Ppt defensa
 
Buxo
BuxoBuxo
Buxo
 
Rochester Landscaping, Nursery Plants Plants Price List
Rochester Landscaping, Nursery Plants Plants Price ListRochester Landscaping, Nursery Plants Plants Price List
Rochester Landscaping, Nursery Plants Plants Price List
 
Carbono de los bosques.
Carbono de los bosques.Carbono de los bosques.
Carbono de los bosques.
 
Palermo - Pp6 case of study in catalonia
Palermo - Pp6 case of study in cataloniaPalermo - Pp6 case of study in catalonia
Palermo - Pp6 case of study in catalonia
 
شمشاد
شمشادشمشاد
شمشاد
 
Plants
PlantsPlants
Plants
 
Crecimiento en masas forestales
Crecimiento en masas forestalesCrecimiento en masas forestales
Crecimiento en masas forestales
 

Similaire à The Academic Review How box blight of Buxus spp. is changing the landscape in the 21st Century.

Invasive impact of prosopis juliflora on wildlife conservation and livelihoods
Invasive impact of prosopis juliflora on wildlife conservation and livelihoodsInvasive impact of prosopis juliflora on wildlife conservation and livelihoods
Invasive impact of prosopis juliflora on wildlife conservation and livelihoods
Glidayyuka
 
convesation of Biodiversity
convesation of Biodiversityconvesation of Biodiversity
convesation of Biodiversity
Nehal Naik
 
Environmental change and vector borne disease
Environmental change and vector borne diseaseEnvironmental change and vector borne disease
Environmental change and vector borne disease
Nik Ronaidi
 

Similaire à The Academic Review How box blight of Buxus spp. is changing the landscape in the 21st Century. (20)

overview of plant pathogenesis
overview of plant pathogenesisoverview of plant pathogenesis
overview of plant pathogenesis
 
Why study plants?
Why study plants?Why study plants?
Why study plants?
 
The Edge of Tomorrow — Plant Health in the 21st Century
The Edge of Tomorrow — Plant Health in the 21st CenturyThe Edge of Tomorrow — Plant Health in the 21st Century
The Edge of Tomorrow — Plant Health in the 21st Century
 
Downy mildew (Pseudoperonospora Cubensis); A devastating phytopathological is...
Downy mildew (Pseudoperonospora Cubensis); A devastating phytopathological is...Downy mildew (Pseudoperonospora Cubensis); A devastating phytopathological is...
Downy mildew (Pseudoperonospora Cubensis); A devastating phytopathological is...
 
Global Epidemiological Situation of Fusarium Wilt of Bananas (TR4)
Global Epidemiological Situation of Fusarium Wilt of Bananas (TR4)Global Epidemiological Situation of Fusarium Wilt of Bananas (TR4)
Global Epidemiological Situation of Fusarium Wilt of Bananas (TR4)
 
Global Epidemiological Situation of Fusarium Wilt of Bananas (TR4)
Global Epidemiological Situation of Fusarium Wilt of Bananas (TR4)Global Epidemiological Situation of Fusarium Wilt of Bananas (TR4)
Global Epidemiological Situation of Fusarium Wilt of Bananas (TR4)
 
Global Epidemiological Situation of Fusarium Wilt of Bananas (TR4)
Global Epidemiological Situation of Fusarium Wilt of Bananas (TR4)Global Epidemiological Situation of Fusarium Wilt of Bananas (TR4)
Global Epidemiological Situation of Fusarium Wilt of Bananas (TR4)
 
Beehives article
Beehives articleBeehives article
Beehives article
 
Ttpb1 whystudyplants
Ttpb1 whystudyplantsTtpb1 whystudyplants
Ttpb1 whystudyplants
 
Invasive impact of prosopis juliflora on wildlife conservation and livelihoods
Invasive impact of prosopis juliflora on wildlife conservation and livelihoodsInvasive impact of prosopis juliflora on wildlife conservation and livelihoods
Invasive impact of prosopis juliflora on wildlife conservation and livelihoods
 
Japanese Knotweed
Japanese KnotweedJapanese Knotweed
Japanese Knotweed
 
convesation of Biodiversity
convesation of Biodiversityconvesation of Biodiversity
convesation of Biodiversity
 
Response of potential stored grain insect pests to bfl 225 multi attractant l...
Response of potential stored grain insect pests to bfl 225 multi attractant l...Response of potential stored grain insect pests to bfl 225 multi attractant l...
Response of potential stored grain insect pests to bfl 225 multi attractant l...
 
