1. 1
This report is protected by copyright - Any full or partial reproduction is subject to prior authorization of B3tsi - Concomitance
A clearer insight into the
MICE market in France,
Germany and the UK
White Paper
March 2016
Produced by
2. 2
This report is protected by copyright - Any full or partial reproduction is subject to prior authorization of B3tsi - Concomitance
3. 3
This report is protected by copyright - Any full or partial reproduction is subject to prior authorization of B3tsi - Concomitance
INTRODUCTION
Why does nobody know the size of the MICE market?
The MICE market (Meetings, Incentives, Congresses and Events) not only arouses
considerable interest, but also raises many question marks. Little is known about this
market, and yet it represents a core activity in the business travel and hotel sectors.
Big data is on its way to becoming "outdated", and yet the MICE business continues to
confound any attempts to gauge its size, which all industry professionalsrecognise without
exception.
Some experts may release studies or hazard ballpark figures, but it only takes a few
questions to reach the only realistic consensus, namely that nobody knows the size of the
MICE market, despite weighing several billions of euros for Western Europe (estimates
vary from 40 to 120 billion euros a year)!
MICE: a host of players with mixed budgets
The market for corporate events alone is both extensive and multi-faceted. The MICE
acronym encompasses a broad array of situations for both decision-makers and service
providers.
First of all, the initial complexity arises from the large number of entities present with
potential decision-making authority, including associations, companies, consortiums and
federations.
Secondly, the market is rife with event organisers, including event planners, business travel
agencies, destination management companies (DMCs), professional congress organisers
(PCOs) and venues serving as congress centres. Some stakeholders, such as tourist
information centres and regional / departmental tourist boards, also wield considerable
influence.
The companies operating in the travel industry, such as airlines, rail companies, cruise lines,
car rental firms, insurers, hotels and accommodation providers, are often the same as
those involved in the business travel sector; an overlap in expenditure is therefore
inevitable, even though purchasing practices are different.
Finally, the market also features catering firms, content producers, audiovisual experts,
scenic designers and new technology firms.
4. 4
This report is protected by copyright - Any full or partial reproduction is subject to prior authorization of B3tsi - Concomitance
What you will find in this white paper
This is the background to the study that Concomitance Consulting carried out among more
than 300 meeting planners in the top three European markets: France, Germany and the
United Kingdom.
This study laid the foundations for the white paper that we are offering to share with you.
You will find a summary of the study's main findings, the salient points of the French,
German and UK markets, and a benchmark of MICE practices among hotel groups.
This document represents an executive summary of the information collected. A broader
summary is actually available. We will do our utmost to address any remarks and
comments, as well as respond to any enquiries.
5. 5
This report is protected by copyright - Any full or partial reproduction is subject to prior authorization of B3tsi - Concomitance
MICE markets in France, Germany and the UK
In 2015, the MICE market in France, Germany and the United Kingdom could be estimated at
approximately €70 billion and accounts for slightly more than two thirds of the business travel
market.
MICE undeniably represents a significant share of company spending on travel. Despite its size,
the market lacks structure and faces major challenges in the form of growth and digitisation.
We came to this observation after interviewing professionals in the MICE market and analysing
the wide range of practices between countries and according to the types of event and
decision-maker.
54
28 28,4
Germany
Business
travel
2015
MICE
market*
2015
40
23 23,3
UK
Business
travel
2015
MICE
market*
2015
33
20 19,9
France
Business
travel
2015
MICE
market*
2015
MICE
market*
2016
MICE
market*
2016
+1.3%
MICE
market*
2016
* The market valuation (in € billion) includes venue hire, accommodation and F&B
+1.3%
-0.4%
6. 6
This report is protected by copyright - Any full or partial reproduction is subject to prior authorization of B3tsi - Concomitance
Some salient facts relating to events in Northwest Europe
o Close to two thirds of events are meetings involving fewer than 30 people
In France, Germany and the United Kingdom, close to two thirds of events are meetings
involving fewer than 30 people. Not only does this apply to companies but also
associations, unions and other federations. It goes without saying that specialised MICE
agents are not often contracted to organise such events.
This first risk shows the extent to which the MICE market is fragmented, often
underestimated and in need of specific tools to market services and solutions.
o 46% of organisations have a MICE budget of less than €150k
Over 60% of associations, unions and other federations have a MICE budget of less than
€150k, while nearly 40% of companies are required to manage their events with less than
€150k.
A parallel can be drawn between this observation and the slight reduction in the duration
of events. The vast majority of events lasted less than two days in 2015. Only conferences
and congresses still average two days.
Although MICE budgets are increasing on average, companies are tending to streamline
their event budgets and shorten their duration. Therefore, meeting planners are faced
with a growing number of short-duration events.
o 44% of events are for in-house purposes
Whereas 37% of events are organised to achieve a commercial or communication
objective (product launches, conferences, congresses, communication and media
relations), 44% of events are laid on for the company's internal management (training,
meetings, management seminars, board meetings and incentives). The remaining 19% are
special events or participation in events organised by other entities.
44%
37%
19%
Event objectives
Internal meetings
Commercial or
communication
Special events
or organised
by others
7. 7
This report is protected by copyright - Any full or partial reproduction is subject to prior authorization of B3tsi - Concomitance
70% of events are organised locally
(i.e. in the country of the entity holding the event)
Of the 30% of events staged abroad, most take place in Europe. Events are most often
organised abroad by associations, unions and federations. Companies prefer holding their
events at a local venue. When staging their event abroad, companies most frequently
enlist the services of an agent.
How are events managed?
o Senior management is involved in the decision-making process in over half
of all events
Senior executives actively participate in the selection and negotiation process when
organising events. Even when the company features buyers, meeting planners or a
dedicated events department, senior management remains highly involved in over 50% of
all event-related decisions.
o 90% of events are managed internally by companies. Providers (agencies)
only take part in 10% of events, although they believe that they are involved
in 30% to 40% of cases.
Companies and associations estimate that 90% of their events are managed directly with
their internal teams. They do not believe that they are outsourcing the management of
their event by using online booking or sourcing systems or a venue finder's services.
Consequently, only 10% of events are entrusted to agents.
However, agents believe that they are involved in 30% to 40% of events. This difference in
perception is likely related to the scope of the market, insofar as agents are probably
unaware of some of the small events organised.
o 91% of companies believe that MICE expenditure is under control, but only
50% have a system for tracking expenditure
Although many companies believe that expenditure is under control and that they are
unable to optimise their MICE budget, 50% of companies do not have a system for
managing and tracking expenditure. Tools for measuring ROI or processes for reclaiming
VAT are far from standard practice. These points illustrate that business travel has
reached a higher level of maturity than MICE in most companies.
8. 8
This report is protected by copyright - Any full or partial reproduction is subject to prior authorization of B3tsi - Concomitance
Some of the specific features observed in France, Germany and the UK
o France:
In 2015, France achieved third position in Europe behind Germany and the United Kingdom in terms
of the volume of MICE activity. In 2016, market players are expecting to see a slight fall due to the
terrorist attacks in Paris late 2015.
57% of events in France include fewer than 30 participants, and 59% of companies have a budget of
less than €150k. Nevertheless, the cost per participant with or without accommodation is clearly
higher in France (approximately +20%) than in Germany or the United Kingdom. This finding can
partly be explained by the greater use of agents for organising events.
In terms of the types of event, training sessions and internal team meetings were the most frequent
in France in 2015.
French companies organised 73% of their events in France. Over two thirds of events held abroad
took place within Europe.
57% of events are
attended by fewer than
30 participants
MICE budget
< €150k
> €150k59%
41%
59% of organisations have an annual
MICE budget of less than €150k
73% of
events
are organised on a
national scale
27% of
events
are held abroad
Intermediation
French companies are
more often inclined to
use agents (+/- 60%)
61% of companies have a
MICE management system
MICE costs
The average cost per
participant is higher in
France than in the United
Kingdom and Germany
9. 9
This report is protected by copyright - Any full or partial reproduction is subject to prior authorization of B3tsi - Concomitance
o Germany:
With the volume of business estimated at €28 billion, Germany is home to Europe's leading market.
Professionals are expecting to see growth of 1.3% in 2016.