Mycorrhiza Vam and Am type and it's physiological and Ecological studies.pptx
Mycorrhiza Vam and Am type and it's physiological and Ecological studies.pptxMycorrhiza Vam and Am type and it's physiological and Ecological studies.pptx
Mycorrhiza Vam and Am type and it's physiological and Ecological studies.pptx
 
Environmental change and vector borne disease
Environmental change and vector borne diseaseEnvironmental change and vector borne disease
Environmental change and vector borne disease
 
Biodiversity Essay Writing
Biodiversity Essay WritingBiodiversity Essay Writing
Biodiversity Essay Writing
 
ENGAGE invasion
ENGAGE invasionENGAGE invasion
ENGAGE invasion
 
jkjhk
jkjhkjkjhk
jkjhk
 
Soil Remediation
Soil RemediationSoil Remediation
Soil Remediation
 
Making and Using Worm Compost
Making and Using Worm CompostMaking and Using Worm Compost
Making and Using Worm Compost
 

The Academic Review How box blight of Buxus spp. is changing the landscape in the 21st Century.

  • 1. The Academic Review: How box blight of Buxus spp. is changing the landscape in the 21st Century. Introduction Buxussppis an importantplantinhistoryaswell asin today’sworld.The firstformal clippedbox was usedbythe Egyptiansin4,000BC (TopiaryArts,2016). Throughouthistoryand still todaybox is usedas the structural,formal elementingardensandlandscape design.Ithasbeen usedasa means of executionof ‘control of nature’andas a status symbol of wealthandalso formedicinal purposes (TopiaryArts,2016). Howeverthisiconicplantspeciesisunderthreatinthe wildaswell asinman- made landscapesandgardens.The pestanddiseasesthat affectthe Buxusspp.are many.However inthispaper the mainfocuswill be Box Blight’simpactonlandscapesandhorticulture. Historic importance of the Buxus spp. in the UK. In the UK particularlythe native Buxus sppwasgrowingwilduntil the Ice Age whereuponthe native spp.was destroyed.Howeverthe Romaninvasionin100BC re-introducedthe species(TopiaryArts, 2016). In the Middle Agesandthroughto the Elizabethanperiodthe Buxuswasusedforknot gardens,hedges,galleriesaswell asindividualspecimendisplays afteritwasfound thatcypressspp were notas reliable (TopiaryArts,2016).The Hamptoncourt gardensof HenryVIIIhad box spheres, conesand animals(TopiaryArts,2016). Topiarywas bornas a statussymbol and to indicate control of nature. Throughthe 17th into18th centurythe naturalisticmovementledbyCapabilityBrownsaw Buxus’usage decline asitwasno longerfashionable toimpose formalityontothe landscape (Wilson, 2014). In the 19th centurythe returnof formalitycame ina re-birthof the ‘Italian Renaissance’The Buxusbecame a staple; carpetbeddingschemes,low hedgesandextreme topiarydesignsof crowns, birdsdominatedlandscape designandparks.Nurseriesinthe UKwere becomingspecialisedin topiaryworksand selling‘alreadyformed’plantsincontainerstothe public(TopiaryArts,2016). The returnof ‘knotstyle’gardensandparterresbecame the identityof the ‘BritishGarden’ In the 20th centurythe Arts and Craftmovementmeantthatthe harshcontrol of nature was relaxed thoughinformal borderdesignswithplantingschemesandlayoutdidnotbanishthe box but incorporateditas a backdropand structural elementwithinadesign.Topiarywasless extremein design.Inthe 60’s the publicwentthroughthe ‘FrontGardenMovement’ withclassicrose bedsand the use of topiaryandhedgingwaspopular.We still see the Buxusasa stable plantinthe garden and instructural landscape designsanduse itheavilyforcreationof shapesandbackdrops.Inthe urban landscape itisusedinlowline fronthedgingasa protective andframingbarrieraround
  • 2. plantingschemesandthe topiaryball andpyramidisusedoutside establishmentssuchashotels, restaurants,shoppingcentresandpublichousestomarkformalisedentrances tobuildings. The Main threats to Buxus spp. The Box Caterpillar Moth– Cydalimaperspectalishasbecome anincreasing threatinrecentyears. The Box CaterpillarenteredEurope in2007 andin 2011 the pesthad fullyreproducedinthis country. In 2012 thiscaterpillarreplacedthe molluscsspp.(snail/slug) as the mosttroublesomepest ina poll conductedbythe RHS (Appleby,M.2013). By 2014, it had become fullyestablishedin Londonand the home-counties(Royal Horticultural Society,2016). These caterpillarscause defoliationbyeatingthe foliage (Plate 1) andinclippedBuxuscause full dyingbackof the plantin highdensityfeedingareas. The caterpillarprotectthemselveswithwhite webbingduringfeeding and pupation. Plate 1 - The Box Tree Caterpillar Image Source; Royal Horticultural Society https://www.rhs.org.uk/advice/profile?pid=760 Caption: Identification information; The moth eggs are laid on the underside of the leaves in an overlapping/flat sheet formation and have a greenish/yellow appearance. The young caterpillars have yellow/green bodies with a black head, as they mature the body has black and white striping down the sides. The adult moth have white wings with a brown rim border. There ischemical treatmentavailable forthe caterpillaraswell asa pheromone treatmentfor attractingthe adultstagedmothintotraps (Royal Horticultural Society,2016). The impactof this invaderon the UK isa cause forconcern as ithas the potential toattack our wildbox treesandhave a large impact onour hedges,topiaryspecimens. Box Blight- There are twogeneticstrains of the fungal disease;Cylindrocladiumbuxicola(now knownas Calonectriapseudonauiculata)affectingthe wholeBuxaceaefamily.The second; Pseudonetriabuxi onlyaffecting the Buxusspp (Royal Horticultural Society,2015; Ivors,2016;
  • 3. Horticulture Week,2015).The fungal infectionsco-existwithone anothermostoftenon aplant Cylindrocladiumbuxicolabeingthe mostserious of the two(Royal HorticulturalSociety,2015; Ivors, 2016). Both strainsexhibitthe,browningandspottingonleaves,anddefoliation,dyingbackpatches (Plate 2) whichleadstodeathof the plant (Henricot& Wedgwood,2013; Royal Horticultural Society , 2015; Horticulture Week,2015).The Cylindrocladiumbuxicolaaffectsstemtissuesinadditionwith blackstreaksand die back (Henricot&Wedgwood,2013) The sporesof the fungi are distinctly differentandinwetweathercanbe seen.The Cylindrocladiumbuxicolahaswhite sporesandthe Pseudonectriabuxi haspinkspores (Royal Horticultural Society,2015; Ivors,2016). Plate 2 - Box Blight Image Source; Royal Horticultural Society https://www.rhs.org.uk/advice/profile?pid=96 Caption: A Fungal disease affecting foliage and is spread by moisture and overwintering reproductive soil borne spores. Classic symptoms of browning and sudden dying back and death spots can take hold very quickly. Climate Change As we knowclimate change globallyisaffectingmany organismsandplantlife.Fromthe statistics and analysisof the UK’s climate change forecast(UKCP09) reportitprojectsthat warmer andwetter wintersanddrierbut more humidsummerswill become the UKclimate (UKClimate Projections - Met Office,2009). Thiswill resultinarapidincrease of fungal infectionsandspeedof spread of box blightandotherfungal infectionsinthe UK (Forestry Comission,2015).The wettersoil conditions will alsoincrease the riskof rootrot diseasesforthe Buxusandof course other plants. The Significance of Box Blight affecting Horticulture. It isa worldwide spreadproblem. (Plate3) There are 70 speciesof Buxusworldwide whichare mainlyinthe tropical andsubtropical regions, 30reside inCubaand 17 are native toMadagascar (Wilson,2014). The restof the Buxusspp are spreadacross the Caribbean,Chinaandthe Americas includingLatinAmerica(Henricot&Wedgwood,2013; Wilson,2014). The Native Europeanand AsianBuxusare the onlyfrost hardy species.The true originof the disease isunknown.The earliest