The proportion of events with fewer than 30 participants is also the highest in Germany (74%). In
32% of cases, such events are training sessions or internal team meetings.
A defining feature of Germany is the implementation of strict (57%) or directive MICE policies (32%)
for organising events. Companies without a MICE policy are few and far between. With the aim of
improving the process, German meeting planners prefer using online sourcing tools, and 94% have
installed a system for managing and tracking their events.
74% of events organised by German organisations are held in Germany. Only 8% of events take place
outside Europe.
74% of events are
attended by fewer
than 30 participants
MICE policy
Directive
policy
Strict
policy
Lenient policy
No policy
32%
57%
89% of organisations have a strict or
directive MICE policy
Types of event
32%
68%
Training & internal
team meetings
Other events74% of events are organised on
a national scale
26% of events are
held abroad Germans prefer online
sourcing for finding new
venues
94% of companies do
not have a MICE
management system
10. 10
This report is protected by copyright - Any full or partial reproduction is subject to prior authorization of B3tsi - Concomitance
o United Kingdom:
The UK is home to the second largest MICE market in Europe with €23 billion and projected growth
of 1.3% in 2016.
The events held by English organisations are generally on a larger scale. 63% of events are attended
by over 100 participants. It logically follows that MICE budgets are also higher on average. These
results can be attributed to the types of event, with conferences and congresses representing 40%
of events in the United Kingdom.
Another specific feature of the MICE market in the United Kingdom is the tendency among decision-
makers to organise events abroad. In 45% of cases, the chosen venue is located abroad in Europe
(23%), North America (9%) or the rest of the world (13%).
In terms of expenditure, venue hire represents a significantly larger cost item in the United Kingdom
than in other countries.
Loyalty programmes are less used in the United Kingdom. This can be attributed to the fact that
many companies prevent their employees from signing up for this type of programme.
63% of events are attended
by fewer than 100
participants
MICE budget
< €150k > €150k
34%
66%
66% of organisations have an annual
MICE budget in excess of €150k
Types of event
40%
60%
Conferences/
Congresses
Other
events
55% of
events
are organised on a national scale
45% of
events
are held abroad
MICE expenditure
Venue hire accounts
for a major proportion
of costs
(46%)
65% of interviewees do not
have a loyalty card (they are
not allowed to sign up for a
loyalty programme)
92% of companies do not
have an expense management
system
11. 11
This report is protected by copyright - Any full or partial reproduction is subject to prior authorization of B3tsi - Concomitance
Closer look at MICE services by hotel groups
MICE experts emphasise the lack of market knowledge, in spite of the complexity relating to its
fragmentation and the wide range of stakeholders involved. Few in-depth market analyses are
available, and research has failed to zero in on the customer experience. The result is that hotels
experience real trouble in building services and solutions suited to each type of meeting planner and
the different providers.
Hotels are actively involved in the market, but do not disclose their MICE activities. There is no
identified or recognised leader in the market.
Analysing the main hotel groups operating in the market reveals that only international groups are
starting to roll out services and tools that could ultimately structure the market.
Although they are aware of how important MICE activities are to their business, hotel groups have not
defined a true MICE strategy. They develop solutions focused on one or more competitive advantages
that enable them to gain market shares in the short term. They have recently started developing digital
tools. Most have a dedicated MICE loyalty programme that is directly or indirectly related to the hotel
loyalty programme. Hotels still pursue a traditional strategy for acquiring new market shares by
communicating directly with customers and commercial platforms. Some hotels are consequently
strengthening their position and raising their profile.
National hotel groups have to contend with a much more restricted budget for developing their MICE
activities. In general, they have built one or two services, but do not offer online tools or a loyalty
programme. Only some hotels appear to be significantly developing their activities in the MICE market
as part of an exclusive MICE strategy. They offer to welcome groups with an end-to-end range of
services, including team-building and recreational activities.