  • 4. record of the disease wasfoundinthe UK in1990’s (Henricot&Wedgwood,2013; Ivors,2016; Wilson,2014; Weeda,S.M etal, 2012; Horticulture Week,2015) ina Hampshire nursery (Appleby, M. 2013). From2002 onwardsit had spreadthroughEurope and to New Zealand (Weeda,S.M etal, 2012). In recentyearsit hasspreadto the Americasand East Asia (Henricot&Wedgwood,2013; Ivors,2016; Wilson,2014, Weeds,S.Metal, 2012). Plate 3 - Worldwide Map of Box Blight infections. Source; Authors own creation with map image from http//:mapsofthe world.com. The Native BuxussempervienslocatedinSurreywasreportedin2000 to have Box Blightpresent (Appleby,M.2013) and the Turkishnative collection confirmedinfectionin2011 (Lehtrijarvi,2014) whichisof greatconcern. Production and Commercially Commerciallythe salesof the Buxushave droppedinrecentyearsdue tothe fearand stigma attachedto the plant. In additionsome nurseriesare unknowingly sellinginfectedplantstothe gardencentre sectorby not fullyunderstandingthe diseasesidentifiable markers.Howeverinsome casesthere has beenpoorpractice by nurseriesandproducersbysuppressinginfectedplantswith fungicidesreadyforsale andthe gardencentressuddenlyexperiencingexplosionsof box blightfrom the re-emergence(Henricot,B. 2013; The EuropeanBoxwoodandTopiarySociety,2014). Nurseries such as BuckinghamNurseriesdiversifieddue toseeingBuxussalesdropby50% andthe sales of the alternativesincreasing(Appleby,M.2013). Howeversome of the alternativesare currentlyinshort supplyasmany establishmentshave notfully/speedilydiversified.Some of these‘replacementof
  • 5. box plants’are vulnerable inthemselvesassuchas Loniceraspp. because theytendtobe mass/over producedandthisin turn could furthercause weaknessestootherdiseases (Appleby,M.2013). Historic/Visitor Attraction Gardens and Landscapes In the amenitysectorof horticulture Box Blightgreatlyaffects the finances of visitorattractionsas well asthe aestheticappearance andhistoric,iconiccharacterof a landscape (Reid,2015; Watkins& Wright,2007; Wilson,2014; The EuropeanBoxwoodandTopiarySociety,2014). The economic damage that the infectioncaninflictuponanestablishmentcanrunintothe thousands. The fact that Buxusisslowgrowing; andit takes 18 yearsto grow and shape a large topiaryball means that specimenwouldbe worth£1,000 if notmore (Wilson,2014). Whenan infectionbreaksout the need for pathologyreports,closure of the site duringinfections,the fungicides, andmanpowerinitself and the operationof removal of infectedmaterial andreplacementplantingare all factorsarising fromBox Blightinfection (Reid,2015).In many historiclandscapesthe Buxusisthe mostimportant structural plantand the loss/damage the diseasecausesmore than financial andpractical problems. In some establishmentsthe spreadof itcan be so horrificand fast(48hrs) (Reid,2015; Horticulture Week,2015) the devastationandlossof keyandspecial specimenscanhithard. IckworthParkthe Italianate Renaissance Gardenswere repeatedlystruckoveratenyearperiodanda massive infectionin2015 wipedout80% of the hedgingincludingaspecimenthatwasover200years old (Reid,2015). Up and downthe UK managersof landscapes,gardensandvisitorattractionsare havingto make difficult decisionsinregardstohow bestto manage the disease andthe future of the designandplantselectionforthese establishments.The combinationof cultural practicesand hygiene managementwithfungicidesisonlyworkinguptoapoint. Management of the Disease and New Developments – Is there a way forward? Buxus spp Genetics The study of susceptibilitytothe box blightdisease hasbeenextensivelyresearchedand ithas been foundthat there are some speciesandcultivarsthatappearto be more resistanttothe infection (Shishkoff,2015) butthisis debatable asthe studiesshow thatthe resistance isnota ‘complete’ resistance.Eventuallytheydoall succumb to the box blightinfection andthatresistance is marginal (Yonghong,2015). Eventhoughthe geneticvariation of the genusiswide ithas provendifficultto breedBuxus (Laere &Hermans,2015). Howeverthere iscurrentlysome optimismintermsof breeding.The scientificcommunity isincreasingfurtherunderstandingof the characteristicsof the Buxaceae family. The leaf structure of aparticularspp.such as thickerleaf cuticle/epidermal tissue layersanda smallerleaf surface areaindicate aphysiological designthatprovestoprovide ‘alevel’ of plantdefence fromthe fungus (Shishkoff,2015).This isparticularlyapparentinthe macrophylla subspeciesof Buxushavinga highertolerance andlowersusceptibilitycomparedtosempervirens
  • 6. but the varietyof cultivarshada significantgeneticimpactof the resistance levelwithinthese sub speciesgroups (Henricot&Wedgwood,2013; Shishkoff,2015; Yonghong,2015). Howeverthe techniquesof testingsusceptibilityneedmore refining asfieldtrialsandlaboratoryscenariosare verydifferentandusinginoculatedcuttingsisverydifferenttousingplantspecimens (Henricot, 2013; Yonghong,2015). A newdevelopmentof aSSR-cDNalibraryhas been createdtolook forparticulargeneticmarkers. 845 of these have beenisolatedfrommRNA material andfromthose 23 polymorphicprimerpairs have beenidentified (Thammina,2014) as keygeneticcharatisiticthatcan be usedforBox Blight resistance ingeneticdiversity,hybridisationandcultivarbreedingof Buxus (Thammina,2014). Hybridization of BuxustoF1 fromcross combinationsresultingin 4750 ‘interspecific’F1 seedlings has recentlybeenachieved in2015 witha seedgerminationrate between0-47%. (Laere & Hermans, 2015). Howeverthese are earlydaysandthe interspecificrange of those seedlingsmay/maynotbe variable orsuccessful butthe hybridscouldofferthe scientificcommunitythe opportunitytoexploit the F1 fordesirable traits (Laere &Hermans,2015). Biological Understanding of the Funguses Life Cycles In a taxonomicre assessmentof Cylindrocladiumbuxicola(reclassifiedasCalonectriapseudonavicala now) the fungushastwo geneticcladesunearthinganew phylogeneticspecies‘Calonectria henricotiae’ (Gehesquière,2016) as an additional variantof the Box Blightdiseasewhichhasa greatertolerance tohighertemperaturesandincreasedtolerance tofungicides (Gehesquière,2016). Thisnewinformationisworryingbutthe communityknow thatthere ismore variance inthe fungal familynowand more researchcan be undertaken (Gehesquière,2016). The twostrainsof Box Blight have very differentoverwinteringmechanisms.Itwasfoundthatthe Cylindrocladiumbuxicolahasa unique overwinteringstructure form; ‘Microsclerotia’whichallowsthe fungustoreproduce during wintermonthswithinsoil.Thisexplainshow repeatedre infectionoccurfromleaf littermaterial and dirtytools/machineryasthiscell structure cansurvive for5yearswithinleaf material andupto15 yearsin soil and inminusfigure temperatures (Weeda, S.Metal 2012; Ganci,2013). This evolutionaryadaptationinthe Cylindrocladiumbuxicolaisnotpresentinthe Pseudonectriabuxi strainof the fungus (Weeda, S.Met al 2012) whichconfirmshow andwhyone strainis more rampant andmore difficulttotreatincomparisonto the otherstrain. Thiscouldunlockwhattypes of fungicide touse andtailormake compoundingredientstotargetthisaspectof the funguseslife cycle inthe future.