International hotel
groups
• Important, but no explicit
strategy
National hotel
groups
Strategy
Services
Online tools
Loyalty programme
Specific features
• Not important
• Focused on certain
competitive advantages
• Few MICE services and no
dedicated communication
• Basic tools (RFI, budgeting
tools & to-do list)
• No online tools
• Related to the hospitality
loyalty programme
• No loyalty programme
• Some groups are trying to
pre-empt the MICE market
• Some groups specialise
exclusively in MICE
services
12. 12
This report is protected by copyright - Any full or partial reproduction is subject to prior authorization of B3tsi - Concomitance
New providers that are more akin to start-ups are taking an interest in this market. Aware that many
organisations cannot easily find a venue for their events, these new providers give customers access
to a booking platform and appropriate management tools. In the medium term, these companies could
achieve leadership status in the market and give greater structure to what is still an inconsistent range
of practices.
13. 13
This report is protected by copyright - Any full or partial reproduction is subject to prior authorization of B3tsi - Concomitance
CONCLUSION
The main complexity for sizing and getting established: the wide range of
decision-makers
One thing is for sure: covering the MICE market involves reaching out to a large number of
stakeholders. There are several tens of thousands of clients in each of the three countries in
this white paper alone. The vast majority of these clients are not incorporated into a structured
MICE organisation (such as MPI: Meeting Professionals International), and their demand for
events varies considerably from one period to the next.
Furthermore, each stakeholder has an extremely different set of objectives, room for
manoeuvre, needs and desires, which depend on the function or role of the person managing
the planned event. That person could be a travel manager, an executive or team assistant, an
event / incentive / seminar project manager within a functional department, or a senior
executive.
This allows companies operating in the market to nurture high ambitions, because this level of
disparity and fragmentation currently enables many companies to prosper with varying
degrees of success. But this also prevents organisations from establishing a holistic and suitable
position spanning the entire market.
Gaining a foothold in the market means choosing target groups, and choosing means giving up
ambitions of covering the market. But the fact that the market has not been sized implies that
all providers are becoming established but without truly leveraging the opportunities available.
An opportunity for improvement to be shared: creating a consolidated insight
into expenditure
No country has a clearer insight into the size of the market than the others. The solution is to
carry out a recurring syndicated study among several thousands of decision-makers and
providers to exchange views on how they can improve performance rather than on how much
they can do!
14. 14
This report is protected by copyright - Any full or partial reproduction is subject to prior authorization of B3tsi - Concomitance
Methodology
B3tsi/Concomitance Consulting conducted this study late 2015 based on:
- A telephone survey among 300 professionals responsible for organising events for a
company, association or agency. These organisations are located in France, Germany
and the United Kingdom, and are distributed according to a representative sample
group of major corporations, mid-cap companies, SMEs and small/medium-sized
industries.
- An analysis of existing research into the MICE market in France, Germany and the UK.
- A benchmark of the MICE services offered by hotel groups.
- Interviews with MICE market experts.
Credits: the icons used in this white paper are taken from The Noun Project collaborative
icon sharing platform and were created by Ema Dimitrova, Olivier, Creative Stall, Frederick
Allen and Gerard Wildmoser.
Definitions:
Venue finders: specialists who focus their expertise on selecting and recommending the
venues best suited to hosting the event. Venue finders are widespread in the English market.
PCO (Professional Congress Organiser): a company that specialises in organising congresses.
DMC (Destination Management Company): an organisation (freelancer or company) that is
permanently based in a country and which designs programmes for stays in its home country.
15. 15
This report is protected by copyright - Any full or partial reproduction is subject to prior authorization of B3tsi - Concomitance
16. 16
This report is protected by copyright - Any full or partial reproduction is subject to prior authorization of B3tsi - Concomitance
About Concomitance
Concomitance, a brand of B3tsi, is specialised in marketing and sales consulting.
Concomitance is an independent consulting firm specialised in management and strategy. We focus
on two levers of value creation built on customer experience: marketing and sales.
Since its establishment in 2002, Concomitance has stood out in terms of its capacity to transpose
commercial and marketing issues into action plans which are immediately effective and comprehensible
to all players.
This capacity is a direct result of Concomitance's DNA: the prior business experience of our
consultants allows us to formulate recommendations and share them with our clients in line with
the maturity of their organization.
B3tsi - Concomitance Consulting
3 rue de la Grange Ory – 94230 Cachan – France
Follow us on Concomitance.com or SlideShare
Contact for this white paper: info@Concomitance.com