  • 7. Fungicides The EU have recentlybanned some fungicidesthatare used inthe treatmentof the disease (Royal Horticultural Society,2015). The EU regularlyreviewschemical substancesand thismeansthat horticulturistsacrossthe industryhave tokeepuptodate withthe use of fungicidesandother chemical treatments (Royal Horticultural Society,2015; Wilson,2014). There have beena few studiesintothe effectivenessof themagainstBox Blightbutmostly sothe Cylindrocladiumbuxicola strain.Theyhave beeninconclusive orofferasuppressive/moderate level of control.Howevera recentstudy evaluatedandtestedvariousproducts andfoundthatone all-roundproduct ‘Opponent’ completelyeradiatedbox blightandtimingandchoice of fungicides suchas‘Bravo’, ‘Octave’and‘Signum’ greatly affected how wellthose productsworked(Henricot&Wedgwood, 2013). Howeverthese are all commercial productsthatthe publiccannotaccess.The study did howeverfindthat‘FungusClear’ whichisonthe publicmarket, didofferamoderate control butstill thisdoesnot reallyofferatotal solution tothe general public. Plant Selections The Buxusspp as discussedhaslimitedresistance tothe disease butthe followingtable show more tolerantspecieswhich couldstill be usedwithinalandscape orsoldcommerciallytocustomers whomstill desire box plants. (Table 1) There are a wide range of alternative thatcanbe usedinstead of Buxus if the decisionistobe takento avoidall Buxusspp (Table 1) butthisnot the solutionand otheralternative have theirownpitfalls. Table 1 - Collective list of Buxus spp to avoid and use and alternative plant selections. Authors own consolidation from a range of sources. Buxus spp to avoid using More tolerant Buxus spp Alternatives to Buxus B. sempervirens B. microphylla ‘Compacta’ Euonymus fortunei (various) B. sempervirens ‘Elegantissima’ B. sinica var. insularis ‘Winter Beauty’ Rosmarinus officinalis B. sempervirens ‘Suffruticosa’ B. sinica var. insularis ‘Pincushion’ Lavandula angustifolia B. sempervirens ‘American’ B. microphylla ‘Faulker’ Ligustrum Ovalifolium B. sinica var insularis ‘Justin Brouwers’ B. macrophylla ‘Trompenburg’ Ilex crenata B. sempervirens ‘Marginata’ B. harlandii Lonicera nitida and Lonicera nitida ’Baggins Gold’ B. sempervirens ‘Jensen’ B. microphylla ‘Golden Dream’ Podocarpus lawrencei, salignus and andina B. sempervirens ‘Pendula’ B. microphylla ‘Winter Gem’ Taxus baccata B. sempervirens ‘Scupi’ Myrtus communis Berberis various Hebe ‘buxifolia’ and ‘odora’ (short term solution for urban building enterances)
  • 8. Good Practice and Strategic Methodology Non-chemical/goodpracticesare importanttopreventawiderspreadof box blightfromoutbreaks howevertheyare limitedwithdealingwithinfectionsalone.The combinationof fungicidetreatment and goodpractice offera moderate control of the disease (Royal Horticultural Society,2015). It has beenknowthatsome Buxusdo survive afteraninfectionbuthave ahighriskof infectingother surroundingspecimensandare likelytobecome re-infectedagain. Belowisa range of advisoryinformationthatconsiderschemicalandnon-chemical options.  The current advice fordealingwithbox blightinfectionswithoutfungicidesemphasises good hygiene practice withmachinery,pruningequipmentandPPE/clothingbyusingdisinfectant and washingclothingarticlesregularly(Horticulture Week,2015; Ganci, 2013; Ivors,2016; The EuropeanBoxwoodandTopiarySociety,2014; Royal Horticultural Society,2015).  Whenan infectionisidentifieditisimportanttoascertainwhichorif co-existence of strains are present(Reid,2015; Henricot& Wedgwood,2013; Ivors,2016). That waythe decision whethertouse fungicidesandpractice operationssuchaspruningoutmaterial can be examined (RoyalHorticulturalSociety ,2015). The removal of all dead,dyingandinfected material shouldbe incineratedandsoil disposedof inaccordance to legislation (Reid,2015; The EuropeanBoxwoodandTopiarySociety,2014; Horticulture Week,2015; Watkins& Wright,2007).  Overheadirrigationincreasesthe spreadingpotential of the fungussothisshouldbe avoided (The EuropeanBoxwoodandTopiarySociety,2014). Dripirrigationinthe commercial settingoffersareductioninrisk(Wilson,2014).  Reducingthe clippingregimeof hedgesandtopiaryshouldbe consideredwherepossibleas tightlyclippedspecimenshave poorairventilationandthis increasesthe riskof infection (Royal Horticultural Society,2015; The EuropeanBoxwoodandTopiarySociety,2014).  Landscape and Commercial Managersshouldtake cuttingsfromnon-infectedmaterial and builda ‘safetybank’of specimens (The EuropeanBoxwoodandTopiarySociety,2014) so if infectionstrikesthe replantationcostsare reducedbythe creationof yourownstock.
  • 9.  Applicationof mulchonsoil areascouldassistinreducingre-infectionfrom fungusspores leftinthe soil (CU Cooperative ExtensionTeam, 2015). Conclusion Commercial growers,nurseriesandlandscape managersneedtoselect,evaluate andplanhow they wishto use fungicide productsonthe basisof theirsituationorpreventativemethodsof protecting theirbox plants. The scientificcommunityare discoveringmore andmore aboutthe disease andthe Buxaceae familyinwhichgeneticscreening,cataloguingandbreedingprogrammesare beginningto developmethodsof producingplantswithtraitsthatcouldprove significantindisease resistance and increasingtolerance levels.The morphological understandingof the fungushasshedlightona newsubstrainof the disease fromCylindrocladiumbuxicolaandleda nomaculture reclassification of thatstrain to Calonectriapseudonviculata.The fungi lifecycle andreproductivemechanismshave beenexploredandthisinturnmay offera soil treatmentinthe future.The assessmentandattitude to the usage of Buxus species inthe landscape isthatevenwiththe disease beingpresentthere are waysforwardin termsof alternativesanddifferentselectionsof box plants.Stillthere are fearsof Native spp.areaswill be greatlyaffectedbythe disease,climate change andotherpestand disease infections.The combinationof hygieneandfungicidetreatmentofferaslow downto the spreadof the disease butdonot offera true eradication. Fungicide developmentincorrelation to understandingthe disease will eventuallybecomeasignificantmethodtopossiblyeradicate it. Currentlyfungicide offersuppressionandcontainmentbutthe developmentof new productsare provingtobe increasinglyeffective andthe timingof applicationshave proventobe a breakthrough inthe managementof the disease. Onlytime,scienceandeffective managementwill determine how far thisdisease takesholdandthe outcome forthe Buxussppas a plant. Word Count2,804
  • 10. References Appleby,M.(2013) ‘Box blightdisease continuestostrike box hedges’The TelegraphOnline Article written11th February2013 TelegraphMediaGroupLimited2016 http://www.telegraph.co.uk/gardening/plants/9862995/Box-blight-disease-continues-to-strike-box- hedges.html[Accessed14thFebruary2016] CU Cooperative ExtensionTeam,2015. Clemson University - Home and Garden Information. http://www.clemson.edu/extension/hgic/pests/plant_pests/shrubs/hgic2052.html [Accessed3May 2016]. ForestryComission,2015. Forestry Research. http://www.forestry.gov.uk/fr/urgc-7qjery [Accessed15 February2016]. Ganci, M., 2013. 'Evaluatingthe role of Microsclerotiainthe Diease Cycle of BoxwoodBlight,caused by the fungusCylindrocladiumbuxicola. Collegeof Agricultureand Life Sciences - CAL NewLetter, Issue https://www.cals.ncsu.edu/agcomm/news-center/perspectives/stopping-aggressive-boxwood- blight/. [Accessed24th March 2016] Gehesquière,B.etal,2016. Characterizationandtaxonomicreassessmentof the box blight pathogenCalonectriapseudonaviculata,introducing Calonectriahenricotiae sp.nov.Plant Pathology, Volume65, Issue 1, pp.37-52. Henricot,B.& Wedgwood,E.,2013. Evaluationof FoliarFungicide Spraysforthe Control of Boxwood Blight,Causedbythe FungusCylindrocladiumbuxicola. PlantManagementNetwork - PlantHealth Progress, http://www.plantmanagementnetwork.org/pub/php/research/2013/boxwood/ [Accessed 14th Feburary2016] Horticulture Week,2015. Pest and DiseaseManagement - Box Blight. [Accessed14thFeburary2016]. Ivors,K.,2016. The NorthCarolina StateUniversity - Box Blight Guide. https://yancey.ces.ncsu.edu/wp-content/uploads/2013/02/Boxwood-Blight-Guide- 01.03.13.pdf?fwd=no [Accessed14thFebruary2016]. Laere,K. V.& Hermans,D. e.a., 2015. Interspecific hybridisationwithBuxusspp. Scientia Horticulturea, Volume 185, pp. 139-144. Lehtrijarvi,A.,2014. Cylindrocladiumbuxicolaisthreateningthe native Buxussempervirens populationsinTurkey. PlantProtection Science, Volume50,Issue 4, pp. 227-229. Reid,S.,2015. Head Gardener,LandscapeManager [Interview] (14thOctober2015). Royal Horticultural Society,2015. Box Blight. [Online] Available at:https://www.rhs.org.uk/advice/profile?pid=96 [Accessed14thFebruary2016]. Royal Horticultural Society,2016. Box Tree Caterpillar. https://www.rhs.org.uk/advice/profile?pid=760 [Accessed24thMarch 2016]. Shishkoff,N.etal,2015. EvaluatingboxwoodsusceptibilitytoCalonectriapseudonviculatausing cuttingsfromthe National BoxwoodCollection. PlantHealth Progress, Volume16,Issue 1, pp.11-15.
  • 11. Thammina,C.et al,2014. Developmentof polymorphicgenic-SSRmarkersbycDNA library sequencinginboxwood,Buxusspp.. Applicationsin PlantSciences,Volume 9, Issue 12. The EuropeanBoxwoodandTopiarySociety,2014. The European Boxwoodand Topiary Society. http://www.ebts.org/2014/02/another-year-with-box-blight-box-tree-moth/(Extracted/Printed Originallyfrom'Topiarius'Volume17 page 31. 2013) [Accessed2ndMay 2016]. TopiaryArts,2016. Topiary Arts - English Grown Topiary Design & Landscaping,Gardens& Restoration. http://www.topiaryarts.com/tips-techniques/history [Accessed14thFebruary2016]. UK Climate Projections - MetOffice,2009. UKClimate Projections - UKCP09. http://ukclimateprojections.metoffice.gov.uk/21708 [Accessed28thSeptember2015]. Watkins,J.& Wright, T.,2007. The managementand maintenanceof historic parks,gardensand landscapes:TheEngligh Heritage Handbook. 1ed.London:FrancesLincolnLtd . Weeda,S.M. etal, 2012. Histological Evidence thatMicrosclerotiaPlayaSignificantRole inDisease Cycle of the BoxwoodBlightPathogeninSoutheasternUnitedStatesandImplicationsforDisease Mitigation. PlantManagementNetwork - PlantHealth Progress, p. http://www.plantmanagementnetwork.org/pub/php/brief/2012/boxwood/. Wilson,M.,2014. FinnanalTimes Online- Houseand Home - Gardens. http://www.ft.com/cms/s/2/1ec2db22-eb1e-11e3-bab6-00144feabdc0.html#axzz46q7BrgIW [Accessed23 04 2016]. Yonghong,G. e.a., 2015. Effective BioassaysforEvaluatingBoxwoodBlightSusceptibilityUsing DetachedStemInoculations. HortScience, Volume50,Issue 2, pp. 268-271. List of Plates Plate 1 - The Box Tree CaterpillarImage Source;Royal Horticultural Society https://www.rhs.org.uk/advice/profile?pid=760 Plate 2 - Box BlightImage Source;Royal Horticultural Society https://www.rhs.org.uk/advice/profile?pid=96 Plate 3 - Worldwide Mapof Box Blightinfections.Source;Authorsowncreationwithmapimage fromhttp://mapsoftheworld.com List of Tables Table 1 - Collective listof Buxusspptoavoidand use and alternative plantselections.Authorsown consolidationfromarange of sources.